Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Okay,
we are live.
Barashem
took us a little a little while. Yeah,
I'm back in the old studio. That's just
what had to happen for reasons.
I'm back in the old studio
at home in my garage. This is my garage.
You don't realize that we're back here.
Better late than never. Most people
watch this on replay anyway. Usually
live a few hundred people and then over
the week another couple thousand people
usually watch it.
>> Um,
so most people aren't even going to
realize we started at 9:55. We're
supposed to start at 9:30. It's 9:55.
I'm going to make a on my orange juice.
Yum.
Okay. Um,
we had an amazing event last night at
the Soul Words House Barashem
in honor of Tuba of which is called Y
Mashidim. Special holiday uh
historically connected to the idea of
marriage, matchmaking and marriage.
Um
yeah, it was beautiful. Last night at
Sward's house, we had Sapora Grodco from
the um Stories of Hope podcast. We had
an honest discussion of Shidim. It was
Gavaldic. I don't want to give you the
link right now because then you're going
to leave this and go watch that and you
know can only do one thing at a time.
But yeah, it was pretty awesome. The
live stream is you can replay the live
stream. Um I forget what it's called.
honest discussion of or something like
that. It was really good. Anyways,
um
so that's that. Also, I want to remind
everyone that we're still in the midst
of our annual campaign. We're almost
done really. It was supposed to be over
a long time ago, but whatever. Hashem
had different plans. So, our annual
campaign is still going on, but we're
almost there. We're so close. We're
almost 90% of the way. Um, if you could
donate any amount, really literally any
amount at charity.comst,
that's charity.comst.
The link is actually in the description
of this video. So, if you're watching us
right now on YouTube, just look in the
description, click on that link. Any
amount, even a dollar, gets us closer.
Uh, and it helps us to do events like we
did last night, which was a beautiful
event, and just in general to pay for
all the technical stuff. If you guys
don't realize how much technical stuff
is involved, my gosh, it's so much more
complex than you realize. Okay. Um, and
I'll write it in the chat for the people
who are on here. Live charity.comst.
And if you donate live during the
calling show, uh, I'll read your
dedication as long as it's not um,
pornographic or blasphemous or
threatening or hate speech
or weird. Well, it could be weird, but
it has to be benign weird. It can't be
like hostile weird. Okay. Um,
that's that. And oh, I want to do one
more thing. One more thing, which is I
want to tell the Instagram people, you
know, I have like 57
something thousand followers on
Instagram. Is that crazy?
Is that crazy? Yeah, I have 573,000
followers on Instagram. That's amazing.
Okay, I'm gonna do a little something
real quick, though. Um
Uh, okay.
I'm going to go live for a second.
Uh, yeah. Okay.
All right.
All right. I'm simultaneously
the people on YouTube see me um which
call it I'm simultaneously live on
Instagram right now. Okay. Um
there's no one coming on yet
enough people are saying to join. Okay.
Uh I'm starting this live uh Instagram
because Bahasham we have 570,000
followers on Instagram, which is pretty
cool. And we want to let you know that
we're doing our live weekly Thursday
night call-in show right now on YouTube.
Okay. So, what you're going to have to
do, just YouTube people, one second. I'm
going to talk to the Instagram people.
Okay, Instagram people, what we want you
to do is go to YouTube. Okay? Um, it's
in my bio. If you care, you can go to my
bio. go to my bio and look at my YouTube
channel and go to my YouTube
and
um go to the live call-in show. Thursday
night live call-in show. Okay, I think
that's it. That's all I'm going to say.
All right.
Okay. I don't know what the point of
that was, but maybe it'll gain us a
couple more viewers. All right, I'm
going to put on my headphones.
Okay, is the phone system working?
Is the phone system?
>> Yes. Did you hear me?
>> I hear you. Yeah. All right. We have Can
you hear me?
>> Yeah, I hear you. Can you hear me?
>> We have our first caller. Yes, I hear
you.
>> Our first caller is anonymous.
Okay, great. So, should we get our first
caller on?
>> Yep. Hello. Welcome to the Thursday
calling show.
>> Hi, Rabbi. How are you,
>> Barm? I'm very good. How are you doing?
>> Good. Thanks for taking my call.
>> My pleasure. My pleasure. Okay. So, what
are we talking about tonight? I don't
even know.
>> Okay. Um, I have a question for you.
>> Okay. How does one deal with
co-parenting
with a parent who does not care about
the child's well-being
and
is
doing the opposite for the child?
>> Okay.
So,
I'm going to be uh very forthright with
you here. I'm going to skip all the
nicities.
First of all, I want to validate that
I believe
I believe what you're saying,
but I also need to give push back. Okay?
So, I I I it's not nice to start right
away with push back, but I think it's
just going to be helpful. Okay? And and
I my point here is to be helpful. Um, so
here here's my push back. You made a
statement. This is a very sweeping
statement, a very strong statement
that the co-parent not only does not
care about the child's welfare or
well-being, but quite the opposite,
which the opposite of that would not
only be they don't care, it would be
like they have some a vested interest
in, god forbid, undermining the child's
well-being. So, that's a very strong
statement. I'm not telling you I don't
believe you, but I want to push back
against that be just because
>> it's so exceedingly rare. It's not
unknown, but it is exceedingly rare for
a parent, even a parent who's not
particularly
um emotionally well. It is so ex
exceedingly rare for a parent to
actually
purposely willfully
undermine a child's well-being. So, can
I push back a little bit and let's kind
of figure out where where the truth is
because it it'll it'll just be more
helpful for you in navigating this.
>> Sure.
>> Okay.
So, do you want to adjust this statement
or do you want to double down on it and
and back it up or help me understand it?
What What do you mean the co-parent
doesn't? Yeah. Okay.
>> Um I can go with an example if that will
help.
>> Yeah, sure. That that
>> Okay. My daughter came to me with a
concern
that is a big concern and when I
addressed it with her father,
he denied it and is denying help for the
child.
>> Okay. And I'm assuming in this situation
you're talking about because people can
use the term co-parent even for a
married couple, but we're talking about
you're not married
>> to the
>> Okay. to your child's father. Okay.
So, your daughter came to you with a
concern,
>> a general concern or a specific concern
about her father,
>> a specific concern about something
happening in the home.
>> In the home, you came to him and said,
"Hey,
>> she's not okay with that." And he was
like, "What?
>> Well, that that didn't happen." Or,
"Yeah, it happened and who cares?"
>> You're lying.
>> No, you're lying. It's not true.
>> Who's lying? You lying or your
daughter's lying?
>> It was told to both of us that we're
lying.
>> You're both lying. Didn't happen.
>> Mhm.
>> Okay.
>> It didn't happen.
>> Didn't happen
based on your experience
>> with this person who I mean, you have a
child with him, so I assume you know him
somewhat. Um,
obviously you can't know with 100%
certainty, but
is this
is it consistent with this person's
history
to gaslight like that? To just flat out
deny something that everybody knows is
true?
>> Yeah.
>> Okay.
>> Yeah.
>> Yeah. So, you believe your daughter
And
>> yes, they do.
>> Yeah.
>> And you think
that
her father is just flat out
gaslighting, denying?
Well, okay,
>> that's a tough one. Okay, so that's
essentially your question, but I want to
push back and say like this.
Remember I said I I I have a hard time
accepting the original premise that the
co-parent yes
>> doesn't care for the child's well-being
or even the opposite like actually wants
them not to be well.
