Laws of Eruv Chatzeros - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

make [Music] I turned them on look at my boy and mache meet again sheer terror we would like to welcome everyone to today's year from of Yaakov Zev Smith Selita unchallenging here answers questions like a big-ish a character of some pecans with supports of today she didn't issue us others name is posted service or a hymen Arif Smith's Lisa someone else recently he made an era Terrace in his apartment building he's a younger man just got married and he was told the officers it might be a problem because there are some non-jewish tenants in there in the building so I was thinking as he told me that it's not a problem it's a Mishnah and see tomorrow at the seminar tomorrow the problem is that we don't know the whole office and indeed this question of the situation that you have to make an era Terrace whether it's a apartment building or a three family house a bungalow County will soon see when there's a non Jewish person living there is a significant digit ila from a different angle there are people that need help constant help whether it's an elderly person a sick person so you have a living maid or a a home attendant a non-jewish person living in any additional and the question is as far as caring in the home since you have someone else living in the house I just heard the Shai alit was a very Hamish a bungalow count Leo got over 100 families and they made a name a terrace and they made the tour suppressor and on Shabbos someone pointed out that there was a non Jew actually the owner the original owner was living on the premises he had a bungalow and someone said that the air is no good because you did include the non-jewish owner of the bungalow County we're in a child of someone ended up in China for Shabbos and he was in a car you show tell what what does that love is not a carrier can I make an air cut a race so as we'll see today Suki is making an air cuts a race that when there is a non Jewish person on the premises never from their book I should just say the terrain regard oh the same shilassen again when you have a fryer person be so caloric and shinpei hey see if Kimmel says when you have a mom or someone that is not living like a ye then a very severe way and of course you have to know when is someone's a moment but there's no doubt about it a moomer has the same Alaka like a guy so unfortunately we have to say that when you have a irreligious person it's the same Sheil of the same sugar so today we're talking about a guy but the same is true regarding a friar person and the question is very simple let's say you're making an air vetericyn apartment building that has 50 families or you're making in a three family house and one of the tenants happens to be non-jewish is there any problem with that before we could argue what's the problem then aren't you is now believed to keep Shabbos doesn't have to be part of the area so dude make the air of the way you like and just ignore than aren't you or maybe we'll say mice he's living there and since he's not part of the he'll Kazarian maybe can only disturb the EV and doesn't can't be part of it now her you'll say why should that be so if the guy has to be part of the area so let me part of there and the truth is I should mention that when you make an advocate say race each person contributes a gregory's which is less than a Casillas so here for matzo per person and you're good to go like they say let's say you have a big oil them you have a bongo County you have an apartment building with a hundred families so the unlucky is you don't need more maximum than 18 Gregory's that's the maximum even for hundreds or thousands of people you have a big community if 18 Gregory's is the maximum it happens to be that a 16 ounce box of matzo in other words a pound of matzo has the required 18 Greiger's so you wondering listen my mana sure if the guy doesn't have the part of the Arabs so so find this good way it is if you tell me I see part of the earth god I'll take it back so much up for hundreds of others and include the guy but both of these assumptions don't seem to be correct because we have a mission up in air Vanessa McCallum obeys hedorium Optima qotsa effort or Misha a name I've ever talked about either a gossip person or a fryer person her Aiza oyster all of dr. Mishnah the guy has to be part of the aerial but can't be included in the earth then the mr. quotes ashita of a blessing oh yeah please if you have a two-family house one guy is your family one year this your family there's no problem but once you have two or more eaten living together with the guy then you have a double problem the guy has to be part of the Arabs but he can't be part of a river now I'll explain that in a moment but Frank do you Maura listen if the guy has to be part of the area why is there a difference one or two so the gemara basically explains that really a guy is not part of he'll to save them a god could be living in your apartment building and doesn't have to part of the earth he doesn't keep Shabbos he doesn't wear trill and he's not part of the caesarian nothing against him he's just not part of our MIT's availeth because I'll wanted that we should not live together with the non-jews we have our culture they have theirs vowel esta Menominee so cuz I'll said you have to make an Arab but he can't be part of your area so the F we will say wow this is difficult so live only with Eden and they'll look the Graham will live with themselves will have ourselves and show him are you strong Craig do you morrison one second if that's the case that a guy has to be part of the Arab so why one's family is different why you have a two family house one get one guide is no problem Supt America that's like sphere to have just one family with the year now guy that's not true but once you have two or more Yiddish your families we have this unique problem that the guy has to be somehow part of the heta but he can't be included in the area you could have a boxer and today till tomorrow the guy is not part of that boxer Matz's so what then is the ADA will soon see you have to be safe as with shows you have to get part of his wishes but what we do see in response to our question is that really a guy I mean Mickey the tin doesn't have to part of the area you can have an apartment building and ignore him but me there are born on if you have a number of year there's a families with a guy you we say the guy has to be somehow included in the area if you want to see this very clearly the tauren beginning of our sim and shinpei Bayes says mom mr. suicide that Nikita then a guy is not on the map you know cos everything be there Ivana you have to have a part of it if there's two or more families will have will soon see the exact procedure and this indeed is our Simmons for today Simmons in pay pay see if I love the guy he has to be somehow part of the area now to apply this more specifically let's go in order with different groups of questions well title start with the simple Schuyler that let's say you have a two family house upstairs lives a ye down so he's a guy a vice versa so Mia keyed it in you don't need anything the it could carry in his house in his backyard the guy you'd have to make an Arab this is how about this our Mishnah one year and one guy is no problem of course the it should make sure that he doesn't learn from the darker outcome but that's basically enough if you have a three family house to Eden and one guy then we have this issue of being social resource will soon