Kidushin Learnt Throughout The Ages

[Music] foreign [Music] T it's a pleasure to have you and today we go back to the basics the first thing I think we should say the first thing one of the first things that we began and we constantly do before every pneumon sector where my brother takes us through history of some of the Swarm that have been written on the upcoming sector and usually highlights a couple of personalities for us so that's what we're doing we're about to start my second one of the classic Yeshiva masectas which I'm sure unlimited amount of sarum and shoe room available on the masecta but we leave it there by brought to climb ice as they say in English to choose for us some of the more interesting ones some of the fascinating farm that are out there my brother's laughing maybe we should have like a couple of Yiddish words thrown in every episode to focus on we'll learn Yiddish that way either way um this episode is been sponsored this one is not anonymous it is in memory of Moshe Ben eliano and Aaron benell Yahoo and we hope that the learning the tiger knowledge that comes out of this episode should be an Eloy for their neshama and my brother take it away okay so we're gonna we're we're ending say the nation which is interesting why is it all the way at the end so looking it's not it's not clear how God put at the end why it's at the end um I came across a work it's called and he has a whole chapter listing out we're in the in the order let's say the rambam how he has this um and all the different that he was able to collect where he deals with this trying to figure out how this happened um and this is a question that's a known question now we we always just throw that out always in the beginning sometime where the frame of the massacre is in this in the particular center now so for the manuscripts and all the type all the all that type of stuff we have four volumes from Hometown and Israeli I'm a secretion from schneis we have the safraim as we mentioned in the past now just to briefly mention for you xiaomi success we have an amazing tool from Dr Menachem cats where basically he started in his Doctorate where he did a one parrot but he ends up publishing a few years back the whole US Army based on manuscripts and more importantly while the Muslim is found in the different shining him that he collected from all over continuing the credible work from berettner Ave finding more stuff based on the card catalogs of the corner of Herzog and Professor Yakov zusman so this is available for purchase by macron Bensley antisafter we have shaliman okay so this is those are the early materials now we go a little later so we got him we have Levine we've mentioned in the past whenever it's available now just to point out one your deal because it affects the beginning of your condition a lot of your shine and bring this down already is there sugar going says in the famous letter of his that the first blood or first two blot of the masekto is from the rabbanan savarai we shine in the oldest it's brought down in different there's different a lot of different colors for this one could see with lighter in his midteras and shall we shine him has some material about it already which we've quoted in the past a talmud of Elijah and a javrusa and talmud of the mentioned this also briefly and again in this Hebrew he has a whole about it discussing the material about it now if one wants to understand this other works about it but the keyboard can be found on Hebrew Books Okay now that's now we go a little further so in a lot of sectors we have on the Charlesville you look on the side over here it's not um you will get to us on the side shortly but the starting of collecting of material from manuscripts was again bam Levin he puts it in his continued with this with more materials in his famous and then more recently has a bunch of more pieces which is a claim they have discovered okay so this is getting us closer now we're going to Rashi so Rashi as far as we know Rashi on this message is Rashi we've discussed in the past on different receptors if it's Rashi it's not Rashi okay the kids are in 1977 Professor kufuffer talmudram chick happens to be um worked in Hebrew University he finds a Madrid um what seems to be labeled Rashi from the last in the last few blood of them and it's not the same as what we have anyway the question is is it really rashy it seems that there are some shinim that also have these materials and they call it Rashi anyway he deals with it it seems he's not it's not Rashi but it's definitely a real reason early on we should maybe pass away from the basement maybe a little later anyway I came across a few years ago a work family which Co which redoes the work of kofor and more because it seems they have a better manuscript and it's it's it seems It's a reason the question is who it is but the name is ramberg Ram sorry Ram roog it could be one of three different people and this person put out a much more extensive Edition I never I try to make inquiries to purchase it to find it as a hard copy it seems it did come out can't find it but the work exists anyway one other thing to mention with Rashi is a point that we mentioned briefly and other times as Rashid a lot of times deals with the gearsalis of the gemara and he has a lot of garcinons and we explained a little bit weird that's coming from really Rashi saw a manuscript he's fixing it or whatever how is he doing this so work was done in Barry land dealing with Rashi specifically on masectus kadushan um garcinian stories of Rashi in this masekra and again if you go back to itsin he has found that a lot of times if you go back to gynic literature you can understand the gear solution okay these are the boring typical um details for most people on the on