Laws Of Boneh On Shabbos As They May Apply In The Common Household - Rabbi Yaakov Zev Smith

it's too far listen to his name [Music] 851-8651 his belt buckle fell off the belt so now he had a strap a piece of leather that was not functional he wanted to know could he attach the belt buckle to the belt on jabba's another child that i saw personally someone was dipsicha obviously was a very weak connection and the whole process fell on top of him it was embarrassing and no one knew what to do so everybody kept on saying along berkshire and he stand there like with the prayers on him should he put it back he'll ought to put it back someone asked the question he wanted to build either a shabbos or on sukis he wanted to build something out of coca-cola crates maybe make a little house maybe a sukkah and as we'll see this is also negative the toys that are today there are many different toys whether it's lego or the new type of toy it's called magnet tiles it's like tiles that stick together with a magnet so now you have a connection but it's not even interlocking like legos so the kits are and elohir is always busy there's always new shyless and newmanciasin but the common denominator is we always visualize buena like you're building something a face with bricks and cement and or glue or a hot hat or something uh of significance is it true sticking things one into the other is enough of an issa of buena also certainly by lego the children play with they don't do it to last you play you take it apart so maybe building has to be permanent like in a house or something of that permanence maybe just toys or magnet tiles that you play and take it apart maybe it's not buena so listen to a real metea because we solve both our problems asked the question where did we find the original buying and as we don't make barnacles in the michigan it was buying them my binyan higher michigan what was the binion in the michigan so you shall be showing us them crushed on them they would interlock they would fit the beams into the sockets on the bottom do you hear what the original binion was no hot hat no glue no cement no hammer nail interlocking putting one piece in the other i'm afraid to compare the mishkan to lego but it's a pretty good comparison both of them you're not connecting it you're fitting one in the other but what's even more striking the mishkan unlike the base hamikdash was not permanent so frag do you show me the same do you show me this show hoisa since they did not know how long they're going to stay it's like a binyan as i stated you shall be the mice of the islamic concludes like one sheet upon him no you don't have to come on to that binyan le binyan in other words the whole question is it tell us you don't have to have opinion forever even a temporary binion is awesome so i don't know if you realize but both of our shy lists we found in the usami which is the makara binion binyan the shaw is a binyan like in the mishkan and interlocking lav dafty building is mishkan so a better definition of building bueno is creating forming assembling but loved africa that you have to build something of significance once said if you steal a child's toy playing la marshall is like stealing an adult's plane for the child that's his life so i'm thinking let go the child builds something in his mind this is my misha kardashian so why don't we say legos is also based on the original mishkan i'll take it apart but then again then that's binyan the show and the embassy you look into gemara especially not long ago you'll see a number of examples of buena that will laugh after building like weak picture at the conventional building shabbos kobe's on the base you make a hole in the ground enough space to hide something even hide a money or hide a ring that's buena the marin in shabbos also based if he puts stones in formation he puts it in the right design let's say landscaping he wants to make a border to his of his lawn so rashi says even though he didn't put tit that's also buying it putting down stones that's going to stay there is buena the umar has in fact the mars spells out there are certain structures that you stack stones and the mars says iloi that the upper level the top level i guess the way they built it it was in a way that the top level stones you didn't have to cement to the bottom levels you just put the stones on and it stayed i guess they did it in a way that it wouldn't fall off but listen to the lush in the gemara placing a stone is already buena yuzuka don't need nails and hammers and glue the gemara has a muscle of boeing in shabbos buena we'll soon see how you do it but you press together the curds of the cheese and you may cheese then you're not cementing you're not knacking nails but what's really significant the murray shabbos but it's all the same thing basically someone was a craftsman a salesman and he would go traveling from city to city i guess he couldn't afford to take a room in a hotel so he had a bed that he would disassemble when he would travel put all the pieces in his knapsack when he got to a place that he wanted to sleep he would take out the pieces and assemble the pieces in other words he's taking parts of the bed and putting it together it's a nice way of saying it and this is quoting now we'll soon see that mostly saying them hold higher in them okay russia is making the partisan but whatever the case is putting pieces together without gluing is moloch their iso because the meter shall proc them they didn't glue it together it fit in nicely something like our lego so boomer gate and boom estate we see lego i'll give you another example the gemara says in shabbos also a connoisseur said on is also to construct on shabbos what's a connoisseur sidon so rashi explains someone's a painter so he has the regular sized paintbrush but he wants to do to a high ceiling and he can't climb up so high he takes another stick attaches it to the first stick and now he has a long paintbrush that's a connoisseur side then he cements or paints