Haeitz Or Ha'adama? - A practical Guide - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

email isd dot com this week i learned once again that you didn't have a board we had a few shows in this broadcast which kept us busy and we think well maybe technology only is challenging simple jokes bro somebody asked about craisins of popular food today you heard things have changed the bra has changed papaya hearts of ponds things that are pretty common and indeed there was a lot of truth to what he said that maybe in recent years maybe the brock has changed and of course as we'll see many other questions but basically the shial of today is determining the the halacha when someone has a sufficient or adama how do you what does allah classify something as ates or adam but i must mention the same question also pertains to hilkaz arla is there orla on craisins or papaya or other palms it's aids there's olives that dumb but there's not is there an issa baltasquez you got to cut down a papaya tree if it doesn't have a dinner of a tree maybe it's muta to cut it down a third in africa mean a very significant which is not today's year but is the what bracha do you make when you smell a fragrant papaya if it's if i'm a tree it's a nice rare type of paris if it's not a tree would be a different brother so as you see we have quite a challenge for today but really the the crux of the issue is what is the allah definition of a better priority is it africa tree how about something grows on a bush blueberries grow in a bush how about somebody grows on vines cranberries grows on vines like grapes so hopefully once we have a definition of what the vaporia eight is we'll be able to apply it to many more questions in our minds maybe in our since we're children we have this idea that on fruits you make or ate and vegetables is abdominal and that's not true i mean we'll see but the avocado is a vegetable and the brock is definitely burpio eggs melons are considered fruits but melons that don't so basically we might be tempted to take the easy way out what do you have to spend so much time learning is based on a mishna if you make a a dharma on the eights but the evidence in fact the end of rage base recommends when you have a suffix make a dhamma so what's the shia la croix craisins or or all these different uh products just make adam but that's wrong points out right away you only can make a dharma if you have a real halachic suffolk but if you didn't learn that allah is go learn allah police can use a sharp term that's called a dash that you have a suffix you're just totally ignorant now we don't have to destroy them here but we have to learn that to know what is the exact definition of aids versus our dhamma and they will apply it to many shias so the macaroon of today's sugya is a short two lines in brachis of men with umar is talking nothing about his brokers per se but tomorrow says one sheet to hold that the eight saddas that adam sinned with was keita which is a kiddish is called the aids and in fact the amari s if that's the case you maybe should have to make appropriate on frito if you call it a tadas that it's considered eight so then the gemara says no regarding the bracha of eight and this is the most important line in here for today when do you make a burpier eight only the fish actually le perry east of the gaza of a hotel in other words typically trees grow but then comes the winter and the fruit either are picked or die zak tikimara but a halal tree even if the winter comes and there are no fruits but they still gave them most vegetables when the winter comes there's no the even the gabza dies and therefore that's considered a boy or priyadama so the key word here is the word gavison now what does gabza mean so the rush on this kimura in semenhoff gimble says basically that gabza is the root in other words we'll have to use an english word because we'll use a latte the word perennial means that you don't have to replant it typically most vegetables a mushroom tomato you plant and it grows we have to replant it the next season that's not perennial an apple tree is certainly perennial you know you go wait for the after the summer you come back the apple tree is uh going strong the gemara according to rush is saying if it grows year after year if it's perennial then it's a burpier aids something that's abdominal is because you have to replant it every year and assumingly the assumption is that eat them you have to replant very good this is also the sheath of the torn hour cinnamon raised gimmel that basically the philip is if you have to replant it or not the problem with this shot is that we have in three places in shasta quotes that the word gamza does not mean roots godzilla means the tree stung stump the trunk and therefore the going in that the torque quotes and it's a sheet of rashi as well that says no if the the fact is that if the roots remain it still could be a biopia doma in order for it to be a burpier eight not only has to be perennial and you have to be planted but during the winter the trees stump the trunk has to survive the winter and we'll soon see many examples but basically as the chuvas that goes saying the fact that you that you don't have to replant it does not make it or eight it has to be enough to replant it it's perennial and also part of the tree survives the winter now the rush probably held as long as it you don't have to be planted it's a very good hanok and brock has charisma but the going and seem to held that if you want to make a bear prior aids the tree has to survive the winter the fact that the roots survive and it it creates a new tree but that's not considered a tree if it dies winter to winter but the end of the day we have this fundamental machis what makes something creates according to the rush as long as the roots survive and it grows back next year it's a bird creates according to the gohanim and that's what's rashi seems to say even if the roots survive if the tree is dead and now next year a new tree grows with the old roots that would still be a berry piadama typically an apple most trees especially fruit trees not only do the roots survive but the tree survives you go back to your bungalow county