Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
okay sh
everyone after that that short trip from
the ra to the sh you know it's
very noteworthy that we're going from
the Rama to the Shak first of all the
Shak is the primary commentary on
the and furthermore the sh married the
son the Shak married the daughter of the
great grandson
of the Rama so the Shak was married to a
descendant of the
Rama and the Shak was born in
1622 the most extensive commentary on
youra is the Shak does anybody know what
your Shak was written in it was written
in the year bakesh bakesh is the year
1646 the greatest work ever written on
Yura was written when the Shak was 24 4
years old brings the it's a dla the Shak
wrote his commentary at
24 years old the further points out that
if you read the sh you'll see that he
had also written a commentary on the
tourah in the which we don't have and
that's something he wrote even before he
was 24 years old I'm going to give you a
little sampling because we know that the
Taz was published the very same year and
the Taz was much the Taz was much older
than the
Shak and in that very same year both of
these far were published I'm going to
give you a little sampling
of between the Taz and the sh
so that if sh more than one animal all
you need to do is to make one
braa however if the talks and he's M
between Shing one animal and the next so
if he speaks about something that's
connected to the he does not have to
make another but if he speaks about
something not related to the he would
have to make another that's the
day that speaking is not a he it's not a
separation and he should not make
another bra the shak's like the first de
that you always make another bra this is
the
sh Z the sh is like the second comes the
Taz and the Taz says that since the
brings down both de and he doesn't give
any conclusive ruling it has a din of a
saf and we utilize the rule
sa this is what the Taz says the sh on
the other hand Pas like the first
opinion now the Shak in his humility
wrote a commentary on the Taz
called and
in the reason why he called it he wanted
to show humility to the Taz as if the
Taz is zahav the Taz is gold and he is
merely KF so he says no he says
emphatically and
unequivocally it's not a suff because
many Pim follow the first
and therefore you need to make
a now this is something which is not so
well known who do we pass like the Shak
or the
Taz whenever there's the sh and the Taz
the in po andita follow the
Shak in Ash follow the Taz but in
general we usually follow the rulings of
the sh we headed to the C of the Shak
which was published in the
yeares bakes the Shak was published in
the
yeares
1646 so the little what city we in halev
halev in
Moravia okay we're just we have to re
review this one more time because we're
having technical difficulties so again
it's a great to be here at the cover of
the Shak on we mentioned that the Shak
wrote his commentary at 24 years old
he's called s h The Jug of the man
because he provided for the Jewish
people like the rash
like and the sh learned by the rebes of
kraal he's also student of the M schlomo
of krao the Shak wrote on yadea the
other great commentary on yadea was the
Taz the Taz Rao David the Tazo David was
much older than the Shak and theim were
published in the very same year in the
year
1660 six when the Shak was 24 years old
and against the Taz the Shak wrote
another commentary
called the Taz responded the Taz
responded with his own P against the to
answer the questions of the Shak and
this is
called the last page
in response to the the
wrot now many people thought that the sh
being much younger than the Taz maybe he
doesn't have the right to argue with the
Taz maybe there's a personal animosity a
personal quarrel between them so I want
to read to you what the sh says he says
Anyone who reads
my should not think that I wrote these
comments against the Taz because of any
personal animosity everybody knows how
fond I am am of the Taz the Shak hosted
the Taz for 3 days so can imagine here
we are in HEV and the Shak host the Taz
for three days and not only that I
honored him greatly and the Taz gave a
kiss to the Shak the almighty knows and
God is a witness that I wrote these
comments
only only for the sake of the
truth
for fore
the amount of effort the Shak put in to
write his
saers the Shak says nobody should
question me that I said something and
you don't understand it because the
amount of am that I put into writing
this commentary is I didn't review it
once I didn't review it twice I didn't
review it many times before I wrote
anything I reviewed my learning
101 times and only then did I compose it
how could the sh do this brings down
that he has a tradition that the Shak
knew special shame Hashem that when he
would invoke this name of God he would
