8 Min Daf - Chullin Daf 119 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] you huland a few tests we're in the middle of this amazing suya of handles and protectors of food how they combine with the fruit and with the meat to combine for a shear of a cabeza you have a handle you have a yard that's connected to meet it combines to the shear of a cabeza but what is the minimum shear of the food that we're discussing here can it be a tiny piece of barley does it have to be a larger piece of food so we have enough like this wrap says that when it comes to handles the minimum shear of the food is a cos I use an olive and when it comes to a shame her the protector the skin the peel of a fruit the skin on meat then the minimum shear is a bean a large being a pull her girlfriend says no when it comes to a handle the minimum is less than a kiss ice it's a large beam it's a pull and when it comes to the protector of the food then the food itself doesn't have to be as large as a bean it could be even less than a bean and then the killer goes on to ask a few questions from different prices we have a Bryce so that says that if you walk into a house say for instance you have a bone this is the bone with a piece of meat at the end let's take a more colorful one here now you walk into the house this is a bone of a person a dead person and all you put into the house you stick into the house is the bony part so if the meat is a full koozies and all that goes into the house is the bone part then the whole house becomes common oil there's a tent over the bone and the bone is a conduit to tumor because the tongue is in the meat even though the meat is outside the house the whole house becomes Tommy because of yad this is the handle of the meat question is what happens in the malaika's is what happens if you have two pieces of meat and each piece is a half a gazaís do they combine to make a focus ice and all that goes into the house are these two bones sticking up so the town of Commerce says yes the combined review who the McCoys been in crisis says they do not combine you can't combine two halves so how does that fit in with my leg that we just said between rabbit really so this two ways to look at it either Rav says I could be talking about over here a handle that there's indeed meat on this side and this is the handle and since I hold that you need a Casillas and there's not a size it's too heavy cos a Sam I hold I hear you who the Ben Nick I saw and therefore it's no good or you could say we're not talking about that there's meat on this side we're talking about that there's meat inside the bone the bone marrow let's call this the bone marrow and it's actually a protector the the bone protects the bone marrow inside so no matter shomer it comes to Shamer you need less than a concise you need a point you need a beam and I hold like the Manta armor that says all you need is the tonic comma that says to have a causation of a Shimer arm it's tariff and everything is great according to her be open on they were talking about real and says you need less Anika's eyes so you need less than his eyes you need a pile so we're talking about each one has a half of his eyes that's enough that's why the Terra Cotta says two of these are M it's tariff and our Midtown of the house there's another price that says that if you have a thigh bone and it's interesting the doors gonna discuss this lush and why are we talking at a fiber but if you have a thigh bone and on the entire thigh bone is my like is how much meat you need in order for this piece of thigh bone to be Mitama to cause coma is it a cos ice or a poil a bean so again if we're talking about according to Rav so we're talking about is this bone a yard is it a handle and on top of the bone there's meat and we go according to review though and that's how we pass kin that you need acres ice the evidence says no we're discussing a trimer we're discussing that there's marrow inside of the thigh bone and as rather points out that's why we're talking about a thigh bone why we do so many other bones in an animal why are we discussing it's a coil is a thigh bone because that has a lot of marrows with all about of schramer and therefore you don't need you don't even need it once we talk about a Shimer beyond says you don't even need the size of it beam this that the other manometer says the higher me say that you need a size i mean they didn't really mean a beanie they meant even less than a beam Rav agrees that if we're talking about a creation a entity individual piece like we say how lava by an ant one small ant even though it's Anika's ice you're over five times monkeys why because it's his own entity so if you have your own being if it's a full thing then also the husk the appeal the Shimer could be its tariff to that fruit and create and become one combined for this year as we see in the price that it says the way how do we know Shurmur because that's how you plant that's how you see a your your seeds and you see them with the husk on it with the Shimer so you see even individual ones they have the Shimer can combine for the shear of a cabeza and one of the one of the things that's brought down a heat the sorrow and - a lentil which is obviously less then a shear a shimmer on top of a shimmer so the Gemara it's not MIT's tariff you cannot combine one layer above another layer so if you have for instance an onion that has many layers the top layer is obviously not a swimmer the layer below that the second layer if it doesn't have any cracks in it and it's actually protecting the onion so that can combine with the rest of the onion as a Shimer and a third layer since it's white it's already considered part of the onion food that you separate and one half of the food has a half a sheer and other half has the other half as here and they both have shame room are they mat starting Mars must open the Bryce's says the way like we brought it down before the way you seed a field is you you take these rhyme and in order to get to the shear of a cabeza you need obviously many seeds because the seeds are much less than a cabeza so the higher its Araya that you could take many seeds to combine to a shear so if you have 1/2 a shear and each half a shear has a small asteroid on it they can combine says Gamora perhaps we're talking about the amazing story myself in Steiners we're sharing instead of diving for we and each week Raschi brings over here it's not really in the kamorin tightness but he brings I think Martin Tanis says that they were each wheat each kernel was the size of two kidneys of a large ox according to everybody now we're talking about two here on an animal according to everybody the here on an animal is considered a Shimer there's a mouth like is whether or not it's considered to handle why cause in order for be the handle as yet you have to be able to pick it up lift it up without it ripping off and when you take the height of animal you lift it up by one here the height will rip off your sluggish has therefore it's not considered a handle but it is considered as Shimer what would be the difference being a streamer in a handle they both accomplish the same thing they both combine for the shear the answer is a shomer has to be directly above the meat and it's not directly above what it's protecting that it's not a protector you can't have something an umbrella protecting a person that's standing outside of the umbrella you have to have the piece of here directly above the piece of meat whereas a handle doesn't have to be directly above it could be either to the side so there's a kasha it says that if you have a piece of skin and underneath you have Acrisius meat and somebody touched to here on top he becomes Tommy so you see that even one here is Mitama so you have to say that it's talking about that the here is puncture through the skin and therefore it's a Shimer it's a protector of the meat because if it's above the skin then the skins are protected and this is a Shimer on top of a shaver which we said is no good or we could say that we're talking about many hears together many strands and it's a Yad because when you have many you could lift up to the height and since you have many even one of them if you touch it Smith Tama have a wonderful day