them now we go on to more um practical a lot of times and we're talking about now talking about the reshining so a lot of times I quote is that who we have discussed also saw a lot of return that people up to his time did not see in his travels we mentioned that in the episodes where he can ask you a little bit also so he talks about he has a listing of the different machine that he saw or was aware of so kadushan for him he has listing the ramban the rajba the tysis rig and the ritva fourish item okay so that's nice but the question is is that really um is that and anyone who knows today what's going on it's incredible incredible incredible the scene of the reshaynum alone on the Maser and let's begin briefly we're not going to go into every single region but we're just going to mention briefly like this first places so we have tysus Rush places okay then there's a tysis talk that comes out um which caused the whole discussion what is the Texas Turk where is it coming from we're not going to get into this but there's an article in the journal from a um who has a doctor in a bunch of articles in hakira a journal all about role in the typhus um on chats that we have now tysis and Shas early without going through the whole history of the of the tysus and the generations and all the different people and what's happening in Texas which obviously the starting point is a fry more box classic work baliat Isis which is in multiple multiple editions but one of the main early recruitment is entry about he talks about chance he says it's a tysis revalid Isis is the first generation malatosis then he says what happened the culture he made it short and not only him other recite him that's what they did they had a longer tices and now we know this because we have the Marshall we pointed out by myself chances the humongous if you compare it to the tices on the page now a lot of times the length helps because a lot of times what happens is certain pieces critical pieces even words are removed and that helps well that makes all the difference in understanding the tices anyway a fellow we've quoted him in the past a bunch of episodes he has collected numerous pieces that I've never published before from if someone wants the article I could send a PDF now this is a general point a guy point just to mention briefly it's a sad thing that Hashem we live in a generation that the reshine them as we're going to continue seeing now and even acroenim it's incredible what's out there and there's no real listing of all the restraining that there are in each nothing we shared him there was an attemption did a few times where he lists today are all the different machine that were published but if he his work ends in 1984. now what he also did which is significant is let's say there was an article printed in a journal the Maria someone discovered five black of a particular region on masaktus kadushan so he would try to incorporate it into this thing but there's been from 1984 till today is a long long time a ton of material there's no way to keep track there's been no real there's been attempts but it's a work that needs to be done by um and led out there so for Marshall this ties the chance that he discovered from various places if you don't happen to know that it's in the usual you're it's going to be lost okay we're pointing that out over here now in general over there in this article what's also interesting is he talks about the significance of the of the various Tyson that exist on masakis gives you a few pages of information very interesting information about the chance okay now just once you're talking about Isis so if you look on the side of yugamaram and kadushan says twice is riyazaki so it's your Dua and developed in the chevalt that Rebel Khan already said that it's not really a zucking and so who is it so it's been proven by ramay um in 1962 maybe even earlier that is so in point is it's a real reliable region it's just not as early it's a little later okay so at this point we could see that there's a lot of a shine amount there already and we didn't even scratch the surface all of a sudden we now know we have the ramban rajman ritva okay as I've pointed out in the past we're not going to go into the sparicos but these materials only come available later on what I mean to say is ramban is 1759 the rash was 1717 the ritva is in 1715 but it's not complete so at the point that I try to make in all the different episodes of these shiram is that the name did not really have the reciting we in our generation we are when you walk into a standard shoe many people in the standard homes have so many wishing them did not have and would have wished and loves to have and we should take advantage of it anyway the Ritzville so in 2012 a Madura bastra of the rifle came out from oyster of cook the question is if it's really a Madura bastard of the ritva it seems that it's not but okay now another early reason from this Space Management has come out in 1904 is the ra'a so we know a lot of us they have a but according to Bam Levine this is no this is definitely not our oh it's a late Akron um Gabby in his in an article which I'm going to talk about momentarily he seems to say it's it's probably someone from the early early okay it could be I don't know um what bam Levine was basing it on or what Kaaba is basing the each one what they're basing it on anyway um we have another work that is connected to the basement ramban published in 1972 from Republic um called chitas kadmanius it's available on Hebrew Books Okay now of course there's also the Mii the remilonal and all very salaries we're not going to highlight all of them just to mention three more Russian and that is his files we mentioned in the past one of the macombs that you get that gets major