be able to have the to access it quickly
to be able to compose his now the sh
wrote many he also wrote
a tu are the laws of possession do you
know how long it took the Shak to write
30 days this saer which is studied in
all the 30 days in fact and iish wrote a
of the amazing commentary of the Shak
the Shak also was a poet he wrote the
keyote for what happened in 1648 1649 he
wrote a saer called M which is a record
of all the terrible pams of the kitki
pams I want to tell you a story about
the daughter of the Shak the Shak had a
daughter
Esther you know you learned it I the
they told on the bus what's what's your
last name again yobu told you the whole
story so you got it the bottom line is
that when the Shak later in life came to
the city of his future son-in-law RAB
RAB mayor and his daughter revealed
herself
his daughter revealed herself so then
the new husband was so happy to have
this father-in-law he helped the Shak
publish his p
on one last story you'll tell me if you
heard this story in Mexico if it made it
to
Mexico in 1648 1649 the G on were
terrible and there were two great
MIM and the sh and made a how he could
be the Gaz and he was told that if he
and the Shak would give up their
life theot would
stop agreed to give up his life he came
to the sh he says if you will also agree
to give up your life Theo will stop the
sh says I need to think about it he
comes back to he said I will give up my
life for cl but I can't do it yet I
didn't finish writing the Shak wow he
says not until I finish riding the Shak
can I give up my
life isman Meltzer would say over this
story and he would
say even though this would have meant
saving the lives of Jews the fact that
we have the
Shak was more important for the future
of the Jewish people even than
being so this was the of the not to give
up his life to be able to produce for
clel the works of is a
double
ands today's what's the sphere
of is
the who is the greatest example
of in his should we should all that
should be shalom shalom
[Music]
amen for
shom
and I'm going to translate into English
yeah please okay also because we didn't
get in the First Recording again we said
that the sh
was today like said the man came down
for the Jewish people was called The Jug
of the man and in the Merit of standing
here Hashem should send us all the man
spiritual
benefits complet theing
together we say want to Li together
please
in the Shak wrote some of the alltime
great classic commentaries of Lamas that
are studied in the Yesa aside from the
Shak the Shak wrote
this is one of the classic L works that
were ever written about the laws of
possession in and by the way the Shak
was n before he reached 42 years old
among other things you know the refers
to a p the Shak has an so we have what
the Shak wrote Ona we have what he wrote
on we don't have an AR but he wrote an
AR as well there's a fundamental
difference between what the Shak wrote
Ona and what he wrote on Ona he wrote it
as a commentary on the words of the and
the so aside from his own he's being the
words of the the m and the however later
on in life when he wrote on he did not
explain the words of the M for a very
simple reason he felt that the the
commentary the already accomplished a
commentary on the m and now all that was
needed was for his own but he wrote this
and in it he brings various laws
of about various for example if
Ru quotes
he doesn't necessarily refer to our he's
referring
to like that there's another important
rule that the Rama says this is very
important rule remember the sh married a
descendant of the Rama what's
the if argue on who do you follow if
argue on you follow the they were later
they were the but there is an exception
to that that's only if theim saw the but
if you could find the that the AK didn't
know about we're not going to say we
follow the AK because he's later because
we could say if he would have seen this
reine he never would have pass in the
way he did so the question now is we'll
always pass in like the Shak but we need
to know what books the Shak had access
to because if he didn't have access to
certain books we're not going to pan
like him so there's a long discussion
which did the sh see which did the Shak
not see so for for
example brings that the Shak did not see
the and therefore we wouldn't
necessarily follow the rulings of the
Shak under these circumstances so
there's a very lengthy introduction here
about the that the Shak says what's the
difference between what we
call and there's something in the gar
the has a question and the gar doesn't
come out with the definitive answer and
sometimes the gamar will say take so
these are issues that the wrote
about the
wrote in one month this great work one
of the great Classics of all time that
it could take a lifetime to write the sh
wrot in 30