zapdikimura that's awesome to make on shabbos you're not building from scratch you're not cementing you're attaching it you're screwing it in and we'll soon see the significance of this and i'm sure there are other eyes but it's very clear that building after the way we picture building construction with a hot hat with a nail and hammers it's basically assembling something that's also awesome now i must mention that we kept on saying that buena is awesome and making a bet is awesome if you notice the original cases of boeing were bakarkam or at least making a structure on the ground building the mishkan digging in the ground rashi has a fiddish on that kimora uh mamzay and meet the shop him that if you assemble the bed the person assembles a bed because rashid is is associated to kharkum or at least ex connected to karaka so rashi says so what does it mean okay so rashid is is still still over just it's not buoyant it's making isis takes exception and twices has arrived from gemara later and basically the mecca in the beginning of shinjuk goes with twices so i feel comfortable to say that buena is loved africa building in the conventional sense it's assembling it's constructing it's putting together also even according to rashi if something's attached to the ground we'll soon see if you attach something to the kitchen sink since the sink is also the ramos said in the beginning of shinjuku dalit a big kaley that's memsa that holds approximately 150 gallons even the cointerashi is considered boeing because it's so big it loses the chem kali so the kitsa we're very comfortable to say that baina is much more applicable than we think it is the rambam when he speaks about cheese and this is a pair zion alohav if you connect pieces we'll soon see what i what what it means by cheese that's also buying them so here you see a striking re resemblance from all this to lego you take pieces you interlock it you connect it ah it's only temporary but that's that's benue show i'll give you a muscle of a brain of a kali and this will date yourself but today in the shiva no one knew what i was talking about but basically they used to have a model i'm out of plane model car it was very good to keep children busy it was a like many many pieces and you had to connect it and after he finished he felt like a million dollars and then he painted it and he put on the the stickers the kids say you make a model of a plane or a boat so this mirror shabbos and tazzayan says that's mama's because that attacker is you're constructing a kali but the truth is lego even though you take it apart it's opinion the show so it still should be awesome you have to come on to a model to be over and the embassies that the police kentucky say and there are in perry good basis even the baby holds binion so now we have a problem i saw the sri sashabus is not over it goes with the passionately xiaomi and he proves that it can't be but one of the writers is from the famous knight to be huda's chuva that if someone uses it makes an umbrella launch obviously an umbrella is only the show so again i can't say everybody agrees but the poi skins seem to agree binyan the show is over now if a person has a binyan shot that can't last it's so flimsy it's so temporary that it can't last but that's not opinion because you can't last i'll give you an example building blocks where we used to play with you put it like pieces of wood you put one on top of the other if a child sneezed the whole thing fell apart that's not opinion if it falls apart so that would be not buena but building blocks that interlock lego or magnet tiles that mamas could last that should be a problem now that we have a better definition of buena is lava after building and construction let's apply it to into many different childhoods so first of all i want to try to explain why making cheese is boeing so without getting into the details the cheese making process you separate the whey the liquid part of it from the piece that's called curds it's a curling process so basically you have the whey which is a liquid that's used in a different way and now you have little pieces of cheese so magavin is you take those pieces those curds put it into either you do it by hand or you put it into a mold and you press it together pressing it together is cheese making that is buena because that's the dab you're connecting the piece of the kurds and that's why the rambam said that that's what maury says but ram explains it let me give you a much more common muscle is the gay of a shabbos especially for yomtiv as you know a number of years ago there was a problem about the copepods the insects invest in water the little tiny bugs in water and many people are mocked but they will not drink to water unless it is strained so there are different methods that don't you could have a a a strainer that's on the in the bottom of the sink before the water comes out but there's a simple method that's known as an easy filter it's a very wonderful idea you screw it onto the sink and that sifts all the copepods and you get water without bugs for those that use it know that depending where you live but if you live in a place that there is the water is is it's depending on the configuration of the piping but there are some places that you have to change the clean out the filter every other day because there's so much impurities and copepods and there's cotton the the charcoal that's used to clean the water but as people that know that every other day the water does not come out it's very slow so you have to unscrew it take a q-tip clean it and put it back the sheila is on shabbos there's no problem of cleaning it because that's you're not doing anything of no malacha but unscrewing the easy filter and then screwing it back on that should be a problem of buena are you not nailing it in or gluing it in but this is at least madabe khaloken but here it's more serious of a problem because here since the sink is attached to the house this is buena bukar even according to rashi and your