>> Okay, I want to put I'm I'm going to
actually still push back against that
and again for the purpose of being
helpful I want to help you here. And I
think because right now if you just say
I'm dealing with somebody who doesn't
care about their own child and and
actually has bad intentions toward their
own child, that's like so
basically it's it's an insurmountable
problem. How do you even deal with that?
You don't deal with it. The only way to
deal with it is by by not having to deal
with it. But I I want to push back and
say maybe we could reshape this
narrative a little bit um and be a
little bit more accurate. How about
this? I'm gonna throw something against
the wall and see if it sticks. Okay? And
and I'm going to trust you to guide me
>> if there's truth to this or not.
>> I would say like this knowing very very
little. I know nothing. I really know
nothing. But I'm just, you know, chat
gpting it over here and using, you know,
like, well, you know how chat GPT, it's
b it's basically predictive text, you
know, like when you do predictive text
and okay, that's how chat GPT, it's a
language model this predictive text, but
it's based on on on patterns. So, I've
been do, by the way, I've been doing it
>> be long before chat GPT was doing it.
Um, it's called pattern recognition, and
I'm 90% of the Yeah, I would say 90%
right. Um, but that's why I say if I'm
if I'm wrong, just tell me. Okay,
here's what I'm saying. Based on the
tiny tiny specks of information that
you've given me, I would like to reframe
it like this.
Your ex, your child's father,
instead of saying he doesn't care about
his child's well-being, I would like to
reframe it like this and say something a
little bit different.
There are things
that he cares about
way more than his own child's well-being
to the extent
that those things
cause him to do things
that if he were thinking straight, he
himself would be ashamed of. And and in
fact, maybe even
is ashamed of, which is why he lies
about it.
Is that possible?
>> Yes.
>> Yes. You're agreeing
>> it is possible.
>> Okay. Is it likely? Meaning to say, let
me let me explain what I mean. It's not
that he doesn't care about his
daughter's wellbeing. It's that he cares
about do whatever doing what he feels he
needs to do.
And if
having to compromise in his parenting in
order to do what he wants to do,
if that's what has to be done, then you
know, okay, when push comes to shove,
he's going to do what he wants to do.
Meaning to say, I'm trying to say it's
not like
if he had the option of doing right by
his daughter or not doing right by her,
he would willfully just pick not doing
right by his daughter. He's picking the
option of not doing right by his
daughter because he's forced to pick
that in order to get something else that
he wants which is more important to him.
Does this make sense? That's what I'm
saying.
>> It does.
>> Okay.
>> I'm still trying to figure out what that
is.
>> What that is? I I I know what it is
because it's it's 100% of the time it's
always the same thing. It's always
safety security. It's basic basic stuff.
Safety security.
That's always what it is. So, I don't
know what dysfunctional behavior he's
engaging in, which his uh brain has
decided symbolizes safety and security
to him, but that's why he's doing it.
And then you're telling him, well, you
can't do that. That's dysfunctional. You
can't do that around a child. And you
know, he's not prepared to say, you're
right. I'm going to stop that thing.
Because that would be like saying,
you're right. I'm gonna forfeit my own
safety and security.
>> Does that make sense?
>> Yes.
>> So, you know, let's say you didn't tell
me what the behavior is at all, but
let's say it's like an addiction, you
know, let's uh let's say it's like, hey,
you're using drugs in a house with a
child. Well, I didn't do it right in
front of her. I did you did it in the
next room and she knows that you're
doing I'm not saying that's what it is.
I'm not saying it's drugs, but like
let's pretend that's what it is. So, you
know, somebody could say, well, this
person doesn't care about their child's
well-being. And I would say that's an
oversimpl over oversimplification that's
not going to serve you well in the
process of strategizing what your next
move is.
>> I would say go back to the drawing
board. Instead of saying this person
doesn't care about their child's
wellbeing, say this person cares so much
about what their brain has been twisted
into thinking provides their own
well-being that that becomes paramount
to the to the extent of of thrusting
aside their concern for their child's
well-being.
>> I hear you.
>> So
>> I hear it. Is this helpful? Is this kind
of making sense?
>> It makes sense.
It just
>> it's like how do you deal with someone
like that?
>> Um
>> when there's a real issue at hand.
>> Yeah. So I mean can I ask you another
question?
>> Sure.
Is this related to what led to the
divorce?
>> No.
>> Okay.
Um,
but am I right to say that it's some
type of behavior that he feels he needs
to do and it's super important to him?
>> Yes.
>> Yeah.
Okay. I and by the way when I say that
100% of the time it's safety and
security
um because that's just the way the brain
is wired
it's it's I don't like using these terms
because a lot of these terms are uh
these secular terms are based on uh
models that I don't believe in um and
which
yeah have a have a certain
uh lack of of spiritual uality in them.
But for instance, you know the term like
the the lizard brain, right? Or lyic
system, right? Brain stem. So um yeah,
just for a disclaimer and people can
decide to not trust me or like me
anymore, but the one of the reasons I
don't like it is because it's kind of
Darwinian. And no, I someone asked me
once, do you believe in Darwin? I of
course the man existed. There. I think
they're pictures of him. But no, I'm not
into
the whole evolution thing. Yeah, you
could decide that I'm a barbarian and
you could stop listening to me and
decide that I'm stupid now. But no, I I
don't. So, I'm not when I say like
lizard brain, I don't I don't mean like
in an evolutionary type of way. But what
I do mean is
the way that people are wired. By the
way, if I would use the theidic mystical
metaphysical terminology, I would say
the nephew of Bahamas, the enlivening
animal soul. Okay? But at any rate,
there's this basic impulse for survival
and self-preservation
that's always looking for safety and
security. Now, it's a funny impulse
because it gravitates toward really
basic stuff, coarse stuff. It's not
interested in abstraction. In fact, it
can't even comprehend abstraction. So
things like spirituality or even things
like morality are completely foreign to
it because it just doesn't have the the
the ability to to grasp abstraction.
What does it grasp? Very physical
physical physical things like bodily
needs. So basically I'm going to say you
know food and sex. So basically what it
comes down to is
self-medicating or self-numbing
behaviors, addictive behaviors. So it's
basically either, you know, like
drugs,
uh, pornography, something else that's
sexually inappropriate. Those are the
types of behaviors that people get
really, really locked in on. And then
even though you come to them and be
like, "Hey, as a moral person, as a as
an adult, as a who's who's charged with
caring for a child, don't you know
that's wrong?" Like, don't you? And it's
like, well, that my thinking brain knows
that it's wrong, but I'm not in my
thinking brain right now because I'm
just trying to get safety and security.
I'm feeling I'm registering some type of
cue to um you know some cue of threat to
my survival
and um and this is what I have to do to
self soo
and now you're going to come talk to me
about morality.
I can't afford to have a discussion
about right and wrong over here. I'm
trying to survive and that's why like
when you're saying like how do you even
talk to a person like that and you're
expressing that frustration. Yeah. It's
the frustration of I'm trying to talk
about right and wrong and you're checked
out of any ability to speak about such
abstract concepts because you are in
fight or flight like live or die
absolute like you know you you're down
in that lowest most basic level of
impulse and so we can't even have a
discussion about morality and when I get
called out what am I going to do? I'm
going to lie about it. Well, it's so
stupid. Why would you lie? But like, we
all know you're lying. Yeah, but you
know what? I can't afford to have this
conversation with you. So, what am I
gonna do? I'm just gonna be impossible
and I'm going to stonewall you by lying.
