Mekalkel: Constructive Destruction On Shabbos - 5784 Rav Zev Smith

like to welcome everyone to constructive destruction on CHAS have the great sponsoring at 718 851 8651 email.com har Smith you heard a sh someone who made a big and he had a lot of disposable pans that were used and it would take up a lot of room in the garbage so he wanted to crush all the pans and of course reduce the amount of garbage and he wanted to know is that a problem of so he's breaking a what used to be a k then I had a different sh a totally different angle where someone was was making a sh and he had a warmer that he kept the food in and people came Friday night Uninvited and they were making they were taking cougle whatever CH he wanted to make sure no one tampers so he got a tape and put it around the warmer so this way no one's going to open it the sh morning is to cut the tape to to get to the food in the war so this began my journey on really a challenging agenda because really it's two that we're going to discuss but it really has the same guidelines and that is the one we know about not how to destroy K so the question is when you destroy a disposable pan is that the Mal of you're breaking the Disposable pan cutting the tape is not so it's not a k but that might be the is of you're tearing tape like tearing paper or tearing anything else might be that of I you'll say but it'sa it's mical you're destroying it true but that's the the says call Al is not an well soon see if you if you if you something for a purpose that's destruction is but it's still so whether it's breaking a aluminum pan Which is mical or tearing the tape but there's a reason for it so this is our Su for today we gave an interesting name constructive destruction you're not St M that's breaking thing you're breaking the pants to make room in the garbage you're tearing the tape to get to the warmer and many other questions so the says you're allow to destroy something for be able to eat which at first glance is far from convincing because you're not allow to cook for why you allow to destroy so we have a that we have to learn and is in which is a big big so right away you have to underline the word I thought you know how to make it's one of the is allowing someone to tear the the leather let me explain very simply those days they didn't have bottles and cans they kept wine in a barrel now they sealed the barrel with leather they had somehow of connecting the leather strip to the barrel and now will come shabas you want to make kides you had to get the wine out of the barrel so says you allow to tear the leather to gain access to the barrel of wine but don't make it into a spout you'll cut it in a certain way that now it's a functional spout so that's thees you're taking a piece of leather and make it into a spout so what do you want to do you want to make KES you destroy you tear through the leather and that would basically ruin the leather and it's m the question is why is Kare M why is that the is of Kare just like we see if you make a a a spout as AA why is there's no is of has been written as we'll soon see but the most accepted in based on the same thing that even though but it's no more than so we say it's close that's the there's a beautiful CH in the he quotes other that there is but if it's a it's now you'll ask me well if it's why do you need say no no K is a even but overrides before we apply this to the miror of questions I have to REM them one more and this is a in again a barrel that's that was their most used type of storaging you allowed to break a barrel GRE now this is not wine this is GRE this is fruits dried fruit again same you have a barrel and you want to get to the food you're allow to break the barrel but don't make it into a fancy opening then you're making an opening so so it's the very similar like but there's one big difference was talking about tearing a piece of leather which in the worst scenario is the ISA of this is breaking a barrel breaking a barrel is the ISA of this is so the question is why is you're breaking a barrel so Rashi says very there's nothing wrong with being Mal back says and this is probably the biggest for today that you're right you want to get the GRE you can't get the GRE and you're allowed to he does add that there is a mish in chabas in that we see even we'll soon discuss that but no doubt about it we have two sources for our big question we have the tear leather and the big you have the M you're allowed to break a the now you notice there's a big difference the which might include even uh opening a package of plastic cups not eating the cups but says now himself on that has a different shot and says you know why you allow to break this it's not your regular and he quotes and let me give a little background to seems to hold you know how to break a k even for not like the but if the K is broken like the way he says the K was broken and you put it together you know half a job if you sneeze too hard it's going to break again you know B this Barrel is not a full-fledged Barrel so to quote the slang language that we talk if it ain't fixed you can't break it in other words if it's not a k you can't be it's not a Ki so that's what T learns the it's not all a and we'll soon see if we could apply that to our disposable pans but that's a it's almost there's no if it's not a and quotes