you'll see the same apple tree that is herbal aids the big question is how do we pusk it and also what would be a good enough demeanor so the going in that i quoted earlier then gives a muscle it has to be that the root and the trunk survives says the gainer but hani musi this movie since the tree dies even though it's perennial and the roots survived it would be a bayer priyagama what is mooji in rage gimbal gimbal says so both the choice is bananas so now we see a beautiful nafkamina as we will soon see in detail but a banana tree is a tree it's 20 feet sometimes even 40 feet but at the end of the season the tree dies actually it's a hollow trunk and now it regrows from the same roots and according to the rush bananas be appropriate because it's perennial it regrows from the same roots but the grain and field the tree has to survive and the banana tree does not survive the winter the roots do and therefore it's a boire priyadam but your body said look again says on a banana you make kadama and doesn't mention other shita evidently the machaba like to go in him it's not enough to be a perennial fruit it has to also be that the trunk or the tree survives the winter but there's another riot at the macabre held like the going in and that's in c base of our simmon when he speaks about berries he says on berries the majapasi jamaica burpia dharma but says there are more that basically berries is adorable even though it grows on a pretty high bush but since the color eights of the gallery since the bush dies during the winter even though it's perennial and regrows on its own berries are a bayer piadama so we have two simon siphons pascal's like to go in him it's not enough to be perennial it has to be that the truck the tree itself survives now i am aware that paraguay says that ramo is misplaced should be unseat gimbal and chum but we still have two rayas that something is an adama unless not only the roots survive but the tree trunk itself survives the winter what i found beautiful is ravoisna the trouble hey that was him in cuffs regarding on papaya which we'll soon see but he says the beautiful you say that we have to will appreciate as we proceed and he says we learn from the gemara that the kimora are called by one shita hated to be an elon man so he says the terror it says when it comes to allah we don't look at what the baton is saying and what what the belt says there are certain halachic features that are deciding factors it could be a very high tree banana tree is 20 feet but a it could be a low bush that survives the winter it appropriates so he says decides aids or adam and again we might see some surprises but that's they said we have to hear so now that we see that the definition of a tree is it survives the winter not only the roots but the tree itself anything else adama let's apply this more specifically so i'll start with an interesting dish which is possible avocado in our mind is is a vegetable eaten in a salad but avocado the holidays is a pure berry priorates why plus it grows on a tree and that's why avocado is our if you eat it plain usually as a toefl to the bread so it's it's part of my broccoli but avocado is a clear cut of egg because it grows on a tree and certainly there's a lot on avocado because it's a biorepresent ago are connected because if you make a bird creates that means it's a a tree and therefore arla applies to it persimmon a sharon fruit is appropriate it grows on a tree a star fruit a quince all berry pre eggs the only question about a quince is if it's not edible raw so you have to prepare it kumquat is a clear cut by a priori and obviously in all of these cases if it's about pre-aids hilca's arlo is fully applicable a tomato or many vegetables for that matter basically the the plant does not survive the winter so even if you don't have to replant it even if it grows again but if the plant does not survive the winter these vegetables would be a boilerplate the tour does say a a vegetable that's not perennial that you have to [Music] actually replant it as well then all agree of course that is the regular butter pre-abdominal artichoke incidentally grows on a pretty a nice bush but the fact is that artichoke the the bush does not survive the winter and that will be italian out with shayla and allah artichokes is the boy priyadama now watermelon all melons cantaloupe honeydew etc but for them they're really fruits but since they don't grow on a tree it would be pretty dangerous if a watermelon grows on a tree the fall down hurts somebody but it doesn't grow on a tree and therefore that's a clear-cut biopia dumber for a different reason it's not a bar periods simply nuts all nuts actually are very pure eggs that has been pushed all nuts grow on a tree the notable exception peanuts peanuts is basic a legume that's why peanuts on on pasta resources kidneys so really peanuts is not enough i once said it you know there are two nuts that are not a bird preheats peanuts and donuts and it's a very nice lumber to that joe because just like a donut is not a nut peanut's also not nut doesn't grow on a tree so all nuts are eight except of course for peanuts and doughnuts what's interesting is there's a little of a tom on the toy skin if cashew is really burpier eight even though it grows on a tree but actually the cashew tree there's a the primary fruit is not the cashew it's a different fruit that's not eaten as much but they are let's see and then bola but says that basically since the cashew even though the other fruit is bigger but the cashew is the icker of that that tree and therefore cashew is still is a boilerplate another fruit i want to mention because i touched upon a lot of how you say this is the what's called the sabra or a cactus prickly pier now the mathias we have to know a little you know before we talk any about any show we have to know them but see us i want to be making toys to assay from midair illinois that provide a lot of information that i desperately needed but basically the sabre as it's called or the prickly pear grows on a spiky cactus which is not a typical tree there are no leaves but lameisa it does survive the winter and therefore the higher the barakah on a sabra a prickly pear