I know that you know that I'm lying, but
if I can just lie and it's it's so
exhausting, you'll go away.
>> And I know if I lie long enough, you'll
just go away. You'll leave me alone. I
can go go back to my numbing behavior.
Is Is this consistent with reality? I'm
chat gpting it over here.
Um, yes.
Yes.
>> Very well said.
>> Okay. So,
so everything I'm saying is consistent
with the actual facts.
>> Mhm.
>> Okay. Um,
does looking at it this way
give you any insight about how you may
want to deal with it?
>> It gives me a new perspective of how I
how I view it, but
it's still
feels impossible to deal with someone
like that.
>> Yeah. Well, what if we were to introduce
some truth?
>> What if Okay.
>> Well, what if you were to say, "Listen,
you can tell me I'm lying. That's okay.
Um, I think you know that it's not a
lie." And and here's the thing. Um, I
don't judge you for this. I really don't
judge you. I know that you're doing what
you feel that you need to do. Um,
but here's the thing.
When your daughter is home, you're not
going to be able to do that. So, I think
you need to make a decision.
If this thing is really super important
to you, uh, to the to the extent that
you're not going to be able to refrain
from it when she's with you, then I
think you need to think about this. Make
a choice. Maybe it's more important for
you for now to do that thing than to
have your daughter with you.
And could you maybe make that
responsible as it would be very selfless
of you. It would be very selfless of
you. Maybe you'll make that decision
that you for right now are choosing your
certain behaviors, your certain I don't
know if it's a lifestyle, but um because
that's important to you and you need
that right now,
but it's not compatible with having a
child in the home. Maybe you can make a
selfless decision right now that while
you still need to engage in that
behavior, you're not going to have her
around.
Or you could decide you're going to
refrain from it when she's around. But
who are we kidding? We You and I both
know that that would be too stressful
for you. And why should you feel stress?
I don't want you to feel stressed.
>> See, I like it. I like it because it's
compassionate and it's honest.
I love, you know, they there's an
expression brutal honesty. I love gentle
honesty.
Like, let's be so real. Realer than
real, but not in a hurtful way. It's not
to the contrary. I'm trying to help you.
I know it's too painful for you to act
the way you need to act. Like, ho how
how long of a stretch is she with him
for?
>> It's not too long, but
>> a couple days. I've definitely tried
that that no hours but
>> it doesn't
>> Yeah, but it doesn't that that doesn't
work. It doesn't work with him.
>> You've tried the approach of being like,
"Listen, I don't need you to admit or
deny cuz I know the truth and I'm not
faulting you and I'm not blaming you.
I'm not even judging you. I'm just
saying this."
>> You can have a conversation with him.
It's impossible.
>> Impossible. Okay. So, he's
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I hear you. So, he's
totally locked in
>> the the survival mode.
>> Yeah. So, even even more so than I
thought cuz I was imagining he kind of
like
>> fades in and out of survival mode and
has moments. No, he's always in survival
mode.
>> No.
>> Which is why he's always lying because
he says whatever he needs to do to get
what he wants.
>> Anything. any issue that's addressed,
you're a liar. It's not true. And then
he says conversation over and that's it.
>> And it's because it's so effective. It
>> doesn't work.
>> It's so effective because he first of
all, he knows he's not fooling anybody,
but he doesn't care. He's not trying to
fool anyone. He's just trying to get you
off his back so he can continue doing
what he wants to do. And he knows that
it's so exhausting to be lied to right
to your face like that. So exhausting
that eventually you'll just stop talking
to him. And that's what he wants. That's
his goal. Just make you be quiet.
And and and he probably feels probably
feels better about that than something
like overtly hostile or or or uh
violent. You know, if if to get somebody
off my back, I'm going to have to scream
at them. You know, I'll do it right. But
this is so much more pleasant than
screaming at them. I'll just lie at them
and lie lie lie in their face until they
get tired of talking to me. And then
they'll just never talk to me again.
Good. Problem solved.
Right. But it's it's dealing with that
and then dealing with other people a
step above him such as therapists or
schools, different things that you know,
let's say we address an issue and then
they he says it's not true. So then it's
like you can't get anywhere with anyone,
>> right?
>> That's that's where the issue is.
>> I bet you everyone's super curious what
the issue is. You don't have to say if
you don't want to, but like what's the
thing that
he's doing?
>> I not going to say it on here just for
privacy purposes of my daughter and
myself.
>> Good. Respect that. Okay. Um,
>> thank you.
>> And it doesn't matter, by the way. I
mean, because we all know the the
category of things. It's it, you know,
whatever.
>> Okay.
It's unfortunate because we always want
to be able to talk with people and reach
some kind of compromise, but he's you're
saying he's not he's not capable of
that.
>> No,
>> I mean it forces you it forces you to
then sidestep him. Um,
I mean, now now now we get to the domain
where you got to call a lawyer
basically. I mean, I'm sure you do have
a lawyer if you're dealing with this
type of situation
>> because now you're talking about Yeah.
Because now you're talking about, you
know, I I would wish we could just talk
it through, but you're not ready to
talk. You don't want to talk. You find
it excruciating to talk.
So, so now, okay, fine. So, there's no
conversation.
If there if there's if there truly is no
possibility for a conversation,
>> then you're forced to just
I I I hate to say it because I just I
don't like I don't I don't like having
to function that way. But there's
someone you can't even talk to then and
comes a comes a legal matter,
>> right?
breath.
>> It's not it's not not ideal, but
>> that's kind of what you're left with.
>> Any
Yeah, I can give you a lot of physic.
First of all,
you know, your daughter is learning from
you
how to deal with difficult situations
and she knows that you're taking care of
her.
She knows that
you care about her safety and security.
Uh, and she knows that you're able to to
deal with it in a calm way even when
they're difficult situations.
That's important.
>> Mhm.
>> That's important. You know that she told
you something and you believed her and
she knows you believe her. That's super
important.
>> Yeah.
>> It is.
>> Definitely is. Especially when, you
know, I hate to say it this way because
it makes it sound like, you know, even
when you have a co-parent like this, I'm
sure you have zero desire to vilify him
in your child's eyes. I would hope so.
And if you know, you need any reminder.
Yeah. Even when a co-parent is totally
dysfunctional, you gain nothing by
vilifying that co-parent in your child's
eyes. Um, but
>> right.
>> Yeah. So, you know that.
What I will say is in a especially in a
situation where
>> you took her word over an adult. That's
very powerful
as far as you know her feeling of
connection to you.
>> An adult called her a liar and you know
that she's not.
So, I would say I'm sorry you have this
difficult
co-parenting situation, but I would also
say
I think you have a I think you're doing
a pretty great job with your daughter as
a as a as a as a mother, as a
an adult in her life who provides safety
and protection.
>> And you're doing it you're doing it
under difficult circumstances. Sorry.
>> Yeah.
>> Yeah. Extremely difficult.
>> Listen, I'm sure that many people will
gain from I I appreciate your
willingness to have this conversation uh
in a public forum. I I'm certain that
there are people who will gain from this
because as you know, I'm sure you know
there are people who deal with similar
situations.
some, you know, yes,
>> more challenging, some less challenging
than yours, but
>> I think many people will relate.
>> Yeah. And I appreciate you taking the
call and the time.
>> Of course.
>> Of course. Certainly.
>> Thank you, Rabbi.
>> Okay. All right.
>> Have a good night.
>> You too. Okay. Be well. All right.
Byebye.