this mishna and he mentions the word the concept of now you I'm sure you're wondering wait a second if you're telling me it's not a k it's a must so why do you have to have a of if it's not broken if it's not a K you can't break it why do you need even though it's not a breaking things is aome it's it looks like you're breaking you know someone wants to ask me he's in the mood he takes the twig and he wants to break it in half twig is not a c so I told him first of all a twig is M but besides m the m says we'll soon see that breaking something for reason which looks like should not be done permitted it that's true but it has the it's only so we have two sources the regarding the leather the mishna regarding the K now we're going to go through all the Shas that's going to be simple well a sh will say or sh Miss shab because one of the two will guide us the rest of the sh so we're going to first discuss safety seals which today is unavoidable everything has a safety seal let once and for all we're talking about that you're not tearing through lettering because once you get through tearing lettering different sh we're talking that you're able to avoid lettering so the EMS is that this is a perfect example of so let me explain I brought along some a little show and tell for today but this bottle of grape juice is bottle is fully made no problem the only problem is that there's a safety seal that happens to be in this case it is aluminum foil sometimes it's plastic but the K is made what you have to do is tear this off which I'm not going do now but you can see you tear it off you're not making a ky what you're doing is you're tearing the so this be it's made now this is very different than once you take off the seal you're GNA Twist Off the cap because that many p hold you're making the cap because the cap was sealed on it was O K by taking over a soda bottle or wine Etc it's o k but the wine bottles that just have a white cap that screws on and off that is no Shila because the safety seal in all the different types is no more than a contemporary or you'll open the you have a dip you open up there a a plastic covering can you tear through that or so it comes in different forms and shapes but safety seals cross the board are no more than our original question that we asked someone wants to put tape around his warmer I heard this from from a Mas he wanted to put his tape around the warmer so no want should tamper with it so the this should be no difference however we come to an incredible of the is in a different context he was asked about A's issue where where yid would keep their the chant in a I guess there was no problem of of the bleers of the oven but they wanted to make sure the GU would not open it and take some at night so they put paper they had a double seal they first locked the oven number one and they wanted to be firm they put paper on the lock so if it's tampered with it will be noticeable so the problem is very good it's kosher double KAS what's that the tear the paper so don't be so firm and don't put a paper seal on it because you're going to have to tear the paper and that's the ISA of K but listen to his that that's of tearing the paper seal on the on the lock why the it's not because till now you can gain access to the chalant by taking off the paper seal you're gaining access to the chant and that's a m and it's an is in other words he's telling us that constructive destruction is you're gaining access to the shant and he has a different point he says don't bring me a from the Min but the Min of both and as that they have a go open a letter an envelope here's a envelope to get to the letter so you see allow to do it he says don't bring me a I'm it's wrong in other words the in that stickle he says tearing the the tape around the warmer opening letters taking off safety seals from wines inside or outside any place it is is so he says don't be from rely onck to open on CH obviously this is a big and we could almost say first of all the of is only which is a mishin that they they made the the theas and there was a hole whatever it was and you didn't just patch it you cut around to put in a patch to put in to make it nice to weave it nicely so the K was very much constructed Al that's the real the says a it doesn't sound like but a and he says if you tear something to use it it's also even though it's not he gives an example in if you have a big piece of paper me you have to make it into aat paper tissue paper so you cut up from a big piece into small pieces to use is now really that's a because it's not but that's constructive tearing okay so we have two levels is the worst and tearing paper to use is bad enough but who says getting being getting rid of a a tape makes it into don't didn't we just see and did not say it's aome because it's because you're making you're gaining access to the wine both as this on the now I must tell you the he doesn't need more than that the end of tries to explain the that he holds with the is is and this is constructive enough okay it's aat but I wanted to tell you before we move on that there is a lot to say about the you know devotes 28 pages of his chuva which is very atypical of him to prove that PES is right and therefore you have to open all seals bottles covering everything before shabas soes knew what he was talking about but most