outline in a moment first I want to showcase that an anti-gay question a year lives next door to a guy and they have a common yard and the boys the initial boys are playing ball on Shabbos the ball went into the guy's yard candy it'd walk into the backyard of the guy take the ball and walk back to their house the answer is yes because this is basically two families that are connected one years one guy that's all it is he's living alone guys living alone and basically when you have a year and a guy and that's it you don't need a name so as long as the entire cuts is enclosed you could carry the ball back interesting question and this is becoming more common when you have a living whether again whether it's a nurse for an older person a sick child or it's a live-in maid and the question is they are given their own room or something to give me their own basement their own apartment does that require them to be part of the Erika Terrace now you have a year and the guy living in one location so the answer is if it's a one family house the even living and the guy has their own basement even there's no fear of Erika Terrace because this is one family year the shirt and one guy you should there's no fever and Pateros the question is if you have a two family house two or more family house so now you have two Yudin and one guy says the Prima garden and see if cotton vase you sir also yes Leymah Shari's album yes Lima Doster now you have a scenario of two year the chef emmalee's you need an air of containers the finish in this is that when you have a guy that's renting serious Konya so he's part of the equation he's part of the big picture but if you give the guy you should work or a room but it's not theirs because when young tip comes you move them to a different place that you need to move for your children if you could move them around and they're not paying rent and they don't have any rights to this specific room so they're not like a sofa they don't have really part of the house additionally even if they have their own room but if they eat from one kitchen if it's pizza at heard of it's considered really one kitchen that's feeding all of the people it's like a guest in your home and I still talk to them our shaman Haley Bob Simon you Italian asks this on the crema Gaza he says why is the green MacArthur Makai even air if the fire it's not a regular rental that requires an air so the emphasis is not still because it could be the prima garden was talking about a scenario and to go ahead its own room that can't be moved and it's all but we could say in response to our original question if you have a guy a full time living guy that's working living in the house usually an Arab is not required if it's a one family house certainly not if it's a two family at three two family house and this to Eden and the guy has his own basement that's theirs and their own food then you should focus on making a proper area the question that we began with someone I'm summing here from the grab that said he was then that up in China for Shabbos he wanted Kerry in the hotel the after making air pateros try making an air of her in a Chinese hotel you don't know where to begin so if he's certain he's the only year there for Shabbos believe it or not he's a lot of Kerry in the hotel but it becomes a question when Shabbos morning he bumps into another geek from Borough Park and he says happy I mean very unhappy to see you because he really is unhappy to see the other year because now he has to Eden and he has to really stop caring because now we have to Eden with gladium and then an Arab really was required all along well soon see that Jim isn't a ton Shabbos but again if you know certainly he's the only year on the premises there is no here very the question that we began with the bungalow colony which means it was a gunner they made a beautiful Arab to her semester that's a race and it was an oversight they forgot that there was a non Jew living on the premises so the truth is that Arafat this point is not good because since there's many families of the guy they needed to include the guy well soon see the ASA is Spheeris even on Shabbos but that was the problem hopefully they should have solved it on Shabbos we had a question I'm sorry for Shabbos but on Shabbos also is innate we had a question there was a different bundle colony Schuyler but this is the the Macias that the guy a guy from outside rented the store and ran the store the local vongole economy store so the guy was working I think five days a week from 9 to 3 or 9 to 5 whatever it is and the guy rented had exclusive rights that is store and the bungalow county does that require more than just an air cut series with the families can I have a guy on the and he was paying rent and it was his exclusively so there is one redeeming factor that the guy doesn't really live there and his Markham PETA his source of food is not in the store now even though if he's there a whole day he has to eat lunch or supper whatever it is but that's not as not completely he's now living there and this goes back to one of the gotelli areas showing him the Taj bus and failing Bay's Simha Marmot vuelven then mr. Rosman and the rush and Hoover's say the same thing but the Tasman smells it out he has come out this shyly has about a guy a baker that rents a bakery he's as posh it if that Baker has his own home even though he eats by day in his bakery but that's not Malcolm PETA and therefore he does not fit into this big picture he's not really considered a dweller in this regard he has a bakery he's there for a good part of the day but he doesn't sleep there he doesn't eat his regular meals there the fact that he eats luncheon and supplement when necessary does not make it Malcolm PETA so basically I love he's not on the pill face and cut a race map interesting question now I guess we could understand why it's not a Shila but for those that are there go away it's a cap a stock or they sell their house for pay sir they're selling the house to a guy now assuming you're living in apartment buildings for now Oh suddenly guy owns or renting this house does that require a new area of Caceres can now we have a new guy that has a house if he brought it around to the cafe sir the answer I hope is postured the guy even if he brought it then even if he or rented it and even if he did it la loca but he's not living in it's a lot less than welcome PITA it's mommy's not his place and you know the guy will not eat bread in your house over Pesach you could be certain now you even know even though he has rights and he has legal rights but he's not living them he could do it but he's not living them if he's not living there it again is not part of the question of Erica Saylor's I just heard this silence could I dimension it because it brings out the point there was a No houses in Kensington with that sweetness thought it was a few houses one next to the other and the backyards were pretty much connected so a number of the others of families made a big air of cuts areas that connect let's say four or five homes so the children could go from one to the other through the backyard and play the sixth home was a year that had her own the house and he had a great you should tenant and that wasn't part of this big area of chaos recently wanted include him into the air of continuous so it came out interesting thing all the years that the Year lived with the guy used to tenant you don't need any area at all they're just one on one there's no fever now all of a sudden he wanted include