The Do's And Don't's Of Seuda Shlishis - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

oh [Music] okay i'm sorry oh thank you [Music] attire seven one eight eight five one eight six five one or email ist receivernet.com we recently had interesting shiloh it was a it was a hotel for a convention for shabbos and you know they give a lot to eat and someone asked me right after minha he has no appetite for jealousy he could eat it he'll be have no eye makeup whatever i say he'll do so the question was should he exert himself and eat or like he told me i'd rather go learn and the truth is this is a game when people have a shabba shimh and they finish late or even during the summer when we have a longer afternoon but some people late afternoon they have a lavish ironic shabbos and they eat various foods and it comes to the shallow shooters i have no appetite so the question is is there any hat or is there maybe the thief is only when you enjoy the soda maybe if you don't enjoy it don't bother eating but as we'll see this touches upon many meiji you said this in the aloha of sudasha first of all is there a past can you ever use cake are any different men or women what's the earliest what's the latest time to eat so as we see there's a beautiful sugiya which really is the insight into what charles shoot is all about the gemara in shabbos curfew zion says now this is not a typical gemara that mar makes a statement here tomorrow has a question and answer format which needs a hezbollah but how many sugars you thrive to eat chalice and the more marshall the pasta we just laying yesterday in paris allah it says three times hayyoim so therefore you have to have three sudhisan shabbas and this is why there are sheathes that hold that suit the three pseudos on shabbos are their iso it's based on apostate three high items but more importantly for us there's absolutely no difference in the third suit and the first two it's the same hyeong for the third like the first and second and there's also gamora and broca's mem test them at meiji look at isis the mosquito boy that's bearish that based on the plastic on the gomorrah there's no hill at third or first and second however the next blood and shab is kurfurkes we get a mixed message that needs to be students on jobs what's the big deal don't we all you know you don't say i would love to be from a tv lager everybody wears to film you know you say i would love to be a baby or show your meat no okay i could understand because not everybody does it but i want to have a hey look at eating three pseudos more so the mauro says said tasty league i want to get special skar because i had all three pseudosanchabas so twice this in bahrain is that beijing bays picks up on this and toys's quotes were being utam now please remember when the time is a very main part of today's show we have a beautiful ishita but rebel time says from this gemara in shabbos it's clear that people will not niza in having the three sudas tasty li is some type of extraordinary madriga okay so please note towards the menu time but what's really perplexing is what's going on here zion it's mashima to their iso all three pseudos coffee and people didn't do it are you talking people didn't know what they had to do so if you look at toys simpson kofalev twices introduces a new option which we'll soon see is either cake or meat and fish or maybe paris but to tois is it's possible that if targhima helps if there's no past it's only by sudesh leashes but not by the first two sudis which are the ikka covered shabbos so twices is the first to my knowledge that makes it different in the third suit and the first two that maybe you could be outside the the third suda with targhima which is cake or other options and it's important to mention menu tom is quoted in a few places that also said this that cake doesn't work for the first two pseudos but maybe for the third suit but the question is where do they get this comic from the gemara learns in the past three high youngs there's no difference first or third so here we come to an extremely important aside and that is that really in aloha all agree there's no difference first second or third but the third pseudo is at risk especially during the winter because after you have a big southern shabbos by day you have no appetite to eat and sometimes a person is worried maybe i'm talking about achilles now that's a very bad thing to do do you know that the ramen rav and simmon tough i involved says if a person eats afraid he's not yo to the mitzvah but a bigger dish based on a gemara in chicago the person ate until the last moment of him kippah and then he came him kippah a strange person he ate more if it's an achilles of course uh there's a lot to say how far we have to stay away from but suffice to say what the rambam says in today's dollar judge that most highland most sicknesses come from from aruba you know it's interesting that the ramen was happened to our times someone showed me a study that the second most preventable cause of death in america is overeating could you imagine a person eats like a palm said once he digs his grave with his own teeth he eats too much and the ramen said it a long time ago grave of the sicknesses come from overeating the slaw says the person that eats too much dive on three sued him but to this kashville we don't have to stress that but the question now is for someone that ate too much by the day now maybe shall shoot this not if