Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
What May Be Done Before Birkas Hatorah? - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith
244 views
1. Saying שמע קריאת) to make the zman) before saying התורה ברכת 2. Thinking Torah thoughts (הרהור (before התורה ברכת 3. Doing a mitzvah (i.e. shaking lulav) before התורה ברכת 4.Saying ברכת התורה before י״ג מדות or קדושה 5. Saying Tehillim or תחינות before התורה ברכת 6. Should one say התורה ברכת before putting on talis and tefillin? 7. Listening to leining before התורה ברכת 8. Called for aliya or to lain before התורה ברכת was said 9. Listening to a recorded shiur before התורה ברכת 10. Paskening a sheila before התורה ברכת 11. May one who is late for davening say התורה ברכת after davening? 12. Drinking a coffee before התורה ב
Categories:Torah/Halacha
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Easy.
[Music]
like to welcome everyone to today's
will be done before
Michelle sponsor
his daughter tomorrow night
from the new couple
for sponsoring Lyn
sponsoring call 7188518651
or email is.com.
>> Someone asked me recently he was making
a mitzvah and he wanted to know what's
the right way as far as putting on
fillin. Should he first say and then put
on fillin or you could put on fillin
first and then say
so interesting thing is to all of us but
as we'll see it's not so also talk about
someone that woke up late and he has to
say Krishna to make this man is he
allowed to say that without
can someone say
kadusha he walks in the sh and he has a
kadusha can he say kadusha before
and we'll soon see other questions but
really the common denominator for Today
is a simple question with many and that
basically is
is there a
when is there an isa to learn or to say
do a mitzvah before
in other words we know one thing it's
very wrong it's terribly wrong to learn
before
just like we don't eat before saying we
don't do a mitzvah before making a
mitzvah
is the on the learning whether it's
or
whatever this whatever it is it's
probably all three but you're not
allowed to learn before you say
but there's really much more to this
there's a well-known gmorra in the
where the says that
and no one knew of No one know why there
was a until
explain
that means as as the on the points out
they learned day and night they were
great people no one knew what the a was
but the a that caused the even though
they learned day and night was that they
learned without
and that's the famous.
Whatever the case is, the Torah begins
you have to be very careful with
and he quotes and in the beginning of
Zion also uses simil
it's not often that the begins with such
a statement every mitz is important but
here it's especially important that's
the reason of the mr The says
so that's why all agree
the
was was the
good children when you say properly. So
we have to take this very seriously.
So this is inf
says it clearly
and
as the explain although tora is a higher
level than
understandably and gumar is less than
that but it's still it doesn't have to
only except
any
soil
and you're putting on you're saying the
that's a
so
whenever there's a in davening and
putting on in anything however However,
here we come to a very simple but a very
fundamental question that's going to
have probably tens of meanings.
If a person learns a
he certainly is to say but when you say
at when you finish putting on you're not
saying it to learn
you're saying it quote unquote as part
of or part of so maybe you'll make the
following distinction when you learn to
like typically we do you make on
anything on
But when you're saying
as part of
maybe it's looked at like and that's no
doubt about it. You're allowed to say in
the morning
afterh
you didn't say
it's holy words and it's not a so maybe
we'll take that a step further. Even if
you say a but if you say
maybe it's what's the
I'm say say it's what's the I'll tell
you four minutes before we start when a
person is holding at the end of this man
can he quickly say without
in
but you're saying
maybe allow to say kadusha
Even though comes from
but you're saying
maybe another
but maybe if you're saying
there's no
so I perhaps could prove this from
something we just had pretty recently.
We know on tishab there's an isa to
learn to
we don't learn you can't learn on on
tishab because it's so now the question
is how come we said oash in d if you
can't learn why can you say it on
tishabukas
they're all what's to say it it's tim
it's maybe that from here we seen that
if you learn and you're not allowed to
do it on but if you're saying it
had we relabeled it we we redirected it
and now it's part of ding you're allowed
to say it maybe I'll tell you a stronger
ayah the famous
and that really a person could be
with and we discussed this last year
says you could be
In other words, if you want to be you
have to learn right away. So that means
you finish say
whatever it is finishing and then learn
something. So the oldest question is why
do you have to say you're going to you
have to learn right away? Typically
after Shak and what comes after
Krishna
so of course you're learning what do you
have to add
maybe the is the same concept you have
to learn after
butish that we say both in shak and is
said mitzvah maybe
is not limit so we have two rias that if
we We label something it's not the
regular conventional. So I'll tell you
and I'll tell you a third riot happens
just last week we discussed this that
you're not allowed to say a half a when
you're learning
in beginning of raise pay but a half a
you're allowed to so we see three
precedents that when you say something
it has of but could be if you say
maybe it's not the full identity of and
maybe it's not.