do reject the I'll read you in simil he discusses the casis issue if you need two or one that's the bulk of his cha but at the end he says what the says that don't use two use one because if you tear off the paper it's this is and he says the was guilty of being M the anding the he said use one seal instead of two that's wrong and he said don't tear when you allow to tear I'm only reading this for reason I'll tell you why and he concludes I gave it to him don't forget lived and the but he must have passed through and he said I gave it him and he was quiet now why did I read this because the did not accept the and the is like we said it's not constructive it's getting rid of a problem it's a so that's why safety seals is and we'll soon discuss envelopes sometimes you have on a safety seal that it says it almost it's it's sort of you like it makes it easy to tear they says they point an arrow tear here so it it tears easier this one kind of doesn't have but very often these type of packaging the little tab sticking out and you pull the tab around so it tears off easy that's no problem at all because you're not to size the ISA of tear here is when you cut a paper towel you're making the paper towel to size that's but this is just making it easy to be so what's wrong with doing things easy so if it says teer here that's making the heta easier to do but don't confuse that with what people know is wrong if you have a box of tissues you forgot to punch out the center so you tear around the the the perforated Edge that's a problem CU you're making a box of tissues a functional box of tissues or you tear a tablecloth and you tear it at the per at the the the perforated line down the the center of it you're making a tablecloth we're talking about that you te it makes it easier to tear but at the end of the day it's one big maalo and that should not be a problem now once I mentioned that I should tell you that we'll soon discuss this but tearing the table Claus has nothing to do with a you're making a functional tablecloth a lollipop wrapper and you want to tear it off so that would be an plus the whole WAP is one big must it's flimsy it's broken almost before you start tearing a wafer W off the the the wafer if there's no lettering again is an and it's fine a box of mat typically mat or a lot of box of cereal It's tricky because the same thing tear here and you pull a tab off the top of the box right down the center but that's much worse there it's not just making it easier to tear there you're making the box and VAR you could close the box it has a fold has a flap it's a whole fancy I mean a fancy you know paper box but there the tier here is facilit facilitating making a box so that's why should done before shabas now there's a whole different Su of making a k that's that's that's some place make because of a different Su will leave a different sh that's called is just a container we're not getting that now but making a tier here on a safety seal is fine te here on a box that makes the Box functional is presumably if you consider that a what's more of a sh I couldn't find one in the house to bring it but they have prepackaged knots or Etc but they used to make it in a package with a safety seal now it's a little fancier it's packaged in a way that you can't open it as it is you have to tear it on the side a strip of leather off the side and then you could open and close this plastic uh packaging of nuts and chocolate etc etc Z yeah z i don't ziplock because you you don't weal it you tear off the plastic off the oh that's another one you something you tear off the and then you use the ziplock but I'm talking about these boxes plastic and carttons that you tear it off and you could use it that is a real ticking K because P this the K as it is is not functional and you're fashioning the K now this would also explain why tearing a tablecloth disposable Shas is a major problem it's presumably you're making a tablecloth now people say you could use the roll without tearing but it's very bonish to use a roll and drop it down and but no doubt about it I saw Sim gim giml proves this the fact that the t is disposable is not a for disos might be a for k or or or or because it's it's not a k so you can't break an on K but he proves this conclusively from the gor says you're not to take a even though it's it's disposable but once you make something functional that's the problem so basically a tablecloth should be a serious and again even no but I want to add a point that brings us another beautiful part of our there is a number of malas I wouldn't say it's two Hales because it's two malas but it's sort of like a set if a wrote a wrong letter that is he wrote and a so he has to correct it to an and a hey so you'll say what's wrong with racing am I it's constructed I'm not doing anything why that's tearing down a building is I'm is awesome another example is so there's a connection between and that's probably the hband the now you have to real the ra says if you tear leather to size that's but and I want to writes this whole thing in parentheses this whole I'm going to tell you now dark of the was when he had a suff he put the in parenthesis but here's a a phenomenal when you tear leather destructively to get to some place that tearing is not awesome even why the only is is something that was woven that