The Mezuzah In Hilchos Shabbos - Rabbi Zev Smith

huh [Applause] like to welcome everyone 851 8651 or email ist this week i yoshinet.com the new shot and the uh word emma harvey it was a i started with a simple shield a few weeks ago and it developed into literally an entire ship here's the mice someone asked me arab shabbos he he has a warehouse out of state again two to two hour drive from here and the kitschy has these um security cameras and occasionally he checks what's doing by in his warehouse and it was like friday afternoon he saw that they the workers were moving uh boxes and they by mistake they with the box they hit the mezuzah knocked them zuzu off onto the floor and he's watching it mama she's live or whatever it just happened that much so it was just mama's life and it and of course you know when they did that one said some nice curse words oh no another said no problem let's put it back no oh no so here it was his mezuzah in his warehouse that was knocked on the floor and put on by a guy is now the mezuzah puzzle a guy put up a mezuzah does he have to go back today and reattach it can you wait left the shabbos is it kosher as it is and then you think that this is kamen shaila and it will soon see it's negay when they have a painter or a worker that takes off and and puts back the mezuzah and yet it's not on if a guy that was attached to there is a custard act then we had a similar shahila maybe a little slightly different but it that was the end of marma atwa bay where on shabbos and mezuzah fell off either fell off the tape dried or in this case the children were playing they threw a ball the ball hit the mezuzah the kid said the muzzus on the floor so the shialu was first of all can they pick up a mezuzah is it is there a special hat because of brazilian if let's say the case is still on can they slip the mezuzah in on shabbos without actually knocking a nail slipping a mezuzan to the case and if you can't do that can have a guy or a child put back to mezuzah the messages of jamaica broca so bikitsa it's mr mahatma say haribe literally the question of a guy putting up a mezuzah can a cotton put up with is there a problem of buying on shabbos another interesting question was this room did not have a message at that point the question is is there an issue to use the room or you know if you don't have a mitzvah you don't have a mitzvah is there an issa on a room to be used if there's no mezuzah attached to that door so i'll just be moisturizing before we start that we're talking about shabbos but the entire shear is negative as well because the sugar of today muktsa orbino or the like so we actually have 12 more days that this year is relevant so let's go in order we'll start with this the most important question to start and that is is there an issue to live in the room without a mezuzah in other words if you hold there's no issa so continue living put it up when you're at you know at your at your convenience or maybe there's an issa to live in a room with atomizer so one thing is clear all agreed put it up asap as soon as possible because forget about if there's an iss or not but this is clear in the poi skim that every moment the music is on the door you became a mitzvah in other words unlike their hanukkah that atlanta is one my submits and then it's over i mean it's burning but that's the one mitzvah mezuzah every moment on the doorpost there's a definite different mitzvah it's not a mitzvah of fiesta and then it's all over it's the existence of the mezuzah so why should you not capitalize and put it up as soon as possible so that's all agreed says forget about if there's an israelite put up the mezuzah as soon as you can to be every moment and this enough reason to never delay putting up a mezuzah their hashochan enraged and i quote if a person realizes he has no mezuzah on his door don't delay even a moment yeah that is rule number one don't delay putting up or having a mezuzah on your doorpost people sometimes given the mezuzah to check which is a key of twice in seven years so it's kadai not to just bring it to the cipher and he'll call you when he finishes it might be a very busy day they can't do it that day call them in advance say i would like to have same-day service can you do it today i'll pick it up today if not i'll wait till tomorrow but don't miss the mitzvah of mezuzah that's so precious so rule number one is don't delay in putting up the mezuzah but the question is is there an issa to be in a room without a mezuzah like in that case the mezuzah was knocked off the study so they maybe they shouldn't go into the study the whole shop is the case of the warehouse yeah he's not going there but his stuff are being uh kept in that warehouse so the truth is that this question believe it or not as fundamental as it is it's not me foreign so let's think about other mitzvahs i'll give you an example amits are very much related to the house but no one had a hot minute to say that if someone khalid didn't like their hanukkah one night he can't live in the house what does chanukah do with the house right there's a mitzvah in his house so why should i think if you don't have a message you can't use the house you have atlanta but why is there an issa on the house i'll give you a better analogy there's a mitzvah i said actually says a mistake to make a makkah protect the fence on your roof and it's also alive to have a roof without a maca so it is alive and i say but says in my sim in your tests and i sort of yes micah quotes it and adds a riot to that from a yada rama that if a person has a roof and he didn't put