Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
[Music]
Shalom everybody Welcome Home to Torah a
warm welcome home to Tor we are now in
the new y b m okay there's only one room
that's kind of ready we're doing
renovations just let me just introduce
this idea that we're going to be using
the CLE car first as the basis of our
discussion and I really want you to
learn Hebrew so down below in the
description box you can find not a
colored copy but black and white
original Hebrew follow it as best you
can if you want want to join the English
sour sheet uh email list so send me an
email and we'll add you to the
list just I want to add one more thing
we are in the midst of Renovations on
our new center and we're coming to
completion as you can see we're sitting
in new chair some of us and I want to
thank those few uh donors who've already
given mamish a real thank you um but
please we want people to consider
various ways they can help
ongoing there's dedication list and I'll
be sending that out in the next email so
there are certain things that are still
available and general contributions can
be made uh through through my email I'm
sorry through the website
y.com and if you are interested in a
special dedication then definitely reach
out to me directly at U Aaron doid a a r
o n d o von.com
that link that email address will be
down below okay so we're in chapter
32 we're gonna look we always learn the
fundamentals right we're talking about
deep Concepts in
Judaism sometimes we deal with things
that you're really interesting like for
you personally and then sometimes it's
new stuff that you would never even have
thought of okay
so again we're really going to learn the
Hebrew because it says
and Rashi actually says these are real
angels why does Rashi need to tell me
that because the word MIM means an agent
um a a a messenger it doesn't always
mean and many times in the Torah itself
malim are referred to as a human agents
human Messengers and we're going to see
a few of those verses so it's very
interesting that he says these were
angels he sent them to asov to convey a
certain
message the main message that he wanted
to convey to him maybe that's an
indiffer shear and I'll put that link
down below is basically he was conveying
that I didn't steal the BR the BR that
our father gave me was meant for you and
I came back to Earth I'm coming back to
Earth Israel he's sending this message
through these agents through these
Messengers through the angels in order
to convince or try to convince ASA not
to kill him right he stole the Bros or
he deceived his father to receive the
Bros obviously those words need to be
discussed um cuz Yakov is emis he didn't
steal he didn't deceive yet the name yov
itself actually means deception so we'll
have to discuss that perhaps another
time but this is the idea of him him
sending these angels to convey a message
he calls asav adoni he calls himself an
evid he's trying to show some of the
blessings that were given to him like
you're going to rule over your brother
doesn't really apply you're still ruling
over me that's the underlying message
but what the CLE card is going to point
out at
first even though the verse says it
actually says he sent them he didn't
send them yet because if you look at the
second verse it says he charged them
saying what do you mean he sent them and
then he's talking to them so he he never
actually sends them and we'll see that
in a second so you never read the verses
like this says he sent them and then the
following verse says he charged them you
can see this on um number so in number
seven on the sore sheet in verse 5 it
says he commanded them saying
V
Tom he calls as my
master
right th says your servant he's coming
in a humbled
fashion so he doesn't really send them
yet if he's talking to them meaning he
charged them to go he commanded them
they should go eventually once he
finishes conveying the message that he
wants to tell over so he charged him
saying to my Lord to ASA so said your
servant Yakov and this is going to be
very important we're going to deal with
this he says I have sojourned with Lavan
and have lingered until now so this
verse right he was imti we're going to
discuss the word GTI it's a very strange
word to use
here and I lingered I was delayed I I I
was delayed L until now now I've come
and he was away for really 20 years but
it took 2 years to return so he was away
for a total of 22 years how 14 years
working for the two wives seven for Leia
really for ra but it got Leia and then
another seven years for ruo and then
another six years to acquire wealth and
then it took him two years traveling
time to return I he stayed 6 months in a
place called sukot but it took him a
total of 22 years let's go into the
clear the clear we see he brings down
Rashi on the first line Parish Rashi
M like what we need to know that okay
apparently now how do we know you're
going to hear three or four opinions how
we know that they were they were
actually Angels how we going to see
this the CLE says that some say
if you just go back two verses remember