Okay.
All right. I mean,
I love to be able to solve people's
problems or show them how to solve their
own problems and tie everything
with a neat bow.
Um, but yeah, that's one of these tough
situations where the challenge persists.
There's really no
Yeah. Who do I hear on the other end? Is
that you or is there another caller
waiting?
>> This is hiro. How you doing?
I just want to take a moment to let
everyone know that if they um may
benefit from the these calls or enjoy
these calls
and take a moment to subscribe to the
channel and I think you mentioned
previously about donating.
>> Yeah,
>> now is a good time to do that. Also, I
want to make a special mention and thank
you to the sponsor of our call-in system
to make it possible to have calls like
this happen. Uh 9x9,
that's 9x9.com.
Um, if anyone has any phone system needs
or um could benefit from some uh super
cool tech and uh options with their
phone lines, you could visit the website
and uh reach out regarding anything
related with uh phone systems whether
it's for a small business or anything of
the like
Yeah.
Okay.
Any any other uh
messages you want to share, you people
want to hear from you. They want to know
more about what you're into, what you
care about, what's important to you.
>> I'm on the spot now.
>> Want to share with us a message?
What do you like about the Thursday
night call-in show?
[Music]
>> Calling to the
show.
[Music]
>> Anything else?
Um, not off top of my head.
>> Okay. We have any other callers?
>> I'm not currently on the line. I'm not
sure if anyone else uh Oh, that's a
that's a good time to mention if anyone
would like to call in to the call in
show.
>> Um, if they have a question,
>> I'm going to write it in the chat.
>> That's soul words.
>> They would like to discuss.
Yeah. any any anything of the like, they
can email
[email protected].
Um, if they if people are listening to
this call and they find Rabbi Tab's
advice helpful or insightful, they can
either call in. Um,
if you don't want to do it on a public
forum, they could visit
forward.orgconultation.
Um, we have uh
options there for people to call in as
call you as well.
>> Yeah, but it's expensive. So, save your
money and just call into the callin
show.
>> Call into the call.
>> You got to call into the show.
Call the
show.
Call into the callin
show.
I don't see any new donations coming in.
I'm ready to read I'm ready to read
dedications for new donations to come to
charity.comrst.
That's charity.comst
charitywithd.comrst.
You emailed your number.
Somebody's writing in the chat.
[Music]
I don't see any emails.
>> Yes. In the meantime,
>> Yes.
>> Can you tell us a little bit about um
how we go from the three weeks, the nine
days dish above? It's like a full like
three weeks of like
um restraint or you know um I don't know
exactly how to word it and then just in
one day we go back to quote unquote
normal life like how do we take all that
we lived with the past three weeks the
nine days and then tish above itself you
know
all like it's an experience going
through it and then in one day we're
we're switching right back to normal
life like it kind of feels sudden. Is
there like what what could you tell us
about that transition or how do we take
what we grew with or learned throughout
that 3-week experience into you know
into the next day into the quote unquote
normal? Basically what you're saying is
um
we had three weeks of mourning of
grieving
the destruction of the holy temple in
Jerusalem
and that came to an end after tishaba of
which is the anniversary of the
destruction of the temple and you could
you mute yourself because I hear your
street noises in the background.
Okay, awesome.
Um,
and then you're like, "Okay, so for
three weeks we're mourning and then all
of a sudden boom, back to normal."
And not only you're back to normal, I
will
I will make your question even bigger.
We say that tuba, which is the shabas,
the 15th day of the month of of is one
of the happiest days of the year. There
were no greater holidays among the
Jewish people than the the Mishna and
Tinus
um than Yin Kipper and uh
so how do you go not only you were
saying like you're going from like this
low point all of a sudden back to
normaly but it's even more than that
it's you're going from this low point
boom to this super high point.
But ain't that always the way?
if you're going through
>> I think my question is a little bit
my question is a little bit different.
And I I think I use like the three weeks
and the nine days and as example as an
example, but I think it it also I'm I'm
asking kind of like experiences in our
lives when let's say we have a hard day
or something's going on which is
stressful like the low you're talking
about and then like it kind of it's over
in a sense like you've been through that
experience, you experienced it, you grew
from it, you learned from it, whatever
it is and then like the next day you're
kind of like it's normal. You're not in
that like grieving process or that that
you know low low time anymore. You're
out of it. It's over. It's behind you.
But it's just the next day. And like
>> Yeah, but that's like how do you
>> transition? My dear son. My dear sweet
son. That was right in the middle of
saying
>> my dear sweet
truly sunshine. Listen listen.
Yes, I understand. And you're not just
talking about the three weeks, you're
talking about life. But listen,
this is the nature of things. That's
what I was saying. Ain't that always the
way? That when you go lower, it's not
just you come back to normal.
You come to a much higher level. Why?
Why does that make sense? Because
seemingly logically it doesn't make
sense to go from one extreme to the
other extreme.
But when you understand the nature of
the low points in life, then it does
make sense. It's called urita kalia, a
descent for the sake of a posit a
subsequent
ascent. You go low in order to go high.
So it's not just, oh, I was going
through a hard time and now it's over
and it's behind me and I'm now I'm in a
normal place or even an awesome place.
No, no, no. It's not like those two
things are detached. It's one process.
It's not like, oh, I was in a low place,
now I'm in the high place. No, no, no.
It's one process. It's I went through
the low thing
in order to get to the high place. And
you know, this is what it explains that
the reason of is such a great day. It
says, okay, let me go slowly here. So in
some places it says the reason the 15th
of A is so awesome is because the moon
is full. And then the question or the
challenge to that is but every month the
moon is full.
And then the answer to the to that
question
is yeah but this is when the moon is
full after the worst day of the Jewish
year the lowest point to
the anniversary of the destruction.
So when you have a high point that comes
after a low point, it's not just
subjectively it feels greater.
It literally objectively is a higher
level because you cannot reach those
higher levels without going through
lower levels.
So the point is that when you're going
through a low point in life, a lot of
times we think to oursel, "Oh, I just
want to get out of this and have some
relief. I just want to have I just want
to have this be over. Have it be behind
me."
But the truth is, if that's all that
happens, then it would have been better
to never have gone through the low point
because all you're gaining after it's
over is that you're out of it. It's like
banging your head against the wall so
it'll so you'll feel relief when you
stop banging your head against the wall.
I got a better idea. Don't bang your
head against the wall in the first
place.
But what we're talking about is that
there are certain
levels that you can only come to through
going through pain. And if it were
avoidable, then you're then your loving
father and I'm not talking about me.
don't you know you're you love although
I do love you and I am your father but
I'm saying our our loving father Hashem
he would not put us through a challenge
that could have been avoided if there
were a challenge that we could have
avoided then we would have avoided it he
wouldn't he wouldn't put it in our life
but when we do go through a low point in
life even if it's an exceedingly
extended period of time you should know
that it's part of a process to take you
to a higher level and that when the low
part is over, it's not behind you.
You're actually bringing it with you
because that is what has put you at this
higher level. And let me try to put it
more practical.
Whatever lessons that you learn while
you're going through your hardships,
sometimes they're lessons like it's a
cognitive thing. Sometimes it's more
intuitive. It's like a sensitivity that
you gain only through going through a
hard time. But whatever it is that you
gained as far as insight, sensitivity,
knowledge,
that is something you bring with you
into the the good times. Which is why
anyone who has insight has had a hard
life. I don't know anybody who has
insight who hasn't had a hard life. And
you're going to say to me, well, how
about this?
