The ladle In Halacha: Shabbos / Kashrus - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

see many other questions but as we'll see it's really one in the cool that we have to clarify today and that is the status of Allah now let me explain there'll be a difference if a ladle is used till his capturing but the basic you said we have to know is what the mishta says in Shabbos staff members that basically and I brought in a pot so we have a visual aid this is a clear reason agabio age this is a part now this part Cooks the soup the Mr says even when you take this pad off the fire and now it's on the counter but Lamay is a clear reshine is fully capable of cooking why because the fire heated the path and heated the food and as long as the soup or whatever it is it's still hot so a claration is capable of cooking even your age even if it's off the fire and cause get on the fight but the same mishna says but let's say you put it into a this will be the serving Bowl this is cliche if you put it from the from the pot into the serving Bowl now this is a cliche to cross the board come out clicheni cannot cook why that's the message Isis but just to give you a muscle for now what that means let's say you had unexpected guests and that enough soup but you know as the bad boys taught us there's always enough if you ruin the heart there's room at home no problem to add a little bit hot water a little bit cold what I'm sorry to add cold water to this pot of soup is awesome because of the rice even off the fire so simple later pour from the hot pot into a clicheny into a serving Bowl and you'll have to put an even cold into the serving Bowl I how are you talking you can put cold water into boiling hot soup just like our local Maison if you pour from a hot soup from a pot into a serving Bowl you could even add ice cubes into the serving Bowl because cliche now you know that I chose a muscle of water because we'll soon see that many or most Foods we are a suspect of being a clean being kale Bissell that does get cooked in a clicheni but water is definitely not Cali official so if you want to expand your soup don't add cold water to the pot itself put into a serving bowl and you could add that is basically a mission in Shabbos staff members clearation versus cliching the big Kasha is what's the difference and there's a serving Bowl fine that's a difference but how did that affect local Shabbos if the soup is hot in the Clarisse joint it's hot in the cliche so Titus is a little earlier death one of these photos of today and toyesis explains clarissian has two major qualities that make it a clear reshape so I'll tell you is don't forget this path was on the Fire foreign not only does the food get hot but the pot gets hot and that maintains the Heat therefore this could cook even but this is a cliche this is serving Bowl I took it from the cabinet the thing itself was cold so when the soup go hot soup goes into these cold walls it cools it off I have a cliche even though it could be add to lettuce boy ain't since the walls were called and the soup in this cliche it is called clicheni cools off and the assumption is if the temperature is dropping it doesn't have the ability to cook so this is basically showing is Bishop there Isa eventually and clicheni's mother except for Kalia Bishop now I'm going to ask you a million dollar question but it's very intriguing I'm one of you if I use alato to take soup out of a Clarita and let's say I fill up this Ladle with soup and I freeze what is the status of the soup in the ladle and yeah this I think the best Express would be it's not in the clear Regional longer but it didn't get into the kuisine yet right but you say wait a second but there's a very big mile here what the word is wait a second because you put the ladle into the clearest sign so the heat of the creation and it wasn't Clear Vision so just like soup in the Clarita it becomes clearly showing maybe a ladle in a clear resine becomes a clear recent so that's the question maybe the ladle is a extension of a creation ah you'll say but wait a minute this is how does it make a little clear reset but then again you know how to put cold water into this pot because it Cooks eventually so maybe just like a Clarita and that's hot could cook maybe it makes a ladle into a clearishine so clicheni is understandable it's out of the clear reason but a later maybe it was a Mercedes clear recent it became a clear recent or maybe we'll say wait a minute okay old walls it somehow didn't become a giant it's a cliche so this is our sky and you know what makes it more challenging because typically you say you know let's become but it doesn't work and I will see it I'll tell you why if I treat this like a clear reason is that homurakula now let's say I want to capture something and the pot is too heavy so I want to use a ladle take out water and pour the hot water onto the surface that has to be cashed it's called there's a clear research is that humor akula a big bit cooler so it's not even sure it's a bit cooler so this is our side now to my limited knowledge there's no Gamora that speaks about later I'm not sure why it's not like a new invention like a cell phones I don't know but they didn't use ladles but a very prominent Source One of the daily we're showing in my real lemon hogim it's page you're testing the maluma let me make this very clear most things takasha you either have to use a boiling throwing a fork into the tray before into the Boiling Pot of water or something's even more so you have to use fire you have to use h but there are some cases that you're a lot of Kasha