8 Min Daf - Chullin Daf 75 by R’ Eli Stefansky

Hulan define a typically a live animal cannot be Mikado Tomo we're discussing a Ben pakua that you're allowed to eat asses of - ketta can it be Makabe toma since its food we're basically says yes it's Mikado two minutes food home say you write its food but at the end of the day it's a live animal live animals cannot be in Kabul Toma we have a similar flight goes by fish when is official Kabul tumour wish I may say fishes in Kabul Tomo as soon as you pull it out of the water since fish don't require shaquita since this if they're dead even though they're still alive dimma Kabul to me he still says no they still say you have to wait until the fish dies completely then it's McHale Toma if we keep us in between he says if you pull it out of the water and it's not gonna live any longer it's thrashing around or it has a dry spot the size of a cellar that's considered as if it's already dead even though it's a lie and at that point it's Makabe - no what about a fish that has a tray fur to it it has a wholesome in its intestines it's not gonna live it's not gonna live and it doesn't require she thought maybe shipping a couple to me right now Sigmar says even if you hold that tray for lives you can live longer than 12 months maybe a fish is different than an animal by an animal you say that that's considered trade fun it's no good but buy fish since its life has less life than an animal because once you pull out of the water it dies so maybe it's considered dead right now and should be McConnell Tomo on the other hand you could say even if you hold that at Raiford doesn't live that's only by something that has the concept of schita but a fish doesn't have the whole kinds of the cheetah so maybe shouldn't have the kinds of the tray fur now hey Lev we know is the isser chorus whereas the isser of eating novella is alive we're talking about a naval a stillborn that didn't come to full term in the pregnancy what is that like a status of its halo is it chorus like the mother or it's just a piece of meat and it would be an available says the Gemara that a corner be open on all we care about is that it should come and come out into the world see the light of day since this navel was born even though it's dead it was born into the world then it's halo is regular halo the which logo says no what you need is a full-term pregnancy and come out into the world and since there wasn't full-term pregnancy it's not Curtis it's only in available some people say that there's no Shiloh over here that if it wasn't a full-term pregnancy everybody holds that this scale is only novela what it's happening over here is that it is a full-term pregnancy but this animal wasn't born yet and somebody stuck their hand into the mother and pulled that part of the pilot is that considered failing or not why because I was on the one hand you had a full-term pregnancy it's nine months on the other hand it never came into the world rebirthing says it's considered calif because all you need is months they're sluggish says you need both months and see the light of day and since you didn't have that here it's novela now the Gemara says a very interesting Halawa what happens if after you chef to the mother you find out that the mother was a trayful does that trade for go down to the bed pakua you have a fetus that doesn't require a logically shmitah but maybe you can't eat the fetus because it's a fetus of a trade for and in itself is also trayful so the more according to our mayor that holds that if it's a full-term pregnancy you have to chef the fetus anyways so then the fetus is independent of its mother so just because the mothers trayful doesn't make the fetus straight but according to her hyung that whole that you could check the mother and you don't have to Shack the fetus then the fetus is like the mother and since the mother's straight for the fetus is also straight for huh Robert says know that there's two ways to eat this animal one is by shifting the mother and then you don't have to chef the baby the other way is to shut the baby so since you could shut the baby so then you shut the baby and the baby's independent of the mother and you could eat it even though the mother is traif very interesting that room I see set over that he heard from her vehicle and exactly like this that you could check the baby just the mother there's two ways to eat this baby so ribs area is Revathi when you say that you heard this from revealing on what happened to her sluggish all over shots never be a little sluggish either he argues with the realtor he agrees but where is rich luggage over here this is Revathi what happened was that every time rebuildin would say something or slugs want to argue he had a minute cause he would wait maybe Roberto would regret it at this point when he paused stuff database Murray had no idea whether which luggage argued or not there's some that say that Rakesh went to drink water service he didn't know if he argued that's why he just quoted Rebecca none now in the mission we have a mouth like is between a hum and rib Shimon shizuru which doesn't seem like much of the mahadji's it says the haha mom hold then abend pakua is even in the ninth month if a baby came to full term and you shifted the mother you don't have to shut the baby comes rip Seamus to Zuri and says even if the baby was five years old and walked around on the field and was plowing you could eat the baby where's the Mohicans they both hold the same thing that full-term baby is a Ben Burke walk says the guimard Micah says that according to the hummin once a Ben pakua puts its feet on the ground you have to shaft it that people shouldn't mistake he's been pakua for regular analyst say oh you don't have to shuffle any animal says the Gemara and we had this last week that if the father if we care about the genealogy of the father when it comes to animals and the father is a bamboo core and the mother is not a been picure and they had offspring so this offspring has no tack on it you can never eat it you can't checked it you certainly it's not a Ben pakua because one of the parents isn't the member Kaur and to check that you can't because it says if one of the C Mon M is not here and one of the C Mon amis shafted and one of them is not Shepherd over here as she says a little bit different what Roger said in the other game over here actually says something interesting that even if you want to combine the two C Mon and say we want to shift it so I'll stuff the second Simon you can't chef the second Simon because that would be a very long XI here between the birth and escrito that would be she here now there's two the showing us in a bio about it says that today you could eat a bit back or as long as you make a big Hecker then everybody knows that it's been before for instance if you have an animal that has that doesn't have split hooves a collet you laddie eat a bamboo core or dr. Lawson is that it has to have to seem on him it's the son of a animal that had no hooves so you have a father or mother that had no hooves and the baby had no hooves that's a huge Simon the article brings that uh riff sharira going he at his kid's wedding took two member cores and chopped her head off with an axe and he said this is a simian in front of the whole wedding this is a hacker I want to show that is the concept of Ben pakua according this abaya that whole farm of epic was in Australia is not a good idea now xiri passing like you're finished Azuri and he said that even generations after generations of baku if you combine if you have a father mother Bonet before then the next generations been back or like the farm in Australia according to one last reveal don't want to say in Russia machinery that it's only the replica itself but the next generation is not counted as than before actually pass cannot like rubbish in Missouri and he said the only time we passing later dezirian chasse is two times one when a person says give a get to my wife and he forgets to say to new so typically we say he's just trying to upset his wife but if he's going to be killed and if she missions over he adds even if he's very sick then we give it we give the get even though even say giving it the other cases if a person bought fruit from a Moritz and the fruit is mine so he takes true must my sir which is one percent of the fruit and that from smiler fell back into the fruit the problem is that true miss my sisters bottle 1 in 100 over here he took one out of 100 meaning he had 99 left unfortunately for him he was off by one if it would been one more fruit would be bathtub arrived so what does he do since it's a great loss thing because he could only sell tug Clarion Irizarry says he could asked mrs whether or not he took my sir and we could trust a Mars typically we only trust our Mars for Shabbos look over Chavez over here will trust him during the week as well have a wonderful day