Challenging Shome'a Ke'one Questions - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

like to welcome everyone to today's shirt from our yakuza smith and challengey schmeichel any questions advocates this is sponsoring your shaykh against your attire at 718-851-8665 as soon as you get the feeling that wasn't done and it's a special treat what makes it even more of a treat when it's a gesture and as we'll see there's a number of new shilohs that we have and certainly it's a malcolm to go through the sugar i'll tell you one child that we began with someone was driving to show a little late for chakras and he picked up he was embarrassed to say that he didn't yet 10 o'clock in the morning i mean christmas happy to listen to a kid but then he started thinking really allowed to think terror before birkin's entire life what is my status by listening to a person telling me advaita but it's a big beautiful sugar with many nafka meanes but we have to really clarify one important aside of course the most misfits almost all mixes need a deeper if you are it's a kid this you have to have a divorce say a barakah you have to have a debut merely thinking something is the question of hearer mach like is in the gemara breakfast and weep as can hear a lot of kadibir now this is in the remains says if a person mama never can talk so then you try the best you can and think think the broker you know people have problems with their with their voice that people have a pallet they can't talk for a few weeks which is rather good for selling bias what do you do with uh all the mitzvahs so says no do the best you can think but you're not really because hirola of khadibur so we have two extremes deeper is a is a premium way of in cairo mitzvahs and here you're not really you itself now the question is how do we identify when someone's listening to someone learn torah for example he's not a medabar he's not saying a word but then again it's a little more than here because there's someone talking maybe it's a shame and maybe it has the myla of shimayaka and one afghan it would be our case because to think torah without birth certainly allowed to to talk to you without berkshire is a serious issue what about listening to someone tell you so that's basically the question that we have to clarify today and i caution there are many in afghanistan so one thing i want to clarify that this is no doubt about it the concept of jamaica quotes a very powerful source because the possibility says that yoishiyoha melaflamed the torah ashakaramela yehuda frank di mariachio didn't lay in the torah shafon laned saktimar but since yoho was listening and you're allowed to rightfully write in the positive that that yo lane deposit the toyota now we have to appreciate for for an ish ms for tyra's you don't say he laned if he didn't lane but obviously if you put on your toyota eyeglasses and you see shame as a reality and your listened to the kriya you're allowed to write that he leaned it because you listened and it's like he lay in the toyota and this is a concept that we know throughout halakha in raishid gimbal racial tests ray shyam gimble guarding kiddish regarding abdullah regarding them magilla but the point is that we are it's so much america or you know you let us now you could also understand what the raspberry writes in the galaxy that when you say shame it's not a bad evidence because the moral says shimei kaina but let me make that a little more practical let's see a person arab pesach lail say lael er pesach he's lazy and he doesn't want to do buddhica so he gets a shliyak and he makes now let's clear in many homes on a weekly basis where many homes dominic is that the father says kiddish and his mighty the hobne bias even married children single children is that only be the other because the listeners are not saying kiddish maybe they're only even but it can't be because the raj says is making a mistake when i'm sitting on the couch and my shleaf is checking for me i did nothing that's mitsuba when i'm listening i am a very active participant i am listening i'll tell you the truth listening is harder than talking so i'm very involved in the mitzvah okay there's the kidneys of the oil stomach on raisha and gamaliel's it's it's lacking but la maison no i know i knew he was automotive for moisture he was a young teenager a mice invited in fish for the friday night sued them and her moisture said what's dominic in your family does each make their own kiddish or does one make he don't know where she was heading so he says my family we all make kiddish somebody says great you'll make kiddish and you'll be mighty myself and my rabbitson a young teenager why because emotion wanted roivam but he wanted to honor somebody else's minute so that was killer because they all three were you it's the boy now of course we are aware of the minute in many homes that each make their own kiddish and that's because we as human beings have a problem with our attention span and you might lose your concentration and already the rapture says that mr brewer mentions this so i'm not advocating one minute over the other but one thing i will say that she's very real but here comes the big question that we have to clarify do you want to give it a fancy name shamaya kaoina but rabbi did you make kiddish how are you yay so if you didn't say anything okay shimmery kinda but you know i have a mona but we don't know with him how does it work kosher there's