CHAZARAH - Chullin Daf 6 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

[music] Omar, we're like a little bit below halfway. So, it's a great start. [snorts] Two lines and it says, "There was a vote. We had a whole Are you allowed to eat the of ai?" We said if we have we have yes we had another thing if he we do the taste test remember if he eats it himself. So says the gumar in the name of Gaml. Now Rashi points out that this is not the thinking of this is actually a later generation. This is below the la like from the last last the son of Rabenui. >> There's your chart. >> Yeah, I should have the chart correct. The chart should be in here. He and his bestimu they voted. They just did a vote. They decided we're not allowing the of ai and the is going to go into it. Why? Not this minute. Says it was a bad move for saying it. Messed up a little bit. He tells perhaps what you're saying over is in a in a case of there's no but otherwise if there's we could eat the meat of a you know what you sound like like a person like somebody doesn't know how to learn like you never learned today in your life. of them. We know doesn't care about he learns the very literal that it means don't put a stone as a blind person is walking do not trip him up. It has nothing to do with tripping people up with and andra and therefore if you don't have 100% it's also that's the whole obviously when comes and says that you can't eat the meat he means with you can't eat his meat was agreeable to what he said or not I'm going to prove to you that he agreed with him he realized that he made a mistake there's No, there's no way the said that the beat of a when there's no when there's no we know it's another story go from story I saw like the first later on he ate the he ate the also by ribb himself who just got himself in a little bit of a pickle when he was yelled at. He says you don't you don't it sounds like you don't never learn before is wondering what happened there. Why did eat the meat is the he never heard about this from have because had he heard it he would have never eaten it. He would have accepted it. Maybe he heard and he couldn't care less and he ate it anyways. Then he said, "Oh, must be has to be that he heard it and he didn't accept it." Why? impossible. When we learned the we spoke about every one of those things. So that how could it be possible that if there's a not meat go ahead and eat it by mistake if the animal of wouldn't eat the wheat that didn't have micer himself would never ever trip and and and and do by mistake wouldn't let it happen. I don't even know how to say the name. Let's do a quick review messed up a little bit. He said that what meant when he said that you can't eat a kusi is only when there's no mia. And then he has a problem. He himself himself has a problem with how did eat this meat? Did he know? Did he know about it? Did he not know about the the and it's impossible that he didn't know that that that that he didn't know and that had he known he wouldn't have eaten it because it's not so and if you would think that did not accept the muser in other words he held no only pas in a situation where there's no but if there's a masg you're allowed to eat What are you asking me a question about ate meat that had a that's why he ate it even after the took the he agreed that there is zero difference between a and a made no meat forever in any circumstance wheat and that's why he had a problem with no And why did make not to eat mayor sender to buy some wine from the from the house. So this old man met him. So the famous typhus >> it's not it's not always but here we have the tyis straight out and small the first on it's easy when we learn every tyus which is the whole story of is gimmel But Tyus brings >> Oh, cuz today [clears throat] so comes and says, "Put a knife right in your cheeks." If you're a person that has an a person that that does the right thing, do not drink this wine. Put a knife there. Don't Don't let yourself drink it. So runs back to says, "You're not going to believe who I bumped into. I bumped into and he says don't don't drink their wine." So says, "You know what? If says it, let's make no wine." So now we have that says no wine. We have that says no meat. That's it. They're closed off. What's the reason? The reason is because who? Not everybody. A few few sick people. Why? If you ask anybody that learns the daf, who's the person in shas that always is concerned with the me with the with the minority. Reme everybody knows it's Remor in all Rome says a a youngster, a kid that's under 13 should not do Yeum. Why? Cuz maybe it'll turn out that he's going to be a Surus or the woman if she's Akana, she shouldn't you shouldn't marry her. Why? Because she might turn out to be an islandist. What percentage of are very very small percentem so he's he is concerned about the minority. So over here also he's concerned about those two people that bow to the to the pigeon and