media occurs I tell you for what it's been doing for the world overshinim and even a little bit ishana so nism he's done incredible work La Marshall in 1995 he puts out the Yad Rama Rama is on an early region dies in 1245 that everyone knows in Sanhedrin is unbelievable whenever you have the Rama people it's well known those that are is one very special reason and through a whole introduction a great length how he concludes that it is the Rahman it seems it really is the Rama um he proves that this drama and he deals with the significance of it including foreign he does interestingly enough in this introduction he tries to he's been accused I would say sometimes for having too long of footnotes in his various works that he puts out but in the Rama and also in the next book which you're going to mention he tries to excuse himself that over here it's very important because it's so significant and kadushan so nagaya so he's justifying why he has lengthy footnotes but he's trying to stick straight to the topic okay um fine another work that he publishes two massive Vines is called araganus so this work first comes out in 1999 based on Savia they discover in the in the Ginsburg collection that's its own interesting story but what but it doesn't have the name of this region however through incredible research he is able to prove the following it's been claimed by people I have not been able to um I don't know offhand who's their source for such a claim but the claim has been that the RAM on every masecto has a reason that he feels is the go-to reason of the sadness actor and that's what he uses to go build off on his on on particular massage so for kadushan remember shashana was able to document that this work we don't know who it is is the um what Iran used for his work extensively it seems it might have even been a rabbi over the run and that's why he doesn't have his name mentioned in it this is a very tough question when it will try trying to understand the concept of Navy a concept all over in the restraining where we do not find a lot of sorry A lot of times we don't find them mentioning where they're getting Concepts from and it could be a Rashi or could say not once to the taking a cancer from Rashi it could be they could take hundreds of cancer suration they'll never barely ever mention it in the safer that they're using Rashi per se but it could be much more blatant what today will be called plagiarism in the times in which I know it's clear they didn't hold it was an issue I maybe double shame I'm right this is a question and a topic that needs to be explored fully and has not yet been properly explored but it seems of shashana when relating to Iran got in trouble for this um people were upset so to speak but he defends himself very well and have learned an article you sure and also that this is accepted with Iran such an okay now another piece of information that's found in this organos is a work from remarkinesia so this is an early reason who seems to die around 12 20. this is a reason that a professor simpler Manuel has done a lot of work in trying to locate his writings and over here shashana has him right the introduction part about him in this volume arganos and there's also a manuscript from from relating to a parish on the rush also so it's two massive volumes of ton of information just to stop you for a second so you can catch your breath as you were speeding through what you're talking about you mentioned this idea of shining quoting Concepts from Rashi and what we call quote-unquote plagiarism and we see that we shine them did it that hasn't been fully explored maybe you want to spend a minute or two you know just to talk about what you mean an example I think we hear this and to know okay so I'll explain to what I mean okay very um like this let's say one is learning this a good example will be as fast is a safer one of the most famous works on davening and on a lot of topics related very very important work printed numerous numerous times numerous additions now this work is not only himself there is stuff from himself but he also is Malachi from a lot of different places but you can find search literally certain points let's say he's talking about Parish of of ProCom where he's talking about umra literally could be a few pages where it's taken from a reason from a generation a few Generations before him such as specifically the maal muratulli a famous region today we don't know much about we don't he's not commonly hurt you don't hear about him so much but he had this work how do we know very simple after having is much later we we compare you just take 10 pages and you compare and you could see almost everything is there so now you would think he should say these next 10 pages I'm using rebiakov antuli's work let's say and he does he doesn't now could be Rebecca ventuli might be a bad example because it could be Rebecca mantuli sometimes he does mention so he just doesn't mention him every time that's another um another Concept in the story of what we call today plagiarism but it's not really plagiarism but we're not going to go into it right now but that's the idea we find we shine him they're really using the ramban the rich for the rajman they don't say that they're using right now it could be because everyone knew hey they would tell me them of that base murder-ish they weren't writing it for the public they could be all different types of Mahal come to explain it but that's somewhat of a one or two minute brief thing to answer your question okay now just to illustrate this with the last state for of the returning that we'll deal with is the sheet the line now deal with me everyone on YouTube you always come across as a safer coach she's learning to me we don't even know who he is anyway well