with e-recleration the Marshall a surface that got traded because of iroy so you have to cash it by eru that's the general so you boil up water and you take the clear reason and you pour it on the affected surface but let's say you have the pots too heavy you can't pick up a pot like that as big as this so you want to take a ladle or any path for that matter take the water out and pour it onto the surface so that was a Shiloh if the ladle is a Cleary showing because it was in a clear reset you could capture it but later the cliche you can't capture the cliche so that my real was asked this very exact question and he says cliche who cliche and you cannot cash it with a later really using a clear reason and submerging it but you allowed to use eroi but using a ladle would be considered cliche and you can't capture it as I stayed in my real ex very very clear Aledo becomes a cliche okay now let me ask you a question according to the Mario is it cliche so if Maria was convinced that the latest a cliche so so why can't you you be in that case you know if you decided at the very end the same value it's on the top phrase line medallion now you'll said the following that he assumed that a a cliche which is a lost credit for later is only regarding agala he was mahama and he said that Aledo is a clicheni this is a totally different picture then my real was not sure the status of alato and you can't catch it with it so it's a plea the grace of Ariel but wait there's one more very important part of our sugar and that's the Taz and every day at the end of Simon Sadiq base the task quotes albemaril and I just mentioned that you can't cash it with a ladle I don't understand this because definitely a clear reason and it's so much you can even cash it with it why and he says pretty good arguments he says if you want to cast your fork that became shape so you put it into a clear reset How Does It capture it I thought it was a cliche oh it is a cliche also if you stick a a flash sticker Fork into a hot pot of milks it becomes Trey why do we say that this the spoon is like a cliche the turrets is when it goes into a clear reshine it becomes a clear reason and then he quotes if you learn superficially you see something one way if you learn it properly it's a whole different picture is and his devoted says he wanted to give him oil to to anoint himself with which is but the oil was cold and it wasn't good for the rabbit it's too cold so he wanted to to heat the oil and put it into the in the markets so he goes no no that's Bishop told the clicheni betaine put water in the cliche and then you can put the oil in because cliche now how do you tastes those words the time so the task says people would think it means let's say take a ladle if it's big enough take water out and put the oil in it now what does that mean that means I'm Shabbos that's mother why is because the ladle is a because it's not true layers of clarison so it does it can't be shot put it into the ladle and put the oil in because White Russian told the cliche and also why is all of a sudden this becomes a cliche and it is a ladle says the task it means take a ladle Ladle out some water put that water into a cliche and then put your oil in in other words Aledo is a clear resin so from the gemara is a parent you're making two steps get the water in a label and what's the water at that point reshine put it cliche pack a cliche any different Kaley later and then put the oil in and therefore he says no doubt about it that a ladle is a clear recent and listen then what he is and it's beautiful he says this says what's the what's the mile up of a clicheni daifenice miscarriage this Ladle in the pot is not the difference of skyroise it's getting it's getting more warmed by the pot so therefore he says no doubt about it a ladle is a Cleary showing and yet after all this he says but I must tell you when Hook is capturing you have to be mahmir and assume that a ladle is a clicheni foreign that we cannot really determine the status of a later on yeah we're gonna get there going to get that soon now I must mention also if you look in the tasks he says that we treat the lady like a clarison on Shabbos now it's not a stir up but but it's what's very interesting is people can't figure out what a ladle is but I think the shot is the difficulty is because it's very unusual because typically Clarice shine is in 1K cliche is from a cold Katie this is a cold Kaylee going into a clear reason especially the fire is underneath it's being boiled so how why should it not be a clear reason but then again it has his own identity foreign because he says if you look at toys says this two miles of a claration number one there's a fire underneath and number two the walls are hat so he says I feel that the creation is the fire underneath now if that's the case by Aledo maybe if there's no fire maybe it's a Cleveland there's no fire underneath it's a cliche but the Taz held what's the main mile of a clear region definition what makes Omni Clear recent is it the fact is a fire or is it enough that it is daif nice hat and the ladle the walls are hot and that's basically the sheet of javasdas but the shack all the party scheme go with the tasks so let's be very clear although you know my some do question the task but I saw a very interesting he says although we could argue on the Taz but Mia khalik Miss Forest cares who's gonna argue with a boy swara on the task in other words don't play around with the Taz so Rabbi say now we basically have Hashem the status of a label later let me ask you the question so what is a later lamisa clarissian