8 Min Daf - Chullin Daf 72 by R’ Eli Stefansky

Hulan laughs iron Bay's we learned yesterday that if somebody swallows Touring's one is Tommy one a star there in his body cavity the tie ring remains third even if it touches the Tommy ring because of the concept called tumor blue swallow tumor if a tumor is in a hidden swallowed place that Toma doesn't emit doesn't transfer to the other ring so as the Gemara so then what's the difference between the midwife who's assisting the birth as soon as she touches the baby the mission says she becomes Tommy but why it occurred in a place of Baloo ah it was in a swallow place why she any different then at ah her ring says Itamar you write me there I saw she should be completely Taher the reason why she's Tommy is only exerted their opponent with the robot were worried that the baby will come out a little bit become Tommy and then go back in equip this goes according to Rabbi Shmuel who says then the baby is completely tired even a coronary Shmuel that the baby is completely tired we still make it zero that she is Tommy and why is the mother any different because for the mother she didn't touch the bit the dead baby the baby's worth inside her in it's too much base has started that's not Mitama her now maybe you should make a zero that once the baby comes out and then goes back in it she should become Tommy well she knows when the baby comes out she feels it but she doesn't have the time or the mindset to give that information over to the Midwife and that's why we were guys are only on the Midwife now who's McCullough Rameshwaram all says a baby with inside a mother's stomach even if the baby's dead is completely toy Bettina says completely Tommy and he brings up Ozzie as apposite to learn this it's actually a three-step process 3 sukham the posix says call naturally space all the souls of a dead person now a dead person usually only has one soul so what's this plural Lawson says Webb Akiva is referring to that blood of a dead person a reveres has Toma just like a limb of a dead person says rebec eva that naturalist means even if the blood came from two dead people a half of a reviews from one and a half a reviews of another they combine to make one reviews maybe schmosby says the Amos is not true it has to be from one person now since the rib Akiva learns from : Oishi May's that is talking batteries so the possibly be mates bin FS completely extra he learns from that and that's our so you been mace there's a dead person bin nefesh in a soul how do you have a dead person in a soul says Rubik either you have a dead baby within its mother and here you see that that baby is Mitama and therefore the third posture can a saw the is that recording to keep open a southern riebeck evil learns comes to say that a guy landed effect meaning the cover of a coffin and the sides of the coffin have the same Halawa as a dead person itself in other words if one were to take a cover of a coffin that had a dead person in the coffin and put that cover inside a room everything in the room becomes tommy to my soil just like a dead person himself tremendous village says the Mishnah we know as we said in the beginning of the parrot that if we chef the mother the baby is motor back he let's call the bin pack or if the baby stuck at its foot before you had the opportunity to shut the mother that foot is considered a vermin achhi and it has two ma likun availa the tomb is called every minute - mo very interesting question you have here a situation where you have a baby a calf its foot is Tommy Thomas novela the rest of the body is not does the tumor transfer from its from its foot to the rest of the body well if you cut off the foot while the baby was still alive then there was no way for the tomato transfer because a live animal does not is not susceptible to Toma if the baby was dead when you cut the foot off in other words you chef - the mother and the baby is dead and the baby is motor Bakula but now you want the Toma to transfer from the foot to the baby to the rest of the body does it transfer the answer is according to remains FERS and a very high level of Toma called Thomas novella according to hummin almost no tomato called Thomas Truffaut Truffaut is really not Tommy it's only Tommy Maduro Bonin when it's regarding puchen now question is how exactly does the Toma transfer what's the problem the problem is if you have two things touching the inside part is hidden this part is hitting so when they're touching they're not really touching they're touching but you don't see where they're touching and when you separate them when you cut it they no longer touch so how do they have the power to transmit Toma one to the other from the foot to the rest of the animal there's two answers Allah says you're right it doesn't really transfer naturally it transfers while you cut when you cut it's inevitable that one piece will rub against the other piece as you remove it that's one shot and that's why it fits very well into the mission with the Mishna says you cut the limb and that's to tell us that that's when the Toma transfers according to Raveena you don't have to come out to cutting anything that's about to be cut is as if you cut it so therefore this limb you're gonna cut because it's Tomas Nevada you want to get rid of it so it's as if it's cut already we find the same allahabad ackley that you wanna bring to the mikveh let's say somebody's wife tells him go out and buy me a frying pan and he goes out and buys a frying pan with a broom handle he comes home and his wife says what are you crazy she said yeah you're right I'm gonna cut the handle but before he cuts a handle he goes to the mikveh with it he tries to get it into the Kaylin mikvah and it doesn't work according to her Maher it's fine you don't have to put the whole handle in the mikveh because you you're gonna come home and if you know what's good for you you're gonna cut that handle so therefore even though now it's not cut there's no tumor the it's enough to be title whatever part you are gonna have it then according to Hamid no you have to be title of the whole thing says the Gemara well even a point of a common there you have to be title the whole thing maybe over here in our sugar they will admit that by food there's a concept called and here's the concept for the whole shot according to common have or a robbery all clink Amanda mattress a dummy it's any time that comes to food everything is separated even though they're connected it's as if they are separated now she's going back to the Mishnah the Mishna says that a tray for once you shift a traif animal let's say it has a hole in its heart you shift it the schita is good enough to get rid of the Toman animal yes you're right you can't eat the animal but there's no more to man animal says the mission it's not similar to shifting a non kosher animal you shut the lion never in its lifetime or any of its family's lifetime does she eat the work but in an analyst Rafe even maybe before it became a trade for you were able to shut it but certainly its family members you could check see the works once you keep the work says Rashi sheathing never comes off of it so the sheath will work to remove Toma from it remain says yes he the works to remove tray feh the automa but it only works for the mother and not for the limb of the fetus one more I love the Gemara discusses brings in part of the shackling carrier but it's important to know is the halacha of tumors bedrooms if you have a piece of cloth that's three by three to five and it's royal for somebody to sit on and stand on I love it if you have a Slavs over neither yet stand on and put their body weight on it then that beg it becomes Tommy what if you rip that baguette in half then the tumor disappears the Tomas measures however the Gemara says the remai holds its puzzler air holds that even though it's hidden like we said the the place where it was cut was hidden he might hold that tumor space s arm does give Toma so when you cut it you write the metrics flies away but now it's as if it touched measures it's a much lower tumor called megameters but it touched or we can learn differently that the only time you have Maggie mattresses if azov' stepped on it with his feet barefoot meaning there's two tombs that occurred here one from his weight and one from actually touching it so when you cut it the weight Toma the measures disappears but the touching tumor which is a much lower torment Amin it's only a resign that could only be my time of food and not people in jail that remains