I'll forgo having insight
and then I won't have a hard life. How
about that? I don't care about having
insight. What does that gain me? The
answer is, who said it gains you
anything? It's not for you. It's for
others.
It's not for you. It's for others. If it
were for you, how about this? Don't put
me through hell and don't give me the
insight that I gain after going through
hell. But it's not for you. It's for
others.
Hashem is turning into source of help
for others. So let me ask you like this
is if you're going through difficulties
because that is the only way to turn you
into the person who can help other
people.
Isn't Isn't that a different
proposition than saying will you go
through hell in order to
gain something personally? No. You know
what? Let's not. I'm not interested. But
if I say we need you to become something
so that other people will benefit from
you. But in order for you to come to
that level where you're going to be able
to help others, you're going to have to
go through a period of hardship.
It's a little bit different question.
Okay. Go ahead. But tell tell me
>> also what I was saying is that like the
low points have rules, you know, like
let's go back to three weeks. There's
regulation, you know, there's rules to
it. like you're guided in the path of
the low points. And if we're not talking
about the three weeks, we're talking
about experiences. The experiences are
in your face. Those low points are kind
of guiding you. Like you're have you
kind of have instructions and guidance
of the low point. My question is the
next day after that low point like you
lived it. It's over. You don't have
instructions like the moon is just full.
There's no there's nothing you're doing.
It just is the next day. It just is
good. There's no instructions. There's
no regulations like like the positive
half of like the flip side of the coin
of regulations. There's no dues. There's
no instructions. It's just it's in your
face like okay the the the regulations
the down below is over. We're now in the
past.
>> You don't get instructions
>> all of a sudden.
>> But that's what I'm saying. You said you
don't need instructions.
The going through the difficult time did
something to your brain.
>> It changed your brain.
Now when you're in the quote unquote
good days, your brain is different. You
will see things that you wouldn't have
seen before. So you don't need
instructions
to open your eyes.
>> Oh, so that's boom. That's exactly what
I was looking for. The instructions are
open your eyes. You have all the
regulations and and instructions for the
low. And then once you get out of it,
you're now instructions are it's there.
Just open your eyes like the moon. Okay,
I'll take that. Thank you.
>> You You know everything you need to
know. You were prepared for this moment.
And the preparation is what you just
finished going through.
So you don't have to Here's the thing.
And and
>> if if you're if you're
if you don't live something, you can
never really know it. Even if you learn
about it, you're just memorizing
somebody else's knowledge. So then you
need instructions typed up on a sheet
for you. But if you lived it, if you
went through that hell yourself, you
don't need any instructions typed up.
Your brain got changed. Your eyes get
got changed. Just open up your eyes and
you're going to see things differently.
you're going to see things the way that
you need to see them.
>> Okay. And how do you how do you open
your eyes and and live differently when
like the the low points is just is just
one heel step behind you? It's like
right there. Like sometimes it's hard to
like it's like harder to open your eyes
and like live with the experience you
have. It's sometimes easier to fall back
or think back to like the right behind
you that low right there. like how do
you exercise? Meaning I guess there's a
lot of like
I'll say again rules, instructions,
regulations when it comes to the low in
the in the high you're saying it's just
open your eyes to what you've just
gained the the change that happened in
your in your mind and then go with that
and and grow and and help others grow.
But like like it'd be nice to have like
a I don't know a slogan or a mindset or
kind of an instruction to like ground
you to the to the new phase and like
without having to look back at the low
and like go back into it, you know?
I'm seeing if the people in the chat
have any uh
have any insight.
Someone writes, "Learning Torah can also
make you insightful."
Yeah, sometimes you got to learn it
firsthand.
Like we say,
what are you asking? You're asking how
should you look at that period of time,
the difficult period of time?
>> It's it's it's
easier to be in the low phase because
it's like happening. It's right there.
there. It's like the the the experiences
are are more like more apparent. It's
more like in your face kind of or like
the three weeks there's actual
regulations
to the to the high. It's just a matter
of keeping your eyes open.
>> Hello.
>> Yeah.
>> Elaborate please. That's the That's the
struggle, I guess.
>> I'll elaborate. Um
I like I don't know like how to describe
it. It's more like you have an
experience which you know there's a lot
going on in the experience like the
lower exper the low experiences are like
a lot more like tangible versus the high
which is you're saying opening your eyes
it's not very tangible and like us being
people in this world it's a lot easier
to go back to the tangible going back to
like the regulations the rules the you
know the the tangible things. So yeah,
essentially you're out of that period of
of the low,
but it's so easy to think back or or go
back to the habits or the regulations,
the rules of the low. It's a lot harder
to just open your eyes and live a new,
you know, with those experiences.
You're talking about two different
things. You're talking about the habits
that perhaps you form when you're in
survival mode going through a difficult
time as opposed to the insights that
have become the second nature of your
brain. Those are two different things.
>> Yeah, that's that's
>> I'm also referring to the emotions
emotions you go through
>> emotional habits
>> like you're given three weeks of of
regulated emotions.
uh and the nine days of like okay this
is morning and yeah emotional habits
correct
like let's say I'm out the other end you
know you made it you went through the
experiences and you've grown you did you
you see the growth you had but but the
emotions the emotional emotion emotional
habits whatever however you described it
they're right there and like the new
period is kind of just like a passive
experience and for people like for being
a person in this world and being earthly
You know, passive is a lot harder than
active.
>> Yeah.
>> Like surrender. Surrender fle
is very very hard.
>> The hardest thing,
>> right?
>> Someone wrote in the chat, by the way, I
think they're talking about you. They
said, "What does he expect? Unicorns."
You have a good response for that.
>> Someone wrote, "There's a part of our
brain that only grows through hardship
and it makes it easier to handle
hardship in the future." That's an
important point by the way also
interior midsulate cortex.
So the growth and value of the hardship
is intrinsic. But what's the question?
How do I know if I surrendered or gave
up? Oh my gosh, that's deep.
You said, "Oh, you ever heard that
before?
How do I know if I surrendered or gave?"
>> Whatever. What?
>> You were talking about BL.
>> Someone said, "How do I know?"
>> Exactly. That's exactly my question.
>> How do I know if I surrendered or gave
up
>> the line,
>> right? You're saying that this next
period is just about like kind of
existing and and you know, like opening
your eyes, but how do I know if I'm
surrendering or giving up? You know,
>> someone wrote here, "It's like moving
out of your home." I realized today I
can do it in two days, but that would
suck because all of the boxes and work
>> or I can do it slowly, one hour a day
for an extended period of time.
By the way, uh Tybo wrote in the chat
that we have a caller, another caller.
Did they call in?
>> There's no one on the line yet.
>> No one on the line.
>> Once they call in, we'll uh
>> hold on a second.
Um,
[Music]
Let me just check the email real quick.
[Music]
See? Okay. So, basically
what what's your conclusion here? You
tell us wrap it up for us. Give us some
clarity.
What what should we know?
>> Um I think you I think you I think you
wrapped it up pretty good. I think you
summed it up. It's about that
experiences and not in the past, but
it's you're present now. Also, like
those regulations that were put in place
are to learn, to grow. And once it's
over, you have to open your eyes and
live those experiences, but not as lows
as highs. And the ultimate high is to go
and then teach other people as well.
>> Yes, that's beautiful. And that's what I
think the meaning of life is
in case you're wondering.
Someone's writing in the chat, please
can we discuss surrender versus giving
up or numbing the pain?