a person ate shallow shoot this animal he wasted his time he's not yet so the question is so what's the guidelines when is it when is it just that uh and no appetite so listen to our being second verb is in nazir so what does that mean tom says there are two achilles gases the first is nafshay kotzbakhila he finds it repulsive he cannot eat how do you do it okay akashev but he does that's not an achilles not rafikomin not not for sue the species but for hawkers he doesn't have an appetite but you tell him eat he could eat he's not repulsive but he has no appetite zombie time that second level is not a hilagasa what then is it it just he has no appetite so now we see this second rabbe new time that there are two levels a hilagasa is no mitzvah at all it's an abaya in fact but someone has no appetite it's an achilles but he has no appetite our question the person said i could eat but i have no appetite what should we tell them eat who said you have to have oinig and the mahabhara the girl of aleph is no don't force yourself because that might be achilles but then says if you could eat you could be mikayam the mitzvah so evidently the fact that he has no appetite is not a hetero he still has the mitzvah in the of of sudashabs and if you look in rage paid festive base the machab again says if someone finds the eating to be hesic don't eat but our question he has no appetite to eat so eat anyhow but here comes the last piece of the puzzle the third ebay new town listen to this beautiful ishita the r zero one of the shining bays says the following in the name of tom if someone he has a suit to eat like a swedish leashes and he's not hungry then he doesn't have to eat chalice sugars because the reason why we eat is also oine egg and it's not ironic that when he was afraid that he didn't enjoy the southern chalices he wouldn't eat what did he do listen to this he would take mini tagima cake or other sweets will soon see and traces in brackets mantes amid base also called chabenutam that sometimes use cake as an option so symbol after him what we said from the surgery that if you have no appetite to eat you behave to eat that's the two places no doubt about it but himself said that there's no ioniq he didn't each other sugars now why is cake better because for cake a person has an appetite [Applause] that's the shot really there's a fear of te3 because he was a very wealthy person he was a hustler in the seer and he had a big suitor and he could have eaten the suit of hashem but he was focused he ate minimally and saved room for shallow sugars so he got scar for me and not overeating what we do see according to bennutam if you have no appetite then your partner shall issue this and i was thinking there's another beautiful ishita say the or zerua that has taught and raised i endowed at the end quotes his er zerua that says maybe that's the reason why we don't make abraham you make a broken heavy mitzvah but then again a person might make a bracha on the third suit and not enjoy it then he has no mitzvah so it's about all right listen to this it's very possible there's another shot and this makes all the revenue times that if you don't enjoy it that says people didn't eat swedish leashes why because they had winter bus rice they had big island shabbos during the summer and they came to the sudesh leash as i'm stuffed so it's possible during the timeless acknowledged many didn't eat shallow shooters and that i saw in the in the shade but i want to add even more so since are being with time held if you have no appetite you're not you eat so the same way banana times are going to have an answer for you eat something that you will enjoy because you have no appetite to eat challah but a good piece of cake you could manage so the point is that the double kiddish is all the rebel timeless the ms there's no difference third or first suda the thieve is passing all three pseudos but if you can't eat what should you do you shouldn't have came to this situation but you can't eat so by the time improvised try cake and the embassy is what i'm telling you is not my fitness it's a fairy shikamura you know you probably have it with your children or grandchildren you say yo have some delicious delicious broccoli and the child says broccoli oh i'm full it's a free lagasse okay good a minute later you bring out dessert and he wants doubles so i thought you're full so the child there's a little child the grace of bakade says i have a special compartment in my stomach for dessert right it's not your kriedish tagamore in megillah that that's not long ago there's a special room for sweet things and don't think this is just bruce where's if he ate sweet foods he is over because even if he's told about kilagasa there's room for sweets so i was thinking what a beautiful urbana thomas holds that there's no oyonig many people chose not to eat soda species that's what made it but he gave an eighth he gave the eight sir that i told you that racism brokers and other places if you eat a sweet food and you'll enjoy it so you have the mitzvah you don't have the the optima mitzvah because you don't eat pasta but at least you could eat swedish leashes but this is not the person said i'll what every time i do i'll do i could wash and bench it's not a gossip but i have no i have no appetite so according to maine with tom tucker don't bother but the mahabharata says twice even without an appetite eat as long as so i told the person is try to get a