Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
this Torah class is brought to you by
Torah anytime.com America I think your
mama's just arrived today and uh and I
arrived and my stuff is still on the
yeah their stuff is still on the plane
and uh um and yes it's it's wonderful to
have uh have from America come and speak
to us and Enlighten us
and thank you very
much
okay good evening gentlemen it's a great
honor to be here this
evening it gives me tremendous to see
that even at difficult times young men
gather to learn not just to learn T but
to learn with AOS to learn gamar to
learn Rashi and
tus nothing destroys the sitra nothing
destroys thear nothing does more for cl
is than genuin
Li I was asked to speak about a subject
I don't think I ever spoke about this as
a topic by itself the Legacy
ofm I am I am
not um I don't identify you know in
America I don't identify as aardi
although some of my family lineage May
Trace back to Spain so I might have some
saric
blood but I was asked to speak about the
ramban and actually I brought some notes
with me that I read on the plane about
the ramban but I left it on the plane I
was asked to speak about the
ramban's
or and I have what to tell you about it
but I left my notes on the plane so let
me tell you a little bit about the
rambana and then we'll speak about four
the old time
great you know there's a there's an
amazing the
says you know what the Mila of Spain
over ashas was the ritv
says all the of comes from one Shepherd
as opposed to an ashaz where there were
different streams of tradition in
all the says came from ran it's
interesting from the
ran even the same who
writes you know the expression they say
about the ram that from Mo to the r
nobody stood up like mha like the ram
himself by the way ashaz don't agree
with
that you know if I were to ask you who
was the greatest
reine anybody know the answer who's the
greatest
Rish what rashash Rashi
the
Riff
no the the an the rambam yes if you're
AI don't agree with that there's
a and also the
brings
that that RAB is greater than R you
everybody wonders why do asham follow
the RAB
what about the
r you didn't want to start up
with okay but I'm here to talk about the
legacy
of the
ramban the ramban had a tradition in
cabala also the ramban was a of RAB Ezra
R Ezra had G the writes the ran also had
G I had a certain
harha when I was at the mar if you come
out of the mar you go onto the plaza and
you make a left there is a Mata there
that Legend has it the raan is there
even though there are other places that
ran is also purported to be buried but
that this is one of them ran has a c at
the and it hit me it's interesting that
the ran would be buried right at the you
know one of
the most well-known teachings of the
ran it appears in the beginning of it
appears
in it appears in it appears in what's
one of the most welln teachings of
ranim the ran holds that everything that
ab and yob did literally created the
future history and Destiny of the Jewish
people so nobody more than the r
upheld the value of every
single of so you know
his is right there right next to
AB there is a saer the ran
wrote called a
saer which he debated a Jewish apostate
named Pablo
christiani this was a very dangerous
uh proposition for the ran because it
was a lose lose proposition you know if
Pablo Christianity wins a debate it will
be demoralizing for the Jewish people if
ramban wins the debate then will he
escape with his
life there are a few things that I want
to share with you the ran we have it if
you look in the ran we have a saer
called in the course of the argument
they're talking about a lot of much of
the argument is about you know
did Mia come already or you know like
the believe or like we
believe you know we of course believe
didn't come yet actually I once served
on azdin in Queens of geros and the
person was in the
Mikvah and the rozen said to the person
in the Mikvah you're going to be M mitz
yeah
you going to keep chabas yeah do you
believe in Messiah yeah do you believe
Messiah came or will come if you say he
came we can't convert
you they made the conversion dependent
on
that anyway in the course of this
discussion they're discussing
the so Pablo kushani says to Ran hey you
know ran um what does it
mean someone from Yehuda ruled from the
beginning of time who who are these
people Kao didn't have Kings throughout
what the
rabbis so paani says to ran who do you
think you well you think you're such a
big Rabbi that you
fulfill so the ran says some rabbis did
some rabbis didn't if you're called rebi
maybe you have a certain kak if you're
called RAV maybe not and then the ran
says
me I'm I don't qualify and the ran
writes I said this to him out of
humility out of uh politeness meaning he
didn't want to boast and say really me
yeah if there's anybody that qualifies
to be me now the Ran So that hit me as
very powerful here the ramban is
debating this man about the basic
fundamental principles of
Judaism is challenging the ran about a
in
the but instead of the ramban basically
hitting back and saying yeah I am I do
fulfill I'm one of the eminent alltime
figures in CLA is the ran shows in the
course of a debate