So this
we have a source for this and gives us
direction. The Torah in the beginning of
sin me come out of the beginning. The
Torah records the meaning of Ashkanaz
that they woke up in the morning they
said numerous and then they said
it bothered me. Why are you saying
before?
And I decided I'm not following
and I'm going to say first thing in the
morning be and then I will say
now we see two things from this Torah.
first of all that Ashkenaz was to say
before
and we'll soon see a much bigger
Ashkanaz was to say
before
why obviously if you're labeling it as
but we also see the although in a
certain sense he was from the aim
ashkinaz he did not like Dominic and he
changed it cuz he felt Why say a before?
Now there's an earlier source that is
shibi in sim quotes the minig of the
mayor rutenber that was that that lisa
you allowed to fel
before
but the ri insisted no and I'll quote
the ri that what do you mean you say for
soar
says you have to say
so how could you say before
so we see our question is in fact
the augur one of the earlier and sim and
actually the mariel and simnun we find
the same.
So we see our question was very well put
ashkaz
was to save before apparently
not said
but there was resistance the did not
like the mig and I'll tell you another
person had this approach in
he says that the mig was to say before
but says the I didn't like
Now the was known as the
but he did not like the of saying
before.
Now if you want something noteworthy and
that's an understatement there's a
who asks an obvious question
we ask him
the question is I we all know
and not
so why did I say
so one terret the famous terret is that
learn what they have to know.
So they make a on that then adds a
second terrorist
that
and get ready for this and to say
so
make you know today many men don't say
and says women say but listen what he's
saying you have to say because of carbon
I carbon is part of davening
The answer is it's part of ding but it's
stillim whether it's whether it's
so now we see the himself feltim
that we say
are still
so we see this very clearly now if you
want to see a very sharp lion defending
ashk the marshal and simun he quotes the
that that did not like the minig of
saying before he says it's
and there's no problem and even sayow
even say before
so I hope it's clear that the following
always was to be
before
but many
rejected that now
are not
why Yeah. So if you look at the chamb
says that you must make in the morning
first thing in the morning even though
you're saying a
doesn't make a difference
and that's why
test says says
so clearly says that we don't rely on
that.
Why you say it?
However, the then adds
okay. But if you know the style when he
says and then he says
he doesn't pass like that. So the have
basically no choice before
they must say.
However,
adds his famous.
So
did accept min
in
the
all accepted min.
However, the Mr. Bur in two places
and
seems to say and I guess he means to say
the following. You're right. You could
be and say before but everybody agrees
it's better to say first you have no
choice. there are most but no one says
it's a mitzvah to say and then so really
insists that we follow the right way by
saying first and then saying and then
saying
actually there are more
so we have a pretty tricky question that
to say before
the tour changed the mar changed and the
seem to have changed and that's the of
the so our simple question is far from
simple but we could say the following
have to say
but there's nothing wrong with following
the of many try to say try to say
And of course before
now let's apply this. So one thing I
think we should mention we have a
problem right away and that is we walk
into and if you follow the that quotes
we say
now wait a second.
[Music]
So how do you say that before? So if
you're say at home, you have no problem.
But let's say you say when you get the
why are you saying
so listen to this
he says our
so that's why the
is we say
they make up their own they don't use a
regular so in other words it's sort of
like a that's the justification of
saying
now the is not like that and evidently
even the
do say
would rely on the
next question. Someone comes late to sh
and typically when you come late you
know a
and but his story true story he jumped
into catch
he did not say so saying how lucas he oh
I didn't say
what should he do so we would think well
you know to say
is maybe have a mind
maybe you'll just continue saying it
wrong
and this is
caught in yours. What are you thinking?