is by april 8 and there would be hillhaus aurora now the truth is there is a sheet of choices in our more broken that says only on a tree do we say burpier eight ana a todd which is a very well fit for the this cactus is a burpie abdomen but most boys can reject that they have a dust and base cavaliers therefore we pass again not like twice that even a cactus is considered a tree and the broccoli is beautiful and is orlan now the truth is some cactus grow wildly and we know the sugar says enraged gimbal dollar than hay that whatever grows wildly the brook is not our aids it's a shackle but the ta's ready and safe cut an olive regarding berries he says it's not exercise whatever grows wildly is a shackle it's whatever grows wildly and is not as tasty as other fruit it's not as developed as other fruit it's not exactly wildly versus planted it's a fully developed fruit but typically wild fruits like crab apples are not edible as apples but he says the ferris if you have a wild fruit that is edible it's definitely about creates and the sabra is edible it's a eight and the allah apply as well i saw already as early as the berkeley yosef enraged he writes very cryptically mysteriously that it's recovering that you make hadamard on the sabbath because it's made legendary i first thought it was surprising get this it would sound like a muslim it's a gathering but he doesn't mean that and i did a little research and i'll quote again what i saw that this cactus these these um the actual cats of the sabra were used as a feed source for cattle and as a boundary fence and listen to the initiatives the truth is that you could save a lot of money by instead of putting up a fence you just grow cactus that keeps the animals in because the cattle don't want to get cut from the thorns of the cactus so it's very very economic way of making defense keep them inside but more than that the cactus fruit that the the sabra has more nutrition than any other cattle plus the fact that it's it has so much water content if they eat these if the cattle eat these cyber they don't have to be watered so you have three monetary benefits in having cactus grown as fences no any shallow i guess they always have to find ways of being economical they grew the cactus as a fence and also as cattle feed so maybe that was the mini event but today it's definitely a big industry and taco the hindi kapoor ice cream say that today it's grown as a fruit and it's back to bur pre-aids and of course hilhais arla are fully applicable now today i noticed they're selling coconut chips that's flavored now coconut definitely grows on a tree the only point that the place can do say that typically coconut is grown for its oil so it's really just an ingredient but not ate the coconut but today it's fully edible it's a snack and indeed the broccoli is boiling prior eight a little of an issue maybe a little more than a little of an issue you remember today grad is a little different but they used to make the macaroons on pesa that a big part of it were the coconut so does that mean on a macro you make your bur prior eights but the paiskims say that really the coconut is only an ingredient it's not there and it's also ground up to smaller pieces so it's basically bottle so no a macaroon is not a boilerplate but if you have plain coconut chips avada if it's the fact that it's eaten today and it would be a boy or a pre or eight the next question brings us to a very bigger soy and that is basically the brach on a banana is it a eight or a dome so again before we go to allah we have to know the matias banana i quote is a large plant it measures six to fifteen feet i've seen it could even be up to 20 to 40 feet in fact but basically the trunk is not a typical tree and i saw pictures it's amazing it's really compacted leaves that that grow wrapped around each other and you look inside a banana tree leave the the trunk of it it looks like an onion it's layers of leaves but it's not a real trunk in fact the scent is hollow now really this the banana is classified as a giant herb but not even a tree and the banana is considered a giant berry in other words it's not your typical apple or orange it's not a real fruit it's not a real tree but what's most important it's the banana is classified as ammonia carpet now in simple english it doesn't survive the winter the fact that it's really not a tree the huge banana tree up to 20 maybe even 40 feet dies during the winter but it is a basically it does regrow from the same roots and therefore bananas is a perfect nafcamina the macholic is the rush and the garnier light the rush since it's perennial you have to be planted it's about pure eight light the gaining the fact that the tree dies is a biopriyadama and now you understand why the granules marshall was musi mujai which is a banana the question is so is that mean that it's a vadama we totally reject the rush or maybe it's just that it's a suffolk so the mordecai seems to say that because don't forget like the rush is about to preach specifically in the end of steve memphis sim and memphis if someone video made a mistake and made a burpier eight on a banana he would be your it's a biddy of it because according to the rush that's the right brother you can't repeat the break like the russians in other words the so he says assuming that the bracham banana is sufficient so according to this i will tell you a very interesting is that i saw in two high tickets forum let this person has a potato coogle and he's not sure if the pieces are really ground finally and it's a shackle or a dumb he's not sure what brock would make on the kuggle so people typically reach for that banana make a dumb on the banana and we might see the kubo not so passionate because you're going from one selfie to the other like the way it's a suffocation or aids or maybe more so it says hey let's see a person has an eight's an apple and a banana so he wants to make eight it's an adult but if he makes the eights on the apple according to the rush he's he adds to the banana also because it's an eight so although you can make a eight on an apple and then the bananas you have a mine you make the eights i don't want to include the banana and the swara