0:00 / 0:00
Likutei Moharan Lesson 2 Shiur by Rav Yoeli Klein at Scheiner's Shul in Monsey
78 views
Video from the Weekly Thursday Night Likutei Moharan Chaburah at Bais Medrash Ohr Chaim
Featuring:
Yoeli Klein
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Yeah.
So, yeah, there was a little confusion
with that, but we're going to start the
new tire today. We'll do at least an
introduction, an introduction and get
our feet wet in terra base and we'll see
what what happens from there.
That's why we said that we mentioned
this in the first year that the Maran is
very unique and all of Turas in that you
have a lot of background information
from
RaNas came close to the Reb so he
decided to record almost everything
which at that time was was more rare you
don't have that by a lot of
otherwise has a whole very unique and
interesting story background. First of
all, it says in the
beginning which means that it was
handwritten
by others that are not written like that
are dictated or were heard by and then
looked it over. But these were
handwritten
by and this one is unique because it was
before even came close to the Reb. A lot
of the terrors from afar of mass were
were not lost but they weren't recorded
well. So over here
um the Reb himself said that when came
close to him he said if it wasn't for
Abnas not one page in my writings would
would would uh would exist. Nassan was
the one that recorded almost everything.
So over here that's why I brought the
English version here for for this intro
and for a lot of the historical
information. Um the ty over here this ty
bay was given in
1801 which is before even moved to to
breast. He was living in Zlatipole.
Rabbn Nassen came close I think in 1802
1803. So before even came close and the
whole story is
that there was a um a follower of
Nakman. Nakman had already followers
from when he was 13. As far as we know
from the days of his bar mitzvah, he uh
he went out to the forests and he uh he
would speak to people and they would be
very enthused and get very inspired and
they were very were very dic to him. And
uh so one of his followers over here um
was Isaac and Rashel Isaac he had a very
uh interesting
dream and this dream was disturbed them
so much that he actually ran to Zapia to
speak to the Reb to his reb to see what
what what's going on with this dream and
so he he he would give over this dream
and he said that he saw himself in a
very very thick forest and he came up
with this person. He saw this person
that was carrying a huge sword that was
double-edged, meaning you could have a
sword that's, you know, sharp on one
edge and dull on the other side. It was
two edges were sharp. It was a It was a
unique sword. And he was frightened, but
he started to follow this man.
Eventually, they came to some house and
the old the man told him that there are
many other swords over here and you
could take one, but you have to know how
to use the sword. You have to know how
to do it. So he came inside and he was
uh he was a little scared at first and
this old man was there and he said that
you have to be totally clean of
immorality in order to take and know how
to and you have to know how to handle
the sword. So all of a sudden Isaac
found himself like filled with clouds
dark dark clouds and he said look you're
still surrounded by all these clouds
which means that you know you're still
not clean and you're not ready for the
sword yet. So, you'll come to a a place
soon in the forest that you'll be able
to get a proper master craftsman. He
sharpens these swords. If you get there,
maybe maybe you'll be able to to wield
the sword properly. And he said, "But
who knows if they'll open the door for
you."
So, Isaac woke and from this dream and
he ran straight to Zia. I don't know how
far it was. And he went there in the
winter and uh part of the way he he
actually walked there and Nakman just
moved to Loly Hamish a few months
earlier and Isaac is never there yet. So
he was like looking for Abnakman.
Finally he got there and they said like
don't you know there's a whole
opposition after he said don't worry I I
need to go there. So that's when he
realized that in the dream they told him
who knows you know if you'll even make
it to this house and who knows if
they'll open up for you. So he finally
found Rabnak's house and he knocked and
knocked and knocked and there was no
answer. So he kept knocking and knocking
and knocking and finally he heard the
Reb say behind the
door it's impossible to open the door
for you now. I can't I can't open the
door. So he was broken and he started to
cry and cry. He stood by the Reb's door
for an hour at least just crying that
here he came all the way to the Reb and
he was told that I can't open the door
for you. And finally after a long time
not going to open the door and he says
but weren't you already told even before
setting out that you might have not be
let in. He says very good you cried a
lot and you know the sh of the dees are
open but there's so much clouds and when
he heard that he realized that even
though he was coming to tell the rebba
about a dream the rebba already knew the
entire dream and he was just he couldn't
even talk so that he stayed that shabas
and then on that shabas the rebba taught
this now this whole is an explanation of
the dream so here he was he had this
dream he ranted the rebba played out the
dream by saying you can't even come in
here because you're not clean and then
he taught the Torah which is all about
this dream.
