CHAZARAH - Chullin Daf 37 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

a boy. We're starting a brand new Mishna. We're going to be talking about this is a animal. It's about to die. Three shittas over here. Let's even show it over here. Actually, it's not over here. It's in tomorrow's D. I put it together. Three shittas. Number one is so I'll just show you this for a second. Byel, the hand, the front, the fore leg, and the the hind leg. You need according to both very you need both moving. Now if you're a little sensitive to this kind of stuff maybe you don't have to look that day that we did the it's getting further and further. It's within the week. So here is the actual pirus after the animal. Here's the perus is explaining it. either or because that's the next that's the final. >> You could even see the the tail moving. >> Did you guys know that ruin is a is a very interested over there with the phone. Those kids are very interested in the picture. >> Okay, so that's Pirus. What's the idea? The idea is as follows. If you can about to die, perhaps she didn't make it through the she died during the that's not good. You need that there should be a little bit of life at towards the end of the even after we're done with the a little bit of life. It's enough. In other words, he's it seems like he's being more makeal. You don't need her to move a hand and a foot. It's enough if a spritz of blood comes out of her neck and it hits her neck. Basically, it goes all over her neck of a person at night. Now, you're not supposed to really at night unless there's lights, we said, but at night it's not a good time to sh. And if this animal is she's about to die, how you going to know if she moved a hand or a foot and the following day you find according to this we're learning the sol means the neck you see that the neck is full of blood and not just like a drip down it's spread everywhere then I know that she this animal was not because otherwise she wouldn't have the power to spray the blood out like that. Shazo because there was a flow of blood, a strong flow of blood and the rebel is the one that said it's enough if there's a spray of blood. That's what said it's enough either or. You don't need like you need the animal to bend both the hand and the foot. Either or. If it would wag its tail, that's enough. Whether it's a small animal, it's a large animal, both of them need pirus. They need to prove that they had some life at the end of the but the mission is going to explain what that means. Not every time do you need pir when you have a small animal like a goat, a sheep who made her hand go straight but did not bend it back. Sula the same exact thing. If a beaha a cow goes like this that's enough proof that there's life. It's only a small animal because moving a hand from a bent position to a straight position that's normal from when the goes out but it's not an indication of life. That's only when this animal we know that she's a dying animal. She's bri like our sheep that we had the other day. The mission says it's not necessary. She's a healthy animal. Shro you even if there's you don't have a sim of pir that's kosher says the how do we know that an animal that is about to die and you run and you real quickly before it dies that's considered a good and it's okay ask the I love this you're asking me how do you know it's okay how do you know say it's so I'll tell you why I think it could be and then we're going to have to prove why it's I'm going to tell you why I think it's not really user because in fact it is mut if you could prove that that she had life dur at the end of the a little after the then then it's mut even if she was a msukanis but I'll tell you why I thought it's aer and and and therefore I'm going to have to prove why it's mut the reason Why I think it's also this is the the alive not you could learn as like a wild beast but this this is the you could also learn it as it has life and this is like that was saying before 12 months it doesn't have life says oh oh so so we're going to try Now, a few different reasons to tell me that you're allowed to eat a says don't eat an aa is an animal that died natural death only after it dies on its own without a then you're not allowed to eat it. But if you shed it and then it died then it should be okay because if in fact an animal who's about to die and even if you because of maybe he'll say so then what I need a for even a live animal who's about to die it's certainly an says you're right Maybe maybe there's a that says there's a say, but you'd get an extra laugh if you eat. If you eat a mukus is what's the over there. So that's number one. And number two is that it's an avail to be of another laugh. The animal dies and then it's also the says then you have an you can't tell me that every died maybe raps Perhaps the are the same thing just so then why do I have to say it's different when it's alive you get two you get the is yeah it is too you get the of it being alive you get an not of so after it dies you get the the is of eating mukanis plus I'll I'll add a little bit a of a how do I know that is maybe in fact it's a it's a to eat it I'm going to try again tells us don't eat a only a you shouldn't eat what's a traa missing a limb it it has a hole in the heart whatever it is seems like it's a whole animal completely good just What? It's about to die. Hello. So from the fact that says don't eat a seems like she's only about to die because in fact even about to die animal nothing's missing from her body just about to die. Imagine uh this goat that was about to die after child birth whatever you call it birth. How do you um birth? >> A kid birth. A kid birth. Exactly. A kid birth. Nothing's missing from her body. She's dying. So ta this ta which by the way every tra is a mucenis but so certainly a traa should be. So then why did the to tell me don't eat a traa if it's already included in a mucanis mus is better off than a traa and a mucanus is oer nothing's missing from its body. So certainly a traa like we had the picture the other day of the animal that's missing a whole um thigh. It's a tra says okay same question before you're right maybe tra is misus is a tra so then why the give me one for one to be will two things if you're if the animals so your and also if it's only okay because then why does say talk if certainly after it's and here's here's a who told you no maybe there's something called ana but it's really an is the same thing and is the same all three are the same so then why is it talking about a tra why is to talk about an aa Why is it talking about two plus one? That's what this three. Okay. So fin. So we need a source to tell us that is a man is about to die. You