a mitzvah of kiddushala kois you weren't holding any kicks i didn't see a curse why isn't i kidding warren for you so as you know a lot has been written about this but we're going to focus on one point that we have to clarify imagine after a long learning night on schwes and the queen is pretty tired he has an original idea he tells his brother who typically is always a korean he says you know what you ducking and you'll be made to me i'm going to listen to shame the original does that work in the countries at the end special countries on hanukkah and he says it doesn't work because even though she may have kaoina works because means with your listening you heard this by listening but but this is with a loud voice so it's reason to base the lady even if he says duchenne but he doesn't say it loudly he's not yet sir so if he's quiet of course he's not yo itza zak the steipler in killasayaki bro simon you'd gimmel evidently the basal lady understood the mechanics of shemeka oyena is i am yoitsa with my listening there are two currencies in shamayim you could say kiddish or listen to kiddies and both are equally valid so i'm yo it's my listening but if i have a perfect listening i still don't have coil rum so so in other words if you're listening and that's why it's mitsuboi but the basil levy is not the only one that says this this concept there's a meaning in some souls maybe maybe many shows the right way of right choice of word that when you're laying the megillah the balcore pauses when it comes to the series and the siba says hopefully and then essentials don't have the meaning but there's a minute in many souls why can't we be with the spirit and the question is even stronger because the rama has four places that the valkyrie pauses and the tsiba says various doesn't mention a serious benefit in southwest on the rambam is this is a beautiful point because it's not enough to lane as serious so even though the valkyrie says and you're listening to every word so you heard us but you don't have nishima akas so obviously the rugged shove understood that shame kaina works it's a transfer through the shmiah if the listener holds his breath as the balcore lanes maybe that makes it better but that's something that obviously is difficult so the rugged shovel like the basal lady understood chameleon who works with your listening and therefore you're lacking in coral rum and as serious now this sounds beautiful but there's an obvious problem because if you're yo it's with your shamia but you can't transfer physical realities so how could the shame be your it's a kiddish where's your kais if you can't transfer kawaram how do you transfer kais bishlaima shaifa you have to hit kaushal if you have to hold the shafa but how you it's a kiddish starts with a question why does shemehoina work does it work simply because you're listening or maybe whatever the mavarik the makadesh says you get his package his kiddish with all its details so the hazard says shame is more than just listening his beautiful lotion is it is smeared there's some type of connection because there's a valid chemical aina as an ish explains whatever he did you did it and the listen to a brilliant proof because let's say i'm listening to kiddish so you should know the meaning is that the mavarik makes holds of course and everybody listens but to wonders if each person has to be holding your car is to be it's a kiddish you don't have to say it but you have to be holding the kicks but we passing that you don't have to hold the case why not that's whatever he did you get credit so the choice is transferable then a bit apologetically but i must say according to my understanding i have akasha on the basal levy why does he say that a korean can be oita shimayuko oina by listening if you could transfer a kois you could transfer coil rum and of course we would add you could also transfer nishimakas and i think we could even add more than that if the navi writes that yo laned even though he didn't land so obviously the physical aspect is also transferable so if you could say he laned and he's holding a kais and there's karl rum so why can you say minishima is also transferable and the truth is that's why you'll see in many schools especially yeshivas they don't pause for the oil to say yes now just to give one marshall the sabres i think it's a good analogy how shimaya kaina works there's a beautiful concept based on apostate in the torah there's someone that's a bigger veer but he can't learn he's too busy so he makes the asakus bulan with the yasaka the asaka learns and he supports him now it's not just a tzedakah it's a partnership and this the usaka gets the uzbull and gets all the satori but not just yenneville but he gets the idea of vienna gets credited to this vulner they say a story of it one of the one big one of the big night vaughan in the belgian yeshiva who supported the yeshiva very generously he passed away and like i was that night he came to brigham village in a dream and he was you know shooting shasta poiskin so kaya woke up and said the next day told people i knew isakri's wound works obazo ishmael he's left a few hours and became a guy now going no but that's the transfer of swollen that's the aside of chameleon now of course the we realized that the basal levy and the rubbish of it didn't forget you have to have a choice it's probable that both are true it's a combination you go to with yeshmia but there's also a