clicheni or both or none of the above the answer is it's none of the above not a creation only nothing only now both it's on both ends now what now you can understand what really my real himself says that my real himself that says you can't Kasha with Aledo he says but if you have to cash it with a later because you can't lift the pot I have a great answer take the ladle what's the Assumption then everything becomes hot so you transform the ladle into a Clear Vision Mario says it and Mr Brewer inspace quotes this as well all say that but there's one more factor and then we're going to apply this more specifically and that is cotton gimmel he says I have another point let's say you're capturing with a pat pat a ladle but the fire is on underneath the hot pot of water so you're laddling out the water and you with the fire that's still warming the water if there's an H underneath all the green even regarding castering that it's a clear reason and the sword is mostly because the only has a cliche there's no age and there's no diapers mascar race there's no if it's common here you have an Ace and though if noise that's on you could even Ladle the water and Caster because basically when you keep the ladle in the pot it becomes a clear reason so you basically moving a clear reason I you're pouring it out but then again when you use pour the pots alsoin is able to capture certain things but I think we could say the following if you want to be very safe take the ladle put it into the Boiling Pot again keep it there now once you keep it there and you have the fire on I think you're certain that it is a real clear research okay so let's apply this to mice let's start with a simple shot you the wife made the soup everything is fine but she forgot to add spices and you can serve soup that's not spiced now tell people the advice is not going to go so the question is how and when is it mutter to add spices to a hot pot of soup so one thing is a mishna to add spices to the hot pot that's that's clearation is awesome eventually and don't forget pepper ground pepper was never cooked it was ground but not cooked so you can add pepper to the pot question if you later a little bit of the soup and put it into a bowl can I add spices to this so here this is the question is if a ladle is a clear reset then this is clicheni and clicheni could be visual if it's Kalia Bishop and indeed the Mr Bureau says the shine when he's talking about water issue we'll soon see about adding water he says that even if you use a lado like a Clarice strain in other words he says he's going with the sheet this and he says certainly if you master it you keep it in the in the bowl it's a clear reason is very consistent like the Taza Mario we treat it on shoppers like a clarison so the latest the Kiwi shine and the soup bowls are cliche now could be spices multiple students get to that but before we you know too quick to pass it like this a little earlier actually 42 Thief Cottons earlier same shine he discussed you want to add matzah khala croutons baked items to your hot bowl of soup so Mr Brewer says basically if you Ladle out the soup and put it into your bowl you could add baked items into your soup the question is but if the soup is still hot why don't we say it's visual the croutons were baked but that we know yes and in fact it could be and that's the way the uranium assumes that these baked items are Kalia Bishop so it's not even both of the cliche so how can you add baked items to your bowl of soup what is it at most clicheni came from the past latest and you put it into the boat so Mr Brewer says well that's why the best data is wait till the soup cools off then you could add the croutons but people like a hot soup so it's not practical or at least use a lado so then your bowl of soup is a cliche now this is a theorem see if cotton pays I and he says Ladle is a clear reshine and the balls are clicheni and see if cotton mem hey he says now one day I guarantee you the mystery was not soyuz himself he had much too much and much too much to besides himself to write like a reason you can die because but to say he was himself in the same same semen Unthinkable and the m is Mr Brewer in the third place register and gimmel paid out also says if you have a calf a ladle you could be Michael so here's the shank out of the sugar everything fits in beautifully did you ever wonder we're talking about ladling out soup from a hot pot of soup on the fire wait a second we don't make a ghost you know stir mix or scoop out food from a paragabio ace what's Mission we're talking about the turrets it and you see it's so unbelievably madoic the Mr Brewer Taco when he's talking about in in sinus see if cotton pays eye and he's talking about water because it's all one one volume of water so Mr river is talking about that the pot of water is on the fire and you make is it agabio Ace oh Agave your age all agree is a Clarissa so it gets to your bowl of soup at mostly cliching and that's why it's Hummer but the other place your look is talking about a hot food you can't be magazine it has to be being made you took the pot off the fire Ace then we could assume rightfully so that's really cliche you know he doesn't say anything just as with as if we're supposed to figure it out but a much more positive and a much more fundamental hillock is the following when you have eyes you look at the ladle you know the ladle is synonymous with ladle Suffolk right I'm not sure what a little is I mean you see enough you know it's one big Suffic so one suffix you have to be but let's say you have a situation you have two