it in the bigger area now taka the guy has to be reckoned with because now he's part of the bigger picture now there's a few eatin at him so you would have to come on to what we said the Spheeris Fisher says will soon see but the point is you have to snow the basics the step one part one is when there's a one year and one guy nothing is required because me it could it in again a guy is not in the equation as far as health is everything part two which is a limb of course a lot more challenging is when you have more than one year dish' family you have an apartment building again the ngah light that living in in Flatbush have the shower all the time whether it's non-jews or Fri Eden a bungalow colony basically what is the eighths of when you have a non Jew a Friday person on them in this area and you have the halacha that he has to be part of there but he's not part of there so this is our Mishnah and we'll soon see the details you have to make sukira stressors you have to get richest for his property and then he is so sort of part of the aims but before we get to the eighties maybe today biz man has there maybe you don't really need an answer and here is the following suggestion that has the sauce in rishonim maybe the hold in that a guy has to be included in the area was in those days that basically even live in their own little step lock or ghettos it was exclusively you even then and the real scenario that you had a lead with the guy he has out around upon that and wanted to make sure it doesn't happen so they made a difficult that he thing you have to make an air but he's not part of their in others when it was not typical to have a year ago you living together then we have to find aces to try to prevent that relationship but bisman has there even in bar parking Flatbush and then them all over they were hidden and going about living peacefully so what do you say don't do the Arab doesn't work we don't you live together but we're living together it's a done deal it's happening so why should this Monkeywrench be necessary today it's done anyhow so in other words when was the real America dinner guy is not part of it all we just want to discourage living together but today that it's happening and we are living together maybe you don't have this monkey wrench that really makes the problem because no today it's being done whether we like it or not I will say me some foolish who gives you the right to start to saying this not long replies and this is different so there is a precedent that we see things might have changed the Aloha is it's a possibility that a ye'd is allowed to lend money to a gravy rivers but me there are born on the Sigma involvement SIA that I now lift shimmy yo might be myself we don't want needing to be dealing with for longer periods of time and you get involved with business and money lending so you know I learned to a guy be rivers sucked Isis in buffman see that I enema days that on the shrine Bainer almost today thigh saying his times that any I will living with I'm not doing business with with gyeom day and night there's no longer that concern because they're ready it's happening any out and you go back to the equator then you allow to lend money to a guy be river and that's talking a passenger they assimilate cook none tests so we see aha so we see such a approach me make it at the end we shouldn't do it but today that it's done so we go back to original offer but the Emmis is a kept the fact is that tasteless Lamesa says it regarding witness that today is different and it makes no mention this regarding else's Arvin maybe for some reasons the helical teen air vent and rivers but what should be the hillock so I want to mention the Guiness rodham inhaler gimel Simmons of Bayes vivir Moscow kukuda the Mizzou he Tucker says this Lamesa he says that week there is it's out to be make when you have a geyser pennant that since today anyhow he's olivine astok Parnassus a know we should happen also we can't live alone so the Guinness world them already mentioned it's out to be make of his man Hazare the marsh I'm inhaling the case in Muhammad Ali quotes of the summon rush some rushes question who wrote it is it the roster some site for calls at the kids veja rush not the rush okay he quotes that Bush and America is a rule but the Martian quotes that the salmon rush that Bashar saqqaq Naha goolah 'aka with this Laura but as I said bear mister spoonful carrot Tice's says the cooler gotta be Ribbit's now look I Bearden I what's the shot okay it's very possible business doesn't foster a real relationship if you're gonna lend money to a guy you become a business acquaintance someone's a competitor and the Mattias is call effort saying it venereal nursing so dealing in business virtually taking someone else's money doesn't make a friendly relationship so we can say today don't worry about it but living in the same house with non-jews that's what caused all were concerned about so even if we might make a by rivers who said you could apply that to health is everything and that's why the postgame reject this forum but some safe and sim inside the gray says the cloud saref minion alkyl ethereal you have to be on the same status to revoke a tack on Azazel but I did see the base mayor and shinpei Bay's seek off he says if you have no other choice there is a child to be same on this floor Ravana and Greta three tubers dalaman baisemeaux of MEMS I enhanced the end of South Italian and is lost in the last two with a sniff by Alma kadar iam good Gangnam I meet them eylül you could follow this that if you have other sleeve from the huckle that if you have a guy that doesn't want to cooperate and you can't find a better eight sir perhaps today is different even though as I said that some say four holds you after them in your NASA I'm slaying the clip of Bihar the battalion's has passed me and cook above casa milà house killing McCain so I can't say it's posh it but as another sniff perhaps this floor would work one thing I will mention I saw the necklace Vieira de is Simon Coughlin test he says that we find regarding Rivest that atomic problem is allowed a length to a graver rebus can we say that least tomahawk Imzadi Luba to go doctor now cos we're very similar smart he says Lamar comic awesome if you lens with Larry rivers or not he's not gonna have a fun friend not gonna get learned me myself but if a macaque am is living with a guy day in day out that's the chakras I will concerned about shimoyama be myself so now we see basically we're back power Mishnah that if you have readin and one guy or even any more than one guy certainly you have to find the native what is the answer for example of an apartment building that has some guidance from fryer people what is the ASA to make a box of matzah for the all Yeadon and a Bunga colony is fine but once you have one go you or more or one fryer or more then we have a problem so as we mentioned the mission the juror says you have to be sighs delicious man what that means very basically is you give the guy a token payment will soon see even less than us of a puta and you rent his rights to his apartment now his apartment becomes mine as well the Rambam insane everything Bayard or the hasta Arkham kilo array of heme iron it's as if now I have the virus and the guy is living by me now in other words what basically the problem was that we had that there was a non-jewish person living on the premises now you made a token Pyrrhus it's like it's your house as well the grain Yakov and even some obeys adds that really there's