There's no Minyan. Now What? Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

foreign [Music] uh there's no minion now what have the great source to sponsor your share call ignore terror at 718-851-8651 they realized there was no minion evidently someone walked out they had to go to the bathroom either was too embarrassed to tell them or didn't realize the kits are shots there's no minion what do you do or what's more common by elena you look around there's no minion and the the asthma is fuming he has to say this yes but there's no minion so we'll see these questions and probably 30 more questions regarding this we're in the middle of a minute of davening with the minion muslims you don't have a minion what are you supposed to do and i can tell you during chakras in a busy morning rush hour is the worst time to be clueless not gonna know what to do so we'll see basically a beautiful your side which is really very much hands-on sugi once we get to your site we could approach the older shyless but one thing i wanted to mention as we once discussed in the past davoning with the minion but simpson but sum sum is fraught with problems it ends up having a lot of problems it's always best to avoid a minion tsum tsum but today sugya there is a minion but some so now there's not even a minion what are you allowed to say what he's supposed to do so push it we wonder what's the shiela the more in mcgill was also based on a possible israel that any devil ship could do that needs a minion you're not going to say it without a minion so what should what why do we have a shahilah how can you say kaddish or kazar shots without a minion i it's an anus what could you do you don't have a minion how could you proceed but the truth is i'll tell you even more so i once had the there was a minion and they said the middle of laini they wanted to give a bacha he's wearing children he's wearing a hat but he's put it on three months for bar mitzvah then they started thinking geval do you have to go and say hello again they said the entire kazar shots without a minion so i found the rivers quoting the stipela and the levin and an earlier source the bergassa bayes members all agree without a doubt that if you said that there wasn't the men you have to repeat it you weren't joined i mean i don't think that people are going to like that idea just going back to those shots but what should i tell you ain davish of geducio so what's the sheila if you started beheaded what should be at any difference and the truth is in babali there's no mention of this shyla but that's why today's source is you shall me do you shall me in peri on the mishnah which is of course also in babli the mr says there are certain things that you need a minion to be able to say it the marshall [Applause] all those things you need a minion that's the mishna in the mcgill comes because of a certain diet comes to the following conclusion avadha you can't start davis without a minion but let's say you started davos of edu and someone walked out in the middle you're allowed to finish that inion we'll soon see what that means be allowed to finish kazarsa shots you can't lane because there's no minion but your ladder that you started with this is what the ishami says of course the xiaomi concludes with a very stern warning this is apostate in yeshaya but hazal darshan if you were in a situation that is a minion and you walk out and therefore you basically ruined dominion so you basically sent the shrine because now there is one thing we see he did a terrible avla but for the remaining nine you're allowed to finish that inion actually the random sector megillah says not only if one left as long as you have roive and the paise can say you don't need a rubric so if even four people walked out and you have six people remaining you're allowed to finish that indian and all of this is in seat base if you started kaddish or kedusha and someone walked out so you're allowed to finish that indian as long as you have roy mr virus has six people but it's a terrible available for the one that leaves that's not minimizing his surveyor but if you have at least six people you're allowed to finish that in you now before we apply this more specifically i want to point out one thing this concept to us is pretty familiar that if not someone's a person now that'll walk out in the middle of laning now that in a certain sense is more homo because as the mr khmer says the pharisees aleph even if there's a minion without you and even if you heard laning already you're not allowed to walk out in the middle of lane it happens often a person needs a safe and shul he's learning space in the basement he goes the zoo walks in the middle of landing takes safe and walks out in order to walk out of the lane even if you heard landing even if there's a menu without you oh bengal agave allowed to walk out but you can't walk out in the middle of landing but that's a different sorrow because the laning is that var hashem and don't be hashem so are you heard laning and i doesn't mean you without you but it's the laws of hashem is fundamentally different here you're breaking a minion and if you're number 10 don't walk out but let's say you're number 11 allah allah walk out you're not being hashem so this in a certain sense this is when you are ruining the minion but really what needs a hezbo is how does this work you know if you need a device if you can do so 10 people so what's the heck of the fact that you started and maybe you could even ask a more interesting question if your ladder finished that indian so why is it always here what would i do wrong you're a lot of finishers that's without me so what's so terrible but that's not a cancer because a lot of fetish hazardous shots but about the rest of davening so you ruined the rest of davening so that question we could deal with la maison you're ruining it for the tibor but how do we understand you're allowed to finish that double ship you could do you