Megillah 4a - Gemarah Megillah #11

the yeshiva dotnet okay let's begin DAF Dollard I'm an Aleph for lines from the bottom allergic forum academically I'm Aneesa so tune in we have to recall here this is a new piece of Gomorrah on the next piece of the Mishnah let's recall the opening of mastectomy Gila the first Mishnah the Mishnah began that a megillah' could be read on one of five days your ala few days you'd give Malia dollar and Tessa other not before and that later what's the rule the rule is cities that are fortified with a wharf in the days of Yeshua they read it on to slough and villages and cities large cities small cities villages towns that are not fortified from the days of your show even if they have a wall but not from the days of Eurasian will be known they read on your dollar so that covers two dates your dominant to smoke which is what we do till today we read on your Dalit right if you're in your salon for example which is look of Cojimar you're gonna read the Megillah on pass love or yeah that's the first Clause of the Mishnah but then the missionary continued what about your a Levite base you get most of the mission continue that's where this Gomorrah take continuous eller shock forum adamantly eye mechanism if you lived in a village you had an option and the option was to read the Megillah early when early your mechanism because it means the day that you were anyway going into the city the larger city where there are manana regular manana sorry about Lana so Magda mainly a mechanism they can do the Megillah early they have an option to read the Megillah Leonie Melissa the day that they go into the city they're gathered in the city which is when Mondays and Thursdays was the regular regular routine was that Jews of villages would enter and travel into the larger cities of course by the means of transportation that they had during the time of the Mishnah this is a couple of years before Henry Ford and they would travel whether it was a long walk whether it was a camel whether it was a donkey whether it was a coach a horse etc the mela when they're coming in Monday and Thursday why are they coming in Monday and Thursday Rashi says because that's when the courts would sit besten would sit monday answer is there's all disputes and people had disputes would be dealt with other is showing him say Korea's hot area Monday and Thursday so they have come and said you could read the Megillah then the Monday and Thursday before you doll it right that's what the Mishnah said before Magna melia mechanism that's it and then the Mishnah went through the calendar went through the week to illustrate cater and the Mishnah goes through what was the first thing the Mishnah said if your dollar is on Monday started with Monday if you doubt it is on Monday then we know everyone does your dollars because it's a Monday so if it's a Monday you're coming in anyway so you could have the cake and eat it too what if poor him if your doll it is Tuesday so everybody does it on Tuesday but the villagers do it on Monday which is you'd gimble what if podium is on Wednesday you down is on Wednesday so everybody doesn't on Wednesday but the villages the villagers do it on Monday which would be you'd base what if podium is on Thursday your dollars on Thursday everybody doesn't on Thursday because it's a Thursday enough to do it on Monday you can do it on Thursday wonderful disunity by Claudius wrong what happens if Purim is on a Friday everybody does and I'm Friday but in the village you do it on Thursday which would be you'd get mo so remember Monday Tuesday Wednesday and tune is Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday if you're living in a village either you did it on your Dalit if it was Monday if there is that or you did it on youth base if poram was Wednesday oh you did it on your Gitmo if Porter was Tuesday or Friday thank you what if put him is on Shabbos meaning your dollar is on Shabbos Oh everybody now has a problem because you can't read the Megillah on Shabbos so what happens now whether the mission to say that if it's on Shabbos so then we know that in the villages you do it on Thursday meaning you do it on your base right because you can't do it on Friday they're not coming into the city on Friday but as the mission to put it who else does it on Thursday the regular cities who can do it on Shabbos are that they really go back to Thursday they do it together with the villagers on Thursday meaning they do it when on you'd base of course if you live in a fortified city good because you can do it on Sunday what happens if program is on Sunday oh this is the end because we started Monday so we went a full circle for Monday till Sunday if you're living in a city you do it on Sunday but if you're living in a village when do you do it on Thursday which day is that you're Alif that's the only scenario where the Megillah is read so far behind you doubt of course if you download a Sunday so Shabbos is you'd get Mol Friday use your base and Thursday is your Aleph that's the finally the scenario when they read the Megillah on your Aleph other poram is unser on Sunday they can do it Monday because you never do it later you always do it earlier and therefore they have to go back to Thursday when we say a half-two they don't have to they could if they want to come in on Sunday Raja mysticism to hate wonderful but we don't make you come in on Sunday we say you're coming in anyway Monday and Thursday we want to make life easier so you don't have to schlep again a second wasn't easy to come into the city it wasn't just you ran into your car and it was a 15 minute drive it was an avoider it was hard work and therefore we protect them we want to help them and we say you have a special Magilla reading opportunity when you're coming in anyway so you could then go to the minion and do the Megillah and show in the morning on Monday or Thursday that was the mission first the Gomora discussed