the responsible because it is still a suffolk 8 but the point is that what they're saying is that this would be a sophic a toradoma but what's really surprising that according to this it comes out that on bananas we have to treat it as arla for the first three years if it's a suffocates even though it's only a suffix but understandably says narrative that all the rights of bismarck suffered however from the stimulus of surgery that says mom is just a few words on bananas you make a dhamma he doesn't mention the rosh hashita led many him to say that a banana is a vada hadama because allah is bad they like to go in them and not like the rush the kayode and aleph tess and mr brewer enraged wolves if cotton bays says jamaica or eight on something like banana which the macholic is rush and but even with the ebed with the boy creates on that suffix evidently due we can like to go on him and it's not a suffolk a toradoma so the follows the rav and the raf takis says the pharaoh say the birth oh so then you're right if you made her aids but the effort he hates them but says the earl let's see it in memphis test that if it would be a suffic then how could you not take arlo it would be a suffic then the stronghold should mention something and therefore he says that it's avaday bananas biopriatama and if you made her aids you have to repeat the program rabbi yoshida is quoted as saying that bananas is a adama mitara's vadai and it's not even a suffolk so this is relieving i mean the fact is that bananas is recite but as we will soon see the fact is bananas give off fruit the very first year and i will soon see the place can say that typically if an a fruit tree never gets fruits the first year so that isn't in the case that it's not really a tree plus the fact is that it's a hollow trunk and most fruit trees every year is most of the high left the fruit gets better and better quality a banana is just the opposite it deteriorates me yet the year and that's probably why the boys can assume that a banana is better as vada a boya priyadama and as the playskim do say the fearish we don't have any questions that we do not keep us older for bananas had it been a suffolk you would have to make yeah you'd have to keep healing all of the bananas so we see two allah is that a banana is a vada and we're not quite just for all the even inertistrol so this would be relieving if taka like this conclusion if you have a suffix you have to make a break on your coogle you could grab a banana because the banana is a bad day okay maybe you'll say but then again i saw other players called to suffolk i'll take a baby but it's we see that it's really halacha is very much related impact hill the next question is a much easier question and that is the halacha on pineapple so again the pineapple is and i quote a perennial plant growing approximately three feet it's not like the banana that's 20 feet this is a three feet but the the uniqueness of a banana of a pineapple i wish i had a picture to show it to you but it's something unusual it's a plant again about three feet and the pineapple grows from on top of the plant i mean as it's growing out of a plant it looks beautiful looks like it looks like it's a pineapple on a stand but it's a plant that grows and the pineapple starts to grow bigger and bigger so basically the plant does not survive the winter so even though it's perennial the roots do but the plant doesn't but what's therefore la la tuber piadama but there's another interesting factor because the planters have it's a majority in the planters let's see it listen to this because if you use the same plant for the second year it will regrow a little faster because you have the same the same roots but the problem is that it won't it will only grow to 60 percent of its typical size so you're losing a lot of the pineapple if you cut it down and replant it then it grows a full height it folds the full size of the pineapple but it takes six to nine months longer so some planters don't mind having a smaller pineapple that tac interestingly enough they don't have to replant but the other pineapples literally their mom is replanted so that's why another slur that pineapples has another white it's a real hadam even light to rush if it's replanted so it only has only grows once it's not even perennial but at the end of the day pineapple is the minute it's adama and also for aurora regarding pineapples lately someone wrote a stickle toyota that maybe pineapples should change but it wasn't the scabba by the poison a more challenging question is papaya now papaya looks and really is treated as a fruit but it has a very unique feature to it and i quote again it's a tree that reaches the height of up to 30 feet i mean that's a tree okay the stem resembles a real trunk the stem is hollow very large leaves the leaves are two and a half feet each leaf i mean an unusual combination the papaya grows from the trunk itself typically a a fruit grows from a branch there are no branches it grows in the trunk itself and only the top of the papaya tree the papaya tree with his sick 30 feet height lasts for six years sometimes three but it could be less than six years and the only real problem with the papaya fruit is because it's unable to sustain the weight of it because after a while it gets too weak and it topples over and then it falls out with the roots against has to be uprooted but if you notice i gave you a lot of information because unlike a banana a papaya is a real tree hollow it is okay but it's not just leaves that wrapped around and indeed ravosna and the ozni both say that papaya has to be treated as orla because it's a regular tree feet last for six years however there are those that are mako regarding the papaya for a different reason and that is papaya as we said last between three or six years it's interesting because a typical fruit only produces fruit after after the first year the second year but this papaya is gives food right away now to us you wonder is that a myeloma if i can't get a lot of it gives fruit but it is a myelin but the question is i told you for my balls and the question is is it a fruit or not and a fruit doesn't give right away so even though it's a