therefore since I'm going with the minority I'm going to be allin they're all going to suffer and you can't drink their wine and when it came to meat they're also concerned about the minority and they answer the meat says I enjoy every minute I heard that all 140 Daff like this [snorts] besides and they're serious but there's two two three daff in the entire that we need some good charts. So this says with a sin what's the what's the simple meaning you have sitting in front of the bread sitting and learning what's going on here If you know that your rebi could answer you well bin go ahead ask him good cautious get get to the bottom of it he'll he'll teach you the give him if not you should understand on your own says don't embarrass him you hear this no you should go to another send to bring wine from the house once again according to some nobody keeps the here nobody keeps the means you're done you can't you can't can't bring wine you can't buy wine from so went and said this over with he said this over toi where didi live >> where >> whoa >> how do you know >> very good yeah they live in cuz we had a braas they were sitting under those beams there what does it mean we just decided made a on what? On wine. What make the meat? So already we already had this in in the generation. So why do you need later on to do this? By the way, the from the five, right? >> This is this is today. This is when they started today. They went took the whatever he had left over the five and he made from from these five. Nobody accepted mayor. Rashi explains why. What do you mean? What do you mean you don't accept? Because they were so intertwined in society. Theim and the Jews lived together in the same building. They were friends, work together. So they they couldn't accept it. But in the later generations when there was already separation, then they made okay fine. We'll take it. So this is mish that lotion he's a what's a if the is he's wearing a blue shirt I understand but the he's a but he's a go that Arab he's mish he's such a he's a go doesn't pass the >> very oh exactly not says you're right he's not a ausi is not a ausi is a g. We're going the whole sugi is a gs. He's a real g. So if he messed up, it doesn't make him a guy. A Jew cannot become a guy, >> but he's a guy. What does that mean? Because when we're talking about anov, this is you have this uh you have a you have this uh courtyard and the houses they come into the courtyard. So Rabon said you can't carry their own in Shabas but it's private property. No it's like you can confuse it with so what do you do? You make of you take a meal take some egg whatever you make a meal and everybody participates in that meal. Now what happens if you have a the cannot participate in that meal. The only way to circumvent that is to to rent it from him to rent his house from him. Otherwise he can't he can't be a here. So says these because the Jew could also be in that category. If you have a Jew that's he cannot uh he cannot be with just like a cannot give up his property. So, so too this if a person doesn't believe in certain things. If he's respectful of Shabas, he doesn't do it in public. He could give up his like anybody else gives up their thing. We're all we're all partners in this. But if he does, if he's even a Jew doesn't have the right He has to rent it out. Has a Jew. Ah, another [clears throat] who runs the ins besides from Amarim. We love you. So they bring him like some sort of eggs in in wine. So real quickly, there's something called it's it's not a scary word at all. It's like an amorit. So for the new guys, this is a beautiful chart redone. When you have 100 fruit, you give 2% to the kayen. You give 10% to the ley and the ley takes from his 10% and he gives 10% to the cen. Okay, that's what we have to know. And is not a bad person. He's not a learned person. So the 2% to the kay the first part he has no problem. It's only 2% big deal. 10% is already that hurts. So he doesn't give sometimes sometimes he won't give the micer part but most amirat do give on anything that you buy from an amarat such as let's say the fruit store here in the in the in the center owned by not a mitzvah so you can't rely on him that he gave trum so you would have to what to have etc of course but what he tells you privately you can't rely on so that's called you buy from an it's called what is this you have to take saysi how in the world are you eating this shakshuka it has wine in it wine you have to take if if it if it uh if you bought it from you would have to take your owners how you eating it there's a mixture of of wine in here when I chakshuka. I'm not looking at the ingredients. I'm not saying, "Oh, it has tomatoes." I eat chakshuka. I didn't realize I didn't pay attention to this wine in here that needs that needs uh micers taken from it. [clears throat] Says, "Is it possible that you can eat this and is going to eat it by mistake? If the animal of a sadic is