azapella nish in the end of simon nun gimmel speaks about what eden did for divers i imagine that they had a smarter on this on the sink and pesach they tried to sift at any impurities so the hazardous if you try and smart the tight even if you don't make kesha he's for buena because you're attaching something to the sink no a smartest boner call skin a easy filter that you screw on so tightly that it doesn't even drip and tucker rabelski in the surface page paella although his opinion was that there was no problem with the water you don't need this easy filter but he says but those that use it to screw it or unscrew it is the surim shall be the fact is that you're attaching something on a permanent basis even if you take it off two days later but it's attached very strongly it's a binion on shabbos of caleb again the shaver akasi and alif kuff khafalif says even attaching a shemata like the khasinish coast game a easy filter now consider the next question as they get to all of us let's say you don't have an easy filter you have a different type of or you're not just whatever it is but what happens is you take the leftover soup and throw it into the sink and what typically the soup goes down and the luxian or the vegetables or the bones remain in the strainer the problem is after a while the sink strainer is clogged so the water starts to raise you know rise in its level so you have to be a big plumber to know it's a very simple solution you pick up the sink strainer empty it into the garbage and put it back now there's no chair there's no problem of muktsu with that first of all you know hopefully you don't touch the muksabi adayam and also in our sink the some of it is still edible a vegetable is basically edible oxygen is edible so even if there's bones in it but there's enough heter that we could say that you're not moving just muktsar you're moving heter so because you have to pick up the strainer and empty in the garbage the problem is when you put it back are you the same voice of albinion it's the same sink the same character why is the sink strainer also just like a easy filter is awesome so you'll say no no i'm not screwing it on i'm just putting it in but that's the gemara massage also putting it down but you think about it is it pushed acrylic this sink strainer is made to constantly take it out and put it back unlike an easy filter that's screwed on and becomes part of the sink this is an alma that's not there to stay the worst is you put the upper layer up a layer of a binion you didn't take it off the next day you movatle it there or landscaping stones like we said you put on the beginning of your lawn you're putting the stones there to stay hannah is a problem this you put down and take up and put down and take off it's unreasonable that that's buying them the only reason why easy filters are even though you take it off also after a day and two is when you put it back you put it back very securely so there's takahilak and i saw the arkhashabis in paragraph siflame bay says he has no problem with the removing the sink strainer and i think i know why it's different than a easy filter next questions that kadeir mentioned senona dioima many people have a water faucet in their on the in the back of their houses basically like a piping water faucet and that's you have water that you could use either during the summer months or you could use it in your circle the question is if it was before sukkas before shabbos whatever it is you forgot to attach the hose to the faucet on shabbos you're allowed to screw on the hose onto the faucet so this is the same problem you're screwing it on and you're doing it in a way that it stays and that's tucker problem same place talking and steve gimme dalit tucker points out that this would be a problem of moisture all opinion opinion of character that's not much a problem of bueno someone had the shield of the pot handle fell off but he had the screw so he wanted to screw it back on shabbos so he thought there's no problem because the screwdriver is taken and type is the tougher the problem of much is not a problem but the problem with bueno this is screwing on a handle to a pot that's not a tikkun question i hope it's not nigeya but when sukkas comes later in the season it could happen person had a wonderful sukkah a wind came and blew off his bamboo mat now he has a beautiful sukkah but it's not kosher so can you put the mat this mat back on top of the circle so then the person was worrying about muktsa the different person rather but everybody's worried about but he'll do it and i'll move it without touching it via dying but this he's missing the point putting onto a sukkah is real bueno it's oil it's putting the roofing on the sukkah and this already is character attached to the ground the fact that the sook is on the ground and taka the price kim are clear about this that to put on sukkah is a shia labeouf says if put the point is that this is a serious problem that's lost that's an issue you don't have to glue this the fact that it's there is the problem but now we come to an extremely important aside someone has many people have slacks different types but basically it's very important because if it rains you're going to get the whole sukkah wet what's the hectare to put slack onto this why isn't that putting in oil so the terrace that everybody knows is if you put this slack directly onto the sky it's not we're not making oil because the oil is there ready so oil agave oil is not a problem so you could put the schlock onto the anchovies no problem the place can say but if the shlock is a tephach or more above the so that's its own sham oil so you're making a new oil on existing uh that's not a problem so that's why the best way to do it is make a slack that goes onto the scratch you have no problem but the methius is and if you know a little bit why give me how it's made you understand why but if you have one of these pulley system slots that are pretty heavy you don't want to put it directly on to