8 Min Daf - Bechoros Daf 11 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] you but I raised a few Dolloff says Allah huh what a donkey gives birth to a firstborn male now you have to redeem it first you try redeeming it with a set with a sheep or a goat if that doesn't work then you can redeem the donkey with its value you give the full value to the color sensor of alka that's not true only according to arab shimon who holds that Apodaca mark is motor bana then you can redeem it with its value but according to Abby who de who says that a pedal amar is Oscar bana so the Torah is very mock pit and says you can only redeem with a Seth the Seth takes away is makea the is er but you cannot redeem it with its value the mark brings another of nombre I said you see that he used to redeem even with cooked greens with the value of the donkey cooked greens not even money what happens if you go along and you redeem your friends Heather home owner says the Gemara works you redeemed it but you didn't gain anything you can't take the donkey in return according to rebbi shimon who says that a pet amar is motor by now so certainly you can't take it away from the owner it's the owners you could do whatever you want with it but even according to you who de who says that it's Oscar bhai now so you might say that it's up in the air whoever redeems it could grab it says a good morrow no it's really the owners and how do I know that because what happens if somebody comes along and steals your donkey before you had the chance to redeem it he owes you CAFO that proves that it's yours it's not like egg dish or something like that it's yours you own it fully says the Gemara it says in the Mishnah that at a certain point if you have a cell then you've designated as for the pedicle mark because you had a Suffolk let's say the donkey gave birth to twins and one was a female and we don't know maybe perhaps the female was born born first and there's no cars he designated a set he put it aside that says says the Mishnah is yours completely and therefore your hive in my sir and it says the Gemara let me explain even a where you had ten such donkeys who gave birth to ten sets of twins and we had tents vacancy you don't know what to do with all tending he's designated ten sheep on the side one of them will become my sir and you could bring it as your own schlomit whereas if we know for sure that it's the coins you can't benefit from it you can't bring it as long as the clans completely sense him are very interesting case if a year all had ten pedal cars they were known pedal cars you had to give it to the client and before you had a chance to give it to the client you inherited it you gave it over to your grandson the Austral gave it to his grandson who was a client in other words his daughter married a client and he had a grandson okay now the client is able to be mafia to remove the user from the bahar then that grandson went and gave it over to his own grandson inherited over to his own grandson who happened to be his thrall so we having strong Cayenne useful it started off with the field it ends off with a few but in the middle is absurd says anymore what do you do do you stroll the last guy designates 10 sheep puts it on the side but he gets to keep them because his grandfather the coin already removed it sir he just has to designate it and he gets to use it the same halluf would apply with fruit you have you stroll over at fruit and he put he was hired in trim semesters and instead he gave it over to his grandson the clayey and his grandson doesn't have to get trim some extra seats father and that grandson gave it to his own grandson great-great grandson of the original guy who is a his role and the easterlies sky patron surmise what does he do he designates puts aside from some mattress he sells it to a client and gets to keep all the money for himself what happens if you buy fruit from a guy after losing a marble aha everything was completed somebody went along and smooth out the pile of fruit that's the marble aha now you have in terms of my sizing tomorrow if the guy's the one that smooth out the pile go he's not high with room so my trousseau when you buy from him your partner but if the Jew is the one that didn't block he's the one that smooth out the pile he was a sharecropper so he had some sort of partnership the guy since this role did the mirror he did in Melaka he must designate aside trauma trouble he has designator side and give it to the kite but true must my sir he doesn't have to give why smart brings a possible it says no possible he's sick who maze banana stroll it's a very long path I can alright the end it says they're getting it says when you buy from any stroke you see comments you saw it and it says my sir minimizer so true must my sir you are Potter completely if you don't buy from a Jew if you buy from going Potter but true McDonald you are hired says Gemara in a similar vein if somebody goes and has a Emirates watch his fruit or a cuckoo see the Kumar has always been super giver Kushi is a complete gear or maybe they were garam because of the fear of the Lions so they're not complete garam at any rate there's someone Jewish and he entrusted his fruit with the cushy order marked and after he already removed the trauma so misers says Gemara we're not concerned that the cuisine a Moritz might have switched the fruit and therefore he's have again from semesters however if he entrusted his fruit with a guy then we have to be concerned that he switched it out and now we have a new human true so my dress according to the telecom we say that the guy certainly switched that 100% and therefore you must give true Magdala like me said before but not true mass miser because of that posit that we had before but according to Rabbi Shimon we don't know for a fact that the guy switched it out it's only a Suffolk your parents are our de my so even the true military law you you designate on the side but you don't have to give it to client you could sell the claim and the profit remains yours when the Mishna says that if the set the sheet that you designated on the side for the pedo camera dies the client could use it the says the Gemara explains that even if the scroll never gave it to the client he just designated on the side the coin can use it because it's as if the client has received it it was his completely even though he never received it and therefore he can benefit from the dead sheep have a wonderful day