we have like this it's published early on and doesn't have a name so okay balamisa interestingly enough mayor binayo wrote an article and kedarka he's able to with his incredible ideas and bibliographical skills he deals with the hashivas of his work and he basically shows that the Ashkenazi had the work that's the worth of the shielding says who was a tremendously Adams Farm because we know he an expert and we shine him because he one of the things he was doing was collecting a lot of things during him and he says he's from the he's a bandar of the rajma so he basically says like this if the if the titles can as he says he could be sure he knew what he was talking about so like this I wanted to say haara is that um Levine when he's using different sources for his safer he says that he's not going to use this work because it's late and he's not sure of the origins I I think is that had he seen this article beneo which only came out years later then maybe he would have Incorporated with it because it's early work so if there will be some early goonic work in such a material in such a safer um that the that the metallics and as he authenticated that maybe he would be more okay now just to conclude and I've mentioned this in the past and a few others so he has an intense listing of reshine him and information about if one wants to have a PDF of it you can email me I will be more than happy to send it to you and there's a lot of interesting information about to be showing him and details with manuscripts and all different things um different material valuable information okay that concludes the reshining part of the thing now we go on to we'll go we'll try to go through as fast as fast as a maribe RAF maribe RAV is active1474 dies in 1546. now we spoke about him already on a little bit in the episode of the nausea controversy we hope Mr sham one day will get back to talking specifically about him but right now what significant is like this in 1663 that's a long time over 100 years after he dies a work of his uncadushan comes out we don't have a work of his in any other masakis and it also has what's called the Talman of the Raj so if you're already following there's a lot of works that we don't know the names of the authors on this I don't know why that is so maybe this is the unique thing to exactly condition I'm pretty sure it's not found in many others now and that causes a lot of times confusion because you'll say yo she's learning to me and she deserves she okay anyway the kids are so one of the hashivasan besides her being the Marie Bay RAV who's famous for a lot of different things including the smika controversy is that it has quotes from from your shining so it's important it's not only what he has to say that's significant but it's also that he has Messiah okay now interesting thing happens in 1926 the famous um at that time book dealer ramika rabanovic Israel a big expert on those on Swarm and the kid so he buys a manuscript at first he didn't realize what it was and then he hops that well that this maribe RAV was missing more than half the work and by mistake discovered and this thing that he bought by mistake he didn't even realize the significance yet since he bought it for a different reason anyway in 1940 he publishes come out another 40 50 blot of this um work in uh Levine who we've mentioned a few times today and Maduro of has a lot of um has a fancy Edition this fascinating base mattress which has a tremendous impact on the base Yusuf and the diures afterwards so Heim de matrovsky has an in-depth article on the space manager okay so this is basically the earliest um one of the earlier another early action which was only published for the first time in 1995 is the incredible rebeliezer Ashkenazi of the Rama base consider one of the daily adore of that time maybe one day we'll discuss him by Rico's a specific episode just about him but I sadly forgot to mention in the episode of the get of Tamari that he was also involved trying to make Charlotte okay so but the thing is this work even though he dies in 1586 he's quite early but only 1995 support we're pretty sure that the work that they published is from the surveillance Ashkenazi another early work from a from someone a drop older than the um sadly we've mentioned this numerous times even though he dies in 1573 till he still it takes till 1766 for it to be published why that is it's a story one day I will discuss do you mind when you mention the previous that you mentioned and the one that you go further briefly describe what type of safer they are what type of peers they are so I really would the reason why I'm not going to is it it's basically I'm going to use words that each word I'm gonna have to it's like let's say I'll give an example if I go over to guy and I say what is the word yeshivish mean okay what happens you get seven different you could get ten you could take a poll on Twitter and ask the various Twitter people to do it you'll see you'll get so if I'm gonna use the word it's purple let's say so I'm gonna say what does purple mean and it's Taco a worthy episode of six episodes to finally discuss what is the word purple means I'm gonna say oh it's pimple you say oh it's that means it's Hungarian pill no it's not Hungarian purple it's before Hungarian people even came to that's why I don't like to be mag there so much what it is but the it's kadai to sit and use even though kadushan it's ironic he says Services especially for comparing he's the second generation basically of the acronym compared to reshining it's unbelievable but anyway in this execution it's very halach oriented it's a very kadai to give a look even when you're not learning so beyond but if you don't have it on that many messages that it is and in my work he's he had