the first part of the mission and now the Gemara gets to this part of the mission eller shock for him adamantly I'm a kanesha what do you want to ask if Purim is on Shabbos so everybody did two days back Thursday you want to know why why don't the regular cities do Friday okay good question why do the regular cities have to go back two days that's your question right excellent question why don't they just do it why don't they just do it on Friday how come I'm said since there anyway going out of their comfort zone so let them already go back to Thursday not on Friday you know they should do it together another since your anyway not doing it on time so let's already do it together it's always nicer when it's together right we're ready I'm have to smell it if you were doing it on time you can do it together it's like it's like I'm in Hood Floyd's I'm making a second say there I have to make a second said I'm not a nature straw but if you're anyway not doing it on time so really do it together with me so everybody does it on Thursday the villagers come to the to the cities on Thursday and they do and they do they do the Megillah but if your dollar is on Friday then the people in the city could do it on Friday so they could do it on times they do it on Friday and then what happens and then the people and the villagers do it on Thursday the people in the fortified cities they can't do it on Shabbos because it's test evolved and you can't read them in you listen they do it on Friday also now you don't put them on Thursday why cuz why should you put them with the villagers when you could put them with the cities you understand when test some of is on Shabbos then the people in the fortified cities read the Megillah when on Friday not on Thursday why when your dollar is on Shabbos everybody reads on Thursday because why not unite the Jewish people to agreed on Thursday but when test fathers on Shabbos the people of the regular cities are reading it on Friday so why should you ask the Jews in the fortified cities to read it on Thursday with the Jews of the village when they can read it on Friday with the Jews of the cities that's the logic but samba she can't read the Megillah so they have to go backwards so they go back one day not two days when you're in a regular city you go back two days because that way they'll unite but when you're in a fortified city you're going back one day you'll unite with much more Jews than going back to days because more Jews live in the largest cities than the little villages first taste okay dr. Kumari I'll check fire magadh Emily Emily it's clear if solemn klar America Nina Nina says commie made kilo a lock for him Lea's macademia mechanistically she is SAP come I'm a Muslim I came across the sages will lenient with the Jews in villages that they can read the Nagila before poor him on Monday you Thursday why so that I'm poor him they should have free time to be able to provide water and food to their brothers who live in the larger cities the Jews in the villages were usually involved in agriculture agriculture is of course the source of nutrition the source of food they usually were in the job they were in the work their vocation was providing Jews and cities with food grain and water as a result of that they wanted that on Purim which is you dollars they should have a free day if you would make them come to the city to read the Megillah that takes up time you have to travel is reading the Megillah this traveling back etc in order for them to have your dollars free so they allowed that if on your dollar they're coming to the city anyway if it's a Monday or if there is they fight but sins they're not coming to the city anyway because it's not Monday or Thursday for bez dinner for curious authorities so read the Megillah earlier and then you download they can bring food to their brothers and this is a benefit of course for them for their economic situation but it's also a benefit primarily for the Jews in the cities because they all want to have a Suda's Purim and there was no extra food that was just you know people just had food food was very very precious it's hard for us to understand for their sunnah of Purim they need food they need water so they get them you doubted they could bring food to their brothers in the crime well it's just a much more stressful time it will be much more stressful yeah you have to go and bring them this huh you can just call them uber to deliver the food to realize fact the Gemara lament that i can to the croc another really this would have come in a set it's all because we're looking out for the jews in the cities in the largest cities they should be able to have food from porter one second this doesn't add up vietnam we learned in our Mishnah kali as moschini foreign buyer leaderless korean by by Y if you dowel rod it is on son one day they all read on that day cuz it's Monday the e miss but if it's true that it's for the benefit of the people in this city so one second even if quoted ms on Monday they shouldn't read the Megillah them because if the if podium is on Monday who's gonna suffer the Jews in the cities because I'm coming into this city from the village I'm busy with the Megillah you're not gonna get your food or at least half the people won't get their food because I'm busy I'm stressed off their slept on them a good laugh to go we have to go there so even if you dial it out there is a Monday lick the movie miss if it's true lick the movie I might konista they should do it on Thursday in other words even if you dial it others on Monday they should do it on Thursday if the whole reason for this is what not you're telling me you don't want to make them come twice you telling me so that the Jews in the cities should have foods for pudding that why we want to give those use who are busy with this vocation we want to give them a free day so if the Mosel is that your dollar is on Monday so now they lose if your