8 Min Daf - Chullin Daf 78 by R’ Eli Stefansky

Hulan DAF ein feste was starting a brand new Parekh Aceves binoy which is an insert the shaft a mother and her offspring on the same day some say even a father in sorcery on the same day the ister is irish chorus this sir applies even if you shut the offspring first and then the parent and even if two separate people do it the second person who chefs the second animal of the pair gets malgus we're going to be discussing Hulan inside that Zara and heck - car bunnies that are that are shafted outside as our if you shall Hulan inside as are you don't get it - however the hoon is also about healing you now that eat it if you shift hutch him outside of the me some English you get Korres and Malchus and in addition you now how to eat the animal if you chef and here's a very interesting Allah if you shift a mother and the the offspring let's say is cotton that same day the costume is removed from the offspring because you have a history of Isis binoy that's what we call me hustlers man the second carbon it's not in its right time since you cannot hello quickly Shack the second one so it's no longer costume you don't get in a very of caution today but you get that very of all you say that's Bernard says the Mishnah OMS binoy is even in who starts even in America you now as chef a mother and her offspring on the same day even in a time when there's no way I'm English so really we have four possibilities here we have hula and cotton we have inside the base I'm Mick Dodge and outside of the base innings and now we're gonna have a very very interesting mission on where the mission goes through all 12 possibilities and combinations of hula and egg dish inside and outside of the base amigos and we'll go through them one by one with these pictures the first case is if both animals are Hulan outside the base em English so the first one is 100% motor to chef because it's cooling this have what we do every day this second one is and really let eat it the second one is not a is a problem because you're shifting oh you save as binoy it's not that's outside the problem is Isis binoy and therefore you are allowed to eat it those even though he doesn't ask her to eat but you will get Marcus only one person gets marks second case is both animals are clutching and you shuffle them outside so now the first one number one has a big problem cuz you shuttle come outside you get cars and Malthus the second one is not coaching anymore because it's mitosis man since you chef to the first one you can chop the second one so the second one you get Malthus only for ISIL is benign the third case is if both animals are Hulan and they're inside of you some English you now a - a fool inside a Miss it based on English but you don't get an Irish but you cannot eat it so the first guy doesn't get Malchus the second guy gets monkeys because he shifted vice-versa Benari and therefore you can't eat it because it's inside any side Mick dodge both of them you can't eat coolin inside of me some additionality eat the fourth case if both animals are cutting inside of you some English the first one is perfect no way sir it's a mitzvah the second one is the problem is it's not coaching because it's moses mom because you shut it the first one but it is Isis Benari so you'll get only Malkin's because of i service Venoy the fifth case Hulan and kuchen outside so the Hulan part is perfect you let a shuffling outside no there the second one coach him outside it's not a problem for coaching because it's Moses man it's a problem because of Ava's Venoy you get only Marcus the sixth phase coaching and Hulan outside so now you started with kocham that's a big no-no for that you get cars and Malchus the second carbon is only Hulan outside so you get Marcus but you don't you're allowed to eat that carbon with the first one you're not ready the seven case kulhanek option inside so you know our chef cooling inside we don't get punished the second one is not kocham because it's moses man but you'll get Marcus so basically the second guy gets mark is you cannot eat both of the car bonus the eighth case coach him and Hulan inside coach him inside is perfect you'll add a chef the carbon inside of a sandwich the problem is the Hulan inside the Hulan you only get mouth is for oysters Benari and you know how to eat it because you shuffle until you see this in that case is Hulan out side and inside so the whole nation the answer is perfect Huna shafted inside you don't get Irish for the chuffing inside we get orange voices binoy the Leavitt case sorry the 10th case coach him outside and inside chef Nicotra matter you get cars and Malchus stuffing inside you only get Marcus fries this video you but not for watching because this man 11 the case who an inside and outside the who and inside is no gonna be don't get punished for it but you know let's eat it the whole an outside you are over voices binoy but you're allowed to eat it 12 and final cases Hatchin inside perfect and the costume outside you will bet marcus only choices binoy and you're not allowed to eat it now let's go back to the Gemara so the first puzzle tells us about this helluva Moses man that you now that a chef an animal when it's about unto its eight days old and the tire uses the Russian sharp boy said oh yes so it says both the Shar you seen read a second later the next posture talks about us visit binoy said the Gemara from the fact that it says love and the buff connects the to pursue kim so we know that the first ones he's talking about coaching so the second passing is also talking about coaching and the fact that it says sure and say again so we know the song about Hulan as well so we know who land and culture the is sir of isis Venoy is also by climb so we have a hybrid of a goat and a sheep you're now at a chef the mother and offering the same day i would think that maybe after chef sorry sir and their and their offspring in other words have to shop for animals in order to be over and that says a good mario know it says the word binoy singular it's a parent and their offspring I don't think maybe have to chef three let's say an ax plus a sheep and its offspring for that ignore says it says are you saw singular that only to now according to a Haniyeh as gonna see later that he uses the site to teach us that even a father and its offspring is all sir he uses the word I say so the word I say is not extra so according to him you have to say that anytime the tire says two things like sure say you put in automatically by yourself you put in the word I say for instance by Michaela of a v-mail we know that you're not the curse both a father so the tire doesn't need to say that the winter is shaky Cal obviousiy my it's either horses kanayo now the regulation she learns from the fact that the tiger puts the word koala by the father and then the word caller by the mother that's how I know that it's either/or but I wouldn't know it on our own so hanami would take that dress should attribution just said and learn from there that uh you're not a lot of curses is there I see the curse your parents after they are dead now the question is is I say Benari also with a father even though the word I say is masculine it's it's a soccer but we say certainly means in a cable does it also mean ossifer a father and his Austrian Anna shaft in one day so Kahana learn oh sorry means either or either the father or the mother so which one is it they say makes a lot more sense to say it's the mother because we find by she lua Hakan that mitzvah only applies to a mother like the turkey isn't saying emo that there's it's talking about a mother over there mm Ayla by an hour possum it's also talking to referring to the mother and in addition to that even if we don't learn from she walk again since it says binoy it means a kid that's connected to their parent especially when it comes to animals the the the offspring are a lot more connected to the mother they nurse from them and they're taken care by the parent the mother so they're more connected to the mother makes more sense that we were talking about a history of shuffling a mother and her offsprings now finale says since it says I saw and it also says binoy I saw it would mean either or and binoy I saw it would mean the father sorry I say would mean a saw her I saw I not only saw and been I would mean the one that he's connected to the most which is the mother so therefore this is room I said this when I record the Hanyu applies to both a father and a mother and their offspring have a wonderful day