transfer of his mitzvah you get so basically now we understand how shame kind of works you're doing something very actively yeshimaya and you get his mitzvah now let's move on to our question a person is listening to someone say this before does he have to make berkshire is that is that a medal bear no is that a hero not really how do we identify that so our body side if you think about the concept of jamaica oina and you think about both hezbairam why don't we say that the person listening is doing something he's listening maybe i have to make breakfast around listening especially if i if i get his mitzvah let me tell you allah that probably seems obscure when you learn it but it's extremely relevant to all of our silas a person was given a job friday afternoon go table to kaylee and he knows and that's not always true but he knows his mikvah that he tells himself he's good for two less kaylee he decides to save time he's walking in upon me without clothing into the mic for the top of the kale and someone said what are you doing you don't make a broker but this myhriyah is also a shotgun he says you know i know someone's about to make a broke outside cadastrin has a table with kaylee so i'll tell him to make the broker loudly the door's closed you gotta make it you'll hear the bro in other words an aurum does not gonna make a barakah can he be it's jamaica aina and i i made that case because the mavari can make a brock on the mikveh now i'll make a broccoli even if no one's there i'm talking about he's outside and it's a perfect bracha so the sheila is when he can't make a bracha can he be so with jamaica so this is a mahabha listen so we can't make it why can't he share terrorism is going to make to do a mitzvah you have to make a barakah and even though bro broke his aim at voice but don't do that so get dressed and then you could make a broken shift so all the praise can say why don't you find an eighth for the seed let this aram sheikh and his ko shoifet who's in a different room who's the laddermaker broker will be made so i made up the story about the mikveh but this thing is is the poison so the priestha in the end of aleph yerudeya says yeah but that doesn't work because the one that's listening to the bracha is at least mahara you can't be mahara as as an aram so you can't be yay to the brach now rabbi said this is a big it's a plea is the right word because the character is a gemara carrot and this is a biggie sight for our sugy in shabbos kofun the gemara makes a blanket statement a person is allowed to be mahara and devaytora any situation except an unclean place whether it's a base akise or the old-fashioned america toys that were very dirty in the presence of sawyer then you not even think tired but when a person's in a massive with his a lack of sneeze even if he's he's allowed to think tayo ayo last manishtana the issue of making a broken a dirty place is there isa this is making a broker when there's a lack of sneeze is also their isa that you look at the pasik it's very obvious the difference means when you when you learn or make a broke it has to be a clean place so if it's not then nothing goes because as rashi explains he eaten always thinking torah but when it comes to torah or mitzvahs or brachas no thinking if it's not clean so here in the base like he said is absolutely awesome when it comes to the isa of aurum to make a bracha as an arm is a hundred percent awesome with their isa to think torah as an aram is mutha manataera and mirabano and this isn't this very basic helmet so in other words auram is allowed to think tire so this is a big kasha on the prison the preacher says you can't hear the brah because he's hearer but here is mota so they are hiraban or all say we don't understand the priesthood but you could say another hezbollah which is extremely regarded and your vamas kuf based there's a famous cloud of aina roy labila bila macevis b on this context means mixing if something has to be mixed and you don't mix it and you can mix it then you're not yourself you have to be able to do what you're supposed to do if you can't do it both still you're not your it's up if you don't do it so some points you want to say you know why you can't be it's a broke when you're listening because since you can't say it you can't be itself ain't roy labila bila marquez sounds great if you can't be say it you can't be arched by listening but it's not true because here we come to one of the manuscripts of schmidtkind hundreds of times every day someone's in the middle of davening so you can't foreign and say kadusha because it's going to be half sick so choice is quotes rashi no problem pause listen you'll have jamaica and euits who listening and they'll have sick great idea and we do that every day but frick we're paying the time and the reason is this make up your mind if chameleon works so to have sex if it doesn't work so why wasting your time so he says but the minute gets to listen and you don't fight with the minute and that became allah what do we see even though he can't say it you could listen to people got them in cough dallas if cotton zion that someone that can't say could usually could be your chameleon so who i so what's the problem with the arm so here we realize it back to our question why can't an aurum be it's making so again although the orange per se is not so negative but the aside we're going to learn is extremely relevant says that to usher one of the