was made with fibers whether it's sewn or woven a jacket a in the Mish you made it through so undo so K is undoing the but a piece of leather that's one piece and will soon see a piece of plastic a piece of paper that's one stick if it wasn't did not use to make it then there's no of tearing it and where did he get this from he got he learned why not like the the is if it's one piece if it's not is D I don't have to tell you but what I think the hezar is he doesn't spell it out but probably that's what he means to say that since K is the opposite of it has to come from got hey I think he mean say this also he says when regarding the paper is considered a a a k so why in hus in Korea it's not he says because shabas is different standards it's probably the because shab and is one now the big p on the ra is as that this in thei in B that even by leather there's regular I saw also the on now the way writes it very beautifully referring to the didn't mention his name is very now the so see B is does prove that the r is correct but we see that we cannot accept this of the that tearing paper or leather or plastic is M across the board but don't forget tearing leather plastic or paper when there's I did see one of the he says maybe if the great pass table cloths but the you allow to use them cuz maybe you could rely on the that there's no by plastic but I think it's wrong the said without parentheses by Le is because so plastic tablecloths especially cut on the on the lines is real so T should be open before shabas no doubt about someone asked me what he thought was a challenging question he bought a fancy wine for shabas and you have to use a cork screw to take out the cork so it's basically K you screw it in you pull out a a cork so that although it sounds pretty sophisticated is because the wine bottle was made and you're not making it you're not making the cork the cork was made it's I'll give you a muscle not a good mus like taking the out of the Mikvah that's basically what it is the cork is form of a it happens to be it's put in a more secure way but this cork is made and the wine is made and is make someone bought a box a cake in a box a St mat comes in a box and there's a string around it so to untie the string is of M untying but it's mut to tear the string in a destructive way because again you're not making the box and the string you're basically destroying so that's why it's p the has another that on this string it's never so once it's not then there's no but what I did see a B I want to to say about this in the he says very often you buy I'm in a camp in Yesa have this all the time they have slice it comes in a regular plastic bag and there's a red tape I couldn't I don't have this in my house so but a red tape that very securely holds the bag almost airtight and when you're ready you just cut through the tape it's like a little probably probably less than an inch and the rad tape comes off you open the bag and you have kala it's typically kala and Cake to keep it fresh it's also a good safety seal so he says that's much worse than cutting the string because the bag when it's tightened like that is not functional so the problem is not tearing through the red tape that's a that's a uh that's M karea that's the case of the safety seal but you're making the bag from dysfunctional to functional he says if the bag was was closed to keep for less than seven days it never lost that never became so attached but if it's made for more than seven days it's considered o bag and opening it is making a bag I don't understand that but one thing I will say the good news is kala cake any food is typically not made to keep clothes for more than seven days but this is what he wants to say that you're making the bag aam he does say I know that that since it can't be used you have like sort of reopen it so someone asked this question he had a bag of Cups plastic PL um the regular cold cups in its regular plastic cover can he open a plastic bag over cups Cutlery had a very more more sophisticated child someone got in the mail a beautiful K that Thea sent out and it came on Friday no sh of M but it came in a plastic cover and he forgot to open it before shabas and he wanted to tear the plastic cover no different like a plastic bag on on cups and use the contess see I'm not saying magazine because magazine we can live with on jais but let's talk about the contess so the MS is here we come to an interesting question is the heta of Korea then all this is or is it only because of and you're not eating the cont so the emesis if you start from the shus you'll get pretty good guidance maybe a little mixed message but thean said that's the and theor the Mish and shabas are both talking about shabas talking about GRE the is talking about wine the unlike the says so that's pretty much mixed messages is to so as you see there's that the he brings a CAU quoting you all to break a a a container to get to a is not goes with that and he writes if someone has socks in a plastic cover whatever plastic a container but wrapper you allow to tear the wrapper to get to the socks to wear on shs but but the the problem here is that the Pim even the P that a with opening an envelope destroying an envelope are only it could be the is only and maybe envelopes would not be included but one thing I will say that as I told you