bigger myeloid but doesn't have the characteristics of a fruit tree plus it's a hollow trunk which is not typical of a fruit tree plus the quality of the papaya as years go on is poisonous and that's why the rav paalam and that's the benefits someone wrote him in our city the minigames you make appropriate on the papaya because he says that's what we did and no one told us differently so he writes a little sharply he says don't bring a writer from your minute because your minute was khasara yadiya but look again at what you just said he says listen you told me to make a burp for your eggs because it grows on a tree that lasts three years that it grows and it lasts for three years and it's a tree making for a p8 it should be arlo and if it's erla it's also the first three years so how did you eat it so how do you eat it that make it burp relates so it's up there so why taka isn't it a burp reads he says because the mice it's mighty paris the first year unlike other fruits number two it only grows on the top of the tree not a regular tree and he says basically it's poisonous it's a hollow trunk and he says i'm comfortable to say that it's a regular boya priyadoma and there's no orlan and he's taking a tremendous tremendous substance he says anybody says definitely was a pessy you can't make a burpee eggs and eat it that's a steering wheel obey now he does add that someone came to me as a post script and he told me that he planted papaya on sukkas and by other it was already edible aha you see it's not a burpio aids and it's a hollow trunk so the ralph paulin with great confidence says it's a burpee adama and it's no aurora and tucker many hindi kapoor skin say a papaya the broccoli is burpi adam now the myself it's amazing and robustness definition is so vital it's a high tree of 30 feet and it has a typical feature of a tree that from the outside it's a tree not like a banana that's that leaves but if it but it lacks the basic characteristics of a tree even though the tree survives the winter but the fact that it's hollow and it bears fruit the first year and it's poisonous makes it so much a burpie i can't say all agree rabbi yahshua was quoted as saying that me suffolk you can't negate the fact that some say it's a tree so he says an interesting combination you'll make an adam on papaya but you have to be hoises for all of them also argues emphatically that it's taka or allah he says but he says he says i could understand that someone treats it like a priyadoma but his feeling is it's an it's a it's definitely a real key of orla that impacts papaya and he says regarding an abstract fruit that only gives up pears for three years so such a fruit can't be high even harlow because it can be the ancestor they have to have the das toilet of the head of krash to make the statement but you tell her that the terror cannot say that a fruit that grows is always awesome you have an apple tree the first because it's parlov wonderful the rest of it is makes this statement with this tremendous dashboard that it can't be so if indeed the papaya only grows three years we have another reason why you'd understand it's not limited by hilca's orolo but the maison we're going to leave her allah for her to swell and poison but i think what to me was amazing himself quoted in the in the safe in um that he heard that on papaya make a boy priya now you understand that it's a vaday orla but al suffic you make a boya priyadam so this is something that really gives us an insight into the whole suggest it's not what meets the eye it's the third definition of a fruit versus a non-fruit now i would think it's possible that on if you a person with the evidence made a eight on papaya he would be item because tom something says where it creates but one thing i hope is clear the point is when you come to a shalom zoho or any type of fruit platter and there's many other fruits try to stay away from making a bracha directly on the papaya because even though the minigames can make an adoma but some sail aids if you have anyhow a grape would you go first anyhow make it eight on the grape make kadanga on the watermelon the cantaloupe whatsavaday papaya is a pretty huge suffix i mean again we we passed in the minutes to make adorama some say eight but again it's hard to say that it's about their eights and berkshire there are many other certain brachis so stay away at least from papaya someone only eating papaya what's the bracha so now the next question that's very much connected even though it doesn't seem so is eggplant in ireland today you're only what's this what's this island eggplant is a vegetable but then again avocado is also a vegetable if it grows on a tree it's at eight so what's the materials of an eggplant avocado is a tree very good what's that eggplant so eggplant is a perennial plant grown in grown annual hardy woods stem and that has leaves and it grows from branches in other words it seems very similar to a tree again has branches woody tree typically you don't have to replant it and basically it could even live for three years so the fact that you hear the words woody stem branches would indicate that it appropriates and indeed the radhvas and khalid gimbal tough lamar mentioned the cheetah that it might be or aids and the full hilgas are applied to an eggplant i have to make your eights on an eggplant a vegetable avocado doesn't bother us however as you know the minute is to make our dhamma and i'll soon tell you that dominic is not to be gracious for allah what's shot so first of all i'll tell you it's interesting because if you look in the base yosef that quotes the guy in him with him saying which is a banana make her dama the guy named continues and i'll read because of all he's off the base he is going to go in him then high timer is comparing bananas to bart sinon is the word for hatselem eggplant so you're wondering what's the cyclist between bananas and eggplant especially a banana is a big high tree but for us it's beautiful and they're their advantage gimbal tough highlights this point that it's very similar in its nature it's a perennial growth that although it survived the roots survived the winter but the plant doesn't so just like a banana as high