8 Min Daf - Chullin Daf 102 by R’ Eli Stefansky

huland Daffy cook BAE's a good Arab Shabbos when it comes to a ver minify the Israel to eat a limb from a live animal so this is a three sheeta's you have the schita that says everything in the world is included all animals kosher not kosher all birds kosher in our culture they have the schita that says only kosher animals highest Bahama spur kosher birds as well and then you have remain that says it only applies exclusively to bahama that are kosher not even high set a kosher knob birds that a kosher only to Bahama scows goat sheep etc what schmuck like is because it says yeah damn who are nephesh and the positive every minute hi it says that the blood that's the net that you can't eat every minify so anything that has a history of blood meaning all animals in the world have a sister to eat there drink their blood besides fish and grasshoppers but all animals including non kosher animals proponent say no it has to be a he look something that's right to be to eat that's where you have the instrument Amanda hi so meaning only kosher animals Bahama sky is advice but kosher those are the ones that have an icer ever gonna hi now review that we had the other day that says mr. Holland on an assert you can take one insert and apply it to another is if the second answer is more Hummer than the first one so you have everyone how should be able to apply itself to novela to at Mayo to an animal that's not kosher why because every man high was like you're not sure we said was before McIntyre's it's a very strong answer so in fact according to review that you don't need a pausing to learn the isser of every minute high on Tommy animal remain says that everyone highs only in behemoth and why does he say that because - took him before the positive everyone high it says me mid car home it's a hawk so he takes that to say that everyone high only applies to famous Barker and son now what about abhinaya what's his view says Rob according to everybody abhinaya would be offering all animals then there's no difference between kosher and Tommy so male all animals all birds have a history every man I find that is a very interesting browser that in one sentence you have to the split up the side and say the first part of the sentence talking about a Jew and the second part of the sentence on better when I because it says in the browser that if you eat a a ver one limb of a non kosher bird you don't get Malthus obviously is talking about a Jew a Jew doesn't get Malthus for eating a vermin a height from a non kosher animal according to this browser but why does itah get Marcus for eating non kosher the answer is because there's not a cos ice of meat of just me you have a cause ice total in other words you have a little bit of meat and sinews and bones and together it creates a gazaís for forever even a high you'd be over but for bus or Tommy you're not over for that then the creation of the sentences that there's no the she thought doesn't make this animal tire now if you're talking about a Jew and a non kosher animal of course the shaquita doesn't help obviously says the Gomorrah that this second part of the price is talking about a non Jew of Benoa and for him he that doesn't do anything in general for been Noah if a Bernard was to shift an animal since he's not even Chiquito he's a sir - eat the animal when it's jumping around like a chicken without a head would be awesome to eat even though shafted but for Jew it's motor as long as soon as you chef that you're allowed to eat it there's no every minute high but here's a big footage that if you take a Bahama Cairo that for a Jew you're allowed to eat it immediately after Chiquito so for been Noah because it's a kosher animal the Chiquita he's also letting eating it'll be after schita even though she does work from why because there's nowhere in the tyro that that something is motor for a Jew and a sir for a guy I don't know if you hear that but that's the siren here and remember she was saying that it's Shabbos we're gonna have to go soon now this tube sukham one talks about a vermin a high a limb of a live animal and other talks about the buzzer minute hi so Rav says in order to be over on a vermin 'hi you think that it's as long as we in you eatin a verse even if it's less in his eyes she says no you need at least the COS ice that ava has to be his eyes but you could add the sinews and the bones to the meat in order to make it as ice however when it comes to an availa meaning a kosher animal that died so over there you have that you're over on eating his ice boss or an SME pure meat no sinews and the same thing when you eat buzzer minute hi not every minute I put bathroom in a fight meat off a live animal you're only over if you eat it with pure meat and no sinews and bones now a non kosher animal whether it's alive or dead you have either if you eat a Casillas of it or if you eat a Bria in other words if you take a you eat an entire bird a small tiny bird that's less than in his eyes even though swastika size in Soho Brio york i've by the way Ranchi points out that a Bria is like one of the Duran says is three things that you need in order for Bria one of them and Russia points out is that it has to be created like that as a breeder for instance if you to eat an entire breeding availa you're not high if it's less than a gazaís why because an available created as Abril the novela happened after it died mashenka never been a high happened when it was born we'll skip ahead here a little bit because of the siren of Shabbos so if you eat a bird that doesn't have a concise it doesn't have a concise at all so according to Rebbe or Potter why so Rebbe says a very interesting this far he says since the a varam the limbs are not meant to be separated while it's alive so if he ate all the limbs each limb by itself is nothing because it's not meant to be separated once alive it's meant thinks everyone's dead so therefore we eat the whole bird you Potter says rava according to that if somebody were to think in his mind that he wants to separate it then for him would be austere even though he didn't separate it would be awesome so in other words for him it's awesome for the rest of old world motor says abide that doesn't make sense how could something be Oscar for you and mother for everybody else then Commissioner Lawson says that how he says an unready if one aver is also so then certainly the eighth entire bird should be austere and that Rob also says this this attachment of machetes alcohol is eyeful in other words if a person had in mind to eat this animal instead so in other words he designated that he's not gonna separate it when it's alive because rib symbol aza says that a varam are meant to be separated when he's alive but what if in his mind he said I'm only gonna separate after it dies and then he ate it when it was alive so for him it would be the opposite will be pottery because in his mind he made it Potter and for everybody else it's motor officer says I buy it that also doesn't make sense how's it possible that for everybody it's also for you its motor have a wonderful Shabbos I'll see you master Chavez