doubt is on Tuesday up bar as I said they're open your dollar is on Monday so now they're stuck they can't it they don't have the time to do everything they're busy here [Music] they're coming in Monday usually they came in Monday and thirst so he's the Bernina said the reason for this entire issue was that you want give them off on your dollar that was this now you have to decide which days you're gonna do it so they're gonna do it the days that are coming in anyway fine I understand that but it comes out that whenever put him is on Monday so then the whole issue is canceled let them do McGill on Thursday and poor him they're open they're free they can give them food that was your point so the Gomora says no have a las navas if you download is on Monday so Thursday is ten your daughter Vasari latina very abundant on day ten there's no dispensation to read the McGill you can also time to read the McGill on Hanukkah I mean do it on Rosh Hashanah he can just meet the McGill on your daughter we learned in the Gemara earlier that the anti-cancer saga Darla were the ones who gave permission to read the Megillah before Porter we learnt it from the posse clerk imec mayor poor Emma Ella bisman a Hammond there are many times for the Megillah but the limit was there's two days explicit your dollar dentist's love and there's few days you can go till your dolly an elevated base you'd give what we learned it's Monica Gila you can't go back so you there's not an option so therefore they couldn't do it they couldn't give them the Thursday before we explained the aunt recognizes a gorilla didn't give dates time drink mrs. igudala said you could read the McGill a few days earlier right as as needed if there's an issue if there's a problem you could you don't have to come and do it on your dollar the car coming with the ones who created the order the structure that we discussed it should be a Monday it should be on Thursday but there's a limit the aunt regrets a gorilla's limit was not before your Alice if it's not before you now love they can't just give you the Thursday before so therefore they have to do it on Monday so the Gomorra said why didn't this have come and give them the Thursday so the answer is they were also limited they're confined by the dates so the commerce is okay fine those I so there's basically no choice yeah you're right it's a nice thing to go Thursday before we have no choice but when we do have a choice we're gonna make life easier that's the point yeah you're right that's poor time is Monday it's gonna be a little bit of a and I want to call it a stressful day cuz put them shouldn't be a stressful day even though it is for many people which don't look - it's very stressful but it's gonna be a busier day let's put it that way in life you have to learn it's a hard thing how do you differentiate between being busy and becoming stressed it's not it's so easy right so some people for them not to be stressed they have to have no responsibilities how could you be very busy and still not be stressed that's a gong siripuram if we're drinking on Porter because of stress bad news you have to be fully in the moment if you're fully in the moment something a mother ah yeah the stress has not coming from the fact that you have responsibility stress is coming from an inner voice that's telling you how inadequate you are that's usually the case okay but we're not doing psychoanalysis right now we'll get to that MA coming here what did the mission is say holy is bahama if you doubt that other there's on Thursday funding by others Berlusconi buddy by young everybody reads that day even the villagers way the e miss if you're cunning it was right lick them Willie I'm acne sir let them do it Monday - uh sir who if you doubt us on Thursday Wednesday is it give all Tuesdays you'd based Monday is you know if let them do it Monday hey they do ever hear they do have an opportunity to help the situation they didn't say that they said to do it on Thursday what do we see from here that this whole idea is something not adding up here you have an opportunity for them to read the Megillah on Monday it's making life easier your dollar they'll be able to be open but you're telling them to read it on your dala dala they can't do it on the Monday before why cuz poem is on your dollar and it's Thursday wonderful something is not adding up the Gemara says no not he still didn't refute us me a Mac initially a Mac initially the henna we don't postponed reading the from 1y Makani sir yeah Melissa means the day that they come into the city to another year mechanism that we do not do since you download others on your Mac Anissa which is Thursday we'll go back Wednesday we can go we will do it on Thursday will not go back to Monday if it's Wednesday or Tuesday you can go back to Monday if it's Friday Shabbos is Sunday you can go back to Thursday I got no problem but if it's on a Thursday we don't go back to another Monday thinking water doesn't explain what's the logic in the ointment why not mean those come here my krisily a mechanism why not not the common felt that this would be the wrong thing to go from Thursday to Monday they'll go from Wednesday and Tuesday to Monday they'll go Friday Shabbos Sunday back to Thursday but not from a Thursday to on Monday from a yarmulke nisa we're not gonna go to another even though the dates work cuz it's gonna be your Aleph it's not gonna be a problem in terms of dates in the previous scenario the problem was the date to go from Monday to Thursday you're going to you the other but to go from Thursday to Monday you're good you dial it you'd get more your days and Monday's URL if that works but here that's why they might ask to introduce a new idea my micronesia Leah Mike listen listen what's the logic in this what's the latter the more doesn't say but the miry ah I got it but if ripken in is correct that we're trying to help Jews get food to put him and that why we want