the fundamental principles of Judaism
the ran says better to be an un of even
than to you know get a undercut in
better be better to show humility than
to uh get a winning argument I thought
to me that was very
powerful it's one of the great hash of
that
debate was Pablo Christianity asked for
safer from the
ran where Pablo Christian and he said
there in it says Mia may
die and actually he made a mistake
because
that maybe the r talks about in a
different
saer where the ran brings such a
opinion but slipped and he asked
for and the ran says it's not there it
doesn't say it there and yeah it does
and the ran says uh um no it doesn't say
it there and says well the r was one of
the greatest ever lived on so they open
up and the RAM and the ramban reads to
him that a king is destined to arise and
build the B mikdash and gather CLA is
and it didn't say anything of the
sort and the ramban says you think your
your uh
leader your God was mhia he couldn't
even help himself he couldn't even save
his own skin certainly not save anybody
else so anyway this is considered one of
the great acts of hash in this debate a
few years ago I was in France at
um at the
location um excuse me in Spain at the
location of the debate of the ran and
Pablo christani so that's just a little
bit about the ran that the says is so to
speak the RO where pis comes from now I
had a cha I wanted to go to
thear of maybe the four alltime
great now I don't know that there's you
know in America they have uh some Matt
Rushmore you know mat Rushmore you know
the four greatest presidents of the
United States I don't know if there's an
official Mount Rushmore of
but I guess in my own
mind got to be you know the
right in terms
of
um
fi
yeah the
benai and rad right now rad not so hard
to go to the Cav you know where it is
it's say you go to sanhedria in saneda
Cemetery is there and people
come and they pour out their hearts okay
so is not not such a big
deal does on har but he wasn't
originally on har he originally was
buried on in lavaro so actually a few
weeks ago let's say it's almost
right two weeks ago I was in
learno and I wanted to go to the
original spot where the was buried in
lavaro and I wanted to go there on the
day of his burial meaning I want on his
yard side who knows when the's yard side
is so we were trying to arrange the trip
so I should go to
La it didn't work out it was a day off I
was a little disappointed so you say
okay you know it's not like you're going
to his he's not there anymore moved they
moved the from laar to Har but I don't
know I wanted to go there I went there
and I didn't realize I didn't know the
original mat of the is in Leo it's
unbelievable and uh it has on the side
all the the wrote more than 70 or so you
know and a lot of the that the wrote
have the names of parts of the body so
you have
Mo you have sa sh you
have a lot of the a lot of the names of
the are from parts of the body and all
all the are listed on the on the and all
the buried next to
the there is oh this was a bias by the
this was one of the three
who if you whatever your was with the
that's you know that's your
godas anyway so we were there
on we came home shabas and I was
learning on
shabas on on chabas so he was buried on
y so had it that I was to be at the
original of the on the day the was
buried only 218 years later the was n in
1806 and uh we were there in 2024 a
little bit later but Mish exactly to the
date by the way the has an amazing
observation in
the says you know the first comment of
theama you have Miss Brew over here
uh some something very
interesting you know every time the the
Rama writes something what does the Rama
say what word does that with
okay anybody know what's the
first everyone says no it's not yeah
says it's all about talking why does he
say
twice so the say because it's they want
it to be to the
in the beginning of their
work 13
so two
times to the in the very beginning of
his
work starts
off which says what that means is one
should always imagine their Mind's Eye
the sh in front of them doesn't matter
what you're looking at you're looking at
your the wall you're looking at your
friend you're looking at the sun you're
looking at whatever you see there's sh
in front of you and says you should
be
that's the last comments of
the the discusses
the is per something or is not anything
you know do do you celebrate per I think
according to the r and the
r does not have according to other it
does have
says so we have two says the
first the
second is
the
says that if
you're if you put the in front of you
always then you'll be someone
who you'll always be happy you want
happiness if you always see and
everything that happens to you and
everything that occurs and everything
that you do if
you're
you and one thing that's very
interesting so this is officially
um so so you learn you ever
learn
what of
now they have an
addition
has I think what is it called he has a
maybe something like that on the on
the a lot of the of
the were to connect in all MIT that you
do to the shame I'll give you a few
examples the says you know when you give
he would
say it
says the arm is the V the hand is the he
the the coin is the yud even if you use