You're going to continue saying
it. Then you're going to get to
it in the don't do that. So, you have no
choice. You have to stop where you are
say
and Mr. adds and you can even make them
afterwards because it's wrong to
continue saying
without
in other words felt it's not to go with
the we don't say before so much so that
you're allowed to be in the middle of
and say
now obviously this is also a another
reason Why writes this in
B when a person comes late don't skip
first of all you can't with
if you do skip you're going to have a
problem you're going to be with so
you're going to lose three is because of
so the best thing is to come on time you
know people say when when I'm late which
is better to skip or not to skip so I
say wait a If you say which is better,
that means you're better. No, which is
worse is the way to say it. And it's
worse to skip.
So the best thing is to come on time.
That's the best thing. But skipping is
not an option. Question. Someone walks
into and they're saying kadusha. Now I'm
not that he's dreadfully late for the
minion, but he's coming for the next
minion. But this minion they're holding
the earlier holding kadusha. Can he say
kadusha with the you have to realize the
first of is a
is a
and is a so you're about to say three
without
so the question is is that okay so this
is a perfect
had it been to before you have no choice
Mr. The says in the beginning of the end
of
that when you even though you said kadoo
already if you walk into a that's saying
kadoo you have to say with them it's a
Mr. points out it's a
true but if there would be no to say
before
so then don't say according to some it
might be
you're saying without
but
it seems that the and this is
interesting the m is not discussed but
the later pkim did say that if you're
going to miss kadusha if You can't even
say one. you can't
then you have no choice but to quickly
be to say with the team now like I told
you it's interesting there's no there's
nothing about this but we find something
that's perhaps a bigger
says when a person comes into he's
holding before
and they're saying
so is that when
You say with them
let's say you come into saying and you
didn't hold
you have no choice you must say at least
why because
the points out but don't say beyond that
don't start being firm and saying just
to be safe because you're holding before
now it's interesting he says They both
say is but don't say what about
do you say?
So let me tell you, I'm sure you know
this is not a
it's a based on based on so it seems
you're allowed to say
because the it's not a we'll soon see
it's it's a it's used as a so here's the
point a person is holding before
he's allowed to say the
which is no more than a minute because
the himself writes if the is saying
and you're holding up.
Don't say it's aim.
What should you do? Close your eyes and
play along. You continue saying, but
close your eyes as if you're saying
Israel. What's that? Say is only a
minute. If you could have if if it comes
to a half sick, don't do it. But it's
enough of a to say before
the last and that's if you're allowed to
say
with only a meaning
you're allowed to say
with which is a and he has a very good
because it's a from that case. So we're
going to say the following. If someone
comes late and he could say even one
even
and then say that's better after you'll
say the other two of of of but let's say
it's timesensitive it's either say it
now or lose then the seems to be like we
said it's a you're allowed to say
kadusha and rely that it's
and that's the we could rely
The next question
and that is saying
before
I hope it's very clear that even though
the meaning was to be but there are more
says it twice
do things correctly you come to you say
and then you start
we should not
if we could do it more correctly, more
properly. So
the question is if someone p comes into
and they're saying
and he didn't say yet. So you can't say
and then say because you have to say
with the So it's interesting the thinks
that
it's not true
about
but there's no to say with
you need a to say it but there's no on
every person to say every time you give
and that's Why it's could be that when
you come saying that don't say with them
but I did see the
end of he says it's not but you need to
say with the so if once you're holding
the of labeling it as a it makes sense
you could say with even though you're
holding before
okay the next question shouldn't happen
but it happened a person wakes up late
in the morning and he has two minutes
till
now if he says first he's going to lose
the so of course this is not the way to
be and you know we see this
unfortunately
they're in bed with with pajamas and no
hat no filler no talis
that basically the not the right way to
say Christian but the sh is what am I
going to do if I wake up and addressed
and and and and say I'm going to lose
his mind. So in that extenduating
circumstances there is no choice you
have to say I have to say before
so then we're going to rely on the
meaning that is being said
note
and is so again it's not the right way
to do it
is
that's not the way it's done in bed in
pajamas but if it's
This would be the eight. So
the interesting thing here is that the
I'm sorry in inf
quotes
in the test that
if someone only said
and didn't learn
he's
that mitzvah. Now the question is why is
he the mitzvah if he said mitzvah
apparently
also includes the mitzvah of
but then we have a different direction
that we're being sent in and that is I
mentioned earlier says if you want to be
with you could be but
you have to learn right away the himself
Why do you have to learn what's wrong
with so the for us is pretty obvious if
you're saying
maybe it's not so then we have to
understand so why
minimally
so a lot has been said about this but
basically it seems that ideally Krishna
that said we try to treat it like tora
but The function is
and that's why we could understand when
you say
and basically you have a mind to be
those that did not learn they had to be
have a mind to be with
now you'll ask me so why do you have to
learn something after ding when just
bees with So it could be a totally
different reason because the issami's
problem is that every single morning you
see not.
