CHAZARAH - Chullin Daf 140 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

[music] I want to tell the about that we're doing tomorrow. The Hebrew Shir is finishing tomorrow. The the English is going to be finishing on. So we're doing something that I'm not so into usually which is but they cover the mitzvah of the so we'll do right after the Hebrew. We're going to go next door to the Prusham Hall. Everybody's invited. Only one ticket per person. Do not I know it's only 30 shekel a ticket. Oh, [snorts] 30 shekel a ticket, but do not buy for one per person kind of thing. Children at home. We're holding Wow. We got to learn. You should send the way to the mother and take the the chicks. You think there's a mitzvah. They should go search for the mitzvah. Like you go for for pes before pes you go to the the fields for your matzah and you work really hard. You should go everywhere. go into the fields and find birds which is it has to happen upon you just you just bumped into it. The word con means that any type of nest, even if it only has one egg, one. We're not going to use our special uh thing. We'll use it tomorrow. We'll use it tomorrow. The thing in the kitchen. >> N fine. Let's just use it now. Here. This is okay. kiss her anywhere you find it. How do you know that? Even on tree on all trees, if you found it deep in the ground, we're ready. He included every single place. What I need in front of you on the way. It's not. It's not there. It can't be something that's already prepared. These pigeons that come [clears throat] and sit in your you make special nest for them. They live in your attic. They made their their they they made their nest in different like you know in the walls and the in the houses. These this is interesting. This is your chicken, your goose, your your your your duck that ran away. They flew away and they made a nest in the orchard where you don't have control. Then it's not yours anymore. Once it flies away, what if they made a nest in your house or these pigeons called these are wild and you have no connection to them. You don't control them. They come and go as they wish. There's no Oh, so because if it's in your house, then you have control. You're have control. And we're going to have a story about so anything you have control over they'll go in your hand like this like this kind of bird if you use kosher you would be but other types of birds they have zero control they come and go then you potter you have control if you have control you if you don't have control it has to be something that's not in your possession we already learned learned. We start off the you happened upon it says we already learned that in front of you. You have a this is interesting right? You bought this bird but it rebelled. It flew away. So once it flies away you lost your ownership over it. That's a So therefore, what if it says on on the path? What if it's not on the path? It's in the ocean. We need a policy for this to tell us that the way is also in the ocean. If you have a nest in the tree, in the water, then What have you found? Uh, you're doing one of these. You happen to be in in the middle of the sky. So, like on a plane. Oh, today we can understand on the plane. Oh, sorry. How do you know? It's there's no that says that the So since it says in the so maybe in the middle of while you're flying around in the sky. You're right. It's called but it's not called is a pathway on land or in the ocean. This is one of the most interesting shus in all of Shas. This is one of those questions you'll never forget. What if you found a nest on somebody's head? How exactly do you have a nest somebody's head? So I saw two and um I forgot who the second one is. They talk about monks. They say there are monks that sit for many months without moving. They just sit and eventually uh a bird could come even if in Tibet. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Monks in Tibet they say hodu hodu they say in in India they have such a thing they meditate for many months at a time. The point is whether it happened or never happened. What is that? Yeah it works. It's good. It's cuz we it could have said it's comes from the a person's head is like is like the earth says the famous what do we see in the beginning of the before he was born says it says in the is and at the end it says or what does it say at the end of he's going to live 120 years. How do you see in the because it says all the way in it says and ended up >> dying on a tree. [clears throat] Where do we see Esther? aster it's also a ping this week's parish sort of a about him but is the concept of when sins takes away his his um he's not there he's not you can't you can't see him he hides so to speak aster that's the of aster when sinned over there with did not reveal himself how do you see that in the murder which means the head of like fragrance which is what does it mean that it's available to you right there and you cannot do we're talking we have a guy there finishing comes before the ra the before thee hudus hurdus was a slave and he killed all his masters and he became king it's notus it's had it comes from a place called these are birds these are pigeons I saw with my own eyes say they're sitting there 16 rows the width of a mill very thousands tens of thousands of these pigeons they would just say over and over pigeons would talk they