Unbelievable like a pelic way that the
Reb's lessons would come out. Now as an
addition now the dream sorry the dream
with all of these ideas is exactly
alluded to in the toyra which speaks
very much
about but he says as we're going to see
as an intro to the toy is a sword has to
be like a double-edged sword where it
has the edge of where you praise and the
edge of where you cry out to so it's
like a double-edged sword but in order
to know how to wield the sword you have
to
know have to to have mishbat and in
order to have mishbat you have to be
close to the tadikim and he goes through
but but but if you have if you're not
worthy you have tons of clouds that are
clouding your judgment you're not going
to be able to do any of this so that's
what the to was about so the amazing
addition to the story was that a bunch
of years back we to have loser kenn come
to the house a lot and had become very
close to him um he passed away a few
years back and he had a lung transplant
by us And we had a very very deep
connection throughout the years.
Actually the first time that he came was
around was around kissave to our house
here. And Kaneka that Kaneka was an
incredible Kaneka. He was on double
oxygen dying from a genetic lung
disease. And every night he gave over to
for like 20 minutes, half hour, an hour.
He could barely breathe. He could barely
talk. The doctor said that if you were
um you know getting the amount of oxygen
that he was getting which is about 7% of
the norm normal oxygen levels you would
be basically passed out fainted on a bed
all day long. That's how most people
would be. He would push and push and
push and he would do whatever he could
and he would
teacher. So from then on he had the lung
transplant which is a different story
tons of miracles tons of stories but I
would try to make it my my way to he was
the r of the breast of communas every
year to be there for a night
um to see him light the candles and many
years I was to be there it's not just
lighting the candles it's preappearing
for it and then afterwards they would
sing there's like I don't know 20
breastless nigun to sing and some of
them are very slow takes a long time and
they would sing happy nigun and you
would sing over some it was always a
beautiful beautiful amazing amazing
experience. So one year I don't know how
many years ago this was must have been
12 years ago the RV was always very you
know he was always battling back and
forth even after lung transplant with
health and but you know we were the ones
that hosted him here in Muny so we had
very very special status and we would
always get to to to be close to him and
come in and us very very much kitser
that year he was taka feeling very I
made it for there and we we we dire
together and I went over afterwards And
one of the sons came over to me. I saw
you was mamish. Like barely bar really
could barely stand. One of the sons came
over to me afterwards. He said, "This
year, I'm really really sorry. I know
you came all the way here. Maybe
tomorrow you'll be able to come in, but
tonight don't even bother. Don't even
come. He's too weak to see anyone. He's
going to light the candles and go to
sleep. Like don't come. Don't bother
coming. Don't bother coming to the
door." So I said, you know, I listened
to the the words of the Tadikim. He says
not to come. I'm not going to come. So I
went I lived I sang my my songs then I
went around and I had a very close
friend that lived mish actually across
the street
in from the r. I ended up at his house
with a friend of mine and we start
bringing and we start talking we start
smoozing and for some reason or another
he brings out this whole story that I
was talking to you because I told him
that they told me that I shouldn't even
come that I shouldn't even knock at the
door. He said nash he said come let's
learn the story and he he opened up the
book and he we learned through this
whole story and he said you see was also
told go away don't you know and he even
knocked and even cried he still told him
go away eventually the reb opened the
door you have to knock you have to push
you have to it's like don't give me
these things of yourself person's sick
and he says don't come you don't come so
the whole time we're fighting and we're
going through this story I'm
like okay kids Just to add one point
that I forgot that's very important to
the story is that when I was speaking
before that that uh that this toy is
about the first line of the we'll see we
can start the like
this the main weapons of Msiah are
that's how the Reb starts off this and
he goes on to explain that is the weapon
of Msiah right in different places he
says that Msiah is going to take over
the whole world without one shot being
fired there's weapons of mass
destructions and all sorts of Armageddon
doomsday theories and all sorts of
stuff. Reb says Mashiach is going to
come. It's going to be
one is one puts the whole thing over the
over the top and all of a sudden Msiah
comes.
