Crumbs In Halacha - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

okay I'd like to welcome everyone to Terry sheer from Arabia Smith teams are sponsoring today itself we're gonna be outside Smith we always wonder we know there's any concept that stepping on crumbs is Kosh does that mean any crumbs and especially before pesach we have to consider that peso comes there's so many crumbs on the floor is that really a problem when there's crumbs and you step on crumbs and say kosher La Neos we had a question throughout the year about benching when you bench you have to have bread on the table and it's not practical to keep bread on the table sometimes especially at work is it good enough crumbs and I realized there's a whole sugier really about crumbs besides of course cleaning crumbs crumbs and swarm but as we see it's really throughout our time it even touched upon you already um the basic status of crumbs and halach and let me explain the truth is we know there's a severity of wasting about away something is especially when it comes to bread bread is than other food you're learning a whole bunch of Allah how to treat bread properly so now the question that we have to clarify is is that only by bread when something became breadcrumbs after Amelia breadcrumbs does it have the same status like bread and therefore you can't step on it you can't waste it it would be good for benching you don't need bread bread comes enough or maybe bread is bread bread crumbs is the remainder it's the leftover who said that has the same shivas as bread so it sounds like uh you know an abstract question but as we'll see there's at least three gamaras that discuss breadcrumbs and gives gives us a very clear insight and what's the luck about breadcrumbs [Applause] if you're worried then maybe you didn't find every last crumb and that's where you have to be movable it they don't count then on the map it's so much not on the map that you don't even have to make a a Bittle now this is the concept and we'll soon see them again rephrase that camera and they say you don't have to make a bit long promise because the crumbs I'm a vocal of I made because that only crumbs now I know this is the wrong time to say that crumbs don't count the national have been cleaning since Hanukkah the microscopic crumbs and animals says crumbs don't count but as I say think about what could I do but there's even a another source and that's the suggest numbers where basically the murderer says we do know you're not allowed to destroy that's an Issa of besides but crumbs destroy will soon see them in the context you're watching them over the crumbs so there's no problem of iPod why again because crumbs don't count Now Toys is quick to point out which makes it a little complicated even though you're allowed to pour water onto crumbs but don't forget it's causalenius and tice refers to tuga Mars that stepping on crumbs is so now the question is why taka are you allowed to destroy crumbs and if we say crumbs don't count so Isaac Ashland is but to make a mortgage makakasha who says you're allowed to destroy crumbs is the one that says you can't destroy bread so why isn't crumbs or South here for today is the following the truth is but it has to be an oil it has to have the status of an oil something crumbs that are the remainder after eating and typically we don't collect the crumbs to eat because now this is not just to play on words it in order to be ourselves that crumbs don't have Hashem you know but whatever the case is some crumbs because they're The Leftovers are bread don't have Hashem bread the stapler because it is a letter he wrote in print the end of he also discussed his breadcrumbs and he says Lafayette if you're not going to eat it it's not ointment it doesn't have Hashem it has a beautiful Raya even regarding true mothers and it's Roma if it's not ointment it's not considered we see that breadcrumbs don't have Hashem but obviously we could understand the next let's say a person decides he wants to eat just one breadcrumb and he wants to eat does he have to make a burger I bread crumbs don't count that's only because if you want to eat it but you have to make a broke even on a call soon it's more than actually since he's intending to eat it it never was now the mice even though we're going to be Maple Taco by breadcrumbs regarding either oil I must mention Ed really a fascinating he says the inside of the Isabel is to train ourselves to appreciate the goodness was so careful even a gargam shall guard up even in a mustard seed one solitary Mustard Seed not to waste it it is only we saw him don't care about wasting food is talking about a new meaning in this times to start planting nice flowers in the basic forests he says and he says teaching us it's not even an oil it's a preparation to make mustard and you don't waste so we competency start planting usable flowers in a basic Forest that becomes the point only is If today were Mako it's only because Allah but a person has the right tire perspective don't waste anything will soon collect the crumbs and eat it why waste crumbs if you could use it but the point only is and I saw the uh it goes back 150 years ago in Perry craftes he says even more because even the Gabi the real issue about kashkas of koreana fruit tree din if it's no longer giving Paris and you need the space and it's not worth the money you allowed to cut it down now