primary poison especially in simin aleph that you're right and he says if you only need hearer and if this only hearer then it's a person is thinking torah when he's not dressed perfectly mutter but when there is a debor so it's more than hero it graduated to a deeper so it says the foreshadow it's question if a person is not dressed then he thinks tyra perfectly muthu but if he's listening to sama make a bracha this is my hero but there's also a divorce oh now it's more than hero no good it's only pure hiromuta when there's any deeper it's worse then he says i have a better terrorist if you have to be it's the only with shemaya kaoina then you're not just a plain hero what are you you're an oina you're a mavarek you can't make a bracha oram so the first parish as long as there is a deburr that's bad enough the secondary is worse if you have to be kawaiina then you can't be auram if you can't be right by saying you can't be righteous and that's why la mais he spells out that the shaitan cannot be oh it's about listening says cotton base the in fact the parashar points to the famous sugiya in brock that by sinai even though here was muta but isis spells out but she may coin is worse why because if you need aina then it's worse than her and to quote the pacific ah mr brewer in two places in the beginning i'll quote spells out our sugar in a few lines a person is allowed to think taiwanese arum it's only here no it's not if you need shaymayaka oina and you can't say it you can't believe to jamaica so therefore we see and it's posted that a person cannot be it's a not sneeze i hope you realize that in a place that's dirty let's say this sawyer so you'd have to come on to the islamdus because even here is awesome certainly listening is us so that's khazerova that basically as we see hiro is not an acceptable form to be itself is not hero it's a step above and if you can't say it there's no shame now let's apply it la mais and i hope we'll have enough time to go through all the shadows one thing is possible the question i began that i added to someone in the mikvah can it be it's up with someone's broken outside avadanat that's come out of the first because you get his package with the kais so why can't i get his broke with his with his clothing so the turret says that you could transfer all miles in kiddish or all miles um but if someone's absolute if he's an aram so he can't get abraham forget about transferring he has a perfect bracha but you're imperfect you can't master a puzzle a person and that's why the khayodam seems to imply in valued base that is even possible with the evid if he did it he has to make another bracha because an arm cannot be height the next question which sounds not negay but says clearly it's awesome to say krishna davin say abraca in the presence why because before the advent of plumbing this is very common today it's a different world but i'll tell you a shout out i was a gay and aberdeen throughout the divers someone was thrown to jail and he's not leaving so fast and pardon me they don't have plumbing in those days so after a few days this the jail cell was was full of soya the hailey van ruttenberg was in jail for a long time what to do by making a broccoli the therapist is he is an ironist he can't make a broccoli but you have to make it in such a place when it when his tack asks sawyer i why can someone outside make a bracha loudly and be mutes him inside that's mama does not work now this is actually the ferrous there are more i intense see if aleph says that the shot is dappening there because it says the muscle and pardon me the sight in the basic nessus and again without plumbing these things happened but this vehicle is available he looks and it's out of his dalaramis he keeps on going i'm fine no you're not fine because people that are in the within dalaran so what do we see not only can make a bracha in the presence of soya but there's no shame coin so alva sugars came out of the pharisee but let's make this a little more practical you know sometimes i don't know that's part of the nefarious boy until you get to the family together to make kiddish and is there they're all over the place finally about them a kiddish and someone says i'm sorry that baby needs a diaper change that's a lush nikiya for saying that you can make this because this is in other words i'm talking about a real diaper capsule you can't make it and the father has had it he lost his patient says you know what take the baby out of the room and baby doesn't have to have kids anyhow i'm making kiddish you listen i can't wait so if the person was obedient listen to the father they probably weren't going to kill you even with the other because if the baby has taco jamaican does not work even with the habit hopefully we realize this when you're traveling in a car a plane a train whatever it might be and you have to change the dirty diaper of the child so you have to make sure they get rid of it before you make a broker that might be a contemporary now of course there are details a child that's a very a small baby doesn't eat food it's not soya and miracle is different than sawyer and if the toy is covered with a kissima alia then it's okay but basically this is the cloud next question you have a guest in your house and irreligious and you don't want to rack the boat you'll tell them you know what i'll make a barakah and you listen and you get the credit of the broker he's all excited but the