How We Count the Three Years of Arlah - Gemarah Rosh Hashanah 9b 10a

the yeshiva dotnet their Shoshana Duff Tessa mad bass and one two three four five six seven and eleven eleven lines from the bottom the line starts with hooks largest two dots villain idea the Gemara continues to unravel and decipher the words in the mission so till now we discussed the opening of the mission which said that there are four dishes summers on the first of mrs. Richard Shauna for kings and for holidays and the first of ellos wish Hashanah for my supper Hema even though the velocity of Shimon disagree and they say that it's only on the first day of Tishri on the first day of Tishri such a summer for years Rosh Hashana for schmitter and there's a sauna for even the 50th Jubilee year begins on Rosh Hashanah and it will end at the end of the year at the end of that year and not continue with all of the whole office of Yeovil discussed the next line in the Mishna says that the first day of Tishri is a Shoshanna limit Tia and then we'll have one more which is Leah raucous that's going to be the last one what is limit ear the Tia literally means for that which you plant that would you plant but actually vegetables Yosa plant when the TIA means a sapling which means a young tree the Tia is a young tree what is the concept here of Rosh Hashana rashly already told us in the Mishnah it's dealing with the years of our law this is a whole new racial shun it has to do with our losses of arla what are the halacha so Varla we all know that the Toyotas says in part Shas where is it partials condition partials kadosh of the trailer says that every single tree that you plant the first three years from when you planted the tree all fruits that grow on the tree are off-limits to the Jew he can't eat them nor can he even sell them and benefit from them the trees are called the fruits are called Arlo Arlo literally means as Rashi says a partial condition it means plugged Ataman stuff like something plugged in the sense that the person cannot have any that some of these fruits it's uh sir again by Juma and OSA Bono you actually destroy the fruits the first three years from when you planted them what about the fourth year three years passed what about the fourth year the fourth year the fruits are called Netta reavoice revived from the word Arbor the fourth the fourth of the planting in other words the fourth year after the planting method avoid now the fruits become holy actually you could eat them but their holy they have the same Iloka like mice or Shanee like the 10% that you segregate that you tithe from your produce and you have to bring to your shall I am and eat it they're these fruits you have to bring to your show lion and eat the fruits are there or conversely if you have a lot of fruits and you can't slap them so you could redeem the fruits on money confirm the holiness of these fruits on money and then the fruits are regular fruits that you can eat wherever you want you bring the money to your salon and you buy their food and you eat it in your salon then you have the fifth year and the fifth year you're good to go it's regular mundane fruits like we have here and you eat the fruits stop just to know our law doesn't apply only tell you sir the dinner of our lives also outside a vegetable if you plant a tree in your garden you plant an orange tree or any other tree the first three years you can't eat the fruits and you can't benefit in the foods the difference between full arts and artists all is Suffolk our law the Carlo night to suit all you now let's eat Safa Carlin cooks Lars is fine welcome I should missing therefore we can go in anywhere in America into a food store and not ask questions I need to fruit I it's possible that maybe the fruit is coming from the first three years that's true but it's not a problem sulfa Carlin cooks Lawrence is yeah if they're not you have to make sure that it's not our love and excess stuff so now when we say it sirisha sundar for Allah what do we mean the church on the farm the what would be or Shoshanna for Allah let's say I plant my tree on Purim I plant my tree put him Tufts and I involved so women's are look I would think I wait for him Tufts my enzyme one year poor Natasha is s two years per thousand nine in test three years any fruits that came out during that time the fruits that come out after that look fine or whenever the date that's what you would think so the mission comes and says no the first day of stitches there's a summer for Arlo what would it mean if she's on a furlough this is a big finish this means that if I plant my tree before Hashanah that Risha Sun is considered a new year in other words let's say I plant my tree tests love of the fifteenth day of of a particular year Rosh Hashanah comes the tree only exists for a month and two weeks basically six weeks I planted to buff right two weeks later Tsar straightish Ellen there's another month of Ella the tree is only six weeks old not a year so the mission that comes and says the first day of Tisha is Rosh Hashanah limit II it's considered a new year this is a new year in other words we know she summer comes near to begins year two and year one ended year one lasted not a full calendar year but mom is six weeks or if it was early it's a little more time it has to be more than 30 days before this is shown as we will see but if it's more than thirty days let's say I plant the trees off test of right in a month of tests ello and one basis is Shana it's a new here already now there's a sudden I start counting here - Wow that's unbelievable so how did you gain a significant amount of time here so basically I plant it when tough test of Tufts and I involve right tough test of the day this year after soft option I involve richer Sean becomes richer sonnet option I ins ioan this is already considered the second year that's what Raschi already explained in the mission sama lamaa t now we have to understand why why and why again why a competition a what's this mother what's the logic while it has I'll come up with this etcetera sucked the Gemara Russia Shyamalan it validity rabbit issues or Shoshana also vanity a meaning if I plant in a month above when I could officially comes it's considered that I completed a year practical more than me Nolan how do we know what's the source of this based on what and for the you Meredith it says in passions condition painting test positive Gitmo I'm gonna read the whole pasta if you have the sukham on the side you could follow inside I'm gonna read the whole pasta because the Gemara only quotes a few words select words octopus but he serve all you allotted she come to the land when the top ten colleagues my hope you're going to plant every tree to produce food by route very Eltham or lossless period you have to stuff up its fruit Shola shun and ye love Mi Rae Lim lawyer for three years it should be arrayed limb for you you should not be Oh Bosh uh no Harvey is on the fourth year year call period Kurdish she Lulu Masha all the fruits should be wholly hey Lou Lamar Sam a praise for God meaning you have to bring it to your shall I am and eat it it is not regular mundane food it's food that has to be eaten with Nana Shem in Yerushalayim just like my society and then he continues Hashanah commish's on the fifth year it's all belongs to you it's your fruit and and and you're free to do with the food as you wish that's what the posix what does the comodo gonna say here so I think Amara deceive shalosh Sun in my reign three years it should be I read books if the next bus successful box on our vehicle period fetish so you have you the word summer by natural ie by Shana Harvey's you have also the word summon by our look so like some NIM oh by son RVs the yeah live Sun nurse on the matere we learn now dogs Irish Sava the Shana that says by these sukham from the summer that says by today and apparently it would seem that the Shana is extra because it says so economy look I'm irate limbo Yakko and then it says by Shannara V is it could have said for example who by Revere's you understand it would be Sean solenoid it seems like the Shawna's extra whenever we have an extra word we say let's explain it so we have Xavier Shover of another place it says informa tion and then we applied this sonnet to this summer we learned this journal from this time where's the other son yeah live shall not summon me Tishrei with an automaton related exhibits as a purchase a curve may gracious Hashanah that era too slow we learned before I destroyed as the land that a neshama laquet abominations our son no but after Hashanah and the Gomorrah said what's relations our son of a doctor son that means Russia son of tisha that's cool gracious our son why cuz we explained what does it mean Malaysia - son of a doctor - Sean and that what that he decides what's gonna be from the beginning of the it'll end of the year and the question is when is the beginning of that year and the answer is we saw it - he'll and pay our Tico Buffet the chauffeur by Kessel am car game ok cochlea Snohomish pot mich mult lilyc a Yaakov and that's Tacoma Fighters chauffeur did that reduce when you blow show for that rich traders that's a holiday by Castle am again which is only one which is better petitioner so ratios are son is when the estimate issue so we learn out sauna from sauna sauna oven a curve is what the beginning of the year what's the year the year would be Titian it here it says my son our reveal is the fourth year Cal period or solid Sun in my Raylan what year you say when does the year begin we say a special mr. Shanker Gregg