as it is it's an abdominal because the the tree does not survive the winter so to an eggplant is a bayer priyadam the aloha in aleppo was asked about takahatsilan and some say it's hosta altar at the burpio aids and he says no no no because first of all the fact that hatsellem grow the first year is an indication it's not appropriate because fruit don't give fruit the first year also he says it's a hollow trunk and therefore he says that you could ignore the minigur making aids on the eggplant the minute is to make a boy ray priyadama so it's amazing a katsylim eggplant is similar to banana in one respect and also symbol to papaya one of the reasons why papaya is available also has that hollow trunk feature so that's why the halogenous is confident that you make a burrito pre abdomen and there's no aurora on eggplant i must add the ralph pauline much later than that a few hundred years later he says you know the iraq the tanis writes that this concept of giving off the first year is a schwa reason so he says shouldn't say that because this reason is found in the trisefta it's a very strong reason you know the fact that it gives off fruit the first year is a strong reason to say it's a very predominant even though it's a myeloma but it's not a feature of a fruit so the maiza regarding urla we also have because again the hazelnut don't last more than three years and it seems to me that the minute taka today is that there's no we don't treat of the eggplant with wilhelm and the the meaning is to make it i did see in the same from he adds just to i guess relieve us he said the mice are today there's no shiloh whatsoever not an oral man because they they the planters tell him that they want to get to maximize the growth of the hot sealing and they actually replant it every new crop is replanted so basically the hazelnut today comes from a it's not even perennial it doesn't even last beyond the first planting so that's pretty relieving so no kasha orlan it's vaping hot peppers now the um i'm not familiar with this but in the mysore the mathias it grows on a plant that's basically that that has a feature of a tree and a certain that's similar to bananas and eggplants now it's called the english tabasco but la mais it's not of course black pepper but there are those that hold this full hillchat's orla on this the hot pepper because it has the features of a tree it's a bush actually but it would be a butter puree aids lamisa no one eats the tabasco these hot pepper plain so therefore the broccoli is definitely not our eights maybe hadamard maybe even shaku if you can't eat a plain but the truth is there are still those that are still hoisting that it might be because it grows on a halachic bush the reason why most poison that it's not a concern of orla is because la maison we don't see us is that it's a vegetable that's really has that lock of the betray and but the mice you'll look into the play scheme there are those that consider this would be haka's arla because even though it's a vegetable it would be something like avocado and it might be hokusarova but again the bracha is definitely not bioprioids the next group is a challenging sugia and that's the alohas of berries so let's start with the easy one which probably you don't even have and that's what's called the mulberry now let me explain with the macias mulberry is a high regular tree that survives the winter no doubt about it mulberry is a burger prior aids the mulberry fruits look like blackberries but it comes from a different tree it's a tree now we'll see this occasionally even in the city when you're walking along the street and you see what looks like blackberries on the floor and you step on them and it makes dirt and attracts flies and people ask you shout outs can i cut down this tree and say this is a fruit tree that's a mulberry tree blackberries don't grow in the city it's a huge pretty big tree that the tree survives the winter it has hilcha is orla if you plant it but i don't advise it because you can have problems with you know the bugs and everything that attracts it has orlan it has baltastras and it's burpee eight if it's edible but that's typically not negative because again we don't have we don't harvest all these things what's much more negay and a big discussion the pie skin is raspberries or blackberries now before we go vita i must tell you raspberries and blackberries are highly infested so it's basically we don't get near them today if someone knows there's no shield of you know shrugs in what's the bracha on it so the mathias is very unique it has a root system it is perennial it's capable living and producing fruits for several years la maison it sounds like a burpier eight and a half days says that these blackberries this vada and that they because again it's a bush not a tree it's a bush but it really survives the winter however the minig is baire priyadama on blackberries and raspberries and we have to try to figure out why so this i saw a whole write up about blackberries and the marsham with sangresa das torah writes the exact same description of sim and khuf and basically it's not your typical tree because the first it grows one year now and that's the the growth one year has no fruit it's called a primocane the next year a whole new planting grows and that's the florican that gives off the fruits but he says after my sham really there's no brand that gives off more than one year because after the when the the second year the the florida king gives her fruit it dies and they start again with the primocane so it never has too much of a life to it so hashem says that basically it should be hadamard some make her eight but the derivative is a little more emphatic and he said that this is not considered a tree because every year there's a different as if it's a different branch as it would be different branch and therefore the bracha is baire pri now it's what's strange about it is the odom like i told you also they all insist that on blackberries and raspberries is a boilerplate because the actual bush itself lasts from year to year why are you looking at the that particular branch la maison we don't change the minigun first in his first safe he wrote berry