the actual sukkah it's not this good for the sukkam so you basically put it a little higher above see here you have a pulley system that works great the slot goes on but it does not rest directly onto the in fact it's a tougher or [Applause] so once they had to use a pulley system shlak that's a tether or more above the this is already making an oil so this is a problem but there are more in the end of tough race and it's more foreign this is not a problem if you the if the slack is attached to the sukkah or attached to the house whatever the case is but it's attached to something you allow to open it and close it even though it's a tefl above the sukkah and listen to his lashes shall bias it's no different than a door that opens and closes you're allowed to do it on champions so there are saying it's a very interesting tradition a slack which is oil is motto like a door what's the door to a slack so to answer this question i'll ask you a better question let's say someone has a leg of a table that fell off but he's a stickle handy and he could wedge it in that will fix the table and shabbos that's awesome right that's bueno or macabre so now i'll ask you a question let's say suddenly you had a need guest came unexpected you run down to the basement and you take out looks like a suitcase it's not a suitcase it's a folding table a real patent the legs fold up the table folds up it has a handle it looks like a suitcase but it's a table there's more work opening a folding table then securing a leg into a table here you have to make the table you have to make the legs so why is a folding table mutter if putting one leg is awesome okay here's another question the gemara says in erev and of course dallas almona which means basically there's a open pot on the wall so you take a door that has no it's not attached to anything it's almond or actually explains it's not connected to something and you stuff up the hole in the wall and now you kept out the elements you kept out the cold or the heat whatever it is so you took a stray door and you put it into the wall and that stuffs up the open area that that's over why because you're making it's most of all opinion so let me ask you a question imagine you go to a place that the door is always kept open okay a certain place ladies i mean sherman shops i don't know why they have doors on their front anyhow it's always open and closing let's you have a door that's never closed it's open it's held open with the door stopper and for the past 10 years it hasn't been used once you decide you want a little quiet you want to learn so you pick up the door holder and the door for the first time closes is that a problem because you're you're fun you're making a functional door that was not used for 10 years the prima gotham says the it's not a problem even if it wasn't used in years the question is why is dallas almana awesome and this other wasn't used in 10 years why is it muta so the answer to all three questions is one simple you said if something is broken it shy the issa of bueno the leg fell out it's a dysfunctional table there's a hole in the wall so it's broken you're putting in a table you're putting in a delos armani you're fixing it but if something is not broken like in america if it ain't broke you can't fix it or if it's not broken you can't fix it when you have this folding table and all the pieces are there i wouldn't say it's broken and you're fixing it i'm using it using is fine creating constructing is us using is fine so the difference between a folding table is it's not broken but a leg that fell off is broken or a dallas that was not used in years but it's on the hinges is not broken but if there's nothing in the wall and you put in a dallas arm on it it's over that's the same you said regarding the shlock if you take a piece of wood even if it's not muksi there's going to be a slack and you put it above the you're putting a new oil on the oil that's awesome but if the the slack is attached to the sucker or attached to the house so it's the attacking moisture is massive since attached that's the way it's used it's like a dallas now you're wondering what's slot cycles to deal with it's the same lumbers if something that's attached is not broken if it's not broken you can't fix it so putting a new piece of wood as an as a schlock is us using the existing connected slack is not creating it is using creating is awesome using his mutter and that's the hezbollah which basically is like a folding chair or a folding item you're allowed to open it on shabbos rashi says why delay me the of it you're not doing anything rashi's lashing is avid now i know dakimar is talking about the problem of oil but the same lumbers we could use to any folding item a folding item is not broken it's ovid the koi it's made love me the oven and folding item i mean not just a table or a chair or a bed but a play pen a stroller today you know it's an imagination of people to make things that fold up and your store away is wonderful it's very convenient so a fold up stroller look at it it doesn't resemble a stroller but you're not creating it because it's not broken if it's not broken you can't fix it so the ramos muscle is brilliant adele's even though you're putting stuffing up that area is connected it's not like a della salmon so now we understand why a shlock on on shabbos mutter as long as it was connected from before i hope the point is clear derek misoy is muta because it was never broken a meat that shall proc him like we said even though you're saying what's wrong i'm just doing it temporarily true it's temporary but the mice is broken you took it apart disassemble and assemble is the malacha of bueno patis question i just saw this yesterday somebody asked me this they had a dessert cup a fruit cup whatever it is a disposable dessert cup that came with two pieces i i should have brought on i couldn't bring from jobs naturally but basically it's a cup that you can doesn't stand you can't use it so you wedge it into a base and