svakis or two stars maybe the truth doesn't add up to a legitimate Hunter and that's the Mr Brewer's real upset you should know because when you want when you use a ladle and you put into this bowl of soup it's not certainly shiny maybe the layers of cliche and there's a cliche now you want to put in baked items if you look at Singh is so when you have two coolers that's when the Mr Brewer says you could rely on the ladle being a Shaney both sleazy because that's too cool is that coincide you could be Mako and you're looking and you'll see that's very madurians and I found a half a dozen of the high integer pie skin that all say the same you saw it so let's review these sizes I'm gonna apply this basically clarissian is able to cook eventually clicheni doesn't cook anything except for Kalyan bishlo which is a lot as we'll soon see a ladle is a Suffolk we could reasonably say if you have an A Gabriel age with the fire on the ladle is a clear reset but also a most important if you have a ladle with another coulomb another sadhetam that adds up to a head now you'll see how practical this is a person is making hot coffee on Shabbos so the oldest question is why can't I just do things simply there's a hot cup right I pull up why can't I put the coffee powder into my cup like I do during the week and run the water into it what's wrong why do I have to have two cups three cups you know it just gets confusing so the truth is it's not a bad question because all of instant coffee and Institute for that matter was once cooked they take the coffee beans actually they grind it into coffee ground they cook it it's a very extremely thick soupy coffee liquid then they remove the water either through either freeze drying they used to use spray dry but basically then you have powdered coffee or powder tea that is a hundred percent I mean it's as cooked as you can be why can't I just put the coffee into my cup run the water on do it I don't have to have cups all over the place so it's a good question the only reason that we use a second cup is because the coffee powder is now a powder but and its use it as a coffee powder it's soluble and a liquefies and it becomes a liquid now napshot you can't find it in the liquid like you throw sand in a liquid it's also it's still there but that's there this becomes a liquid so the sharer tuba wants to say that maybe we have to treat a powder liquid as a liquid ah once the powder was a liquid yes so that's why we use an extra cup so then we'll hold it back please see fine now this is interesting that some people really like a hot coffee they don't like this business of taking the cup to another cup so he's an aggressive fellow and when no one's looking I guess he goes over to the urn The Shield picks up the cover takes his cup clean and ships out water and now he wants to use it then put his coffee into it so he says well now it's a clicheni but he's wrong because this is a Bonafide clear Regional holidays because he's alarmed if I didn't think what he was doing he's drawing water from agabio age and this is a collateral it's a spoon it's a it's a it's a cup but this is water from agabio age and this would still be the original Cleary shame someone rinsed a bowl okay this is the El Super Bowl for today and he wants to add soup into this bowl and it's too lazy to dry it off or he enjoyed a good bowl of soup now there's a little bit cool soup in the bowl and he wants to have doubles the question is can he add hot soup to this bowl that either has water or cool soup so we'll go one step at a time if this has water that rinsed the bowl it was never cooked that technically is Bishop if that water gets cooked so it's Bishop the rice the only question is if I use a lado and I pour it on like this would that be a tar hepta maybe I'll say later is a cliche ah once a later the cliche so going into the bowl is a Eerie cliche what is the one one of the things that's not Kalia bishop and never Cooks in a clicheni certainly it doesn't cook an irie cliche so the color I could take it Pour hot soup into the bowl as is but here we're gonna say you have to we have to rewind a second because this Ladle we have to treat Le humra like a clear recent cold water and that's movasso at least even though it's just a little bit water let's say it's bottle you can't be bottle and Bishop it might be hatsis so basically to add hot soup from a later on to cold water again you rinse with cold water typically that is a definitely a problem now if you next question let's say you use this ladle and you serve now the ladle is cooled and the soup in it a little bit soup is cooled can I reuse the label the ladle as is and put it back into the pot so if the soup in the ladle is still hot so hot as hot but I'm talking about it really cooled off it's cold by a liquid yes but you want to see this later but wait a minute look what you're doing you're taking this Ladle and putting it back into the creation Cooks so this is a major problem you're putting cool soup into a clean reason Ace now the next question is let's say I take from a ladle I want to add it to my bowl that has leftover cooled soup I'm having doubles I have the the leftovers and the singles in the bowl can I take from the soup and pour it directly onto my leftovers from the my first Bowl that's completely cold this we have two speakers first I'm using a ladle and also the soup in this bowl is not the end of the world what is the soup in this bowl yes we all know Vietnam unlike the first case where it was water from a sink that was never cooked this is soup that was cooked so we have two we have two reasons