said that indian so what the is there's no minion and an army left that's the terrible available hashem but you started bahata so we find that another area is a lot of finish and evidently that's the hezbollah of the noida behuda kama evan as a sim and nunva right in the beginning now god he's talking about a different shiloh he's talking about saying because heiress and assume without a minion and he says even though you need a minion but but the evidence without a minion varia how are you is xiaomi in other words he understood that without if someone walked out there's no longer there's no longer a minion but a minion is not market you're allowed to finish that in you without a minion and look at the b aloha in our sim in simon hey steve bays he has an interesting shiloh let's say you have 10 people and a person did a terrible habla and walked out no doubt about it now you don't have a minion so can the ninth person say well if he left i want to leave he says to be aloha maybe it's not wrong because when the tenth person left the shkina left so what's the ninth person doing anything wrong okay some say that the embassies when you have nine there's a good chance of getting it center but when you have eight you know it's hard to get to center maybe it's an avalanche but what seems to be that once the tenth person walked out the skin is gone it has to be this once you start a beget you'll have to finish with adam in you now i must mention ravos sim and zion with great their heritage he says i don't understand the need to be who them because who said that the left once the shrine is here even if the minion left maybe the shrine remains until the end of the reciprocation and as he wants to say that the heter to continue is because the skinner stays until the end of that dovah do so so the if it's not sure how you're allowed to finish now he does add ask on himself so light me what's that if the screen is still there he says ah that's not swear because to the next javascript i ruined it and i want to add this i found in the earliest source the berkshires test who says this does not leave until you finish that double shepherd kadusa what you started so advice we have two as bay rim and how this halacha works of once you start it now you view the holes there's no minion and no skinner but you gotta finish it and her bosma has a little of an of a little more smack to it this kind of stays until you finish that davosadusha but one thing i want to say this is not a klingokite the kazenish in kuflamazay and hey and you're looking at mr bruins he's caught in your zion in different contexts but both say if you started with a minion and someone walked out you're allowed to continue and it's considered filabotible i for the end of it there's no minion but once you started the hector you're allowed to finish once you're out of finish it has the status of minion even regarding being mighty someone else so here we have the soid and now we understand our original question if you started and you never had a minion you thought it by mitzvah and he's not so then you never had a minion so it's it's worthless you have to start again but if you started the hat then someone walked out we have this extraordinary criticism you're allowed to finish not the entire davening that indian and now we'll apply this lemisa and i'm going to try to go in order so we'll be able to retain it better let's start with a simple shiloh in the middle of kaddish something that happens the end of davening a person in a rush he just walks out and now the awesome is saying there's no minion so as long as you know you started with the minion you're allowed to complete the kaddish and they stayed in surrender base i should mention when people are diving with a minion with tsum tsum it's an acharyas to make sure that the minion succeeds you know let him walk out if someone is in a rush he wants to walk out i advise you to check if there's a minion without you people think that is probably a minion count what's what's a little frightening the makarkai and the chavez your because actually a kobe who says there's a family garrison when there's a small minion even if there's 12 people a muscle but when there's a small minion don't walk out even if there's a menu without you unless you have a good reason to walk out now you're wondering why can number 12 walk out because if 12 walks out 11 walks out and then 10 walks out you know that's the way it is someone told me there was once a city that had punk 10 people and the minion worked perfectly everybody came one day 11th man joined the city the next day no one showed up for davening well i everybody lied another person so you can't rely on anybody else you know am i anna david tell the other being if you have a small minion stay till the end and make sure it works but it again if the mice if someone has a real need to leave he's allowed to leave as long as the minion remaining even though kirkham says it but here's the catch if you're number 10 and you very much have to leave get a replacement find someone but you can't leave that's khalil question what happens often there's a struggling minion and they need a center and they're trying and they no one to be found they just find someone and he says listen i have to leave at eight o'clock shop i have to make a flight i must be on the road eight o'clock and now you know we make you make the calculation you have to leave a military after the muscle so he'll make filipino the other might have to feel a batiba and but he didn't have to leave the middle of the happening the question is can they start davening knowing that they're going to stop the middle now this is a pretty luminous society because the ashanti lafayette says you're allowed to finish but maybe that's only if you started beheaded and someone walked out so you didn't ask questions but who said you like to start when you have to end up relying on the hetero or finishing the oyster indian maybe but