So how do I know punk today that you
want to be with? It has to be nick. When
do you how do you make it nicker? By
after learning, you don't go home for
breakfast. You take out a a and you
learn. So if the learning after a is to
make it,
we very easily understand you can't be
withishma
because not every day you say and so it
could be both are true. If you have a
mind to be with
it's fine. It's but
with and and that you learn the learning
going back that's not
so
but again it's not ideal it's far from
ideal to say in bed but if there's no
other choice you can beishma
without and you'll keep it as a mitzvah
not as
now there is another important question
which I would like to mention and that
is imagine someone woke up and he said
Krishna before this man he's ding 9:30
and he dabs Krishna and basically he's
said this man so listen to an
interesting question a person wants to
ask me this because I guess he was
thinking he forgot this morning to say
but he said ready in the morning he says
yeah that now when he comes to ding
saying he comes torishna that he says
before
he wasn't even he's not being to that
it's after this man why is he saying if
it's after this man so is to stand
so if you're telling me that your
what's before the happening before I
told him he's right unless he's being
with
then he has but if he wants to b say
after dinging
And it's not he can't say then so we'll
have to skip the it's only being said.
So again the bright thing that avoids
all sh on time for and everything works
out wonderfully. Now I'll tell you
many yed stay up night and they don't
dab in they go to sleep and they dive in
the regular time 9:15 whatever it may
be. So they have a little of a problem
because once they go to sleep after so
the say and since there is a chance that
they might wake up after this man
Krishna is sure torish pretty early so
the meaning has become that if if you
dive in right away so you're fine but if
you're going to go to sleep by you
should say Krishna before you go to
sleep so this is a question again to
thousands of Eden
are you allowed to say Krishna after
without
because presumably the new day this
but then again you're going to go to
sleep you're going to wake up at 9:00
and you'll say
so you can't say it now because you're
saying it then but wait a second
but if I'm going to sayishma before I go
to sleep maybe the
have no choice the terror is but that
will say we'll rely on the Krishna is
saying
is lashem
note lima. So better don't say Krishna
don't listen to someone else's Krishma
which is just as good sayishma
note
go to sleep when you wake up you'll
haveishma you have
but to say
you're get losing more than you're
gaining
you're losing more than you're gaining
so it's best would be to not to say and
rely on two things first of all who said
if you didn't go to sleep but more more
we rely on Christian being a mitzvah and
note
okay now the next question which is also
an important and that is when a person
comes to sh even early
and the saying so I told you earlier Mr
says in that case you should say along
with the even though you didn't say but
again only
is also okay not the because That's
already unnecessary and that should not
be done before. Now question and that is
a big question of saying
before. So let me remind you that we say
some people say it every morning some
people say it's but but basically
is minimally from it's the it's the of
of so it's not but it's definitely
but there's a much stronger factor that
might impact that with and that is the
famous medish that
that his should not just be it should be
enough to that
wanted his to have meaning. So he's
wondering that people should get and
they say as if they're learning the
which is the most difficult one of the
most difficult.