that's why we want their brethren in the villages to have a free pudding they wake up in the morning 6 o'clock all they think about is foods let's deliver the foods and off the run hoppin Minyoung em pushing in shul right getting the kids out of the house McGill and Magilla Magilla and I don't have what to wear I don't know what to wear etcetera so go shopping but I don't know what to wear in order to go shopping etc you know I had a court case I had to come to the court case irrelevant of my business what are you asking on which how long I asked in honor honestly I asked you on the mouth so let me tell you what the me Erie says the miry says that the logic is he says the caca is an expression and Gomorrah that the hakam have always tried to keep a rhythm in halakhah for the ability for people to want to just see it in a structured way in an organized way they didn't want to the Gemara as an expression latane Devorah Hamlisch Urim meaning fragmenting their words different sizes for different people because it gets confusing when your dollar is on Monday they can't go to the previous yarmulke nice so why can't I go in vision mechanism because it's your other so it's not worthy so you do it by by you so therefore they said so from your Mac so from one game occasionally won't work if it's Monday to Thursday so therefore they also said the second year Micronesia should not work which is from Thursday to Monday so there will be a uniform Aloka that if Purim is on your Mac Anissa we stick to that day if Purim is on another day and we're anyway changing now it's fine because that's consistently you always go backwards till you hit your Thursday til you hit your Monday but just like they couldn't make from Monday to go back to Thursday yeah my Christian militias are the secondary mechanism they kept in that framework your mechanisms your madness so there's a consistent tradition that is uniform that's how the media understands there's Gomorrah and therefore they will not go back from Thursday to Monday despite the fact that it would have been easier in the sense that poram would be with free it would be free the Gomorrah says no no no we're not done yet Tasha you answered the questions but there's another mission on that hey I'm gonna be you heard the aim aside this whole Holika works the Malcolm train is monster machine nearby community if there any way going into the city on Monday or Thursday so then it makes life easier but the Markov of Albemarle cover Malcolm Shane it's not super shiny but Commission curtain I sell abysmal there are villages we're not going in on Monday and Thursday maybe they don't have any disputes they get along very nicely they're wonderful people this weather sweet people it's working they're not work they're not really to the city on Monday or Thursday so then the whole hour has cancelled because it's not like they're coming in Monday and then you're forcing them to come back Tuesday are they and there were Wednesday yeah so twice a week it's very hard it's very difficult but there anyway not coming in Monday and Thursday so what's the problem so poor them they'll come in to that's what they know they're Jews you celebrate podem it's called the holiday that's what you do if Purim is on Tuesdays I would come in Monday and then again Tuesday it's very hard for people that wanted to make life easier but here you're not making life easier because they're not coming in anyway so what why not let's celebrate put them with the rest of class or why give them a separate day when it's not making in a change that's for me who does logic makes a lot of sense right which is the reason why by the way this how Locke has gone nobody reads the Megillah anymore at all of your days you'd give more why because we don't have this scenario not like you have Jews in Montana who are going and traveling to a big city on Monday and Thursday and put him you're gonna we don't just don't have this scenario today so already in days of yore this was not relevant anymore this is the idea today everybody reads the Magill on you darlin want to smoke clear practicum artery soca Dietetic on to the cross but if you really believe that this whole dispensation is Walt is or in order for the pews in the big cities to have food I'm putting some dane it's an awesome Bechet me but Commission mouths a dual across here so just because in the villages you don't go in on Monday and Thursday therefore you're gonna ruin it for all the Jews in the big cities they won't be able to prepare their meal for Purim the way it is because basically review hood is basically telling us that in some situations this whole Hollow has canceled and what happens everybody reads the Megillah on your dialog which basically means you just showed that you're not really thinking of how the Jews in the cities because of these situations they're never free on your dollars it's not like something they're never free on your dalit doesn't this demonstrate that this has nothing or at least it's not completely connected with the Jews living in the cities I mean America this scenario basically they're always doing in your dollar Dwight but even if they don't come in give them a separate give them their own border let there let's say they don't come in on Monday if there is that let them come in for the Megillah let them come in for the Megillah your dollar few days you'd get moe so your dollar they'll be free but you never do that review this says cancelled so this means that it's not about that or at least not completely about that even if it's even if it's a side benefit the beauty is not going against the Mishnah rub you hood the what have you there's a ton about if you'da is identifying if it is identifying the corner of the hama it really is just saying there's a rhythm to this tikona it's not a decree that you have to do it yet all of your days your game all of that you're allowed oh it's based on the idea that you're coming in if