earlier breaking things for no that he says stepping on a bro en kav to break a broken K is it's broken there it is it's doing the and don't do it unless it's a of question someone got a longer way to CH from a in the mail it came Friday afternoon no sh of he forgot to open before shabas can he tear the the envelope in a destructive way to read the letter which of course is a real so if you hold it's only so this not but let's assume be so until today we would say opening a letter which year opens a letter now we'll say what's the problem if it's what's the problem but the problem is pretty serious one that discuss this very question and calls it we don't do but even the that took exception he only was and the question is why if you're assuming it's why so the ter probably is if it letter us only maybe these held there's no it's only or number two maybe the only het is if it's a real if you could wait to read the after shabas so maybe covered chabas would be to wait again maybe the the cha you want to read I'm not going to get into the detail but you have to make sure that it's now hold to tear an envelope but he writes there he adds it was he he said that I don't know if he means but he's definitely to open it when there's a need for sure but I think it's a combination of two things first of all someh you have to have and also is this really now but I'll give you a mall that all agree is aome but you might feel a little old so I'm warning you I said in the Yesa that you have a ear mail letter what's that you remember that arram it was sort of a blue very thin paper and you wrote a letter to S those are the days that people wrote letters before texting and well not not writing anyhow and you wrote it and you sealed it the receiver got a sealed letter and opening was not destroying an envelope was making this arram so that old the place say is a real tick TI G now that's why if you know the Pim they discuss if there's a says that if there's if it's a piece on cont an envelope on top of the letter what do they mean the same thing you know some invitations today come the same way not not something that's made but you you you put together by a little sticker it's closed in a way that when you open it you actually fashion that that letter or whatever it is so the at the end of the day I can't say it's wrong to open a letter if someone feels it's and he's convinced it's if he destroys it but this person that asked he got a letter from God and he wasn't going to destroy the envelope because the godler wrote his name you know and sent the address so he wanted to make a functional envelope to store the letter in it that's something like an aerogram that's something like the the other case which is a problem says to to open a a letter says don't first be careful with the lettering but he writes so apparently not or maybe only and he explains what he writes there but he definitely says that we should not open letters don't forget sort of an aan X in s of C B he says don't open letterings because sometimes you want to reuse the envelope and then you're making an envelope the say that really it should be M but he says that since sometimes you want to reuse the envelope you're making the envelope and that's why it's a I think again it's something that we could live without it so let's be more someone asked this question that basically the he got a C in the mail okay similar sh and it's basically just a plastic wrapper that keeps it from getting dirty is there any more of a I told him that might be more mut because there's no way that you make a plastic container out of the plastic bag you know there's an envelope a big part of the problem is you might make open the envelope to you reuse the envelope but this plastic cover on the cont is no different than a plastic bag on Cutlery or or socks or or plastic cups so if you're convinced that there's no Isa if it's I believe the should not be any different because you're not going to make a container out of the plastic a plastic cover someone got a package of napkins I think it was F your napkins and there's a place in the center that you cut out you pick it up whatever and now you have a nice dispenser that gives you napkins one at a time so that is a problem that's a now so you might say but the whole plastic um is not a k it's a plastic wrapper so that's maybe that might be mustii but if it's functional as it is that that's a problem the eight to avoid all shs would be tear apart the bag entirely you'll put the napkins in a different place but that's we could say probably this is part of the suda napkins Cutlery even though you're not eating it cups those probably are more like the and you could be make them someone asked me he's a little has a little of nerven that's why I told him this he's afraid to use the regular paper towels and the Sho not the ones that you tear off you know comes in the the stacks so what's the problem cuz sometimes the paper towel tears it happens I told them first of all that's at most and that's more so in the worst scenario if he does tear a paper towel that's a real Kil with absolutely no benefit it just makes him nervous I told him today till 120 use paper towels don't ask again I hope it works but that's the truth because that's the best scenario to mention to show you how versatile this sug is we have this child in in