8 Min Daf - Bechoros Daf 18 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] you the Huayra is da field has a glare Ruffa a murder victim was found next to a city the closest city has to bring a calf he kept decapitated in not Lisa if the murder victim was found exactly between two cities be measured and it came out exact measurements between two cities 3-way my collages either you don't bring any egg my roof o or you bring one egg Meru file or you bring it to tonic on it says you don't bring any because it says Craver it can only be close to one city and not the two and therefore since it's called the treetop again maybe lies it says karate means also crave ice so you bring two and Cohanim say you bring one and you make a condition both cities participate in buying this igloo and they say if the murder victim came from our city we're the ones that brought it and if the murder Victor came from the other city they're the ones that brought but you see from here the cajon hold that EF Charlotte Sampson that humans can't possibly measure precisely the same spot it's impossible that this murder victim actually happened the murder happened between the two cities exactly and that's why they only bring one if to bahar two males were born from one animal simultaneously the mission says we keep a hold miss shaman by name says the Gemara of very interesting Russian Reba Thiet bar-abba told Reba - and I believe that the halacha means the shaman you do yeah like you you split divide between the client and the owner says we be - on and the hot caffeine eyassa de varville targum no miss Ava while you were busy indulging yourself eating dates in Bothell we already figured out the Mishnah from the safer in other words the safer says there we keep a hold how might seem cavalry Oliver aiya so therefore the ratio also neshama means let the claim bring Araya because these trolls the one that's holding onto this animals be strong it's the larger animal the coin gets the worst Ram the worst animal but the owner who has the better animal he's - Matt Matt lacunae he has to give according to her marry us to give Israel iron Makeba to the coil why because the client comes with a monoshock which needs dadam he comes from both angles he tells these throw what you have your hand either a Bihar and it belongs completely to me or if you say it's not about cars born second then it's a regular coolin animal and you have to give me mad at schooner so therefore he has to get mad as Kuna because the the client at the end of the day gets a full animal at mana School where BAC says no ruins of the Bigfoot UAC says that we pretend as if the kind owned the animal and gave it to the straw they made a deal the stroll gives the client the smaller animal and the claim who owned this larger animal for a moment gives it to the straw and therefore since he owned it momentarily a kyon who sells an animal too strong because it has a mom dot you don't have to give madness scooter for that why did ha ha women act as Aaron pretended he owned it because her harm or concern that if the Austral gave madness Kuna people would consider that animals complete Hulan and they might come to work it and shear its wool and it's possible that animals of hearts we gotta be concerned however in a case where there's only a Suffolk Bihar we don't enact that and you are highly madness Kuna what's the subject Bihar such as if an animal gave birth to twins a male and a female and it's passed whether the female came out first and therefore the Bihar at all I would think there there be I see hold that we have to be concerned that people might confuse this animal as a non Bihar and use it for work or share it nevertheless we're not concerned and he's kind of metal ease when a case of Suffolk my sir what is something my sir if you have ten animals you let them add at the pen the tenth one becomes my sir what do you do the my sir you use it for yourself as a slumming it goes to the owner it's not a fight so what happens if you took a my sir and the animal jump jump back into the pen and we don't know which animal was the my sir each animal could be a Suffolk my sir now so you can't eat them so what do you do you wait until they all get a moment and then you eat them in that case you don't have to give madness schooners because the client has no clay because he doesn't have to claims he only comes from one angle the angle that it's my sir is not even his it's completely these roles if an animal gave birth to two males and one of them died ripped arvind says yeah like you split between the client of these stroke obviously ripped - retracted original spur that we had the other day their apparent held that the stronger twin always wins the race it comes out first over here you see that he doesn't hold that anymore because otherwise you wouldn't say if I can't say let's check who died if the stronger one died then the kind doesn't get anything three cases if two people entrust one animal each to a third party shepherd and one of the animals died and we don't know whose animal died the Shepherd simply takes the remaining animal and puts it between the two and says do whatever you are with it you like so in our case also when two males were born and one died and they were entrusted by a shepherd the Shepherd takes remaining animal puts it between the client in the east role and says fight it out yes like if one person entrusted is one animal with the Shepherd and the Shepherd had one animal and one animal died now we don't know whose animal died the Shepherd always wins his he has the upper hand because I might have area Oliver right he's holding on to the animals so the other person has to bring arrive in our case two if these straws holding on to the Behar the remaining heart let the claim bring a riot however the third case is different and here's the my phobias if the animal is in these roles property but the client is the shepherd and thus Rawls says ribbit - would give the ability to the client to make it King in and use his property to be make a king and in the heart why because a person wants to enable other people to use his property for mitzvahs KIFI says no that's only good when it's a mitzvah but when it causes harm like in our case these trolls not gonna let the client uses property to cause the Estrela harm and therefore he never made a king in and how much single hobby really Oliver Rio says the Mishnah if a person has two animals that never gave birth before and they both gave birth to males then obviously they're both before him and both go to the client if one is a man one is a female the color only gets one if they gave birth to twins and you have a total of two males and one female it's possible that one of the animals gave birth to a female first so the coin only gets one which one is he get retiring at the end of the day says you do yellow cool maybe Kiba says how much milk available Rio the coin gets the lesser of the two and the bigger one you have to let it graze and you have to give him a takuna but what's the difference in this case and the case that we had before with the one animal giving birth to two animals simultaneously siegmeyer because when you see a very large animal it's obvious you could say that rib ribbity would admit that it's obvious that he was born from the animal and never the animal I gave birth to one because a single animal is larger than twins nevertheless wicketkeeper says no how many's a very elaborate if you have two animals one never gave birth before so her firstborn the her birth is gonna be a firstborn another animal the second animal gave birth before and now you have two males in front of us what is the bihar what does that have a hook which one with the before which animal does the client get ripped arvind says that the claim gets a nicer one room this is always behavioural Araya and you have to give - who know everybody says you don't think about the school of like he said before that since the coin comes then since the coin owned it momentarily so dad gave up tour to the Bolero and the fishes over here that again the same kind of sparta we had before since this animal never gave birth before she probably gave birth to the larger animal and i would think there would be Kiva admits that it's not on my Samaria right commercial and that he says no I might have very elaborate and finally the last Hollow if two animals give birth one to a sucker and in a cable they each gave birth so the coin doesn't have anything because it's possible that they both gave birth to their cave at first and the claim doesn't get anything have a wonderful day