then you have a dessert cup and it's disposable so it's very convenient for a simcha can you construct that on shabbos so again the one i saw you could not use it as it is and when you put it into the base it actually stayed if you wedged it in it fit it stood that would be a crystal problem what's the difference meters of problem cause broken because that was never made and when you put it together you're making it that's taco problem let's talk about it now listen to the next question it's the gay gratitum many people use oil when they like neighbors shabbos or yum but a regular shabbos is not nigeria because you make the if you use floating wicks you make it before shabbos but when you have your own div so whether you light it in the first or second day if you light on light on yum tip itself the problem is can you put the floating wick through the cork the round cylinder and that keeps the wick floating so i saw on the safety he said that's also a problem of buena you're making a floating rig and i would say just like a disposable cup is only two pieces but it's still awesome so why is the floating wick different but the mice it is different because the cup as it is is not usable so you're making a cup the wick is the same wick before and after you put in the the the cork the cork is just meant to hold up the weight but you didn't make a wick says you're not allowed to cut a long piece of wick into two because you're making two wicks the attacking making a wick but here the wick is made you're not making the wick you're giving a feature that it could float you know what it's like the old-fashioned for those that use you know oil they have like a metal holder that holds up the wick so to put the wick into the metal holder no one says you're making a wick the wick is fine it's holding up the wick so here you're making a cup here you're just finding a way of using the existing wick and take the shaver alleviates all say that the case of the wick is fine the floating biggest mutant and yumty what could be a problem that thomas goes on notice when you get a floating wick and the hole was not yet punched out or was the it was made both be punches but it's still still there pushing out the center of it to be able to fit the wick through that's takamaka the party or if you call a bunny or whatever it is because that was not made and you're actually making it knocking a nail into a wall is based on shabbos cough gimbal that's moist the coca-cola shabbos islamidal so that's a question of mr burn in in shin you doubt they've caught dallas at the end he calls the machiavellis but whatever the case is knocking a nail onto the wall which stays there is now i'm going to ask you two questions and i would like you to think today they have what's called a plasti a plastic hook now i don't have one house to bring it but basically it's a like a backwoods s picture backwards s and one side hooks onto the door and the other side comes up like an s and you hang your hat or jacket you know it's camp it's very popular you hang it onto the door and you hang your your coat whatever jacket from that hook is that a problem putting it onto the door ah you're saying i'm not attaching it to the door but this doesn't seem that it's a problem and the answer is positive because it doesn't stay there it moves around you take it off sometimes but it doesn't it's not like it's when you put it down but it stays there like in the case of the the landscaping or the billion building and i did see the shabbos and his takameko and i think the svara is it's not it doesn't stay there it moves it shifts oh that's one question next question many people have what's called a suction hook basically you want to have a hook to hang something so you take a suction cup i mean they sell it and you suction it properly and really theoretically you can stay for a long time so this the smear of gimbal is your base that's taco moisture because the suction cup is a connection ah you'll say i didn't use glue on nails but that we said it's not it's not relevant the fact that it stays it's a connection you're putting something functional onto your house that's most of all opinion and that seems to be muslim but the poison that's considered a moist of alabinian but the next question i think is not as positive today they have magnet they use magnets in many ways one of the ways is you want to hang something on the refrigerator you hang it with a magnet today someone told me they even sell lettering that has a magnetic backing to it you could write a message on the refrigerator i went to school i'll be home this time or your bath time but putting letters one on the other one after the other it's a magnetic backing you can put it onto any any place that holds up the magnet the question is is that also being moist of our opinion if it would be a din dafgo knocking nails or gluing so then there's no shiloh but since we just said a suction cup is a problem so why is the magnet different and take this mirror shabbos and says using a magnet to attach something or attach them with a magnet is a problem you have a bench holder with a magnet and the whole swara is once you once you it's lobbed after glue or nails so if it stays it stays so what's different suction or magnet the orchestra shabbos and festive gimmel is more maker with a magnet he's mahmoud the suction cup with a magnetism as i mentioned in helix base ahmed rajasthan is also makel but i think the main sword to be makel is because the mag doesn't doesn't last as long simply you put one bencher okay three benches the whole thing falls down someone brushes into it so it could be a possibility is that a suction cup has the ability it's considered a keyboard the magnet is not but someone told me these lettering that you put onto the refrigerator attacker stays it's lightweight so if it's a real connection you have to be crushed that this would be no different than any other connection to a binion that is a problem of moisture of our opinion a belt buckle that fell