Yeah. Okay. So, can we discuss this?
What's the difference between surrender
versus giving up?
Okay.
So, uh,
here's how I see it.
Surrender is when you are prepared
to accept the reality without any
buffers,
without any escape,
without any numbness.
You're just going to be fully present
even if it's excruciating.
That's surrender. Because basically it's
saying, God, I'm not going to try to
edit this reality. I'm going to be just
completely present and lucid in whatever
reality you choose to create.
And it can be very painful.
Giving up is h
cares.
Reality isn't that important anyway. You
know what? I'm just going to go back to
my dysfunctional coping mechanisms
and uh got to do, you know, like the
previous caller where she was talking
about her co-parent who's basically just
in survival mode and constantly just
doing what he wants to do and lying
about it so that he can continue doing
it. That's called giving up. Giving up
is like I'm going to be a slave to my
survival impulses
and that's it.
I don't care.
Yeah.
Do we have this next caller on the line
yet? So when we say I'm reading the
comments. So when we say
how does that fit in with surrender
I don't know does it
does it say
we say toem
open up your hands
or you actually saying it as a
description
you open up your hands hashem
He opens up his hands and satiates
every living thing
with its desires.
Now, how does that fit in with
surrender?
Um,
yeah. Well, part of surrender is
realizing that this is true, that Hashem
is taking care of every living thing.
And if Hashem is taking care of every
living thing, what are you straining so
much for?
Let him take care of every living thing,
including you.
[Music]
One second. I'm checking the donations.
Okay.
So,
one of them is anonymous. $9 doubled to
be 18. Everything's matched.
Anonymous. No message, but for $9
effectively 18. No, hold on. There's one
before that even. Nathan Lax, I saw you
first on Instagram reels and I'm excited
to see more. Thank you. Anonymous
then. Oh, hold there's another N. Yeah.
Yeah. Okay, fine. All right, cool.
And then there's an anonymous
gave to the for the cats
team.
$7
doubled
V14.
Fantastic.
All right.
If that other caller didn't call in yet,
I don't think we should wait around
anymore.
Tired, too.
>> Uh, we have our next caller.
>> Oh, we do. Great.
Hello.
>> They're on the line right now. Welcome
to the call, Joe.
>> Yes. Hello.
>> Hello.
>> Yeah, you're on the air. How are you
doing?
>> Oh, great.
>> Fantastic. Okay,
so what are we talking about?
Okay. Um, so I saw your post and I was
just wondering about, you know,
stepparenting and if you had any words
of wisdom
that you could bestow upon me
uh, regarding that.
>> Okay. So, you ever seen this show called
The Brady Bunch?
>> No, but I have heard of it.
>> Yeah. Yeah. Well, I was going to say to
you, it's not like that.
So, you don't have to
[Laughter]
anyways.
Is is is there a specific thing about
stepparenting or just in general the
challenges of stepparenting?
Um,
well, one specific thing is like, you
know, loving a person, another person's
child, but just always feeling like
you're on the outside, you know, because
you're not like the real parent, but you
do wind up becoming a parent, you know,
like completely.
>> Yeah.
>> But it's just kind of isolating and very
challenging in that aspect.
So, I'm going to tell you something, and
if it doesn't resonate with you, I want
you to completely just reject it. You
don't have to grapple with accepting
what I'm saying. If it doesn't fit, then
just send it right back.
>> Okay.
Here are my thoughts about
stepparenting. I think that
stepparenting in today's day and age has
become inordinately difficult because of
an expectation that's been placed on
stepparents. And it's fairly common. I
mean there are enough
remarages today, second marriages where
happens pretty often. You have a
stepparent type situation, right?
I think today's day and age,
>> I don't know how long it's been this
way, but you know, I'm 51 and I think
certainly like most of my life, I've
seen this and I've seen it growing and
growing. They they whose they I don't
know society created this message of
like
where this unreasonable expectation
that you're supposed to have the exact
level of relationship with your
stepchild as with your own child. And I
think that sets people up for failure.
And really great stepparents who are
really devoted end up feeling like
failures because they can't live up to
what a parent is able to do. And and and
I I just want to like explain that a
little more.
>> A parent is given a special superhuman
ability from God to take care of their
child. It's a special thing that a
parent has for a child.
Now a stepparent can be a very important
figure in a stepchild's life. They can
be a mentor, a guide, a protector. Um
they can be you know like like having I
don't want to minimize it by saying like
a really important teacher who changed
your life because it's more than you
know a teacher. A teacher you might have
for one year and this is someone who's
in in your life for many years you know
or for the rest of your life. But what
I'm saying is I think we do a disservice
by just telling a stepparent be a
parent. It's a different role. It's not
the same as a parent.
>> It's a loving
>> adult in a child's life who can meet a
lot of that child's emotional needs. But
at the same time, there has to be some
recognition that there's certain things
that just you can't do because it's not
your own child.
And
>> right,
>> you know,
I've seen that stepparents who
have the humility to recognize that
limitation
end up feeling a lot
a lot better about their role as
stepparents and having better
relationships with their stepchildren.
So, I don't know if that resonates with
you at all, but you know,
I definitely think that it's it's a if
if you com if you compare yourself to a
regular parent, you're you're doing
yourself a disservice. It's a different
category. It's a different type of
relationship.
>> Like,
>> yeah, you know, I that does resonate.
>> It does. Okay. And and what it means is
like you can look at your role as a
stepparent and like you know you're a
person I'm sure who you work on yourself
and you try to grow and you try to be
better every day. So you can look at
yourself as a steparent and say how can
I be a better stepparent today
>> than yesterday. Like what can I do
>> to provide
>> more guidance, more love, more
support for this for this child.
But that's very different than holding
yourself
to the standard of of feeling the lack
that
let me let me put it like this.
You cannot be a substitute parent.
There's something that your stepchild
can only get from their own parents that
you cannot fill. And it's wrong to
expect you to fill it.
>> What you can be, yes, you're agreeing
with that. What you can be as a
supplement,
>> a supplement you can add to your
stepchild's life. You can enrich their
life, but a supplement, not a
substitute. You're not replacing their
parent,
>> right?
Yes, I I agree with that because it's
impossible to replace
someone like that, you know.
>> That's right.
You only have one mother.
>> Um,
>> and by the way, there are cases where,
let's say, a parent is dysfunctional,
god forbid, and where the steparent
is way more
helpful to the child than the actual
parent. There are many cases like that.
And yet you still can't compare the two.
They're fundamentally different roles,
>> right?
>> Yeah.
Yes. I agree.
Yeah. Yeah. It's uh the expectation to
fill those shoes is pretty impossible.
>> It's impossible, right? And when you try
to do something that's impossible,
eventually you just give up
>> and then you don't even do what's
possible,
>> right? Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Maybe. Uh
I think uh what some people say is, you
know, like the love that you have for
your biological children is
>> different than the love that you have
for your stepchildren, but they're both
unique and special in their own ways.
And I can say that that is true.
>> And you know,
it's not wrong.
>> No, it's a reality.
Yeah,
>> thank you.
>> All right. I'm glad that that helps.
>> But yes, it does. Thank you very much.
>> Hey, my pleasure. Thanks for calling in.
All right.
>> Yeah, no problem.
>> Okay, that was a nice call. Byebye. I'm
going to read a uh dedication here. We
just had a uh another Oh, actually two
donations. Another anonymous donation,
$5 doubled for 10. And then we have
another anonymous,
$36 doubled for 72
with a comment which I'm going to read.