a tremendous impact on the dyrus afterwards contrary to what other people um believe um but that's not for now now there's a statement that this statement um pretty much seems to be you know he doesn't need any askamas but they say he says it and it seems to be true they bring down from the Khazana of kadushan is the father one is the atmos yasif two is the marit and the three is the the makna or the mikno however you want to say it okay so let's go through these so the first work that really is published as it's published earlier than the maribe rav and here I will give a haggadara about what this work style is based on not only because of your um pointing it out but you'll see why in a second it's it's the atmos he's born in 1560 dies in 1620. it's published first in 1601 and it's published numerous numerous times you could find that it's you hear of it sadly I will say as follows that I went to go buy one a few weeks ago in a bunches Farm Stores all over your slime you can't get it anymore which is a there's a sad editor we're not going to go into this now but it's a sad state of description of my opinion about the sparm world of what's Happening tons of smart coming out but the main acronym you can't buy I don't know if this would make you feel better but most people who are learning musakas it's in the crevice him so is there even a clientele to buy the atomic status as a standalone safer so the answer is like this yes it's in the congressman function it definitely is but the problem is like this the codes on version if one understands the history of the characters inversion which began way way back till today today you got to walk around with these monstrosities that weigh a few pounds and the same hand you're also carrying your is that also blossomed a ton and you want to sit and learn and you're flipping back and forth it makes it hard now we're going to see why this plays out for that so serious I'm not saying every Akron should be available but the two the main main acronym you would hope it was now was recently reprinted in a few years back today forget about it now but how so first of all we said the kazim but now I'm going to tell you something that I heard so first to mention yaakov Spiegel has a whole beautiful article write up about it in the Maduro of the truvis of his that was collected they also he also published a Hebrew is called massamela important work these were published in recent years reprinted now when I was learning in the mirror and this will get to relating to the style of the safer so I learned one of the people I heard Sheeran Can Say Goodbye was amazed for for years and years he is one of the chief editors involved with encyclopedia tamudas and other things so one time we learned kadushan and he somehow came up about that so see how you see if we learned the first Park so those that are familiar or will be familiar shortly a lot of the first Paragons allowed to deal with Russia's so it's not only Concepts but a lot of times as Russia learns that from sukum so the atmosph deals with a lot is to explain the drushas of hazal how hazal seized various things from the second now tysis also deals with it when you learn the Tyson but when you tend to learn today in the Yeshiva Cheval we many people they don't Focus so much on the on how the gemara sees it from the sukum and the afusa they're looking for the Lambda shavart so now he said like this he said the atmos yasif is famous this is going back 20 something years ago and he said like this why is it famous because of the London so other people took from the safe but most of the safer proportionally deals with the the technicalities partnership shot being aimed on every single Township attack of the gamara to understand every single Dr Russia so he said that's how people used to learn and he said it's not people think oh the londis will I'm done he said no people think it's a my love that we're much better than the earlier Generations he says we're so far lost that we have no Sheikh as to what it's about anyone who learns what's up solution he's handling these type of issues yes he also will handle the what the Yeshiva World today um is very into but this is a obviously a whole discussion of the Mahal khalimur as it evolved over the years but the point is that's what Yusuf has in it yes the Lambda shavarts but it also deals with very technical explaining the gamara how the drushas work how how hazal see what they see all these things have the yugamome this play out and stuff like that so it's a very very important safer on them okay the next very important safer also in the list so we're not going to go into him he's also a great Giant in his time of use of tyranny and um there's a fancy new edition of the marit published a bunch of years ago again I went looking for it you can't find it so you'll say yes it's in the codes of fashion but this is a beautiful beautiful addition with footnotes and everything on Galore including I think Harris and a fancy introduction from my friends Villa kids so you can't find it anymore this is we're not going to go back to the discussing about the sad State of Affairs of sperm today now playing Yeshua comes out afterwards 1739 doesn't need any more enemies comes it's a safer Blossom as Binion comes down 2011 he's a talmud of the play Yeshua he plays a major role in the get of Cleves which we hope to discuss um in an episode soon this early work early araba 1768 is when it comes out even though he died in 1712 this is the famous Al yaraba onara again svler has excellent article on him now fast forward there's a word called is published in 1790. Berlin the incredible incredible chapter about the suit could be found in the work of Yeshiva harama buffer I've been a Brock famous Yaki expert charging there's