nothing wrong with having a go there but Sammy yelling you myself so therefore try to find a different place to live but mom I said you can't find different place to live so now you have no choice then you go back to you could didn't just any little token Spheeris is good enough now Lamesa the Gomora calls it this is an every time i think the most important two words for today this Spheeris is a sphere a straw it's a very inferior Spheeris why is that we'll soon see because you don't need almost anything to make this series the camaris of the fair is even less than sour proof to works you could even do it on Shabbos when you can't make a Kinyon you don't start this serious as the Ramban puts it in in Perak days I'm lucky good base a little late on the other pair the other bahai mentioned shot Cyrus capital rich Lewis Shaina say Faris vada Ella heck evolved odd again it's basically a symbolic token that the guy is giving you rights to his house so when this house I'll make Xavier there a bonnet that a girl has to have to find a Nate's up when it's his house when you have a hey look of it when he's nervous was just to you you basically avoided the prom the house that were concerned about but again the manga site is it's really make it then you don't need anything it's exactly abundant so with a minimal scheme us through oh yeah that's enough there's a choleric and shinpei berries see if Dalit says you could even do it on Shabbos we'll soon see how but again you're not being kind of the go his house you know people approach the guy can i buy your house i'll give you less than a penny disrespectful and it's wrong you're not buying this house it's basically a Bittle resource the gomorian air even Islamic berry that Tom mentioned earlier shinpei hey that you could even give him less than us ever proved too high there's no Qingyun in this world that works with less atomic Ruta is not a Kenyan there are moss says and also see fade you could even do it on Shabbos and I'll give you a good example the Berlin Connelly story that we mentioned they made a beautiful tourist FSF we made a beautiful haircut failures but they forgot to go Isha Paula boss go over them on Shabbos and basically say could we rent your resource right now you can't give him money says the mr. Berger's money is mucked up so give him some item of food and again leave even a minimal amount it's not buying his house you're not stealing his house you're taking her logic right it's not even legal rights because you're not making a start it's a logic rights that you have a pay look of his house the mr. Burriss says with the reason why it works she ain't a spirit vada he's a little research - heck of a Alma again you're not exploiting the guy you're not mistreating him you're getting what you need which to him is really meaningless divya waka and see if allah says that Matano will not work unless it's a real Madonna because there has to be some form of actual sphere s masseuse the biggest finish which is based on the Quran even doc pay that if the guy refuses you could go to his wife even though he's not happy with it but says the and but my my sir if the guy is your woman will have consent or anybody of the family it's also good because you're not buying the house you don't need the balla bus you need some form of connection to that house and this is taka keep askin Inchon sama didn't pay very few dollars the mr. this artsy and says a loss Shin Megami this how you resolved in Sweeney's vini it's not a regular Kenyan but it's a Kenyan regarding this fear us rule and then the word spirit who is the most helpful words for today what exactly should you tell the guy when you make this ceremonial Kenyan so the shock on earth and see if Dalit says ain't sorrowful of Irish lace sure hula had to tilt them don't try to explain to him we want to carry because he's just gonna get concerned he's not gonna know what's happening you basically I think the rightness of is you take your nice $2.00 give them a nice you know have to be a mention I am renting the rights to your apartment that I need for religious purposes it doesn't happen in stand the whole I make of the sukhiya and you're not fooling him is not Gaza Malcolm has to show them the high autumn and iron haze alien says saruyama house Calera Josefa I need rights to your apartment so I could carry my apartment and you could certainly promise him that he's not going to lose not gonna cost him anything he's not giving up anything it's basically he's keeping his but now I have a right to carry a my house or my or our common yards no it was not that Vickie's it's not it's matter it's not taking his violence you don't need to Keith at all and again don't be afraid to be honest because honestly is the best way to do things you're not taking it and are buying it you're basically taking a bit Lyra shows that now you have a sizes now this to me was very interesting but I think I couldn't explain it meet at fo the guy is not part of your concern urban so you can make an error and totally ignore him du hast thou made it very difficult for us to coexist with the guy and you're and therefore he's not part of the earth and you have to make scarce resource but he came to serious resource it has unprecedented coolers less than us have a puta even on Chavez no star tell you was often you could use his wife will soon see serial Akita so things be two extremes meet our efforts has not made it difficult we touch a me the Spheeris is the easiest thing in the world because the point is we try to discourage it if it can't if it has to it has to be the way it is now make it easier as long as you got the message that we try to maintain our knit 3 is the Abdul s women arm and that's the secret of that successor although you shocker now in apartment building but we have 50 families does every year have to go to the guy and say could I be safe for your wishes so now that you understand a little makings of the sukiya its passion a father not as long as the guy he was my vice versa just to even one of the Eden that's enough and that's why it says the Pharisees in chief test of our sim in that one heat they may excuse us with the guy is enough you know if they have all these marching into the guy's house if you have a few guy in tackle yep it's carries just some each one of them is out of fear we want to get everybody on board for this pair of Caceres now you're not to tell the guy I am a representative of all the people in the apartment girl you're gonna scare him unnecessarily you don't have to do that as long as you one year has rights to his apartment then has solved the problem that we are facing okay when they get there okay hopefully get there at the end now the my sir the question that comes up quite often you made America Terrace in apartment building and one gate moved out and then another it moved in he was not there when you made the original series of shows we have to do it over again and the answer is absolutely not think about its portion the guy gave up his Bible is he's still living there why should a new year acquire new scarier shows he didn't give it to the guy via got left you don't have to buy you do not have part of it as long as he relinquishes bonus part of his Bible is so and it's still in existence so the fact that it was not there be shots of here so shows has absolutely no bearing on decision now a challenging question I should say a very beautiful question because it's an idea but it really brings us to the Shanghai takasugi let us begin let us now go back to one