off so basically it's totally dysfunctional you can't use a belt without a buckle and you put a piece of leather so the embassy is if when you reattach it it works so you fixed it and it kind of happened if it whenever you eat something it pops off you know expands a little bit and you put it on and eat something it falls off again so if it's not fixed you can't fix it you know so if it's not fixed there's no issue fixing but if when you put it on it stays taken he says if it stays after you put it on the hurry that should be a problem of either buena or macabre adding a leaf now today called an extension to a table basically you pull out the sides of the table you put the leaf in and you push it together so even if it even if there are little pegs that in they go into a hole but the place can seem to be make or that's not emotive the table is made are you adding an oil but it's only moisture oil and also this is the marshmallow involvement gimbal and the ashtray is a rule makel apparently you're not really constructing something the table is there you're adding an extension but you're not making the table it's not broken and if it's not broken you can't fix it a mezuzah that fell off the doorpost it's a problem on shabbos you're in a house or a door without a mezuzah so even if you somehow could put the mezuzah back in the same existing nails let's say it fell off but the nails are there and you could stick the mezuzah hole the cover hole through the nails and you get it back onto the door without knocking your nails but that's definitely a problem of melissa balabinion this is a house this is carica and you're attaching successfully the mezuzah to the nails are you to knock the nails in who cares that less and that attacker saw the shabbos and others say that that's tucker most of our opinion the only question is if the mezuzah case is on the on the doorpost sometimes the mezuzah itself falls out so you want to slip the mezuzah into the connected mezuzah holder so that the state remed simon kuft teswav discusses if there's a problem of tikkuna bias because the door without a mezuzah something wrong to do with with the room so maybe you're being messaging the bias now he doesn't seem to be concerned about most of all opinion you're putting the mezuzah back into the case and it's going to stay there and wonders why is there a problem why you small opinion you're not attaching the case the case is already attached but you're sticking the muzzus in and the message is now being moisted so once you hold you don't have to have a connection of nails or glue so putting in the mezuzah as long as it stays the same ice valabinion is right it's a new type of alma that stays so if you can attach the mezuzah attaching the mezuzah into the cave should be the same problem i had the shiloh when someone heard his foot on shabbos and he was a very tall fellow that was was that do it with the shabbos because in the infirmary they had crutches from a boy that just finished using them a very short fellow the difference was about two feet the tall fella needed crutches but the other crutches the way they were now was made for a short fellow so you take out these screws and you could lengthen the crutches and now you have a longer crutch for the tall fellow this sounds similar to our gemara of connoisseur seiden you there you extended the paintbrush here extending the crutches ah you're not screwing you're not tight you're not nailing it together but this is a very strong connection obviously if a person can lean his weight on the crutches and it doesn't crack obviously if you're unscrewing it stretching it and putting back the screw i saw it so yankee fishes it's on the top of me he says since then it's made to stay this person could use it until he has the reform it that would be like a tequila and it stays well that would be constructing a new crutch the other one's not good for this person it's a it's much shorter so it's very similar to the kanusha said in that's a problem the prices that fell re reattaching it if you put it back on a place that it stays so that's takamoise of alabinian and reza pelham the magnum steve bays speaks about the parishes attaching a pariahs rum says but there's no problem of oil because the ironications of the oil so putting a pirate is no problem with oil shinto is i don't understand i know there's no problem with oil why is there no problem of moisture of all opinion you're attaching a project on an ernakari dish to stay and it spells out attaching something to a bias that's there to stay is moist of our opinion so according to the case it would take to be a problem of adding a parishes if it will stay indefinitely but here's the big but if something's wrong with the pariah's attachment that a fellow from the first place so you put it back it might fall off again so if it's not fixed you can't fix it but if indeed you put back the parietas in a way that it stays that should be a problem of moisture fall opinion and should not be done on shabbos opening a stroller is no problem because that's one piece attaching a seat to a carriage they have today you could take a seat another child to sit on it and you screw it in that's being myself to a kali and you're tightening it in a way the attacker you're giving it permanence now somebody asked why could i close the high chair i attach the tray to the high chair the turret says that that's not made to stay you're not locking your child up forever you're putting him inside each takes it off that's not a that's an attachment but this is certainly an attachment that you're keeping it to use as long as you want to use it and that's not a problem and the last group of questions is based on the delightful sugiya that we have in our sugar the magnesium gimbal see if caught in your base says meet this al prakim is awesome kaiser prakim which means you have a cup that obviously with two pieces and you screw them together so now you have a cup that's the issa of bueno or macabre path it's like meat to