So, but the Reb uses a very interesting
lion. The weapon the main weapon of
Msiah is so we'll speak about that maybe
a little bit. But Kitser at a certain
point it got to a to a crescendo and I
said okay fine for your sake I'm going
to go to their house and I'm going to
knock like a baby like this and if they
don't answer I'm leaving. I said fine at
least you did your go do it. So I go
over there I'm like shake I'm like they
told me not to knock. They told me don't
come to the door. So I knock like as if
like no one no hopefully no one will
hear me. Sure enough of course they
opened the door they
said come they they honored me. They
brought me in with my with my friend and
they sat us down talk at that point
there was only family members and it was
very intimate. But as the night wore on
and they were singing and the RV got a
little more energy. They let more people
more people more people. Eventually
there was 20 30 people there. There was
a whole whole crew of people and they
did all the songs. The Ravi even sent
over a
short. Everyone was very very excited
and very happy and I was like amazed
that already like the first half of this
story came true that like I wasn't
supposed to go to the door but I knocked
and they let me in. I was like
ahaldic. Then the amazing part comes
that there's a bak one of the bak is
walking out and I'm sitting there like a
few feet away from the r and my friend
and all these this guy that pushed me to
come and the other friend I was with
they're all standing around and this
baker comes over to the and he says
that I've had enough of dodging the
draft you know in air they have a draft
to go to the army he said I uh you know
I'm not learning so great I don't I
don't want to dodge I don't want to do
this stuff I just want to go to the army
me, get it over with and get a normal
job and go on with my life. So the
without looking at me or anything, he
just
goes, "The main weapons
of army has their weapons. You have your
weapons." And I was just like, me and my
all my friends look at each other. Did
that just happen? Did we just like
experience a parallel story? You know,
it was it was quite unbelievable. So,
you know, I've been around a lot of
breast of people. I've seen so many and
I mean the Reb over here when he was
telling Isaac straight you know where
Reb was on aesh where he would say it
and sometimes I've seen from the like
that a lot of times I've seen especially
from Sadikim that the kind of just comes
it's like they're so simply in tune with
with Hashem and with the with the with
the Reb that everything they say just
flows with unbelievable unity. But with
that said and done, so the toy of is
about all these ideas that were alluded
to in this in this dream and in this
story. And starts
off this is a in the end the end of the
is going to be explained more thoroughly
how it fits in with the
lesson. There's a very deep and esoteric
part of the Z. Not that the rest of it
is not not esoteric, but this part is
like um rich in in
secrets simply from the from the holes
of the nose. Let's say the breath of
life is drawn into Msiah. So now the
sides the main weapons of
Msiah is prayer.
Prayer as a weapon is an element of the
nostrils, the
nose. And my uh the over there is
speaking about the wrath of says but for
for my glory and for my praise, I'm
going to which is a very strange. It
sounds like I'm gonna nostril it. I'm
gonna nose it. It means that my wrath
that could come through my nostrils, you
know, the imagery of people that are
angry is through their nose. So I'm
gonna stop that wrath. I'm gonna instead
give kindness. He's
saying over here he's saying that that
that's the aspect of praise is my is is
connected to the
nostrils all the wars and the battles of
Msiah are going to be captured all from
this place of Msiah which is an aspect
of the nostrils.
This is an aspect of the that I will
breathe
like he's connecting the ideas
of and the nostrils and
breathing is again going to explain on
another level how this this relates to
weaponry like what shist you know okay
things happen you get miracles What? Why
does that have to do with war with
weapons? Says, "With my sword and with
my bow, I won the battles with my
brother with
my filling to him." Again we see the
idea
of that with connecting to to toal with
praising the idea of connecting
to the the nose and the nostrils and
breathing and Msiah. So again over here
it's interesting to note that the Reb
speaks about it in the terms
of a weapon. What is a weapon? A weapon
is something that you wield. kind of
like similar to if we were speaking
about mal is something that you have
over here it's something that you wield
that you use to affect the world right
like America there's a big debate about
gun control and like many people uh on
one side of the debate say you know guns
don't kill people kill people a gun is
an inanimate object that sits on a table
or in a box it just sits there it won't
kill anyone for all of eternity if you
don't do anything with it a human being
that's evil will take it and try to kill
people. So then the humans are where you
should work on not the guns. So over
here too a sword is something that could
be used for terrible things. You can
murder people. In those days there was
the gun, the gun of the times with
swords and bows and all these ideas. But
it could also be used to kill bad
people. It could also be used to protect
people and to say here I have a weapon.