of the questions we began with they didn't in the bunker for example made a wonderful - a suppressor and Pateros they forgot to make it fresh with the guy so let's assume they remember they remembered on Friday so you wonder what's the problem go Friday give the guy a few dollars say could we be regulars just and now retro actively the area bust out what's wrong you made a nice area you had a problem that you forgot to go I still include and then you go back to the a of right or maybe since when you made the Arafat tears with all the Eden there was a guy and he prevented the error from working maybe you have to do it all over again maybe it's not Fallon there was a guy that wasn't included and if you want to be very tactical the kumaras lotion in evidence I'm afraid that we learned earlier an area from my album Alka maqam so if you went through all the motions to making Erica terrorized but it was ineffective because there was a guy living there in other words maybe you have to go in the right order first fear is vicious and then you have to make an air of Caceres if you don't follow that order it's invalid or you might say what should be this far in that if all the heat and joy and making air cuts a race that's good how does every fares work by the way if you have 50 families that have share one hallway or one bongo County the lawn you have to make you one family air means remix so what's wrong if we first mix now 50 families is one family i we have a problem so solve the problem why is it absurd in the area it's a problem so if you have a problem you solve it so this question is a wonderful question and the be I love sub and see if I love discusses this and he says taka fungal Asha Nakamura ain't era of Moya of amok amok and would seem to indicate that you first have to make the series and then the area but then he points to a camera - Sam evolved that seemed to say you could first make care of and then cipher mistress and then he quotes summer saying say if I cared so the allaha says a beautiful shot he says in Florida there's nothing wrong with first making the era of making all Yeadon one and then solving the problem of the non-jewish participant so why should there be a soiree that you have to first make the serious resource suck the velour golden of art because if you make the air Crusaders the amenities are make a brothel you can't make a brother at that point because the air was not effective because the guy was not threatened with ends up to be a law firm also the gray might say no so then you made a brothel that's all but you can't make a brothel on an air that's really ineffective so really meets either a live you could make the air and then you can make spirits with us the problem is only regarding the broker so therefore both the UK my right meet side the area of you can make any order but let my sister ain't areum is not gonna work here if it doesn't work yet you can't make it brown eyes I wanna make a broker but we know them ourselves famous Russian in the trubiz to do a mixer without a bra as an oven goggles so I do that now I saw it as a safe a hakama slave while hiding on how Kazarian I'm a crook flop addresses all right this be I love her it would come out that in a situation you're not making a bra then tacky you can make the area first and then you could make this clear sisters but also I want to mention in the previous case that we mentioned on the bongo County with a Mary made the air and ready made the Bravo so not to do it over again we have to do now is go to the guy you're making Spears for shows and the air but you did originally was feel caution now another question that that is thrown that say for Hoffmeister laid on with Coughlin Lyman Zion discusses how about the other question you first made it surah step s around the whole bangla county strings and or whatever you need user and then you made skiers it's just from the guy is there any reason that the sphere is just to go first and then it's your successor so he says what should be have Amina that there's an order it's two independent concepts one is making it one reaches in physically and then you have to work with the the fact that God is there he does crota Rivage and tough cop Zion that both the dust tire and see valid and the car behind she'd gotten test i'ma died from the Rivage that first you have to have spheres to shows and then you have to pure suppressor but he shows conclusively that that's really a miss reading of the of the reverse the reverse which does not mean to say that it's possum you'll see the lost you'll see its Oh dig like he says and he says every awesome greet him that even though did that tell you the kappa hi mom asked me but Matata swore it definitely makes sense that you can make the servicer pass up the string stick area first and then afterwards you can make a little officials the term point is that it's really two independent procedures why should they be an order that's mahaki I'll tell you where there might be an order that's market we can understand it and that is if you buy a used Pat from a non Jew so in shock on earth ancestry that many resign him before you title it you have to capture it that's smart because titling is bringing in the glue shuts its route but if it still trade it's lacking the dishes hero now we understand it has to be an order but in this case why should we be in order necessarily doesn't seem to have any smaller why this has to go before after the sphere s mistress let's say you have a bundle of county or you have a apartment building and you want to make history sisters and it's not so difficult you give the guy your token payment and you take valueless for how long does this work can you do it indefinitely for the rest of your life because it is there a lot of time wonders that does it get expired after a while and the truth is the base the ICC records the Minich that every Arab Shabbos they would make another scarce resource dr. banks the ice if it's not necessary you could do it once for many years why you doing every Arab shop is sort of a sex is very Mustafa for it to make it difficult you have to do it every single week is you know this is difficult let's get the Jewish tenants in the future so it's basically part of the original objective to try to keep us valve the lesson but Lamesa debase the ice it does say clearly that if you make it indefinitely it works cause Mon as long as the great does not we retract from his Pyrrhus the Screamers adjust is in effect the question is so if it does work indefinitely is there any time limit could work forever so the Emmis is that it really doesn't spire the air Faris that we put down a mots I should mention could last a year or two but after a while it gets wormy or it gets you know inedible you have to keep on refreshing it so to speak but an a but this fear is just you're not putting on a matzah or something doesn't get stale infested by bugs theoretically it could work forever and shinpei Bay's Steve Zaillian the circle nerve says that if you made it for 10 years and every 10 years it expires you have to do it over again if you make it forever it never expires the mr. Brewer says kashat that if it expired you have to make a new one the guy can take it out let's just keep it you have to make a new spheres for shows but that's only when you limited it originally but if you make it forever the ferrets posit that it works in fact I saw one of these Gedaliah placed him to base Lima 'cimmanon olive he says that really making it a longer time is better than just making its