the your mother believed my Shauna Shauna me listen why don't you learn our son our son affirmed listen to achieve the success in passions but I've heard this a seller Kamaraj Nadar Yishun hula hemlock ah Cheh ha Shauna and fatigue Amara done in sauna Shana mahadesh commissioners anemic adults faint done in sauna Cheney mahadesh emission regime of Hadassah it's always preferable to learn Xavier shovin that says Shauna with is no mention of months from Hashanah with his no mention of months for example by shauna reveals from Rachel's Hashanah rather than learn Xavier shovel from asunder with his no mention of months like Hashanah service from Hashanah where there is mention of month which is regional of Hemlock accession by or Lynette because over there the focuses on kasha months here the focus is on a year by our Lynette Iroquois and by nations are shown of Tishrei there's no mention of months by missiles I mention of months so I have two ways to do my Xavier shovel this is what gets preference according to the logic of interpreting Tyra and hence we China when do the three years and three years of our law when do they begin when do they end they begin on Rosh Hashanah and the same is true with Natalie so we learned that out from Tishrei and not from Miss of course of there would be no other Shana you would use will cut your son we have a choice so what's the preference the preference is to go to this one that has no months this is other needs for explains the remark okay now we have to understand the practicalities of area so what does this mean it doesn't mean that all our love begins on Rosh Hashanah although begins when I plant the tree it says you plant the tree if three years it Sarla so what did we say you plant the tree and of or an ear and say plant a tree on my boiler mr. Sun is the end of the first run it begins the second when when does the second year end when there's a second year whether it's a sauna again and when there's a third year at the next verse Hashanah so from my boy Mathilda Shoshanna I have one year there's your son attrition sudden have a second year yeah but now I have another year till the next recession oh that precious Shana finishes three years even though it's not three calendar years it's really only two years and a few months because I planted my true life boy I'm right but after that that second is your son of that past I'm good to go and my early years are over and I can eat the tree that's little you know what we understand now Marc Namie Tamar's gonna go into a whole circuit to really analyze the dynamics of how it works with Arlo because it's a little more complicated than this something tomorrow turn a knob on the rabbi is taught in a Bryce we'll see we'll see it's not so simple but we'll see yeah that's you're gonna be exploring them talking to that one effort on it a this is a costume of nice African a taya one who plants which means somebody who plants a nutrient new sapling in the earth akadama virile somebody who bends after the market and somebody who grafts there are three different planting dynamics that are described here one is Nydia maverick and marcus what's the difference my taya means from scratch take a seat seat of an apple say are you planting an apple tree or any tree in the ground from new to new reality a new creation that's my take what's maverick maverick is you bend what's called a thing layering in English yeah what are they called layering probably called layering you take a branch from our pre-existing tree and the grande should take you lower it you bend it into the earth and then you bring it out at some point so what happens now is ultimately this new brand that is now coming out of the earth ultimately develops its own roots develops its own roots in the ground and it becomes an independent tree once it develops its own roots you go and you cut it off you cut off the branch from its connection to its mother to its original tree and it becomes its own meiosis it becomes his own master an egg in a tub a story becomes his own guy that's called Marcus that's called I'm sorry maverick so again you bend the branch you put it in the earth it takes root in the earth it comes up and then you cut off its connection to the original tree so it becomes an independent tree that's called maverick then you have marked if mark if in English is called grafting what do you do the average tree create a hole in the trunk of the tree on some part of the tree and you feed into that hole a branch from another tree in other words you mix marker from the word hardcover which means synthesis like if to mix to bring together two things hybrid so here you take a branch from another tree you bring it in you penetrate you create a hole in this tree and you stick in that branch from the other tree into this tree and what now happens is this branch contributes to this new tree see you now she limit iam in know when the recession or sluggishly maverick crayfishes has made its part it's occurred in proof ena you bend the the twig that branches into the earth it's called proof ena now if even baka Vader should create an initiative here you graft one tree in another tree this rat she calls initiative so I make a hole in the tree I take a soft branch from another tree I stick in that branch into this hole and basically this branch the soft branch grows in the tree that it was brought into ah Athena's propagate propagates through fitna propagate which is which is maverick you propagate you propagate the branch market means to mix what are you gain yeah you get the type of species that comes from that branch with this tria no no that's fine this is fine to put a branch of the trees for maverick you have in purchase purchase hi Sawyer yeah what does a yes you do by average as McMullen by average has AG malum right so it means rivets he allows the animals to the Tamils to relax the crouch to meal to come down so here maverick is the branch Neil's you bend it in it comes into the earth of I Africa said now know many of market which is mixer so you have here three different ways in which new trees are being produced one is mama sure new tree and one is maverick and one is market what's the hollow love is and if she is if you did this the year before schmitter the year before the seventh year beginner slice some young life nourish your son at least 30 days before Shoshanna when Schmidt to begins so let's say you did any of these three things on to Bob or professor all solution the next month is considered the first year is ended and and now Rosh Hashana begins the second year in terms of our law now this doesn't have to do with area of trees and additives fees this would be any air any year when you plant the tree or you graph the tree boy you propagate a tree 30 days before the Shoshanna when there's a Shana comes you finished a year also leshawna and Shunta start you second you have higher why in the world is the price of mixing in any of shriya's why are you mixing me up with another myself with Schmidt because there's gonna be another hollow there a separate out locker outside of Arlen that has to do with Smith so the Bryce is mentioning energy is only because of the second stands that we're gonna learn who metallic imma and that's the thing you're allowed even though you plan to this tree and if she is metallic I'm members she is you're allowed to let it exist through our Twitter usually the how love is that a tree that you planted in Schmidt or right before Schmidt than when you weren't a lot of plant that you have to uproot it you now rather believe it because it was planted as a it's a prohibited substance was planted by is she after prudent but here since he planted it not on Schmidt and not even right before Schmidt but thirty days at least before Schmidt to began somewhat till the time of mystery is he allowed to leave it on shriya's it's not a problem what happens if in all of the years you planted it puff this machine um the flourishes on less than 30 days before is your Shana loyal solution the year is not complete unless you're sana so you have to wait till the Tishrei of the next year they have to wait till the tisha T over the next year to finish your first year for Arlo so let's say I plant them tree on tuft SLO or test evolve a low there's only two weeks finishes Sharma I don't send us your son that came my year is up and there's your summer begins the second year no I have to wait till the next year tests love Elmo and Rosh Hashana and that's my first year so the first year is actually longer than the calendar here it's a year in two weeks or a year in one day or a year in 20 days depends when you planted it in the middle of l1 but your first year begins only next to something but also like Shana and therefore if it was before Schmitter also like anniversaries you're now gonna leave this sapling around on shemitah and you have to uproot it like a tree that was planted on trees ah you planted it before shemitah Toto says you know planted planted before Schmitter but here we have the concept of theis for Schmidt you have to be mice if McConnell r-ky dish like we learned before we've all said it said but I'm sorry Becky Bessette said but about cancer tissue ice so he says what does it teach you that there's a concept of toys mysteries before and after so there for 30 days before I have to add from Crayola Chi dish and hence if I plant the tree within 30 days I would have to uproot it on shriya's but if it's before aunt Orla I don't get that full year when Russia Shana comes after wait till the next choice virus not to separate dinner one hour