problem is he's not ringing yamaka and you don't antagonize and put a yamaha you say you know i'll make the blessing you listen and you feel good about it then you say wait a minute he's not ringing yamaka we learned punk last week in fact it says in two places and sadik allah without a head covering so how can you make it or maybe you'll say he's not making a barakah i'm making i have a nice yamaka or maybe chameleon would say even that doesn't work so we have it right for toyota we have to go a little further and base base yoyos of sim and cuff pay gimmel quoting bala that the gemara requires for benching one of the many requirements is itof fracture bay says that of sounds like head covering but every broken it had covering so the basic ice if you know what it means put a hat or turban on top of yamaka i was covered for the benching mr murataka closed this besides the yamaki we were had for benching but the ramon dakamoisha says what can we learn simply to make a brocco you have to have a yarmulke but to listen to abraham if you don't need yamaka and there are more saying for benching even the listeners have to have an etuf which clearly implies that to regular bracha the chameleon could listen without a yamaka bach i don't understand that because if you hold shaymaya koina is like a mavari hamish a beautiful beautiful raya by listening you're not just listening hiro you're making a bracha and if an arm can't make a bracha a gilly rice can make a bracha so this is mamish in its case of torah there's a cuff bay gimbal benching and there's a shrita and islam is one is as real as can be you need to be dressed and a yamaka a is a little easier because unlike magnetic and rebecca gilray should only meet rabona so maybe jamaica in the works but it's hard to understand like if it's possible it's possible but the maester we definitely could say that regarding our guest like we said last week really saw my makeup with ariyama at all and the marshall so if you asked what should you do so if you could put them on the yamaha that's better but if that's not going to work it's probably better to say the brach and be mighty him so you have to start of course first of all some say and also we have at least that the yamaka is only for the mavores and not necessarily for the shame next question a person wants to be it's a bracha but the problem is that he's his hands are not clean i don't mean dirty from work i mean he can't make a bracha because he needs until you die dies before negovasa out of the bathroom a situation that his hands cannot make a bracha can he listen to abraham so basically this is the same you saw it if you can't say it such american doesn't work and take the ritual gimmel your test and the buchacha and cement pedal it spells it out that if you can't make a broke because your hands are unclean then you can't be yours with jamaica now i should mention that prima goddamn in kavdala zayan and kuffman seems to be a little more makel and his story is like i told you earlier it's only there born on maybe it does work and the cloud is one and the same if you can't make a bracha because of your condition whether it's aurum and hinoki if your hands are not clean you can't be always with your mayo coin i should mention also what the buchacha writes there and others say this also but to say on main with unclean hands is mutha which is very good a person comes out of the bathroom he's washing his hands and he hears them dabbing and saying kaddish you already answered kaddish before you wash your hands but to you it's a bracha that's certainly not next question again the same scenario you got the family together about the mckiddish and someone announces i have to go to the bathroom she say listen the kid is you listen and then go to the bathroom when a person is nitzrachman he has to go can he be outside by listening to someone else's kiddish what's we just learned so many examples if you can't say it you can't be right jamaica so it's right true comes again in the end of semen coup dalit and is it sorry maybe you're not saying it and it doesn't seem to be he sends you to the premier goddamn that speaks about your dying that are dirty but it seems to have a suffix you might be it's up even though it's literally and the plea is why is it different man is tandem if aaron doesn't can't be ho chi mai kainen and if there's a mocking up an enoki and and and kill the rice and unclean hands why is punk different so obviously i'm not going to tell you the rajbeer saskatchewan but he asked this question and he responded that he's saying a lot and those two that are half a line all the cases till now is the bazine for the barakah oraim malcolm zoya gilu royce but this that's an eternal no one knows now i'm certain he really means to say a stronger point because unlike all the previous cases ago of shane and noki mr mr writes as the fairish is at most and is there a bonan there's no iss of their eyes they're making a bracha and shayna noki so it's an ana it's only rabona and it's not knicker maybe that's why the mystery has a suffolk but the hindi kapoor ice cream i saw the baseball base ahmed rachel dallas says we shouldn't treat it as a suffix because if you can't make the bracha you can't be heights and don't forget we came out by the tillsyadayam and by gilda rice also either also the rabbanons so it's hard to be makel but i would say this usoid is that when there's a soul in the person if chameleon