time without a time why he says let's say you make it's done I meant to nourish us it could be totally for one Chavez more so if you make it spam like we say I'm just renting your wrist without making a time limit what happens when the gray moves out and other guy moves in so you can't say that the first guy made it for the second going so then you have to do it over again so as well should this go who the holy a day is safer she believes mom cuts if you don't make it time use comedy coolly absurd there are many problems first of all it might be only one week it might but the gray moves out you have a problem with the new guy buddy says if you make let's say for twenty years and that's the number he uses then it's good for twenty years and will soon see this the pie tomorrow did you post the placement say this if you made it with guy number one for 20 years and then he sold the house to a different guy believe it or not it's still effective because the second guy could only buy from the first grade but the first guy owns and he gave their hey he only owns the house without a little butt masseuse he gave it to the heed the my mother said recently shady he could only sell to the second guy where he owns so depends depends on the up map but if he tactic gave versus for twenty years and he gives it over to the second guy the way it is he doesn't have more so many pay small is good so the big slam that's the best frame it probably also means to imply if you make it without a time limit it could be only one week and you name problems with future people that are taking over the house so basically we see three you say this if you do its time without a time it's problematic you could do it for a longer time but when every time you do it if you if it expires if you say 20 years 20 years how long can you actually make it as long as you want so this is interesting the back and the hadass is the end of sim and valid it seems to imply I made it for 50 years is a long time the base limas says I'm not so happy with 50 years that makes it a hooker be crueler like a joke I'm really not so sure what it means a hooker through that I mean the whole thing I wouldn't say it's a joke but the whole thing is a serious reward lessons interpreter on Shabbos know star tell you was oven so if all that doesn't bother us why olds that making in 50 years is such a problem but michl Amos says he doesn't like fifty years so he says make it for 20 years he says because 20 is a lot less than fifteen come swing in the chin a famous Truman sim involved has a problem of 15 years for different reason because you're not dealing with the bow the boss himself if the only problem Buster's worker so he's a breakthrough flipping he gives you the bottle of Buster's house or 50 years maybe the bow bus is not happy so it seems that if you deal with him our boss directly could even do 50 years Solem I said the mr. Berlin this is the one of the few places that mr. real close today slamming the scholar of mr. Steve Kot Memphis he writes his schema harborough cranium via colossal is corrals man or akhirah you could even do 50 years after the heart illa totally miss Larock add a stream shaman and start seeing quotes this Langley so the myself again if you did it forever it works no one holds it doesn't work but it's good to make it mr. burr across the beach laying over 20 years I should mention if you can make it whatever years you make it 10 or 20 years mark it down in the place that you remember to see it because you make it 20 years and you forget about it 20 years comes and then it's sort of self destructs so maybe put it the same place you write down when the last time you checked your mezuzahs you have to do it twice in seven years so if we have that in a place that you see it occasionally so you'll becomes been in contact how long you have yet until this skills just becomes invalid it also makes sense that if you're dealing with the biome directly you can make it even longer than twenty years at least according to local haunts me now as I mentioned earlier the question is that when you made a serious with one good and then the guy changed to sell to different guy they're lucky is that the Spheeris is still good I said as man choking I'm sorry it is in choke on oxy fess and mr. Burris says because my my sir the first guy only owns the house - the Spheeris and when he sold that the second guy he song the house - the Spheeris so it is actually be fair assume I have I'm sorry I said it earlier this one differently but the mohab is the Farish the second guy only got buys the house with the scarcest in place until the end of 20 years question this be a beautiful heart let's say you have a three family helm right now this one year and one girls living there no area no participation of the gray required now a lead moves in and pays to the greater landlord the a nice hefty 59 mm month rent now all of a sudden we have a problem because you have to make an area you have two families you have one guy right oh let me tell you a very nice phone if you have two years on one good and you give the guy a half a penny so it's good right here it's just as good so now if the kid comes along and gives down $1,500 rent why can that be scary so shows so any anomaly you need it but it comes with the serous mother bless her puth is good cause game rental but the muhabba there are more and see if I love says the fairies when the inmates pays for rent he can't use that as seriously shows the question is why I think the answer is very possible these theorists is a solution to the problem you have a creative to make an error but the guy can be part of it by giving him a screen rest you get in his bias in this case the Spheeris is making the problem you're making the need for the area you can't use the problem as a solution and this is I think the rapture-con RF and C phase means he says it can't work the in light came by extra bein of dearest Eva evaluates emission the sphere is exposed to the air P of a problem it's a solution but here the Spheeris are paying the rent is making the problem the problem can't be a solution there's another shock which is also push it and that the heavy go has a mission pay base hey says cousin ish says that the sphere is supposed to get part of the glacier apartment here you paying your rent for your apartment so you're not really addressing the problem so that both shut them are true and both talked to my Emma's the lamai set when a person pays rent that's not serious he has to go after the rental and take a again Akopian theorist from the guy if the guy refuses to take part of Spheeris so this is a Gomorrah it's very interesting in urban some of kimmel I'm a gamer speaks about a certain person last one bar is cook and twice this makes a point of saying if you look in the rack its harman barista and the Vergara and many price can quote hummin so interesting it's almost poem and Harman will become to a nice Jewish boy with the name Harmon but the terrace is questioned it wasn't yet this Hartmann by mystic was a joy and he refused to take part of the earth so what's the answer so the Gemara says and of Sam McGee mo zhee low but English society the Gabi fact go try to have one of the eaten give over his wishes to the other kid so now is one year one guy you have a problem tomorrow no doesn't work here but a less with shows does not work you can't make to eat into one and there's only one and one doesn't work by you but by a guy so what's the aid sir so stuff to give aren't even a summer salad the 8c is go