Now there is a discussion if the wasab
the
expresses doubts in this per
if was but I did see enough that assume
that was in fact
he has a whole to say when you're about
to say
and it should
has a meaning and this is in
have this meaning to say on why
because has
to
be
what can be better than do something
that has so much meaning in it. So be
that as it may
is definitely minimally
and maybe even
so now
it makes sense you can't say before
and one of his says
you have to be not to learn or say
before
which makes a lot of sense. However, I
should say it's more than the kayod the
lavush in in in in simmon alf test the
famous lavush he says talking about and
basically lavush's point is both and
cannot be said before
now his point his main point is the
zi
is tim is but more than Z
you look at the
of the
a lot of it is but why do we say
before
so he says it's
but it's not just
saying words and he goes on to say the
meaning of saying
is
in other words there's some that some
that want to
And we have to pierce that we have to
avoid that. So the way that is if we say
the
is like cutting it cuts away all the
machin. So therefore he says it's much
more than standard
and definitely he says integral part of
and therefore he says that the is of
course we should say um the the before
the because it's and also has a special
function to cut away the matri
so we see very clearly that tim needs
is but in extenduating circumstance
where
hey someone asked him he's an older
person he wakes up sometimes a few hours
after he went to sleep he's barely
rested and he can't fall asleep so he
wants to say a little bit till hopefully
that will then put him to sleep but he
starts saying
then he's going to be so awake he won't
fall asleep so he says basically you
rely on the saying note
and therefore you can be but here we
want to of it to cut away the and that's
why
the should be
should require
because of the status of
and also it's
now lisa I did see uh an interesting
thing I could say is a because the
shabas one of the famous onro
a
which is
he says the is during the week you could
say you could say till
but not on
is not a because really we could have we
have the option of saying tillum
exclusively as
then you could say it before but you're
not you're not offer
so you can't make it. So if you do say
till what is it
tora needs to so we definitely see that
we could identify till asra and should
require
now if someone comes to and they're
saying for and he wants to join and he
can't rush up to I can hear because that
particular is said
but on a regular basis for for tim and
and
also we should treat it like real and
should require
now there is a big which is not for now
or when is awesome is some allowed to
say so the m quotes this even though not
all agree
that that in the morning we don't say
till of the afternoon where we see
certain cool we sit up some are make to
say till of the afternoon others will
not not do that call they will they'll
make up the onish
but the point is it's the same shim
because if you hold that till isra then
you can't say on or but if you want to
relabel it as
then maybe tak could understand why it's
and I once saw this and I looked it up
again to make sure I was saying
correctly in
he has a beautiful story there where
Kanyash
said her father told her that even
though she was during a she's allowed to
say tale so she told him that's at my
father's sac she goes no your father sac
is only for women not for men so she
couldn't figure out what that mean I
mean different but it's very beautiful
because for a woman that doesn't have
the mitzvah of
so what does function as
so it's but for a man that besides the
tum and its greatness as a it's also
maybe it's for a man so is a woman and a
man regarding
but we should do things correctly when
possible before we do day.
The next question, believe it or not, is
easiest of all and that is when a person
says in the morning whether it's or
he definitely should say
and this is that I mentioned in
because why do we say in the morning?
What is one of the primary reasons
besides
to start the day to add more
to have you have you have so if it said
you can't say it's just
and more so
it's not it's
so explains it's not
should be said I should mention that in
cotton
says that don't say
before
because it's not just
now we did see
oh very good we get that too very good
why are we on to say so the says
explains because whatever is part of the
is said tish even though it originates
from now I should mention regarding
don't forget what we saw for the taz
quote this why do say in the morning
every morning because of that means
requires
even for women for men so here listen to
this carbonis are considered Even on
tish number one even
and some men don't take at all. What
happened? Where'd we go wrong? If it's
if women say it men should say it. So
that's has to be changed. We have to say
it's part of it's part of the it's part
of let's move on. Okay. Interesting.
someone was
when someone relied on a rabba
even though you're not supposed to but
he he wanted to rely on aa and didn't
say
in the morning he should not say kabonis
because again without you can't have now
I'll tell you an interesting sh we have
in our camp every year we want the to
sleep a little later so we das and we
make the Second man, Krishna. Now all
the those that are mak and the first man
which really we should. So what do you
do when you when you make making the
second man typically on regular shabas
many people have this this quandry we
say Krishna before the first man and
make it tonight. If Allah like the first
man this myrrishma if Allah like the
second man I want to be right with the
second man and my first Krishma is a
terrible vad. So every year the get all
nervous
you can't
so how could I say with tonight
is when we we don't mean you're learning
auga we mean I don't want it to be
mitzvah what is it it's a suffic it's a
standbyish
a suffix standbyish but not that I'm
limit and once it's not real it doesn't
require it it's not a problem on okay
question and that's where we began. Is
there any problem of doing a mitzvah
before example putting a talent fill? Is
it anything wrong with putting a talis
in fill and then saying or comes a
sukus? You're walking to shul did not
say yet and your friend has the most
gorgeous estri. So you say please let me
shake it. I'll give it right back. You
take it. You shake it and give it back.