days okay it's a great to be at the of
the somebody his son writes about him in
his
that the entire day from morning
until night even while he was lying down
even as he was falling asleep but he
likewise excelled in mid and before he
died he left word that he doesn't want
anyone to describe him in a HED as a go
as a r as Aid as an unov he just wants a
simple stone nothing written on it no
they didn't listen to him so they took a
very Exquisite marble and they carved
out a very ornate
that very night the mat broke it cracked
in half and they saw the the wish of the
sadic was being fulfilled what's amazing
is that in 1930 when they redid this
space they found in the corner of the sh
the broken slab with his name on it and
it was like a my face that they found
the remnant of the original Mata that
they had made for the now the writes
and this is also brought in the
beginning of
the that the was
so story goes like this one day they
found the corpse and they found a knife
next to it and the knife was clearly
from the home of the but of course he
didn't do it so they advised him listen
you're going to be taken to court
they're going to cross examine you just
say it's not your knife if you say it's
your knife then it's going to be
impossible to wiggle out of the the
situation and say yeah it's my knife I
didn't do it when it came down to it and
they asked him Rabbi whose knife is this
he said as follows
Ms dark it's my knife but I didn't do
this brings out from here how careful
one has to be in the of
Ms nees so we're going to go to his Mata
we'll hear more about the life ofu
we're here on the top of the mountain in
masich basovich looking over the city
we're at the K of
the
mar I want to read to you
the he says
he was an elderly venerated
Sage with thousands
of the almighty spoke out of his throat
like
who as we mentioned in his youth from
his
youth from the early morning until late
at night one of his uh signs of
greatness is people from all over would
come to him give him a name of a and in
all of his he would D for others and
his his eyes would be dripping with
tears for all the that he daved for we
mentioned his an now it's a very
interesting name of
a think about it you know if you're
writing a book you don't want to would
you call
it half like what 50 you know so in the
of
the in the of his son-in-law he says
that said that even though he was not
Ming to the MS all the time he at least
got it 50% at least 50% of the things
were correct and then he
said and he had another hidden
reason are we even allowed to conjecture
but maybe there's an idea that the word
there's a system
of
is
B 26 that's the name of hasem to
indicate name was not is not M maybe it
was a it was a that was a for the
fruition of the fullness of hm's name as
we know the M writes that the reason why
named even though we don't give a we
give is we're awaiting the day that
we're going to give a maybe he called to
indicate like a that we should
be in any event it's very interesting
it's brought in the biography in the
name
of that the once said to you know why I
called because what's by the way do you
know what is the it's a not a it's aish
on the the was the most cryptic of all
the maim one of the reasons is because
he was very poor he actually wrote
portions of on the walls of his home he
could not afford paper so told Adler I
don't understand thear of the but Ben I
understand it halfway where said I
understand Nar I could only understand
onethird of what the M says
benar in his great humility he did not
publish his farm in his lifetime they
came out the on
the these were all published ply this is
someone who
was and so this is particularly to have
our
answered okay good afternoon everyone
we're headed to Nichols
BG to the Cav
of nikolsburg and Benet I would like to
share with you perhaps the most stirring
story that you'll hear on the whole trip
and this will give you an understanding
of where AET is buried and it's an
amazing controversy a very stirring
controversy and something very
mysterious Mor Benet lived from 1753 to
1829 he was the acclaimed godar
however when he died he could not be
buried in nickelsburg he had to be
buried in
Li and here's how it all happened when
ra morai Benet was 60 years old ra morai
suffered from severe ailments they grew
steadily worse and then finally in the
year
1829 Benet passed away at 75 years old
RA morai in his final year was secluded
in a chamber a within a learning the
cabala learning the secrets of the
to and his illness begins to overcome
him and the doctor
say you need to go to carsbad you know
what carsbad is kbad is the the mineral
baths so they warn him if you don't go
to kbad You're forfeiting your
life so goes to kbad It's the middle of
to drink the May of kbad however the
accursed Waters of the mineral baths