sweet hollow try if you like matzah better or i told them it's not it's not a hay mache it's a but it's a good answer take some peanut butter and jelly put it on to your challah and then you then it's sweet you'll enjoy it so at least you have you you're using the eights of gamora but of course the best ether would be and don't overeat but the point is that this that cake works is only a pseudo-species and only because there's no other choice now i saw rafas someone asked him an interesting shirt he ate in kiddish kedusha rabba then he came home and had a suit of shabbos so he decided he has no appetite to eat but i thought he was for sure he said you know what i'm gonna do i'm gonna have three sodas friday night one sudam kedusha rabbah chennai mall is a sudah and then my destinations so wasn't this doesn't work if if cake does work like rebecca it's only the third suda and bosnia says the finish is really a taster he says it says three times a year well it gives you the right to say that that there's a cake is good for even the third suit so must be that the third pseudo is to show cover chapters every shabbos every day i have to sue this shabbos i have to show cover chapters and that's the third suitor so maybe you're being a time held the invite it's only to show coverage cake is also enough you're doing something special but you can't be yates uh the second suitor with cake the point only is that me din i'll quote that you have to have three sue the surpass if someone was not living and he came the third suit i have no appetite try to find an appetite and you can't but the average cake is acceptable but it's not the right thing targema the basic american based on the basic is of course that the best thing is to have missionaries products especially cake is a suffolk pass it's even better if you can't handle cake busted the dog him or minimally like some sheep there's even fruit but the aside at dover is the starting point is what people think i shall sue this man it's not true no one says that even tom that ate cake was only because if he could need pass so the best is to avoid even level number two of no appetite you know it's interesting there's a there's a heinous developed a good word that we call the third pseudo solei sudais that's wrong the gemara speaks about you have to eat three so there's all three but why do we call shabbos the afternoon through the shallow shoot this is one sooner but you know it's a bigger player the mahabharata speaks about the first two sudahs and rayshadgalap is our indian of sudasha you know what he calls it it's not true it's actually this so the belt says of art and bamas says it that the first suit though he says the cover chambers are fleeting the himalayan fine mask second pseudo the cover chambers come the third suit that i can't look at food what happened parents may be the first to suit of a cover to bike pardon me it's not nice but it might be true so where do you see them afraid that the three soudis wore the covered shabbos if he lives with the freshman and the third suit is also kidasakudin in how authentic the first two this all but this we could live with the bin yo that's the ben yard and the first part of the safer on on our shabbos clifford zion he won this one every gemara says why this gemara says calm the because if you don't have all three you're not you see any how much the mars is very literal three you only ate two and the third one you you could look at food you're not you ate to any i hope we don't pass them like this but it reads more very nicely but you know it's interesting let's be more positive you know it was so inspiring six months ago we had to come out we had the er pace of basabas and people woke up early and they they they struggled to have to sue this in the morning and people walked around the block it looked like a like a walkathon everybody's walking around even though as we'll soon see to eat before katsuri's like most sheep is not even yourself so why are people going so to the extent of eating two suitors or past era peso for one cheetah no it comes a regular shabbos the winter shabbos it's taka and the soya but do it right for logistics i could prove it to you this is lotion that the third suit is the icker how do i know yesterday makes so many reasons not to have third suitor but the embassy abuja ham one of them was showing him in ahmed ray shah from the new prince he has a whole different outlook and he says the three suitors have to train ourselves to eat properly because you have to eat friday night okay shabbos day you have to eat a big souther and same one for sodas so you're eating with control and he says therefore you're working on the the vicious yates even on shabbos and that will certainly help during the week is one of the rashing i'm talking that the three soothers are there to give us a sense of control so the mice we have to say that is unthinkable let's not talk about it but yes if someone says i have no appetite to eat suede so we'd say either kabaya will soon see that's the minimum and that's the best thing if he can't do that either then tagima cake but it shouldn't be holding that that in that situation the person should eat with a husband appreciate the three soothes and leave room for to have the third sue the latte of them moving on to the next group of questions and that is the question about notion because you know for men you have to go to school so you're up anyhow but women they fall asleep