How To Combat Enemy of Jewish People, the Neturie Karta, Niturei Karta, Neturai Karta, נטורי קרתא

Top 10 Reasons Why Neturei Karta is Harmful to Jews and Opposes the Torah** ### **1. Public Alliance with Enemies of the Jewish People** Neturei Karta openly supports and meets with leaders of groups that have a well-documented history of violence and anti-Semitism, including Iran’s leadership and Hamas. The Torah commands us to protect Jewish lives, as stated in **Vayikra 19:16**, "Do not stand idly by the blood of your neighbor." By aligning with sworn enemies of Israel and Jews worldwide, they violate this fundamental Torah obligation. ### **2. Chillul Hashem (Desecration of Hashem's Name)** The Torah commands Jews to uphold a sanctified and respected image among the nations. **"And you shall not profane My holy name..." (Vayikra 22:32).** By participating in anti-Israel and anti-Jewish demonstrations alongside those who call for Jewish harm, Neturei Karta causes a massive **Chillul Hashem**, portraying Jews as traitors to their own people. ### **3. Endangering Jewish Lives (Pikuach Nefesh)** Halacha dictates that **Pikuach Nefesh (saving a Jewish life) overrides almost all mitzvos.** By advocating for the destruction of the State of Israel and befriending those who seek to harm Jews, Neturei Karta directly endangers Jewish lives, contradicting the Torah's emphasis on protecting life. ### **4. Violating the Mitzvah of “Lo Titgodedu” (Do Not Cause Division Among Jews)** Devarim 14:1 states, **"You shall not cut yourselves [into factions]"**—a warning against dividing the Jewish people. By promoting extreme anti-Zionist rhetoric and publicly opposing mainstream Jewish communities, Neturei Karta sows deep division and discord, weakening Jewish unity. ### **5. False Claim that All Religious Jews Oppose Israel** Neturei Karta spreads the misconception that all Torah Jews reject the State of Israel. In reality, mainstream Torah-observant communities, including Chabad, Agudas Yisroel, and many Gedolim, recognize that Israel is a place where Jews can live and thrive in Torah observance. Neturei Karta's extremist stance misrepresents authentic Torah values. ### **6. Rewriting the Torah’s View on Jewish Sovereignty** Neturei Karta claims Jews must remain stateless until Moshiach comes. However, throughout Tanach, Hashem repeatedly commands the Jewish people to settle Eretz Yisrael. **Bamidbar 33:53 states, "You shall take possession of the land and settle in it, for I have given you the land to possess it."** The Ramban counts settling Eretz Yisrael as a mitzvah. Rejecting Jewish sovereignty contradicts this mitzvah. ### **7. Supporting Amalek and Reshaim (Wicked People)** The Torah commands us to **eradicate Amalek** (Devarim 25:19), referring to those who seek to destroy the Jewish people. When Neturei Karta praises Iran’s leadership, which openly calls for the destruction of Jews, they violate this Torah obligation. Instead of defending Am Yisrael, they befriend our enemies. ### **8. Disrespecting and Slandering Talmidei Chachamim** The Torah warns against **slandering Torah scholars** (Shemos 22:27: **"Do not curse a judge or a prince among your people"**). Neturei Karta frequently attacks great Torah leaders, including the Chazon Ish, Rav Ovadia Yosef, and the Lubavitcher Rebbe, simply because they did not share their extreme anti-Zionist ideology. Such behavior is against Torah values. ### **9. Misusing the Concept of Exile (Galus)** While Jews are in galus until Moshiach comes, that does not mean we must **oppose our own survival.** The Gemara (Kesubos 111a) discusses the “Three Oaths,” which some interpret as forbidding rebellion against nations, but **nowhere does it say Jews must assist their enemies.** Neturei Karta misuses this concept to justify treachery. ### **10. Weakening Jewish Safety Worldwide** When Neturei Karta marches with anti-Semites and extremists, they give **credibility to lies about Jews.** They fuel anti-Semitic propaganda by falsely portraying Jews as traitors to their own people. This leads to **increased violence against Jews worldwide,** in direct violation of the Torah’s command to ensure Jewish survival. ### **Common English Spellings:** - Neturei Karta - Niturei Karta - Neturai Karta - Neturey Karta - Niturey Karta ### **Hebrew Spellings:** - נטורי קרתא - נטורי קרטא - נטורי כרטא ### **Alternative English Search Terms:** - Neturei Karta anti-Zionism - Neturei Karta Iran - Neturei Karta Hamas - Neturei Karta Israel protest - Neturei Karta Zionism opposition - Neturei Karta traitors - Neturei Karta controversy - Neturei Karta halacha - Neturei Karta Torah view - Neturei Karta and Gedolim