up a marker even but there's no issue to go on that roof the roof is not tray for the atamaka i mean you have to be careful it's dangerous but there's no issue to go on a roof without a marker there's a bit la saying but there's no issa so if there's noise to go on a dangerous roof why should it be unison to use the room with atomizer but then again we know certain mitzvahs besides the mitzvah is an issue at least we we seem to think that if i have dalit khan voice and i've note since this it doesn't issue to wear that or better yet there's a mix of their eyes to the table of kaylee but if i don't table the caylee there's an ister button to use the kayleigh chili towel maybe the same is true regarding a room without a mezuzah how about eating out of the sukkah there's a mitzvah to eat is there an issue to eat out of the sukkah or just bit lasse so that's a big discussion in the poiskon but the point is we see there are different types of mitzvahs by some there's a mitzvah that doesn't make an issue to us kayla makes an issue so let's see if we can find richey and to discuss this cemetery discusses citizens and he says that we might find surprising there's no issa per se to wear dollar complex without citizens and he i quote the terror doesn't say like silva is but the terrorist says on teleconference put on citizens but there's no issue per se of wearing dial conference without titties and then he says various the person that has a study with adam azuza is mitzvah a terrible thing he's losing him it's a terrible thing but there's no issa the room is not traif just like the al-khan face is not traith and there's a second reason that says the same analogy also talking about valid can voice a beggar the four corners he says but citrus is like makka and bazooza that we don't find that there's an issa to go in that room and then we're gonna have ram in your gimbals and simultaneously twice seems to say just that that a mezuzah that's not put up on a room so it's a bit la say a terrible thing but there's no issue to use that room but what's noteworthy we do seem to feel that there's an issue to put on campus without citizens because me there are born on there is definitely an issue and that all the police can say if you remember the aloha if someone really sits with apostle on shabbos and he's british around him he's allowed to wear them until he gets home because they're quite happiest i if there's an issue with their eyes so you have to take off sits even in the street so the poison states only this if there are born until we're dialed conference without census and since on shabbos you can't we make senses you'll have to wear it so the obvious implication is during the week there's an israel bottom to wear down complex without citrus but who said that applies to mezuzah in fact the the civ in a magdalen he has an interesting vehicle when the terrorist has put up a mezuzah on the house in other words the house is okay there's a mitsubishi but regarding this is ashitaka boy you didn't put it on yet put on put on citrus right away because there's an issa of at least media born on to wear dial companies without senses so we definitely see a person on the car that even that there is no islam to be in a room with adam azuza however the premier garden in simon lambert crest h lebron tesla based on inshallah me he says there's an issa to go into a room without a mezuzah unless you have no other choice le marshall people lived in one room homes and there's a fellow off so where's he going to go become homeless so the the primage lotion is if you have no other deera you allowed to stay in the house so the pisgah chuva in in year a day a beginning of civil rights pay and other policy that if you have a different room don't use the room with adam azusa is classic says also if you have a different home to relocate don't use the home that has no mezuzah but it makes interesting hillary which i saw that also says that the issue to go this issa of going into a room with adam bezos is only on the bala bus you didn't put up the system don't use the room an outsider could go into the room with adam azusa obviously he's not it was even me when i rent an apartment the chutzlarets we started in the first 30 days i bought them from amazon after you have to live there so how could a visitor be worse than than the owner the first 30 days apart from azusa to go into a room it's only in the baller boss because your glove in eretz he entertains a thought that even an outsider can't go into a room without a mezuzah now he doesn't speak this habit i think it's possible i how could that be if if the person living there the soy is part of 30 days so how could a visitor for two hours be worse there is push it because if there's a bala boss that has a mezuzah he bought the house or it's renting beyond 30 days so since there's a creep on the bias no one could use that bias maybe but first 30 days is nothing so we do see even a havamina that even an outsider can't use the room but definitely the prima goddamn seems to feel that the bala boss of a house that has no mezuzah should not use the house if there's a different alternative the sicilian helicopter gimbal gives clarity clarity and he says that it's not a real issa de ra bona mamish because the cream of god says if you have no house you like to live there what kind of what kind of is is that territories it's a precaution don't delay don't use the house if you have a different alternative so i think we could say with regarding our first question is there an issa mamish to live in a house without a mezuzah it doesn't seem