then again if lemaiser we just proved there's a hectare to complete it and it's considered fema but siebel and according to avosna it's this going to stays and here's the catch and there's no other choice either this person will join us and we'll have to feel the placebo and we'll stop in the middle or we'll have nothing so i saw in both the makurchayan and the pisgreshuva and simmon kuffman gimmick and awesome and then hey they both have the sheila but the wrath just discusses if you're allowed to start knowing someone's going to leave and he says you know how to do it but it's hard to know what he was talking about but one thing i think is possible if they tried and there's no other choice they're not being makeable there's no other choice it's either have partial thriller but sibo or nothing why not say pot is better than nothing now the person that's going to leave he told you he's going to leave and he's annoyingist we hope that he's not going to be a victim of aussie hashem because he only came until 8 o'clock so he's leaving bahata because that was his precondition now once he's leaving bejeto what are you doing wrong once there's a head to the start there's no easy hashem to continue when he started and i believe that's why the mr burns have caught in your day now it's very ambiguous but he says if la maison he's part of the minion until baruch he's allowed to leave after barakum now it's hard to know what he means but probably he meant such a scenario there's a minion that's missing one someone joined but he says he has to leave at a certain time but i did see was very reassuring he was asked for clarification but in both places he has this very shiloh that there's a minion that won't happen unless someone joins but he didn't have to leave in the middle so our version says and there's a biddy effort would be find a different minion in other words let the nine people especially today there's upstairs and downstairs and concur go so go downstairs and wait for the next minion you have to make a minion that struggles but let's say the question is this or nothing he says since there there's no problem with hashem because he said he has to leave at this time so if he's allowed to leave you could start dominion now but again this is pashit he doesn't mean just put together a minion a makeshift minion you know someone's by person by and you know this the smell of the smorgasbord is tantalizing so he puts together you know what we call a chick check you know let's go hurry hurry but you know just join us for you know and then glue and leave that leave when you have to leave get a better minion you know there are many on them they have that that last you can't just hop laugh a minion and rely on this and why on that if you could find a better minion don't stop in the middle but let's say the choice is this or nothing so if it's this or nothing so the person that leaves is an eyeness is allowed to leave and hopefully the menu is allowed to continue as we said because this is the only choice now la maison the question that that's hard to answer regular but let's say a person is on the way to darwin with his minion that he enjoys when he's dividing up and slow and there's a minion and but he's walking by and there's a base over please join us we need a menu of the empty what should he do should he give up his regular minion and down with the minion but you know is a very important concept so sometimes you have a shoe that every day they need five centers you know what i mean they're always struggling i mean the minion you know basically time to close but every day they struggle and they schlep so i'm not sure you have to every day giving you the avenue for that but here's a base of they have no other choice and they're really trying so again what to do you have to you have to use your muscular see this but i could tell you that making a minion happen is a very great source you'll find something unusual the end of our sim and nun hey the mahabharata says a city that has just 10 people and comes yamana roy man one person wants to down with israel his love he's now i'll leave the city down with his love because you're going to ruin the minion of this city says it is just a minion but tsum tsum and someone doesn't show up you give them a canas you must show up to make a minion now i understand that's different that's because you have an obligation to your community but sometimes it's worth doing a guest to help you eat and make a minion so basically not only you're not allowed to ruin a minion or as you say but if you could complete a minion it's a certainly a great source at what personal cost in rukhbys that you have to judge but it certainly a guest said to help them especially a struggling baseball there's no other choice it's not like they're they're every day doing this obviously they don't want to do this but then you have to realize that is sometimes a very big factor question they were learning before davening and there was a minion and the other would love to say kardashians the special cardistry abundance but somehow right before he said kaddish someone walked out so the oval said well we started learning with dominion can i say kaddish even though there's no minion now however this is wrong for two reasons number one kaddish is not this the second half of learning learning is not the first if kaddish it's too independence so it's not really to say the same indian but here we come to a much more fundamental you say that's going to be negaya to many of our shias the main motherhood in simmon cutting gimbals yes this is very shiro there was a minion for learning and africa is no minion so the fighter will say israel you started with the minion you had to be gleimer so he says the cloud that the khayodam says the exact same cloud and cloud he says remember his skull beheader only works when the thing you started needs a minion la marshall you started duchening and someone walked out or laning you