you're not coming and they never made this Tacoma he's not nullifying the Tacoma just saying it's not applicable the Rambam asks a question how do you say that now there's no Mitzvahed to kill our Moloch yeah and so from mitzvos every Mitzvah entire is eternal one of the 13 principles of faith is a tire has a slightly more Klaas so the REM says it's not that we're not flying the Mitzvah the circumstances are not here if the circumstances are not here why don't we bring a carbon tommy this morning it's a mitzvah you never cancel a mitzvah the answer is I need a miss babe I need him is may if I need a base on McNish I need pure kalyanam and then I have a mitzvah I don't have the circumstances to make me do the Mitzvah you understand that's what he's saying today you have to kill them all akin sighs I don't mean you I mean inside of me you have to kill your own I have to kill my own we're good at killing other people's it's a harness you know the most sometimes one said it doesn't pick a office hey Zoey barkow vicious it's Roy who's a powerful personal Congress is a says I should have said I crave it just hates it okay which means I says no okay wish the seats Roy it's very easy for me to conquer you yet so hard yeah this guy's I'm having these outlaw cover disease thyroid that makes a horace everybody conquers the other person's it's on when we went suck him I thought the avoiding of iron colony he said the first mission says uh hola boss Herbert you'll come as later on a call mahkum Shane Mike listen by comets ain't sorry petechiae right place we don't being in comedy enough Lucas comments she says what does that mean he says you boy degree you bring in comets where other people bring in comments let them be by I'll cope on him so Ben Ava this is disproven not interested they just don't it's just not part of that yeah why do you want to come in on Monday Thursday no no we're talking about places where on a regular week forget put them on a regular week they don't have this idea of coming to the city they just don't come to the city it's not part of their routine you know there's something called Sunday Costco shopping do you have the supposed to that okay so it's not part of your routine so imagine every Sunday we go to Costco right you go to the big trip to Costco a very big attraction for Jewish families Sunday afternoon okay keeps them out of the house keeps the husband harnessed etc right great outlet yes yes try it you bike in were there and you buy seltzer etc it's a wonderful experience you meet your friends you socialize and then it just doesn't count for spending time with your wife because it has to be private and alone and you have to be calm but my point is it is an outing so now imagine well have them say okay you're going Sunday every Sunday there let's put the Megillah this you don't have to do a double trip fine what if you don't have this Minich of going there so then just do it in the right time you anyway have to schlep to the city for Magilla so should I put everybody else laps why give them a dispensation so that the Kemara proofs from this if the whole idea was if it started because they wanted to give food to the people in the city's an abuser just with one marker Becky says there the whole thing is canceled no they were going for economic purposes but not regular routine visits for this or create superior Ashley says for Bezdek for both but if it didn't if there was no city near whatever whatever the issue was they didn't like the Gemara no you're right let's fix this up Lloyd a mega nation you stop go buy a mimosa and it's not about the people in the city it's about the people in the villages Laurie teh machinations aapko my mother it's interesting I did the Tacoma is not for the people in the villages for somebody else they're not they're not a means for an end they are the end in and of themselves we thought there are means for an end and I'm changing your Magilla so I should benefit because I live in the city says no that's not shots it it's a benefit it's wonderful we're happy that they get food but that's not the issue because if that was the issue then it wouldn't add up Roy came have kumihimo muslin la Monnaie chamois SAP Kim I am a Muslim I am Shiva truck you see how we changed it not in order they should give water and food it's because they give water and food and therefore we want to be sensitive to their needs we are extremely respectful and sensitive to their year-long sacrifices of slipping around and feeding the Jewish people and we want to make their lives comfortable yes they are always in a state of such a beautiful answer there it's always dedicated to their people all year around not do we do it so they should give food we do it because they give food but you see how how easy it was to misunderstand up come in he said we do it because they give fruits everyone think more instead what does that mean we do it so they should have time to give food so did you Maura says no no we do it because they give food all year so we want to accommodate them as much as we can so how do we accommodate them by minimizing the need for another trip to the city to in order to Magilla yeah we want to help them so Monday and Thursday we say do it long answers if put up is on your dollar your anyway coming fights all sighing poor them on your dollar if your anyway not coming into the city do it on your Dalit the focus is not the Jews in this city the focus is helping them the fact that the Jews in the city often benefit from the fact that they're all fun put up five extra credit doesn't they nothing wrong we're happy that other treatment huh it's also spirit essence for him that just like by Hashem you can't say Hashem is a means for an end Hashem is not a means for an end he is he is the tactless yeah drew is a helical economy mouth is also doing one drew is a means for another Jew the tactless is always in him or her itself of course through you other