You can't touch me. So over here the Reb
is showing us that basically through we
have to be able to we wield a tremendous
power and this power could be used if
it's garnered properly to help us affect
other people in a in a powerful way
ourselves and other people as the Tor is
going to go on is going to say that you
have to know how to do this. So over
here we have to receive this this weapon
of was famous for withstanding the
greatest test of all time seemingly
with as a young man filled with energy
in a land where no one would ever know
what he did in a situation where he was
being offered the greatest temptations.
He withheld
that you should g your sword on your
loin.
is a reflection reference to
um this is an aspect referring this this
is referring
to not going to get too much into the
how they all connect but that's the idea
of connecting
to he's going to explain it a little
more though um in a way that's more
understandable
who did guard his
brisk took the inheritance of the
firstborn like we see that he got double
portion of two of two tribes
being say that this idea
of is connected very very much
to like we said
before there's two elements that
There is an aspect where you praise and
there's an aspect when you beg for
stuff which is like we said before in
the dream a double-edged sword. It's
sharp on both
edges. Two mouths so to speak, right?
It's that's
inalucos. You're saying praises and
you're also saying
that you want to bring more goodness
into the world which very much relates
to what we said. Malus is
that a
um sabris also sabris very uh vaguely
spoken about is like stop looking at bad
things don't do this stay away from that
but sabris really means to guard the
covenant to guard something that you
hold um close to yourself something that
you've forged as being part of you hold
to
it right it means to basically stay true
to what you know is righteous and good.
What does that mean? Stay true. Stay
true means that when you're experiencing
times that obviously when it's flowing
and you're feeling it and you have no
time, oh, very nice. Stay true. It's not
a big deal. Staying true means to stay
faithful to that which you know means
that you have to really work on it. When
it's times that you don't feel like that
and you feel miserable and you feel dark
and you feel like who cares, nothing
makes sense anymore. There stay true.
Stay faithful to that which you already
know is true. So over here when it comes
to chila if and when we look at the
world like we said that you know
everything is mine and everything I have
is mine we look at it from a very
superficial aspect so you like our is
going to be pretty poor it's just going
to be like oh hashem you know sometimes
you feel like that thank you for the
walls thank you for my hands thank you I
don't feel anything you're saying thank
you hashem which is nice beautiful but
when we really feel it when we recognize
you know we have the we have the yatar
So you say, "Wow." So it's so nice. You
come out of the bathroom and if you're
to be amongst the, you know,
sigula that says the asher without
running and drying your hands and doing
13 things, you actually stop and you say
the words. So you feel like you're a
million dollars. I said, "Maybe now
Hashem is going to, you know, heal me
and heal some person." But doesn't need
your doesn't need a you recognizing
that. Wow. both we just gave you the
ability to go to the bathroom and if it
comes to a point of humility I had a
minor surgery a hernia operation but
they give you anesthesia and they put
you out in gans I didn't know about the
posttop app at all uh which is probably
better that way but it was pretty
shocking that when you wake up so your
body is actually still asleep you can't
go to the bathroom cuz your muscles are
sleeping and it's a big deal to go to
the bathroom for the first like 8 to 10
hours they don't even let you out of the
hospital so finally they let me out of
the by I remember finally after like 10
12 hours of feeling the need to go to
the bathroom but not being able to do it
just you can't it's like you're you're
in like that long everlasting car ride
where your parents are like we're not
stopping we're not stop like bus driver
say we're not stopping we just took a
break you know you're like ah you're
exploding you can't go it's it's
terrible and finally you able to go so I
always try to remind myself and say the
fact that you're just able to go to the
bathroom is a gift hashem is just
allowing you to recognize these gifts of
life of the ability to do the most
simple things to have a drink of water
whatever it is gives you that gift. So
when you recognize that gift and you
have that praise of that that
perspective of like wow hashem I don't
have anything you blessed me with water
you've blessed me with bathroom you
blessed me with with the grape juice for
kish you blessed me with with every
little then you could start feeling the
true the the
um and then you could start saying he
blessed you with so many gifts that you
just give to me hashem help me use them.