after the pseudo wake me up for abdullah you know but we have to wake up for shallow southeast so the embassies in pastures there's no difference men are women first of all the possible is men and no different men and women but bainu tam and seyfa yoshi says women are higher than three suitors like them on the most simple shot is ah says for that reason alone women are higher than the three sodas and keeping shabbos and kiddish and three suitors and in because all shabbos men and women are equal and tells us so it's as positive as can be three reasons that women are higher like men i will say some women don't so it's a good question asked this question and he says the answer is notify them that they have not much of a hater that's so it's an opportunity i guess the best is do as i do if parents show devotion to the third suitor do as i do is better than do as i say so but definitely there's no difference men are women regarding the third pseudo now the sometimes the women have a problem we don't have lucha mishna so first of all the makhabas says and also in but if they don't have it so if you don't have it it's only a mile i should mention if a person doesn't have lucha mishna by sudhish is another tattoo makeup the shivali allequite one of the washington sim inside the gimbal he says according his brother that could be there's no uh by the third suit even for men because think about it why do we have that because the one fell double so tiny she bought elected's brother friday friday morning they had one of the friday night they had three left shabbos day they had two left left mishna and came the third sudah they only had one so they didn't have lachemist why should i and he always does no of course the obvious problem with this reasoning is we don't do like they did by each suitor but right we don't have three legends friday night the turret says we learn from the month that a sooner needs to so there's no difference during suda or first suit and that's why the mahabharata says in the end of race in invasive of dalit sorak left soya kick race even for the third suit okay a question i'd like you to think about because it's nigeria let's say a person a man or woman they come to a sudden species there's only one bill killer left the shaolin so this is said it might be kadai before you make a moity to break the shalom in half and make the moity on two pieces of khala at least you have primarily means double two pieces is double are you giving up the mile of solar and regarding ibrahim that's a maya but is based on apostate and i've been mr mayshevdova then it's says no doubt about it if a person comes home or insures only bro small piece of khala nach layman pick up two the only thing is if you have a left ham in front of you to break it maybe it's wrong which gravity is absent is right but no doubt about it if there's no slayman take too slow the main thing is to have a double dummy so certainly there's no reason to say that i don't have i cannot show us to this it's not mark of the holiday is something it's not needed but definitely two broken pieces has much of the significance of lehigh the next question is what's the minimum amount to eat to be it's the sudesh shabbos primarily of course suda species now the real question is someone that's full but he can manage someone that's uh doesn't have a tolerance to wheat he could eat a little bit but tell me the exact minimum no more so the embassy is regarding all mitzvas akhira with the gosias so maybe we'll say sue the shabbos also a person that's allergic either cause is a person that's full eaters and there are we shine them the rav and sifal that brings we shine him that he is so that's very very positive this is not a mitzvah this is a pseudo akazai is not a pseudonym it might be akira akabaya is resembles sphere now the real sphere of account of the savarta is much more but minimally the the price can say that akazai is not a suitable aliyah magnum says plus has a pseudo dimension to it with them with the causalis so that's different because somehow that immunity with the case of the island it's just to give some divers but in sudha shabbis don't forget the mecca holds lester yeah says quebec plus to give it clears now the embassy is there's another reason that a person should have a kebaya by every suitor because if he'll tell you don't make a broken piece of diamond unless you have a cabellian so people impulsively wash make a bracha they're not eating kabaya then you shouldn't make a bracha so the mice that's why it's more than just advisable now unfortunately this is miguel more than we'd like it to be not only shall i show this friday night in the land of affluence is so much to eat people nibble like you know like like the birds on parsley a little piece they don't have a kazayas with achilles you have a problem with benching with eating without a broccoli shine on the foods minimally you have to have a cause and we try to have a cabella but at least the kazarus so it's definitely advisable i can't say it's aloha but after you wash make sure you have a conveyor pass and then you're ready for the rest of the suit now i want to make a point that a kebaya is not that much let me tell this to you very clearly go home today take a a extra large egg and that amount is more than a cabella how do i know a kebaya is the size of an egg but it says so moisture in america there are five great eggs small medium large extra large and jumbo so a bay