8 Min Daf - Bechoros Daf 17 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] you but where is that you design the game art brings an interesting Bryce which needs explanation after three attempts that the Gemara pushes off the Gemara says two possible explanations the rice is the remai says that if a cheap gave birth to something that looks like a goat a Midna or go gave birth some sheep - I'm sick Potter kyvan what says ignore it can't be that he means hive on abhor because everybody holds that if the offspring doesn't look like the mother you powder from heart it can't mean that if I even reached a guess that you have to give some of the first shearing 's of the world to a claim because everybody agrees that if it's not wool and in our case the goat which the mother is a sheep doesn't have wool it has goat here and that's not something that warms animal and it can't be says the Gemara that the mother the father is a goat and therefore the offspring is a goat and the Shiloh is if questions there have in other words the old my flake is by I see visible oh you know I just have the mother and her offspring the same day my like it's whether you could shock the father nor me on the same day so that's the Mayan mark that's the case the wording is off it should have the same wording as the my leg is over there but therefore the camara comes up with explanation that we're talking about one or two cases either that you have a sheep of a car whose mothers a sheep but the grandmother is a goat so remember says all we care about is the immediate mother was a sheep and it's not considered enigma and therefore if I Behar harm say no you have to look this is genes of this sheep I really go James it just happens to be that his mother looks like a sheep and therefore you go by the grandmother and the grandmother there's a goat and therefore your father would click or alternatively we could say the Shila is you have a sheep whose mother is a goat whose grandmother is a sheep and remain whole that you go by the grandmother house realists say you study it goes the Sheep goes back to its original what it's supposed to be supposed to be a sheep and therefore if a vampire in accordance of humming we go to the immediate one right above his mother is a cop looks like a go and therefore positive employer now if you say that how easy let's say you say according to a mayor in other words you have a sheep or a goat let's say you have a goat whose mother is a sheep whose grandmother is a goat the mayor says he hired because inquiry go by the grandmother it goes bad however says her mayor when it comes to a goat that you have to bring for a carbon a cellulitis or yontiff that is not considered a vote unless it has perfect jeans it was always a goat every single generation all the way to say she's maybe racist so goat whose mother's a sheep whose grandmothers vote is no good for the mis amigos there's another postdoc we learned that from the plastic ask me me you could and it's another plastic oh yes I think one has its - who's it for that now this sheep yeah a cheap whose mother is a goat whose grandmother's a sheep quarter mayor you find in bolero it's a complete scheme where health possible era what about its wool says the Gemara is wool for three Allah has is not considered wool Iloka number one two chapters even though it's a sheep it looks like his peep and it has a wool like a sheep but since its mother is it goat its wool is not kinda shot as if you combine wool and linen together another Allah is then again too famous on census it's not considered wool for instances and it's not considered wool Fritz the wrath of a bigot of wool and rub ah she adds Allah he says based on this if you take the vines of grape and you put them on a fig tree where the figs infuse a Roma of fig so it's now you have great that our fig grapes in terms of their smell that kind of wine made out of those grapes is Oscar for the man you can't begin as the stuffing and says they might but it's obvious that if you take pitched on and you you take flags and you put it in a thorn-bush the thornbush the the the smell of the thorns doesn't create a different type of flex it's the same flags and therefore doesn't create an issue says the Mishnah this is the mission that we discussed previously regarding epsilon Thompson can two occurrences two events happen at the same exact moment the millionth of a second so here I have two males first Born's come out simultaneously is it possible physically to happen according to basically actually Thompson it's possible for that but not only that the tire allows for two behind to happen in same time because the Tharsis has heart according to how common it's not possible to happen it's so you have a Suffolk which one is what if you have a situation where these two males are born so Accord to retire fine in the beginning the Mizpah and it's interesting because the next big mission is they had the same situation where instead something then it retract the beginning retired and said the stronger one who usually wins or always wins when he comes out the bigger stronger ones are therefore the bigger stronger one goes to the claim and the weaker one goes things grow and according to River kevo you do you miss Shabnam II think the difference in the fat between the two and basically the claim gets the weaker one because how much new hub a row over later on the paraffin and emission are retracted it and he said that if one of them dies one of the two males die you do a howl Luka you don't say oh the stronger one do you please put it down the middle and according to Rabbi Akiva Mahavira Oliver right nothing more ask if you hold after what's happening you could it's possible that something of an occurrence happened to get it simultaneously at the same exact moment so then humans get fish or do it if they intend to do something sometimes they could do it but if you hold here is valid Sampson before the hominid say ears on Sampson that's mission I mean it's not possible that it still happened by itself the two animals were born the same exact millionth of a second but if humans wanted that to happen is it possible now with more beings arrived from the photo sticker of the red line around the base I make those around them is bear some of the bloods are sprinkled below the red line and some above how's it possible to know if it's above or below the red line perhaps since it was done by humans maybe it's not exactly in the middle of them is bad maybe it's slightly below slightly Bob says the Gemara the the seeker was wide and therefore there's a little bit of wiggle room there says the kymaro what about the halacha that the pirate says in the basically that she has certain vessels there's possibly certain thighs a log or Rubeus house a passel of her and human that make it exactly Revere's but exactly alone says the Gemara because it when the particles Berkhamstead to do it he understood that humans are not perfect and it won't be perfect and the Gemara beings arrived from an oven that's tummy and if you split it down the middle exactly evenly we still have to be concerned that both pieces that are not even so you see that humans do not make something even so he mark was earthenware has jagged edges and therefore it's impossible to make it even and finally the last ride of the Chimera is from a murder victim was found and we're not sure which city it came from and you took a measurement and it's exactly the same distance from both cities each city brings a calf now what should be the lava if humans cannot measure precisely so then they should bring one calf and maketh maggots from this city then it's yours if it's from the sea but the fact that you the rebel an surpasses he bring to you see that humans could measure precisely and come up with the same exact measurement have a wonderful week and a good