so some place to be fairish there's no issa even the premier goddard makes it conditional if you have no other place to go you could stay there and the truth is the fact that an outsider could use the room without a mezuzah is an indication that it's not a tray for room otherwise why difference between bala bus and visitor so the fact that the bala bus could use the room if he has no other choice and an outsider could use the room is not is there enough of a riot that it's not an issa darbanan to use the room now of course as we said as soon as possible put up the mezuzah but if someone has a room that has no mezuzah he would be allowed to use that room that leads us to the next question now that we see that asap put up the misuse as soon as possible let's go to our shabbos dilemma the mezuzah fell off was knocked off bukit said there's a room with adam azuza you don't want to live with adam azuza i want them it's a museum is it an option to call a guy to reattach the mezuzah now of course if the guy takes nails and acts in a case let's assume the grave will do only in this rapport we'll soon see the details but the guy is doing it mocca is maybe will say or maybe we'll say what kind of myths is that a guy should put up a mezuzah mitzvah he's not he'd puts on villain for you why wisenses are better the question is is there any value if a guy puts up a mezuzah like that story in the warehouse the guy knocked it down and put it up or the most famous story about this painter gracious paint he took off the mezuzah and he told the boss don't worry rabbi i have experience i'm a painter for jews many years i took off the musician i put it back i didn't have to read the directions i just threw out that whole directions and they put up the case he didn't read directions because he didn't look inside that was the mezuzah but you know that's what they're going to do but let's say he did it right he read the direction the instruction then he put it back but when i say are you it's because this question is also fundamental and it's not the person but you have a pretty good start let's think of other mitzvahs where the question is can a great do it or not is found in a gemara so it comes to mind probably first is the gemaran shabbos gimmel a guy the lights near hanukkah the guy's participation is meaningless regarding a guy that wrote stamps for territorial that's a rage pay aleph it's a gemara that if you can't you have no mitzvah putting on film you can't write him so agree that i wrote it even if it's a beautiful sab you put it in shame but there are some myths that a guy could do and i'll tell you my sister someone told me he was what he was recently got recently he was in a one of these outdoor mikviz that one the big supermarkets have and there were a bunch of guy him lined up and they were traveling kale and one after the other and he was infuriated go ahead and totally kill him so yes then who you work for so he told him a big company a big food company and he was incensed we trust the heckster they have graham tufflin caleb what's going on here so yes do you see what's going on he goes i'm watching don't worry they're okay he goes oh really he can't be how how could you use this food so i would say loya moritz steve that if a guy told the kaylee it helps the only problem is he's not nem on that he did it right because you know why she do all of them he does part of him makes his cocoon like you know he looks for excuses he doesn't do entirely in but if god's lying without gaba forget his watching then it's kosher the only issue is you lose the broker so i'm sure that year that he was the godline he made the bracha and he titled some of them but you know before we quit to criticize we have to learn but we see that mitara did the only problem is burkha but that field is perfectly valid and i'll give you another example where guys mitzvah my submits for works unfortunately this is kadaira mentioned because it comes up more than it should sometimes an issue is delayed on air of shabbos and piquetsa it's aftershia and she didn't like their shabbos which is for the woman is you know not just intimidating it's devastating because you didn't like there's classification there's a canas terrible so the aloha is you allowed to call a guy if it's still being ash monsters to light daenerys instead of the woman i how does a guy like their sharpest fried but that's a schwa this is i'm sorry lighting is a terrain but since it's been ash how could a guy lighten their shabbos for a woman and the cash is bigger like there is one shita that the issue can make a bracha on the grease how could that be so territory is that the midsole i'd like is near shabbos is to have mayor that gives kavichabis or enik shabbos and sheldon baez who cares who did it now we passed you don't make it that's the way they post compassion but no doubt about it that the guy is allowed to write and the ish is i the brother of the heart dictionary is why he's different than hanukkah that's a different schmooze but if it's still bananas the guy could do alakaz because there are some mitzvahs that it's not the mice alone it's the result and if you have the nearest shabbos you have the shonen valleys covered shabbos on any shabbos you're okay if a guy did mila so you're looking [Music] great day builds a sukkah we know if he did okay that's not a riot because that's not a mitsu that's a that's a hack but there are some mixes that a guy has very much tied us to the mitsuba so we're not most of us don't have the ability to build a marker you call it a worker so rather call the initial worker