zel or quick pay whatever it's still
yeah and then the hand of the on is a
hey this way you're you're you're
focusing on the sh in
the or the would say that
after uh daving so you should try to
learn in your a little bit
even and he
says the is the the is the the V is the
MIT and the
is a lot of
the a lot of the
or um you know many of you probably were
not yet M the mitvah of anyone be
the says every time you
say you
should why because even though it's very
interesting brings down what does
mean
shame the name should be made M and
rejects that says that's not what it
means it doesn't mean shame sh means
shame it means the shame but the brings
that that's the and therefore when you
answer you should think you're being
theah of wiping out because when is
destroyed then hashem's name will become
great again the sh will become the sh so
you see in many of the of
the it was focused on
bringing actually uh
I have a very special connection with
the I mentioned my my family origin is
from Poland my
grandfather is a survivor of the
Holocaust he was in aitz he was in Wars
so he was a tal ra zba he was a Ben
biased by RAM
zba and before the war he also knew
English so when he was liberated from
the Holocaust the American Army made him
the head of the religious Department Of
The Joint The Joint was uh an office of
the American Army to help the survivors
so my grandfather after he was liberated
helped the Survivors by printing the
very first farum for the survivors and
the first saare my grandfather published
for the survivors was the LA D of the I
have a copy of it it's in army green it
was published in Germany in 1945 46 the
LA D of the was the first saer published
for the survivors in right after the
Holocaust
in rights in something out of this world
you
know you guys in England you're very
polite you know you're very proper
you're
civilized so probably on purm it's a
very elevated experience it's a very
Sanctified experience you know even if
there's a little bit of drinking I'm
sure it's with tremendous Kad and
and but not
every in the world you know are the
B uh on such a high level as they are
here in right is that how you say it so
the talks
about that
onm and uh where he quotes from the
where the of PM are the greatest
and of any time during the year of any
time in our history says that if CL on
this day would spend the day aside from
being
in especially
in
says he gives like a that if clo would
dedicate
themselves he says there it's certain
for sure the G would happen right
away it was it was very interesting to
me I uh saw recently that one of the
oldtime great
Giants from the world from the mum the
abov you ever the
yob the abov was
born the day the passed away on Al in
1806 so you see that connection between
uh
the and so to speak like the
continuation of the the legacy of the
and what was very interesting to me is
the Benes Kai's
parents were not able to have children
right away and the Benes Kai's mother
from
Baghdad made the trick
trip I think to
Morocco to the abir
yov to get AA and sure enough she gave
gave birth to the Ben from the so you
see you know like from
the to the
the now the Benes you know I cheated
with the
Benes why cuz the Baghdad Kev didn't
work out into the itinerary for certain
reasons we couldn't make it no we were
about to go it just you know didn't work
out but the har you know
and then the mum say that he
moved you know I think shimi one of the
M Bagdad said you know the Ben moved
from Baghdad to Har I go with that so
according to that you know I got that
K Ben is also what he was able to
accomplish and the that he wrote
this the the benai writes we have a
letter from the Benes Kai to one of the
great philanthropists in the sadic
world um he
says you know the benai originally was
in a business partnership with his
brothers his brothers had a whole
business in India and they they
supported
him and somehow there was some kind
of
um impropriety that supposed that was
discovered and the you know Ben was
implicated on it and he was imprisoned
because of it and when he came out he
went into seclusion for some time in M
you know
his but the Ben at a certain point of
time he could not continue to afford to
publish his far and we have a letter
from him I believe to the sason family
that it hurts him more than the fact he
can support his family is the fact he
can continue publishing his far he even
writes he has a historic
and he's willing to sell the
sa to for funding to be able to continue
to publish his far you know when he was
when he was young he discovered in the
BR we make on
havah we make four
BR we
make we
make and we
make so the want to know you know what's
the reason for the order of these four
why first and then and
then and then um and then very
simple then you move up to the nose then
you move up to the eyes and then you
move up to the mind so that's the the
for the reason of those
four now fi that was a tough
one if if uh now I don't highly do not
recommend anyone going to the Kev fagi
in Turkey they're not that friendly to
us right now nor were they when we went
but at that time we didn't know any
better and um I started learning
thei I really loved a lot of