to be Mako first of all maybe a little cliche and also maybe yes and that's why it's okay to be soy mechan this is onto it and you have to dry it first because we have two reasons to be makeled at both air up now this would be another question Also let's say you have a cooked cooked soup that cooled off and I want to take more hot soup with a ladle and pour it out into the cool soup just to give it all to revive a little bit to make it warm so I'm adding hot soup into cold soup so here again this is the same we have two swarthy Michael later and the worst scenario this soup is himself says in Raceland gimbals if cut and pay dalit and you look at you'll see that's the case that I mentioned earlier because he's saying if you have two reasons to be magical you could add them up so to take hot soup from the creation and put it into a bowl that has cool soup we have two starting to make and you could be Mako question a with this very negative because I'm in a camp in a camps and hotels all these big oysters they have a pot of soup that no one could lift I mean they have to add the water you know as it is but gets up but they have the pot of soup on a heating element actually it's a fire type element but it's basically a hot pot that they don't pick off the fire so there you have these questions of actually taking food Ace that's much more humor because then we have no Suffic that the ladle that goes into this big path Clarissa because it's Agape your age and it is very hot now typically the fight is supposed to go up when they serve the soup but if the fire is on don't forget that would be clear we should be your age and we'll look at the latest the Clarissa and pouring from the ladle on to cool soup is only one side to be Michael and taco that should not be done the next point which um I wanted to mention someone asked me an interesting question is it a Myla whenever you're serving soup to always keep the ladle in the the pot of soup I said it's I'll tell you why because if you keep the ladle in the soup at all times you don't have a problem of soup that cooled off the light is always hot so then you could take it out serve again put it back serve again you're never a problem of cool soup in a ladle because it's always hot but the issue is the ladle in the clear region the whole time is going to get hot after a while and then it's not a cooled cliche it's probably a warm clear reset question let's say someone wants to avoids Vegas so he knows a hot pot of soup he takes a ladle and he sticks it in quickly and takes out too quickly did he avoid this becoming a clearishime because it was in the path for the shortest amount of time was masking for this if you put it in a regular commemorate that it didn't get hot then it doesn't become a clear reset I mean you know it's all about facts now how do I know so if you have time on a Friday don't get in your wife's way but go into the kitchen take a ladle this guy is plastic metal will be easier to work with take a metal a ladle stick it into the soup and take it out quickly and feel it and you tell me is it it's not piping hot it can't get hot so quickly so Miriam cause is everybody I should agree to that it's not as a cost of Ladle it's clear recently illness in a pot is a Suffolk you keep it a long time that's the that's the Mario but in and out maybe it's a cliche so you have to be you have to experiment to make sure that he's doing it right but it makes sense that once the ladle was in and out so quickly that it didn't absorb the heat it still retained its cliche status next question you want to add baked items to a hot soup so as explained really baked items is fully baked is you look and see if hey mentioned two days it's not certain but it's enough for Eurasia we don't add baked items to a clear reason oh here's where we see the Mr Brewer's biggest site that you want to add to a hot bowl of soup best would be if the soup cooled then you have no problem or Beyond yet but if you want to have a hot soup with your Canada with your croutons then if you use a lado so again The Soup pot is clearly showing later will rely the cool as a cliche it gets into your bowl it's a cliche you're eating mats and croutons and we're assuming that it is so even though Matsu is Kalia Bishop we're gonna have to hope that in the cliche it's not hot enough to cook the Kalia Bishop now this is important to mention also because if you have sometimes there are certain croutons that are actually deep fried which means not just a baked but it's cooked in a big amount of oil deep fried is considered there's no difference cooking in water and oil so we could assume that deep fried mandolin when that's the Matthias you'll have to put even into a foreign [Music] make a point of here's the next question sometimes uh these people don't realize that but let's say you want to dip your cake into the hot coffee shop is very kid dish at home whatever it is you have a hot coffee and you want to dip designers into the cake into into coffee I'm sorry so this is very similar to the above don't forget because if we assume that the cup of coffee is a cliche then we have to still be racist yes on the cake so if you pour the water from the urn into this cup okay and then you add a coffee which is pretty okay now to add cake into that is yes because the cliche at most nothing else if you made coffee like most people use one cup and use the second one so there's a cliche then you could dip in them with the cake or the cookies into the cliche but if this is a real clean shiny coffee we have to be racist yes now a point I want to mention which uh so it