for two reasons giving it business and let him do a maca caller but if a guy does a maca says it's so it's so much of a good markup that the guy could build the maca and he can make a break on that now most players can question that if he doesn't do anything how do you make a brah but no doubt about it a guy that makes a marker for the yid is a mice because that's the same point that if the mitzvah is the outcome the result so then who cares who did it so we have maca for sure we have nero shabbos we have three last calendar that a croatia action counts but then again we have chanukah doesn't count meal doesn't count me so the big question for me to you is what's talaka regarding mezuzah the question about that worker that in the warehouse or the painter that took it off i know people had this question from time to time and ray zappell i'm not sure why but this question also is not mafoorish we mentioned that probably more than half a dozen gamoras that speak about other mitzvos not a word about mezuzah so we might suggest that the ick of the mezuzah is the smearer so if the guy puts up the smoke alarm so it's a good it's a good protection the guy puts up the mezuzah why isn't it good the helicopter is on my wall but that's a very poor analogy because the mezuzah works because it's a maester mitzvah if it's laying in your drawer the missouri doesn't work if the glacier conveyors doesn't count so it's not on your wall i mean it's there but it's not it's not functional it wasn't activated in svara it makes sense that you need a mice at first was that just like doesn't work because you need a mice locker when it comes to mezuzah the brach is the volume azusa you need them isoqueeus a guy's aqueous doesn't count so therefore passion should not help have to take it off and put it back again with a by a israel the second time is up the hike there's you can't just write tillen unless you have a mitzvah of villain agrees on mr mezuzah how could he put up mezuzah and what's noteworthy he says but i don't know i don't know i didn't discover america i didn't think why isn't anybody talking about this and this is also the opinion of other parties giving them or more of a whole is that he quotes that he says khalilah loima that by makkah you make a broke on it you know he argues vehemently with the mahna frame he writes many are lawyers if a guy does a makkah you can make a prachant and therefore he says if a guy put up a mezuzah that's not a myself and he has a very interesting writer anybody ever had a question in their family of a pigeon i've been that the 31st day when the pigeon's supposed to be falls on chavez so you can't do it on shabbos you do postpone it the question is sunday the question is why don't you have a guy who make the pigeon if it helps ibeacon there is if you don't have the mitzvah you can't do it and this is the opinion of the description the pachacho love and they do their koi dish that's all on rage pay test the teal of the david has thin trailer the second volume right there sim and kuf test he says you have to have the small you have to have a mitzvah and a guy has no strikers to any of this a guy that put up a mezuzah you're not yourself but and here's the big butt why isn't this a gemara in chichen ark we find regarding and then you have a marshal now this is an atypical chuva maharashtra mashal there's a grain oil with very bright gazunte plates who pass skinned everything with shasta and poison he doesn't have a whole truth about this is simmering zion at the end of a chuva but something else animus topic if a girl is a is it is it good he then he first thinks maybe it's like tits is pastel but it says not true because this guy that makes the sukket the sukkah mk mashma the mezuzah should cover no no gamoras no because there are no commanders but he says if it's not found any place in shas that it's possible it must be kosher the terror of the small that's the banished kai say to us is also makel and again it's not a tremendous quidditch to us because we do have myths that are going to do an air shabbos a guy does it she loves caleb a guy does it okay you have to make sure the guy put it up properly but if you know it's there and you see it's good what could be the problem i saw a new safe with me where he says the same and he brings two resharing that he found him and the ito the mezuzah that even though a guy can't write it ago he's allowed to put it up and he refused all the reason to say a guy can put up azusa there's no dinner task let's see in this context he says that the the mitzvah is being not the cleous and this you don't need to loshman decrees and he says that charitable is only you gotta be writing and allah be putting up the kid say he is very convinced that a girl could put up a mezuzah the only issue which no one could deny is that if a guy puts it up then you'd lose the broker and we spoke not so long ago that we should have a great title for us because if the great title is for us the martial on champions you lose the brother don't do a miss without a brother so if a guy puts it up he lost he lost the broker but our case the person's warehouse the guy knocked down and put it up so it's up does he have to run back to today or sunday or monday nope especially our shabbos don't run back let's find the way it is so the mice it's interesting something as fundamental as this we could say it's not earlier so we must say that this question i rather leave it as i said there are many that are mako the swara is it's just being there but there are most players can seem to be mahmear that it's not a good queers