doesn't work if oina doesn't work then she may also doesn't work consider the next question we'll have this tough phrase in the beginning elaine and magilla even sitting but the price came sane but the brotherhood should be set standing i was covered in the brachu mr brewer and he's quoting the mogan abram but regarding the one that's listening to the to the megillah he also should stand up i am i'm making a bro why can't i sit so the answer is music that way is so if you want to get credit for magilla bro you have to stand now you might ask wait a second if coice and coil rum and everything else is transferable why can i transfer the amidah parrots is pushed la maisa if you're sitting that's the bazaar in the bracha there's a star in the bracha so you're sitting you're doing something wrong it's like almost like absolute and that's why it's clear there's something wrong with sitting when the when the maverick is making the you stand up for the brook and then you can sit because i'm paid for the rest of the megillah the ramos says the same idea without expressing it in kufrov zion and that's the meaning of ashkenazim many ashkenazim i should mention swardham afaquert because if you want to be yikes by listening you have to stand as well and again with due respect to those that sit is what to be saying says that when if you if you're you it's a with jamaican which you're not supposed to but if you're jamaica and a sphere you don't have to stand when he when he stands you could be sitting so why is mcgill a different so repdovacone has a a darker stick of art but then the point he says is if there's something wrong with sitting so then you have to stand but in the indian of svera it's a din in the midst of the myself the mighty estimates has to be done by media so as long as he's standing you're allowed to sit but the point is clear whenever you need amida generally this also has to stand next point is i find very challenging it's you do it before you learn taiwanese you have to make birks the mitsubishi to learn without birth but hero is without the now my question i began with if someone's telling me a beautiful kid is before i said can i listen or satire so if you think about all we said it really makes sense that this is not a because you're not just a regular hero that's muta you're a shimei koina you're hearing a yi tell you that hashem so if shame coin is real which it is you have a problem you can't listen to that kiddish you could think turvan is morgan but not to listen and allah spells it out this very island hashemaya devatora has to make abraham and then he says it even clearer even like the ogre sheet and i must tell you the ogre is the mechaba that hero is mutter without berkshire so even like to argue a lot of things but here this deeper someone telling you and you can't listen to your friends without beer in the end of simmons that says as well for david the karen the david and simon alex is a beautiful beautiful info he's i'll prove you mine obey that listening to toyota's when i the literal sense of the word they would listen to moisture being brilliant share but it was only listening the territory has a different understanding he says you the reason why there's no din of bersera on here is because it's not the way you transmit tire or learn torah because it's personal but he says but but giving a share and listening to hashir that's the derek ikitsura's talmutoya so listening to shia definitely requires beer now i must mention rapslama kluger have to do with this question and which rashid is referring to so let's look beautiful you saw it rashi says you allowed to listen to kedusha in the nest says if jamaica in the works it's a half sick soccer slam the kluger if you hold that listening to caduceus they have sick it's so real it's a half sick then it's so real and it's a torah but if you hold like rashi jamaica in the works but it's not f sick so it's not a deeper not a deeper it doesn't mean but the truth is most places don't say this and as far as possible even if it's not khadibramish but it's not hero only here doesn't require beerus more so even here are the growing holes is that toyota so the terrorists we hold only here is potter anything beyond that is kaivenberger my question is this fella was the rob was telling me this she's embarrassed to say i didn't say that he doesn't even islam could he have in mind to say i'm listening but i only want to keep it as here and no he's going to demote his rav into a hearer so the truth is it doesn't sound right because there is a deeper but i could do much better than that this is the first you sight of the twist said even though here is mutter it's only pure hero once you have a notch higher it's awesome this is undeniable there's a deeper once it's deeper you need bigger next question is a bit more tricky a person every morning gets into the car and drives to shore but he's a bent tire you don't waste time he always has vehicles there in his house and he gets into the car he puts on the the mp3 whatever the mystery whatever medium he uses and he listens to his shirt as he's going one morning you forgot to be satire so you don't give a stir as you're driving i missed your eyes you have to say it so have a good idea i'll listen to the tape whatever it is recording the question is can you listen to a pre-recorded torah of any sort phone mp3 before birksett so you're probably wondering what's the shiny we just spoke about that