over to the guy this hummin and ask him to hold something a hold one of your items now you have rights to his apartment to hold an item somehow get rights to use his apartment and the murse is meeting to have iliacus period Akita now since you have a right to keep your item in the Galatian apartment you have rights this apartment and you are like Spiro the kita and this website is used in many situations when the grape does not want to cooperate or maybe when there's too many Guardian to go to each and get a serious vicious there's something called a theory oddity thing which basically means if you could go to a worker that works for all the Guardian or works for the entire apartment building and you get the richest from him that he represents all the Guardian so instead of going to each individual guy you go to a representative the goddess periodically rashes as he remains a full-time worker the keep that means he cuts the crops but basically a serial Akita and the shocked American your olive says is like an each time a vimini split or steal the key tie you louder take a serious even the guy who refused to cooperate so here we see an eighth so that might be much more practical instead of going to eat go go to cereal Akita and then have rights to all the apartments it's up to mr. burr how does one worker give away so many visualize the same you say this is really a Spheeris Maroa you don't really need it it's good enough if you go to his representative his worker and he could do it for all his the guy used to tenants the beer locker quotes an axiom item that the sphere the key has to have rights in the apartment which very often a worker keeps some of his tools or something in the apartment so this is known as the stimuli Keaton once you locate will soon see if the superintendent's a good idea but once you locate a serial the key type go straight to him and make a serious with him the same way you did it with the guy listen to a beautiful holler you could have and this grata comes up quite often you have a guy that owns an apartment building deregulation and got used to tenants you have to make an area and you have to get a few other key thing the the guys should landlord has a leadership building manager who is has rights to all the apartments so it's a wonderful idea you have a year a year this is clear the key type go straight to him and work out as Pierce is just right well let's be a little more aggressive once the year is as clear of the kita you'd have to even make it serious because he's part of the area so the question is how does she really keep they work does it work that he is like the Bilaam and all the apartments then he's included in the air the matzo if he's a representative of the guy she's not better than the guy you have to mix here so shows Cerezo pail and see if you advance this is my life is two days in Sahara if Syria lakita works automatically or you have to make a serious wish us and the swara in the mouth white is like I told you if you learn Cyril Akita is like the by limb he is a new violin he's mr. owner so then if he's a year it works automatically he's part of them back some answer but if he works as a representative of the guy he's not better than the guy and there are too days in South America and the muhabba in fact the circular says Mahakala mr. burrows McCullen c-cut ma'am Aleph not flying la flesche the Safari showing them so if you do find a leadership representative let's say the building manager and his rights the apartments go to him and say I'd like you to be a representative for all the I'm gonna give you a token payment I want to be social it's just of all the fryer and the guy you should people and then you have a wonderful air cut service last but not least a tricky question is who's considered as clear of the kita so the most popular question of Hazare even is what we used to have a superintendent and became call the super Janet I'm building manage whatever it is is a superintendent a valid serial to keep day for all the workers in other words since he's cleaning the halls and taking out the garbage and doing all the work for all the tenants and before the holidays he reminds he's working for you you know so maybe that's a skill the key for all the tenants so you have a simple lights of go to him rent the resource of all the grime and fryer and then you can make a regular haircut sales and I've heard people say this that the superintendent is a serial Akita of all the tenants the problem is that reality is who is hiring who's paying who could fire the superintendent on the landlord so he is working for somebody but not for the tenant he working for the landlord and as early as the debris Malkiel in the ash Mathis to hail the game of similar Aleph he says what people are that making sure stress with the Strongs which is presumably is the worker is wrong he says because these destroys which i think is somewhat of a super is working for the bala bus not for the garnish attendants the Marshawn inhaler case in Milan with verve has an idea you could rent ski researchers from the measureless sup Tamar Chamonix not true the landlord high is the mushara sister clean up the apartment it's not the tenants of the apartment building it's the landlord so he some does it if each tenant gives part of the payment to the superintendent okay then he's working for each one but if it's a regular scenario that they that the boundary layer mode is paying for the superintendent he that he's a worker for the landlord not kill attendance and that's why I think there's a problem with going straight to the superintendent of the building manager or the janitor whether you want to call him but he's really working for the ball a boss it could be a different kanae-chan I think this might this might have some truth to it why is a landlord spending all that money having a full-time worker in the apartment building and especially not to be living there the answer is basically he has to satisfy the tenants part of the rental that every tenant pays is to help pay for this worker so why don't we say that the each tenant pays part of the rent to maintain the building and the balla boss is like hiring the superintendent for all the tenants I mean the truth disease that's really where he works I saw that cosmas a lathe he says it's something like a scalar sphere you're telling the landlords to hire workers for me now it's really not actually that but definitely we could say that it could work because at the end of a he's working for each tenant individually now Lamesa there's a different approach and that is if the janitor the superintendent has rights to keep his clayey vadose he keeps the mops and the brooms in the cup in the common hall that means he's keeping his stuff in our Hall because the hall belongs to all the tenants I mean have rights to all the tenants so maybe it's like we had that he he's keeping stuff in our apartment and all the apartments I go straight to him he's representing all the attendants avinash decline in the trubiz inhaler dial don't test someone wrote him that the puppy loves behind LaRocca hell you could go straight to the superintendent and he says I cannot gonna put Perot but I think it's a mistake because the superintendent is working for the ballet boss not for the tenants MA mr. Steiner but rose master caught himself in simin intestine Simon Schama develops the concept that you could make a serious just with dibala boss because the balla boss has rights in every apartment dibala bus keeps items of is in every apartment