okay? Provided it does. So we're starting all over again. says in the it says that you're permitted to use the fats of ana the fats of a traa also we saw by the he showed us all the different fats that are mut that are user most of them are user different body parts around the the kidneys around the there's fats everywhere we had that blanket the nice blanket that's on the on the bottom of the animal. It's like a beautiful blanket. You put it over the head, the cut part of the head. And here's that tells us that you're permitted to do all with this. Meaning it doesn't give off. I'm assuming that we learn from here doesn't give because the Torah says the word twice. Notice of an animal that drops dead. An animal that had an existing problem that we're going to have in just a few days. What consists of you should not eat from it. Why does the have to say it again? Why here says It already says you're not in the So why does the Torah repeat itself? It's extra possible. There's a famous concept in the Torah called you. You can't have one that goes on top of another is usually, right? There's exceptions to the rule. But over here the Tory is telling you that the should apply itself on top of this comes first. Why does come first? Because every animal is born with the and the says that when it dies as a I'm going to add another of on top of the and the of should apply itself to the is of now there's two there's two ways to learn traa could either mean an animal who's complete and we're trying to say that it means even a muk is complete nothing wrong with it or a tra that we understood up until this point that means it's missing something so says if and are one of the same in other words it means even the guy on the right the guy that's not missing anything is fine he's just about to die he's on his last breath So then the is saying then there's no point of the talking about an why here there's a cult here. If the if if an animal is considered a is considered a even nothing's wrong with it. So just tell me that that you're allowed to do any meaning it's not and then and then just tell me another part of the puzzle that you can't eat and I'll know and when it's alive and it's in the wheelchair it's about to die it's considered a And that is goes on top of this. It's all good. You get two and certainly after it dies the says about not eating. Don't eat this this repeated itself to tell you to teach you that are not the same. Otherwise, you could have learned what animals you're allowed to eat. If you and it moves its hand or its leg after then you're good. Maybe perhaps it's one of the same as me to say they can learn. No perhaps there is an ara that has nothing to do with that. What? Yeah. Where's the gist thing? Check this out. What? Now, why did the sauce stop there? I asked Yoshi to stop it there. Why? Because says this is an it wasn't sick at all before it died. So the says what do you mean it wasn't sick before it died because it's considered an aa right away. What do you mean? It it happened right away, but as the saw was going through its body at this point, let's do it again in slow motion. It cut it. And at that point, it was very, very sick. And only afterwards, here at this point, that's a slow motion. Yeah. Now, it's a gster up. Okay, so that's a gista. But before it became a gista, the only way could the only way you could cut an animal in half is if you cut it in a quarter. Like you have to go through it. And once you go through it, you just start you already made it extremely sick. Say, I'll prove to you again that msukin is mut. Well, again, we're trying the whole day today. We're trying to figure out how do you know that an animal is about to die? You're allowed to eat it. Why does the say the word twice in the same puzzle? There's a only a has two and this is the source that tells us that there's something called And it's don't have two another source. Oh, so over here this is seriously tells that he should take a brick, lay on his left side. I think it was 390 days. Don't move. You can't turn over. No. Lay like that. Then lay on your right side for 90 days. I don't remember the exact days. 40 days. 40 days. And then the entire time you have to eat very very low calories. Very low. Like 200 calories a day or something. bread made on made out of gross stuff like like uh beans and stuff, but also the fire has to be on human waste. That's the coals. The coals are human waste. You can imagine not very tellsum when he's done with this he says I said I didn't become tommy. Now the question right away is what do you mean I didn't become? What's the big they say in what's the glick like what's the big deal? He didn't become tommy. is a is also for him to become and then we go I didn't even eat again what's the big glick he didn't eat I didn't eat any meat that that the ken had a thought that he's going to eat it outside of the the time that he's allowed to eat it usually can eat let's say two days thought he's going to eat in five days is a carus. I didn't even eat that. No big deal. None. No one in this room ever ate pigle. So what does it mean? We have to understand he didn't become. Of course he didn't become I didn't think about things I shouldn't think. So I shouldn't become a carry at night. So Tyson says over here, isn't that isn't that uh something everybody should be careful with? You're right. You should be careful. But nobody nobody nobody could say that they w they weren't over on this. These are things that people all the time. He says, "No, I never had an issue." So that's our right here. I never ate from means fast she check before it dies. Let's get a here. Like I don't know who would want to eat from that meat, but you know, hey, meat is meat. So here you see what he So why is he telling the I never ate him sucanis. The is because everybody's allowed to eat him. If everybody's not allowed to eat mukas, why would he say I never ate a mucanus? It's not he's allowed to eat and he was not to eat it. What does it mean? I didn't eat I didn't eat from an animal that that had a shock. Oh. It it means even though I'm a and I we didn't take a picture of the and I could have given it at least a I found out at least a kayen that's that doesn't care. I don't know if there was anybody in the audience that doesn't care to eat that. It could have been people what >> no according to it was no good according to the is a way to make it. >> Okay. Oh, sorry. So it I didn't eat from an animal that I that I didn't give matis even though I'm a that's why he was telling the I could have eaten and I never ate but if it's awesome. So you see from here is have a wonderful day. Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor at mdy.com.