start him and he needs a minion so then it's like you started with a hectare and you had to finish that inion but if you started learning with a minion it's very wonderful but learn doesn't need a minion so now that someone walked out you can't say you started the hetero so the fact you started learning with dominion doesn't affect the cottage and you cannot say kaddish in other words he says you have to start something that needs a minion and he proves this from an exceptional let's say you started chakras still with the minion you don't know how but someone left and now you have no minion shots can you see if that shots with nine people because you started distillerishment with a minion so we'll soon see it's in the first that you can't fret why not you started with a minion so he says even though nephews you could damage my nest without a minion so it's not considered as his behead used by nasra with dominion now we'll soon get back to that but one thing we see that my mother says this with emphasis as the autumn does his skull means you started something that needs a minion so therefore he says you started learning with dominion is very nice but if now there's no minion for the kaddish you're not allowed to say kardashian now the mystibura very briefly in sydney has this shayla says if you started min learning with a minion you cannot say kaddish was no meaning he doesn't say what reason is but the mice mr brewer we will soon see hold of the motherhood so la maisa in this case if there's no meaning for kaddish the oval cannot say kardashian question you now you'll see how muhammad everything flows you start up such a december with dominion there was a minion he said kaddish before zimmer it comes to kardashian there's no minion now to truth is today these problems are more common because there are minion and concurrently on them upstairs and downstairs some people go to catch they they literally they'll go to the next million they wanted them slowly some people leave to catch the express minion that's ahead of them you know how it is people but everybody's moving so you could start with a minion and you end up there's no minion because you're holding by you starbuck and there's no minion can you say at least says well if you started such december with a minion you want to say kaddish that's the end of sukhoda zimmer however this is where for two good reasons first of all who told you that kaddish is the end of sukhothi zimmer the premier goddamn and the mr says cotton alex has a clown when you say kaddish descabel on schweinster soon see except for slithers is said to separate two and yanum an example is the kaddish earth of sukhothi zimmer so maybe we will identify the kaddish after because of zimmer as the break in between the zimmer and bergas krishna but it's not the completion of sukhothi zimbra but the truth is there's a more fundamental problem such a december does not need a minion what does it help you start absolutely with a minion but it's not and that's why the mr burundi zion based on the mordechai says if you start upset with him with a minion and now there's no minion you cannot say kaddish before berku and the ms we have two reasons for this now how about you started saying carlos and someone walked out because they finished kai that's fine that's that's how i look that's one in you next question pretty tricky you said you said kaddish without with a minion like he's supposed to before you said baruch or during the kaddish someone walked out can you at least say the baruch does the kaddish justify the boroku so here there are deus i saw the tila david said him say well once you started kaddish with a minion you're allowed to say [Applause] but it's hardly convincing because our bodies say what is the baruch of birkas it's the beginning of that kaddish is the either the end of such december or more likely they break but it's two different currencies and that's why the siddhiyavits with a minion and then the person walked out you can't say barakum boroku is the beginning of krishna now the truth is i would like to mention allah to mention because it happens unfortunately a person comes late of such december but he's okay because he he made baruch quote unquote you know people gauge being on time or late to baruch so what does he do he answers baruch and then he catches up sukkah december that's one of the floyd sabari you could pack in two zimmerman and break his krishna and catch up to the batiba but anyhow so he enters baroque and then he continues lucas is almost israel and the chubas and august both say that's not so polished because if you answered the says baruch 35 times during chakras throughout the whole day so why can i say baruch you could but if you're saying like the shamish it's just a regular aniya that means it's not a boroku that's the beginning of birkas krishna so that means you said but you said because chris without barack that's like saying barack obama even though you miss baruch it doesn't help you you reduce your borrow but you're going to have to have in mind that the borough is not the beginning of birkas krishna it's an animal a very reduced effective burku so that's why it's always better to be on time and dive and straight and be holding after you stab then you could answer baruch and continue berka's krishna now i should mention mr burroughs says and see if gimbal says that let's say you started with a minion and then someone walked out and let's say you're mean against you never say kadusha de yoitsa kadesh unless you have a minion and that was dominion what do you do he said we're lucky no problem because since you said barku with a minion so you started chris with him and you had to finish that that inion question you had a minion for the still swain estra and now la mesa i'm sorry i used to have a minion for the beerus christmas and now someone walked out so what do you do what could you do nothing you could do look when your mice you started trying