0:00 / 0:00
Live streaming of TLPS !
13 views
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
for the sake of like doing videos, you
know, live streams like the computer
capacity. I also edit on my phone. Why
is it so thick? It's thicker than the
S20. It has a lot of uh it's one
terabyte that it's carrying. That's so I
mean I don't know if that's the reason.
I think all these phones anyway.
Is this a paid Apple app? No, not at
all. It's also Samsung. Oh, you're
[Music]
saying yeah,
it's actually if I were to advertise for
any phone company, it would be LG, but
they stopped making phones.
I was an LG fan till until they were
like, "We're not supporting our phones
anymore." LG
Black is good. I don't even know if I'm
in the frame here. I hope there was a
company called like uh Huawei or
something like that, you know? Uh, it
was a um not sure which country was it
from, but they stopped selling them in
America. They used to Oh, yeah. They
were so good and cheap. Yeah, they were
really good and cheap. I I probably just
judged it by its name and I was like,
there's no way that that's a good phone,
right? That's why that's why they sold
it for so cheap because I don't I don't
know exactly the reasons why, but they
they were doing something illegal. They
were collecting information. It's the
Chinese Communist Party was collecting
information. Oh, that was that was
together that company. Yeah.
Interesting. This is the Chinese
company. So that you're saying that they
basically were like um giving expensive
phones out of their pocket in order to
because your information has value,
right? Gotcha.
Most valuable thing is your uh your
attention. So however they know the more
they know value, the more they know how
to get your attention, right?
And then they invented Tik Tok.
Tik Tok's gone. had the page. Tik Tok's
over by the way until the news day that
uh in order to bring it back there Trump
was talking to the Chinese government
and it's over. They're not going to
bring it back. He were not even buying
it or anything like that. They wanted to
make a deal in order to bring it back.
The Chinese government said no. They
said no algorithm is I mean I think
overall it did more damage than good to
them. Well, to us. Yeah. To us that's
good for them. Like I mean it it like
anything it's a tool that could be used
for goodness but like there was an
overwhelming amount of like garbage on
there. That's true. Also X I've noticed
I I'm not I'm not on X but I I've found
out that X is actually also pornographic
sites. Did you know that? I didn't know
that. Yeah, there's lots of porn too.
But X is Twitter. Yeah. They have the
most lenient uh guidelines.
He's saying you could post images and
video on Twitter. They don't take it
down. Yeah. So like
interesting. Um I want to get a
[Music]
reference. So
we don't need a we need. So
there. That's neat. Except um this is
missing something. We'll see. This
doesn't besides we don't say hey mana in
the Anyways, but to finish this
um unlikely but um but maybe I'll give
you enough of the taste if you want to
continue on your own. Maybe we'll
continue
together. So yeah.
Ready? Let's do it.
So this document may not be harmful for
your device. Make sure you trust the
ender. You ready? You can trust me.
Okay. It's known
as the following. So there's a
difference between there's there's on
the night of PES to tell the
story. There's a mitzvah every single
day to remember.
So there's a known difference between
these two obligations, right? You have
the obligation every day and then you
have the once um a year obligation and
the
nightly one of the differences is
that all year a reference uh just to
remember it to a simple reminder is
sufficient.
mitzvah is to
remember is the
mitzvah and on the night of pes the
mitzvah is to tell the story
of right like the
[Music]
says in the language of the raam it's a
mitzvah it's a positive commandment of
the to tell the story of the miracles
that were done for our forefathers
in. Okay.
Since the telling of the
story is a great foundation and a a
strong pillar in
our our faith uh mitzvah I'll say and
many mitzvah are connected with this
zira say both mitzvah say mit
That's why we say we're we're making
references to it all the time. This is a
remembrance to like we say
it's a fundamental thing in our in our
life. Yeah. So is understood as
in that in the telling of the story on
the night of
Pesra is also brought out elaborated on
meaning somehow it has to be contained
in the in the telling meaning if it's
included in the point then when you
expand on it surely that feature is also
um brought
out right
is that how this is a great foundation
and a solid strong pillar in our
etc.
lengthen
up the mitzvah of telling the story we
learn from
the you shall tell it to your son is the
mitzvah for this is the mitzvah of
saying
the the section of in the on
night since
um
the the the um where you see the the
revelation of a a point that you're
trying to make, right? You're let's say
you're in any what's the structure of
any good essay, right? In the beginning,
you um there's a you introduce your
topic and in your conclusion, you sum up
what you said, right? So there's in the
beginning of something and in the end of
something you find an emphasis on what
the main point of the uh of the whole
structure is right. So his movement is
understood
as that in the telling of the story how
this thing is a
fundamental foundational concept.