now besides that as we said every moment that mrs is up you have a mitzvah so why keep the mezuzah up that a great put which is questionable i've had to take it down and put it back now if you if the guy put it back properly and you take it off just to put it back i would make another broker because maybe the way the guy did it was good but no doubt about it if the case at a warehouse he told me it was friday afternoon it was a probably one and a half hour drive each way so to risk arab shabbos forget it go back as soon as possible i mean as soon as reason be possible but la maison it's he would say but i'm convinced that marshall is right that it's good okay you know the other person will also say that but basically we could tell him too far as lahoka at least until he gets back to the warehouse number one maybe the guy's curious is good and number two in the worst scenario even if the girl is clears wasn't good but there's no issa to have a house a room with adam azuza so let's let the room be with adam azuza there's no iss in what he's doing keeping his stuff in his warehouse but again we are mailed go asap to go and put up the mezuzah three holidays now the big question now is let's say it's a typical case at home the tape dried and the mezuzah fell on the floor or a child knocked it down the many different situations the message is off the wall how are you allowed to pick it up and put it back so when try to go in order to as he said to ask a guy doesn't seem to be proper because some say you're not even yay so what are you gaining for no mitzvah doesn't seem to be a profitable investment now if someone says kimly that the guy is perfectly now what's interesting is that the the bosnia has two chubas base coughlin hess and dalkof mangimo and he says emphatically to ask the guy to do it is not an asa because the that puts up so you're only losing the mixed math also say this to have a great put it up and it's not even kosher so what are you gaining now i you'll say i left my a child on the mitzvah so my first question is is a jewish child why are you asking because it's for you a child also so a cotton is usually not an option in this case certainly not but besides all the shabbos issues involved with the cotton if you assume which most players can seem to that a girl can't put up a mezuzah cotton also it's kind of straight to the cotton that's typically in one group so our question that some reason not in the version in if we assume a guy can't put it up a cotton is not better so basically we we see that the cotton is not an option as a guy is not an option probably a cotton is worse on shabbos because of the shadows so now the question is is there any way that i as a goddard yid could put it back so let's go in order the first question that someone asked me was a good question is now it might sound strange what's wrong with me but the truth is it's a wonderful mitzvah but why isn't it i'll give you an example let's we have a shayla a mezuzah what's his mom someone's going through the mountains after shabbos you know before the summit and he bought a few missours he left in his bedroom so you know in a bedroom absolutely doesn't belong there at night shabbos five night it was she wanted to pick up the scissors and take it out of the room is that are those muktsa now why should they be muktsa i'll tell you it's not you don't eat it you don't use it it's not functional you put it onto the wall up putting onto the wall is a nissan shabbos so basically it's not a functional kaili it's not food it's not a safer plus a mezuzah might but more so if it fell off on shabbos like our case venus master is the entire banana shimasu attached to the wall why don't we say racing so it's pretty reasonable that a mezuzah might be muksa even and was that it wasn't on the wall like i told you it was laying in his bedroom but la maison it's not a functional caylee and the min has this very shy and he basically says that even though you could look in it and you could read the words but obviously it's not it's not argument to read words and it's attached to your door post which is an isaan shabbos so it's basically not a functional cavie then he adds that maybe if i could get and he get according to some sheet this graphics am i going and then his third reason is really convincing that since we are marked with not to use the mezuzah for anything but its intended usage it might qualify to be a siren kiss circus not to be a million dollar value it's something that you set aside that you don't use it no you don't use mezuzah to stuff a bottle so therefore he says if you hold that the mezuzah is like a cliche because you attach it so to move it out of the bedroom you could say it's maybe a circle mcqueen like because i can't use the room as it is that that's a form of creamery but if this mezuzah is hussaring kiss then even sarah mccain you can't move it and the oz need blue and hail the crest says the same thing and he says bish lema magillah even if it's not you know you don't name the gill on chabas but it's functional you could practice you could read it but in mezuzah what use do you have out of it so he says now the truth is that's not so hard to explain it's a it's a non-functional valuable game but there's one catch and that is you should move even there's food you let it move unrestricted even slower there cloud but other caleb even the hectare only move with the site you know the famous question is someone's sitting by shadow brokers and the speeches are going on and on and it's all speeched out so he gets nervous he picks up the silverware and