grab the people I'm mocked with cutting out a tree am I gonna get into that now but even about if it's not worth much he says crumbs sometimes a person will worry about the crumbs this game makes him nervous there is no problem of ebudd of crumbs now but if you use it because I'll give you a muscle you know it's like chicken bones after you finish eating that's up but if you want to use it you want to feed it to your dogs and where is apella the third Source in Hazard that speaks about crumbs foreign bones shells and crumbs they don't have a kazarius there's no problem of muktsa because you could feed it to your animals it's a plea located of crumbs crumbs together with bones and eggshells that's them it says they didn't eat crumbs if it was so therefore the only head to why it's not mukta is it's regular Club so that's why the analogy that I said comparing crumbs to bones is really a mishnah because bones shells and breadcrumbs are not multicolas regular club that will soon see if it's Mana is there we don't have dogs maybe Taco bread comes to return to our original question so what is the status of breadcrumbs basically it depends on your SC access to it breadcrumbs that remain after eating and you're not going to eat it doesn't have but it's enough of the urban Islam's creation don't step on it because Brazilian of crumbs or breadcrumbs is Aeneas and we did see a good morning brochus nun base regarding Bob regardingham and Shabbos Goodman gimbal regarding so now let's apply this Lamesa and hope you enjoyed as much as I did because you see everything stems with this definition first of all let's start with the child someone's on a very strict diet and it takes the snack a breadcrumb a pure breadcrumb do you make so this is why not it's bread if you decide you don't want to eat it and you throw it out it's not an Aveda but if you want to eat it you will you you sort of activate its status as bread and Avada much someone asked me a very amusing question what broccoli I make on the the the chopped liver on Sunday night I said what about Tuesday night so chocolates as well see in my house the chopped liver left over from Shabbos there's always breadcrumbs in it because people take the challah and they dip it into the bread into the chopped liver so he says maybe you may have to make a mighty because the bread crumbs in the chopped liver I said okay good the Meister bread come to somebody but this you're not eating about that beside the enacted this is like to Ema and I love myself is never bottled that's only if you haven't to eat it if it's there just to hold the the filter fish together the flowers they're holding filters together we don't make them we don't make a messiness if it's not cavana sahili if it's a TOEFL Gummer if you have a very salty fish together with bread the mission says you don't make a break on the bread so this is not even a TOEFL it's just there it's in your way so you eat shop liver Sunday night make a shackle and escuzante a interesting question they gave a hoya and the Frat pesach is when you find if you bench you find some breadcrumbs with Max it's really hard to get rid of and after you bench you have you have massacrums or bread crumbs in your mouth [Music] you have to spit it out so the embassy is that you'll say what do you mean I made them I made a mighty before but then again you benched and once you benched benching is a silk and even if you have that's the idea of the benching you have to make a new broken what's my Riya we bench with a koi cell bracha we have that's the drink we made a girlfriend by kiddies but yet you make a new girlfriend because Amazon is a silk Masala Cobra because you have to make a new brother there is a sad to say if you swallow a breadcrumb after bench you have to make another Burger but the police can say for numerous reasons not the case first of Allah it's just it's easier to swallow than to spit it out and you don't want to cause someone distressed and start spitting it out also the partially decomposed breadcrumb in your mouth is already not so much but crumbs of the mouth doesn't have a dinner and then I saw let's see and I saw others all say the same if the food is in your mouth the whole time it's not then it's not even a silhouette if you're holding the case I hope it's not in your mouth but the bread comes you made a broken and stayed in your mouth the whole time the broker with China is still in effect has a short tube and the result page 191 and he says a different can age that breadcrumbs and he says therefore even if you change location and you go to a second place so the previous svara that the Brock will shine is still good doesn't work why like we said and doesn't need a new book the next question is you see how hazal was so focused that everything has to stim there's a mini Israel that has become a little embellished I should say but the minute stamson Gamora brachis in the end of Simon kuf Ayan aleph they used to throw argosa not Peck look he's a throw hit them kernels of wheat and that's was their meaning some through Clovis at the end of says if you do that fine but make sure you only throw the kernels of wheat in a makam Naki and clean it up afterwards because if not you're gonna be my Abid so sounds right takasha is and all the acronym is this what do you mean the kernels of wheat themselves are less than a kazayas so just like DiMare says in Mr de braces so why can we