loss there's about every single year it's gone it's Ned you killed it yeah uproot a tree doesn't live it's over it's not again I'll anymore now she says also a sauna also they son Kevin she gave him as a petitioner also a son on the minions a ARLA your first year is up now you start your second year pocus mineral oil solution odd Tish may have bought you have to wait till the next Tuesday aina and if she is if it's not enough she is because if it's error-free is you're not waiting for anything it's gone it's over under wait if it's a regular year not ed of trees you have to wait till the next issue being nf3 you see Aucilla kindly you can't keep it why we're someplace the spheres because we add on tetrameter so my city my final okay this and therefore cut off time is 30 days we have to understand why 30 days why not a day one in a week one in three weeks for some 30 days ok good question but there's a principle of most of McCullough here's a go more explored before but hardship makutsi teach boys and therefore I cannot beep this tree if there was planted within 30 days of shoes no both said that both said it types of trees the question was just will you learn enough if you look at the gomorian of tests Amidala right the Commerce's the hudson about constitutes so that McKeever says it teaches you that the plowing and the harvesting of elefseus and post Vyas is awesome be small uses it for something else Sidhu Marty says how does it be small moment system o'clock cuz she knows it's from Ian kipper you write you write something about it What's Up motivate the price of continuous you know here we're throwing a little bit of a curveball with pay this matias zoom and the fruits of the sampling which you planted thirty days before the Shoshanna and I emphasized that according Tadashi the fruits of this sapling which use planted at least 30 days before the Shoshanna I'll sue them out commish us abyss rods they become forbidden till the 15th day of SH raft whoa so sounds absolute has the fruits of these saplings I'm now waiting for ARLA to finish so I have to wait till the time things they have swapped what is he saying well he's saying this first of facts before the explanations I planted my tree tuber of tough shin myeon better to barf Tufts in summer tests I planted a tree i grafted a tree Maile in a tree I propagated a tree shut to Bob so I have a month two weeks I'm good to go Rosh Hashanah top Senayan starts my second year right and cause the month and two weeks gave me a full year Varla or Shoshanna Luna T is now as a second year so there's a sonnet option ayan starts you to wish your sonnet option I in olive starts year three I have a second full year term mm I love starts year three when should gear three end there's a sonnet option iron base Hashanah tough senayan baits all fruit still addition salmon Tufts nine Bay's garbage Arlie any fruit that appears on the tree after is your son a Tufts 9 base should be net terabyte I can eat it I take a new dish a lot there's some at Tufts night in Gitmo the first year ends every year told us any food tillage is on the top line given life they clearly supply a food that appears on the tree post research on assumption IMO it's all got that the fifth year fifth year ended comes the Bryson says Sinister's I push it the fruits that you planted 30 days before Hashanah or more don't think that when tourists shun is pass the first research saw no one here is up second Rosh Hashana the first original year is up now to Russia Shawna's pass and you're good no no no no you have to wait till Commission established fact so when I said that there's shown at Tufts 19 base reshawna tops 9 was your first year mister Charlotte option I an olive is his second year it's not a tough client base you finished three years not three full calendar years but three years for Allah so look like right after his return to Tufts my in base I'm good so now it comes the month of Kislev or the month of tailors or the beginning of shrouds of Tufts in iron Bay's and a fruit appears on the tree right the fire there take the - shall I am visit eight we say no no no no till to Bush rot this is garbage this fruit is garbage to be swapped a continent silicon which I was reduced reddish lot we're gonna follow to be schwate because I'm off just like this civil but yeah according to my Xiaomi would be would be the stress right Rebecca Vegas Esther but till then the fruit is considered our law in other words the our law extended afternoon Shoshanna till to be swamped so that means if I'm looking at my fruit and I see this a fruit that even started to but even if it's not right remember even if it's not right let's say you're daleks rot there's a fruit what's called Kanata kanata means the flower fell off you don't have a ripe fruit yet it's just the beginning of the emergence of the fruit but it was before to b'shvat so what's the halacha this is our low this is ARLA now the fruit let's say becomes right to Nissen or an ear this fruit has to be best to go to this fruit is has been destroyed there's nothing to do with it nothing to do with it your typhus in other words yes the 30 days helped me that it made my year shorter but it didn't help me so much it's not like I completely get rid of a calendar year and all after wait is a month no no because I'm gonna have to make that up till to Misrata in other words I'm gonna have to add after the Shoshana Tishrei tessarin kiss live Tavis and half of shot four and a half months it still I gained a lot I basically gained if I planted my tree my super off right I only had two weeks in a month basically six weeks and then another few months and I'm gone I still didn't have to wait a full calendar year right if I would I had to wait a full calendar yeah I would have to wait till to buff top Senayan base I left to it summer test iodine Alif iron base but I came to half a year so you want to know if he planned to say his tree in the catchment or Kistler repairs now what happens let's say it was tough since summer tests right so when did the next year begin Rosh Hashanah right mr. Shana less than a year so stuff should I it so now you have it is your son a tough Senayan you have is your son a tough Senayan Aleph this two years are over there son of Tufts nine days you would think three years are over do you say he has to wait till Cashman which would that could be I or Laura Cashman kiss love Tavis which would be three full years right why make him suffer more he did three for you so you say no to be spat is the time it works both ways it works for your benefit it also works for you that remit right well you would be Marshman now the two big fat would be the date to be smart would be the date what you have to wait for in order to get out of our law right so there is your son is only for the beginning not for the end for the end you waiting for to be swapped now that's a good question what's this whole like what this is very confusing now you say what do you call me bad a petition I mean what do you need that competition if okay good but these are all the problems here now one more thing this is for ARLA but the same would apply the next year the fruits that appear before to b'shvat have to go to the garbage because there are low the fruits that appear after to be scrapped have to take to your shall I oh yeah when is the fourth year beginning so we say you don't wait till recession you wait till to be scrapped so that means till this to be smart everything is our law after to be shot it's considered not to avoid for another year right so anything that appears any fruit that appears till the next year to be smart after this to be scrapped after take to your salon I don't say that Rosh Hashana top shinai in Gitmo I'm good to go it's five years no no no shot at Tufts Megan well it's still the middle of your fourth year that would be shot Tufts nyan gimel to be smart that's when your fourth year ends and fifth year your good outcome this is what this line just said Oh pay this in the Tia's ooh a certain octopus back in LA our Allah our Allah Emily avoid Leroy whether we're dealing with the first three years so we're dealing with ARLA or we're dealing with the fourth year which is revived Rashi explains paid is Matias suicune ah for peace of mind also Lozano even though we just said that if you plant it before 30 days before there's a son of 30 days before this is on there more you have a year remember one in income tuba paid us laughter is your son shall Sunnis licious fiat I die in a pseudonym alumnus mission Marlowe what's fun to come to means fruits begin to bond I'm not asking them to be right even though they're not ripe they just begin to bud when after it should Shona of your third year in other words you're good to go you had we should summit option high in yet we should shun the Tufts and I and I'll live you have Richard Shawna Thompson I in Bay three years so now after there's a son I see a fruit Rashi says i sir in Haines alumnus it's forbidden forever I for Patricia Shana tissue in a TIA even though you just told me there's a shun is delicious on a furfrou saplings that's above rot research on allele on to be sweated a Hashanah for the tree bazooka Varanasi sila and this now graduated from a sapling into a tree the fief of ain't some amiss Kadesh nation also miss cardassia's lots is me they are allowed to be smart so therefore her new year when she could leave the status of our law and going to the status of Rivoli begins after to be shmatte album is Shambala how long what if after to be smart the affinity to pop areas if you're gonna come to