Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
8 Min Daf - Chullin Daf 66 by R’ Eli Stefansky
26 views
Video from Gary
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
a good nerve shop is huland of some of
of yesterday with discussing
grasshoppers and one of the grasshoppers
we were discussing was the elongated
head grasshopper mcquaig is whether or
not he's kosher what's the McLucas well
the Torah says that any grasshopper that
has crying
meaning he has those two jumper feet
that propels him to the air is kosher
the way the tire says it I sure like
crying he has crying but in fact it's
written with a Aleph like he doesn't
have cried so what's going on here does
he have to have crying he doesn't have
cried well obviously the tire means that
he has crying so why didn't I write it
without us so the Gemara in yesterday's
DAF that the tire is telling us that
sometimes the grasshopper is so young he
doesn't have the jumpers yet boy crying
he doesn't have crying
nevertheless he's kosher because he's
from the species that eventually will
have jumpers and therefore today's
culture but the Gemara says that we're
dealing here with a cloud and Pratt and
maybe even a cloud Pratt the cloud
according to the bay rubbish mall and
that's the mahadji's what is it is
Charlotte crying any grasshopper from
all 800 grasshoppers that has two
jumpers this culture so that's a very
general statement then the turn comes
along says no let me qualify that only
four out of the 800
are bow solemn cargo and hug of for this
is very very specific so that's a clown
and a prat and when I have a comma Pratt
I can't learn anything else I can't have
any long gated head guy it's only those
specific for and what's exactly like the
specific for the babyish well says and
why don't the very rather learned that
there's a cloud private cloud in fact
that the Torah says limine a who which
should include a lot of other
grasshoppers they hold that when you
have a chiropractic cloud the final the
second cloud has to be very similar to
the first cloud the first law says
jumpers but the second Clause says
limine a its kind which would mean that
it has the the foursome on him that the
mission of states which are for legs for
wings and that the wings
for most of its body and then it has two
jumpers but then has nothing in common
with the first cloud so therefore they
learned that it's not a cloud Pratt and
cloud it's just a cloud Pratt the very
small say no it doesn't matter that the
last cloud is not similar to the first
one it's still a cloud will practically
and in fact this is the source to all
shots that the barriers will hold that a
cloud look at the cloud the first and
last cloud won't have to be similar
that's the my collegues and therefore an
elongated head grasshopper corn the very
small is included in the cloud proudly
clock now we're gonna move on to fish
the cache missile fish the Mishna says
that in order for a fish to be kosher it
has to have to see monitor snap it
because guesses fins basically like
wings that propelled through the water
and discusses scales scales don't move
they don't have to move fins move to
propel through the water what happens if
a fish doesn't have scales today but as
he grows older he'll develop skills
similar to the question we had by
grasshoppers and their jumpers says the
Gemara that's perfectly fine meaning
well think Mars trying to say here is
that you don't need to have scales in
order to eat a fish the scales just show
us what type of fish we're dealing with
it's that species that's kosher how do I
know it supposed to because it has
scales but it doesn't have to have
skills today it's not like say to simona
buy a Bahama they have AK on
intervention if you don't have a con
intervention that obviously the pain is
straight no this is just showing you
what species it is and therefore says
the Gemara if you have a fish that as
you take him out of the water there's
some sort of tuna that has you take it
out of the water it loses its scales
it's also poaching because there's a
species that has scales now there's a
concept that any fish that has scales
automatically has fins but not
necessarily if you have fins you have
scales therefore if you see that a fish
has scales it's automatically cause you
don't have to check for its fins the
obvious question is then why does the
term mention fins at all all the time
should say is any fish that has scales
closure I mean we know that any fish
that has scales has fins
and answer is very unique answer that so
the goddess was wearing Cass Kassim is
wearing an armor that looked like scales
so we know that scales means what we
know today has scales that has Kassim
our scales but nevertheless there are
people that might not know the Navi
so therefore the tiger elaborates borne
meaning there's the ocean and not the
other scale there's water and a clean
now we're talking about fish conscious
of fish and then there's two in between
so goes ocean is number one the best of
the best for fish to catch the fish then
goes my own it's the water that comes
out of the ground they have a bar or a
cave where it's rainwater gathered but
it doesn't come out of the ground just
stays there worst of the worst is water
that just sits in a clean like a mikvah
and the Gemara tells us an amazing ilaha
ilallah that not everybody knows and
just for this it's worth doing the death
if one were to be in a mikveh and he's
very hungry and along comes a juicy worm
or some source chickens that was created
in the water and doesn't have a snapper
to kiss kisses you let it eat it because
it's in a body of water that doesn't
flow from the ground and it's not a yam
says the game are not only that not only
in a mikveh but even if the water is
gathered in a pit and it's connected to
the ground and how do I know that
selling tomorrow there are tubes soaking
but talk about the caches of fish who
want positive starts off saying that
you're allowed to eat any fish that has
snappy big discusses that has a modem
then the psychopathic says that you're
not a lot of eat fish that don't have
stopped it because kisses and they would
seem redundant because if I know that I
have to have snapper because guys didn't
feed fish then obviously if they don't
have some greatest kissers it saucer
teeth the first POSIX says to include in
the beginning of the possum and at the
end of the second says to halo says the
good money that the second plastic helps
us for the first possible meaning then
for the second passing I learned that
any fish that's in the ocean has to have
sniper because cases
however if it's not in the ocean if it's
in a barter if it's a pet who's creating
a pen it does not need to have snob
every case guesses doesn't have to have
a seam on it you're allowed to eat worms
in the makeup and how do I know that in
a bar as well because of that extra say
flu in the beginning of the possible now
just one other hahaha
it seems like from the word - hello son
flu I know that even an animal that a
shake is that's in a body of water such
as a Bart that's like a plea you're
allowed to eat the amar says but wait a
minute I have a cloud loop rat here that
that teaches the same exact thing and I
don't need the word tight food what's
the cloud prophet it says by Mayim once
and then read weights by mag means all
water in the world and then it says by
Yaman which means only the oceans so
it's very very specific only the oceans
and anything outside the ocean even in a
Mayan even in a in a water that comes
out of the ground you should be able to
eat scottson that don't have started
because guesses so the Gemara
no because we're dealing with a cloud
proud to cloud not a culprit
I mean Mela it tells us that you cannot
eat from a mile
why is it a cloud practical Club because
it says amyum amyum twice that's two
clouds and then afterwards it says
Mohammed well wait a minute it's not a
cloud with brother Klaus it's a cloud
cloud El Prat says the cabarrus the same
thing anytime you have a cloud cloud you
prat you take the prep and you put it
between the two clouds and you come out
with a cloud
Pratt you clock have a wonderful Shabbos
I'll see you later champ on jobs
you