so he has rights in every apartment if you go straight to the balla boss that might be the answer so we just recommend when someone has a need for an heir of an apartment building one will counter with is a guy consult with a Mayan hero you could sometimes you could use the superintendent when you pay him directly someone who could use the bala boss whatever you do do it right we're talking about doing it for 20 or more years do it right and last but not least let me tell you a beautiful aura I saw this from the Brisky rub he once ended up somebody for Shabbos and he was in Switzerland and it was a gay person on the premise that he had to make his Kirsten shoes so the bisgrove had an idea he says please hold my umbrella in your house over the over Shabbos it was very honored to cut to come into this curve and then he's a lot of carry so he might Festiva screw of having about the gain from the truth is not to be scrubs - that was gotta finish it - the Pharisee kumara that we mentioned get get let him hold your item the my 'this is the mascara of new the Gemara and applied it but basically this is the eight so you'd have to go hold something for you and then he's like work if you have part of his vicious the basin says it's if you tell him to hold it even though he puts it into one Lachlan but you have rights he could move it from place to place but this is an eight so now the mice you're not gonna give your guy your neighbor if you have a three family house to hold your umbrella but I saw him that safe across must aim is to give all to get eight sir knocking two guys go and say you know I would be very comfortable if you would have my teeth to keep in my apartment just in case something happens I need access you need access please hold my key indefinitely then you have a ride to his apartment now I wondered that's a great idea cuz its base - c'mon it's like the Biscay rub but the guy is holding your key you're not very comfortable that ASA have a simple eight to give him the wrong key as long as he has a key it's okay he's long as holding your item it's not working because the miser he has rights to your apartment it works for Kennedy Christ this apartment he's holding an item this is grab the answer your question when you have a city a roof which is a different shear which is not for now but witty if you go to every single guy so there's some eights you go to the government officials which is not so push it because they have no rights to your apartment you know we have the third amendment they can't station soldiers in your apartment some have a merge that gets out because the the water meters is in every single of mota meters of lecture meters is in every single home so you go to eat electric company or you go to the government it has the water meters they have part of their part of their item is in your house but that's really a shift for itself but basically here's the suger make sure it's done right I wouldn't talk to you say making shirt I like giving extra characters mister today she like you big issue care just simply calling to support it today she'll do the initial install this if you think when we saw like cutting of a solemn I would like to have two great supposed to sponsoring a she called ears and she retired seven one eight eight five one eight six five one those missiles say a seeker on the shin about five minutes are not even a costumer service mobilization is so freaky everyone's our mission her mother knows offensive on Cisco jogged off arrabiata [Applause] [Music] you don't mind to make a movie moves up a second is just your voice everyone here's an on a roof is one of us and we have a/c come from Smith's on today's show just take a few minutes [Music] just saw some relented SSM personal support learn a lot on the Audion office and basically when there's a non Jew or a irreligious Jew on the premises on the in the area and the bungalow county in the apartment in the apartment building in a three family house he's really not required to be part of the area but as a deterrent as al said you have to do something skills just to get him as part of the area but one ye'd and one guy is you go back to the original la jolla mice and nothing is required and i'll tell that only one year is there and all really does not eat any air whatsoever if a guy has a store but he's not living on that on the premises the fact that he eats lunch there he's as if he's not there if a guy buys a room or a house for Pesach again does not require an Arab because he's not living there a maid that's living in someone's house but not an independent apartment that she has exclusive rights to or even if she has rights if she's eating together with the family she does not complicate matters at all because it's as if it's part of the family when you have a situation where a guy is living with to Eden or more then we have this interesting combination me Akira didn't you don't need anything me there are Bonin you need a spiritual to I guess to send the message that this is not ideal try to find other accommodations but if it's necessary when you have to Eden and one good you need a minimal Spheeris through a token hiring of the guy's property an apartment building where you have using a and a hotel when there's more than one year and there's some and the truth is even today where the mice that we are living bein ha Kyung and anyhow it's it's happening but we still will still like the Sun cypress as we stay with the original lava and we don't change we try to keep this halakhah of spirits which shows the site of spiritus you're not buying his property you're not stealing from him has to show them there's no gas alarm going on it's basically a token rights that you have choices to his apartment even less than us of a puta works even on Shabbos when there's no Kenya nom it works even tell you of a sovereign you don't need a star all you have to have is some type of rights to his apartment if a yield in after the scarcest it's fine there's no problem with that because as long as you have the guardianship was just it's fine if only one he has to make spirits truce with the girl you don't have to have all the Eden you could do it after the Arafat heiress was made the only promise as far as the brothel but you want to make a profit of course you should make the hereis and then the era of the order of Taurus of pestilence clearest ability is no water any order is good weaker than you could make this researchers forever Dominica's to make it for 20 years okay but more than that is also okay but the min ago to make it for 20 years you made a spirit with the guy and the guy sold to a different guy the serious resource is still in effect this a second ye'd rents the apartment and now we have two years and a guy that does not count as the Spheeris resource because that's the problem not the solution what the sums because initial you have to get part of the goyish apartment if the guy refuses to participate in the scarcest you could use his wife or child or cereal the key type like we said his worker or permission to keep an item in his possession a Jewish clearly kita it's McClay cos if you need serious but dishonorably mr. Berg is married should have Spheeris resource if a superintendent is a good sphere the kita is questionable if the landlord could be as could be considered the scaler Keith is also questionable so you have to know them it's serious in each particular case but the best thing there isn't age that get permission to keep a item in the Glacial property and that definitely works