So we'll we'll see how in the beginning
and in the end of the structure as it
was um uh instituted by the that
everyone should say this this text this
articulation we'll see how in the
beginning and the end it brings out this
uh concept how this is a fundamental
um concept from the beginning of
Yes.
So,
yeah. So the Mishna says that there's a
there's a that that the way in which we
structure the story is
that we start we start with with the um
the something derogatory something
derogatory right where we started out
from where we're coming from and we end
on a high note we end with the with with
praise with um with telling the um with
the the highlight the the the you see
it. Yeah, I'm being freed.
So,
just be careful. Don't push it, okay?
Cuz it's a camera. Please don't stay
here. So, in the beginning, right, we
talked about how we were
slaves. In the beginning, our
forefathers served idols.
And then later we say the the section of
the the
uh conclusion of the concept
of the story of
love. Okay. So we'll see how that all
plays
out. Furthermore,
um uh so according to the the text of
the which is the which is this this is
the custom that our that we have been
accustomed to from the earliest
generations. We start before everything
we say
which we say right at the beginning and
before right is where you start asking
questions right that's the that's the
that is what um kicks off the whole
process right so even before saying we
say see how even in the in the in the
beginning there is it is emphasized of
the book of not not just the section of
but even the very beginning of the whole
procedure of the you see
yeah in the same way in the in the
conclusion about the miracles and
wonders that did for us at that
time the part where we say how many
great things did um did Hashem do for
us? Which concludes with right the last
the last clause in that it lists a whole
bunch of things. I think it lists 15
things and the last thing it
says he built for us the house of which
is to atone for all of our sins.
Hagada to understand the general
concept of the Hagada and the telling of
the
story, we have to first before before we
can see the whole structure and how it
plays out um how this point is um is
brought out in the structure of the
story, we have to uh zoom in on some uh
particularities in the um in the
different in the sections that we
mentioned. Okay, start.
We need to see how it all comes
together. We need to zoom into each
detail. Umbrella. We need an umbrella.
But is that your umbrella? Well, we need
an umbrella. This
is my umbrella, so I can't give it to
you. I'm sorry. We're going to the park,
huh? How are you? Good to see you.
Shalom. Is going to take you in here?
No, I don't think so. I don't think so.
Okay. I haven't forgotten to get you
that number. By the way, I don't have
it. I thought I had it in my phone.
Okay. I'm going to just strap up, read,
coffee, and chat. I mean, we'll
Yeah, interrupt. Okay.
This is the bread of affliction that our
forefathers ate in the land
of this
section, right? You'll find it under the
header of mag in your text. You'll find
a section and the header will say
and why am I thinking that that's the
beginning? Because it's what's the very
beginning of the Well, we'll see. We'll
see how
really we don't say really. It's not
really the It's not really mag. It's an
introduction to mag.
It's not part of the previous section.
Well, for some reason, I thought that
this is that before kibish, you invite
everybody.
Must be confusing me. That's that's one
of the questions that the rep is going
to address. Oh, why don't you do it
before kittish? Yeah, let's go. Um,
that's one of the famous questions that
meaning it's it's odd to say once you're
already sitting down, you already made
kish, right? You already did a bunch of
steps of now. Now you're
saying it, right?