your tree you're gonna see new fruits coming out didn't revile a.m. la cabeza y they have the din of metal voice over test valve leshawna Jabara the next year test love Yeats uma de Rivoli paid us a ha Newton ba McConville next year till to be smart it's part of natural voice after to be smart it's part of the fifth year the COS phi e lu la la Mitchell if name is Shoshana this is what we mean that the 30 days we finish Hashanah help what do they help chemin my head had taken me to be suave Audrey Shoshana basically it cuts off the Hector I mean it shortens the Hector from to be smarter Hashanah which is more than a half a year it's seven and a half months seven and a half months you gain you don't have to wait those seven and a half months why because you started 30 days before this your shopping you started 30 days before the show only tree fruits are low me applies to trees so what is rashly saying that since to be sponsorship some early llamas so therefore we have to consider here on nutrition what's a shot to be strategy Shoshanna Lila honest so that's going to be later in the Gemara to explain but what's the point that's relevant here the point is that trees have their own rashanna that's not connected to other issue Shamas when it comes to vegetables or comes to grain over there Rosh Hashanah is a competition what do we mean vegetables which I'm as mathematician I think it means in terms of mice and it's very very negative because let's say tough Shan ayan is for me year to top shinai and Aleph is year three for my Schmidt or whatever the husband is year two I have to give my sash a knee you three have to give my surrani so I have to know when it's cut off time so let's say I collect my vegetables I pluck my vegetable stuff tests ll out of nutrition now give my sachet need I give my Sami is a year to a year three let's say collected in Cushman it's a click didn't Thomas what's what is it the answer is at the petitioners cutoff time any vegetable I collected a day before is to any vegetable a day after is year three not only that I can't mix the two I can't give my sir from one year for another year it's two separate piles I'm now allowed oh I have to give my so from each year so that's when it comes to vegetables when it comes to grain as well when it comes to grain when it's cut off time cut off time is Rosh Hashanah but grain is different than vegetables buy vegetables it's always when you pluck it when you take it off the tree when you take it off the plant not the tree by grain it's when it reached a third when it became to a third that's the cutoff time when did it reach a third didn't reach a third before the first day of Tisha after you reach the third after the first day of Tishri it's a new year to reach the third before the first day of Tishri it's the old year so a person had to really have Hegeman of how cashman comes to trees we make also addition I have to have the same question I have fruits I have apples fresh apples doesn't go to my sachet me does it go to my surrani you say oh when did it happen I have to ask one question did these fruits appear on the tree after to be Swatow before to bhishma let's say this year is a year of a third year this is the third year Schmidt right the third year it's my sir or me not my sashimi if the fruits appeared before to be shot then it belongs to the previous year if the fruits appeared after to be fought belongs to the new year was that finish Hashanah for to be fought not for trees Titian doesn't have trees here Mattia is not a tree natee is a sapling that's a baby tree that's gonna be the difference here so when it comes to our law our laws also forbade retreats called anitya sapling by the way usually you're not gonna get fruits from a tree for the first few years stomp it sound like Arlo's a big loss usually most trees it's not the trees are not easy trees are long-term investments right that's the definition of a tree the famous story with finding a mango yeah the planting of the tree 70 years so you have fruits that it takes decades decades to produce so some the first three years usually not gonna get fruits and also the fruits that you're gonna get are very inferior quality I think there are bond rides that's the simple reason for our low because of health the first three years they're usually not good to fruits that's a very practical reason for there's other reasons file huh yes the are that could but many can't I think most can't right away yeah passion comes and passion goes right right no no Arnold is not my stylist is garbage forgive my sofa all those garbage it's destroyed he's destroyed the burner you can't even have enough of it now my soul starts after so four trees is only for fruits fruits that come from a big tree a ripe tree of a color mature tree not a baby tree I'm a church tree that's cut off time so any fruits that appeared before to be scrapped or the previous year any fruits that appear after to be sure what does it mean appear that the flower a flower is not called appear the flower and leaves the flower falls off and the Pater starts to but it's still not ripe but if that happened before to be shocked it's year two could be five to zero three and again I can't mix the two papers I have a few apples I have many apple trees so I'll just say let me take all the apples and give my son no no the apples that appeared before to be Shroud have one nicer the apples that appear as did which one have another mice and Truman my cereal oh oh I was so that's what Rashi is saying you planted it when we go back to our lock you planted the sapling to buff right Richard Shana was here one if it would have remained the baby I would have kept his date I would have kept this date the problem is he decided to grow up that's a problem sirisha Sean adoption ayan was the first year now start you second here there's an adoption I in Aleph you first you finished two years where she's shown adoption iron base you finished three years right so look later you good to go not now you now became a tree he became a trees lover does she summon you still stuck in your last year so you shift it over and now your passport doesn't work anymore because you went into a whole different category now now you're a tree as far as a tree is concerned your year is not over here extends so I have to wait till to be smart to be smart to here is over any fruit that's before to be swatters are landé g-factor to be smart is not to avoid and the Saints to with not to revalue another year that's where - she says that worked Zook ran a Cecila this became a tree and the tree has different unlocks why does a tree's roshanna change so drastically the answer is because the the we say most of the rain of the year we're going to see later most it has to do with the rain the seasons of the rain collection - Michonne Brazil is a fascinating my cloak is related to the truck but as the most of the rain of the new year are ready to send in tonight's is strong because it's already middle of Chaumont and winter is the time of rain in my son shaman misson is already much much less rain in Maya Hama so therefore most of the rain passed already and it's considered that the fruits that nurture the fruits that are there got nurtured from the previous year versus the new fruits after - Bhishma that's considered a whole different category they receive their unique their nurture in a different fashion as we shall see so Mela to be smarter comes the date that's what the commander says Haggadah Kamara mean neuron Emilia how do you come up how do you come up with this idea with this hollow that the years of our land revive finish on to be smart or manipulated by Rama Americana he Barabbas and the Naval Aviation or multi Bobby shmurda biana some say omatsu bhavish made to the beyond i it was said over in the name of her beyond all mark ruther past success it's a fascinating limb with now every dimension of a pasta every way you could read it becomes a way that you read it if you could read it this way you read it this way right we spoke yesterday hi MA becomes Hema why there's no verb it becomes claim I it's supposed to be fine MA if you could read it as claim but you have to read it as claim so here you have a possible I'm gonna quote the pastic again showers son Danny look um I randomly uh-huh oh by Sean Rav is here called P okay - little my sham or by shall not Commission specialist period the trailer keeps on using evolve uberchaun rvs who bhishan are commish's whenever you have evolved the prefix of above its called evolved a cable right like an English you say end the third year three years it should be ARLA and in the fourth year you should bring the tuition line and in the fifty you should in it what's an e it's a new sentence three years now the fourth year yes the fifth year yes what's the end so the motor is gonna learn you say three years you now let it eat it ooh by Shawn are Revere's and in the fourth year you know how to eat it yeah for years you have to bring the - fourth year fourth year after me - I'm blossom and the fifth day you have to pay material I'm so you continue reading uberchaun arteries as part of ARMA 3 years it's our Lobo Sonora visa so Sarla even though it's not how you really do supposed to make a period after three years but son arteries is a new is a new is a new mid serious but nonetheless it's a new passing we also read it who bhishan Olivia's that's what he says on microbus unnerving supersonic emissions is the snapshot per our members visa diana sir sometimes your sapling is already in the fourth year what's our fourth year a fourth year