we're in verse actually it says we're in
verse four if you go back to verse two
meaning you just turn your page back
right in the Kish just one little page
and on the English Source sheet it's
number two it says yakob went on his way
the angels of God met him right the
yov we're saying these are actually
angel of God so these are real angels he
met two verses before like two minutes
before 2 seconds before two verses
before right he met real angels it
says I'm sorry
Mal these were the angels of God there's
no doubt that he just met a real angels
so what happens two verses later he
sends
Messengers so that's according to the
first opinion it's so obvious that
they're real angels
okay look at um thear he
says you can carefully examine from the
ju
position of the verse which we just
read second
opinion right if you read this the verse
three uh when yak and Yakov said when he
saw them he saw these angels He said
this is the camp of
godak what did he
say he actually called the
place so ritos are acronyms right it's
the first letter well to say the letters
of this particular word can spell out a
whole new sentence and if you look at
the third line down m
it was from that group right um of or
Army of angels Yakov took these
Messengers or in this case real
angels that's the second opinion what
does the explain
raish if you look at verse seven
carefully verse seven
says that the Angels
returned but when were they ever
actually sent we already saw the first
verse as he sent angels and we know for
sure he didn't send them then yet cuz he
was talking to them about what they need
to do and verse 7 says they returned I
mean shouldn't The Narrative have said
after he got done telling them what to
do then he sent them so the first
sending you know the the ISL yov he
never really sent them or maybe they
didn't go he charged them to go but we
don't see let's look at
the he
says we don't see that they actually
departed we don't see that they moved
they went
anywhere sh before they even left they
already
returned the
there's another way to explain
it now this is something
incredible it does say that the
is he sent them before him even in the
English it clearly says that he sent
them ahead of
him what the cleard is going to describe
is whenever malim are sent ahead they're
always God's angels they're real angels
when the word leun of is not used
they're human they're human Messengers
and there's a deep reason why we would
never have figured it out and he says
like
this it's mentioned here it's
specifically mentioned here that yakob
sent them before
him in if you look in two verses numbers
20:4 as well as numbers
2121 and you can see this in the last
two on the page one
um Source four and five Moses sent this
is 20:4 in numbers the
islim but doesn't say leov and we know
that he really sent um um agents human
Agents from Kadesh to the king of
Edom so so says your brother Israel you
know of all the hardships that has
befallen us and again in 2121 of numbers
Israel sent mess MERS to the king of the
amorites
saying right you don't see the word leun
of so these are humans Not
Angels okay so that's what um we're
we're dealing with
here right 1 2 3 four five six lines
then the last two words doesn't mention
the but over here in our verse with
Yakov sending they're really they're
real angels because leun was used now
wait to hear this
sh because their way the way of the
Angel is to go before you now before you
remember they're they're not goshas
there's no physical body so what does it
mean the fun of
k um in in Exodus 23:23
which you'll find in number six God
himself said for my angel will go before
you that's again my Godly Angel right
God speaking they're going to go and is
the same as it's the same concept and
what is this hinting to at this point I
usually would ask drum roll
please thees this hints to the the
idea you know that angels can be in two
places at the same time he never had to
send them they never had a but I mean
look they it says they returned so he
never sent them because they could be as
soon as he said I'm going to send you
I'm going to tell you what this what
needs to be said instantaneously they
were already by asav having a
conversation and return turned with his
response which his response was he's
coming with 400 men wasn't a very good
response I mean it was his response I
read the words
again meaning the idea they're always
before you they didn't have to depart
from your presence to be in another
place it's like Be Me Up Scotty right
R they were constantly in front of
yov even while simultaneously
they did their thing they did their
mission and they were in a different
place by
as and they could appear in two
different places at the same time which
are very far apart from each other I
understand if I was like here on I could
be like you know on the middle of the
street looking at the new y center and I
could be over at reichman's Pizza across
the street it's a great place to
eat okay okay so he
says the only way that you can be in two
places simultaneously is if you're an