enter his body they cause him to suffer
terrible cramps in the abdomen abdomen
they weaken his arteries his ligaments
and he suffers for 17 days the doctors
try to cure him but on Wednesday the
13th of a he was nft on the yard side
ofala he he dies in carlbad what are
they going to do with him so the city of
nickelsburg sends word he's arov he
needs to be buried the nickelsburg but
the law of the land was if you're going
to move him to a far distance he has to
be in bombed they don't know what to do
they bury him in carlbad it's not even a
Jewish City so they they decide they're
going to bury him in liad which was only
a 2hour away journey and that's what
they do they bury him in lienin
meanwhile the city of B is up in arms
that's not his
City says there's a wherever you bury a
mace he the Earth is kind of him the
city is kind of him he is now
ours belongs to us nikolsburg said what
do you mean he was AR he even left in
his that at the very least that he would
like to be buried in nickelsburg and if
not nickelsburg at least the city of
Prague and this Shila of what to do with
the Holy go
was brought to none other
than and you can look in
the by the way now we know it was also
brought to two other G it was brought
toar it was also brought
to the son of
the and very unusually
the writes that he's inclined to say
that you can move him but he stopped
short of definitively saying that he
could be
moved so when the city of nickelsburg
hears that the sort of was not
definitive so they back off and they let
it be 7 months and according to some six
months pass and all of a sudden the
revisits the case and now finally he
writes definitively to nikolsburg that
he has decided that they should move his
body and he this is his decision
definitively and they bring him TOA on
the 12th of Adar in the year T 1830 in
the city of nickelsburg and it was
always a mystery the never h never the
always gave a definitive in fact theer
would say that he didn't need to bring
Ras to his Pak whatever his Pak was that
is what they agreed to in the sh he
doesn't need R whatever he says in fact
says only two times he ever retracted
aak and both times that he retracted his
Pak he was wrong he got it right the
first time so why
was unsure so to speak of theak over
here so there's
AER and he brings the testimony of
shimer the son
ofer that theer was in the middle of
riding the cha to allow to pasan that
they should move from M Benet to
nickelsburg
however as he's completing writing the
Chua suddenly the is overtaken with
sleep and he has a dream and none other
than ra Benet reveals himself in a dream
to
the and Benet says let me explain to you
why I'm buried here in
in you see many years ago I issued
a to allow an engagement to be
broken and because I was to this lady to
allow her engagement to be
broken I am
punished to be
buried next to this girl who I allowed
her engagement to be broken and the
proof is says go take a look inad I am
buried next to the girl whose engagement
iasin could be broken however there's
another version of the story that Benet
revealed himself
says I was engaged to this lady the
Ritson ofat we were engaged for seven
months and then I broke the engagement
and as a punishment for breaking the
engagement I needed to be buried next to
her for seven months go and check and
verify who I'm buried next to but now
the seven months SH now the seven months
are over now you can move me and theer
in fact pasin that he could be moved by
the way when they went when the
residents of nickelsburg went to
move
theet the residents ofat did not let
these emissaries come in they hired
Hooligans they hired a mob it became a
very great controversy finally they had
to get military protection to move the
holy body of Mor Benet who was finally
moved on the 12th day and buried on the
12th day of Adar
7 months later in the year 1830 so this
is the story of how raet was fin finally
moved from the city of lonat to
nickelsburg
soet he passes in carlbad he's first
buried in lad and finally he's buried in
this city that we're headed to in
nikolsburg okay we're headed to the
of nikolsburg here is a sign that tells
us after this long trk to go up
here so we're here we're in the Czech
Republic we're mikov we nikolsburg the
rebka the renowned
rebina
now this is very important to understand
the Reber of scha was one of the
earliest promats of the IDE ideology
ofid he was a t of the maged however he
didn't start off as of the maged started
off in VNA by the vag and through the
influence of early he moved he became a
t of the maged and he he is responsible
for spreading
kidos not only here but throughout
Poland however he didn't fully
endorse some of the views of the B and
the maged he took AOS and combined it to
a certain extent with in-depth learning
and polish kidos was deeply influenced