is after the Shoshana Tufts nine base three years are gone but it's still awesome mr. Marlowe right the gap in the tea it's a full year mr. Marlowe it's already awesome mr. Marlowe Oh barman by commish's it's ready in the fifth year which is post recession adoption I in Gitmo Vidhana Soudha machinery voice and it's still a sir because of her voice why because it's even though it's in the fear but it's before to be spots so once we say which Hashanah Leland is not the F of attention right so there's a time of the year that you say that Bashan Rav is it still ARLA member somnath commish's it's still not really that's the source so trashy mean on the malicious noise our Lord avoiding and shocking lesser paid as a hanuta call them tests from vishwas hawkish ecologist Neela what's your source to say that the years of our land avoid continue to prohibit the fruits that but it before to be smart even though the three years of our life complete it's not fair the answer is a mother Buchanan said and the Gemara says everybody send their beer Oh muck to punish magnet event what small to but it's a strange luncheon so crashing yes mutton mutton means recline gravity yes multi know my name snores ooh lioness my chair there are those who connect this Halawa from the potato beyond that what says uber Jean Olivia's love my Sifl in addition devolve adds to the first subject he laughs Emma Raylan it says solo song you'll accommodate employer Argo ooh boss on our TV is off potential honor of these over some officious titleist period n my stiffly near avoid the Seligman a it's a continuation tonight to avoid that what that person RV is here call Priya coitus uberchaun are commish's padmasambhava sasirekha goin Amir loop a dose of washing liquid of Venus to finish lot if the pain is rushed to bud in the fourth year before she fought that still asanas are law by Diana sued omission Marla Assyrian bond not Alamos I'm sorry after the to be schwa T could eat it these fruits that buttered on the tree are forever forbidden there's nothing you can ever do with them even though they became right months and months later after Arlo was over no difference it appeared on the tree before our law was over I'm gonna Baja Misha's could go pay this home to McRae them swapped the fruits that budded before strike the next year right to own in Hilo civil means you have to desecrate you have to exchange you have to confer these fruits on money of in eternal Caminos I'd like her to be shot what about if the pain is only budded after to be shot aim by an issue this is considered the fifth year there's no Easter whatsoever and your fruits are good to go your fruits are good to go this is if your fruits were planted your tree was planted before 30 days from Tishrei so then you still gained a lot of time what are you gain you gain all the time from tu b'shvat til the end of the year now look how it would seem their bodies are cast what if you planted it earlier so from the marshmallows what we're learning now what it seems like would be the same thing right if I planted the catchment so I wait a full year till Rosh Hashana almost a full year where's your shana starts my second year I have that dresser son the next Richard Shawn that starts my third year the next which is Shana I would think my three years are up but my three years are not up why not because to be fed to be swapped and even if I wait till fleshly and so freshmen my three years are up since the day I plant it right so the question is are my three years up now because my tree is completely complete three years are complete but look I did the much smaller sister actually tells us once you're a tree you have a different issue Shana you have a different issue Charlotte so even though so you'll have to wait another three months till schlotz you lose no so now we lose this well this guy one game you mean the first guy games which person games oh then you wonderful then you gained a lot of time because your year ended like this ah then you have a problem yeah it was a baby that was to be spotted as your son on the ELA not your son alone Athiya that would actually work nicely it would be three years if you planned on - Bhishma fine you actually very good then you have you then you have three real years then you have three what we call three calendar years then you're good to go if you plant after to be smart you gain okay right because you don't have to wait the moment to be smart is up even though you're three years on I'm up yet but you gain if you plant after two weeks on other nittany it's even Thomas off till Ella hello the Fuehrer mandala fizzle is a little short omelet but it's not as short as it looks I'm saying yet so we're up to one two three four five six seven seven miles from the body from there several months on the top leymah the law you care the mayor that's where welder so we have to haul the cup here one has to concentrate here to be able to appreciate the flow which will continue for a while so let's summarize the discussion and move on the mission is said none of the first day of Tishri is your Shoshanna Lana Tia the Tia means planting Mateo and Hebrew means the plant somebody who plans Mattia means a plant more accurately a sapling a baby tree that's planted what's the finish of the mission or what's the mission is saying the mission is saying that when the Toyota says in part is good ocean and when a Jew plants a tree 3 years the first 3 years after the planting all the foods that grow our garbage there are law we can't sell them you can't eat them you can't have any benefit from them whatsoever no I feel an Ohana on the 4th year you could eat then you could benefit but it has to be in Yerushalayim because these fruits are holy unless you redeem them on money and then the money becomes holy and you bring the money to Somalia like by my sashimi and then on the fifth year you're good to go you can enjoy the fruits of the tree without any inhibitions and without any special a locust it's a regular tree in your garden eat cos update EQ peaches eat your oranges eat your apples eat your Kiwis and eat your cherries etc that's on the fifth year do not think that attachment begins as we would think from the day you planted the tree so I planted the tree I'm poor him so put him three years later is cut off time for ARLA and pour them one year later it's cut off time for Netta revite no we learn not from the Xavier shovel Shawna Shawna neisha sashawna that is a unique role here for the first day of Tishri that s a petition and it's precisely additionally not crash beneficial my favors because Xavier Sava register Shawna so because they suffer does two things first of all these areas Ovid tells me that the year is not the year which begins when I planted it but a year that begins on a particular first day of a month the frizz is something called the beginning of a year and it also tells me when that is the beginning of a year like we learned committers finish miss and could be respected Thomas beginning of there can be any time but it's when it's mathematician what's shot that's the beginning of the year what does it mean at the beginning of the year it means the Gemara explains that rosh hashanah completes the first year of our law and starts the second year so when I plant the tree before Shoshanna so that drishya tion of that as competition it's a new year already what sayst it's a new year it's here - it's not year one wow that's a big thing that's a great benefit but there's a condition the condition is it has to be within 30 days before this Shoshanna I'm sorry it has to be not within 30 days before official more than 30 days before she shot if I planned this tree basal or a spider shallow then Rosh Hashanah doesn't begin a new year it does not I have to wait till the next Rosh Hashanah to begin a new year in other words I have to wait up after count a month almost a month and a for another year to have my first year if I plant my tree soft-ass of or earlier Rosh Hashanah is Rosh Hashanah linnethia it's a new anniversary it's a new year in other words year one is over and year two begins that's what the Gemara brought from the Bryce tomorrow support another hollow said there a fog of that if it happens to be air of Schmitter and you planted within 30 days you can have stopped rude and during schmitter so you know don't have our loss of our land anymore because you don't have a tree left killing it you're pruning it before before it matures much before matches but if you plant it in more than 30 days before the siRNA schmidt that doesn't cancel it out it's good - this two different our losses that converging and the prices of the Gemara calls that's it this is Clark now before we go further let's focus on a toy surface here which asks a very interesting question the price is set F upon a taya padam average the effort a market all these are losses applied to three situations you plant you know you you bend you bend what's called layering or propagating I think propagating layering you bend you bend a branch into the earth and it comes up and then it develops its own roots and then you cut the branch off from its mother tree and it's already an independent tree and the third thing is you graph the tree you take you you you penetrate you create a crevice a hole in a tree and you bring a branch from another tree into that hole because this this tree for example a it produces small fruits and this branch comes from a tree that produces large fruits or robust fruits and better fruits and you you bring that quality into this tree lemons Dennis Reagan because the