Barak Hashem, Mashiach. Now,
I can definitely get behind that. It
says BH, which I'm assuming is Barak
Hashem. Mashiach now. All caps now
exclamation point.
I can agree with that. We want Mashiah
now.
Okay.
Um
second
[Music]
Yeah,
I'm going to take a look at the chat.
Call into the calling show.
You got to call into the calling show.
Call into the call in show.
Call into the show.
[Music]
I'm looking in the chat right now.
Any more callers coming in?
[Music]
to the calling show.
[Music]
Uh, we have another caller on the line.
>> All right. Hello, caller. You're live on
the air.
Hi Ra.
>> Yes.
>> Yeah.
>> Yeah. Hi, this is Manakum speaking. Uh
but I prefer to stay anonymous. Okay.
>> So just a few quick questions and I just
have to jump off the call.
>> Yes.
>> I firstly I would like to thank you very
much. Am I coming through clear?
>> Yes, we hear you loud and clear.
>> Okay. So I think you know who I am and I
know who you are.
>> Yes. But uh just for the public, we're
going to keep this uh anonymous.
>> No problem.
>> Um quick question. Um Okay, good. Um
regarding tuba of which is Shabas.
>> Yes.
>> So do you mind you could probably do a
better job than me. What's what's what's
the history brought on Mishnice and
Tinus that the women of your Shalim
would dance in the fields in white
>> and the boys would come and check them
out.
>> Yes. So like just I just want to first
just establish that briefly.
>> Okay. So you are correctly
uh conveying what is described in the
Mishna as you also cited the source
correctly the Mishna and Tinus that the
Benoyalim
the daughters of Jerusalem used to head
out into the vineyards dressed in white
and uh it was sort of like a pageant of
sorts
and these were single girls and then the
single guys would come and sort
check them out and then the girls would
have an opportunity to sort of pitch
themselves and it's described in the in
the Gumra
that those who were beautiful would
try to emphasize that aspect. They'd say
marry us for our beauty and those who
were from illustrious lineage would sell
that.
Uh and then those who didn't have either
of those qualities would appeal to the
altruism of the young men and say,
"Marry us for the sake of heaven. Marry
us for the for the mitzvah."
Um yeah. So that was the scene. I don't
know historically when that stopped.
Although if anybody tried it today, I
think they would have uh I don't know
how Manakim, how do you think that would
go over if somebody would just open up
the Mishna and follow
>> Right. That's I was wondering that that
that's that's exactly what I was leading
to. That's exactly what I was leading
to. You literally took the words out of
my mouth or
>> Yeah.
>> Work them out. Took them Yeah.
>> Right. Um, if someone did that today,
like everyone meet up at uh, let's say
in Crown Heights, give me an example, or
in somewhere in Chicago or somewhere,
let's say in the Van Horn Park on
Westbury in Montreal, Canada. Okay, call
them old single buck and and and uh, and
seminary girls and age 18 and up,
>> right?
>> You know, come hang out, barbecue
tonight, blah blah blah, and on a tuba
of
>> speed dating. It's basically a speed
dating. It is a speed dating. Yeah, it's
it is it's a speed dating. It's a
singles event
>> and I think you could get away with
doing it for people from a secular
background, but if you did this for like
the religious community, I think you
would be shut down pretty quickly.
>> So, I believe it's it's it's yeah, I
think they it's very popular. They call
it
tuba of white white party and and no
white party. Did he
>> I'm sorry I forgot I don't know the
exact uh word for
>> Sean Puffy parties. Those are that has a
very I don't know maybe the Kabad houses
did tuba of white parties but they're
definitely not doing white parties
anymore. Pdy his his beckanalians were
called white parties. So I think that
name was spoiled.
>> Call again could be I have the name
wrong but I believe Kabad also do
something in honor of Tuba of where the
men and women young men and women
>> like the YJP programs young Jewish
professionals you know.
>> Yeah.
>> Yeah. But if you did this let's say for
yeshiva and seminary girls
>> you'd be shut down.
>> Yeah. It wouldn't go down.
>> It would not go down.
>> Yeah.
>> Right.
>> Yeah. So, so I'm just wondering like
like what's what's up with that?
>> I don't know that
>> seemingly this is this is based this is
based in and furthermore what's
interesting is and this is an
interesting thing. It seems like what
you based on what you said that the
woman would approach the boys and not
not vice versa. I always understood that
the boy has to ask the men the woman out
the girl out
>> right. Yeah. It's interesting. the girl
would
she would uh I guess I don't want to say
make the first move because that might
sound crass but she would initiate.
Yeah.
>> I just that was very fascinating. Yeah.
Obviously there's other details why the
vineyard why specifically the vineyard.
>> Yeah. So you want to try to revive this
>> you want to try to revive this customer.
No, no, no. I'm not going I'm not I'm
not I'm not going there. I have enough
on my plate.
>> Yeah. Yeah. Enough going on. Yeah. It
would be interesting to find out
historically when the last time is that
that was done.
>> Yeah. I was thinking maybe your brother
David can make a rabbit hole on this. He
he would uh
>> he would do well with that and he
probably could find out with his
research team when the practice
>> um fell out of
>> Yeah. popularity.
>> Yeah.
>> Yeah. Yeah. It's interesting. It's I
just I find it fascinating how, you
know, culture shifts and things, you
know.
>> Yeah.
>> Things change.
>> What was normal then today would be
would be like it would be who knows
what.
>> I just can't even imagine if I made a
fake fly on chat GPT and I put it out on
WhatsApp. It wouldn't go down very well.
>> Yeah. Things change. Like could you
imagine if you started a restaurant in
Brooklyn where you where you sold kouta
khabavi?
>> What's that?
>> Kouta khabavi is one of the most
scrumptious
um talmudic snacks.
Kut kabavei is breadcrumbs and cream and
salt and it was really popular in
Tamuric times and it's probably someone
could Google this but it probably
appears in shas like a hundred times.
Kutabi comes up all the time but nobody
eats that anymore.
>> So I'm saying you know things culturally
uh change they evolve. If you tried to
sell quit the kabavei today, nobody
would really,
>> no pun intended.
>> No, maybe there are very good in these
things. They they could maybe revive it,
you know, package it.
>> Mhm.
>> Maybe we could pitch it to them.
>> It's interesting. Do you think do you
think um how did it go down on Chabas?
Shab like what? Tuba like
>> Oh, and when Tuba fell on Shabas
>> Friday night.
>> Yeah.
There's nothing about that ritual I can
think of that would be problematic on
Shabas.
He's just dancing around in a field.
>> So maybe maybe it's time to revive it or
you get up again.
>> I certainly I don't want to do it cuz
you know, who knows? Who knows? Maybe
there's a good reason why it
>> but I know I know I know at s I know at
soulwords.org/tuba05785
you're accepting names up until chabas.
>> Yes to be for names of singles people
can submit names of singles uh to be
brought to the oil in honor of
>> right
>> so I was wondering maybe you had you
have names maybe you could even start
getting into the sham business.
>> That's interesting. Like it's a good
idea to bring names to the Reb, but but
maybe you could start
matching names to like I don't know how
you would do it because you're not
really taking any other you're not
taking resumes.
>> No,
>> but maybe maybe that could you know,
>> right? I don't have any other
information names.
>> You mean do do you do you do have you
done?
>> I attempted like making a few times. I
never successfully made a shiddok.