Right. Yeah. So the so Okay. Okay. So
you find under the header of
magic understood
as that you're familiar with this kind
of Yeah.
that since we say this section the
beginning of the
is it can't be that the reason for
saying this is to is only to invite to
the seder table those who don't have
what they require for the the the meal
for the
and we should have said it before we
started the
seder right when coming up for sure
before we come home for sure. Sorry
other not fear even
before right go say anyone needs
something for the You have what you need
for
[Music]
besides in the first column in the
middle as
we're asking why we like make the
invitation that anybody should come join
the sed when we're already in middle of
the sed we're up to the section of so
we're
after coming and we're like anybody who
wants to join the sther can come is like
we should have done this in So
yeah say anyone who
needs meaning it includes also someone
who you would have to provide with the
kis he doesn't need that's one that's a
fundamental thing and you already are
past one of
them but starting from the
first
is so it has to be that this saying this
section is uh
primarily a introduction to the telling
the story
of that's why it comes immediately after
the header that
says it's not
understood what is the connection of all
uh three things well I assume that's
where he's going to say
um in the in the section of
um in the in
the okay which which relates to the the
telling
story
uh this is not telling us anything about
the going out
of right it's not telling us anything
about leaving and we want to see how
this is an inali how it's how it relates
to general concept right this is a
particular which start which is telling
us something about what happened in the
shrine it's telling us the the the the
um derogator like telling us about the
it's reminding us of the hardship of
painful in the past. Yeah. B second
thing we say now we are here now we are
slaves
is right. We're emphasizing how now
we're in a state of well not really
because the end of that sentence is
but that's that's now that's in the
future.
Right. But I'm saying if I start if I
want to tell you if I want to emphasize
like a success story to you. So I start
with the failure or with the problem and
then I bring it to let's let's see it's
climax. Let's uh yeah I hear you. Let's
see.
Meaning the point is this is emphasizing
the situation of Galos and Abdina were
slaves.
which is the which is the opposite
of telling the story of which right
right which is what we're supposed to do
by now it's coming we're supposed to
talk
about okay
yeah
[Music]
fire so where does this this section
have a place in the telling before you
see it in the say their
Yeah.
What do you say?
Hash
um in the general uh order of the
mitzvah and the concepts in on this
night.
Now and and and first and foremost
telling the uh story
of right what has to be emphasized and
recognizable is the concept of the the
freedom now meaning
what's meaning that's that's something
that is every single day When you when
you are remembering it has to be
something that you are talking about
something that's that's a now experience
not something that happened like how
much more
so and the on the night when you're
supposed to elaborate on this right
so right to make the point even stronger
on this night the is you have to do
everything in a manner of right that's
why you lean um and
Um, you're supposed
to I mean some people have a custom
someone for for you like your king.
Okay. And so we're saying got to leave
already today, right? Yeah. Nice. Yeah.
You guys should meet also in in in more
informal settings. Definitely.
Absolutely. Yeah. Create a nice day.
Come down to host. You wrapped already?
Yeah, I would love to. I'm going to wrap
up soon. Yeah, I got to rush it
somewhere. See, sorry to make that
later. I think I told you that
first $10 cash.
Yeah,
a 20 works. 20.
Yeah, I'll grab one second.
phone number or email? Um, phone number.
Either way, you want to catch that Z.
What's the first name? Ellie. Nice.
Okay.
What's the phone? 786. 786. 580 58
020620.
Excellent. Thank you.
Okay. Seemingly, can I read a little
bit? Yeah.
Go. Okay. So maybe we are talking about
we're expressing that our ancestors were
slaves. But by saying that, we're
showing how we're free.
like you were suggesting, right?
Yeah. You can't say that
truthfully. Why? Because of these two
reasons. Amen.
Because if that was the case, meaning if
you were only emphasizing the the fact
that your ancestors were slaves in Egypt
to
emphasize that you're free, that now
we're free. Um, then that should come
after because it's supposed to be in a
in a question answer format and be based
But now, right
now has drawn us close to be able to
serve him.
So if you ever want to if you're
bringing something that's that is uh
seemingly derogatory only to contrast it
with the you know uh with with the
positive side
then that it's only appropriate to do
that when you're talking about something
in the past. In other words, like if I
wanted to, I don't know, do a TED talk
on like a rags to riches story. It's
like it only works if I'm no longer in
rags. I can't tell you like I'm rags to
riches cuz I'm getting there. Like this
is the this is how I'm working on it.