sirillium is not an easy tree stratum is not an easy three lemons is a give alder could schrieffer for sustainability for for various things that's why you're the problem of s Reagan work of amah stable yet so that's why it was a wonderful thing for God for for for people doing guard for for people having ordered these orchards to put lemon lemon into a net circuitry its Givaudan the only problem is it's not a necessary anymore that's the great problem there's also true this some safer many more of a solarium or covering right how do you determine if it's a pure ester it's not because it's a serious kotzur serious issue not a hybrid yeah that's why that was I was one of the big things with Italy because I'm Sophie brings over there's like a murse later for though you did dated darkness like those Gardens yaniv in Italy southern Italy southern Italy it looks good no that's very you look better they look better much better than an S retreat right right rent see that's what that was for universe very prominent this semana michelin artificial Laura arrived doctor never brings for someone and some of this ammonium you can only do after suck this yeah I do it every year I can develop an always I want to see doctor never brings for semana matter cell from work of Malachor if the seeds if they're different direction of the seeds what I'm working I don't meet the Arizona to use a nested work curve as he says accusing a banana on service he said the Menasha client said it's not it's not a nice if it's a banana I mean looks like a nesic it's not a lemon it's not a length will be a lemon wouldn't be a problem he wouldn't be fooled he stood himself a lot it's a heft of a banana no no in terms in terms of mixing if I bring good sri if I bring the branch from another tree but it's the same min there's no is if it's the same species no we produce if I take that branch to this tree abroad again we produce it becomes part of the tree I believe so that's the problem that's the problem you take the seeds reproduces what the original the original that's the clerk of a clerk of a seed is that it's a combination it's combine of both okay so okay so all these three situations basically Mateo Mateo ganas planting was trapped planting I plant a seed I plant a branch of a tree or a tree was uprooted and I replant it all three things are planting plain doesn't only mean a seed planting could mean you replant that tree that was uprooted or you replant the branch then there's lettuce bending and then there's grafting and all these three situations we said that's gonna be the question here and what do we see that in all these situations there's a dinner Varla that's why we're making a husband when three years begin and when they end we telling you that Rosh Hashanah begins a second year but here's a question I have a tree the tree is 70 years old our line has certainly happened the face before I was alive or elapid and now suddenly I took a branch from this tree and I bring it into the earth and I bring it up and suddenly you tell me this new Orla on the new one the same is true when I take the branch I put it into a new tree you're telling me this is our loss that's our here on the brand on the brand on that which comes out of the branch now understand even the third case the third case I already have a tree that tree already was in our law but I bring a branch from another tree into this tree and what happens now there's a new dinner of our law so this is what toy service is going to address take a look okay let's see now customer base maverick well you plant it's you take a tree and you replant it these are long that's part of Natalia that's that's the first no not the three years past the three years passes no it's about the tree years or three years or the three years old no so subhana so some people sacrifice so let's see choice this maverick yeah always also forever know are the fruits are us are forever you just destroy the Thamud and cover all of a person but those fruits are forever uh sir the fruits of our life forever us so dr. Lewis maverick coif fiacre bar it's you bend that twice at bending you bend the year whole year core is a branch into the earth Oh must I say you buy off when you cover it with earth and then once it develops its own roots the crates eighths but empty ography fossa and then you cut it by MC to enforce it means in middle of the bend in other words you cut it between the part that's covered in the earth and the part is connected to the tree for I say a year for that branch that you planted you don't see let's out out here comes out to another side from the earth cuff of Mahatma Akira Ilan of course then somewhat from the source from the Main Street that is what maverick is sucked Isis market what's my give who a market even baka Vader you graphed a tree with its colleague with another tree Omar Sh'ma it seems from our Sookie the Maverick remark is value Varla both of them obligate you in Arlen because the Mishnah Brice's says after the Maverick laugh at the market if it's more than 30 days before Russian Shana also leshawna for what for ARLA in other words you're counting three years of Arlo the cash neither pay the Commodore law and Mishnah is the first pay de Coverley Mishnah a marsh mother cover pot them in Arlo it seems from the Mishnah that a marquis a grafter is part two from Arlo and AB therefore I don't have to count for that Sri knew our love what does it say there it says over there basically that if you take a vine take the branch of a vine or not want it's called the Geffen and you mark it so those pages are looked at and they're not awesome with some our law the Tonya Nami potatoes claim and we also have a price in Toyotas Korean tightest item is of course one of the most important madrasah because it's basically from the tonneau Liam Tyra Chevelle pair explaining viagra and partial code item on the pasta unit captain when it speaks about our low the past success una tap them recently soil on its own the top 10 colleagues Michael you will plant every fruit tree every tree or food dr. Taylor strain I'm gonna tack them problem Avraham our cave this is only if you plant a new tree not if you bend that if you graph we cannot tell him it says the tightest plenum sit book fun in this epoch on this ebook see pucon sip book fan amis when you continue when you continue when you graph the GAF and of in this ebook canvas in focus it Pocono you do it twice you do it again and again alpha P shave listen body even though you bent it into the earth motor you can eat it then you don't have to count again our law and placement says what's it book Russian sipoc big fan and collection our cover be Elon the word sit book by vines is like the word are covered by a tree by a tree it's called our cover which is grafting and by a Geffen it's called sit book Oh Masha marvelous pajamas ooh what you bend this year might cease - and the branch that you put into the earth now produces spiders - means branches because of every fun and now you bend it over again you think those branches and you bend the mosula to the earth and what happens next the Sun our carers the next year's else epoxy poker so you have the first level the first generation and then you have sipoc seppuku which is the second generation nonetheless and all these situations the terrace carrying them says it's not knit Totten that's not called planting it's not planting and their foot spot - from our look there's no Kimura oh this is on the XY my the hussam places says it's not a contradiction over there is talking about very interesting koshevoy NIF suka mayor v ha you did not cut off the branch from its father from its source you left it connected the tree from where the branch comes is still connected to this branch that went into the earth and we're talking about will be Alonso cane and it's a long suckin meaning an older tree which already went through our law and since the branch was never detached it's not considered a separate tree it's gonna sit an extension of the original tree which are ready past the ARLA deadlines of the fruit some wood for hosta here it's talking about cushion if succumb a via you cut off the branch to the Mucca click on a the moment line which asana to your side like we're gonna see that when do you start counting you start counting from when it's planted the male the male from when your mother if it so it's considered like a separate tree because you cut it off and therefore you have ARLA yeah what happens backwards you won't say but what there's nothing growing the person has when you took it all for good why would I no after a while yeah after a while you cut it soon you wanted to take root you wanted for us to take root what point is right right yeah right so when it says over here that what that it's before you even are in law it's talking about you never caught a man when he say it's before you've another thing whether you cut it off you cut off the branch however it's must over to the first tree then there's absolutely no fear neither so you have to say the same thing by her cover also you basically took a branch from a tree to another tree and you created our cover but you didn't separate it from the first tree so then it's up to our law however mark the point is from when you cut it is that considered a new Mitzi that's what he says so place versus botanical doctor you have to be me doctor Kiev a Shia / New Yawk see if we would have be able to set this said said this difference answer this when it says but the pated Machado comma in my sector cite anticipated it begins with midoriyama the