You didn't say
okay do a mitzvah before.
So the question that you might wonder is
what what's the sh if I'm just doing a
without saying anything I'm not
learning. Why should
and we find that
so that's why it seems to do a before
although you're not a robot you think
how do I shake this side and that side
how do I put on filling I I I I put on
make the braha first then I make the and
then and I do everything Right? So even
though you're thinking what to do but at
the end of the day it's
ain't
the only question is going
and he holds you do make a
does that mean according to you can't
put on oralis or because of her the
answer is that's not true because the go
himself in says you'll do a mitzvah
before
I there's inevitably here. So the go's
words are that this is a mitzvah and
what does that mean? So we have he
recently put out a that he wrote it's a
wonderful safer all what he has from the
and the
when you do something as a mitzvah it
doesn't have the status
it could either be or mitzvah but it
can't be both and the brought is the
famous migill that everybody wonders
about
for migill so the question is why is it
to migill?
So some say it's of learning but
is once you're giving it the status of a
mitzvah it's not a mitzvah is a mitzvah
is a different mitzvah but you can't
have two mitzvah overlapping it's too to
have two different mitzvah so perhaps
this what what the meant that's
explained once you're saying that I'm
putting on oral
mitzvah it doesn't have the status of
Tory even in here and therefore you
could in fact put on
or take before
now the the only problem with putting on
before is not
it's the you might say
or
whatever it is. So that ta is a problem
and that's why some would prefer first
saying and then putting on but many
people do put on first the of the
which all the
so it seems that the belt that puts on
fill in first when they say they're not
thinking of learning the in they're
thinking of saying the the beauty of
that we are like married to
so it's not and that's why it's
I should mention
literally half a line he's talking about
this the earliest man for he says some
people they thought they say they take
by the earliest man but he says don't
forget to say
before you
So it seems he holds on you have to have
you have to have but it's probably a and
that's not
there's another true story a walked in
and just then they were now if this
happens in he's dreadfully late and
shouldn't happen it happened there they
every day and this is common place when
people walk in late
they called in con and he's Yeah.
So the question is can he so don't
forget is straight but is so how can you
say before before the is not saying he's
saying
he's not saying it this is a mitzvah and
a mitzvah is before
next question also happened someone came
in late tried to smuggle in a little
late a lot
And they called him to an aliyah. So
he's holding for I don't think he was
wearing tal. I don't know how he did
that but anyhow they called him for an
aliyah. So
can he go for the aliyah now aliyah is
laning tora the real thing. It's not
but then again he has a built-in
solution cuz part of the aliyah is
which is one of the
and that's why says
test if they call you before
asyah
after you finish your aliyah you will go
back to your seat and say the first two
because you have three braas to say now
someone asked me what's the problem why
do you have
I'm not saying the words. I'm just
listening to the So two mistakes he
made. First of all, you're supposed to
lane along number one. And number two,
even if you're not laning along some,
but
is also a currency in this regard.
So that's why you be on time obviously
but if you're very late they call you
finish aliyah go back to seat and finish
the f the other the first two what's
more challenging is if they need a and
in you walk before and they're all lane
lane lane now this is in a Monday and
Thursday rush hour to start making the
is waiting is not safe so can you lane
before
now this top doesn't there's
You're laning to you're not laning
and you're laning it. You know once
what's what's the he said done I'll
think you know and you come in late
you're going to lane what be what could
be the so if you could quickly say at
least
before you lane fine but otherwise you
have you have a problem I'll tell you a
delightful shil which sometimes could
happen purim morning people have an over
they hang over the night before he
walked in late very late they're about
to start the migill they already made
the brah they're about to start the lane
He didn't say can he listen to migilling
before.
So you're wondering what's the migill is
part of the part of the is part of the
migillas.
The fact that he's not saying it he's
listening is not a
this should be a problem. He's listening
to to mill from beginning till the end.
And I saw others say this also say a big
and this is based onesh from the early
that the is not so much the of the
pursu that migill does that's why have
and more so the says where's the onill
is the soak we could look at the migill
on purim as two other function we could
re label it as
pursua but not
and that's why the
has ava and he's also make because of
this
is walking in the street and woke up
late that morning and someone comes over
to him I'd like to ask
he's holding
so the the bu says based on ra actually
says it but develops it more is an hour
in se giml that here is you
I what do you mean? Why is that here? So
Mr. B explains listening to someone talk
that's not not even because basically
it's just a a dry question without a
without a meaning. So the Rav is
listening and he's thinking what to say.