estra without a minion so you're allowed to fish my nester but that's that's basically you starting without a minion the next question is an important question and that is let's say you started schminastra with a minion so far so good someone walked out after he finished my nestor now you look around and you wonder where do we go from here we are holding out as only nine people so that the mystery bureau says and we said this earlier the fact that you started distinguished vanessa with dominion is wonderful but that does not justify saying shots you have no money it's a different indian like the my mother had shot is because it still does not need a minion so basically believe it or not you're not going to be able to say hazardous shots try to find someone else that's a great idea but you can't take lesser shots okay so what do you what do you do so you move on so nicholas you could say no there's no minion you'll give on me this if you dive into you can't say you need a minion let's say on monday and thursday that you're allowed to say it's all dominion now let's be a little aggressive you had no minion shots and you didn't have those shots can i say kaddish to scarbel when i get there you're wondering what kind of mice it is you're not saying there's a shots kind of just cobble you want to say but then again as we learned earlier the caddis discover goes back on schweinster which we had with the minion we started the story with a minion maybe i'm allowed to say caddis discover i'm gonna say wait a minute who said maybe if you have stilles then you could say this cable but that's not convincing because one third of the day we say kaddish descabel on only establishment so maybe the fact that mario we say this kabul after stellar schweinster allows the sadie's goddess discover discover solaisa and if you said that berkshire vegas says and i quote even though there's no there's a chats but the kaddish shalem is for and that you had a minion so you'll you don't say well soon so you don't make laning but this guy ball you're allowed to say and i want to add an earlier source to lavish and steve gimmel says that if la maisa you also if you started the hatta you're allowed to say kaddish this capo however here we come to a fascinating point and listen to this deny to be who the son nobody refers as the knight but it's his son actually in tanyana there was a minion for mahev and the establishment with a minion so far so good someone walked out before kaddish discovered which happens quite often people are you know pretty transit they just walked out so now you're holding by kaddish to scabble and there's no minion so he became a big macholicus one of the poison said you can't say kaddish now ah you started shmanessa with a minion so listen to the music that is but try nasa doesn't need a minion so if he doesn't need a minion it's not an so you can't hit this cable but the other time mahakam says but every schweinster gets a discover why is my reverse says the neighborhood that based on the beautiful deak of the ramo ayansham that the second time is right if you started my nests are still with a minion your ladder said this kabul why because every shemaine astra gets to scabble but then here's the kiddish pillar of the night who the son but regarding chakras and mindra if you don't say hazard if the fellow left during this reign of stella you cannot say to scabble why manishtana suspect now some i mean some i mean the tale of doverness he'd caught in gimel and and so young fish and the two was gimmel and tess sama gimmel strongly reject this and says me guiller who told you if by matter of you we see that kaddish that that established my nestor justifies this god built because you need the scalpel solution so when you get this phenomenal is that needs both a good timer but at the end of the day i must tell you that the bill that the mr bird to be a locker passkins like the knights behuda and i think i mentioned the pastor in the igerus and says that the circum that we have of the mahabharat morgan avram and mr alike meet peace and hajjun nothing less they say get someone to say with you and this is safe and not to do that so what should i do what do you mean you have to follow the mr bureau i got to follow myself you have to tell mr burham i claim the guide to mr moore's up sack so even though these police can reject the night to be huda but mr mirapaska is like that it's a pretty good sack and we'll soon see that the mecca behold you never say kaddish if there's no minion so that we could add to the mission so the neighborhood that says by maya if you say kharis descabil if you didn't say if you didn't say shots yeah but the truth is usually the person leaves during khazar sashats and now we start it becomes really like them so to speak because in malachi there's no minion and again you can't recruit someone do you say kadusa inert troll do you say this yes kapayim where do you go from here so the only simple question to deal with is if he walked in even he just said a few words you complete the entire hazard that's the usher only that's all you say indian the next question is is not as simple as it as we'd like it to be okay you say can i all say kedusha don't forget israel so i'll tell you not to approach it other album because you just said that kadusa is a mitzvah of kadusa maybe it's a separate indian so maybe you'll have to finish kadarsha but who told you allah say kadusha i'll say but but it's part of khloe shots you don't skip anything so we'll soon say it's not true at all because if inherit israel someone walked out during khazar sashats and there's no minion all agreed no no you don't is no different so that's the good aura and the rajba in aleph sadiq struggles with this and he basically says that kedusha he doesn't contrast this kapayam of course but he says kadusa is part of hazard sashats he doesn't really say much of a hezbol but he says it's considered part of the [Applause] even though