by we'll call it this revolutionized
type ofid that was brought by the rebber
OFA so that's why you find
like about
the his great K his prous his gura his
to and he was a great sadic he Afflicted
himself in fasting and he was very close
with his brother
the their father
was and The Story Goes that one year sh
was coming and the father says you know
sh is coming what do you think we should
learn so the re said we should
learn should learn so said you
know is bad Oaths so I know but you
taught us that we're made that we took
an oath to keep the Torah we have to
know the binding nature of an oath the
next year again CH was coming and he
asked his other son the which we should
learn and the said we should learn two
masas and Kad because when gave us the
tah he married us so to speak okay the
re we have AER from
him there he writes that the medish
tells us it's not good to start with the
word
AF anyone who with an AF had a very bad
downfall like who
the or
said whoever starts with the word anger
he's done so the Reber
of the fifth per begins how could you
begin a peric with a says the re ofka an
amazing thing how many Pim are in 13 Pim
the3 is
the therefore it encompasses all
13 the fifth of
the anger
so
is if you have a problem with KAS you
should learn the fifth par ofus
therefore the fifth par ofus begins with
the word AF he was born in 1726 he was
nifter in
1778 how many years did he live 52 years
he would always tell people he had the
Nish of Shu he had the Nish of sh in
fact on his deathbed he told people he
told this my is the ofu here's the
Simmon we have the same name Shmo was a
Ley I'm a Ley shm live 52 years I live
52 years the only difference is he was
and I'm just sha that's the words of the
Reb in
the he brings from the
Reb that anyone who doesn't have
kavana cannot be anything in it's not
possible to have unless by these two
said the rebba rebka when he was
accepted here in nickelsburg in the year
1773 5 years before his P so he was
preparing to greet the people and they
caught him in his room saying
sh
rash you know a little bit strange that
he'd be saying these things to so they
asked Rebo you know what exactly you
doing he says in it says
what does that mean means like this you
know how you should treat coved imagine
if you were yourself imagine if the
coved you were receiving didn't come
from anyone you were telling that to
yourself would you get coved from that
no you would have You' need therapy if
you actually thought that was covered if
you're the one being M yourself
everybody understands it's empty that
you're saying when somebody else gives
you coved you should think of it as if
you yourself are giving yourself coved
so I'm practicing that when people say
this to me it's I'm saying it to myself
just like if I would say it to myself I
would understand that it's meaningless
that's how I view when other
people this is uh the ideology of the
Reb and we have the
it's a great to be here in nickelsburg
in mov at the of three alltime great
sadik and we're going to
begin nit
Rina this is
the so you say
theed that sounds somewhat familiar this
is what we call the
seed Harish
he was a student of the not to be
confused with the
bat he's actually so early he's quoted
by
the brings that there's an indion to eat
fish by three sud and chabas Friday
night chabas day and there's an inan
there many reasons for that however the
gives a that if the fisherman hack jack
up the prices then you don't have to
keep this you don't have to be abused
financially to be m this indan in other
words it's better to keep the economics
of the city feasible for people and to
abandon this custom this is a famous
pack of theed quoted by the M now he's
buried right next to him is re of Legend
has it that samed said that for a 100
years he doesn't want nobody could be
buried next to him and sure enough 100
years later exactly the next great
personality of nickelsburg was buried
right here sham to
okay so we're here we're in the Czech
Republic we're mikov we're nikolsburg
the Reb the renowned
Reb this is very important to understand
the re OFA was one of the earliest
promats of the ideology ofas he was a
talid of the mag however he didn't start
off as a of the mag started off in VNA
by the V and through the influence of
early he moved he became a t of the
maged and he he is responsible for
spreading not only here but throughout
Poland however he didn't fully
endorse some of the views of the B and
theed he
took and combined it to a certain extent
with indepth learning and polish kidos
was deeply influenced but we'll call it
this revolutionized type ofos that was
brought by the Reb so that's why you
find G
like about
the his great Kad his his G his and he
was a great sadic he Afflicted himself
in fasting and he was very close with
his
brother their father