pierre hates then he changed and he told me because he can't change fight the world the minute seems to be on blackberries and raspberries the brochure is priyadoma even though the mr brewer seems to say it's about your po-aids what's much easier is the blueberries blueberries mr miracles in hebrew today the matsias of a blueberry is it grows on bushes that reach 10 to 12 feet in the height the bush itself survives the winter i'm going to camp on we have more than one blueberry bush in our on our grounds you can see it seeing he's believing so basically it's not a tree but it has it's a bush and it has all the miles of a tree it's 10 to 12 feet it survives the winter and the mr burns if cotton gimbal says that on this yacht dish you can make a bird pre-eight then he is a very strange kiddish let's say you find blueberries which you also could find that grow on very low bushes less than gimel talking perhaps less than 11 inches and i see it as my camp also some of them grow wildly there but that he says would be the minute is to make it obviously if it's so close to the ground it's about pierre so mr brewer is recognizing a minute that blueberries the bird preheats from a bush but if you find the blueberry growing in a low bush within gimbal 12. i'm 11 inches in the ground it's about priyadon now for your information you could understand on your own commercial blueberries they don't go climbing mountains to find these little you know blueberry bushes that are on the ground they have bushes that are big and definitely you go and you could make a burpee eggs like on blueberries if you find blueberries that grow close to the ground mr bruce's dominic is not all places that's dominic we grew up promotion rights we made a burpier it's on all blueberries so basically you can be comfortable when you buy blueberries because they're clean properly it's a burger priorates strawberries i should mention also that obviously blueberries has all the velcro's arola and hoteliers also there's a lot strawberries is much easier again the machias is it's a perennial herb on a plant not a tree it's the quickest of all plants to produce fruit and as the years go on the equality declines and it loses its quality so basically it's perennial you'll have to replant like the rush it's a very pre-whole aids but it's for more than one reason besides that we passed like to grind him there has to be also that the has to survive the winter which it doesn't but the fact is that it gives off the first year pairs it's also poison and mr brew attacker right if you've gotten gimme says this as well that base basically the strawberries is a boy prehadoma and there seems to be no suffix about that and also there's no healthiest or allah on strawberries the king of the sheilas i think is really cranberries now let me explain the matsias first of all cranberries has a unique feature it's not a tree and it's not a bush it grows on a vine now for your information vine is a bonafide berry priest and the biggest writer is grapes grapes growing vines the mathias is it grows on creeping vines which grow along the ground although the vine produce fruit year after year but listen to this there's one unique feature of the cranberries versus grapes or kiwis we'll soon see and that is it grows very close to the ground within nine inches of the ground so now we come to a a roadblock the fact is grapes is available eights and kiwis which grows in the vine burpiers this these cranberry vines are very long but they happen to be they grow on the ground so how do you look at a cranberry so basically there's another factor which you have to understand before we could apply lemaiser mr bhura and now was he the cotton gimbal he writes zura venus which is apparently the straw the cranberries he says it's so bitter that you can't even eat it as it is at which is cranberries so now i'm really confused but let me tell you it's very simple all speaks about deserving he says it's a it's a it's a red berry which is cranberries he says i don't know they don't have it in america i don't know the name for it but he says it's so you can't eat it as it is so now here's the mystery that will be clarified once and for all the truth is the actual cranberries cannot be eaten i mean they could but they're very sour and that's why it wasn't the product someone came up with let's make craisins i'm not going to tell you the percentage of sugar in craisins because you might not find it so you know appealing but a big part of craisins are sugar because the the the outer part of the cranberry which you can't eat so cranberry juice became a big product and cranberries once you have the cranberry the cranberries you make into craisins so the myso we have a fully edible craisin which is a big part of its sugar but that's the toefl it should be appropriate it grows on vines reflecting zalman in the same bracha and simon rage gimbal the troubas he says but since it grows within gimbal twelfth above the ground nine inch with the gimbal talking to the ground it's back to the minute which the brewer says and so it has everything going for it but it's closeness to the ground now this is very not pushing first of all where maesha said even blueberries close to the ground there's a minute in certain places there's no meeting regarding cranberries he is one of the greatest experts in agricultural childhood sweetest he says it's the way it grows is like a regular tree with leaves just it happens to be long instead of high and he said he's on splits on cranberries besides that the fact that it's so popular today doesn't have the shy love shackle it's a fully fully edible a fruit of a vine that's that's quite long a different argument i saw he's joan bjorn argues that you're going to come to a taco because you start treating cranberry like a vegetable and you're not going to think of arlo but all the breed there has to be arla to a cranberry so let me tell you there's a a lot of areas i saw but i will tell you that wrote and he's quoted by so many that a cranberry jamaica dumb like of slime is almond he put out safer and he retracted for many reasons he felt that it should be a berea pre-hoax in other words it's better than bananas