show progress bueno then he adds but if you attach the pot cover to the part even though you use a shruay if you never use a screw it's mutton shabbos this at least i have a popular pressure cooker you attach the pot cover to the pack whatever the case is the magnum says using a screw to make a curse is awesome but attaching the pot cover to the path is musta and his resource is since you have to open it to take out the food just like it's not a question yama it's not a binion and it compares to a trimmer sardistrian and simmons they used to cement the oven closed with a black plank of wood you're allowed to break it open on shabbos because it was not done to stay for shabbos you have to get the channel down on shabbos so the question is wait a second koi sho prokim is awesome and there shall proclamation it's the same shrief it's the same problem so the rav and sifka falloff explains there's a fundamental you make a cup you could use it and you do use it indefinitely but this today or so that you screw on the pot cover you're not doing it so you're only chunked on javascript you're doing it for a while but when time's time to have children you're opening it if you open it the shop is absolutely there's no problem azoe taina the mogan avraham however the khasanesh in simon nunez cotton tess there's a there's a guy initial and he says if you take two parts of a cup and screw together you're making a cup that was never here here you're not making a kaley for carrot you're ruining the chillington when you put the pot cover on you're winning the challenge you can't get to it the terrace is you're not putting it on to make it a caylee you're putting it on to cover it so we carry part the hashtag you put on the cover to keep it insulated whatever the reason is but ain't stimulus decreased some of the oil maintenance kelly if you close the charm part and make an iced champagne then how you can get the child down the terrace is you never made a kaylee you had a kaylee if somebody's almond in in the smear shabbos adds a canh that the pot cup the pot is not broken and the cover is not broken you're using a pot cover with a pot you're not making a new kaley but two pairs of a cup is this king cup so you're making a cup so whatever the case is the cup you're making a cup the pot you're using it like i told you earlier constructing assembling making is awesome repairing is asa using his mutter it's very similar to the derek that's not a problem the minhash layman's seminars have cut in your base asks a question how is it to open a soul shaker put in salt and screw it on there it's not like a pot cover there it's tucking out of kaley without the cover so maybe you can't use screw on a salt shaker on shabbos which lies i saw the that the same thing you can't screw on a soul shake and say i made the kelly because you ruined the kaylee because once the souls runs out you're gonna have to open it again so a soil tank is not broken when you put the before the cover it's not fixed afterwards it's using the kali so the myself you're allowed to open a soil shaker and close it on choppers but is mourinh is a very common question obviously and that is today they make extenders that are adjustable in other words the old-fashioned standards the wooden ones are good and wonderful there are those that are adjustable it's basically two pieces of metal that one goes into the other two like like support so to speak and if you want it higher you stretch it and you put the screw in and it's higher you want to make it shorter you take out the screw let it fall to your desired height and you put the screw in so the shahila is adjusting astender on shab is that a problem so this sounds similar to a gemara that we learned which one connoisseur said the paintbrush it sounds similar to their crutches which you said is a problem and indeed the min test feels that adjusting a stand-on chap is a problem he says lamaisa you do it sometimes for your height you keep it and you use it over and over and at lesson is it's hard to be makel on something that's really you're tightening it securely to keep it and use it that's his mascara it's like a meet the shelter because when you lift it up you can't use it as it is so you have to tighten it that stuck a problem like meet the show procum however most places might make for the very simple reason that it was never lost its shams tender a standard any height is a standard it's too tall for this fellow okay so get a you know just get a different person but at no point when we say the standard is broken a meet the shall proclaim when it was disassembled is broken if it's broken the many poi skim that if it's not broken it can't be fixed rav osmond hey level i'm with base he says it's not like you're taking two pieces and you're screwing it together the two pieces are one you're just shifting it and just re reattaching it but he says it's like a door attached to hinges he's using our marshall of dallas that was never broken i don't think he means it like a delos but it was ever broken if it's not broken you can't fix it absolutely like based off zayn says even if i make it for my height this is typical islamic salmon but if a child wants to use it i'll make it for his height but so i never really made it to my height to be permanent because if someone needs it i'll give it to him the point is either it doesn't have permanence which we said the rabbis make of or it's not broken now the or let's see which is true in the midseas it depends where the stand is used a stand in a shoe when you make it to your height it might be changed by the next person that uses it but you stand there in your house that you make to your comfort that maybe tuck is the problem to adjust it because it was made to stay whatever the case is i think it's clear that most places are mako and basically since it's functional in any way it is either way it is it's okay i should mention if the person overdid it and pulled out one piece from the other now it's two pieces so now it's broken