of bananas is large not extra large according so a large egg without the shell is enough okay so mr murray says bigly pasta fine so take an extra large egg visualize that and you'll realize that a half of a small builder is dive high sick obeying the big bill cause i think i mean you have plenty but the smallest builder half of it is enough probably even less but a half of a a small bill clear is a cabell so what's so hard not we we confuse shabbos with pay stuff you have to eat a yamaha because asim so you get nervous but again a half umbilical if not less is a kebaya if you don't not a messiah visualize a a large chicken egg that's all you need moving on the mice i should mention if someone will ask me i'm allergic i can't tolerate wheat but i'll eat tell me the minimum amount so i would have to tell them somehow because i said enough doesn't say that but if you have no answer because it might be enough going to some sheets but if you do that don't make it into the diamond when you wash the next group of questions is the time to have charlotte sodas before and everything in between someone asked me he wants to go to the hospital to visit and it worked out there's a minion from indra but there's no shallowest in the hospitals he wants to eat before he leaves before minha or before hatsais the kitsam what is this for the suit so the emma says we would say why should it be as man it's based on the plastic three high joints eat three sodas so you have to have night day afternoon and a little of a riot not much but a little variety it could be there more says and see if olive if a person was sick friday night and couldn't eat shad this morning he has to have two pseudos three altogether so you see you could have the nights through the by day so why can i have the the afternoon through the before khashoi what's wrong and the embassy is there are restraining the rajva and iran that say beferish that if the ikea's three sued the sachako eat it at your convenience however from the command shabbos the in the afternoon before medium challenges we have eaten before in the afternoon if you eat it beforehand cinnamon that you have that you can't be your eights if you have inshallah is before kha toys the magan mystery points to others that argue so we have a macho it's joining if you had to sell a sugars before it's even with now what's the tackler the higher three suit is that we sue this what do you care when i eat it so in mostavra it's three different parts of the day the levush points out maybe it has to do with the davening knights [Music] so it pushes it means to break it up like the davening but i was thinking maybe this is another golden orbit of timeless tossing but tom was worried more than the rest of us that you're not going to have that appetite for the sudden swishes you can have beforehand that says you have to have an appetite he and sister don't eat beforehand because again this show this is at risk that's what's the most problem but i must tell you that according to the past like mostly showing him if you had childhood before actually half hour after now i we said if you missed the night soon you've got to have it by day there's this that's not the din that's a touch lumen if you miss myra if you dive in two chakras right that's i may have is not time with chakras testument is different and that's tucker why i should mention the character in a regis he says you can't be it's eating the night soother by day unless it's an ionis gumball because it's the wrong time and if a person didn't feel went to sleep woke up the next morning what should he do but it's not an eight so unless it's an on his gum so you can't ask me from tash lumen to ikeda stresses this that if you ate before six and eight hours otherwise so now we have a problem a few months ago we had our places and we ate the third suta quite early and the embassies like the russian the chuvas khaf bay's ballad he says don't forget to eat shall i shoot this in the afternoon have mini tai gima he doesn't mention our eights so why are we eating especially it was difficult the any time i told you earlier some say it's any three ions so try to do the best you can but that's not sufficient because and then in the afternoon we have tagima but no one should today that if you didn't i know someone didn't wash twice you know he's he i can't believe him like most you know and you have great sabbath they said he told agent he can't wash twice in a short erapist he's afraid they wouldn't bench properly you know the eating was okay the benching was the problem you know as i eat and the emphasis is the grains that we're close to going to to chaparra in the first suda early in the early three years to some is but again in this it doesn't exist adds basically this is the the decide that could be there is no one because it's not you can't have pastas too early and later is only tagima so as we said the police can say try to do the best you can but if someone missed it or someone can do it it's there's an eight set they have tagging in the afternoon the next question is so the embassy is it certainly sounds good night morning that sounds great but the question is is it the rama in sieve bay's quoting verbeno tam grande another veil of time but that is not part of al-shitasai but it grows a bit of time that's the taste in the rush quote and the time was very worried about drinking water shabbos after ski until nightfall now this is inch and we spoke about this