CHAZARAH - Bechoros Daf 15 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

[music] need We're discussing in the there's a difference in the Mishna between an animal that has a has a blemish and then you make a kadesh and an animal that's and then it has a bloom boom. So we're talking about it first there was a blemish and then there's a blemish and then you made it. So you can't make it tomorrow. What's tomorrow? You can't use this animal as an example and say, "Okay, I want a second animal to be like this first animal. It doesn't work." Why? Because it doesn't have doesn't have that. And it keeps on it goes on. So asked the obvious question that everybody asks when you read the P and when we discuss this you cannot upgrade from a bad animal and switch it into a better animal. So certainly you can't take a better animal and downgrade it to to lesser animal. So certainly does. Why does it have to repeat itself? So the is like this means an animal without a an animal without a m and you made it. You made it. So then that could be an example. So if you try to change it into another animal they both become meaning if it has a that's how we know it even if you you made it but that's only it doesn't become it may so there's [clears throat] a concept called here this is really for the next but means stand it up on its And then you evaluate it, you assess it, and then you could redeem it. Stand it up on its feet. You say, "Okay, this sheep is worth $500." $575. So you have to give 575 to you redeem it. That's by that's when it it has inherent. But by the dim there's no and we'll see if that's if that stands. It may see what happened if it stands. Oh, if again we're still in the same theme until we say otherwise. We're still discussing the first case of the Mishna where there was a M. [clears throat] So there's a M in the animal. It's not available for the for the MB and you went ahead and you made it. So it's only for D. What happens if it dies? You have to redeem it. The problem is you have to stand an animal up. A little bit of an issue. If an animal's dead, it's very hard to stand him up. So there's no there's no dead animals when it comes to there's no agrees when there's to begin with. Say even for a dead animal, even for Yeah. So since you need if they died, you have to bury them. Who are these? Everything everything even even everything has to be stood up and evaluated. And even if it has a beforehand these are these are things that don't go on a what's not the that we that you put on the o that you don't put on the like a chicken. Oh, seems to to say that there's certain things that you don't do. You tell me you do for everything. So what does come to exclude? In fact, you're right. It's a good question. I don't know what to do with it. That if in fact they die, it dies. You have to redeem it. Why? Because on everything. So it's everybody. Everybody says the same thing. No. So if it's for Yes. If it's for the not but the Mishna cannot go. What do you mean you cover? Why do you have to bury? Because it has Okay. says, "Who told you that the reason why they if they die, it's because they need maybe there's another reason. Who you're you're you're assuming that has to do with no because something no another maybe you don't redeem for to just send it to the dogs. Why do you have to say that it's dead? Even if it's a [clears throat] live animal and a live animal that's a is it could still stand. Tell me, tell me in that you cover the fact that it says me. So you see that the what? because even you're right. You ask me a question. So why don't you say it goes like everybody? Yeah. You have to add it up. All right. So now now we're switching gears. Now we're talking about there was there was a there was then comes m. [clears throat] So we have an animal that's kadesh and then it befalls a m a permanent blemish but not immediately that all these things you can't drink its milk and you can't this and [clears throat] all the things. So we learned by this is called again probably something we weren't very familiar with a few years ago. What does it mean? It means that you have an animal that's designated for and it gets a now you can't bring it on. So what do you do? It's a it can't be it's it's but it's possible now for the so what do you do? You redeem it. But the Torah says it has you could eat it. Eat it. But it's like a deer and like a heart. We said it was some sort of deer. If this animal after it has a it's no longer a regular animal, you can redeem it, do whatever you want. But it if it has a baby, a firstborn, it's not a why it's like a deer. A deer for so then you have to compare to a deer for everything. Matanics perhaps the famous Matanics. Yeah, you remember this me giving the the gifts to to now look closely at this. Look, look, things have changed. I asked AI to take the yellow bag out of it. Didn't listen to me. [laughter] Okay. So the second word in the what does it tell me that is like we know that you eat the fats. There's no forbidden fats in in a deer per this is mish farfetched. You want to tell me that this animal that was designated for that broken leg for life that eat it and can even eat its fats maybe it's like it's like another says let me see if I even have it. Yes. Here only no. Why would I say that? When it comes to there's no but there is matanis. Why? Yeah. Cuz every animal that you give matis but this not this is something else. This is used to be hdish and now you redeemed it. Perhaps you don't have to give because only happens to the firstborn not in every animal very few animals we said already well I don't know what the percentage is 13% whatever it is button should be different than because it it belongs in every animal so tells us that doesn't give matonics you don't give matonics so now the ask the If a deer say keep on going you