CHAZARAH - Bechoros Daf 26 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

He's [music] down. He's your How is your In a true I We're holding we do a little because we stopped in the middle of the but little treat for the we want to get to the new per and stop over there and tomorrow we'll start from the new per. So says we learned it's an interesting it's actually a very very we have a case where there's a thousand animals guy has a whole ranch with thousand animals and introduce one animal that has a mum that you can't put on the so now all thousand animals you can't put on the because you don't know which has the mimar says wait a minute what's the just uh go in there and uh find the animal and yank him out and now you're good to go. So the comes up with an answer that really didn't like. He thought it was uh a really weak answer. The says, "Oh, we're not talking about animals. You read it wrong." Says that there's a mum. No, no, we're not talking about animal. We're talking about it's wool. The wool of a animal that has a mum got mixed in with the other animals dear wool and all the wool looks the same. So now you're stuck you can't use it. So says rever these the the reason why said something like that cuz he comes from bubble and over there the tip called it very very strong. >> They live in a dark place so that's where we're holding which we did a little bit of it. We'll just take it back a few lines. Yeah. You have it like m somewhere smack almost close to the middle of heaven when went from [clears throat] he went and he said this over in front of oh we got to say this over this is such a great line the ones from I'll explain to you why he's talking about he's talking about they lay in a dark land So they say things that are he didn't hear what said. So now we have two each one heard something else. First one heard say heard say when you go into your ranch and you search you have a helicopter. He went he searched he wasn't he wasn't successful he didn't find the what are you going to do find so you have and that's what happened over there he searched you got to you didn't find so now >> [clears throat] >> You have three piles. Let's say you have a you have a tum. You have a a grave or something. You have and you knew you know that you buried somebody over here. The whole place is talking about that until you figure it out. and say that you dig until you realize that there's no grave over there. There was never a grave over there because there's there's a hard bedrock. There's you could tell that this soil was never touched or that there's a stone. So obviously something huge. Nobody ever touched it. So there's no dead person here. Omar says in this in the name of the same person is not when you checked and you couldn't find you did find you found you found the so what's the problem maybe it's not the right bal it's still not a great and is between and you saw the you have a field that you know that there's a grave there but you lost it. If you go inside the field you become but if you found you located a grave. So now you located you found one grave great makes a lot of sense. I found a grave here. Found a grave. It's not true. You found a grave. Very good. But it's possible that there's more graves there. Could be that you found the grave and the is going to go into Listen, if somebody if one person buried there, maybe a second person buried there. It's a field. It's open field. Somebody did it. So maybe it's a thing. Says that he checked animals and he found one. He got lucky. He found the animal with the >> How come he doesn't say like that he checked and he couldn't find anything? When it comes to tum, you had a body, you had a piece of tum. So, it's possible an animal grabbed it and took it out of the field. But over here, you know that there was a balum and you searched and you didn't find him. What could have happened? Oh, which is interesting. I would think that he knew that it's a but anyways he say yeah maybe heal my time why was forced to say that he searched search couldn't find anything maybe he searched and found something say like that in a field you know you find a caver So just because you found one doesn't mean you found them all. But if you found one, why would I say that there's more? You found the guy with the They like to kick each other. I'm getting excited to show it. A guy deliberately yanks wool off of a whole animal. What does it mean? Doesn't have a Doesn't have a Thank you. Even though he developed the and then heeded it because he developed the Mer. This wool is makes. What if he pulled the hair off of a damaged adult that has a has a blemish? So, we're going back. We're going back to says this whole is talking about a case. If you look at like 10 lines from the top of it says, is so that we're going to take to task over here. The only time we have is is when professional says that this animal is since he's but you might now you might come to leave him over. You might do because you're now but you want to accumulate a lot of a lot of wool. So over here it seems like you don't need a what? So it's a cash says you need a pro to say that this this guy is a you don't need a pro. Says you can't make a deal. We're saying that he he pulled the the wool out of a out of unblenmished animal. Yes. If you don't go to the rough it's unblenmished until the rough pass that's blemished. is not blemished. He's not blemished. That's what is going to say maybe you need a professional to to determine that this is a blemished animal. If you rip out this case that we just had a second, you pull out the wool of a sheep that is unblenmished even though later on it became blemished. If you have a who's that has a blemish that already has a blemish and you you pulled out the hair, you didn't shed it. You hear what's going on. There's a big difference when it see the whole you didn't check it. It died. [clears throat] It died. Now, how do you have a situation? So, first of all, how do you have a situation where an animal you pull the hair out and then it dies? Oh, let me show you. I love it. Oh, no. Sorry. So, then what happened? You tore the you to that. That's nitlash by the way. That wasn't you to so the video is in the wrong spot. You the human being pulled hair out of the animal and then the animal died. Dying is not as good as is a lot easier to understand that after you sh the animal the hair the the wool on the animal becomes motor. So maybe also the wool that you pulled out but when it dies the wool doesn't become motor. So that stays throughout all three as we're going to see is the one that says not true. That's not where this is the case right here. His wool got was torn off by itself. He puts it in the on a shelf is a shelf and then he shed it. Not maze. Not maze like the first case we thought is he actually it my father says my father who argues he he says if you in other words he talking about dead not died. Leave it there. You could [clears throat] you can leave it. There's hope because if you it's it's 100% mut afterwards only. So what is he saying? He's saying the same thing that we said before in that is m not. Okay. Oh, and I'm trying to prove something here though. But the two people are saying the same thing. So what's