8 Min Daf - Bechoros Daf 19 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] you Bahai raised a few tests says the Mishnah ribbit - had a Suffolk he wasn't sure if the translation to the word Bihar means firstborn it has to be literally the firstborn or it means the firstborn to the womb naturally meaning if an animal gave birth through cesarean and afterwards her second birth was natural perhaps the one that was born through cesarean is considered of a heart because that's included in the word Bihar or maybe even the second one is Abba Clark because he's the first one to be born naturally therefore both of them are Suffolk Belarus they have two grades until they befall a mum and then the only donor gets to eat them Rebecca says no it's not a Suffolk at all I know that Bihar means both of these things together it has to be the firstborn and firstborn naturally so if there was a cesarean then that one is not a Bihar and therefore the one after him is also not a Bihar this tube tsuki when it comes to Bihar and they're in two different commercial the first plastic is conditionally called Bihar the famous puzzle all behavior should be sanctified the second postulate is called a Bihari srivalli says the Gemara that we're very familiar with the concept of cloud prat this is a generalization and then a specification where the tired narrows down and limits the generalization most of us are a lot of us say everyday in the siliceous remedial shall turn addresses man the Bryson review small one of the Meadows is not very common and that is prat Schatz Oracle cloud and Clausura clip rat meaning that sometimes the turret generalizes and rather than limiting that generalization the tiger explains the generalization and sometimes the Turner says something limiting and then the generalization is an explanation to that limitation and here are the examples the typical one is cloudy prat so the titer says by us call a Bihar that should include all firstborns even females where does the same thing about male military says are Zahar limits the Bihar - only males so that's a Clow a generalization then a specification limitation the tire says Clow at circle Pratt is when the Torah says bahar bahar is the generalization firstborn can be in all different ways the attorney says hetero him only through the womb a natural birth so either the Torah according to one chanting Mars coming to exclude when a male was born after a female so I would think oh he's a Behar he's the first male born to this mother you're right there's a female but he still considered a bar says the Tyra pet the wrath him no he has to be the first male which came out naturally meaning he can't come after a female or it's coming just to say that he has to be born naturally pet the rectum and not through cesarean so if he's the firstborn forget about a female just the a male born through cesarean the tour is coming to say that it's not a Behar you'd have to do pinyin a bad or you'd have to give it as a Behar now you have also Pratt a limitation at sorrowful cloud that the cloud comes to explain it that is when the Paris says two things saw her that's very limited Zohar like we said before that subtract and Petr effin limited the tire comes with a generalization to explain that big heart meaning it has to be first for everything it's not just saw her it has to be the first saw her completely meaning that he shouldn't be born it can't be a male I was born after a cesarean and with that we finish Parekh Halle caliber perusal and now we start parrot Holly calf Bahama if somebody buys an animal from a gun and he's unsure whether this animal gives birth or not and whether the firstborn to him is a true firstborn which you'd be five in a bahai or not and he can't trust the guy whether then animal gave birth enough the guy might not be honest says the mission of that country was small there's a certain period of time for each animal where the animal cannot give birth more than one animal so when it comes to goat if there's a birth within the first year you know when it was born and it gave birth and it's within one years old it has to be that that birth was its first birth because it can't give birth more than once in its first year a sheep it has to be within two years because she cannot give birth more than once in the first two years when it comes to a cow it's three years when it comes to donkey according to our admissions three years the comer brings a sheet over we really review though that it's four years but anything after that period of time is a Suffolk because you don't know perhaps the animal gave birth prior to that why is it only something we should say most animals give birth within let's take a goat for example most goats give birth within the first year of their life so the second one now you had an animal it's not even a Suffolk says the Gemara because we go according to read mayor Ramaiya holds hydration limit all of a Shazz he holds them you have to be concerned for the minority and his minority of goats that don't give birth in the first game so perhaps this birth after his first birthday is indeed its first birth in general and therefore it's a part you have to give it to carry maybe and therefore it's a suffering Bihar I think Martin attempts to say that perhaps and the Guarani locks it up perhaps even according to humming they would admit normal normally they say ain't finishing the meal over here they would because maybe they say when do you say you go by the road when the rape is in front of us by T Shahana if this nine store is selling for sure you found a piece of meat outside on the sidewalk will not eat it because you go by the road but the nine stores are in front of you if you have a bed then the right of the best then is in front of you but by us you go my most animals of the world that they give birth within their first year then if it's a sheep two years kal three years but they're not in front of us so perhaps in that case they admit to remain since we might not because you see by --boom they also use a road that's not in front of us what's the case if a brother dies without children his wife falls to e boom to her brother-in-law what if her brother-in-law is a cotton or she's of Tana we are maybe we not maybe we have to be concerned that the cotton might be a Sarris might be sterile and if we let him get married now before we can really find out when he's a goggle perhaps he's being over an issue such because the only time you can marry a llama and we evil is locking shame locket to be in kinda Mitzvah to have a child in his memory in his namesake but if he can't have children then it's a physician now humm come along and say that reiieve children are not some reason therefore they can get married so you see that even in a situation when the rape is not in front of us ah-hum hold we go by the road and when a flesh for the me that have a wonderful day