say the same regarding the Heat and the kernels of wheat so the Emma says because it's not exerts a cost of less than the gazais doesn't count because then you'll say raisins and peanuts and and candies and anything small is only the remainder of a suda bread crumbs after the meal it law it got demoted it lost as hashivas but something ikara is it's not automatically bottled doesn't count it's if you have a piece of bread that's very Rush of the food and you have leftover crumbs bottle like disciples says but a candy is something that that's a value is not automatically bought but then I saw another you saw it and has a big impact on the rest of the circuit and that is the breaka joycef and I was 7 Cove pay Steve gimmel he says there are many pie skin that hold you only Mako by a breadcrumb or two or three but if you have a number of breadcrumbs that add up to kazayas then is an Issa of he says others are Mako but he quotes somebody Israel you can't be Mako now in verse so the brachiosis says breadcrumbs are really important just it's so small once you have access hold every breadcrumb is a zero you don't eat up zeros so you add up zeros to nothing and the mysterious I did see that those that are Michael but we could understand that taking a handful of hit them and throwing it at the Hassan even if you want to say which is not true then on one heat that is no problem but a handful typically is kazayas and therefore would be us someone asked me it was Molly you're a shame I had enough of it he typically in the morning by a ticket he makes the messiness on cake and then he wants to make a shackle on the snaps the problem is it's very hard to make sure that there's no cake crumbs in his mouth because he especially a dry cake and he said we have the good morning that you have to make a broken and your mouth has to be empty and his mouth is not empty okay so the question is how do you deal with that point so the embassy is that we could say on a simple level through like we said maybe it doesn't count I mean the truth is in your mouth is never really empty I mean there's always saliva there's no luck you have to get a blow dry and you know dry your mouth now it is a problem is when people and the women they they take off the ring for washing and they don't want to put it down and make a loss so they keep it in their mouth so that the whole brush the juggling of ring in their mouth that's really a problem the words are not legible even though you know but anyhow that's the problem but the breadcrumbs but I must say there's a minute contributed to the cinema who's for that reason he made a shock on the schnapps first and then Amazon is on the cake crowded the dead have another husband that really snaps his is more surveyor a whole bunch of reasons but upon Him is someone follows the regular Seda maziness and charcoal so try to swallow as much as you can and if these breadcrumbs will assume peruma may look badly the next question is the gay on a daily basis and that is an Allah's based on a Sanhedrin satic base with quotes I don't touch that but that means if you don't leave Brandon tape of a benching you'll never see bracha forever in other words like say in America forget about it now forever you know it's not gonna happen not in your lifetime but the question on the Practical level is let's see a person's at work and it takes his sandwich and he's about to bench so every day has an issue I leave a piece of bread for benching I'm not gonna eat it after benching because I'm gonna throw it out so either I'm going to not have red on the table for benching or if I leave pieces of bagel on my sandwich I'm gonna throw it out so that's valtages so which is the lesser of two evils like what should I do so the question is maybe there's a third option and that is inevitably when a person eats bread to any type of bread there's some crumbs maybe we'll rely that the crumbs that you leave over that taco is good enough for benching for the cinnamon bra also learn throwing out bread crumbs there's no issue so the question a very simple question if you want to be makayam the dinner gemara is it enough to have breadcrumbs or maybe we'll say who are you fooling if you let it throw it out I mean it's not hot so why is it for benching you can't they have to be consistent so the Emma says that this is totally in the two reasons why because you have to have bread on the table from the gamara quoting a poskin that if there's nothing on the table when you bench there's nothing rake the Taurus he says and nothing remains is not a semen he brings era from the Isha tsunamis from Elisha and from Russ whatever the case is the objective they have bread on the table is if you want benching to be the Brock that it's supposed to be foreign that the real reason is if you're benching it's nice and what's going to be if the benchings are knocking the door and Ani comes he asks what to eat and you have nothing to give him a year that's living like that he's not worrying about an auntie coming he's a naraya Simmons I will think of inside how a person has to think of yanem a person's eating and benching but it attacks is but the mice we have two reasons to leave bread on the table here I saw vertica info someone said cotton gimbal says that really for the reason of Simon bracha it's enough crumbs because there's some it's not empty it's not finished it's it's how but if the reason is to give