there's no minion and the mahabhai and non-hazif gimbal says this perfarish so in other words we'll we'll say if someone walked through there's a shot you're allowed to finish this shots and if you walked out before kedusha you're allowed to even say kadusa the next question is kapayim so the maiser the prima godin mr versus cotton and the malama days all say if he walked out let's say in hutzler it's real every day and there's no minion you're not allowed and now the question is why is kapayam different than kedusha so the premier got and ashley ramsey of cotton gimmel says the following this is it's a milsa it's a different mitzvah then he throws in by the way another sorrow because is [Applause] like it doesn't swim in the husband but his main point seems to be that this is a separate mitzvah now here we could understand that because the mice and the series capacity even though you can't do without its feeling but it's not part of davening it's it's a mitzvah of kaiser now we have to wonder so why could do sir you could say so la maison the premier guard them a little later someone he writes i saw that says that if you can't say in the series when someone left how can you say the kaddish afterwards so he writes with great animus any other day i don't know i don't hear the kasha kadesh is now i understand a little better if you're going to tell me that this is that that goes after kaddish it certainly includes kadusa the series capanium is a separate mitzvah in shots that's the mil sarita but at the end of the day it's clear the following is going to be interesting i have to tell it's all choppy someone walked out during magnaframe right you know he's reasonable he walked that right away you're allowed to say kadusa you don't finish here's kapayum and we'll soon see you do say kaddish a of capitalism now the premier got them and mr brewer quotes it you don't say this yes capacion but your ladder sailor cane of calvary thus yeah because that doesn't need you know the shaft minion magnus is the next question is again a little more challenging because it's something that we have to consider it happens unfortunately that there is a minion with something and you look around someone's talking oh he's not answering sometimes the people you have two people walk out imagine that they don't talk in chill they walk out they leave with eight people what do you do or someone's a person sleeping he fell asleep so this is a big suggy which is not phenomenal but the machabin hey si bob says if someone is sleeping there are khazar you're allowed to continue because you have 10 people zak tatas you can't count someone that's asleep someone's asleep is like a mace and you certainly can't count someone that's that's talking as someone a god loving him to count someone who's sleeping or someone who's talking even if he's in shul you can't continue very sharp lushen he says khalil it's tara from anasha my man is talking you can't count them to dominion now let me ask you a very simple question if this person instead of talking directly shots walks out and goes to play basketball give me a ladder count right he's not fair but if he's in shul talking or sleeping you can't count him must have shot parrots is getting very positive if he walked out and you can't chase after him fa fallen you're an inus what can you do you're allowed to continue but if he's talking so pardon me [Applause] you could stop him from talking or you could wake him up now you don't wake up a year on a regular basis but if he fell asleep he's part of our minion he's out ahri is to make sure the minion continues he's doing another so the point is of course if someone's talking and he walked out call him back don't go on that's ridiculous it's mama's crying but it's but if you could get him back to the minion get him back if he walked out and he he's not accessible not available then you continue without a minion okay so lamaisa you count someone if he's there you wake him up if someone walked out and you only have nine you're allowed to complete hazard as we said you're allowed to say nafio sapayam you don't say you give me this now i'll ask you a very challenging question you're allowed to say as we said this you're allowed to say the end of khadarsa shouts is it so positive you're allowed to say kaddish to kabul so we mentioned yes but it's not the holidays because the basis joseph and our sim and quoting the rambam impair our door with the rambam says that you're allowed to finish because there's a shots but you're never allowed to say kadushi after davening now he doesn't say much of the hezbollah but with the basic explains kaddish is not an integral part of schweinster the bihar dash says see if cotton gimbal if you're not saying then you can't say kaddish so this is the unique sheet of the rambam that you never say even to scarborough not by chakras otherwise however what i told you earlier was correct fashion azim because this is based on the trimmer sadesh and simon tezvov the the desolate asked our question he walked out of military shots what am i allowed to say from suggestion takes it step by step you're allowed to finish hazard shots you can't lane because laning is a different mitzvah but you could say to scarbelle after volation and even if you hold uvolitsian needs a minion because of kadesh and baruch you have the imaginary minion because you started so could you shavold seeing this cable you're okay not laning in fact it's matsuya shabbas if someone walked out during the distillation astra yolada say you evolved sian and kaddish discovered as they stayed in the usami in india the true tradition is what the basis of minik ashkenaz that piscabel is an absolute part of shmainesra an extension of khazar sashats now how do we passkin it's a rambam versus the truman sudeshian so the mahabhara and seat gimbal just says if someone walks in a lot of say kadusa says that my dalid he does not mention kaddish he goes with the mahabharata that