kimono speaks over their leg a bit high simmer camo comma POSIX says that somebody who plants a new vineyard right and he didn't yet enjoy the fruits so he could go back and not fight not fight so the question is mr. maverick what about if you didn't plant a new tree but you a maverick are you crazy are you crazy from the Mihama or not so the kumari over there brings us tear between the Mishnah that says the you are cause america will come in the prices as you're not or Masami the camera answers con barkovis is to become bar covers hat if you a mark of min be shame I mean I it's not called on a tear because it's an issue and you don't go back from war you stay in the war but if it's our covers hat there meaning there was min women know it was a branch from one species and they're the same species it's called an a-team freckie toasters maybe you could have answered oh so this answer and that is if you a math circuit if it's separated then you come back for more and if not you don't come back for more system is if this would actually be an answer let Gaby coming back from a coma just like we're answering Italy Gombe the part is that Toyota doesn't recognize it as a legitimate so he could send a telegram to his wife to approve it they say there was once when the British the British had a mandate over Israel but they were completely in control so there was one of the Jews who was in one of the organizations the groups fighting for independence and he was imprisoned and he had a big pig farm and a big field so his wife writes a letter to him and the prison and she says you know there's nobody to do the plowing that's gonna be horrible we're gonna lose all the fruits she writes back a letter from prison term and he says just make sure if you're getting somebody to do the plowing remember all the weapons that are buried in the farm and all the weapons that are buried in the field just remember that the next day hundreds of British soldiers escaped they turned over the whole field for a few days few days later her husband writes to now you could plant place it's one of the others somebody once said my sister your are you okay okay so that's that's that's just a detail in terms of marvelous and Marcus what are we left with we're left with the fact that we have a nutritious Shana and they start counting for a Shoshanna now look I uh everything is glass the problem is that under a problem I mean the issue is not a problem the fact is that in the few numbered olive the first word the price that continues and throws us what we would call a curveball and the curveball is that to be schrott suddenly comes into play with this to b'shvat come into play gets very apropos to learn this week with this to be smart coming to play that suddenly these fruits that you planted a month before is Hashanah don't think that two years later is a shaman you're good to go because told us is sana you have a one month which is one year you wait one more issue Shana is two years you wait one more - and John is three years and Sun gundalia right after issue sana right after that any fruit that appears on the tree is it ready after look no it's uh sir pens if you fast ok very good yeah so these paints are uh sir till to be Schwab's Austral to be trial in other words I don't really gain mom-ish a month is mama a year and now you still have to wait a few months you have to wait - you have to wait kiss Lou you have to wait Avis the wait till to be Martha Corinne to miss hello what do I have to wait for that any fruit that buds on the tree before the 15th day of trial what do I mean buds the flower falls off and the tiny little fruit starts emerging this is what we call an Aloha nah when the flower falls off and in the place of the flower you have no a little food even though it's gonna take a long time for it to develop and ripe and mature nonetheless if that bobbing began even a day before to be taught that fruit is us or forever forever however if till to be taught the only flowers after to be strata science rots it starts buttock now my ARLA is over because to to be shot is over that science rot my our lives over now it's my fourth year I bring to your shall I am if I wait one more year to be smart my fifth year is over my fourth year is over and I bring it to my house all is good so we added here a few extra months he is over to be swapped for our law and phonetic value that was the end of the price which Mishnah our Mishna says that two brothers a son of a trees but here it began with a sapling with a baby which is called the sapling no I would learn the mission that the once I have a mature tree that's producing apples right and I have to give my sir from these apples okay so my apples are growing now right my apples now let me just tell you usually when you have a tree its be very uncommon to have come not to be for to be shot so not that means buddy-buddy that the flower falls off right usually the fruit start growing after to be shot which is the new year so let's say I have a tree this year tops and I in design I go out to my farm today to my orchard today today which is before to be swapped right just a few days before to be swapped and I see new little fruits that are budding yeah I have to give myself from these fruits based on tops and eyen love not tops my anxiety the year is not over yet if tough soon I evolve is my second year of schmitter I have to give my sir Shanee not my Cerrone the fruits that are budding after to be smart I have to give a new myself to give my sir honey not my sashimi this is a very big illogic difference another thing I can't combine both fruits to give my sir both of them together because the mice has to be given from each year so yes I would have said that Walker she suddenly Lummis is a tree a tree has separate of us vegetables so you would say like this vegetables Arliss for a fur baby tree for anitya for sapling isn't a tea and is an Elan is a baby tree and there's a full tree a mature tree now for vegetables we're gonna see soon the next surrogate that's as a petitioner for grain its as a petition a right for saplings or alerts as a petition it fruits have a separate position now we have to understand why kazaaam makes such a different British honor for vegetables for grain for saplings one and fur for fruits you have to wait a few months that's a great question yes of course it's a whole different creature so that's the see this year that this even for our law once you hit Russia Shawn a year three so I planted my tree - Bob Tufts and some are tests Rosh Hashana Tufts and I in his year one Rosh Hashanah Tufts and I now live two years finished mr. sung at Tufts and I in base three years finished Rosh Hashana Tufts nine bays it's called an Elan it's called an Elan and now the fruits are our law I three years passed but for the Elan three years didn't pass was the elands end of the year is too rich mat so therefore my ARLA extends and this is a compensation for the fact that my first year was so short so my third year gets extended a few months I still gain a lot because after to be smart I can enjoy all the fruits even though may occur had then I should have waited till to buff I have to wait many more months till I have my three full years but now I gain here a lot of time what did I gain I gave all this time between two b'shvat and tuba of whenever I planted the tree I gained a lot of time the same is true the next year with natural outcome that's what the price is set the Gemara also brought the source of this the source of this was that it's Marshman homage that sometimes are the extends to the fourth year and net to avoid extends to the fifth year we have a situation extends to the fourth year and fifth year why should you do that in these situations Richard Sean adoption I in veins three years were over but my our looks tends into my fourth year till two b'shvat and my net de Rivoli which should have been over a Shoshanna Tufts now in Gitmo extends into the fifth year and goes till to bhishma Epcot this is sagina now the gamora starts analyzing this going off to a new subject but it's going to come back to this issue what was very important to remember was it actually sucked darker and actually said earlier was that recession at the third year it's not an idea anymore it's an alum because it's an Elan therefore I have to I have to wait I why didn't you tell me why don't you ask me if you want three full years if you want if you don't like a month you feel that a month is not called a year so extend it much longer make it real years make it two balls left wait three years to Bob what do you have to make what if to make games for the answer is that there's a Shana the third year because the stacker becomes on Ilan because attacker becomes a tree so therefore once to be SWAT hits it's the emissary Shoshana Lille on us and since it's an alumnus so you're good to go and you don't have to you don't have to make it any longer from this that is how Rashi is telling us the Gemara you can you know you can eat a new show lion if you need to - lime wants to be spot comes to be star a candidate no but that's the reason I don't have to go after to be smart I don't have to wait till tomorrow we accomplished changing the name two things first of all we extended it and we shortened it we extend it all to be smart and we shorten it before the end of the year okay now I don't want to confuse Poly alum but this is important to mention this explanation that I just gave is for Raschi as we learn to actually inside yesterday this is what Rashi tells us that what that this whole Allah applies only