the difference between them? You must say that there's a difference. What is the difference? Maybe it has to do with do you need the pro to to intervene here and say that this is you need like says you don't need. So here this is the very very simple chart. Check this out. According to the between and is in two cases you have wool and then you or you have wool and then he died naturally. Same exact same exact but in two cases. And then look look how simple this is says no the is only one of those two cases in what is going to say no the is only one case. So very very simple. says both. So why why does he mention the word maze like the we said all the way like 10 lines up he only mentioned the case of dead dying naturally it doesn't say anything about no that's what the used to say all the time that what that I want to I want to say that it's even in the worst case what's the out of the two cases or dying naturally dying is a much bigger that you're allowed to use the the wool So and as we're going to see that in fact that's [cough and clears throat] how we pass we pass like that the whole is is okay. So when it it came off by itself and the animal died. So we have says if you say and then say both comes no I say is only when he dies when you not when he Right. Don't you remember this? It's brought down many times in is is the best of the best. It's no means witnesses. They they witness. They said they said it's uh this is but you know that this is the this is the best of the best. So if it's brought down in that's how we ain't passing. It's not this case of the the sheep walking, scratching itself on a wall. So his wool fell off. You put it on a shelf and then you shed it. So we have says you can prove him the mission. It's not which we're going to see on B what that means exactly. You have wool that's detached from the animal. It's no longer attached to the animal's body, but it's in the wool. In other words, the root is pulled out already from the body, but it's entangled in the in the rest of the wool. If it looks like part of the wall, then it's also if it's not, if it looks separate, then it's so now we're just going to do a very very simple over here. So take a look at the chart. What does says that the whole is if it's only when it dies but if it's soar goes through the steps this if it looks like part of the animal then it's if it looks like it's separated from the animals what's the case can't be what is what is your hold in that everybody agrees that So you have to say it's going according to all the way on the left and in the case of dead it die by itself and and and in mace according to who either if if it dies that if the animal dies the wool is if you if you removed it you pulled it out. So it's always a but it can't be either why it should say not if it doesn't if it looks like it's separated then it's motor according to so it can't be so then it must be we're trying to prove that we pass like that goes what it goes like so let's go says the Everybody everybody says in the case of mace holds everybody holds it's also only says that if you have wool in a window you have it on a shelf it's so everything's must You see from here as it is in another easy you go ahead you walk over to a a sheep that has that that's designated for so this is interesting because theus writes over here that based Rashi that today it's aim but later on it became a and then you it went over to a unblenmished you pulled the wool out which you did and then it became and then you shuffed it I mean the guys says it fell off by itself can you use it so what's question when a person brings a carbon there's no question listen to this when we have the mdash what's the what's the big problem why do we cry so muchd because of this a person does a he does he feels really bad does this that does it work did he did he did he mean it when you have a mikdash you come with the sheep. You bring the sheep in. Boom. You're clean. Clean slate. Start all over again. So, does he want to wait around? He has this Shabas on his back. He drove a car in Shabas. He thought he's allowed to and he he wasn't allowed to. So, now he's he feels guilty. Something's not good. He could get the says, you know, he could get punished. He has to get rid of it quickly. He doesn't want Shamim to go strike him with lightning. So he goes and he runs to Mikdash the next day and he brings the carbon. He's not going to stick around for a year waiting around with a carbon kas that he should have brought last year. So he get another three ounces of of wool. So very simple. I didn't I didn't talk about Huh? >> Yeah. Hold on. There's no there's no reason to to stick it around. So I didn't make the also not why because you are going to leave it around then I do have it's a because I'm going to stick around. I have no I'm not in a rush to bring my tod or the is interesting. What do you bring? Isa is really for is just it's a it's a carbon da but it also has an an aspect of a of a component of very good a component of in a way not a big one but the main point is not is for the part because uh does come and give for essays. You're not going to leave it around. So I have a question on you rip out the wool of unblenmished even though later on it developed a moment and then you shove it. It's awesome. Says more time than now if the wool came out by itself it's motor. What's the thing? Same kind of it fell off. It came off on the wall when he was scratching itself on the wall. It's still and certainly in where you don't let it stay around says no not a good you said your whole is from a it says that you were to be a not by it happened by itself. No, it's all both cases it should be. So, shouldn't it be a biggerish to say that it happened by itself rather than say that you pulled it off? In that case, of course, it's even when it came by itself, it's also that's what I should say. Because I want to tell you how strong believes in his own opinion that if the animal started off with a blemish, so if you do it by hand, it's a motor. Not also even by itself according to but according to it's when you do it by hand. So what about the fact that says in here says [clears throat] came off by itself on the flip side. Now the the the is that when it came off by itself even by itself it's still awesome and when you pull it off it's to tell you even when you pull it out it's going to yeah go to that what is it how what's that the the the wool came out And it either looks like it's part of the wool or it's not. What does it mean? It doesn't look like part of the wool. Take a look at this. Look at this. The hole here. You can see both ends of the hair. So you see both ends of the hair. Then it looks like it popped out. It's not part of the animal anymore. Something like this. Maybe it's a little bit above the rest. Why does he have to come to a very rare case of that flipped over that the root is also outside? If the yellow in this in this picture is just cuz it popped out a little bit, then every single wool in the world will be because it popped out. But to have a piece of wool that the the the root flipped over, that's rare. >> [music and singing] >> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com [music] or sponsor at mdy do.com.