8 Min Daf - Bechoros Daf 28 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] you the hire a staff of Hess in describing how long one has until must chef is animal it's unclear from the mission of whether the Mishnah means you have 12 months plus 30 days or you only have 12 months and the 30 days only in a situation where it has a mom well it's gonna sag Amara it goes as follows in the time of the base amigos when you're able to bring the Bihar is a carbon then you have if it's a complete animal without any moments a time then you have 12 months this man is there when there's always humming - you have two to three years until it develops a move once it develops a mum you have up until the year and if it developed a mum after the year you have 30 days so basically what's going on here is that you have the longer of the two in other words if you have more than 30 days you have up until the 12 12 months but if let's say the mum happened 15 days before the end of the year so now you have at least 30 days so total of 30 days you get another 15 days into the next year that's what the Bryce's says and it seems like Reb Lazar in the first Lawson says exactly the same thing you have 30 days from the time of the moment so if the mom happens all the way than the year you can go into the second year up to 30 days on the other hand rebel Azhar says there's a lotion or blazer that he learns a new Chad in the words Shana Bashan yes sir yesterday we had to shot him he has a new shot he says it means literally you have two years but not two years two times 365 what he means is one year plus 30 days because 30 days is counted as a year when it comes to our law etc just a problem with this rebel ah sir is that the Bryce's size for him was a brace that we just had it says that you only get up to 30 days from the time of the moment you don't get a year plus 30 days in all situations like your boss wants to say says the Mishnah you must show your mum on the part to a professional if you didn't show it to a professional and you shelter the animal and then you try to show it to a professional after that it will die say here is this a moment or not so my ficus according to our mayor you can't do anything with this animal you must bury it because we give you a canal we penalize you because there's a cataracts change at the time of death so it's impossible to know whether this animal had a real mom or not because it must it could be that it changed when the animal shifted because of that we instituted exira on all Moomin if you don't show it to Mum her before the schita you lose out even though it's a real bomb after the schita review this is no only cataracts you can't do any with anything with after the shaquita but all other moment there's no zero and in fact from the mission of the russian the mission is matched with that is the chat because it says the romaine says hi a finnish had shall oi RP maja austere the reason why it's us is because you didn't listen to what the harm said they have to show Tomoko so it's a keen ass if they are there are witnesses that say we saw that it had a cataract before the shaquita and that's what it looked like we don't say that every time the animal dies his eyes change and even if he had a cataract before his eyes are gonna look different now in the a demur lying because sometimes the eyes don't change as it says specifically softly maybe a Shia the minutiae Baba Rekha Badu can change Nana that sometimes let me show you sometimes they change but sometimes they don't change says the Mishnah if a non professional cause somebody to shut his animal by telling him hey your animal has a mom and he was wrong he's not a professional what you do is you have to bury this animal now what I don't want are we talking about so again a contour merits all animals all mum but a quarter view there's some woman you could tell after the death of the animal so check it out now the only moment you can't check it after the animal shafted is a cataract and this Nam mom cut this non professional must pay for his mistake how much does he pay for a smaller animal he pays 25% of the value of the animal and a larger animal 50% what's the logic says ref Papa because a larger animal the the loss is much greater which needs understanding because yes it's greater but just let's be consistent fifty percent per animal so if it's a smaller animal giving 50% if it's a larger than fifty percent therefore rockabye Rica comes with a shot and he says it's because of its zero according to one China Rashi since you're not supposed to deal with small animals the narrative role and you to them so you get punished we're only gonna give you to recoup 25% of your loss another shot is because the claim when he gets the animal it would cost him a lot of time and an effort to bring up the small animal and he gains that he doesn't have to do that so that therefore the owner only gets 25% says the Mishnah if a once we're talking about people making mistakes in the movement says the mission what happens to regular dying who makes a mistake table at the very Mishnah he made a mistake that's clear innallaha clear in the Mishnah that's a mistake so in that case since it's a first remission now you could take it back and he doesn't have to pay for his mistake but if it's a logical mistake where there's my ficus and it's unclear how we pass can he pass can wrongly then he has to pay for mistake he can't take it back and has to pay however if he's a professional he's a monkey from the best then that he doesn't have to pay if he's not a mom huh and he just cause somebody lost because he passing the wrong tack that's called a dare me and your Potter we're going to your mayor kite but if he did it with physically with his hands and his hive for instance if he took the money from one person and gave it to another person and that person doesn't deserve it that's be a diamond his kind if he took the mass going away from the mouth and gave it back to the live--i when he was wrong that's V died if he took pay rugs that were taller and he said their tummy and he said let me show you how tell me I believe they already took his shares and he touched the Paris and they're in fact art he has to pay for those fruit and if he took thar food and he said it they're tar and let me show you how far they are and he threw them in a pile that turned out to be Tommy and therefore he made his fruit our Tommy has to pay for everything says dimensional an animal without a womb is not considered a tray for who lived many years in fact they used to buy the best type of cows and pigs from Alexandria from its rhyme and the midstream didn't want other people to benefit from their cows and reproduce they removed the womb and they lived for many years see see that that doesn't create a tray phone says repair phone I once made a mistake and I told somebody that an animal without of is a trade fund it took the animal when they buried it they did nothing with it and he said haha hi Marco terrifying terrifying meaning himself just lost his donkey because now he has the sells donkey in order to pay for his mistake since Rubik even know you don't have to pay for your mistake number one your toy a bit very mission and semaphore efficient coolin that an animal missing its womb is not a trayful and we said that if you talk with our Mishnah you take it back second of all since you are a mom ha as we said a mama who makes mistake even that information even she coladas in logic also doesn't have to pay have a wonderful day