8 Min Daf - Chullin Daf 61 by R’ Eli Stefansky

Hulan Daffy Sam halluf come teach us that any bird that's similar to a measure that doesn't have any Simona cashiers is traif and any bird that's similar to a toy which is a Turtledove that has four Simoni conscious is Kaushik one of the Simoni caches it has an extra finger according to Rashi or the finger in the middle is elongated it has a crap and has a quirk of on that peels easily and it's thirst thirst means according to Rashi that it eats its food with its hand or that it sits on its food while it eats it or it kills the food with its feet or it eats its food while it's alive now the question is do we use nature as the prime example and we say anything that has one simin would be caution because inertia has zero C Mon or do we use the Turtledove as a prime example that it has to have at least four C Mon of Patras and anything less than force in Manama caches would betray we come at the mascot as a Silvia that we learn it from an esse any bird that has one sim in Patras is completely kosher provided that it's not on the list of 24 Birds that the tur brings down as trait what is an Escher someone has say that it's an eagle a bald eagle an ego the problem with that is as you can see here it has an extra finger and initial has zero C money caches and that's one semi conscious so I want to say that it's a vulture but we have the same problem it has the extra finger now in that it has a crap which is semi-conscious and initial has 0 C money conscious now allow me to take you through the ninth step so Bo since we have a very short top we could easily do this the Gemara says that repliest holds that a bird is kosher as long as it has once him as the Gemara how could that be a Turtledove attire says it's kosher and as forcing my name is Masha that anything less than 4 is traif says the Chimera but then why did the tyre give us a list of 24 birds that are traif or all you need to say is that a Turtledove is caution and I would know from that that anything less than forcing mana is trave if you take a look at the list zero one two three uh Natura has zero C Mon him a person owes me has one Simon uh I Rev which is a crow has to C Mon him and the rest of the birds 20 birds have three C Mon him but none of these have four seam on him so if a Turtledove has four seam on its culture it's much more than anything else and as less than four is trave this is the Gemara but i said the list of 24 to tell me that any bird that has even one cinnamon is kosher but as tomorrow maybe I told me I said the list I said the twenty birds that have to be C Mon him I tried to say that even if it has three C Mon amidst rave says the camera that can't be that if it has three C monument straight then why in the world did the tire talk about an oil rate all your only has two C Mon him if 3 C my name is trave certainly a crow that has to see my name is strafe LM I maybe I should learn directly from all Europe and say even if has to C Mon him it's still trave why are you telling me that a bird that has one semanas caution the answer is it can't be that if it has to see one of the strafe because then why did the Tigers say we're just going down one step after another then why did the terrorists say Paris anosmia person knows he only has one simin now if I Orion who has to see madam straight so certainly a Paris anosmia what is the Paris in Oz Nia well the fiscally says that a Paris is this guy called a bearded vulture it has a really cool beard and a paws Nia is an osprey now maybe we should learn from a Paris anosmia and say that if a bird has one simin like a person usnea it strafe like a person usnea that can't be and this is the final step because if it's true that a bird that has one similar strafe then why did the tiger talk about an Escher and Escher has zero C Mon if a bird that has one Simon astray so certainly in natural that 0 C - rave alumni I learned from here that any bird that has one Simon is completely kosher provided it's not on the list of the 24 birds at a trake s tomorrow if that's the case then why did the tiger bring down Turtledove at all I know that a Turtledove is not one of the 24 birds and at is at least one sim in it actually has forcing mine so certainly Scott you're sitting about you're right I'll Turtledove we newest question the only the reason why the Torre brought a Turtledove is to tell me that could bring it as a carbon and finally the Gemara asks you said in step number eight that you were going to learn from Paris anosmia to all other birds that if they have to see modern or 1/7 I'm sorry they are traif how can you learn for anything from Paris and owes me a person owes me are two separate things that the term repeated itself on snakes Superman Wonka what a Milan them how could I learn anything from Paris anosmia it says the Gemara no Paris arrows neo-nazi takes him a bomb yeah they're very different than all the other traffic's all the other Schaffer shared three out of the four seam on him but the same exact three out of the four the person that usnea took the fourth Simon and only they had that fourth Simon that no other bird had and therefore it's different than the other birds and different in each others it's not sneaks through my biome cathode have a wonderful day