an honor you can't be Muhammad Ali with crumbs so ready to massageen had hours and he says only satisfies one reason so we don't want to satisfy only one reason we're afraid of the other reason but then I saw the osnid Bruins the same info he was managed to ask someone's at work same am I child and she live over bread so he says at a workplace they might be collectors which typically happened but no one asked for bread so in that situation there's no there's no of giving bread so the only reason remains is foreign but the Shanghai is that our child is telling you two reasons and in a workplace then maybe only have to have the reason of simenburgh so and I learned this thing I recall someone told me this maybe 30 plus years ago but she made a racism he's once in my swifference office and Yeshiva and noticed he had a piece of March on the table and it wasn't the four Pace or interpace what's that so I've also said no it's not Kabbalah very simple every day he eats lunch and his office any benches and he had the child what should I do about that I want to have a cinnamon brother so to leave a piece of bread every day is she had an idea practical he brought a piece of matzo Mata stays the whole year has good shelf life put it on the table and puts it back in his drawer now you want to be really safe you could bring shmur matzah so you could even keep it over Pace but no doubt about it that's a practical item supposed to leave a piece of bread for benching so if it ends up being thrown out because no other choice it's not about taskus it's keeping the midst of them okay but if you use matzah maybe that's a better idea now I wonder how many achieve on a camp so I have this question is there a reason to keep a taco piece of bread as opposed to crumbs because I can't be Macabre and it's not mine either yeshivas or the camps it's attacking makes sense it's telling you two reasons if the reason is I want a broker if the reason is Oni then if it's not mine to give and then breadcrumbs is enough big question which really our sugya is how to deal with the remaining breadcrumbs crumbs so here we have two issues number one and number two stepping on crumbs which camera says in two places so the question which we began with is does breadcrumb have the status of bread so again to repeat the gemara perum that's number one you're allowed to destroy it is but the point that we see from the pasta to the Gamora and that's where twice learns that pouring water on bread is okay there's no Issa but pouring water on bread is kosholanius that's frightening because we always thought the kosher needs is if you step on breadcrumbs twice is learning pouring water on breadcrumbs is bread crumbs but kosher Landings used attack to do just that they would wash my macronium onto the floor which had breadcrumbs basila was not worried about andios so he says must be the only problem of question is stepping on bread and he brings a ride here because the gamara says they used to take the breadcrumbed and throw it into the river into the ocean must be and he says with great confidence Kane narrowly bought her his arguing on tysvis that the only Issa of and it's the only concern of aeneos is when you are stepping on it pouring my name onto it which makes it an edible is not a problem not outboard and not outs this is the cheetah of the maganav rum now a kazayas of bread Avada can't be Mohammed comes again and he says that the magazine is right because the Raya from the throwing in the ocean is that Orion because that's not really a bazoyan first of all it might research the other side like the Gamora famous muranus but besides that he says onto bread crumbs with all this raw is pantamount to stepping on it so that defends twice this but then for us it's a problem that means it's loved Africa foreign here's the problem some people take breadcrumbs especially after they cut on the bread on the taka on the bread tray powertrain what do you do with all the breadcrumbs so we'll soon see there's an onion to eat those bread crumbs and chop especially but let's say a person doesn't want them so some people throw it into the basic he say I'm not so sure that's the right thing to do because they're high in my college and it's safe it reached let's see on an hour Gamora in Brockton Bays he said they were very macbid on stepping on breads in other words assuming for the Post that the the the the concept of Anis is lived after stepping on it it's taking bread even though it's only breadcrumbs and putting it in a Makai meals which parrot was a terrible desire the way he says garbage can is so we have to really pause the moment so is it taco no maybe into the sink so that we have uh what we said earlier like putting in an ocean but throwing it into the base like he sees the problem and her in a garbage can I mean that's his Los Angeles but especially if there are dirty diapers and children bones and it's it's really not a very honorable place to be it might be a Brazilian people take bread come they put it in a bag throw it in the garbage grab this some people have a minute that they take the breadcrumbs feed it to birds I must add it's interesting because from Chinese you know how to take food that's edible and feed animals and that's the Rashi says because you're demoting human food to animal food but obviously in this case that wouldn't apply because you're not going to eat the crumbs anyhow better