a numerous other things he has a massive chapter about this gun oil behind sea Berlin showing how everyone um mamas used in that once not twice hundreds of times he has listings and just the mission of brula Marshall in that in in this farm that relating to the to the mission of Brewer but it's an incredible um arikos maybe one day will be sorry for to give a whole episode discussing this this is a person that's alive in the time the village writes about him unbelievable things that some Cipher quote him dozens of times dozens of times all this is documented by hamburger um okay anyway then we have repencas so he dies in 1805 before he dies he publishes his workflow namakna these are again also says it but everyone knows these are part of the go-to's anyone checking will find this it's very easy it also has a section about to have an episode specifically devoting to him another contemporary is safer called archado dies in 1799 also interesting Hebrew tremendous escamas and there's a whole work of Adam from Rookie seal Greenwald um this guy I believe it's available on Hebrew Books discussing about him his generation a lot of historical interesting information like you can see a Greenwald tends to write okay Tyrus get them from the nasivas he does not write the the side and the sevis does not write a work on her condition but in his work basically it seems he started such a work there's a bunch of different Somalian but he never completed it okay now there's a work called play Maisha he's a nephew and a Talman of a performance on my goal is he seems to argue a lot with the I'd say Rosen but that's not for now then this is spoken about him he dies in 1805. he also work of his was publisher manuscript okay in recent years now we get to one of the basically one of the greatest issues his work the Avenue it's published a little after he dies um in uh he dies in 1812 I think it first comes out in 1815. okay now when many many years ago um rehearsal Shafter began giving a sheer in Flatbush on Monday nights or Tuesday nights and so at that time it started was with myself so I heard a few this year and one of this year I mean he began so he quotes David Malone and he said an interesting idea that stuck with me ready from then I was in 10th grade at the time he said hasidim don't like to use the Avenue they loved excuse they love Schmitz they're more nervous why because sheer his son-in-law had to do with the work and taka if you open up your Avalon you'll see nagdama they give that character Shear now I just wanted to say one horror about this and that is as follows who is sheer who ends up becoming the Rev of Prague and he was prolific he had a tremendous and there's a whole book recently came out mom was dealing every aspect of his life but I go to look there I'm always very curious I ever since I'm very young I heard this professional schachter saying this statement I wanted to know what was his relationship with the safe exercise and also was did he have a relationship with his father he's the son-in-law of the size so does he have a real relationship with him anyway it's very hard to know and I'll explain to you what I mean when you look at the safer you'll see the brother the sons of the choice are involved in the publishing they raise the funds they work on it they give akarsity to their brother-in-law their young brother-in-law who barely knew the size and at that time there's no indication that he was a Moscow it seems he was a brilliant um a brilliant Eloy who married the excited his daughter and basically he does help them and they thank him for helping with and he has Horus in the bottom and different things he found mccarrus or different things a lot of one has to understand when putting out a safe in those days especially a Monumental work like so you need a lot of help so they had him help but if you look carefully at the whole government the thing of the whole safer the main person who did 90 of the work was a talmud of the xais for years and years with inzal his name was and you could see it when you read it he's the one who writes the whole introduction and he was a tremendous person he was a closer to reference now my goal is he and he spent Years Learning with excise he's the one who did most of the works I wouldn't be so nervous even if this story that refresher is saying was so to speak I wouldn't be so nervous first of all this is sheer before he had anything that we know shares life it's very very well documented it's well before he had anything to do with all this and and second of all is the most of the work was done by this tire from the excited one opens up the animal room you can see this okay now just to just to finish this up is like this is also the same generation same there um dies in 1839 but in 1877 as tradition on condition are published he's also one of these that has a lot to do with Ricky Vega the nasivas and Mr Sir Baron published a beautiful edition of it in more recent years and there's a whole book about him if someone wants a small little booklet about him if one wants I can send it to them if they email me there's a now this is um the last main work to mention is another you did of the urban Vega and others only come down for manuscript a few years ago I went looking for my copy this week I cannot locate it in my in my firearm right now so I might have to buy another one anyway but kitzer these are the main aquarium that exist on the Musa fast forward you have the Marshalls and then you have we spoke about an episode that we hope to release soon from the side of his gemara that was it's housed in the reichmann in Rabbi reichmann in new shalimes collection so it was published way back in a safe as a car called so this is also gets into a different complaint to mine not only are