angel and we have a room full of angels
who says we can't Elevate to that level
but okay that's for another that's for
another
Shear now for some reason if you wanted
to really argue say you know what maybe
the word theu has nothing to do with
phys physically returning maybe it's
like responded they
responded maybe it's just they responded
they didn't actually leave and come back
and have a have right a
return maybe that's what you want to say
he already has an answer right that's
the Brilliance of what did they you know
they did respond and
say we came to your
brother the very fact that we're
not he it's not a response but even if
you want to say it was a response what
was their response we were there we were
there so that's what they say that means
they could be real angels in two
different places at the same time okay
now we're on actual verse five he
right thus he says this is the message
he's conveying your servant Yakov he's
calling he's telling the Angels tell um
asav I'm his
servant and I was with laan it should
have said a I worked for him he worked
really for 20
years says I gy I lived with him
the and I was delayed Rashi explains two
things now the clear is very humble he
doesn't like Rashi explanation a very
minor
point and he says I disagree but in a
very um honorable way and he even says
if I was not embarrassed in front of my
colleagues I would have erased these two
words and those two words
are things that the clear uses all the
time and I think I understand him when
he uses those words and I think we can
all understand in Judaism it's about
unifying everything right the world is
really under the opes of God God is one
and everything's connected to him
everything let's start with this Parish
rashi rashi says G which means I live
there
very strange but okay I only was a gar g
implies not having an important position
it's like just a regular person I didn't
become uh high up Authority I didn't
become popular I didn't become ex
whatever very important I did not become
an important
person El I just remained a simple
person
that's going to be the key words that
the CLE car would like to do away with
and the reason he wants to do away with
them is because normally means
alternatively alternatively means that
scratch everything we just said and
here's a whole another shot I want you
to know what I think when the cleart
also
says it doesn't mean alternatively as
scratch what we said but another
dimension another level and he puts it
really nicely he says it's two sides of
the same coin but when you read Rashi
the interesting thing is GTI implies as
Rashi says I didn't become important I'm
just a regular guy I didn't get the
bras says means MIT sharti while I was
away by Lavan I kept the Torah I kept
the 613
misses and if you think about that it
means that I am important I don't know
if you realize we are Jews we have 613
Commandments we are called
aim we are a kingdom of priests go kados
and that's because of the Torah and the
Commandments that we have so he's going
to
say these are very contradictory
Concepts one is I'm a nobody I'm just a
regular person not
important on the other hand he's
saying I kept all Mitzvah I mean like
almost you know you put your chest out a
little bit with some pride right I'm a
king I'm close with God right the whole
world is dependent on what I
do it's very different one is which is
submission you're my master I'm your
slave I'm just a gar I'm just a uh a
regular person on the other hand I kept
all 63 mitzah and the clear
says these two
explanations they're completely opposite
they they contradict each other and now
he spells it
out if you're going to say the words
lo I did not become a
representative in the government I
didn't become a minister I didn't become
an important
person then certainly he's coming
towards as in a submissive
fashion now on the other
hand that I guarded I kept all these
6113 Mitzvah masma adaba you know the
word adaba means the opposite it gives
the other impression it's a impression
of the
opposite MIT he's giving the impression
because I kept the 60 63 mitz I've
nothing to fear from you right the
opposite of
submission the now there is in chapter
27: 40 it's number eight on the sore
sheet when Isaac y gave the broos to
Yakov remember according to what we
think that he did not know that it was
being given to Yakov he thought he gave
those Broast to
ASA it's going to be play an important
part it says you shall live by your
sword and it
says V You Shall Serve your
brother now that's
true
asov would serve the Jewish people yob
bov however if Yakov did not keep the
Mitzvah then Asa has the the right to
grieve I'm using that
word if the Jewish people do not keep
the Mitzvah then Asa has the right to
complain and has the right to remove the
Yoke of his you know the brother he's
serving and then
persecute right basically rule over the
Jews so asav is going to be submissive
according to this verse but if the Jews
don't keep the Torah so then asav rules
over Yakov and what the clear is trying
to say by by him saying I kept them