myself and feed the birds and throw it out he said don't step on crumbs better feed it to the oil face now what is a problem the cool album people take bread and when they go Tasha they throw hot they throw the bread to the fish or they go to the zoo and they feed the the the animals all the Michael Autumn that is but the point is what all agree stepping on breadcrumbs is a problem he writes those that sell bread have to be careful don't step on the bread and those that have bread in the house and be careful with the children so stepping on bread is tuga Mars I just saw the crying falaji in in Cafe it has a bunch of Horrors with breadcrumbs he says be careful Adam number one don't step on breadcrumbs because zanias and tell the maid to be careful with the breadcrumbs and when you eat bread or matzo certainly put it on a plate so you shouldn't splatter all over the floor then you end up stepping on the breadcrumbs and he says even to Decay to that extent be careful the cat doesn't take the bread because the cat crumbles it runs all over the house and and puts all over the house not talking about comets he's talking about it ends up being stepped on and that's causalenius now of course like every other good thing too much obsessiveness is no good you know people get OCD with bread crumbs it's also uh you know amakana of mirzo so a person has to be you know normal and just basically eat carefully eat over a plate and then you dispose of the crumbs as you feel appropriate but the AKA is to you know avoid that problem one point I want to mention if you learned the is is always on the one that's throwing the crumbs on the floor we don't find the Farish stepping on the crumbs but obviously it's the throwing bread comes on the floor is a problem because you're causing someone else to step on it so definitely to step on it would be the issue of Costa landius so as I mentioned earlier there are some that are that very madactic to collect all the Khaled crumbs and eat them so in the kabayas he says and then he throws in a person should not throw away the prayer pass because it's like just like the part of the Cabanas like if I'm saying he says the holocram especially on Shabbos have a special kadusha the kitchen and he has a in in the new print he has a whole bunch of tikkunem foreign it helps remember the Gamora that of course together with khazara Hazard is always number one but that's a mild zika but what's interesting when you want you want to give a about crumbs you have to mention what's probably the Makar of sharayam the you xiaomi in sanhajan hasbays he would go and collect the crumbs and eat them and he said yes explains he wanted to show the hershibous of the suda so he even ate the breadcrumbs obviously in breadcrumbs there is a kadusha a sudas Mitzvah like the kids felt it appropriate enough to collect the crumbs that someone else left that wasn't his and he ate it another question until today we wouldn't consider much of a question but now we see it's a serious question breadcrumbs that you are not planning on eating at all and you're not feeding the birds you're gonna throw in the garbage or throw it in a way that's appropriate is it in fact or not until today now we see it to the Pharisee mishna because if you learn the missionar discussing breadcrumbs the reason why it's not much so like bones and shells is because now so that was always the case people that were very poor everything was used if they didn't eat it they fed the animals people lived in a farm with animals but on top should take him on no one's feeding his crumbs to animals so the Heine tickets can discuss maybe breadcrumbs taka should be mixed up but it doesn't really sound right and if this war really is posted because really the clown is when something is is not muktsun especially it only becomes when it's totally functionless if you could use it in any which way it retains its status as a non-looked cell so really breadcrumbs Hollow Crumbs are part of it if a person wants to eat it they make some mighty so why should it be muktu so the parents I saw this and it's foreign so then if it's mother because of animals but today that we either use it or we feed us it's a possibility we'll use it as long as it's not yet nimas why should it be mukta and especially if you don't clean with your hand you use a napkin don't forget we have another sword that will be tilto minutesag you're not touching it'd be Italian clean the table so the mind is so comfortable to say that breadcrumbs are not muktsumo says especially that we said earlier if there's a chance you might use it so really you make a mighty on it so it's not ice oil the next question also a pastor issue maybe more so because a person is walking but there's no Arab and he notices that this bread comes in his mouth matzo crumbs the question is I saw so the truth is the same child is a person before basically puts a vehicle in his pocket takes it out but then his crumbs in his pocket so here the question is you have to be consistent if you're gonna tell me that breadcrumbs are not milk so it's really lucky so you're carrying something of value in your pocket in your mouth and Tackle they were the answer is careful they cleaned their packets very well before they went out which is a robin and they cleaned their mouths of any food residue foreign first of all most place only a caramelist plus is only katish here and then it may be La