would say my master my master in other words pumping up hudus my master my master's pigeon over there. [clears throat] Refuse to say it. Master happens to be my favorite word. Kiri kiri. [clears throat] She tells She tells the she tells her friend, "You're a shaita for not saying it." Omra, she says back, "Suma biri, you're a shaita." You know what I'm saying? I'm saying master slave. I'm calling who is a slave. The people heard it the the took the pigeon and they killed this pigeon for saying that Hudas is a slave. Sorry. This whole story pigeon speaking it's just a story says I testify that this is what happened says sometimes when you see something that's so I'm talking about you know a pigeon talking when pigeons don't talk. So you have to say that what you saw is real but it's not not necessarily but it's it's with with with yes it happened but it's with words of when there's a bird there's no we don't even have you know It says the word means kosher. When it says the word can mean also a non bird. The word you should not make that that resembles a bird. You shouldn't fashion something that looks like a bird. Now it's referring to means a bird. It means any bird means you shouldn't make a eagle as your andov in the word kov means grasshoppers. So remember this going to do it five times in a row. The word no goes without it only means a kosher bird kov. The word refers to two things and we say it every morning. So it says again and it's a contradiction to what you said. You said means kosher means to cut off has wings means how do you say grasshoppers in Russian? No no no in English. Locus another word fit in our means only kosher is referring to I love this one it says like we asked the question you'll say the answer it's like fill in the blanks you say maybe means also the no it means only the people call it. So why say it over and over five times? But now we're getting to a strong finishing up. Oh, on the branches there will live the birds of the heaven. Meaning all birds. Who lives in the heaven? Who flies around in the sky? Even non-coosher birds. So you see the word se means non birds. Yes, they're called birds from the heaven, but they're not called birds. A regular bird refers to only birds. Says there's a bird that is but there's also there's a bird a that's says no you made a good deal but not not the right one. There's a tahra, but there's a bird that's what could it be? What bird is That's also if you're talking about a that is here referring to birds perhaps they're talking about the mits. So let me just show you real quickly the mitsra the process of the msra very important he's sitting outside of the city right he gets two drawers these little what are they called >> no >> sparrow sparrow yeah so two of them one of them is you put the blood in the water then you take the and you dip the live one this is the live one dipical blood with water spray on him and then you let him go. There's one that you and one you you let free. So you have two birds. So we're talking about the one you just shed. What do we do with the one hefted? Nothing. You bury it. You can't do anything with it. Shave off all his hair, even his eyebrows. >> [clears throat] >> If it's the the one that you do and it's telling us you can't use it. It's that we already learned from the end of the you shall not eat from this. I already learned the puzzle says no no no it is talking about the bird that you sh it for the and it's telling you that you're not allowed to eat it but I already have a that this says it's an you shall eat your if you eat the bird on this is a positive this is not a negative so not only on a negative you a positive Yeah, this is a positive shall that means if it's not it's a it's a bird which is not according to this. Yeah. Oh, sorry. Yeah. If so, say the same exact thing. What did you gain by saying it's talking about go back to the first the first terrace that you had that's talking about? said, "Oh, it's already author in the Tyra says add and say to it these are number 12. What does it mean?" If you're already learning the idea of a good like that of a mitz bird, then learn mitzvah. An aa a traa is not a good. We're talking about it's referring to the bird, not the tra bird. We're talking about a normal thing. It says the two birds are alive means they're alive in your mouth. So it says birds can refer once again another question that a bird could refer to a non bird that they are whole that they're shim that this bird is not missing any limb it says that they should be you see that birds could be in the category there's a bird That's a tra if it says mean it could it could live. We know a traa can't live. We had this a number of times in this because says that a tra could live more goes through this if you a tra could live. So obviously you can't use the word used to tell me that a tra is no good. I need a special word for tra if a tra any animal or human being or a bird that has a cannot survive. If it can't survive then I don't need a special word for it. I could learn it from the word that you have to live whether you hold that it can survive or not I can learn from another person oh the whole there's a concept called a what's a you bring a carbon not because you did an a bring a carbon because you gave birth brings a carbon it allows her to come to the mikdash to to to be taught to eat to