the mountains but it give be again in the city you have a spider web a spin web in yish and it's not sightly you want to remove it on chabas so the quotes from earli that since it's connected that might be K besides M so you can't tear this this SP spiderweb on chabas to say that it's considered that it's tallish it's considered as he's learning it but had enough of of a connection that's considered he says so therefore if it's disturbing so even though it's but but I want to mention twice I'm not sure why but twice gim gim he writes he supposed to take get rid of the the is so do shabas but if if you forgot do shabas and it's disturbing on chabas it's not enough of a to be considered and of the fact that it's a gra now the last part of this of this Shear is a few Shas that are really part of a different Shear opening cans and bottles is not regular it need to share for itself but one part of it is very much NE and that is the question if you have a a a pan aluminum pan a disposable pan you finish using it and it's a big clumpy thing you want to smash it up and put in the garbage if you have 20 of them you have a SIM it's even more common the question is is it m to crush a disposable pan you know this year sh is coming out a few days day beforeit they're going to make a mint on selling disposable Chen pots which I've seen so can you crush that it's pretty easy to crush it's pretty big otherwise someone told me that he goes to when he goes to a speech sh by by by never BR his when the longer this the speaker goes he gets more nervous so he bites on a disposable Fork Until It Breaks so is he breaking it is he precise a Kaye so our question is an interesting one you're not breaking a classic Kaye you're breaking a disposable Kay is this the a problem of now now we're shifting from K to but it's the same guidelines so the question is a very fundamental one can we say that a a regular K would be a disposable might be a must before you started once it's a must then we have the of that if it's a it is but if it's it's so let me add a little more if someone has a lock of his door that that's that's jammed that's broken he has to has to replace it but he wants to get into the room so we'll soon see the P can say that's a major problem why because you're breaking a lock a lock part of the house even more and more so it's really because you have to take that out get it out and put another one in this what I told you is the second half of the ran and that we began with the said to break the but don't compare that the same to the the says to be able to carry in a you have to have an A but you have to have access to the a if the a is in a migdal that you don't have the key maybe the a is no good you have no access to the food ah you could break the lock to get to the food but that's which is much more also references that contrast to to so when we what we see is when you're talking about there's no that's so is how do we look at a disposable pan so what came to mind is well what's the do you have to toal that disposable pan most don't why not it's not a Kaye toless Kaye is based on a Kaye that means you're identifying a disposable pan as an A K so maybe it's a and indeed this P writes it very in length and very dramatic emphatically he quotes Tak raal that a a disposable pan or disposable Fork is a must even though he points out a musi is fundamentally different a musi was a k that broke and is in a holding on for de life it's broken but a exposable fork is not broken it just used only once but he said the Lum this is the same the fact that it's it doesn't last it isn't used it isn't reused so his big is that a disposable item in any form is a must ah once it's a must we have shab that if it's AAS we'll soon see if letting out frustration is aab but if it's aab should be M and he does add thata in the worst scenario it's a but this is his that he and says a little page little later in page of these aluminum these disposable PL pans and you want to make more room in the garbage you're allowed to crush it because this is a must and he assumes that that's considered now I want to just make clear if you you want if you just fold it in half like typically you could do it's not broken so there's no sh I'm talking about it you break with a Vengeance that is not usable so this is his take on the matter so to speak that a disposable pan is not a but I did see in a number of places and this is a real in someone asked him he has a cougle in an aluminum pan so he wants to cut half the coule and half the pan very practical cuts a straight down any sharp knife will cut the CLE and the pan so he says it's a problem because you're making a because aluminum even though aluminum P even though it's only used once is considered a now he says this regarding that you have to to it and he says this that you all to make KES on a disposable be because it's a c called which I understand and in in a different say he says is regarding crushing aluminum pans that it's a problem because he says a disposable pan is considered a k now I guess he understood must something wrong with it's broken but this is not broken this is disposable also says breaking the Disposable pan is which is also in the same SA he says that you're allowed to use a disposable fores disposable is K so our question the very fundamental one is a disposable