people benefit when your life is shining other people's light also shines but was the thing there's a whole picanha that you redefined for for somebody else it the tactless is in the person himself very good which question you mean from Monday to Thursday why cuz we did it for them and they're coming in anyway yeah I know so why not Thursday to Monday yeah and why not Thursday to Monday very good suck dicka Mara rashly says you seen a second round Dollar Man based animation mishap could sky rule ahem wishful Seamus apke Hillsong hated the anus Knutson like Udo the gabbai event can scar we're trying to help them trying to reward them with trying to to make their lives more comfortable and luxurious and here there's a there anyway not coming in you're not you're not helping them make it Monday Thursday for what that's the key Kate's at the tomorrow continues now the mission starts illustrating Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday morning now who's gonna ask a fascinating question it teaches you a lot how to think Kate's of college but Shane Eva shabbos quite admire as though this Korean boy be unruly the whole week okay what's the question now you ask Meisner Asia did naka to do today Arthur Meisner safe for the Nuggets enduring the ointment in the opening of the mission he follows the order of the month in the illustration of the Mishnah he follows the order of the week see Dorothy Erica means the order of the month Garces month Yama's days the second part of the mission he follows the order of the days and the reverse order of the month you understand the question I'll explain in the opening Mishnah he started McGill in a crass yet alle few days you'd give me your dollar that stuff that's called the order of the month eleven twelve thirteen fourteen fifteen now I would expect Cates odd you're gonna illustrate do that illustration tell me yeah when you read a good Aleph is basically with all right what would that mean it would mean start off with this scenario that gives me an explanation when they your olive flower the Mishnah does the mission starts off with Purim being Monday an important being Monday when do they read the Megillah you're Dalit the next scenario is when your dollar is Tuesday and then when they read the Megillah Monday which is you'd give up so you started with your dollars and then you went to your gimbal right right but it's opposite order why can the illustration follow the original order huh one second well let's understand it two ways how does illustration start she died at his Monday if you dollar is Monday they read on your dollars okay if it's Tuesday they read on your gimel if it's Wednesday they read on your base okay if it's Thursday they read on your dollars if it's Friday they read on your gimel if it's Shabbos they read on your base if it's Sunday oh you came in Alice strengthing amariah my snow day she did not consider the ice ax or - a for the Nuggets to do Redeemer in the opening you follow the days of the month you know it's been about this month in this safe for your father the days of the week Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Shabbos Sunday even though what do I care I have nothing against the week but actually it reverses the previous order because you start with your Dalit you go to youth Gitmo you go to youth base right you go again to your Dalit you go to your gimbal you go to your Bey's and the last one is irrelevant and actually it gets even worse because if you would have started with Sunday it would have been wonderful you would have had your Aleph right away you could have started with Sunday which is the first day of the week I'm reassured by Shabbos no you don't start Sunday you start Monday which means it's not just you're doing the reverse order you're also not starting with the week you're cutting the week you're starting Monday so in America we know you start with Monday cuz Sunday is Sunday but this is not America Sunday's work Monday huh if your dollar is Sunday so you really get out yeah I'm just adding in the cash first of all you start here in the order of the month and then you do the order of the week and the month gets reversed you go you Dollard you'd give him all your days you know now I wouldn't have a problem the Mishnah would have done that McGill and across yeah but Tesla of the adalat beard Kim will be in Vaes be an Aleph that's the question of the Gamora so the Gamora says there's a reason for this there's a rhythm the rhythm is after now people's brains work you have to know our people's brains work and that's the mission of rote understanding what we would call the nerd the neurological design of the brain I did a mishap Calleigh if you're gonna do the illustration based on the moms what's gonna happen is the days of the week are gonna have to become topsy-turvy and go in an opposite order as we'll see and you would get confused not cut cedar oedema was much better to follow the week in order meaning if I wanted to follow the original order what would the mission to look like this is what I'll have to say if your dollar is on Sunday you read the Megillah on Thursday which is your Aleph okay now I have to get to your base when when do you read the Megillah on you'd base yeah so for that put him has to be Shabbos so I said if it's Shabbos you read it on Thursday that's your base now I have to get to you'd get Moe if it's Friday you read it on Thursday which is your gimel if it's Thursday you read it on your dollars so basically the minister would be Sunday your Aleph right Shabbos you'd base Friday you'd gimel and Thursday you dollars and the brain ah what it's not bad not bad no consider to do a person would get would get confused and it also gets more complicated because you're a love for Sunday you'd base as Shabbos but your basis also one more situation when ah right Wednesday but let's say you'll do that afterwards but you're going you're going backwards so that's why