8 Min Daf - Chullin Daf 70 by R’ Eli Stefansky

raise other good hiders cool enough ayan we're continuing yesterday's secure at what point is about considered born is it when two-thirds of his body come out from that point on or when two-thirds of his body come out we say that retro actively what we saw coming out was a Behar now if that's what we say then we have to be very careful that if that law has it you're allowed to cut a limb off and feed it to the dog that's if you feed it to the dog right away but you have to be careful not to let two thirds of the Behar accumulate and then feed it to the dog because at that point will be too late it'll be considered a Bihar born and you know how to give it to the dog very interesting halakhah if a Bihar is born feet-first because if he's born headfirst as soon as the head comes out is considered a birth and it's a Bihar but let's say feet first and 51% of the Bihar came out now the 51% is including part of his upper foot let's say and most of his foot is still inside the mother so you're right realistically we have 51% out of the body but maybe how logically we should view it as the part that's out of the body the small part of the foot like you see in the picture the green arrow maybe should be considered as if it's still inside the mother because the larger part of that foot is inside the mother you go after the right size ignore no we definitely don't say such a thing 51% out of the body is considered that the Bihar was born however as the Gemara in the governor stays with the Shilo what if 50% was born and most of the foot is outside of the body now a reverse case the red arrow in the picture is outside of the body the green is inside the body can we use the green part of the arrow which is inside of the body and Bhima Seraphin to the red arrow and say you're right that only 50% of the baby was born but maybe how logically it's 51% Mara stays with us our camp now the tire says that a Bihar is considered a Bihar when the petr ahem it's the first born and it's the one that opened the womb we know that born cesarean with a cesarean is not considered first born now the Maya has a series of questions seven questions which will actually the Gemara stays with at a coup but will explain to us a little bit more what is considered born as a part all these questions are when the heart is born feet first question number one is let's say they wrapped the the calf with a towel of some sort does that create a hats it'sa to the womb does it have to be born touching the womb or a towel is also good or not good now if a towel is not good what if you used the placenta of another animal plus M is a different type of material it's more of its own natural material maybe that doesn't create a casita what about if there's a midwife that helps give birth to this cow and she stuck her hands in do the hands predicate Itza again that's something that's typically done does something that you typically do create a hot seat so the Gemara is a very interesting question that choices in fact uses this Gemara and JavaScript on base on base to say that sometimes the emergence ask questions that are almost impossible just in order for us to get scarred rajshekhar buscar what if a weasel goes into the animal it's his she goes into the she pulls them swallows the baby comes out of the sheet now that's not considered a birth then goes back into the sheep spits out the baby into the sheep and then the baby comes out by itself is that considered a birth or now now twice it says it almost can't happen but maybe in our days something like that could happen for instance if they remove the baby surgically to repair something then they put the baby back in with a cesarean and then the babies born naturally do we say that the natural birth that occurred after the baby is completely outside of the mother is that considered a birth or not etc a similar question that Texas also discusses it says it's almost impossible is that what happens if you take two womb so you put them back to back and the one baby comes out of room number one but makes its way into womb number two so coming out of the womb number one is for sure that the rhythm but and then it's born naturally from womb number two can we use one animal to do Pat the record on two separate animals your mother stays with the tegu in both of these what if the baby never touched the birth canal it was wide open and it fell out let's say does the ear create a pet or ethem or does it have to actually touch the mother what if the birth canal was completely removed from its mother and wrapped around his shoulder for instance does the birth canal have to be in its natural position or just has to be touching the the baby as it's born now if the birth canal somebody took a potato peeler and peeled the entire birth canal that would for sure not be considered birth now but what if says the Gemara a little part of the birth canal was peeled most of it was left intact but the baby came out of the part that was peeled do we go by the ROI and say that this baby was born from a birth canal that has most of its skin intact or no and then vice versa most of the birth canal was peeled and the baby came out of the small part that wasn't peeled do we say you have ripe numerous days with the table says the mission room is numb if we know that every animal is that dies is an available what if the mother a kosher animal had an availa head of the baby inside where that died says says the Gemara that if you touch that and avaylo you are tart however if the animal is a non kosher animal and has a baby inside it that died and you touch it that's my leg is an omission what's the reason why an animal that dies within its mother is not an availa because we have a confinement we say if an animal dies inside its mother a chef the mother you're allowed to eat the animal inside even though it was dead at the time the schita so certainly the mother should protect its baby from Tomah once we have that concept and that's why kosher animal that we can use the heck is from a kosher animal to a non kosher animal because it says in the puzzle but he almost been a Bahama that puzzle really is seems like it's talking about a completely kosher animal but we divide the puzzle the top part we say the key element of a name is talking about a non-kosher random and then it says it's for ye I share Hilo hemlock it is for UT meaning it's talking about a kosher animal so we can compare a kosher animal to non kosher animal and in that cold shower will have the same Aloha as the kosher animal that they may be inside it is not Tommy but really sees mahogany says a by a non kosher animal it is MIT Tommy why be the positive never sure should take up a hold over Tommy I believe let's try to nail the POSIX needs to be talking about a non kosher animal the is what's the between a non-kosher animal and kosher animal all animals are matt i'ma bin availa the answer is because we basically hold it this puzzle is only talking about our situation where an animal is inside its mother and only if it's a tummy animalism atomic and anatomy animal is talk now rebby as we'll see tomorrow staff learns from this puzzle that reveals it brings a completely different limit so therefore we see in order for him to learn from this puzzle that a non-kosher animal isn't Amma has to use another positive reveals hook the music learns from the posse of hongyok kappa than any animal that doesn't have split hooves kappa meaning he wants on his paws so his baby is Mitama her babies in autonomy something more asked for wait a minute what about a pig a pig has split hooves so maybe her baby is not Mitama that can be a piggy sometimes just like any other animal so at any rate so we don't want to use that possible but a combination of that puzzle kalila up oh and our puzzle together we learn that a non-kosher animal is Mitama cornerbacks and finally rabbuna son asked ben azzai we have sukham for three out of the four types of animals a Bahama Cairo and a Bahama that's not a Bahama it's not kosher in a higher that's not cultured that their alma Tom Otterness novela how do we know that if a deer that Sakaya shiro dies how do you know that it emits tumor so he tried to give him an answer from the pilot-house top and the governor said no but I used that for something else so then banana he looks at Revere instances and what is your Rebbe yesh mall say you didn't use the term Rabbi Shmuel he said yes what does he say she said I thought what he says he says he learns it from the positive he almost made a Bahama the top part like we said before is referring to a non kosher animal I should heal of her mouth was referring to a kosher animal and an animal a Bahama is like a higher and a high like a Bahama and kosher is like not kosher and from this faucet you see all animals even a high up Shira is Mitama when as I was extremely impressed and he said this lotion Hvar been as i referring himself it's a shame i'm Banaszak sheila sheemish as rebel oil in other words it's a shame that i didn't have the opportunity to serve rabbi shmuel and now we use the lotion Rebbe as coveted it's what a shame Tyra's so beautiful have a wonderful day have a good bench - fine - I'll see you later Sun tomorrow