tackle putting it back is a problem also when you learn abu sugi and shukhan you'll look at the magnavrom see if got your gimbal he said the fairies coin shall proclaim is awesome who are they standing basically so how can you be making can i get a magnum referring to was made leprechaun it was made pieces you disassembled it and you put it back no meet the show protein is that are basically one piece never was broken if it's not broken you can't fix it and ah the question of legos and various toys and coca-cola crates so the emmys you have to realize there's a lot at stake because if we if we come out with the moscana that legos is buena then not only you can't play with it okay so you won't play with it but you can't give it to your baby to play with your baby child or grandchild because if it's awesome to do then an adult can't give a child safina be a dime even even a cotton benjamin and then it's certainly muktsu so let's think objectively which means not what we do but let's think what should be done past this lego is similar to the mishkan al-hafdil but it's the same idea it's not glue it's not nails it's not anything but interlocking the invite in the michigan that's the so why is lego's any better i let goes you take apart the mishkan amra that bring in felt that tackle legos is a prime of buena binyan becalam either it's bueno machilapatis but it's it's no different than the original mishka now let me add a little of a hezbol the building blocks that we grew up with that there's no connection that's the alma that does not last so that's fine but this lasts and it sees that these things last and according to this of course coca-cola crates has even more of a connection and the magnetic magnetite that also stays are all the problem but and here's the big butt there is certainly a malcolm the huckle which indeed the mini items to be making i'll tell you why if you open within a day we saw a rav learning of ram opening within a day is takamutta we swatch that you you cement a covering onto the oven but and then the true seduction says and there are more quotes in a race than this you'll either break off that connection because it was made to take off on chavez so a regular arroyo is taco it's kept a few days and the michigan it wasn't they didn't move there and a few hours later but if you know the child will make it and take it apart with the say on shabbos then you have a raft to be saimahan but there's a more fundamental you say that brings us to our sugar from a beautiful very beautiful perspective in order to be us it has to be boeing every case of buena you build something to have something you wanted to go to sleep at night or you're a you're that you're a merchant so you took off you took the pieces of the bed and you made a bed ah you're taking it apart a few days later who cares you made a bed the tacklers the aim is to make a bed a person builds a bed on champions you build crutches whatever you build something there's a goal to build lego pardon me the goal is to keep the kids busy they're not building a mansion they're building and taking it apart the tacos is not to build it and use it like a model the topless is to build it and take it apart who says that's binyan a game is not binyan binyan is so happy billion because you have a tactless i want to make crutches i want to make a stender wait some but this is just take it and make it and take it apart this is different than a model than anything we saw till now that there's no taxes of bing in the chambinian the bottom line if it's not fixed you can't fix it if it's not built you can't build it so toys are totally muffka from the issa bana the bear moisture involved both point to our magnavrom about the path that you let us screw up clothes with the cover how do we explain that that if that's derek thompson's it's not buena the part you're not making a new pot you're using it the toys is the greatest derek is to build and take apart and that's why dominica island i think is to allow young children to play with the legos because there's enough starting to say that really it's motum but since we saw this or marsha feinstein held it's a problem so a childhood should not be allowed to play with this lego but ramosa himself who held fact it's awesome he says well i say it's not much because since children do play with it so in the house it's a household toy and they're allowed so if you ask me can i give my child to play with lego or moisture it holds no the other piece came with that but cinderella and those plays that i make say why not but i think the fair mascana would be to to give it to a child probably is also mutter but it's a child could play with it but one thing i will say what this person asked me to take coca-cola crates and start building something that's the problem of the holidays because that's first of all he's doing it he's building a sook he's doing something to last and this is secure and this is not only for children i mean adults also use these things to make whatever they want so that would actually be more like a binion like the michigan it would be a problem i couldn't talk to you all shane eating i would like to thank smith for the wonderful sheer rabbis i would like to ask people to die and not like people are advertising there's no cases there's no corona my shiver and my they went two weeks ago to jaime's show telling the mountains for shabbos and they're both now in the hospital intensive care unit of modern sun and uh moshe shine where robin flowers was dragged this weekend hospital too and many people knew shiva's parents tested positive i know facts from people names and people there are a lot of cases out there the lte industry is acting and people should be careful not to go to people to come come from different states different cities and i'll ask about to have them in mind for us worldwide project we're asking everybody please now for the hailing attack take it out in the journal sponsorship is of zika robin for the whole upcoming [Music] me um oh