gets a little nervous you come to especially yeshivak or big moisted there's hot cups all over the place because people make coffee and they have these clearas now they use end up in the sugar if you use your cup all you have to have for a thousand people is one extra cup not one per person and I'll show you it's very positive and you put water into it okay now you're not gonna make coffee in there even though real you could eat coffee then but you're from you put it into another cup okay then you add your coffee you put this down the next fella that comes also takes his clean hat cup let him put the coffee in this cup I this cold water from the from the previous fellow but cold water can never get cooked beyond the clear recently Shane it doesn't get cooked they said this is even even cliche let him use this first coffee and then put down his original cup and you'll go a thousand people only have to have one cup okay now you know summer question the hot cup whatever but my point is one cup for a thousand people if you use your cup and that's positive but the point is because water can never get cooked Beyond The Creation now we had a question at home or in a big a camp situation that it's not just one person wants to have kuta see if you're home alone you take a ladle quickly you put the soup pick it out if you have a lot of people that want soup with messiness very simple later and that if you can't go wrong take the soup Pat put it into a serving Bowl okay then you can do what you want because this is a cliche the holiday is then once you use a lado from a later for Christmas he is fine so basically you could put it into a serving bowl and then you couldn't have to worry what's the status of the ladle it got cold hot this is a clear-cut cliche someone remembered to make what yeah but then we rely on the ladle here because we have baked Foods don't forget now good news he remembered to make lotion for the soup the bad news he forgot to put her on the black before Shabbos so he has cold locks it in the refrigerator and his wife wants to serve the soup where's the lockshine and it's embarrassed to say he didn't think that he forgot to vomit so there's a simple answer if you have the right facts if indeed the lock Shin is definitely fully cooked but it's dry so take the lotion and put it right into the bowl the into the pot of soup why not you can't put it into the to the pot Agave no problem the only problem is typically after you make luxury you rinse it and there's water that was never cooked so you have to either dry the lotion quickly from all the water or find a different answer the eights with B put the soup from the part into your serving bowl and then the water never gets cooked in a cliche so one of the two eights you do and really you can't go wrong someone made soup and they forgot to spice it so here again it's not the end of the world to add spices to the clear reshoin even your age it's special because again pepper was never cooked but a simple later take the pot and put it into a serving Bowl you're going to pour it straight or use a layer no difference so now this bowl is a clean is one of the few things that we know is not a Kalia Bishop so after you have the soup in your serving Bowl which is very reasonable add the spices and then you can put it on the table and there's no boost to that you forgot to add spices perfect the only issue I must mention representative is almond in in the The Swiss shops there's an incredible he says spices the way they grow are not Kalia Bissell pepper does not grow as ground pepper grows as a peppercorn at this big and the peppercorn is not Kalia Bissell but they sell finely ground pepper that's Kalia Bishop look at it it's so small now the the godlin this sack is that he's assuming in times of hazao they use peppercorn but all the all the boys can wonder they they also grounded they don't have cell phones but they definitely had Grand China you learned myself the Bayer so I must mentioned has a reservation about pepper but most boys can hold in a cliche it's okay adding salt to this cliche and he's also motor now soul is a Sookie for itself because Mr Blue discusses some salt was mined never cooked typically sold today in America Al Capone was cooked is okay recently they started making salt it's not cooked it's a much low lower temperature it's basically the water is is dried from it so that's more of an issue but it's definitely what they make and putting in a cliche certainly and perhaps even a cliche for a different reason that we're not gonna get into now if you had unexpected guests and you need to expand the soup no problem put the water put the soup into a serving Bowl add as much as cold water as you like and that would be again without a suffix question interesting question a person has a clicheny okay let's go about the serving Bowl and you laid it out and this very hot you Ladle out soup from a clicheny very possibly do it all the time right you have a serving Bowl later that soup what's the status of the soup in the ladle so push it time it's like cliche right we're assuming that a later is just like the cliche clear reason no difference cliche and that's to attack what the police can assume because you you don't say Well since it's a cliche so the lady takes on the identity of the Kaylee so later physically restart is a clear reasoning becomes a clicheny as well and that's really what the fight most come out all the bites what I found say this mefarish nothing changes because it has this the original identity of where it came from Cleary shine or cliches both say this my favorite