once many people are mocked bit mom-ish not to drink water some people never heard of it but that's a difference here i'm not going to get into that now but in the rush quarterback the time was marketed not to drink water from ski until after abdullah and therefore when the time insisted you should have shallow sodis before so you can drink all the water you want and you won't get involved with svegas in sakana and there are more in steve bay's ray charles quotes this time so no one could say it's it's knowledge you're not supposed to have a pseudo before minecraft so why are you watching before minha now ebay tom held obviously a suzuki katana you like to have before is my mantra insha'allah typically is a suda katana no problem but the end of the day the rambam islamic simon the rambam passkins and zakhtar goes miami this is based on the gemara and also because of the not to become sued he says also to have the su the after the davening and see if dalit difficult about you could eat before minh who quotes kabbalah says but if you can't do it eat before min now what if you can't do it so i told you someone asked me he has to go to a hospital mitsubika highland but he won't have show shooters there so he shouldn't eat they have the min but no sugars so esque isn't paid at home or someone has a wonderful share between min and he said i can't miss i can miss my should i eat before i come to minha the answer is yes tire is tired yeah you yikes or a question where someone's out of town and you don't have minyana all over the place the minha is far from his house there's no sugars and what should he do eat before minh of course if someone is very mocked but to wash early after close to ski and he missed his regular minion and he died by time he finished the darkening it's going to be too late for him to wash so again we tell them so if you remember many people have a sudden and then they have pseudospecies let's say you missed but no more than a hit what's a very challenging question is what's the latest time for sushi now before katsura's we did after we did let's say it's late so here we have to be respectful for clay israel and you have to realize that a big part of klayswell always washed late or better their sheet is it's too late so do we say whoa din if you don't watch if this if you don't have this gear you don't watch you have to skip so passes will say make sense if it's too late for minecraft it's too late for the however there is a big mockum as early as the mishna bureau ray sadiq tests aleph yes he says and he says he could even eat even if you had a child he'd be hungry but listen to this unless it got so late that it's a half hour before delilah you should have been sorry the same mister he said you could wash so late the byron said you can wash up to not 15. 550 minutes after ski the standoff and base raised gimbal quotes the best grub saying his father abhayam washed for child suits they have to ski now what's going on here the test was always very much with minha he says you could also wash same half hour before night so you think about this is so it's too late because my day it's just it's not your wrong time is totally in charges so what do you care if it's a night we have friday night soon at night so the whole question is who cares if it's night as long as it's now if you're talking you're watching during the it's too late but a half hour we have to share it's vader shabbos but yes should be observed you ever wonder you know we have to make sure we have 100 brokers on shabbos because we have a deficit we don't have the launch of an asterisk the benching that i benched by a regular shell shoe that's already after this man what is that counter to it they may have broken that shabbos or sunday it's already 20 minutes after this man parrot says most price can hold the shabbos of shabbos so that's why i want to be very clear if you're many guys like the khazanesh and the girl to watch if you're many kids to watch after your mind like the vedic time if someone asked me i i don't have much of a minute i've been delayed should i wash now it's 20 minutes after this kia i'll just echo what mr brewer says up to a half hour before it says squash the baron said 50 minutes now you have to realize so with mr burger get a half hour before taste what's what's wrong about that that it has nothing to do with charlottesville once it's man abdullah so you have abdullah if it kicks in but the swedish leashes are not limited like min now of course i said circle inside the twelve points out in eritrea israel don't go with a half hour before before safe you know there's much less time in the in between i was i know of two goddardly israel they were giving shirum that by convention that i attended and it they were right before minh and it was time to get late and they started sending messages you know we're going to miss kia for washing so they both said so i'm not saying who but i'm just telling you it's something they could understand that the the side cooler here is not a type cooler it's the time as long as it's shabbos now the really challenging question i'll leave to the oil but let's say a person has five minutes left to decimate his saves man now i'm leaving that to you you can decide what you want you have five minutes until you can't have a min or wash your shoulder through this and you're not such a speed reader that you could do both what should you do min ho or the species and you can't think