8 Min Daf - Bechoros Daf 32 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] you the higher is def lament Bay's we learned the other day the concept of have law that one buys the hide or the horns of an animal of my sir and although you can't sell the meat but since you can sell the warrant you include the meat in the price of the horns the amar says can you do the same trick with the bones of an animal could I sell the person bones for a very high price and include with it the meat of the my sorbet sitting amar well depends if we're talking about the bones of a very small animal that have absolutely no use so you cannot do have love because nobody buys bones at all and certainly not for a very high price but if we're talking about bones of a larger animal that you could use it for the handle of a hammer or an axe then you could do have law the other Russian Ingemar is well depends on the place certain places let's say in Africa they use bones for handles so in those places you could use have law you can do have law you could sell the meat in the price of the bone but in places that they they don't they don't use the bones as anything then you cannot do have law the emerg says how do we know the concept they cannot sell my survey no there's three ways to learn it to understand the first schita we have to understand that there's three categories here is the category of Bihar and the Turner says Louis if de which means don't redeem and the category of my sir thirst is illegal don't redeem also that means the same thing but a different word and by Herman says the same exact word as my search says low you go what does Hara mean higher means that if somebody wants to give something to a coin or that me some English in our cases the client he says this object should be fair so until he gives it to the client it remains in his possession it is Kadosh once he gives it to the client the client can do with it as he pleases it's like hula each one of these categories has a home row has astringency has something special about it but bahar is born punished my sir as the animals are going out of the pen and he says the 10th on should be Kaddish if he makes a mistake and he says the ninth one should be cottage and then he starts counting over from there so the 11th one becomes cottage nine 10 and 11 are all college Miriam has another stringency all the animals in the pen can be cottage and also Rashi explains you can make Isla a harem you can say I want that toilet you'd have to give the money the value of what that really means to you so now the mother says according to rob how do I know that a Meister Bahama cannot be sold because I learned what you got let you go from Hiram just like my parents is Lego and embed miser says let go so having zero Java and my theorem you cannot sell it so to buy my sir you can't sell it says the Gemara we have a concept called zero Java move know the words are extra once the words are extra it's as if it says it specifically the Taira and that gives us the ability not to be able to refute it I can't come up with one of these rumors that we just mentioned because in BIOS if I want to learn my sir from Hiram I would say well Hyrum I could it applies to everything but because like all by my sir is completely extra so I can't use that as a pure cut of x0 Java why is it completely extra my my sir because the more it says I've learned the Javert of Alberto from before to teaches the Council of gula that I can't redeem and the thirst is everything it's completely the answer to teach us the zero shovel now the words link go by theorem are not extra because I cannot learn Hyrum not from Bihar and not from mine sir because as you see in the chart and as we mentioned Bihar has a special home row that is college mere FM and my sir has a special home row that the one before the one after our college says the Gemara maybe I should learn perhaps x0 Shaba lease if de from Lego another words Bihar from Clara why am i learning mice from Clara nice if that means the same thing as where you go and we had the concept of shovel a noble coin that if the word means the same shove and bow even though there's smell completely different but they mean the same I could learn Xavier Chaves isn't very good you can learn exists over but in our case since we have two words that are identical like golly go it makes a lot more sense to learn my sir from theorem and not the heart from player now what about we shall learn zero Java have Varro from Bihar to my sir and say that before you cannot sell says the mark over there is a special word by theorem says who who college inaudible heart rava says a whole new shot Rob says it says by theorem it says ye Maher can't sell and it's completely extra because of course you can't sell a harem if it's in the possession of the person that made the theorem we said it has a la ha kodesh he can't sell it and if it already got to the client and then it's like cooling of course he can sell it so why is it Thursday Larry mother they may not even we can know you Ian lien ather if it doesn't have any meaning by us and does it doesn't accomplish anything else so let's learn something else from it let's learn my sir he cannot tell my sir Revathi has a third shot the leg I'll buy my sir actually means don't sell it how do I know because it cannot mean redeeming because the Taira says and it's actually this week's parish of the second-last pasa in ecology grow it says in the parcel valhalla who murasa here clay - legal Tamura saying that this animal should be instead of another carbon has the same ilaha as selling as redeeming but it cannot mean redeeming because when did this happen if it happened if the redeeming just like Tamura is when the animals alive so gula is also when it's alive and you cannot it can't mean google or when it's dead because when it's dead you have to have her mother ira the animal has to stand up and even if the animal doesn't need a mother according to one man dama nevertheless it can't mean that he's relieving it because when the animal is alive and it has a lot of do sure we could redeem it that's that's the best chance to get it redeemed and the Terr says you can redeem it so certainly when it's dead and it doesn't have a lot to do sure the redemption wouldn't be foul on it so in Mela it means let girl means it don't sell the question is though if Lego means don't sell why didn't I just say straight out don't sell the answer is because if the turn said don't sell then I wouldn't know that you cannot redeem I think redeeming is good because the money goes to medical bikes says the Mishnah new soviet Bashar may hold that when you have a bahar that with a mum only Kohanim could eat from it and not Easter alien because it says in the puzzle cajas a show it should be like the breast and the thigh they still say you're even Azhar is allowed to eat from because it says the positive battery after vehicle a know that a Cayenne the Gemara says the couple have a client whose tummy cannot eat cotton column yet Elise wrote can't eat cotton column so certainly Israel should be able to eat of a horrible mob have a wonderful day