That's still a story struggle of
redemption.
Exactly. Right now, unfortunately, we're
still
in this year where we won't be.
So I could go and give that TED talk as
passionately as possible and like show
how I'm on the trajectory of success,
but it's not the same as saying like I I
got there. Mhm. You know, so whatever it
is that that the struggle is, it m is
not the place to be saying the story of
struggle. We're like we're still talking
about being in inos. We're still talking
about being in gul. Yeah. And it's more
of a hope and an aspiration to be um
fully
redeemed. Now I can understand this that
we're inviting everybody suddenly only
now.
what connection does it have to telling
over the story
of according to everything that we've
been explaining
um so it's not yet a part of telling
over the story of because that would
come in the question answer format. So
we would be saying what we're saying
like only in the in the which is in
response to the child's questions of
manana but it is relevant it's it's an
appropriate introduction to to the
elaboration on what does it's a general
preface
Wow. The Reb is making a very general
preface over here for the for the point
he's getting to that is a general it it
does away with a certain underlying
question like that that that is that it
would exist if not for first saying and
call it's addressing the elephant in the
room. Right.
Okay.
[Music]
It's also not understood what we're
saying that this is the bread of
affliction that our forefathers ate in
the land of
the
like. They ask This say the matzah we're
eating on this night is connected with
the matzah we ate going out of not the
matzah we ate in it was only matzah
because we ate it on the way because
they were preparing
it right like we say in itself I say
that with this matter
is because it didn't have time for the
dough to rise
etc.
So the
answer
is
the
given
to
that because it was the this this was
the that the food that they would give
to captives
um because it is uh difficult basically
difficult to digest. Sorry man, I'm
sweaty. What's up? What's good, bro?
Good to see you. How you doing? You back
here for hats? Yeah, bro. I live here
now. [ __ ] yeah. What's up? What do you
do? Um learn. I learned. Yeah. Nice.
It's good. Yeah. Good [ __ ] Good to see
I just I just learned this thing last
night that says or maybe it was this
morning, I don't even remember. Says
that
that the mayor says that a person needs
to teach his
child a trade that's easy and clean. And
then
says I love I'm only I'm putting aside
all crafts. I don't care. I'm only the
only thing I'm occupying myself with
that that I'm teaching my son is. So the
Reb points out that that mayor and are
the same
person. Oh, where did I read this?
Actually, I'm sure the Reb speaks about
it, but I I I was running it in the
safer
about actually. So maybe it's one of his
or it was brought there as a
um that and are are one in the same
person, right? They're both like kind of
like
Yeah. Um but mayor was how he was
shining to other people. So the mayor
was the was the public personality
figure that he was and when people would
come to him and say like what should I
do? He would say you need to teach your
son a clean and easy trait. But as far
as who he was, he was expressing as a
private person. Every night he says I'm
I'm putting everything aside.
Nice.
Yeah.
Okay. Um yeah, meaning they're always
meaning that the the in the way Sparta
talks about it is that they always
um sorry um there's
Yeah. Yeah. So that um that it basically
it would it was difficult to digest,
right? So it would last longer, right?
And uh that was a way to uh that hasn't
changed save save money on food for a
slave. So other thus that's what we
that's what the Egyptians fed us in the
was that was based I believe who who was
it? There was
Abu Draham. Wow that's interesting. Yeah
because I think it was Abu Draham who
was was himself a captain. I there's
something like that. He was a captive.
He was captured by pirates. They said
fed masa. So interesting. So he Yeah. Um
so this was like personal experience
that he was relating to the concept of
eating
matri
says what is this word?
I'm not sure what that means. Does that
mean cheaper? I'm not sure.
Probably means cheaper. Yeah, probably.
Um, but there's like there's another
angle saying that that because they were
slaves and they were always um rushed,
right? They didn't have time to for
their bread to rise, so they'd make food
and then they would have to run to their
next task and so they didn't have time
for it to saw you a little bit.
Yeah.