you cannot say any kaddish spells out you're allowed to say kaddish and prima goddamn and mr bruce says this applies on shabbos as well and kaddish so drama is saying the following during is a separate mitzvah there is no shocks of the shots but this cable the end of volatilion is an extension of khadarsashats now this is basically why the price can say that tisca bell belongs to schweinster in fact there's an old haura sometimes you you want you have to avail me the ahmed and only one ahmed so no problem you'll dive into washington seeing and you and he'll take over by a valid scene as you've all seen some wonder how can you do that who said the class of shots hey how could b get up and say iso and sometimes have a cape but the truth is you're looking around and you're there shin i involved dalit rama justifies this very minute he says if a person can't doubt in the whole darwining at least take over ashley valdez the answer is very very true i'm part of the shots i didn't say it i listened who said this calculation going on me saying with my mouth maybe it means that c burst and that's why the mini gistral is that you divide the davening and the second state sibba could say this cable solution now it's only when you get someone to say halloween you just have to restrain this and then you say you say how do you have a nice voice and who says to scarbel the first one that's positive because you could go back to the first one and they're going back to the first one but here you're not going back to the first one the second one could say this couple but getting back to this very tricky question he walked out during khadas hashtag you're allowed to say says see and this is very brief and see zion what is the what does that mean you're allowed to say clerson and then why let's reduce our problems the cousin get ready for this say to scarbel write it after his shots and then say asheville let's see what do you lose don't say another extra card that's what you want to say a very memorable day you can have in shu you skip this kappa you say because but i must mention that the teres khayyim and see if cotton dalit and bama's creeper aegis seems to say this you say khatsi kadesh ashi of all that created on the page and then this gobble and i guess the hezbollah's polish it because la maison that's to say that of the davening your ladder say kaddish to break it and then ash evolved seeing so the mice it's not the holidays but it's at least we have a vehicle you're allowed to say skip laning and then to me laissez ricci le have mr bureau and you've gotten your test he says you're allowed to say to scabel and koscien now why is it kosuke he quoted vega that that's true vegas is both but why is khatikar as a call scheme i would think this cable to license is the close game that's what he wants to say la maison we could say you allowed to say goddess then well and on a monday or thursday if someone walked out and before laning first of all he's in deep trouble that's a double aussie hashem he ruined dominion and he ruined laning but la mesa you're not allowed to lane if you started laning avadilata finish all three brachis like regular the ramon quotes this trim of suggestion if you walked out during laning you're not before laning you're not allowed to start laning laning is a minion indian achrina in gansen a person left after laning prosthetics accept the king of god and you're allowed to say to scarborough the fact that he was there you know longer than during his shots doesn't make it any worse than scarborough but then the other is in trouble because eleno kaddish you can say in fact mr brewer in sith cotton hey s says if he walked out after eleno but there's no minion for kaddish yasser he can't take out this yeah i there was a menu for is referring to that you don't need a minion for eleno so it's not an plus mr brewer says the other card is a minute now this is why when someone is in a rush don't die with a minion but something because if he walks out before this yesterday it's a double avalanche is bad enough trust me but the awesome is left without a kaddish you know it's a very upsetting situation he can't start kaddish even unless there was a minion bishop now if someone is in a terrible rush either don't die for the minion tsum tsum or at least get a replacement you don't have to have someone that dabbled with dominion call someone in to say to answer kaddish and then he could leave a very fascinating question if narrative swirl they say after davening after the last country someone ran out and there's no meaning for barakul no that's paul there's no shaykhs he can't say barakul because there's no menu for that is very similar to chakras you walked out by the shtirish manasera like the night vihud like you cannot say to scarbel might other place came you could if you walked out during the mainstream then you're allowed to finish foreign fascinating shiloh if you dive in some yeshivas they say well it happened once that appeared that they did the kadusa you turn around for kaddish kabul is no minion is it considered that he started so the truth is the godusa is really not a hazard it's three brokers so it's very hard to identify what this is but it's probable that it's a good user some call it but it's not a hazardous shots and he says but it's not worse than my roof crime is very quick but it's so much granus to that because is not worse than myer there is no shots so what do we say all agree it goes after you did what you did you did all you're supposed to do so even if it's not a hazardous shots if a person left after baruch the poison allowed to say khatsi kaddish and then face my nasty without a minion now this bothered me you're allowed to say this why because you started with a minion but i thought you said that that you have to have it it's only considered a start if you need dominion for that thing if you start up such a december you cannot say kadesh so why started christmas so i found that