item pan plastic cup plastic fork a or not is of and it's understandable both both of them are easy to understand now what I will say is when you don't break it just fold it is okay also someone asked me IFA if he has a plastic cup and when he help picked it up it it's it's squeezed in so maybe it's broken and he's fixing it I said it's not broken just like your hat someone sits in it it's not broken so you're allowed to fix it so it has to be broken to be fixed but crushing it destroying it is a problem like manyas now the you have 10 pans put one in the other so you only end up with one one big one stacked High that's much easier to deal with okay question someone his door was jammed and he can't open it can he break the the lock so this is a problem this probably could be because you have to get it out to put in another one so basically use a different door in fact the discuss if anes the lock was jammed to break the lock to get to a sa because if you assume again it's then it would be because you what you do is you break open the lock and therefore it falls apart then you could put the new lock in no of this is the earli discussed this the sh Chua already quotes that it's a problem even regarding an but one thing I will say if a child is locked into a room says the very clearly that could be a the child feels he's trapped he could you know lose his mind so then you allow to even break a door even to be that might be but again don't call have the do it as soon as possible to remove the the danger and let me leave you with a few I would like to hear from the because these are questions that come up I'd like to hear a little guidance first one is an interesting sh the Min was foris that people got married a of shabas and they got to Su the shabas one of the told me his parents got married here in America a shabas there discuss let's say the the the was delayed and they got married on shabas you allowed to even though a but once you start you to conclude it so the interesting sh up is you're making a on shabas can the break the glass at the end of the you're laughing but you know you want to do things right you know there's no have to take pictures on chabas but break the glass so we think why breaking a glass it's not a must it's not a that's different and it's it's a real K not disposable true but let's think what is the worst scenario that he's doing right now he's not breaking it to save a piece to put a souvenir on his wall he's breaking it theem Kil maybe it's a kilab so you might say why is it it's a but you might have a different time the same gar that we mention m is a whole beautiful Su if someone breaks something to vent his frustration let out his anger is a terrible thing to do you're feeding you at but that's because you relax next if someone R his so it's it's a if someone does it's a so maybe breaking the glass would be a m so I looked into this and in the he says this I'm not sure why it's I do understand where it's coming from why it's m because K you're doing the positive Act of making Crea you want to get out anger so you break a k here the minig is to destroy so it's a real Min of destroying so what's wrong it's a that happens to be a which makes it a problem but this is the issue he quotes from the I don't have access but if you see anything different for second question which I really need's help this is a ketchup bottle as you see this is the White Cap okay and this is a safety seal okay so let's say you need this on shabas so taking off the safet is no problem whatsoever but in this he says something that you know is very MAV and he basically says that taking off this cap fine taking go up to Sage is fine but screwing this back on to be able to use it is a problem of makes now let me explain he writes I know it's a but this in p p doll he says right now this bottle is really obstructed by this safety seal so this bottle is not working in sync with the White Cap the bottle is a bottle the cap is a cap but it's not working together you take off the seal and you screw this on and you don't open it up again you're making a functional bottle in other words he's what he says is if you open a salt shake or sugar shake to put in salt and sugar but you open and close it all the time so you're not making it here you take it off putting it back on you're making a ketchup bottle that's functional and then you use it until it ends and you throw in the garbage so this would be marage of the ketchup bottle but now this what he wants to say now said to me if the bottle is usable as it is which it is so this just an just is an accessory but is this is this would you say the bottle is is missing makes but then again this is a much better way of using it than pouring it out because it comes this is no this also made both are made this wait no what what what he does say I forgot to mention this is like a you're taking two p and putting it together a folding she you allow to open up because it's one piece so this is what he says if you have something nice to say please tell me but I do think a pretty good might be that this is really functional and this is functional case you have two nonentities you're putting together this may this one could be used also the P he doesn't speak about ketchup but he talks about salt Shak and sugar Shak he says something that that's that could be