not going to eat something that doesn't have micerk so the is going to be worse off than the donkey he's going to eat something that needs he went and he searched up and down and he found you made some you put wine into some fish brine some food gala kin Last season this veetch stuff. Remember the veetch. Oh, where's the veetch? Here we go. Veetch. >> Le county, Missouri, June the 4th. These guys are busy grazing. Harry Veetch. >> Vet. >> You can watch them do their thing. >> They're very excited. >> Tremendous forage. >> Tremendous forage. Okay. So, it's really a mahim. I'm just trying to show you that that animals eat this. But if he wanted to do say if you buy veet from an amorit you have to take micer. If you buy uh the wine to put into your mus you have to take messer but listen to this certainly if it's not if the tells you I didn't take mser of course you're going to have to take the messer this is the point what if you buy readymade murios readymade readymade the final product the we're talking about the final You don't have to take micer. Why? Cuz it's a mixer. If you buy the solid ingredient, the veetch by itself, fine. But if it's veetch mixed into other stuff and it's already made, then you don't have to take micer. And that's why because ate a readym made thing. Listen, the whole >> the whole exactly the whole is not is not a it's a far-fetched thing that maybe he wasn't most do. So once it's more of once it's in the it's in a thing they weren't going that far what the war is going to have a problem with this you give your neighbor who's she's the wife and she gives him something to to bake you give her you know not everybody had an oven in their in their house very few people had so you take your wife's sour dough ready to go you say here put it into the oven here take the chunk put in she's not going to go maybe they're not on giving 10% of the co but they're not going to steal from they're normal people not going to steal mix up things [clears throat] I don't have to worry about anything but if I tell her use your ingredients oh that's a different problem I have to worry about the barley and the spices maybe it's stuffer even if it's It's mixed. It says over here that you're not allowed to buy because maybe it has in it. So you see that that mixed stuff is a problem. How you eat mixed stuff. If you tell a woman to do I want you to make me a she becomes you're can't tell somebody to do the mixture and then say oh it's mixed. It's like buying fresh stuff. It's it was it was it was individual stuff and you told her to mix that that's that's not okay since it's has a lot of flavor it's done for flavor in the flavor is not something that can be bottle we're not worried about switching things up but not if you give your mother-in-law something to cook so what do you We're concerned. She's going to switch up the whatever you give her a sour dough gets ruined. She's going to [snorts] switch it up. She Why is she doing this? Because she's embarrassed of her son-in-law. She doesn't want to serve burnt chong. So with the son-in-law, she's going to switch it out. Raise. I have bad news for you. I think Tyus always asked the question and I'm going to use Tis's answer. Things have changed in society over there. There used to be a for the son-in-law. Not anymore. Not anymore. My mother-in-law [snorts] is different. You tell me only by a mother-in-law and a son-in-law she'll switch it out. But in the rest of the world now but not now we're talking about literally says talking about gives food to his inkeeper he has to take she's going to switch it out before it's not only son-in-law she'll switch out for says she has a good reason I want the yeshiva to have a great hot meal. I'll suffer. I'll eat the cold meat. We're not concerned for what's somebody who's on tumo onus. He'll he'll treat food. So as she could grind the the wheat with her friend on condition that she's tummy because when she's she she knows not to touch the food because her husband's m not to eat tummy food. So she's not going to eat anything from the amar. When the is right, she could grind with when she's she might eat. She shouldn't because her friend will give her to eat. Says, listen to this. This is going to drive people crazy. Today it's not like this. They say in it's different. Her husband gives her something to grind. She goes ahead and she takes her husband's food and she dishes it out to her friends. If she steals, she already switch out from different pots and do different things. There's a famous there's an old picture have a bull thresh the the disha work on wheat while his mouth is muzzled. So she says I'm working for my husband. I'm worse than a an axe. You're going to muzzle my mouth. I'm allowed to eat. So I'm going to give to my friends. It's a hatter, but otherwise she doesn't steal. Raoai, have a wonderful day. [music] >> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com [music] or sponsor at mdy.com.