my mother had himself a varnish that and then she's caught in gimel he says but since you need dominion that began it's like because krishna needs a minion so you started with a heter and you gotta say kaddish also agrees a question that i always wondered about if someone walked out before me ain't sheva on friday night so this is really tricky because i would have thought my ain sheva is like a small hadron chart so you can't start that and go right to this cable i saw the one of the high ticket points in the easter easter he says i am receiving and i wasn't sure what he meant but with it looked like that by my rib if you started with a minion you're allowed to finish till the end mature shabbos you'll have to say evolution and encourage this cable so apparently he understood that sheva is not worse than uva latin amateur shabbos but truth is maybe it is worse because my aim shiva may might be like a hazardous shots it's like you're walking before there's a shot so that's in a little bit on laning on shabbos no one should ever walk out but if someone walked out again it's a double aussie hashem you're allowed to complete the laning with the bronchus and even say baruch because the borough is part of laning but here there's a few clauses you don't make a master because just seven alias and if it's a special after a week you will you'll make that the seventh aliyah don't make more than shiva korean but the biggest is you will not lay in haftar with brachas because the usami said the list of drums is laning and after that's a separate mitzvah so what you can do is you're going to lane as if there's a minion taken mr brewer says you say kaddish because it's part of laning but after you're laying without barakas without earlier but you're laying it without the bronchus sleekers and a minion you had a minion and someone walked out so this is tricky because needs a minion but once you started you allowed to say to scarbel even though there's no minion because sleekness why do you see this kabul after sleepless because sleep is like like a minish my nestra you start with ashtray then you have your gimbal medius and then you have tachnom so you started tremendously let's take this cable but if let's say the person walked out before you given me this word said then you cannot say you're giving me this that's like that's like the series during hazard shots an important question which is kadai to mention you had a minion shots you look around and someone walked out he went to the bathroom he had to go he didn't ask questions what do you do is he wondering what's the sign that we learned through xiaomi we learned you're allowed to finish but here we might suggest if he left and not coming back so you have to continue no choice but he's coming back he went to the bathroom maybe wait a few minutes till he comes back the answer is that's wrong for two reasons number one and number two craig adam everybody's waiting you know when he comes back he's not going to get a hero's welcome guarantee you so you're just highlighting his omission i didn't find this in any of the place game i guess it's obvious that if you ever have to do it now he walked out hopefully he was a ionist and it's not always but there's no issue on the seaboard to continue i just found this in the video based on in eretz israel you have a unique shiloh because let's see you have a minion but something for chakras and it comes duckening the coin walks out and the lady walks out so you reduce to a so moisture suggests is quoted rivers of bay seminole dalit that the best thing would be when you have a minion with tsum tsum before you zakhadarsa let the lady wash the cayenne's hand but if you didn't do that so it's the same like you learned till now you're allowed to continue and you'll rely on the fact that you assume it's awesome but i went to the end i think this is ms lamite a cointra vozna both cases you didn't do anything wrong let me explain he walked out or the claim walked out you only have nine now let's analyze this a coin was in the description is there until the end of the shots so nothing happened problematic yet and he came back during khadar's shots so the shriner was not affected and basically he said beheta so he wasn't even he didn't do anything wrong by leaving because according to the way that he understood when you walk out the skinner leaves oh that's terrible you came back you brought it back to srinagar but he did an avla but the way we understand this then barbara's understood that this finna never left so he didn't do anything to fair so basically he was mistaken what he did the mr brewer and see if caught in your test sim and if you have a minion on a tightness and someone walked out during the shots you're now going to say it especially because that's considered a different indian it's like this is capable and let me tell you too quick here is beautiful artist someone that hasn't made a mistake and has to start against the chats i guess someone was infuriated again and he just walked out can you start or continue how you look at it he started but it was an aborted attempt so i saw the pisces super insulin nun hey gimmel says you let us thought is it like starting or you like continuing what he said wasn't wasn't good and i was thinking maybe this is telling the old shiloh when someone made a mistake is it like a shots that it wasn't yo or it's like he didn't say it but la mais so the isha israel says it's considered enough of a start but something really beautiful listen to this and someone dotted out and they say what do we do now the question is here he might have a different alternative he might say landen and then just cut his losses but the answer that's wrong is not a viable option unless there's no other choice you can't take a break and turn it into tillam here it doesn't make sense did you start yes so why not finish why are you being firmer than you xiaomi i think it's possible [Music] foreign [Music] hey [Music]