but this just screws on see TR this is a patent of plastic it's just a screwing it on two or three turns it's onone but it's it's forever it's permanent so that's to think about i' love to hear more about that now it's not the end of the world for the ketchup you have one or two choices either you puncture something something thin through the hole and puncture the the safety seal then nothing changed you didn't make anything or open it take off the safety seal and use the ketchup like this question number three also very I saw this and I don't have I don't have house to bring it but they sell in together when they sell the instant soups they have a small disposable Fork basically it's hard describe but it's one piece that's folded in half you're supposed to open it and snap something in place and then you could use it so both these Pim say that's AES because it even though it's one piece it was never made by snapping it in that's you're making a fork now again that's a bigger than till now because this should be like a folding chair it's all one piece but he's saying it was never made into a functional Fork it was folded in half they both considered that a makes of a now if you hold that it's disposable it's less of a problem but again as we said earlier even disposable is a problem I said this to lead to last question this is question that comes up every Y and that is for those that use this um floating Wicks which I did bring this is the wick it's basically a wick with a with a little um um wack on it and this is the cork we'll call it and you put the wick through the Cork and then you do it and it works so the sh is to of course shabas is not a sh you don't make Wicks on shabas but y second night first whatever it is if can you put this this Wick through the C to use it so the EM is some say this is a real it's it's disposable but that we saw that making a is no different than so this is why those hold you have to do before before however here there's much more because this Wick is functional as it is this is basically makes it easier you're not being completing it its use it can be used as it is now hold yeah but the use is together because it's it's very hot to make it work but what I think is important to mention is that all agree if you have this cor sometimes the the hole was not punched out it came with this piece in and you push the wick through you're actually making this cork that would be but using this there's definitely a be because the K is used useful ra has another H that it's not really you're making into a a new K the K was made and this again helps it float but one thing I will say which I try to do also besides that it's if you can but the brings quoting Zoya that the husband is supposed to prepare the N before shabas because say have the three Mitzvah of why this is REM for the the husband has to prepare the N she has to light so the second night we always miss that if we don't prepare the NYS so I always make the Wix Le so you can be with that I talk to you sh today to have the great cl to sponsoring a share call sh Tyra 718 851 8651 on email.com [Music] for the of constructive destruction the will only be constructive we learned first of all we saw the and but not a pushover the only he is if it's a or some say but or is a problem we saw was breaking a flimsy K or the had must which is basically it doesn't have a full sh K but basically tearing that's why safety seals if you avoid the lettering is m some open before as we said but safety seals cross the board even on the line if it just makes it easier to tear not making an item out of the tearing on the lines pulling a tab of a plastic container that prepackage nuts candy Etc is a problem you're making the K like a box of tissue that you're making the the the opening will take out the tissues string on a box of matah tear it in a constru in a destructive way as opposed to the tape on a bag because you make you're remaking the bag that was ice bag tearing tablecloths should not be done especially in the sh it's inappropriate it should be done before shabas the r holds that any carea on plastic paper and leather is no there's no is but of course even like the is a cork screw is perfectly M the only someh only food is M cups plates would be in part would be letters or Contra is they had tear the plastic the wrapping around it we don't open envelopes onab unless that would be an air mail which you're making the letters much worse the paper towel is a problem if you tear it off the roll but using it in is because it's most suffa but it's a m spider web should be removed before chabas with the but if it's not done it's m on chabas if it's distressing the fundamental sh is disposable or that we saw folding the pan is not a problem destroying it is telling this got to mention to break a disposable Fork is a problem like some is is and also people bite on it and leave it on the table and then it's m and then you're going to have it's not nice for other people but basically breaking a a a a must is breaking disposable is breaking a lock in a door is a reala of a k if a Char's locked in do whatever is necessary to put an end to the misery right away breaking glass by the the ketchup we had a stickle of about that and this the soup spoon snapping back in the place floating WIS I do say the Min to be if you do before the