the tan wanted to do the days of the week in order and that's why the second time around an illustration he doesn't mention the days of the month because if he would you would get confused that way because it goes backwards because Monday you read it you Dalit right if Purim is Tuesday you read it you'd gimel if put him is when's that you read it you'd base if put him is Sunday you really get out of so now you're going backwards in the month so that's why in the beginning he says yeah now if you baited him about this book then he follows the order of the week so that if so that you're break grains love symmetry order organization structure not going backwards and therefore in the second illustration is a B doesn't mention the month you'll figure out the month he says if put him is Monday you read it by by Y if you dial it is Tuesday you read it Monday if you doubt it is Wednesday right you mean it Monday if you doubt it's through the we did Thursday if you doubt this Friday you read it you'll already figure out the day of the month he won't mention who doesn't want to confuse you that's what the Gemara more answers in other words let's just understand a little bit let's just understand what he said if he would have done the months in if in Dilys tration he would mention days if in the illustration he would follow the order of the month meaning it all if it basis get more adult as love he would have to mention the day of the week and the day of the month right he would have to say I would have to say he would have to say that ah how would it start it would start put him is on Sunday right and then and then you're reading your Aleph now the days of the week would go opposite so would confuse him now that you follow the order of the week you don't have to mention the days of the month because you're just following the order of the week if you wouldn't follow the order of the week you would have to mention the days of the month right because you're doing sunday is your Aleph okay and I know and then you want to go your base so you can go to Monday so you have to go to Shabbos Shabbos is your base so now you're going the opposite way so they're freed now he just follows the week and he says macademian leo Micronesia you read it that day you read it the next day uh-huh uh-huh yeah if it's Friday it's in you now you can ask a simple question why don't you start with Sunday though if you want to do the days of the week start Sunday why doesn't he start the week with Sunday the Mishnah doesn't start with Sunday you just said you want the order of the week I got it so start with Sunday why and especially it's good to start with Sunday because then you get your dollar first there's the hood the reason is the reason for this near its first says is very nice if you would start with Sunday the days of the month would come out completely confused if you download a Sunday so when do they read the Megillah on your Aleph if you download is Monday when they read Magilla you're Dalit so you skipped from your Aleph to your dollar if it's Tuesday you read it on your gimel so you went from your Aleph to your Dalit to your gimel and if it's Wednesday you read it on your days in this case however when you start with Monday he doesn't mention the month but at least it's not in a confusing or it's just in an opposite order you understand Monday is your Dalit Tuesday is you'd get mo Wednesday is your days Thursday is your Dalit Fridays you'd get mo Shabbos is your base Sunday is your olive it's not confusing it's it's organized it's just in the opposite order so he doesn't mention it but if you would start with Sunday the days of the month would be your Aleph your download your get mo it base and that's why did it first says he does not he does not do that so this is interesting because you know we learned before about you know the you and how you're then hey and overhead when you teach you have to always think how it's going to be received not what you want to say but how it's going to be received you know people speak to their children people speak to their students people speak to their spouse it's not about what you stay and you it's what they hear and how they hear it and how they retain how they absorb it you know we don't focus on this so much this is considered a modern discipline but here you see the Gemara says the mission actually reverses the order and goes the opposite order why so that the weak should be able to be consistent because if not it's going to be an opposite order and the way it's absorbed is just I'm confused I just get confused if I would start with the month of your a love because it would be Sunday and then Shabbos and then it's just it's heart now it's Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday and you could make much argument yourself the mission doesn't say the days of the month that's the point because it doesn't want to confuse you at all it shifts ah right you know you'll figure out what today because he wanted he what he wants it should it should be then chand have that rhythm that consistency take a look in Rashi let's see - it's a beautiful Rashi Sidra the ark silly the alchemy is order with about the katana you're a Lafitte Mason give me adult as 12 can say dominion ahoy - great a ball of fire sure when you come to illustrate knockout say do you may I shop as the week which I'm in and you may I - lock her al-shibh of the fire so when you come - what does he mean why Sarah huh huh you know and I understand I'm just wondering okay cab all the fire so when you come to explained it not cut right say the immeubles with some min and you may have hi - la Corral and then the days of the month right our going backwards like they're going from occur they're going from the back to the front why because Holly is Arif Shabbos when you dollar is Friday for Amanda Melia Melissa so Carmela Madame Elena Lisa eraser you'd get mo collier's be Shabbos I read base Kali is