You know, I have more than just water. I
have tons of food. I have tons of
energy. I have tons of things. You know,
tonight I was I was with the kids and we
had a layover of four minutes before the
food was going to come out of the oven
until the food was ready with a bunch of
hungry children. So, those four minutes
are intense
time. I'm fighting, you know, hungry
children. Don't always have to stuff
them with food. Make sure they're taken
care of. They're they're not hungry, not
thirsty. But they were starving. the
food was going to be ready in four
minutes. So, I just started like, you
know, just being fun and entertaining
and seeing any random thing that came to
my mind. So, I was like, "Do you realize
how much food we have?" I know that's
not going to do it cuz they're like,
"Yeah, but we're starving now." I was
like, "Wait a minute. We have to take an
image right now of all of the food, not
after we've eaten it, before we've eaten
it, right when it gets served to us that
we've eaten our entire life piled on
this table. All of the bread, fresh,
delicious bread. It would probably be up
to the roof already. All of the chicken,
all of the eggs, all the steaks, all of
the hot dogs and everything. Can you
imagine? It would be like an entire room
filled with food. This blessings just
keeps pouring and pouring and pouring
and pouring. One of my kids who only eat
cereal and milk. He's like, "Oh, just be
boxes of cereal." I was like, "Yeah,
you're right. Just boxes of cereal and
milk." But okay, either way, it would be
a lot of boxes, you know? It's but this
is the gift is coming up with it. But
Hashem blesses us with tons of gifts. We
have so much energy and stuff. We come
to a a genuine
hak of these things. Then we say to when
it comes out like
that, thank you and I have and I have
money and I have wisdom and I have
strength. Hashem, please help me guide
me to know what to do to use all of
these things that I could be able to do
it well with my wife, with my family,
with my my siblings, my parents to to
use it all for good. The TA comes out
like that. It's staying true. I think a
an element of also to to to have our
recognition when we have the times that
we're connected and then when we have
other times and we're not feeling it so
much to be able to recognize that the
the um the connection that we have to
our wife or to kaduca to the tora person
that you know it's taught very often
that person that doesn't yet have a wife
everyone should be very very soon they
have the toyra the toyra has all of the
energy the fire of the tya of women that
you could channeling for the Tyra. So we
have that energy. We have that place to
to grab on to have the the engagement
and the connection. So but sometimes we
don't feel it. We don't want it. And we
go with other things like yeah is nice.
It's cute. But right now I'm going to go
to something else. We have to stay true
to the things that we know is true and
recognize that, you know, you can see it
very much in a marriage that this is the
person that's been giving me and giving
to me and giving to me and that we have
a deep very intimate relationship with
and this is someone that I'm going to
stay true to. And the same thing with
the Tyra is word. So I'm going to stay
true to I'm not going to veer off to
other places. Just a couple more
minutes. Maybe I'll be to finish another
stickle to to tie it in. He
says he merits to get this sword. So he
said that Messiah is a weapon a weapon
of in order to get the weapon
of you have to stay true to what you
have and what you know is true.
So we have a sword now but like we said
we have to know how to use it. You have
to have gun
safety. You have to be able to aim
properly. You don't take a gun and start
swinging it around wildly. You have to
be able to aim it to keep it in the
proper place in those days. Arrow or a
sword like it says in the over there
speaks about being able to aim your your
over there speaking about a stone.
whatever you're shooting a stone, a
arrow, a sword at at a hearer's breath
and hit
it. You cannot possibly do this only
through there's an element of just
justice,
judgment is an is the uh the middle
pole. You're able to aim exactly your
weapon where you need to.
So you hit the target in the
middle to sustain your words with
meaning that your words are going to be
able to have a powerful proper effect if
and when you have what does that mean?
It seems uh like again just pretty
random like okay mishb what does mishb
mean and what does that have to do with
my words. So you
explain take a little time but it'll
explain got this from like we said
already in the first but he's going to
bring it down a little bit
differently is I'm giving it over to
you is he's giving it over
to he also had which is an element of
brisk which we stay at bris
receives all
this. So he should be able to hold his
words in the proper
way. Mashiach is the king. He's going to
be able to also have this mishbah. So
what? How do we get to this mishbah? So
we have a sword and it's dangerous and
it's sharp and if we don't know what
we're doing with we could veer off
either too much praise. We just say
thank you Hashem all day or too much
crying and begging and screaming at
Hashem. We have to have like this
beautiful balance of the two. How do we
have this through mishbah through having
a a proper um healthy approach to
mishbah. But how do we do that?