was and The Story Goes that one year sh
was coming and the father says you know
sh is coming what do you think we should
learn so the re said we should learn is
should
learn said you
know is bad Oaths so I know but you
taught us that
we're that we took took an oath to keep
the Torah we have to know the binding
nature of an oath the next year again
was coming and he asked his other son
the which we should learn and said we
should learn
two and K because when gave us the T he
married us so to speak okay the re we
have AER from
him there he writes that the med tells
us it's not good to start with the word
AF anyone who start with an AF had a
very bad downfall like who
the or H
said whoever starts with the word anger
he's done so the Reber
of the fifth per begins how could you
begin a peric with a says re ofka an
amazing thing how many Pim are in 13 Pim
why are there 13 Pim
because is
the therefore it encompasses all
13 the fifth of
the anger
so
is if you have a problem with you should
learn the fifth par ofus therefore the
fifth par ofus begins with the word a he
was born in 17726 he was nter in
1778 how many years did he live 52 years
he would always tell people he had the
Nish of sh he had the Nish of sh in fact
on his deathbed he told people he told
his Tam my is the of sh here's the Simon
we have the same name Shmo was a Ley I'm
a Ley Shmo live 52 years I live 52 years
the only difference is he was and I'm
Justa that's the words of the
re in
the he brings from the
Reka that anyone who doesn't
have cannot be anything in it's not
possible to have unless by these two
said the Reb when he was accepted here
in nickelsburg in the year 1773 5 years
before his ptia so he was preparing to
greet the people and they caught him in
his room saying
shash you know a little bit strange that
he'd be saying these things to so they
asked rebba you know what exactly are
you doing he says I'm
says what does that mean means like this
you know how you should treat coved
imagine if you were M yourself imagine
if the coved you were receiving didn't
come from anyone you were telling that
to yourself would you get coved from
that no you would have you would need
therapy if you actually thought that was
coved if you're the one being M yourself
everybody understands it's empty that
you're saying when somebody else gives
you covered you should think of it as if
you yourself are giving yourself coved
so I'm practicing that when people say
this to me it's I'm saying it to myself
just like if I would say it to myself I
would understand that it's meaningless
that's how I view when other
people this is the ideology of the
re
said and we have
all know it's great to be at the K of
Ben M Benet 17 1753 to
1829 this is what he looked like this is
a picture of
Benet Benet
Marcus
Benedict this is the picture says about
him H
H says
he's like's only son I want to tell you
an
amazing from we know there's
a we bring trees to the Bas there's a
big question about that what's where
does this come from is it even
permitted says very simple make a make a
simple was born on what day
what did his mother do with
him at 3 months what did she then do
with him put him in the sea of reeds
what day was that let's make a three
months
later says why was protected on that day
because that was the day he wased to
give the and what protected him the SF
the reads the tree so we plant the tree
we bring the tree into the
to show that we were to
the that he was hidden on that day 3
months after his
birth it's the second day of rashash
here in nikolsburg and the
Y what's the
Y the Crown Prince is coming to visit
and they need to be prepared and he's
coming he's coming he's coming meanwhile
they're you know they're waiting to DAV
they're waiting to DAV and the hour is
getting late the hour is getting late
and if they don't DAV now they're going
to miss
the says we have to so they start the
and just then the Crown Prince comes in
and he's davening he's daving he's
weeping he's crying and the Crown Prince
is sitting there he's standing there
he's waiting he's waiting he's waiting
he's
Furious and after finishes
the he greets the Crown Prince he speaks
to
him he calms him down he makes
and the Crown Prince said never in his
life did he ever see anyone pray this
way shortly after there was a su there
was an assassination attempt against the
Crown Prince and his life was saved and
the Crown Prince attributed it to the
braa of Benet
now Benet wrote AER
the with DAV from the in
the there was an inscription with his
personal handwriting he would
write I
make will not take pleasure from this
world unless it's really
needed needed for my own personal health
we mentioned the story of when was n in
where car's what
day he's bought brought two hours
later to and ultimately he's buried here
in nikolsburg
on all of