eat that's a what's a is like a it bring to forgiveness so we compare the two inside you bring these two what is you bring outside of the again talking about again and the is a youth it outside of It allows them to go on with his life for compare the two inside. So we should compare the two outside. So I learn that the bird has to be like and it can't be a trade. So I don't need a P for it that I cannot use for the bird. I cannot use a bird. If you remember here, just to remind that uh Fish was very into San was giving people $1,000 to do Sanin. A lot of people jumped on. So this is you have to burn the entire thing. So if you look closely over here, it's every This is before AI by the way. Spent a crazy amount of money on this video. population 17,000 zero. If you live, you wouldn't be living anymore. Okay. You can't use one of these birds from city for if you want to strip them off. The one that there's two birds. One you send away, one if it's a sending away one, you can't send it away. Why? Because it's a if anybody finds it, he'll be eating or dealing with you can't what? So it must be the second bird that we're talking about. What if you know this isapar everybody knows that if you do kaparis a big no no is like to sell it to somebody else. Pretend that you never did kaparis to it. Double dip on one kaparis. Like, wow, this is already full of somebody's air. I'm going to use it again over here also. One one one msar use this bird. Now you're going to go here's another guy. Sell it to him. No, no, no. You can't do that. Now, what are you trying to do exactly? You want to use it for the second bird. This is the the first one bird. Now you have a second bird. What are you going to do with the second bird? You're going to ship it away. You're going to send it off. But instead of sending it off, you're going to sell it to another for what? From you can't check it. It has to be sent away for the first guy. Obviously, you're going to let it fly away. But before you let it fly away, let another use it and then let it fly away for both of you. That you're not allowed to do. A Jew sold. He sold to another to in return he got a bird. Now that bird is also for you to use. It should have that again. Same thing all over trying if using this bird to send it away. This is going to cause a problem for whoever finds it later on. So you can't chip it off. And you're not talking about a bird who killed another person. It was just in the news. What happened now? That the bird killed a human being. It's old. It's old. >> Oh, it it like cut its neck or something with it long. >> But it was a tra. >> Yeah. Okay. Because a bird could kill a human being. We had this also if the already passing that it's you have to kill it. So of course you can't use it for it's before it was sentenced to death. But we know that it killed a human being. If you want to ship it off, you have to bring your to bring to you rid yourself of the of the bad of the evil. You want to you're going to get bad rid of the the rabbi. No, you can't if you have a non-cos bird sitting on kosher eggs. You can't have a mother who's why we said means kosher kosher bird is sitting on the eggs what's the problem if a kosher bird is sitting on no non-cooser eggs says I'll tell you what the problem is says it should be a bird they take for yourself that you can eat and benefit from eating it if you can't eat it why can't you eat it because it's trave then it's not it's not it says in the it's important this doesn't mean bring those two words the the the the little chicks the eggs you must be able to eat you should eat you can make a a an omelet out of it doesn't say it about the mother it only says it so it's not for your dogs it's for It says that if the if the mother is a tra you have to do but if the if the chicks are you why you cannot do on something you can't eat on the on the babies but on the mother you could ask why let's compare the mother to the to the babies in the same just like we already established that you can't do on babies that are maybe on the mother. What the word to tell me that means kosher and a non-coosher bird you can't do. What do you mean a non-cos bird you can't eat? in Rafa said anything you can't eat if you're going to compare a mother to the babies that you can't eat not in you want to compare the mother to the baby so okay so but you can't eat it you can't eat it then I don't need the the what does means that the chicks the are there's two ways to read it how would you read it without aim there's a mother and there's chicks that are wait a minute we just said that that if the are something you can't eat if you can't eat you can't do [clears throat] >> you didn't read it well it says the mother is if the are 100% sent kosher but the mother is st then hold on okay let's do these three lines here he stuck his hand into the into a nest and he cut the the the neck of a chick but a little bit of it he didn't do a full so what's the if he left it as is he didn't continue the become you have to be able to eat it we said not something that goes to your dog since he could finish. It's up to him to finish and he could. It's like a he he has the ability to do it. Perhaps that's considered that it's for you. Remains in a question. Have a wonderful day. >> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com [music] or sponsor at mdyop.com.