not really till now we spoke about a human being there's a chameleon this a pre-recorded sound you're not you're it's a imagine person listens to the software of the dollar from touching your tests very dehydrated but you can't be able to have a dollar with that so there's no shame so maybe it's takamoto but the truth is it makes a lot of sense the way we said certainly that th the the starting point is only here is a period once you have more than hair it's no longer here here you have a micer a machine a lasagna machine but there's a deeper and i take a saw i don't know where to find this more than this is a macar neman because it is mccartney but in the dear mister menzai ten they quote a letter from absolutely if you listen to a data on a colettas or a telephone you beer saturday loyally by like the going it's at least hero but even without the going he says it's also high in beer now again it's a very brief tuva but i think he's saying very simply it's only here is mother anything more needs beer satori restaurants almonds only suffic and this was written many many years ago is because since the reason you haven't been when you hear a shirt is that the derek of limara toyra it's not a derek to listen to a recorded cheer but tire eden and top shin pay bass i would say most of our learning is over the phone or in in pre-recorded children and you know during during covet i mean there's a yam of torah that's transmitted so it's certainly a dara khalimut so knows the point is it is laid to grow avadish and even the dam it's only here and not once it's beyond that the next question is also tricky but very negative without getting into the details but we live in a world rahman a son of poets in a very real sense during the summer especially the streets look the way they look and the planes and the trains because i'm talking about a very specific case that's unfortunately unavoidable a person's going on the train and there are fruit prudesim short sleeves i don't go into details but a place you know that i learned but it's of an issue or a yiddish woman uncovered here the kitsa when there's an is their abundant to learn because of a lack of sneeze even if it's not airbus devamish there's an isla bonon in many situations iron sim and i and hay the question is to learn is awesome can i think twire in that situation absolutely someone asked me but like the going here khadibo how could you think tyra i said you're making a mistake the guy didn't argue on a gemara is a mitzvah but this deposit says air vas dava di is can you listen to a recorded share or your friend is sitting in a different in the beginning at the front of the plane and he's an interesting fellow he tells you you know from seats away he's in a he is in a kosher position but you're not can you listen to someone saying when he is so you probably want we just learned this why is this different so here i would say i think it's possible that listening to a pre-recorded share a phone or mp3 is probably because here the only isa is once it's not a debor anything is motto it's just the opposite of beer beer everything is except for here here the pasta says what's us deeper it's not evil so listening to a tape should be definitely mutton unfortunately i couldn't find this and placed him but i think it's push it variety of samba zaman said let's say you go into a train and you're not allowed to learn the train because this is there's a threat you take out a bigger more and you keep your eyes and you learn from the moving your fingers you're involved with your learning is that mutter yes are you learning it's not people so why is this different might be true and this i'm sorry maybe it's even more to listen to your friend tell you even though that's a physical shame but is that considered deeper or not that like oh so that's taco much worse because that there is a real deborah but certainly the case of the train when you're listening to a pre-recorded share or phone whatever it is the heart that'll be pushed that that's not a violation of this issue question again yeshiva in a camp with a make-up dollar for the islam in bismarck and you know it's very actually even a camp it's hard to get your own wine and and fire and basement but the fellas are militia in astra and he wants it's the the abdullah now but most vanessa what are you doing so he makes a xerox shovel you're allowed to listen to kadusha thanks foreign esther i'll listen to abdullah so i heard the child of someone said he made one's kiddish in his house shabbos morning and his daughter was doing music but she was a lamb dennis and she listened to his kid is during her music what she hates could be in the show a person is a little dabbing man as he wants why not kiddish but here we come to a dove nephilim simon tess points out twice it didn't say she listened to kadusa gazunte no problem he says there's no that jamaica is not a half sick but the circumstance what are you doing again mr eisen so listen see it's only mutha when the mini was to be makel but abdullah so make a dollar later if it's difficult so it's from sarah aguero here not only he says it's the sambas the shabbos twice says this that if you could make abdullah or kiddish later don't be it's uh with shame even though kadusha works kittish is different and garcomay found the das toyo the genre of russia and gimbal sea vault has this sheila a person her kid is in the middle of schweinster he says it's not a good idea