Oh that's her we passed and here is mut.
Now the tricky part is when you you have
to give up don't get into it's based on
a raja we say
so once you keep it to that minimal just
word or two so is is considered
the is that the only is when you keep it
short so if this person has to ask you
an say excuse me not now I have to go
but Mr. does point out that light the
there's no to even answer Shil because
you have to think what to say. So the
Muslim hospital is get up on time and if
you're a rub don't leave your house
without
another question I wanted to mention is
someone asked me can he listen to a
recorded sound before in other words he
gets into his car he doesn't as he's
driving can he listen to a recorded
sound
or recording of which is very popular so
even though there's no on that but that
is tora in other words just like we say
when you hear someone saying
It's not because
but it means it's more than her and felt
that on such a recording you should say
did say if a person's in a car he's not
driving you say he could read from a
without verbalizing the word because
that's keeping it only to a hear and
last but not least I'd like to ask a
question if has anything to add please
tell me I've heard more than once people
say if you want to drink a coffee in the
morning before ding okay It's fine. You
must say first. Now I learned the whole
spent a lot of time. I didn't find such
what is that true or not? Is it true
before before drinking something before
dinging? You have to say so I thought
practically speaking it makes sense cuz
let's say you have a hot cup of coffee.
So what are you going to do on those
minutes that you're drinking a coffee?
You're not going to take it out of New
York Times. What are you do? Takes a
safer. So not the drinking, I was still
learning. Then I thought maybe a little
more to it because B eating before
davening is not poss
and chev that means a person can have a
mini ding that is
would tell women that were they have a
big family they could not d regular ding
he'd say you know you should say at
least in the morning at least he said
really is even better but if you really
press for time
in the three you have so much
so in other words is like a mini ding
I'm thinking maybe that's the mini you
feel guilty eating before ding but can
you
some ding. Yes.
And then drink. The other day it
occurred to me that eat before doing any
mitzvah or even we don't eat before
what's the to eat.
Maybe that's why you say, but I don't
think it's true to be honest with you
because when is the
not in the morning necessarily when
you're about to learn. So if you're not
yet learning maybe
I think the main is to get into get in
to have that tug to you
for today's
Michelle for sponsoring today's cover of
his daughter tomorrow night
so
sponsoring
is sponsoring a share call 7188518651
or emaild.com
is still paying the bills for the air
conditioner. Air Commissioner is still
running and still having the nail
campaign
is back near the door
just
You seek him after.
Amen.
Let's just start we mentioned
don't forget to the
has a lot to it not to learn the came
from from learning with
and any form of
even
is all the only possible is if we could
relabel the learning as a mitzvah or as
So basically as we saw from that we say
is you could say becomes
because it's a mitzvah and
we do make a distinction. So the are not
so in favor of this require even but the
is to say that
does not require and you could say and
even
before
however our beginning with
says not to rely on this but let's
remember you're allowed to learn you're
allowed
before
and a person was a middle and realiz
should say right then and there even
though it's not to continue without
if someone is late never to skip
don't be late but is not be skipped it's
needed to allow the dinging to go
properly a person that came to saying
could say even though he didn't say
I try to say at least one first but it's
not
you could you should say but
before we start if it comes to you good
is saying it with would be without
if there's no other choice it's
not the right way to say but there's no
other choice you're allowed to say it
before
morning those that go to
should go say without and go to sleep
because
is more of a because it's more of a it's
a we say we try not to say some don't
only say it a whole day some say in the
afternoon but the ding that we say is
because it's a
is in on a shab one should not say
before because then it's obviously only
does need that's the purpose of it. You
do a mitzvah
without
somewhat of an issue. It's better to say
for that. But it's a before you call to
an aliyah get the aliyah and then say
the other two a person that must lane
has to say no doubt about it or listen
to laning only with mika might be a
dinner pua/
but maybe you could could listen without
the pasil without pill is okay recorded
sound is is should have
and the last question before drinking.
There are reasons but basically it
seemed that the reason the main reason
is to avoid learning without and also to
have a quasi dabing before drinking.
Heat up
here.