and strawberries it's more like a grape or a kiwi lemaisa and eritisrel they treat it as orlan so the maison i would only tell you i'm not giving mahri and harm good island but certainly if you want to have if you come to the shabbos dessert and there's other fruits and vegetables avoid making the broca's directly on the cranberry even though if you make adobo you're doing like salmon said but it's a huge subject that's not sour it's all you know easy to sell to south some say it's a boilerplate sesame seeds typically are eight at the cow you don't need a plain but we see today they're selling sesame candy which is which the assumption is that the honey is the toefl to the sesame what broccoli says to me because the basil quoting him says three examples bananas and then shomshmi which is sesame it seems to be the same type of growth it's a perennial but the plant does not survive the winter and takara moisture and others assume if it's edible and it's not a tough like on top of khala the bracha on sesame or sesame bar is a boy right pre-abdominal pomegranate is one easy sheila it's a regular it's not a tree gravel but it's a pretty high bush and it grows from year to year and therefore it's about pure aids kiwi is a simple shiloh bor hashem it's a attack of vine but the mice of the fact is that it's higher than einstein it's a barrier prior aids i remember we once said a number of years ago that the real name for the kiwi is a chinese gooseberry so i said what changed i said i i was i was shy someone wanted to make a lot of money and you can't sell no one's gonna buy chinese gooseberry could sound strange so he gave me the name kiwi so after this year someone approached me says you're a good magazine in california became a millionaire she started marketing chinese gooseberries but this was she called it kiwi you see what it means mothers a word of a difference makes a world of a difference and we'll leave you with two fascinating shahilas number one is the allah of the heart of palm so harder palm today is a very popular food what is the matthias so it's again fascinating it's basically what we call a it's this the heart of a palm tree tamar as in lula or tomorrow basically the center of a heart of a palm tree has a long part of it so officially it's the heart of it a soft plant at least 12 inches in its length probably an inch in diameter and i don't know how someone thought of the idea but if you cut down the tree take out the heart and you cook it it's a very fancy delicacy and indeed it was always called a a a rich man's food because you have to be you know you have to be wealthy to cut down a palm tree you have to have a little less you know not too much of a heart than a human heart cut down a whole tree for your heart a pump so therefore you would say it's a burpee eights it's part of a heart a palm parmesan tomato but the plot thickens because the morning brock island with vogue speaks about a koi that the brock is shackled what is kairos ramos says and raised palmito palmito is the name for heart of pond so now we see not only is that a to charcoal and why shaco so here comes the resolution of this mystery the truth is it used to be a rich man's food but today berkeley most of us do eat harder palms are not so rich what's the secret they discovered how good of a product it is so someone else said why should we cut down a big huge palm tree they started cultivating and growing especially special types of palms that they they actually let it grow until it has the heart upon it it's not a high it's not high at all i think it was just about five feet and then they cut it down and actually either cut it down or replant it and from that palm tree they take out the heart and it became the average man's food so now the question is what brock are they making it so the zeiss abraca says a very wonderful you saw it and he says basically that in this particular case the tree does not survive because you cut down the tree and you plant another one so even if it's perennial it's still the but there's another factor and that is what's take-up shot why not bird pro eights if it's really a pre or aids so even like the rush this is why it's out of operates because you don't eat the pre-orders you don't eat the apple of the tree you eat the tree itself and just like you know sugar even though sugar grows on a pretty high bush or actually on a grass but the broccoli is not our age because you're eating the tree itself or or cinnamon you're eating the bark itself when you eat the bark itself or the tree itself it's not a prio eight it's a burpi adam so pahata palms are very adorable but last but not least let me tell you something really fascinating they started today in the world of kadushim they they actually genetic engineering they have grown and i've seen this picture of it grown tomatoes on trees regular tomato on a tree what brother do you make on such a tomato it priorates so i we all know there's a a type of specie looks like a tomato it's called tamarillo that grows on a tree which i saw a picture of it there is no shaykh ushaira because that's a different specie and grows on a tree so that's the bird creates this arola ours was different it was genetically engineered to take a tomato and grow it on the tree so this almond entangled zion says if it grows on a tree it's a blue priest it's finished so you have how could you do it a ate on a panel a potato a tomato burpie eight but it bothered me because the mice that we know on mushrooms the mysteries and broccoli that men make a shackle because it grows from the air not from the ground yes bravo the crust but today most mushrooms are grown you can't produce mushrooms from growing around on on different stumps they grow mushrooms does the broccoli change my moist much more nageya is it on mushrooms today and he said no why cause a mushroom blight mushroom so it bothered me maishnam mushrooms from this tomato but look at his caution you're looking very versatile carefully he says even this type of mushroom that grows they plant where does it grow from from the air so it's still a mushroom but if you have a tomato that grows on a tree the broth will be better creates and i can talk to you foreign