we showing them not available to know these things in rare journals but I try and forget about so you can have some buried and some caveats and it's lost okay so ajma helps a little bit for these types of things if one knows what they're looking for say them I copy this and down this way before it's even thought about existing so I don't get it I didn't get it from myself anyway we mentioned this um also incredible work on this exhibition we mentioned a little bit about Khan the the acronym there's many more but we're not gonna I hope I um um people will welcome me for the ones here talmud endless volumes we'll discuss that a little bit in a in a future episode a little bit and there's a kind of it's called then as you mentioned in the beginning I went looking just to see how many sperm their arms there are hundreds and not only Russia shoes it's crazy it's one of these unbelievably and that's what and that's how we'll conclude we're going to run through this sentiment basically this is so first I there's there's a keyboard called he publishes stuff from but this is focusing on the what's condition about getting married you'll see the the castle has to take place what how all that stuff takes place manuscripts are we shining besides the standard we shine that he collected then there's an incredible incredible work called say the condition is soon from Aaron Fryman it's available on Hebrew Books mamish documents is written 1943 documents through all the kufus all the reshinen early on different areas you want to know how a Hassan looked what they did while the different hug them if one's learning this is an incredible incredible historical work collecting from makairus and the like academic work from uh Professor Weinstein okay then let's go um skip everything is there's a say for sure a nice good Hamish or work I think it's Hungarian but um I forgot to check um pull out my copy I I happen to love this work is everyone wants to know about hassanas and all the different types of hebe-gb questions that come up you have aidlessly throw from the about exclusive rum also another incredible work you have the collected with Toby freund collected tons and tons of stuff from representative Zalman in one of his series on I think it's called xiaomi simcha okay these are the stuff related to the suggests of cadution and then to conclude mustafa's collusion has millions of other suggests we can't even begin to list them suggestions we have to mentioned available on Hebrew Books no excuses not to learn real tire from the end of the first parrot there's another Hebrew whole story this is the Sugi over here the limousine college or author with the stapler and then to conclude there's also kibet of Aiden a few blood of that we're going to discuss a little bit about that but shashana ofek mayor Sharm and the last work is a liquid called hydros kadish with a Malacca from all different places from the tipes of Franco is Tyrus on his suing and etc etc Mila opinion which actually plays out in this massage so these are some of the materials that are available out there on the saxos kadushan it's one sector that one could learn and it's even as from what I was told it's learned um that staff got picked in let's say Lakewood uh eighth grade eighth graders to learn it it's easier um okay that's a conclude absolutely amazing last I checked 8th graders in Lakewood even though my son is not yet in eighth grade they learn gitin and bubbakama I think Aquinas in the first paragraph I don't know I know by now there are dozens and dozens of moisters here so maybe one of them learns condition I don't know if I have to remember I actually I think learned mostaccos Marcus in eighth grade oh you learned Marcus okay I got it my Avenue Loom I think I got in eighth grade I'm not sure so you're gonna say you got Marcus in eighth grade oh I definitely did but I learned I learned kitten in eighth grade fascinating do you want to turn around and whip out a safer to talk about today yes one thing goes over relate to this thing okay so we just mentioned hookers keeper of Aim so just now came out of safer it's called actually I can't even pronounce it for sure saying it wrong okay what I have to do today is that's a different story we're not going to go into right now but it's called it's a it's what the fashion we've spoken about this aspect actually written like a missionary this is put out by a fellow of David Goldstein from New York then he has he seems to be a son-in-law of rabelski so he has a guy from the saviada rabelski on that he gave him the suggests relating to kadushan the parakama Collision are in here and then he has all different stories and on hagas that he collected on kiber of aim this looks like a massive encyclopedia work on the aim just the index alone of the safer's 30 pages including an index of all the suggest and kadushan where he deals with all the stuff so it's very very useful just came out a few weeks ago it's available already for America in America for purchase um that's a work that I wanted to highlight and it relates to this exhibition for the few blood of them beautiful beautiful safer interesting topic to learn and enjoy very relevant today for people of all ages we appreciate Rabbi brought fascinating I hope I don't know when you attempt to even look at the names of all this form that you mentioned and the other hundreds that you didn't mention um if anybody wants any of the PDFs that I brought mentioned please send him an email eliezerbroad gmail.com you can email me schwade m s c h w EDM ou.org once again we thank our sponsors and the dedications the memory of motion manilio and iron manilio and if anybody would like to reach out about other dedications and opportunities feel free and with that we wish you a wonderful day