mitzvas then it's an then it's it ruins
the principle here that you will rule
over your brother and if again the the
main part is that if he doesn't you have
the right to usurp the rulership so
that's one idea the another problem
is why does yov call as my master the
atmo evid and he calls himself in a
submission submissive fashion
the
Slate it's really like exaggerated he's
really going overboard in trying to show
that he is on the submissive
side and another question about the
actual language
G is another word we all refer to the
613 Mitzvah as Tarak it's the exact
letters that we're using right GTI and
tag are the exact same letters but in a
different order and the message is
somehow hinted at and embedded in the
word so these are more like questions
everything he just said at this point
were more questions and
answers so the clear wants to answer
Al my heart wants to say the following
and
teach P these two uh explanations of
Rashi remember how Rashi used the
word it sounds like an alternative
answer he
says that really in truth both of these
answers are like one truth it's all true
and it's one truth and that's really the
way you know we we look at the gar we
say this Rabbi argues with that Rabbi
you ever heard of the expression Al the
El
these and these are the words of the of
God one true God so here too they're not
alternative answers according to clear k
rashi rashi used the
words masma when you use those words
when Rashi uses those
words each one is its own individual
independent answer and not necessarily
congruent
remember what was the message yov was
trying to get
across the
word I did not become an important
minister or an important person I just
remain the simple
person what was the message
was those bras that Dad gave me were
meant for you they were never filled in
me
but he doesn't want to make his father
look like he gave broos that don't that
are not worth anything he
says he doesn't want to contradict his
father his father gave him the
Bros and that to make the Bros like they
were um
invalid uh past is a little bit of a
deception but God forbid that there was
anything any funny business going on
they weren't superficial they were
real but this is going to be very I
would say drum roll please at this point
it's going to be very important we're
about to
[Music]
say when my father Our Father y blessed
me according to what Yakov is saying I
don't know if yakob believed it I I I
have a feeling that yak actually knew
that he was blessing yakob
but let's just go with the flow that
he's telling asov that when ABA blessed
me he thought I was
you and with that in mind he blessed me
and hear this
out when I do something that is
deceptive something that's not yes
something that not straight I will never
benefit from it in fact nobody will
benefit if you do something you
steal you think you're really benefiting
from what you
stole listen to what he
says I look like I stole this is his
conversation looks like I stole looks
like I
deceived there's the principle a
principle is that if it was meant for me
I'll get it if it was meant for you it
doesn't matter how hard I try I will
never benefit from that which was not
meant for me um there is a Gamora here I
wanted to show you if you look at number
10 we're going to deal this with this
verse in number nine uh Proverbs 12:27
but look in Yuma 38b what I highlighted
the principle is no person may touch
that which is prepared for another by
God God prepared you're going to be
wealthy there's nothing I can do to
remove that wealth from you everybody
receives what is designated for them so
let's go back into the clear he
says
the with that in mind that's how I would
right that's
how
blessed and whatever deception I might
have
done it didn't help me at all because of
this verse in Mish Proverbs
12:27 though now that says that you he
will not roast his pre of Deceit meaning
you know remember asov was a hunter and
Hunters they they bring back game so you
take this game that's not yours you're
not going to sit and have a barbecue
it's just not going to happen I mean
whatever might
happen it's not it look appearances are
appearances but it's not happening
you're not going to steal and benefit
from it um if we want to look at Rashi
real quick and this is this idea he will
not Rose his prey of Deceit this is
connected to the verse above in in
Proverbs that is to say that the Way of
the Wicked Will mislead him he will not
roast the prey of his deceit meaning he
will not roast he will not succeed with
his deceit it's not going to benefit you
at all and as Solomon spoke of the
figure with a figure of prey
specifically which really relates to
asav is an expression of roasting is
appropriate for the successful Hunter
hunts the birds and roast them in fire
okay let's go back into the cleard this
is very important principle he
says remember Rifka coached him they
brought him food to yak and Yak was fed
the food so what he's saying whatever I
fed our
father that I was going to get the bras
through giving him food
it's just not
happening if it's not meant to be for me