Um
I don't know. I don't I don't know if
that's it's Can I tell you something
interesting?
Can I tell you? Okay. There's a mimer
from the alter
which
explains the gum in uh about
40 days before conception. the um the
bos the heavenly voice proclaims this
girl is going to marry this boy. Okay.
So, and it says that um it's
like the the miraculous splitting of the
sea. Okay. That's what it says in the
soba
meaning the balata the firstbad says
being that this whole thing is
proclaimed in heaven. It's like this
miraculous supernatural thing.
It's very hard to make it work on earth.
I'm not talking about marriage. I'm not
talking about shambias yet. I'm talking
about just getting them together, you
know, getting them to meet and and agree
to to get married. It doesn't follow the
normal rules because it's it's from a
it's from a heavenly plane. It's from,
you know, another level of reality.
So he says because of that the only way
to make it happen down here is you have
to sort of break the rules
and he says that's why every successful
match has some aspect of falsehood in it
and doesn't say this but in other places
maybe you've heard this it says that
shad the matchmaker is have you ever
heard this shad is an acronym
Yeah,
no something.
>> Yeah,
>> speaks falsehood
and he collects money. But the alter
says that it's actually unavoidable.
There has to be some deceit in every
successful. Now, what does that mean?
Because there's a prohibition in Torah
against misleading people, dece
deceiving people. It's called genevas
das. literally stealing someone's mind.
>> Someone someone has if someone is
struggling someone is struggling with
something I assume at some point you got
to be honest if they're a girl into into
marrying you.
>> Yeah.
>> Right. Or if somebody has uh some type
of a struggle or an issue they're
dealing with, it doesn't mean that
they're not good marriage material, but
there has to be disclosure, right? That
the other party has a right to know what
they're getting into. So when we say
that
>> has to be a right match,
>> right? So we're not saying that you lie
about important information.
I believe what it means is this.
Um actually I was the other day at the
Soulwards house. I was speaking to Rifka
Krinsky because uh Rifka and were doing
their uh from what it was called from
the inside out podcast at Soul Word
Studios and she was going to a singles
event in Muny I think it was she was
speaking she asked me what to speak
about and I gave her a couple ideas
which I I don't know what she ended up
speaking about. By the way, did you get
the diapers? I gave Mrs. Krinsky the
diapers to she lives on Carol Street and
you lives on Carol Street so she brought
the diapers in her purse. So you just
let me know if you got the diapers from
Mrs. Krinsky and if you didn't please go
pick them up from her. Um
what was I going to say? So
what we were talking about the
the deceit the misleading the
>> diapers should
>> the diapers. No no no it's a separate
thing.
My My son needed diapers. My son needed
diapers for his baby.
>> And so I had to drove halfway
>> to pick up from my wife.
>> My wife met me in the parking lot of the
Lens Crafters. Listen, this is
important. My wife met me in the parking
lot of the Lens Crafters on on uh
Sunrise Highway and then I brought the
diapers to the Soulwards house and then
you saw forgot them and I gave them to
Rifkrinsky to bring to Crown Heights.
She was first had to go to to go to my
for a single event. She was speaking
there. What were how did I get on there?
I was speaking to her
and Oh, right. So, she you know that
she's a she's a shan.
>> Yeah.
>> Yeah. Okay. So,
um I I was saying to her that you know
suggesting matches is easy.
any
anyone can uh suggest a match.
What a shad really gets paid for and
what takes skill and what very few are
able to do is close a deal.
It's very hard to close a deal.
>> And in order to close the deal, there is
definitely massaging of the truth that
goes on. And what I mean by this is
again not lying to people about
facts about who they're marrying because
that would be terrible to mislead
someone to get married to someone under
false pretenses. But what it does mean
is sometimes after a date the shad calls
the guy calls the girl and they give the
report
and the shad doesn't exactly accurately
convey how the other side felt because
the shadan's trying to push things in a
certain direction sometimes to create
some tension to keep things interesting
to keep it going like suggesting oh you
know maybe you need to push more this
way And or sometimes Shan realizes, hold
on, the opposite. You know, you got to
step back. You're coming on too strong.
So Shanhan will like say things that are
not 100%
true to like
get the right
emotional
mix going on that will
get things what would be an what would
be an example? So instead of saying
>> like instead the guy is to say the guy
is six is six foot and he's really 5'11.
>> No, no, no. What I'm saying is they went
out. She calls the guy. She calls the
girl. He says, "Ah, whatever. She's
nice, but it wasn't so exciting."
Now, she doesn't Shodgun doesn't
necessarily have to tell that exact. Of
course, she's not going to say that. And
not just because it's impolite, but
because that would kind of kill the
deal. What you do is you try to like
keep the both parties interested and you
tell her, you know, he said that he
really liked it when you did such and
such. Maybe he didn't even say that, but
it's just a way of creating
more engagement. And then in the end,
obviously, you know, they've got to make
the decision whether they want to get
married. But what I'm saying is a shad
will massage the truth about how each
party was speaking about their
experience on the dates in order to get
it to a to close the deal.
>> That's what I believe it means.
>> Yeah.
>> Okay. Now, you asked me originally, do
am I into making? So, here's what I'm
going to tell you. That was my very long
way of explaining to you why. No, I'm
not into it and I don't think I would
ever be good at it.
You know me, like you said at the
beginning of the call, you know who I am
and I know who you are. You know me. I
have certain strengths and I have
certain weaknesses.
I don't know if you call this a strength
or a weakness. I don't know which
category it's in, but I'm very blunt and
very honest. By the way, that's why I
don't like when people call me for
shiddok references because I I will
always tell the truth and
People are so scared to tell the truth
with the reference. They always
assume that it's way worse than what I'm
saying because
what most people do is they take an
issue and they like minimize it and
that's what they tell you. But I do the
opposite. I I just say it the way it is
and then people assume they have to like
multiply it by 10 in order to get the
truth. You know, it's like if you see an
article that says that the the Kabad
House had an event, there were 100
people. So, you know, it means there
were 60 people. That's the math, right?
>> So, okay. Um,
I So, I am not good at playing with
truth. I'm so blunt. That's why I don't
think I could be a good Sean.
>> Well, maybe. Yeah. All right. I hear
that.
I hear that.
We're not sure why to practice anymore.
Okay, listen. You got the names. You got
names and uh you're going to go before
Shabas.
>> Yeah, we'll take the names in. We have
like a Google doc of the names. We'll
bring them in and you know
>> we'll see some uh
>> soulwords.org org.org.
>> Yeah.
>> Tuba 5785.
>> That's correct. So,
>> yeah. And then I guess people people
could go and then people could also
submit their names and resume to maybe
to Rainsky.
>> Yeah.
>> She has uh you got to do
>> you got to do your list. That is
correct.
>> Her website is is
>> Do you know
>> her website is one soul.org.
One soul o neol.org.
Yeah, I know. I just checked it up now.
>> I Google the name pretty quick.
>> Okay.
>> Okay. Well, thank you very much. Thank
you for taking my call.
>> My pleasure.
>> Good news.
>> Oh, man. Okay. Be well.
>> Yeah.
>> Okay. That was a great call. I really
had fun with that. I'm just checking the
donations. We have Rob Rom for the Cats
team. $9 doubled to
18. Thank you, Rob Ram
for the Cats team.
Okay,
I'm getting tired. Can I tell you?
Yeah.
[Music]
I think we're done. I think we did a
good job.
I'm really tired.
We're going to do this, God willing,
next week.