Obviously, if you want to be able to do
things properly, you have to know how to
judge things. How do we get to that? So,
he
says through giving, which is a very
unique. He says when you give to you are
you are literally grabbing the element
of and doing it.
So now he's going to explain more what
that
means. Through
judgment, God is the judge is the judge
is the judger. He decides this guy's
going to be rich. This guy is going to
be
poor. Means that Hashem is the only
decider. Who's going to be rich? Who's
going to be poor? You work hard. I've
seen a lot of people that had talent,
went to very good schools, worked pretty
hard, and failed at everything. I've
seen guys that were
schlamasics and and they're like multi
multi-millionaires, didn't have
charisma, they didn't have like big
backgrounds, didn't go to good college.
Hashem judges, but the Reb looks a
little bit differently. And he has a
unique
interpretation. He's saying each and
every one of us givea
I am being I am being godly now in the
terms of deciding who will be rich and
who will be poor. What does that mean?
Cuz right now in my pocket I have a $100
bill. When I have a $100
bill, I'm the judge over where that's
going to go.
Ah, right now I say that poor guy, this
guy that's collecting for some good
cause, I'm going to give him $100. I
just made a decision like God who
decides who was born and who's not to
take money away from me and give it to
another person. Obviously, if you do it
the opposite way, you're perverting
judgment in the wrong in the worst of
ways. You say, "That guy has $100. He's
not looking. I'm going to take that
$100." That's obviously taking mishb and
m is destroying it because you're
judging but the wrong way against here
tells us all yes give s to daka I'm
telling you to do this hashem says give
sak you're like okay I have the ability
to now say to judge this person me is
going to be a little poorer right now
and that person right now is going to be
a little richer so the reb says how do
you get to this mishbat which we said in
order to get to mishbat you need in
order to get To properly wield the sword
of which is Msiah, you have to have is
through giving through giving physically
you you exercise mishb and then you
bring out this power to wield the sword
of that's why there's a big uh brought
out I think in to give before ding in
it's even in the middle of ding there
which is
again to be able to have your
um your your in order to have your with
the proper balance to have this mishb
let's just finish off a little bit if we
could do it
um gave money. He was the king who had
all the money and he supported his
family in the times of famine. Um during
those
years that was able to now give over
back to his
father. Again he's connecting this idea
of
giving through giving that he was able
to
exercise. So he's able to
have so he gave to who's the element of
gave the back to him. So he gave him
the obviously also is a reference
to
of. So over here in these few
paragraphs, the Reba basically took all
these ideas of of exercising judgment
and uh
doing you give sodaka and again sodaka
now we're in the
spir so I've said over recently a lot
that sodaka doesn't mean just money.
Sedaka can mean many many things can
mean smiling. It can mean anything that
you give to another person. If you ask a
person how he's doing, these are things
that you uh that you help another
person. I remember once I was in in
Mirron for shabas, the only miron shabas
that I was there and I was stuck in a
bench shabas afternoon between twoy
beautiful bakra and we were all dabbling
and learning and I open up a takali and
I was about to start tikka and I said to
myself but I want to give saddaka before
saying takal shabas. So sometimes I try
to look even if it's job is done say a
nice word to a guy say how you doing
give a guy a smile it's giving I was
sitting there stuck in between two
random people there was no one to give
nothing to do so I was sitting there
thinking what can I do all of a sudden
the ber next to me
goes I said there's a mistake he goes
yeah look in
the mistakes you see when we say it in
the morning you see I mean there's
mistakes in there it's not see who it's
he starts showing me all these mistakes
So I smiled to him. I said sweet this is
from this is from that's from that we
say in the morning this is the real text
of he
goes he says my whole life I never said
I was always correcting it say it me
right
now you know I get to say for the first
time in his life I said he could be
sitting in the middle of two people
stuck with nowhere to go nowhere to
speak nothing to do you can do wherever
you are so basically is sitting over
here whatever taka was to do is element
of Mishbah that helps us wield and have
a proper balance of where we praise
Hashem and ask him and through that