starts to play with it so that might be like her cloud or maybe that's to you know to to let out all the steam so it's you know he's nervous you're probably right but you know this turns lately is a problem why because there's a special heter or cooler for kislyak there are more then discuss this filling which is a host moves for itself i'm not going to get into that now but the question is which the taste the shabbos one of the earlier ask on on this is why don't we say that fill in aksar and kiss a person comes to his table and a shabbos and there's someone's left is filling there so even though it's blacklist you'll have to pick it up and move the cirque mccoy you know the children you know hit each other with tilling you know you use a phenomenon so that's it so he says again that the cloud is there's less smokes than any other muktsa says it goes a notch down so any kish is immune is exempt from the muktsu of sarnkis that his reason was based on the tais of shabbos that kiswiat are never sarkis they're always less of an ism so therefore even if it really is he says even attached to the wall the mezuzah is a kali and it's it seems that it's just exempt from the muksa sarkis and the azmid brew although he was mahmoud attacker like the shabbos but he said what should i tell you the min says there's no historian kiss by a mezuzah so we have two pretty good swatters either it's functional being on the wall but more importantly there's no much of a sore and kissed by a mississippi it's very similar to the loch is regarding other kids now the amis is the shmira shabbos in paragraph for our alarm at bays talking about not mezuzah that's he says that la maisa people sometimes do use twilight for a good purpose on shabbos i know someone told me true story he said it was a very short job i said there was a shia but he's afraid you're looking for excuses not to go but he's let me go through the shirts could i he walks into the chair gave up his sleeve for this and he walks in the magazine is wearing twilight he said i knew i shouldn't have come why are you wearing twilight so he was teaching her houseville and he and he walked in just then that's perfectly immortal because that's cliche so let's say our ghoul fight i saw and kiss but if i can't first of all there's a certain kiss by filling and more so there is it sarah goofy but mezuzah the truth is mezuzah there's no real use of that people don't use mazouzes they don't teach those with that because you know it's too small to show and the embassy is that the truth is that mezuzah only has the parasha of mezuzah every city has that a megillah oh magilla is very useful it has the whole mcgill so really it's not used as much as filling or megillah but i'm not saying it's a certain kiss we can understand that it's not so useful but since it's kiss via kodesh now how to apply this more specifically so basically if the mezuzah was attached to bay nashville the entire friday evening it was knocked down after banashmash's vader lila or anytime during shabbos why should it be muktsang because you couldn't use it so the embassy is something very similar is in the mystery and the end of tough that we find if you have paris fully edible pairs food that's locked up with a lock and key and not with a real i'm not a locker with a closure and you can't open it on chapters unless you do so that's me you set it aside the entire shabbos so the kits also explains that that paris if if it was opened by a guy who didn't ask just open it you shouldn't be using it on chiapas because it's katsoy but that's what the mystery allah regarding paris so it's a very good analogy to our case even if the mezuzah will say was is katsuri because it was nailed onto into the wall the doorpost but if it fell down laying on the floor terrible bazillion so pick it up and put it on the side the truth is we find regarding to fill in this design you'll be allowed to do certain things you know for sure to prevent look prevent the bazillion so it's filling also the shaving our levy that will soon see the situation i mentioned both of them discuss putting back the mezuzah when there's no malacca they don't consider a problem of muktsum so we're pretty comfortable that a mezuzah that has a that even a venous muscle is attached would not be considered or if it is basically that we have a heterozygous now the mezuzah itself since you ca well soon you can put it back behind maybe taka it's not books in the first place we thought you can't you can't nail it that's true but you can slip it in as we'll soon see so basically the mezuzah doesn't have to be treated as muktsu the mezuzah case however has two histories first of all you can't learn how loki case and number two it's not kiss but then again the myla is that a case is not a certain kiss unless you have a very expensive case so what type of looks would you consider the case you want to pick up the case and pick up the mezuzah and put it back or you want to move this is the case in the from the bedroom so the truth is it's a very unique situation what what moocs is it it's made to to hold the mezuzah and the bermuda gimbal he said maybe it's uh it's a very host of a function to protect the mezuzah now the truth is most players can feel that that's inaccurate because the case was made to attach the mezuzah to the door post and typically you take out two nails you knocked them into the case which is the moloch of the rice which is a buena so we have to treat him as a case as a malachi islam now it's not your convention this is not a molecule you don't do a melaku with the case but the analogy