8 Min Daf - Bechoros Daf 51 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] you the hora is deaf noon Alif we learnt in the Mishnah that the five shuttle opinion have been the 30 shekel that you give if your acts killed a slave the 50 shekel of aliasing a fad and 100 shuttle of mighty shamera it's all shuttle ahoy - it has to be monetary siree denomination now the question is why does a mission to mention twice that has to be the who Lamba shuttle ahoy - says the Gemara it comes to answer that - MIT camera it doesn't say in the tires specifically chateau so I would think that you could use zouzhen the NorAm comes the mission earth to say that moyzisch Emre annoyingness are similar to the other three things in the mission and they also require monetary shuttle a cottage then the Denisha says that in the entire tire you could use the value of money instead of money itself you don't necessarily have to bring money besides the masses have shackled the klystron brings an other to bring pure bunnies for the miss bail why is it because we're concerned that perhaps if you bring something that's the value of a master cycle you might being a little less and you'll be stealing from the base I'm ENGLISH the Gemara breeds is a lot of two things that the toy was Mac been on a certain type of money that's Mysore shainiel no we said yes so you might say Shana can bring copper coins but they have to be minted copper coins they can't just be any coin and that's because the Torah says the heart AHA kesef the money must be with a surah with a minted coin hey Ryan hey Roy you're in where we say every morning has no share but Madera bond on this is my legacy Ameen basil--oh when you bring a carbon like today Arab newest clients are all be busy bringing carbon oh you see bingo oil are you bringing slummin there is a minimum what you need to spend on that carbon with a rabona either to Ma or one ma and that money must be minted says the mission is as explained by the Gemara the positive my opinion abend says move do you've you could redeem the part in any denomination in value of money and it says tip de anyway you want to be parted and then the tire says kesef that's what we call a cloud Pratt a cloud or a reboot kneeled and a reboot so our Tana holds is a cleric plow and it comes to school three things caca which is not metal and you can't move it and slaves are always compared to Carta and it also comes to exclude Starace star itself says I owe Pliny if somebody owes me money I can't use that star and give it to a client why because the star itself itself has no value and the same applies to heck dish that comes to heck dish I know I want to redeem an animal I can't redeem the animal and give heck dish instead of money given heck there's a slave or give money give heck - real estate or a star according to ready there's only one thing you can't use to redeem your son as opinion have been and that is a star why is it because rebel earns a reboil meal and a reboot from the same words will do your tip tank SF and therefore you only is my might one thing why did Remi pick star and not have vowed to make her quiet that's because Rashi explains star has the least value out of the three since of do yo and TIF de are really close together and only afterwards it says SF usually the kesav is inserted between the two cloud so that's why rebel earns over here we boom you reboot but typically in chaste rebel earns cloud without the cloud like me see bummer it's a yeah how do you make the hole in the slaves ear says rebbe you use only metal because I have a cloud proud to plow and has to be metal you can't use a toothpick or a splinter or any tool made out of wood not like your BAC everybody who da who learns Arriba mutant read boy and he says you could use everything all tools anything you grabbing your hand don't think you can't use he says is poison that would make a hole in the skin according to fund any time you have to Chloe's together like do you haven't if de you take the case f the green and you inserted between the two Reds you pretend it's there and you make a flower brother clock or Reba Mia to me says the mission of somebody wrote to the coil it says I owe you five Sela and you want to use that as opinion I've been it doesn't work if he went ahead and he gave him the money says the Mishnah he has to give him another five shekel five seller although Midori Raisa it works but home were concerned that people might think that the star works so therefore they said any money that's connected to this star doesn't work and he must pay the client another five Sela the Claire wants he'd go and give back the five Sela and that's okay and that's tile aha even though there are those who say that he's good so with the first five seller brother a lot of if somebody took the pinion I bet money the five seller went over to a group of clay Han and put it in the middle and he ran away he's your take another a law says that if he gave the coin one seller and then and gave it to him in installments a week later gave him another seller it's a good pinion I've been the coin is permitted to give back as we said the pinion have been and retire fund was a clay needs to give people back not always as tight as if they were poor but used to give back pinion Abed and Homs ed that even this hollow her he was my colleague Maris is a story Hanina would give back the pinion Abed one day somebody gave him pinion I been and that person started pacing back and forth hinting Tim huh I would like my opinion time and money back Surya bhai Nina you weren't you'd say what you did was bad you must redo the whole thing because you had no intent in giving it to me and therefore you have to do period I've been all over again and Rashi explains even if freakin Enid didn't give it back to him it still wouldn't be a good pitting I bet if somebody set aside pinion I've been money and it got lost or stolen he has to he has to guarantee that money he has to redo it he has to repay although bipedal Kumar if he set aside the money it does work why is it because the center by Erina cutting gierlach it's only opinion when I earn a carry receives the money in his hand and then the tire says will fold a tip though then it becomes a good figure and the same along we have by keratin and by oil a CEO that a person has to he's responsible for the money that gets lost is to replace it and says the Gemara we learned from that also the case where H of a firstborn male was born and he lived thirty days where his father had a heel to give the current opinion event and then he died one would think that the father doesn't have to who exactly is he redeeming the kid that he's trying to redeem his dead an answer is that the father had a field that kid was alive at 8:30 he had to pay then and that he remains and that we learned from Erath in an oilless REO have a wonderful shambles wonderful young turtle soup assertion on mots yontiff