Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
okay good morning everyone we're
continuing of course we're
starting okay here we
go let's say you made a mistake and you
[Music]
because
it's which one do you are you m in
you're m in the first now this is a new
thing because until now we had that if
it's and you're ding two Mar to make up
for in other words let's say you
miss
two you say both because hey it's so you
have to say or if you
missed and now you have to make it up
Friday night you'll say to shabas
because it's chabas but maybe you'll say
if I missed shabas and I'm ding toab
it's matab andab you say havah so maybe
I should say havah in both now you don't
have to say hav in both you only have to
make one hav it's not
like you say but there's no
that all the you say you have to say
it's just that you have to one time
okay let's say I wasn't M the first one
so now I'm showing that the first
one was
the also the second one will count
why I don't why am I
not enough
once it has to be mentioned in
every therefore it's in the
previous now what if I'm not in the
first and I'm ABD in the second the
first one will not count why
as we've learned many times you have to
say the obligatory one
first and by not being in the first one
he is
being that he daved the first one as a
makeup because in the first one he
didn't
say therefore he has to go make up one
for without
what if his thought
was that the first one was
for I why did he say in the second
one it was a mistake and he was
accient or maybe he'll say the reason I
was M the second was I forgot to do it
in the first one so now I'm doing the
second so that's okay
he doesn't have to go back and if you're
in both or neither you're
say but if he explicitly had in mind
that the first one should be
for even though he didn't do anything to
indicate
that it would appear as that he would
not
be
um or if he was not mdon either the
reason he doesn't have to go back is
because
saying you don't have to go back because
of lack of being
mentioning you could say
it
now now here's an
interesting what if somebody forgot to
say in ding he forgot to
say and he forgot and he ate
before again even
though that's because you could but if
you ate now before hav you would have to
D
again if you
ate which then you only have to D in the
obligatory because what you blew think
about it I D in the first one as a and
it and it would work for a provided I
don't forget an e then I di in the
second one as a then I ate eating only
disrupts the
obligatory because at the time you were
saying
the I was exempt from the obligatory
ding cuz I said it mean we know
that we know that you can only say at
the time you're saying and at the time I
was saying it was effective it just
afterwards I ate and I disrupted
it there was a that I could have
made I'm only obligated to repeat it
because he ate so then the would work
and he would have to again say
the sorry say again what
you're now to eat before
abdah and if I
do it
ruins it's
interesting that that you that saying is
provided that you don't eat but if you
eat then it ruins
the we'll get to that when we do but
that's the that is referencing yep
okay if you made a
mistake let's say a
week
two the first I'm not on the second
you should do it as
a I'm not
sure oh this is what we call the
famous and
the let's think about this what did this
guy do he didn't
D so what do we tell him to do okay DAV
a week to make up daving a week I mean
he did that already the problem is he
didn't DAV the shabas so the question is
do we view it that well he didn't D what
he's supposed to so he didn't DAV so he
didn't DAV he has to D again or do we
view it no he didn't say the for shabas
if that's the thing well he's not doing
that now so there would be no
the he's not he's not gaining anything
okay so says
the there's
here um I'm
sorry when he goes back and he do again
it
as he doesn't have to innovate anything
because what he's innovating is this way
he is according to
everyone and we're going to see the
second case of the tomorrow let's see
the there's a
famous in the name
this
is
um I don't remember the page I'm
embarrassed to
say brings in the name
of you don't have to go back because of
this you don't have to be because of
this
why he
he just
forgot and when you go back and you you
don't mention
shabas what are you gaining over
here the sages of
provance if you without mentioning it's
like you at
all because he didn't do it
properly the conclusion of
the he should go back in
as because according to according
to I don't have to D according to the I
have to soav as
a um so there's like a suff whether I
have to DAV again again say yes says no
so I'll DAV again as an just in
deference to
the I don't have to innovate
anything since the there is a that I
have to for
reasons there's no greater thaning again
to be
the but I D it as an what does that mean
as an says
I stipulate and I
say if I'm obligated to the second it
should be
for
not whenever there's you have to again
you again
as provided it's really a suff not
against the Rob him not you know there's
one that holds after
again not a a smaller opinion against a
greater
one whenever there's a real that would
be like we said earlier in
Sim that if you're if you D you DAV
again and you don't have to something
because the is that I'm being for sure
and by the way we
said in
the that you're obligated to DAV again
even though why might obligate it it's a
suff but since there remember we saw in
the that since allow you to DAV again
because even
though all day since I have that if I
don't take it up it's like
I'm
okay here is a very important factor
this weigh out that if you're if you or
if there's a whether you have to DAV
again you again as that will not work on
because you
can't how could you
make you can't bring a car so you can't
let's say you had an O and you didn't D
Saturday night
shabas so then in the Sunday morning
you're going to D
twice do you say in the second one or do
you say it in the first
one even if you make you don't say
he doesn't know
why so the
there
in explains like this one second
let's let's finish up what would you say
should you say
I would
say to say it in the first one because
even though I missed so you say
well and then
in there's no D that you have to
say the is you have to be as soon as you
can so why should you not
sayak unless they were
never past I don't know
the quotes the again let's finish the
says he doesn't know why you shouldn't
say you have to make now they're
only if it's not yet time for once it's
time for they
weren't they didn't make a makeup for
something that has rectification
it cannot be made
up says the dersu quoting the be
explaining
the who says he doesn't know his
reason that according
to your m in in the second one which is
but rer says this is what we were saying
your M only in the first one and the
bris bris also says that why this is the
S we said Hava is not part of Marv it's
not like oh the of is you have to say AB
you think you have to say because it's a
it's the first after but you didn't in
that first now your first is
and brings from the
like the
says that the the why not to say is
because now you're
to so for example by the way let's say m
shab is TSH
and I'm going to
be and so you're supposed to say let's
say I didn't
say do you say it
inak according to the no because I have
a with you only
say because it's before Hava
says if you
already and you forgot
to you don't say not in the first one or
in the second one but if you were
not like
on not
likeis but rather like the p and not
like you're m in
the and not in the first one
not like I was saying
so say you'd say in the first one again
if you if you if you were
not and the conclusion is not like
that only in
the okay we hold it over here have a
great
day have a good day
everyone recording stopped