question someone did not have a ladle so decided to use a hot cup as a ladle in other words he immersed the hot cup into the clear reset in The Soup pot took it out and now put it into a soup bowl what is the Halal regarding a hot cup is a hot cup like a regular Kaylee and therefore it's a clear reshine or maybe a hot cup would be different now here's the the patent of a hot cup the hot cup made of a styrofoam you could always hold on to it Masha ain't gained a glass it gets very hot a metal gets very hot what's shot so this is the signs of a styrofoam is that it doesn't absorb heat it maintains the heat pretty well but doesn't absorb the Heat so here the child is if you use a not a not a metal or even a plastic lid a plastic also absorbs somewhat this is a styrofoam do we say that this would become a vadai clicheny and here it works the cooler so that's pretty Mustafa in fact I saw the safer Shabbos is very good that's first of all there's no age under this and also it's not Dave noise it's not macaroise was so it's basically a neutral position and he wants to assume that this styrofoam being that it does not gonna be your age that's certain and more so it the fact is that it doesn't it's not definitely is Miss Hammer voice it's number car is in between you could treat this like a cliche someone asked me he took a piece of kuggle with a spatula is there any talk to say that a spatula makes it like a cliche this is cliche like a ladle and therefore he put into his plate it's a cliche so you made a big mistake because it's not a then you transfer something it's a then that the soup was in a ladle that had a wall to it that was Makai rice a spatula is like a fork that's just transferring but doesn't affect the the quiggle itself but more of a mistake that he made is that he forgot that the kugel like other Dover gush is not affected by creation cliche if you take a piece of chicken from the from the pan and put it into a bowl so like many wishes so a spatula certain doesn't affect that a full walk a spatula is just transferring a ladle which is a Kaylee and a Kaylee is an issue so that's why the chicken or the kugel that was removed by a spatula onto a plate is double gush can I add this an American child of course can I add ketchup to my piece of chicken on my plate or a hot potato from the child or hot meat from The Challenge so this is beautiful from a different angle because past this if you say David gush is like clarissaim so the piece of meat to a potato in my plate is a Clear Vision how could I add ketchup says cotton hey here we have the same two coolest coinciding but this is einfeld because no one is certain that Dava gush is still a clear region foreign but then what's the problem with ketchup ketchup is why they cooked there it says it cooled so yes coinciding number one and ketchup is coincide he has a different angle and he says very logical because you give someone a hot tea oh that's kismack cold tea is not a hot tea it's not a it's this but ketchup is made to use as cool so it never lost its visual status so the mice you could have your ketchup and eat it on Chavez as well so that's definitely posted that regard because again it's the two uh as cool as they coincide now moving on to a little bit of health is capturing so basically again if someone wants to Caster a surface and he's allowed to use Eerie Clear Vision again typically it's not the case typically you have to either use Ace or gagolo but he's allowed to use iroy and he can't lift up The Pact what you should do is take up the pot pick up the pot and pour it onto the surface but it's too heavy Candy La Miser use a ladle out the water and pour it onto the surface so that's the agreement of Mariel and Taz I'm going to have ROM everybody you can't do that because we have to say that a ladle is a clean Shaney and it's incapable of casturing and that's tackle the police can say the only thing I could mention is what the magana rum says toughness base test which is really echoing what the mario said that if you want you could keep the ladle in the pack until it gets good in hat and rely on shahiya maintaining the Clear Vision status and then cash it with that the embassy we never do on Shabbos during the week we do right so why not be do a little better and keep the pot on the fire and keep the fire on so you have both miles shahia and agabio age and then say for the holidays question someone use a lado and took out hot soup so far so good but but put it into a military Bowl what's the status of the bowl the bowl was used this morning for hat Farina now we put in uh now we put a flace chicken soup so here we have to be honest and realize that this lady is a clear recent so irie Clary shine is so the the bowl is affected and part of the soup is also affected because in this case it's a regular Eerie it's a regular Ladle Cleary shine and definitely affects that part of the of the of the bowl that it hits but more so more posted you know people think later all of a sudden has a cooler if a person and immerse it into a hot bowl hot pot of chicken soup that's not their problem the fact that it's delay does not there is a cause so that it's a cooler you're putting a military into a fly sugar pot that's that's a real bus of a hollow issue so the ladle needs casturing that certain and if there's no sheeshim of Layla in the soup then the soup is a problem because the fact that it's a ladle is only an issue when you're laid out food but when you put it in and especially in the fire is on that makes a real taruba is last question but it just shows that how when you learn a silgio everything