Mesa developed goes out without worrying and this one of the slowest I saw is based on a Mahaba which is based on the Gamora and that is when a person when it's raining so presumably this accumulation of rain on either's clothing on his hat or whatever it is why is that us to go on Shabbos so it's not a map explains since it's EF sharp it's bottle because I'll didn't ask them it's very hard to make sure every last crumb is out you have to collect your pockets and maybe there's a little dirt there's a little this so I did see the police can compare that to the US besides the fact especially in your mouth especially after decomposed so again I do I am aware that it's brought them Sadiq came to be marked but to clean out the pockets well but when you're holding up my Dragon Ball Ace actor it's okay it's many of the Suarez it's iafza and Mela Batley and the fact that it's not going to be used it's considered not on the Alaric map the big question which is really the United for today is cleaning crumbs whether it's on the floor or in swarim etc etc so the embassies that we saw three gamers brockas and suck him basically we saw most most importantly for US soccer involvement base foreign so why are we so busy cleaning but even more than that listen to this the rush in the tube is discusses what we had a few years ago let me remind you of that you know harrowing experience it was a few minutes before this man Shabbos no goiter no vacuum cleaner and you have to have three suits two at least of pass now what do you do so people ate on the porch hanging out the window you know to get rid of those crumbs so somebody has to rush can you eat a suit on the table and have a guy remove the crumbs and get rid of it so you don't have to worry about the crumbs so the rushes and I quote what do you have to worry about crumbs take the map of them tablecloth shake it onto the floor and then you've done no problem now again a few minutes for this man if you do that in your house you'll be sent to Siberia mama just did the 11th Hour you know there's nothing there's nothing after this because what's left on the table only crumbs especially on the floor and therefore there's no share the draw symbolic lion gets stepped on Miss baramiyalayam and why do you have to bother a guy don't call a guy do it yourself now don't do that but that's what it says now this is a shocking expression of perumalabati however before you apply that before you quote me I mean go home there's another good Mark and that's really quoted in tough man and that's the famous which basically means they're a little deposits of dough left on a pot to make a very long story short was the game for us this [Music] that this little bits of dough is okay the dafka when the Royals I'm sorry that this is only when it's pockets it's only like some say when you have little pieces but that's all these Optimus little pieces that's Royals that if those little pieces are still Royal you have a problem the only hat is if it's so badly decomposed or decompose that it's mature but Mr Brewer is nice to say if it's still edible then even a small amount is a problem so here the question is how do the two Mr Burris stem by the case that we said of of erepay so just throw it on the floor no problem and regarding the ball tickets is so the side of this is very simple it doesn't say crumbs don't count period perum dakim they get stepped on that is not a problem now let me explain really this is clear the holidays even though we say that basically there is an Issa by every Islam we know they have that bias but come to Mr pesos all agree now I bet you Robert Matson oh there's no hottie only because but everybody agrees that that a little bit even a culture of matzah is also of Muhammad is awesome so here's the point regarding basically is daika like in the sugar in the car first what do you have to move it you already checked foreign is not the problem because crumbs don't count but if this is that's the enemy and once you want to eat it we said actually you have to make a broken effect that's why we clean for crumbs and he has a beautiful Riot to the seaside to check him what are you going to find the Karma's dog and I can find the build color I'm gonna find crumbs himself that's only when there's no she might come to eat it if it's missing you can't find it but if there's a crumb that you might come to eat it so it's not the existence of crumbs is foreign verbatim talking to soldiers you know try to find the cooler too but there's no cooler crumbs that you might come to eat is unacceptable foreign not only I have to get rid of it you have to put up a Makita if not because you might come to eat it perum or lie they're very cursive because even on a call so there's I should mention the site is one of the resign him and look this up you can see the ray chaos he says before you make you make awesome he writes for crumbs documents for crumbs so you have two eyes you have the hayudn's but let me be very clear per room Taco bottle that we have to get rid of oh so now let's go back to our Suga and see how beautiful it is the truth is the person can sit down to lunch and pay stuff eat a crumb but if it happens it's a problem so we have to worry about that crumbs on the floor even though they're not totally nifs there's no question to come to eat it yeah I picked up crumbs and floor and eating it that's my son of cats it's on the table