8 Min Daf - Bechoros Daf 60 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] you the higher is def sama we learned yesterday robber says in his 4th halacha that if somebody has 15 animals he's now out of pick and choose which animals he wants to leave the pen let's say it has ten week animals he's now allowed to put those ten in the pen and see what happens is to put all fifteen what happens to the five leftover animals they still have to go through the mincer process with other animals Rafa asked the question in front of the entire assembly that came to hear him before yontiff and he had a bobcat she had no answer he says but it says in the bright sir that if you have 19 animals and you leave them out let them go through the pen whatever is left over does not have to be taken my surrogate their parted from I sir what do you do stands up raccoon about her and says I have a Terrence I think it's talking about a pen that has two exits nine left the right and nine left the left and there's one in the middle and that one in the middle could combine to the right and can combine to the left and therefore they're all Potter's we learned the other day even Suffolk minion her oh they're all Potter says they're not great hook unbelievable what ass was the mother of her hooniverse her head that her son was able to answer such an unbeliever come and not only that he did it in a way that didn't contradict Robins other analogs because reporter so he could have answered it's talking about a person that counted until nine then he stopped and instead of counting ten he started all over again one two three four five so the first nine are putler because minion are ready and then he's only five one on the next ten that can't be because raava hauled that the tenth one becomes college by itself and therefore even though he started one two three four five on the second round the first one would be number ten he also couldn't say this talking about peers going out every two the guy said one so if five peers went out that's actually tending to behive imagine but he only called him five and when he got to number ten which is actually twenty and then he gave one my sir and therefore the all Potter because maybe it goes by the way he counts not by the animals that leave the pen no raava holes that it goes by the animals I leave the pen says the mission if let's say number six and seven went out together and the person called him number six what happens is he's off by one number so when he gets to nine and ten says the mission of their macoco they're ruined it's different than if he just counted one through ten and he made a mistake where we said the number ten is my sir number nine also has do sure to it because over there everybody sees what's going on they see his mistake it's obvious but in our case since they both went out together it's not obvious what the mistake is and therefore they were macoco says the mission of if a person called all three a mistake number 90 call 10 and number 10 he called 9 and number you love any call 10 so number nine is cottage it's your net on the moon you have to wait until has a moment you eat it number 10 is actually my sir because it happens by itself and number 11 is ash lemon but number 8 and number 12 never become cottage because the only numbers you can mess up on are the numbers that are closest to 10 number 9 and number 11 but anything further away then the closest ones are not a problem according to our mayor number 11 becomes lemon so if somebody said I want an additional animal to be instead of that schleimann that's called Maura and it works scissor Buda but number 11 is Tora it's instead of number 10 Tamura cannot make another tomorrow says Romare no number 11 it can't be tomorrow because my sir and bahar cannot be tomorrow it was just a plain slummin and therefore it could create another tour if a person called number 9 10 so you messed up at number 9 but then he went back on track and he called 10 10 so 10 was perfect and then he messed up again at number 11 number 11 does not become cottage there's no problem number 11 why in order for number 11 to be a problem you have to mess up also number 10 you have to be a take care number 10 if you're not article number 10 10 remain 10 then there's no problem number 11 mike is he really did ribbon and say that we go we base everything on the person counting and if a person lies he counts every 10 he considers it one and when he gets to a hundred he just takes out 10 my sirs or do we base it on the animals leaving the pen Sony so every 10 they go out that tenth one becomes my sir automatically even though he's holding only at number one my ficus now if a person everybody's made that even the man that says that we go by animals leaving but if a person made a mistake he got confused and he said 6 7 and he messed up 9 and 10 let's say then everybody agrees that it's macoco because we don't go by his we go by his counting and not by animals neck case now everybody agrees that if a person counted backwards in Reverse 10 9 8 7 6 and when he got to one that's actually 10 it is my sir even according to the Mandela that says that we go by his counting over he counted and was only 1 the answer is because in Paris Persians they call number 110 rebel Osterberg shouldn't says a tremendous coach he says it's impossible to have to mess ups in one my sir count you could either mess up number 9 or you can mess up number 11 but you can't you can't mess up number 9 and 11 why because he holds it could be who though that number 11 is tomorrow so that every toes and my sir is considered Tamura and he also holds like his own father we assume by a high that you cannot create to tomorrow's from one animal so since these are Tamura from number 10 so either number nine can be tore for number 10 or number 11 give me number it's more from number 10 but you can't have two tours from one animal if two animals came out together and number nine and instead of counting 9 10 he said 9 to both of them now 9 is not a douche 'deacon number so what we have here is number 10 became college by itself as Robert says but number nine is Hulan oh they got mixed up if a them come along and say hey don't plow the field with one of these animals the guy doesn't get Malkin's because the aidan weren't able to say specifically which one is college which one is it however in the same case where both animals came out together and number 9 and instead of calling them number 9 he called him both number 10 10 has Ducie to his number so they both have to do shucks and therefore if a 'then come and say don't plow a field with these animals he's hive malkos because we're Monica one of them is published the same exact case would be if the number 10 came out together with number 11 and instead of calling them 10 and 11 he calls both of them 10 here's a finish both of them imma do show yet if he says he calls them both 11 only one of them has dilution another one is 11 and the same thing would happen if they didn't come they wouldn't get Malcom's what's the finisher the finishes that we just said that in order for number 11 to become Kaddish you need to be a cure number 10 you have to make a mistake with number 10 you have to call number 10 9 but over here he called number 10 10 yet number 11 is still college why is that because they both came out simultaneously however Revati is mcculloch and he says no it says the mission is a clown and it comes to exclude this case that even if they come out together since there's no I hear it number 10 you didn't rule number 10 so you can't ruin number 11 now the surprise that says that both of them are Kaddish he's gonna say that it's talking about that before they bought him out together one of them stuck out his head and he called it 11 and he pulled his head back in and then both came out together and that's why they're both college question if somebody calls the 11th the 10th one 11 is that considered natira well if the person doesn't have 20 animals according to everybody that's considered nakkeera but if he has 20 animals according to revi it's not enough hero why because sometimes people say if they have my sir they say a had my sir it's one my sir so he said AHA - sir he meant this is one my sir versus - misers coz 20 animals is two misers he's only on one my sir have a wonderful day