fits in Bez Hashem if you get to the bottom of it someone had a pot of soup and he noticed there was a fly flying around and oh it was the right word if it ends up in the soup that's bad but if he can't find it then the whole soup is awesome so he watches it and attacker made a dive into the soup she quickly grabbed the ladle or a spoon whatever it is and took out the the fly with some of the soup so what's Allah about the soup perfectly cautious even if it stayed a while because at worst scenario what's in the soup only a time of that to share it time is I it's a barrier but Barry is also the Thomas battle machine but then he started scratching his head and thinking wait a second soup is fine maybe after Kasha the ladle or the or the spoons I took it out with because he looked at it and the Fly was an ice-sized flight but even if not a nice size fly in a spoon there's no season so maybe I have to capture the the spoon just like he would never drink the soup in the lado because that is no shishim so the Pat's okay but the later than okay the superdan okay so maybe the Lego or the spoon whatever he took it out with needs cashing because you have a fly without chisha so you say oh wait a second you're not gonna blow that by me this is a Cleary sign right and later the cliche but that's wrong why very positive because this went into a clear region and going back that originally you saw it there's something in the clear region we treat the home like a clearishine and Dr is one of the earliest this very Shyla when you had a fly in the soup and you quickly took it out we have to assume that the ladle that went into the Cleary shine is a dinner so now you have a clear resign pictured of Pat with soup and a fly that is absorbing tarphus interlato if you could assume the latest cliche then it doesn't affect the later but since the latest shine we have to assume that the later became affected by the fly and this is so it transfers the time from the fly into the soup which goes into the ladle so the ladle in fact needs cashing and talk to you thank you yes your character Smith for today's year as him after college was Mr says secum tonight foreign [Music] you see the status of a ladle is very and the Pisces assume that it's a sophic and the khum like on shop is like like had it been a Cleary sign and in Castries we treated lachumba like a cliche of the ladle is it's not a clearisha and because it's not on the fire maybe it's a cliche but then again it goes in the in the Cleary shine so that's the suffix which we never really determined but we cheated on both ends the site of a cliche and he has two Milas if you want to call that number one is and the Wolves originally called and later the walls were cold but maybe it was affected by being in the pot the Mr bura does say this because we could add the two up and make it into a head in other words how about you put in baked items that is also that is basically a cup of coffee with also machmere that we make it in a sec use a second cup of cliche because we treat the coffee powder as a soluble as a liquid and yes a cup that you set water out of the urn is a real clearation it's water got your age so even though it's hotter water but that's not for Shabbos if you rinsed a bowl and uncooked water is on the bowl you can use a lado to put onto that water because that would be considered Bissell of the droplets if it's cooled water a cold soup that was once cooked then you have the two coolers that coincide to adding hot water to a cool soup hot soup I'm sorry what either one is good into a cool soup you do have the header if you use it by later because that would be the header of double cooler to keep a ladle in a path at all times is good this way you know the problem of reinsert your label but then the ladle is reason if you put a ladle in and out and you certainly didn't didn't heat up then the hair is back to its original status as a cliche adding baked items are okay if you have it through a lado or Coast game basically species deep fried is melted without this um issue because it's it's ambition to to dunk cake or cookies into hot coffee make sure it's at least a beyond the cliche called Lux and if it's dry can be put into the actual supot Ace of course if there's moisture then you have to put it into a serving bowl and then you could add the entire lotion with the cold uncooked water adding spices I think the mini Garland is to add it to a cliche a Plymouth almond was concerned maybe it's Cali and Bishop expanding a soup you could put the soup into a serving bowl and add water as much as you want into that ladling onto spice as I should mention is a problem because labeling from the creation onto spices is like Eerie creation lately at least until cliche that that would be like a cliche you look cooler if you have other let's not be makeup a hot cup as a ladle you could be saying because it's a cliche a spatula does not affect anything at all a Dover gush Retreat like a Cleary shine but if you have a different cooler ketchup or or anything else then you could say that it's two coolers you're allowed to be so add them up together so being only with an e-weekly reshone a ladle could only be used if it's on the fire and it's kept in the fire as we said but later them used a ladle soup flaky soup of course into a military Bowl the bowl needs sugar pot certainly in detection you took out a share it's a bug from a hot soup even agabio age but we have to assume Taco that even if you took it out the Ledo is like a clear reshine and that would affect the status of the later because of the sheriffs yesterday [Music]