for too long because they only have four and a half minutes left so what would you do so we would say what's the how could you give up that's what i would say but you think about it as freshmen it's not possible because like most youth is rabona certainly minha is not at the right side shall shoot us like many is their eyes but how could you give a min so make sure you're on time but someone said if i ate i could do shiraba you know maybe i'll use that as my second then my sis my day suit as the third again it doesn't work unless you have das now what's possible if an issue is wakes up late and she has five minutes then for sure we tell her to have swedish speeches even if you all she's hivensville who said not necessarily but that's easier to deal with now someone asked me he the same person that he said yeah after that i'll learn instead okay so the truth is learning is wonderful i'm talking a coulomb but you can't learn instead of shaking lou love but he said i heard epis you could be i said with learning let me tell you about that episode so if it's good for him it's good for me he said right okay so first of all he's probably a step above you he was so much tyrodic that he didn't have to dive and there are some nasty so if he did it doesn't mean i could do at least i can do it that's number one number two the shlock cut is right he was by learning this but the main point he missed is quotes this in tough mem dalit why not enrage sabic aleph the terrorist says pashit because he only was yay to suspicious where there is no real good option takes goes to the extent to say that that shall shoot this on your patient is like oh wow he's right because there's nothing there's no greatest no so then sue the species works with tyra but how do we rely on a regular basis so that's why the raya from shimba israel has no shaikh to us we do mitzvahs we learn and of course this is interesting when it happens is always tricky you have to have a pseudo but yamtiv is coming or or er so most people finish the suit up or they break the suit up they bench and they come on absolutely now that satisfies all needs it's afternoon it's after minha and that's the best eights in now how however some people are marked with nothing i'm not gonna get into that now but that's uh yeah you know this this there's a point of of divening mind so what they do is they don't dab them in for early they have a sudden sleeves in the afternoon ah how could you eat before mincha there is especially arab yamtheva yamtiv it has to be a suda katana there's no problem so as always it's some people in fact bisman and have a small suede afterwards also i could understand that because the suede the last group of questions is the actual souza i'll play a few fascinating childhoods someone was by a southern species and he wanted to have a dessert in fact he wanted to make extra breakfast he took out an apple and a glaze of watermelon and chocolate you make three breakfast how can i make it eat now it's very late now that i eat after chase i started eating fine but now already it's the epithelia shabbos so i said that's a lot of euros for my but he made a mistake because when when we make a break on dessert it's not because it's a new souda you can't start a new southerner now it's not a new suit of a riot benching part of your dessert so why do you make a bracha because the past part is all meal thai foods that eat the savoyer dessert is not listed for you so you make a brachioishina but it's certainly part of the soda so if you buy you're adding everything else because you didn't bench you're allowed to eat the dessert i've probably found sternbc now if a person benches alakais by sudasha could he drink the coins if it already tastes like a problem so that's there's a discussion about it but the miniga island is not too once it's live that we don't drink from the coins buy a chevy brokers they do drink from the coins that's different hogging but a regular shabbos you bench but don't drink from the cars some got to do i want to be respectful but the minute is not to so why am i using a case so at home if you've entered the course and you see your camp you make up dollar on it so you'll end up drinking the curse someone asked them i should they never make half dollar they take out of course they bench put it back in in the wine battle it's literally from pesach to pace after he used the same river venus for benching so if you're not drinking what are you gaining but the voslin base says don't be mavato that many because so even if you don't drink it i can't say it's wasting your time but some people they don't drink it they don't use it but there's definitely a myeloma we had a question if someone did let's say by shadowbreakers he drank the curse and he says does he say does he mention shabbos so this is interesting because the suit is over and it's ready it says says dominic is not to say mention shabbos you you sort of f even though you didn't say may of yet but you finished the suda and it says and you do not make don't mention shabbos in the main challenge now i want to make another point we're talking about let's shoot this this will fast forward a few months to a summer chevy broncos and the khasana was sunday afternoon before shikiya so the last day of chevy broncos the last chevy rocket is by specialist so without getting into the detail the sacrament was very much bid that you can't make shuttle brokers after skier because it wants suffolk