whatever dad had in mind for you it's
still going to you there's no reason to
kill me remember this whole thing is
that he's trying to uh get out of being
killed yeah that's how I'm sorry the
next
point he's trying to convince as that
all the bras are going after whatever
father had in
mind and according to yov whatever y had
in mind was the bras were for you not
for
me and you'll get the Bras don't worry
and I'll stay alive if I can just calm
you
down proof for this or a sign for
this he says right we know this idea
he's just a gar in the land
meaning he didn't become a important
person now if you want to
say okay for some reason if Yakov if ASA
would turn around say you know what you
did get the blessings okay and I got the
blessings but I didn't become this
important person even today I'm not even
an important
person maybe it's because I didn't do
the Torah but remember what he says G
right this was actually known toov when
he did receive the Bros that it's on
condition that he keeps the Torah
T MIT on condition I want every Jew out
there to hear this maybe this is news to
you we have a special Mission we're
Servants of God we serve our creator and
it's pleasurable it's extremely
pleasurable right there's no greater
pleasure so don't think it's
all you know hard work it's a lot we
we're like living in a musical right
Jews if you're really with the program
it's like you're living in in in a
musical you're going from a Chev to a
wedding to a bris shabis in between like
life's
great so he
says
um it's all based on that and we go back
to that other
verse and when the Jew or the Jews don't
keep the Mitzvah then asov has the right
to complain and then put the Jew back in
his place so to
speak now we understand why he
says he was saying I kept all the
mitzvas and
nevertheless okay we can call it
deception he was trying to save his life
he wanted to convey a message to him and
the message
was I I kept the Mitzvah but I didn't
become so important the bras Were Meant
for
you I did not benefit from my
actions there's no way that I would
benefit from any kind of
Deceit and the that gave he thought he
was giving to you and therefore the bras
remain on your head not on mine that's
why he says
had many
meanings one of it we said is like a g
which implies I didn't become an
important person you have nothing to
worry about the bras were not fulfilled
in me and T even if I kept the Mitzvah
you see I did keep the Mitzvah and I
still didn't become a an and that's why
the CLE car doesn't like the the CLE car
does not like the words
it's he says they go together it's not
opposite messages it's the same
message even though I kept the Mitzvah
he's trying to convey to him I still
didn't become important has to be the
caseti why did he even use the word GTI
wouldn't have made more
sensear he could have said or should
have said a he worked for 14 and and
then another six years he that's what he
did he really was in truth m a slave to
Le and that's opposite of the blessing
that we saw in chapter 27: 29 it says
this is also what was given to ASA I
mean literally given to yob but he
thought he was giving to ASA Nations
Shall Serve You and kingdoms will bow
down to you it says you shall be a
master over your
brothers we all know Yakov got the BR
and I believe that y knew that he was
giving yakob the bras but okay in the
meantime yakob is trying to get you what
do you call Live Another Day right
something like that so it's the
opposite you're going to you know you're
going to overpower your brothers
have to understand it's the same letters
as tag right 613 now at this point he
says what I said in the beginning the
the
ELO if I was not this is the cleart
saying if I was not embarrassed in front
of my
colleagues I would just simply erase
those two words
according to him it all fits in so
nicely that y that yakob is really
trying his best I'm not going to use the
word deceive anymore he's really telling
the truth right as I
wink um because it is that you know
yakob is EMS you know when he even
fooled when he fooled his father it was
Rifka that told him to do it she was a
prophetess she was and
you know they even say not only did he
asov sell his Birthright which he had
every right to but even in the womb they
say who comes out first you have twins
it's a little bit uh hard to imagine in
what we know about modern science but if
you have a test tube you put in two
marbles the first marble goes in then
the second marble goes which comes out
first the second one comes out first
asov came out first because he was the
second marble Ian using you terminology
but he was the second one he was not the
first born and even if he was he sold us
and Rifka was a prophetes and she had
everything under control her a anyway so
with that in mind we hope that you did
learn something we saw some fascinating
principles as we said we got a little
bit more insight into the para and I
wish everybody not only a good
chabis and coming up Hanukkah soon but a
good life a good life and we'll see you
on the other side thank you for
participating
[Music]