probably is since it's used to do an issa it's something like a phone book i guess today zachariah lebron we'll use the phone book today i used to have phone numbers right so you don't do an issue with the phone book you don't pick up you know start talking to a phone book but you look up a number to call but it's enough related to that it's considered so maybe the case is some says but probably malachi this is the right assessment but there's no kiss via koi dash right but if you want to pick up the case to put the loser back in so it's protected that's a goofy you want it out of the bedroom so that's a form of climate because otherwise you'll be denied usage of the room so it makes sense that moving the case for no reason taco should not be done you have a bunch of empty cases but if there's a need of sir guffin you could attack and move the case itself now if a mezuzah case is there because is it should i have to say that it's on the floor it's the bazoolian just the case so the truth is not a person of a case and we want to be alarmed you could say well if the case was made linoii of the mezuzah it's it's considered tashmish kadusa and you have to put it in sheamus but to say white that there's an isabel on tashmish kadusa it's probably more important to be mark and leave it as it is especially with the cheaper case so this then then since there are typically two covers on the mezuzah especially in rooms where couples are together then the case is not even a tasmania now a tricky question once i'm talking about this i always have to shut up if let's say the shame is what we call sheamus uh torn piece of gemara on the floor now if you could pick out the gemara and start learning it so it's not but let's see a shame is that illegible you can't use it so we assume that's like shivering that's muktsa but it's a it's because i said there's shames on the floor he once was walking with his father the stipela and there was shameless on the floor his diapers would pick it up and put it in the closest place so he got home we told his illustrious uncle what happened and he said no you should have left it on the floor so what's the investment statement i think we can understand it because the mice uh even if it's muktsa but it's a bazillion of of i would say it's not kissed safe third film as losers so it's a probably a bigger bizarre thing to touch muktsa and raphael bizalman's truth i think expresses this question in our shop and as a whole bottom is a whole stickle that the pros and cons of moving sheamus and he's pretty naughty that it's packing no hater if it's not a bazoolian grammar of of kiss foreign so maybe mukesh is more important so i would certainly suggest if you can move it kalakaya talk to the interesting question which you have sometimes after a while you the resistance is fine attached to the wall you want to kiss the mazes or touch them but this is not so secure when you touch it or kiss it it moves slightly so if we're saying when it's attached to the wall it's considered you're moving muffs i it's you're not moving it off its place but tilt the mixers may total it's like the case of a person moves the table and the ricky table and the channel moves and discusses it there's a tilt so the emma says that i saw it again that says it's a very good voice that if it's made to kiss the mezuzah touchdown says whatever the minute is so then that's the name of the car so it's it's it's not much for that purpose so you allowed to move but touch them this is a historicism if it's attached to the wall because that's not a tilt the next question is is it ever muta to simply slip the case slipped the mezuzah into the case in other words that's your mazel the case remained on the wall somehow the mezuzah fell out so the that's clear let's be positive that's what's possible to knock a nail into the wall marsabas cliff gimbal says attaching is an issue the question is sometimes yeah but the whole i'm just reattaching the nails into the existing hole but this is not making the hole this is attaching the system so attachment is categorically awesome the question is can i pick up the mezuzah it's not much to be said or whatever whatever the question is i want to pick up the zuzia and slip it into the case that's fully attached to the wall so the question is why not so maybe tikkun mana because the house is uh like we find it can't be masturbation type of kaley afroscala but stay true with the double first of all there you can't use the tumor the food without tumor some isis but here we said that the house is no issa and even if you go with the price there is to go into the house but everybody else is allowed to go into the house we said it's only the baller and bishop in the ball bus going to the house it's not awesome amish also it's only american massachusetts famous you saw it in lombard base or his club zion's gotten gimmel even tila's kaylee's only near kumasaki because it's not a physical tickling so that doesn't seem to be a problem la maisa the poiskim that i mentioned earlier do seem to say that there's no issue putting back amazon's into the case machiavelli doesn't seem to be correct it's not the finishing touches the secret that i mentioned has an interesting hectare it's aloysia to put a mezuzah into the case like gazura bonham whatever the case is the titelizer in your gimbal non gimbal seems to make them as well the pastas is that if there's no bueno your a lot of symptoms are back into the case now it was interesting to shave in our lady and dalai kuffman gimmel quotes malachim which is safer on kitsap but but particularly um