lilac upon him whenever whenever the ski is but when you get into suffolk lila i we started the early afternoon i was going to say would say and it's still shabbos so the hezbollah is it's still shabbos and you go by the suda but you have no husson the huston basically became back to civilian life because once his mind is he's overshadowed overcrossing so you're right you could suck a bench with say as late as you want but there's no hosting there's no hosting there's no chevy brokers okay someone make a little people have a lot of container shabbos but if you do things right you should try to bench before this man and then you can have the speeches and the dancing afterwards a person asked this question he said barak hamada during sudhistishas he had to do malachi and then he had to bench does he still say he would say that if he said that's enough of an abdullah that he can't say would say because that's passion if a person died in my room but then decided to bench if you got the bench you can't say it would say it's not shabbos that's passion leader the vermoisian the person just answered to a minion that's the express minion before he benched then they could say but say because it didn't and shabbat it was if a person that said could he continue eating maybe he really taught this so that's not foreign says it actually is a bigger federation they even that as long as he didn't yet have a myriad as long as he's still shabbos he can continue eating and the charity and his since he's that he could still continue eating recently i was away for shabbos and i'm going to ask you this question he was very rushed to leave after shabbat after this man so what he did was during charlottesville he was very creative he heard someone making abdullah so he ran he heard abdullah alakais he was joined to adulthood so he came back and he asked now first of all do i say would say can i continue eating and now that i said abdullah do i say attorney in my roof so it's all very simple first of all if you already heard abdallah you zuck against they would say because it's after shabbos could he continue eating so this is the kiddish it could very well be that why not he's still he it's basically i mean i don't know what his location is but the end of the day he heard of all the ready so why can he eat but you know the biggest pastas is that when he happens there's no doubt about it that he definitely says that aleph says the ferris gomorrah that you do both don't forget they we do both every massage shabbos we don't rely on one without the other the iketta kantes rum is the heart of the battle so even though he's holding post abdullah the last question is regarding should this about let's say so the emma says the heinous let's say is not that important that's absolutely incorrect let's make a judgment we have all them and three pseudos so if you left that would say the first is you have to re-bench so why not in the third suit and that's why the tour in the end of kofbejs says like most sheet is you have to have pass you have to bench over that that would say it's only been with time that holds you out with cake that you just topic so what would we say the mahabharata said that you have to eat three sodas and cake is not good enough who told you have to bench over the bach but in you should have to bench over because you don't need because you you ate bread and you didn't say you would say but since there's a sheet that you're not clear to have passed out suffolk brokers you don't say bench over so it's not the chat you don't have to say but say you know someone told me he was once very had a long shot at home he's very late he wanted to make my so he skipped would say on purpose i said that's wrong the best dates would be finished early and go to sue on time you can't skip but say but do you have it but the average you don't have to bench over but let's say a person forgot would say and he's holding he didn't start the brachava taiva native so here we come to an important you saw it basically if you left out the alveoli price can say by shall issue this is no difference if you cut before you started the fourth bracha say the bracha beshem um i you'll say but maybe there's no pass but it's not different but after this mom we go boston killer student it's not so positive but in this case don't air chamber malchus but listen to this happen someone told me hitaka forgot the second the second suit that he forgot to say would say and you know people have an aversion to bench they don't like the washer on the bench the bench the second time forget it she decided to make a cup he wanted to use the kadusa rabin shul that he did say would say in amen he used that for the second pseudo and the big suit in the house of the third sudah and he got the bench over because you left that would say in the second in in the third suit you'd have to bench over some distiple and kill yaki bro and and that's wrong you could only use cake in the third suta you can't use cake in the second suit though we have to bench over i couldn't talk to you english as i would like to thank robert smith for the wonderful share basically the change in the daily schedule tuesday we'll have the supposed to have a dying donor we didn't have a long time me and the champ this tuesday we have dying down and giving 1 30 we ask them to join soldiers and qualities are all over the world participating call each other at 718-851-8655 [Music] foreign the moon [Music] is