just to pause and listen because if you could avoid it you're supposed to avoid it you now you understand let's say a person heard kiddish and then asked to shiloh this this person's daughter so all the greeks she's hates them because it's good but it shouldn't be done and taka swordsmen shabbos adds that as well and his rules will be pushed if let's see a person knows he will not be able to have wine later could he be eight would have dollar now it's either now or never that would be something like kedusha abduvid's kind of though finds an air motion gimbal a striking question if we saw macbeth not to make have sake him why does nusa svard blow kias during the muslim of rosh hashanah why don't you because for it to have sick so david answered him back but he has said if you don't eat jamaica so even if you stop and listen there's no shiloh of shame going to be half sick so why not do that may that's your medic i also wonder taco why isn't that a half sick my sister better time is right you're listening to me if you understand the simple reasoning of shame in your youth with your smear shimmy is terrific which means that i have sick so why is it a half-sig but even like the basal has an issue understanding you get his deeper with all that he do him but you didn't speak have sick is totally in debor mitchell is tully in shmia so the f is not a half sick next question but more tricky because you do it when you have a suffolk breakfast you know an activated chocolate on the coffee or what's morning we make a torah issue we get someone that was has to make the brooklyn and he has the mind so i'm here jamaica and if i don't need it it's not a problem fractal and the view the broken stuff half of my baby's he had a moana that shamaycoin is a real broker why doesn't it sour i'm gonna bottle but he himself writes that that's not correct and the question is why not so the basic terrors the same turrets [Applause] you didn't say shame hashem i always give a muscle imagine you go here someone laying in the magilla and he's yelling saying my grace kavanagh and when he finished his horse okay are you also horse shoemaking that doesn't transfer physical aspects don't transfer so that's why le meister you could be a it because it does add grada when you're you eat the tomato going to have a mind but tonight if i don't need to shame a corner i don't want it to be something and that would add but really it's not unnecessary listening to abdullah i told you which way karen is perfectly mutter i once won the people are very busy with sorry shabbos and sometimes the husband is making a doll and the wife has been in the table but she's listening that's wrong for two reasons first of all you have to listen if you don't listen but also says quote in quoting the ramban just like the one that's mavor of during so too the listener now this is beautiful because apply to the mavar and to the shamaya equally a common question if someone listened very dutifully to the kid abdullah but did not say amen but the evid when you heard the kiddush but didn't say i mean and the answer is simply zilbasa timer why you yay to jamaica and it's not domain you're not used with one word but you get his package so why is it made necessary of course it's wonderful and it's a plus but mccabe is a vegetarian gimmel that reminds me if he didn't see our main he would be you it says well i'm gonna leave you with food for thought i'm not going to get into the details but it's too beautiful to give up and thank you a fella gets up in the morning he got up to the wrong start a little faschlafen he's in shul holding the coffee he forgot if he made a shackle on the coffee over 50 moment to call in english he knows what to do but he's embarrassed he has something invites him because he's already laid as if they're all daughtering but he's a very crafty fellow she goes over to a person about to put on his palace says my pleasure but is wondering he's not holding the tallest he's holding the coffee but he has what they get to see so the it's about and our coffee fella like salutes them thank you shockingly was worried and you live happily ever after does that work why are you laughing zil busta timer why can't jamaica in the transit have a bracha i'll say i never heard of it you did hear of it every purim if you miss the word of the megillah what do you do you add the word so we see deeper does work in braches and in the two of us is zim and zion but the pella is that sadiq dalit steve gimmel based on twice this says that khatsi braha you can't add up to hatsey brothers but you don't make a preamble vegan so fast you didn't forget that the terrorist is very positive if you have a full broker but you're missing a word or two you could supplement it if someone's swallowed over and you listen to kiddish so add the word but to add two halves doesn't work to make this eight surface brackets no one says this there are different ages listen to someone else or or we would go walk out make a shiny marker but no one says make half braces the teres vegas besides the fact that his shame hashem was on a palace not in a coffee but besides that you can't add up two halves and therefore it's not an option that doesn't talk to you [Music] hey few weeks is on the beamer otherwise we started from the campaign for the refugees in the world emergency campaigns and thousands of reasons we're running away from the war in ukraine and getting help funny [Music] is [Music]