want to compare to a deer and say a deer doesn't have a so dear you know there's no what's if you learned with us if you didn't before that says it's really should be whole we discussed this but it means that a mother and her son do not she ever you don't she in the you don't she chef the mother and son on the same day but when you have a deer you could check the mother dear and her and her offspring in the same day so maybe says so you have this animal supposed to be it's not no longer because it got a so now you maybe you could check this it's offspring the same day wait a minute why how you can bring this if It's comp considered 100% it's a sheep and if you want to compare it to regardless how come before you didn't say the same answer or you're saying oh you should you should you should be able to eat and and then you said no there's a pos but say the same thing if it's regardless it's No. So, you know what? Let's go back says that you can't eat it. It's it's it's fats and therefore I learned from the same word that there's you can't do you can't at the same day as its offspring. the word actually just comes from. So how do I know that I can't eat the the fat from the word right going to explain it says blood doesn't say fat how how do you learn fat from blood I really should show the video because I see the falling asleep before there's no video here let's go because it says so let's go the comes from. So how do you know that the of a sheep that that's you eat it? I learned from the blood. You shouldn't eat the blood. You said you said that it's like it's shouldn't be any better than is no better than a deer and a deer the blood is also he must say when it says the blood it's referring to the obvious question is and it's a beautiful answer question why would the Torah use a word a completely different thing it's talking about the brain that says is a heart. Why? Why say it means but it said blood? What's the answer is? Because we have a that says like and we have the theor say that if you eat you don't get carus when it says that this carus on somebody that eats it's talking about the fat of of an animal of a Did you get cars? Here we have the pos if anybody wants to see here. So that's why the switched from the from the word. You think that you only get a lot to teach you two things first of all the fat but that the fat you get you shouldn't say that it's only it's only says how could say such a thing but he's telling me what is no doesn't talk about the the is talking about what is how do from the word. He says the word comes for not for even if we wouldn't say the word I would say means like you thought and now it's now it says the word so the actually comes for if it would have said I would have said it's for Okay, I got this bottle of wine from David Le and it says like this I was able the first time in my life to do. [applause] So it's a reminder to it's perfect time. It doesn't get any better than this year. Start right now. You have the full week. A lot of times you get one or two days and it's a long par. It always starts you off. You know, they they say, "If you can do this, you're good to go." But that first parishes is no joke. This is and it says also that you shouldn't even start your morning s until you're completely done because it's a good thing to do. And many in in the hundreds have started. They're not embarrassed. And don't forget if you ever skip a parish show, you miss a parish show, which happened to me this year, a bunch of parishes because I went to America and it threw me off completely, you just continue. It's a good thing to finish it up before. But you just continue like we got to finish up here. This animal that you made, it was a regular carbon. Then how do you know it doesn't go to? Let's see the Oh, here we go. We're going to dish in the first three words over there. Not the first three, but the red purple red. So, first of all, it says it's talking about this, right? We said at the end, the same we saw before you could check it. Do not cheer its wool. Do not drink its milk. You eat it. Do not send it to the dogs. Here's where we learn that you don't redeem it. Feed it to the dogs. says, "No, you don't learn from here anything about the dogs. What you learn is that when you that's when you're permitted, you could redeem it and send it to the dogs." Why is this milker after you redeem it? Let's see if we can find this one. Yoshi did a new one for us. Maybe this. Let's see. Yeah. Yeah, this one. Love this uh timeline thing. He made it yellow. Then he redeemed it, took the money. So the kadushi goes into the money. Then oh, so she became pregnant and she gave birth after the pion. [music] What game is that? Mario. Am I? Oh, at least Yeshua likes it. [laughter] What's the problem? It's It's like a It's like a a deer's offspring. We said we saidd is like a deer's offspring. It's like a deer. So, dear has offspring is fine. Oh, so we have to say I don't know. We should speed this up somehow. But the point is that the pregnancy happened before the pion's watching good. Oh, here's the pregnancy before the redemption. Then came redeeming then came birth. But what if they gave if she gave birth before the redeeming then it's actually how do you know that if they were born before the college this is referring to it says the word the rabbis is of you you could uh you mac the offspring the rabbis is that if you do a again what's a you take the you say I want this animal to be instead of this animal then both animals you're they have the same that they're all they don't have any blemishes and the doesn't have blemish so it's how do you know that there still the rabbis Should we stop over here? >> Have a good We'll try to be more on time from now on. [music] >> Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com [music] or sponsor at mdyop.com.