theoretic piece bottles you have to get rid of it but when it's on the floor so then Mr Burress attacker says you're not going to bend down to eat that crumb that doesn't count and the attacker you could ignore so both are true we check and we clean for crumbs you might come to eat but the crumbs on the floor are mamela Buckley now of course it's positive don't mention anyhow if you have a buccal on the floor there's no Hector until which is a very rare but crumbs is a turtle number one mamela bathly it's a small amount and number two is a pillow this very lotion that I that I told you Tyler uses he says and the another reason that that's approved what we said is the rush the rush says error pace and right before this man shake out the crumbs now no one stepped in it yet what's the header so why is once it's on the floor it's ready we don't need off the floor so if you have a bilkula on the floor you must get rid of it you can't throw it on the floor but crumbs that um and on the floor is enough we have the attack and that theoretically that's the way the rush says I don't think people do it but that's what says that's enough to get rid of the problem of those crumbs highlights this point that crumbs than themselves you don't need a Bittle it's only concerned so once you're comfortable you could even ignore those crumbs so now let's apply this molamisa and let's just discuss the question of crumbs in swarm so the mice this is Posh this actually system first with the Maison that's recorded that he would check this forum this is he would check this forum that he would bring to the table on pesach which definitely gives us a feeling that you have to check Slaughter because he says there's no difference how much and therefore you have to either clean the Slime or like some people do clothes they described actually he didn't do it but his tamidam did it and they spent many days going through each page of the safer running the finger Over The Binding make so no crumbs remained and that was the meaning of the stapler however as we know many are not news especially we have so many swarm who take years to collect to to clean swarm and one husband is maybe taking the crumbs in swarm is it ready there's like worms that are in in in swarm so it will go back to the same Hector of crumbs mamela bathley and you look at the rav in kunches spells it out that really crumbs don't count and once it's somewhat nimas it's fine so really we have these we're showing him and these pie skin that once you could say the crumbs you will not come to eat it then what's the problem now will the person you know sit down pay stuff open and safe and take out the crumb it's he doesn't know if it's milk you know see a month ago came so something that you have to really there's a real Kardashian plus I must say there's a big plus who said this crumbs in the safe you know does every person to eat with every safer baby big crumbs now why are you checking your house because in a house someplace there are crumbs that I saw another say from the Madonna crumbs a very thorough jewelry and also the Orleans they both say that that was his grace now especially if a person is careful not to eat when he when he learns or whatever he not uses for him then when the leaders of crumbs foreign crumbs on so we're only talking about someone that's you know going with course never use with credible comments so basically eventually that people use on on the whole year with with crumbs so that we can't clean properly so people try to clean it properly we don't we don't like selling comments Gummer and the rest of it basically we put it together to sell it with the comets and hopefully that would be enough the point is that you have to keep their two issues that have to be dealt with individually eating even a crumb of hummus until it's up but having a crumb Ling if you are guarantee that there's no question we're back to the rush and and another party scheme that that's not a problem we had a few years ago but it was a problem I mean it was a child not a problem with the challenge you have to eat and you don't know how much they have so quickly a few minutes for this man any leftover you crumbled it and threw it into the base of Casey and flushed it now we did it then we had no problems now we have two problems in retrospect you're taking a exercise of khala that's ebudd pass baltacious putting the basic is also casual Anis a can't be because hazal say that we have to do after the leftover from the suda the Terrace has to be and that's push it and if now the midst of the hour is to either burn the Comets no baltaskas but PESA because you can't burn it you have to get rid of it so that's the Mitzvah a Mitzvah is not bizarian it's not ebudd and not Kosher than is amitsa brings all of rocks and last but not least I want to mention this because I moved his mom is wrong I know we got it from but comes commercial breadcrumbs so he said that that's for sure because it's not bread crumbs they make it from scratch so I called the head of the okay and he gave me the information that's absolutely not true the Mercedes there are three ways interesting it's okay also to you're there so I'm mentioning it now there are three ways to make bread crumbs none of them is your maker from scratch now you know your people make a sword because you know I'll be you know but you can't make them but no one makes bread crumbs from scrap