Um, they were rough so they didn't have
time to which drives Frank up the
morale. So the morale um is very
skeptical of these interpretations and
he
says these these things are they they
they um they agitate the the the
um the the verses that we're
interpreting right that that MS because
she's the truth is
So the moral says no there's there's no
there's no source whatsoever not in the
not in in not in Mishna not in that the
fed us
in that in addition to this when
what's they contemporaries no
no I think
So the moral basically asks on the other
publicly that you're saying this
and others um is it because he's
disagreeing on principle or he's saying
like there's no proof for this you're
not this you're you're saying it like
it's and it's not written that that we
were fed
ma but it's also not written we were fed
anything obviously we ate
something
Um continue.
Yeah.
And in addition to
this, if this is the
intention, if this was an intention,
then the the author of would would bring
a
source And therefore, which is put
together,
whoever it was, I mean, it was in the
time of the Mishna. It was one person or
it was like a base and like
I'm not sure. Meaning the meaning it's
when you say author, it doesn't
necessarily mean there aren't multiple
authors, but it just means the the
narrator of that like the um the
invisible
narrator meaning the the the publisher.
Yeah. Whoever. Yeah.
Um, yeah. But it's the the in Hagada
it's we find throughout that it's it way
is to he sprinkles it with sources and
I'll bring you Yeah.
Fine. You were slaves to par and took us
out with a strong hand. And if Hashem
had not taken out our fathers, then we
and our children would still be
enslaved. The question on this is
known
to right the whole
we we were in the slaves to the because
Hashem decreed so it be and Hashem told
that it would be for 400 years. Yeah.
So what are we saying that if Hashem
didn't take us out then we would still
be there
right what's his word it was it was a
deal struck
between my I'm thinking more
like on on the second part like how
could we say that we would still be
there but the Reb is just he's cutting
it short more and more to the point like
we wouldn't be here longer than 400
years. So theory, what do you mean if
Hashem never took us out? Yeah, that
that's impossible.
If the is this is a when
I think it's like if Yeah. Yeah. If we
were if we would have been enslaved kind
of more due to like natural
circumstances then it would take some
other you know um some
other circumstance to to free us.
really however we're free
people. We became slaves because that's
how said it should be. This was the deal
struck between
Abd's and as soon as the the time period
was
over. We're not we're not like innately
slaves. This is what Hashem arranged.
And once the time is over, we're no
longer slaves.
In other words, practically it wasn't
even that we were in Mitran for 400
years, but it was only 2
um
11. No,
210.
Um,
210. Why does it say in this way?
Oh, cuz that the
whole Yeah.
In other words, it's not that we that
Hashem didn't keep the time period that
he said he would of 400 years. It's just
that it wasn't
400 said it's not going to be 400 years
of slavery. It's going to be 400 years
from the birth
of after 400 years.
So what in the world could it possibly
mean when we say if Hashem hadn't
redeemed
us? This is the first thing that came to
my mind. But this the Reb is pointing
the Reb is pointing it out. Second
second of all we're saying that we and
our children and our grandchildren will
be enslaved.
is so to say that we and our sons and
our grandchildren would be
enslaved
is what's this? Uh it runs contrary to
dura.
What's the context of there
again as well?
Um the footnote 37 says that
my son I believe so. Yeah.
Look it
up.
Um, trying to stand the question, but I
can't
really design.
Yeah.
He says look
rashi speaking
to it's by the servant. It says
says, "The fourth generation of going
down to
the Oh, yes. Okay, that's that's what I
was confused about means that Hashem's
telling them that they will come back
here
to the fourth generation. There's going
to be three generations that are going
to be
in
the so yeah it it runs contrary like how
could we say that we would still be
there when that's also a very explicit
part of this agreement between Hashem
and Abra that the fourth generation will
be back in in uh in this
land what's the we say
also beno
So Beno seems to be uh Beno simply is
the fourth generation.
Yeah. My father, me, my son, my
grandchild. Yeah. So, Hashem was very
clear that your grandchildren will not
be in the
we have to
[Music]
understand in the beginning we were um
we
served or our forefathers served by and
now has brought us close to his
servants.
You have to
understand brought us close to his
service.
[Music]
So bringing us close to his to service.