his
the not to be conf sometimes you seen a
say for oh you know when you learn Yesa
and you say you think it's
you know any if you're if you're a proud
you need to say no
is but has many many tradition has that
he has
72 and I like to say his you know R
hutner would say that the yard side of
RAB
salant
was every year R's yard comes out
because RAB was the one you know there
are a lot of people who they're very mid
on you know as long as it's not
interpersonal a lot of people are
on or on or on
different yeah so they'll run to do a
Mitzvah and by doing so they'll step you
know they'll put their dirty shoe on the
guy step on a guy's foot he just shined
his shoes so him so strived his whole
life to put on an equal pedestal all
Mitzvah in the anybody know what did
rant do on AR
y you know what would a big sadic do on
Aram Kipper so we imagine big sadic on
Aram Kipper probably woke up early he
went to the Mikvah he probably was toal
you know 101 times no no no let me tell
what R did arer he woke up in the
morning he davened he had a bite
he went into the kitchen he took a
hammer out of the the cupboard he put it
under his jacket he went to the shoes
and he examined every table and Shear so
that to make sure there was no nail
sticking out cuz if there was a nail
sticking out somebody might rip their
pants and whoever owned the Sho would be
a mazik and there' be no way to pay back
and he proceeded to go to every single
Shool he proceeded to go to every single
shol in the city
so that there would not be any Hees in
the
city held you know that there was once
aab of
people who wanted to
be and they were going to start to learn
and they were going to start with and
then go to shabis and then Ain and RAB
salant said it's wrong you should not
learn sh that way so
why it's almost
entirely
is what should we
learn so who strove his whole
life to equate
all he
was would say like to
say because there
72 get the
72 fagi anyway there was a little
opening that uh somebody called me up he
was able to arrange with the government
to make a trip to Turkey it was for the
yard side of
the cats and I to be at the
ofi and when on the day that we went to
the K ofi it was the yard side of fi's
son RAB fi ra fi was his
while we were there we're walking around
ismir and we see this C it's covered in
dirt it's covered in uh weeds we dusted
it off we cleaned it off and we read the
Mata R fi the son of fi also a very
eminent um God of is I had never heard
of him before but uh I was honored that
you know we cleaned off we were I came
back to America I needed a share to say
I give a share every Wednesday night and
I'm looking for a sh I'm looking for a
topic I'm looking for a topic I remember
it was
par Kisa Anda talks about breaking the
and the topic I was looking into is are
we worried about aara when it comes to
teaching T is there AAR when it comes
maybe there's somebody's standing up
everyone's looking at them is there a in
when it comes
to
so I saw first of all the talks about
well maybe we should learn out that that
say the were given in great Pomp and
ceremony and therefore they were broken
the were given in a more discreet Manner
and therefore they were preserved so
maybe when you teach T you should do it
in a more M setting so I saw they quoted
that fi has a Chu on it oh great I was
justify fi so I open up the CH fi
and he writes one paragraph and he says
let me tell you something when it comes
to this subject my
son fagi wrote pages on it here let me c
let me bring it right over here so a few
days before I had never even heard of
ragi and within moments of visiting him
he he came back and he visited us so so
there you have a little bit you have the
ran the ran was the RO from which all
pis comes from you have
great
and the
andagi and of course Marana now I'm
going to tell you my favorite story that
nobody likes okay but you might
appreciate this a little bit but uh it's
not an easy one to swallow and here it
goes
so was headed to the south of
Israel and
and we're good no okay R was headed to
the South and basically the babaali got
win that rad was coming and this was
going to be the first time that these
two giants would meet fine so Raad is
coming and the Babas is preparing
himself and the basali meets R for the
first time and he's Malala to him that
RAB had the soul of one of the fine he
then says everybody leave everybody
leave everybody walk out he tells RAB
the only one in the room at at the time
he was a little boy and he stayed in the
room tells he feels this it's an a that
the two of us are together in the same
room if we rash right now and we eat h m
will come right
now R looks at his watch he says right
now no I have to go to
AER so the babaali says yeah but if you
don't wash right now I don't know when
mhia will come says
okay
I guess Mia will have to wait and did
not wash because the is that as
important as it is to build a bikash
even more important is the fact that you
come together to learn T every night
that's so it's an honor for me to to
tell
you keep up the great work and Mia
should come after the S is over
you've just experienced another Torah
class brought to you by Torah
anytime.com