after a Shabbos farm academia McKenna hired olive in other words you're following the week you're giving me Friday Shabbos and Sunday but the days of the month are now backwards because when you start Friday when you go Friday Shabbos Sunday so Friday is you'd get mo this is youth base which is backwards and Sundays you know that's the question of the Gemara so rashly answers calamar they shame on your oysters in my shop is let me say the image like this if you want it to follow the if create the order of the week based on the order of the month another few I need here an illustration of the week because we want to go through the week we want people to understand it right that's the point we want to explain it through the week but Sunday Monday Tuesday but any Feud would demand consistency because your consistency you would follow you wanted that the illustration through the of the week should also be inconsistent with the order of the month you never can lie the days of the week are gonna have to be reversed for you the tire Bagheera so sorry are showing their submission and the man who's learning and memorizing the missionary make a mistake me show you service last ski remarks on of course he's gonna have to remember and I mention it backwards meaning after a Shabbos dining at Aleph put him a Sunday so then you read your Dallas Shabbos if put him as Shabbos that's how he would have to do it and to recall information in the backward order is much more difficult and gives more room you're more prone to error Shabbos is your days Erev Shabbos is given Tomatoes car and because of that who bollard a leg of Alito's he makes skip he may miss one and he may error because like after Sunday were used to Monday after Monday we used to Tuesday not Sunday Shabbos Friday Thursday well he not good sindhu Redeemer he keeps in the order of the week but say there are Heidi Shabalala arrived are you confusing me because you're doing the month opposite Saint problem you're going from you're going from you're starting Friday so if you do Friday it's a gimbal and trapezes your days and some days of st. problem I'm not used to you'd gimbal your days at all if I'm used to you memo there's a name I ski Reba v he doesn't mention it with his mouth meaning in the illustration he doesn't mention the day of the month right he says if put him is on Shabbos you read on Thursday if put him is on Sunday you read on Thursday if put him is on Monday we're not Monday that's fine it doesn't mention that rain may a la una Sh'ma you figure it out if you say that if Pullum is on Sunday you read on Thursday right so we know what that means we understand that Thursday is your now left if Putin was on Shabbos you read on Thursday yeah we know that that is you days and the program was on a Friday you read on Thursday that's you'd get moe I get that but vain can i toast but you're not gonna error because in your mouth and your explicit mention you're not following that order that's what Rashi explains in the Gemara and we answered a moment ago why the rich verse says why we don't start on Sunday why you start on Monday because then your month becomes confused even non explicitly here the month is apse is backwards but it's not it's it's not still not explicit with but to be confused to be confusing the month at that's that's going to create much more much more disarray the next year will be Monday will resume Monday cuz I'm away in the first office what did you ask what should she say which Russia see the after the Kotani being a lesbian base be dealing with all business laws no that's how the mission what should McGill and across beard olive be he's quoting the Mishnah versus ah listen you know we live in the Internet age people used to work from sunrise till nightfall every single day we ought we all appreciate Shabbos but we don't appreciate job is the way they appreciated Shabbos I'm just telling you huh I'm saying people are still stressed but our stress today is internal much more you know the anxiety not that people don't work hard they work hard but you can't commit the time that we have no one even understands what that means right why is there no summer why is this summer vacation in America for two months three months July and August why we are wise anybody off why is it no school there's only one reason for it you know most kids in the 1800's to walk to school you walked a few miles you walk to school you stand there you walked a few miles back yeah tell that to your kid today and in the summer months summer month another issue wasn't the heat it sure was the farms needed tremendous amount of pier harvest or planting or toiling and your kids couldn't go to school that to all be in the farm that's the reason July and August you were in the farm from morning to light that's the reason so there's no school nobody knows that anymore ah no I'm out of town Monday Monday it's a modern image that basically because of the farm there's no school anymore I'm just explaining things you know we're taking off a day would take more two days we're going here for three days we're going in say that concept I'm just explaining to you so so they were extremely sensitive to the work the work days yeah you haven't brokers in Brussels they say about different things if you work for somebody and you're on top of a tree right all those things so you write because you're working from say some wasalam we hope to follow you very soon the Sundays Lecavalier saying think thank you thank you I appreciate it thank thank you thank you Fargo's on to hate them serious timers keep in touch virtually I will but it's not the same thank you a vine tonight sir he's going through the Karaka my Mac off from climber my my social a bit more he doesn't want to read the McGill Anya dollar he wants to read it on too small this class is brought to you by the achieve Annette please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot a yeshiva net / donate