either they essentially all bread and they of course they dry it and they crush it that's the old-fashioned way which is still done today some companies make a thick bread it's not really bread and then again they dry it and they crush it into crumbs but today the one of the most popular ways is called panko breadcrumbs we haven't noticed this panco on it what does panko mean so I'm not kidding they electrocute a dough of bread they don't bake it they don't cook it they electrocute it I said really yeah yeah they send it a tremendous amount a bolt of electricity that actually doesn't cook it or bake it but it makes it enough edible to eat they got this from World War II the soldiers had to eat and they had no ovens by putting an intense amount of electricity it somehow makes it Royal Aquila it's a certain sense in the science of it similar to the microwave microwave doesn't really bake or cook it it's sort of a you know appeals to the molecules but basically it's literally panko is electrocuted bread and again that's accurate the first type of bread that comes from old bread divided and if the bread was uh was was past palta so the bread comes pasta so you know you keep that in mind if it's made from the thick bread so could be that was never a mighty and now that it's bread crumbs it's like it's like crumbled because if you hold that a thick bread that's not used as bread doesn't have the status of bread so maybe bread comes to be messiness but the pankoelectricated bread electrocuted bread crumbs it's like an interesting thing if they think about that but one thing I will say if someone has regular bread crumbs even if it's flavored but it was made from bread it's amazing but and also again be careful make sure that it's past Israel meets but certainly when we use breadcrumbs in ingredients so that either it's cooked or baked now then we have the Allah elasticized that's not nicotura that's cooked or baked so the broker is definitely relaxation foreign um the big pieces what's this where this is what you would eat off the floor okay okay the Peru maybe bottle but she is not bottle so we're gonna concert with a secret okay we learned today crumbs the status they are demoted it's like sort of a Suffolk basically crumbs that are not only we could assume is no longer an oracle that the voice is the staple explain evidently because it's still the Meister came from bread and that's question word we have to live with that we have to cherish everything of the British arms world even a gargoyle even though is a breadcrumb that a person eats he makes a moitzi because the man now it's still a food bread crumbs in liver Grace and exiled whatever that's Taco bottle but a breadcrumbler person eats loyutsu will be a regular moisture the bread crumbs in the one's mouth that he swallows almost because he knows the choice that does need a new broadcast because that was concluded in the first bottle as a Heroes we have to have when we throw pekluk not to throw any food that comes with a Brazilian even as we said because that's a Brazilian oil kept in a package that keeps it together if you have crumbs is besides of course kashilanias a person try when you make a messianist try to swallow all crumbs before you make a shackle on the drink but if there's little crumbs left over [Music] leaving we leaving bread on the table I should mention is an important Indian it's practical but if there's no Anem they're there you'll either leave just breadcrumbs and throughout the bread comes afterwards a practical idea would be a piece of mats on the table and a camper yes crumbs and FD finished throughout the crumbs if pouring water onto bread crumbs is kosholanius is it only stepping on it or any way of ruining it but we do did see a real bazarian for sure and maybe even a garbage that's very unpleasant would also be a problem of kaushalanias to dispose of the crumbs either in a sink or in a bag and then in the garbage something to show more pass feeding the birds the crumbs is an option there's no on breadcrumbs even if you have no animals on the small crumbs pesach the crumbs are bottled I want to thank him that when you have children or grandchildren running around the house so there's a hashas you have a lawyer claim maybe even on the crumbs if they eat it because they're not supposed to but if they eat it so make sure you clean it properly the ton of sauce on the floor in itself is not a problem but again if there are children that might eat it it should be cleaned I've added to eat a crumb until it sniffs Michaelis and isidarisa but the badika is for the crumbs I forgot to mention Dominican putting on 10 pieces of bread the pie scheme advice put each piece less than a kazales because if you lose it at least you're certainly know about Europe that's the good news but how do you burn it and make it when you when on that burning because the cases to add up so it's good to either use small pieces and kazais all together some clean swarm many don't but the ick is that they fall into the food some are they're gonna be the things that there is more crumbs like bench don't try to clean it so anytime you have to get rid of crumbs the last minute and you have no other choice you're allowed to be my ability because that's the midst of them and last but not least breadcrumbs checked the broken and checked if it's past Israel because it's really originally from a bread original foreign