base that has four reasons not to even slip a mezuzan to the case where no brain is involved if you're going to slip it into a case next week you might put the case back onto the wall dr bosna who gives you the right to make your own xavius we know chemiska a loose and screwed to a tight school but to make an issa out of a hetero because you might do it he says like when you put muksa on a caylee on shabbos and valkyrie you can't move the entire because it's immobile but if you allowed us to in you could take it out so it's not even not not even like that the third sword that he wants to say is ticking mana there's no issa on the bias the fourth sword that he says is it's an akshay that you're doing a very hush for myself and it's he says we don't have to respond to such kindness but then he adds something very nice the shilla say the bank of emdin and al of lambert development he says mezuzah is one mitzvah you can't do it on shabbos so was dr posey so you see he's right you can't put it on you can't slip it around i can't want you slipping around shabbos so you see you can't slip it around childhood zuckerberg's the right he says no it's not a rally because the iv is in that same sheet the whole that chain chuva holds you can't even be right so if you slip the shut the the mezuzah into a groove that's in the wall the majaba grave is make habits as either you could attach it with nails or if you have a little groove a little indentation in the door post slip it in and some says as long as this is on the mesus bay circle don't put it too deep but you can slip it into a groove the eye that says no there has to be a connection of the smarter of nails so software buzz oh she tossed side that you have to have a connection so of course you can't do it on chavez but le ditan that you could slip it into the grooves so why not step it into the case so reversal says i think it's fine but someone wants to be makel yes very powerful so i was thinking i don't know if this was the meant but in his classic work on the hill he says based on ish maybe you can't even slip with mizuzu into the case why because it has a niche holes that they put up a v-line a curtain on a wall even though everything is on just put the curtain on to the wall is considered buying them he argues ram and mr brewer and trump sardashim putting something that's staying israel opinion reasons so putting mazuzi into the case into the case or into the groove is at least most of our opinion but this is a fiddish first of all because most pisces do not accept the hazard the ogave allah that when you put the curtain on the wall it's moist albanian because it becomes part of the house it's the naya bayes the mezuzah is a kia mitzvah on the governor but not on the bias doesn't become a better bias but la maison the price can seem to say that even to put the curtain on most paiskim are mater i'm not going to rummage the world i see so in this so you don't put the curtain on shabbos i'll say but tell a person live a whole shabbos without a mezuzah that makes sense why stay without it to call it guy again you're risking not having anything now the only question is when you put the mezuzah into the groove do you have to make another barakah it fell off and you want to put it in so this we find in if you took a mezuzah to check and you put it back within 24 hours you don't make another break you took it off the paint you don't make another bra but surprisingly enough if the mezuzah fell off out of the case you put it back with a new broker why so the price can prepare this fits us we find falls off entirely you put it back with a new bra i if i go out for a break i go to the bathroom i don't make a new bracha why is fallen golf different tells adrava if you took it off you had that if it fell off the mitzvah is gone and it's a new mitsub so if the palace fell if you make another bracha mezuzah fell off you make another brochure some price can hold that it's not true you don't make another brother but i think most boys can hold you definitely make a bra now the next question which also happens sometimes the top nail or the top the tape mistake fell off and now the mizuno is hanging not cavias backwards no mitzvah the holidays absolutely no mitzvah you want to put back the nail during the week tuesday to make another break on that so question is well well you know you're right to the mitzvah right so takas most places since the mitzvah left you you make another bracha rav nissan gary also had a beautiful lionfall and he said what's that when the talis almost slipped off you grabbed one string of the scissors and you're holding onto for their life it's not on you anymore you don't make another bracha so why is this different but the embassy is a big mukbang because if you are holding on to at least one string you have a scientist to the mitzvah not that the mitch is being this kind with one string but you have a shaykh in the midst when the mezuzah is laying backwards hanging the mitz is gone you're not holding on to anything but what i think the embassy is that since poison holding a makeup rocket oh and this is a fell and this case the smarter like nissan to make another broke but the good news is that the the question that we had is when it was fell on the floor would have to fast so the truth is fasting is not in chicago but that's a very time honored minute it's a mini cuddle filling also if a person could do it he should fast and he fell on the floor directly but mezuzah there's no such meaning so basically be careful i couldn't talk to you [Music] that makes [Music] um [Music] is [Music]