This this already applies to the
generation starting from Abra who's the
first one to um to be brought brought
close to Hashem's service
after which is refers
to why do we say now Hashem has brought
us close to his
service and we don't say and afterwards
is this going to be because
for For us it was more of anusive delay.
Hashem reached out to us by Abra. It was
really Abra did a ton of
you know like inner work and searching
and he went and rejected Zara and he
went and searched for you know the
truth.
Yeah. I don't know. I think that's
all we get to Z or we'll just
go
to 30 minutes or we could stop
here. Let's let's finish this.
And
it's if we will say that the language
saying now and now means not literally
now when we're saying
that but we're talking about the
time still the bringing us close started
much earlier fire time even for me you
today. Okay. I mean, just send me a
message. Okay. I'm leaving town
tomorrow. Yeah. Just send me a message.
Just so we'll be in contact again and
just call the dude up. Who cares? Stop
caring. Do it. I don't I I don't have
his number. That's the problem. All
right. So, I need to get I'm very close
with his brother, so I just need to like
break the wall down, bro. Yeah. I mean,
bro,
so even if you'll say that, why are we
saying now? When we say now, we don't
mean now. We mean the time shrine
because that's where we're entering that
like we're in that space right because
we're talking about so now but still
that doesn't work because the carbon
happened even before the
mutil br even before the bris even
before
um hashem's covenant with that starts
off this whole ghost
has very
dark like we see in brought in the
itself that um I brought your father
Abra where is this where is
I
um saying like what's the source of
Um, it's from Yeshua.
Sorry, but that's after how are we using
that to prove that the took place before
because the as of Ibra when he crossed
the Euphrates that's before I'm sorry
I'm sorry no yeah but it sounds like
saying like in retrospect what I did
was yeah yeah I guess but that's showing
us the the carvano it was already set in
motion way before
Yeah.
Okay. The content of the is the story
telling the
story the miracles and wonders that done
for us and about our freedom, our
redemption.
The whole concept
doesn't this concept saying that we
we're slaves in the beginning and now
we're brought close
to seemingly has no connection to the
telling story. Did you already ask this?
only that it it it follows the pattern
of starting with the derogatory.
So we have to continue that afterwards
we're brought close to service
um until
all the way down to the and we went down
to Matan
the is not it's not smooth.
Why do we have to emphasize that it was
Hashem who brought us close to his his
service? Why don't we say that we
ourselves
or say that became that became close
and to his
[Music]
service. We we're we're we're zooming
we're saying we're zooming in on this is
this is a an important point of emphasis
that what that
now Hashem brought close right so those
we've we've narrowed on those are those
are important um those are the important
details
to zoom in
on nit I don't I'm not following what's
different about this like clearly
different actual verse
is and so there are things that we
should ever suggesting we should have
said instead of
you're saying from the fact that we say
and not
um it shows us that this is an
important nuance
like we're bringing it back to the
present right now like yeah we'll see
why the show us why it's important to
say now versus versus telling the story
in a way of saying
afterwards because you could say it that
way but chooses to say it this way. So
that's going to that that is another
clue meaning we're we're we're we're
sifting through the text. We're looking
for clues that that tell that that are
going to the Rabb is going to weave
together to to So what was the first
question? First question between these
two questions.
[Music]
say and not Africa. Yeah. Now that I was
asking
that I was asking why
why we use the term of no why why it's
important to say
um why it's important to say that Hashem
brought us
close versus saying that we became close
that that Abram became close we became
close but it is something
emphasizing. Yeah. Why was it why why
are we emphasizing the aspect of it that
it was Hashem who who affected this
closeness
that in telling
story it's
relevant right those two are
sorry not only afterwards
But it's it's a good place to stop for
now. Yeah.
As the Reb always tells
us, it's eternally relevant. It's
relevant now and it's relevant to you.
Yeah. That's what that's what we're
setting out in the beginning of M
Yeah, this whole story begins. But one
second. Let's just look out. Look at
where we are
now. We still need to understand though
because seemingly where we are now is
still not the
ideal. We're still, you
know, to mix up the young.
Yeah. It's very exciting.
Who's your cousin?
Um raisal
labor tough.
Do you know uh do you know