to a sapling that was planted thirty days or more before the Shoshanna this is how she learns the Gemara this is how the Rambam learns the Gemara this is your SUSE derived learns the Gemara rabbinic Anana learns the Gemara and the MIDI learns the Gemara meaning some of the greatest fisherman according to all their views what about a sapling that was planted less than 30 days before the Shoshanna let's discuss that one not more than three more than thirty days we just learned that long what if it was planted less than 30 days before the Shoshanna then the years of art nam saying Oxley's if it's out of sharia so yeah you have to destroy it so then it's not negate but if it's a regular year then it seems from Rashi clearly that what do you do you count from British Shana to Russia Shana but you can't if you can't start counting one huh you skip the first Rosh Hashana so basically your first year gets it extend it so if I plant my tree on tests love ello where's your son is not year one if it's Rosh Hashanah tough Shania so I have to wait to the show natasha Lyonne our for year one there's on the Tufts nine pages here to mr. Shaw natasha Lyonne Gitmo is year three and these are three proper years oh so little Aida once Russian son of the fourth year begins the Ilan completely leaves our love and the Paris are not uh sir why they ah sir because you really waited three full years you didn't have any shortcuts you really waited three full yes he waited even longer than three years yeah you started to swell fellow and you really waited the first richardsaunders extra 15 days there you go three - your son is it's really three years and 15 days no submissive applause but they didn't have really my third year yet good question that's what you asked but we'll go there in one minute we'll go there in one minute okay let's this is the of Rashi the Rambam derive it a banana in the middle however other is showing them including toys r us right here including the Iraqis were including the lids of including Iran and including the bow Amaya so you're dealing with heavy hitters on both sides they say that this interpretation of the Gemara is completely wrong they say that this idea that the Paytas are assert ill to be swats applies to every single Mattia not only on the tia in which you gained your thirty days as a full-year cuz he planted it 30 days before the Shoshanna according to then we have AG eval that can finish like about the cat home grab the Brice is teaching us that even though they're Shoshanna linen T is the first day of Tishrei nonetheless and I planted it test above ello and I'm waiting till Rosh Hashana for the first year till the second-richest unmanned have three foolish summers that pass so I have three full years nonetheless our luck continues till the next to be scrapped in other words you wait three years 15 days and tissue recession and kiss left a wish Matt and almost five months why what's the shot what's the havona yeah and again and the same this was not to avoid the same as was not to avoid not to revive he won't be motorist Hashanah tops nine dollars net to the way will be muttered to be smart option I and a lot in other words you're waiting for years and almost a half a year after they come that's their to the world of Russian exams what's the have one they say as far as I the reason we extended it till to be smart is not because we feel guilty that we shorten this year and therefore we say give me another few months and since it's an Elan which eternal aloneness is good that's not divorced was here I have no guilt so to speak I'm using the word guilt I don't mean guilt I mean that there's a problem a that the year was shortened here he does three full years my hybrid minima hundred he did more than three years he did three full County as possible so Titus has three as he waited three years they time NASA that Paytas that but till to be schrott basically are living off the SAP of the tree that was created from the rain of last year painters that emerged in the tree and Kesavan kiss lifts Ava still to be trapped there coming from the unica their nurture from the tree that comes from the rain of last year the kya the use of this tree is not popular in scientist option I involved it's the rain of Tufts not involve the pain is that but after to be smart they primary feels is attributed to the rain of Tufts my anxiety because they're deep into the winter deep into the winter but this budding that comes before to be smart that's called pay this of Tufts my involve even though they truth of science i but mail ad they say what do i kid at three years passed these pages that emerged in tavis these papers that emerge the dollar trap these are Tufts naive of pace they're the rain of Tufts naive are so you have to wait I counted three years you count the three years but the pages are considered old played us that's their right luckily rush saves us and he says you don't have to decide because you're not gonna find the tree that has come out to be forth to be sure about these days he says you don't have to you know if they have a headache from the side of the how often I have to still no no that's clear that's within 30 days your prudish Smith left it in for 30 days you don't have asked but here here does one Schuyler here is one Schuyler what's the Schuyler let's think about this now you understand the second shooter very different so when it says on the first line of the few pages Matias who are soon an apt to be smart what's pay this Matias ooh-rah she says Paytas Matias Lou is he planted at 30 days before the Shoshanna they say pain is Matias uu is both cases 30 days before Hashanah and within 30 days but here we have a question the question is if according to that the 15th day of Shabbat is the day that our Allah ends by every Mattia so there's never a matsyas that our Allah becomes mother but after petitioning there's never such some it sees there's no such a thing right going to - she doesn't see is that s a petition it becomes water when if you planted you tree right before this reshawna within the month that pressure Shana four years later you good but according to city supply service as a petition he never does anything it never does the magic for trees never why because even if I planted it the baby even though I plan to the 10 minutes before the Shoshanna no difference I can't wait till after the petition have to wait till to about that's what you're telling me you're telling me that all the fruit still to be sure they're gonna be earlier if so why are you calling it sunlen idea what makes it a Shoshanna Lydia loads - it's very good smack if I planted Sri within 30 days of richer sana with it no if I plant the tree within 30 days before the Shoshana Shoshana is the time when our legs no no no no that she's sitting on rocks is and to be slapped only it's a game only if you gain the year light Rashi to be smart only works if you plan to get some more than 30 days before that's when you need it because you need to extend it but if you did it Tessa L oh you did a test about hello yeah so there's shunga not that Christmas son is not here one that her son is worthless but the next was his son is here one count Swedish honest and you good there's no to be shot yeah well you had three full years like that 31 days I my ear my ear became a month if you'll never be less than two and a half years right but like twice misses notice your son that why you calling inertia Charlotte Charlotte yeah the answer is the answer is as follows that they're right that is additional immaterial for one issue and that is that for the first year of our law only Tishrei not commercial service smart is considered to Shoshanna meaning in a case where I planted it 30 days before the Shoshanna so then we say that those 30 days are considered the first year those 30 days are considered the first year what about if I planted 30 days before come here sauce of a spot do you say oh I had 30 days before in Shoshanna elonis so cookies right considered a new year no no no no yes the wait older Shoshanna to get your new year that's weird if Shoshana works the Shoshana works for that one situation where you're planting at 30 days before their Shoshana where's your son is considered a new year that wouldn't apply to commercial submission if I plant a tree you Dalit Avis we don't say to be smart the first year of our lives up no to be schwa doesn't mean anything for the SAP link it's a very nice day but this is not a new year wait till next door Shawna that's gonna be your new year that's good yesterday the Gemara says that basically is extra words of Shama year so we make a gazillion sava to race this Hashanah which basically teaches me that Rashad is - she is the new year that's what the tomorrow right away discussed why the Casal are even doing anything with this why don't we just stick to them okay now we have the basics question this is the one last big question here we've been talking about we have been talking about trees that we planted either within 30 days or 30 days before okay so 30 days 30 days is the amount that you need that when Rosh Hashana comes it's considered one year past right and this dushashana is considered a new year okay and the part is you'll have to wake up to be smart okay lightly shine them the first ones rash around them and everybody who hold that we extend it to to be smart only by trees that were planted 30 days or more before the Shoshanna why because their first year got cut off so we compensate so here we have the Isaacs question what happens if I plant my tree investment I plant my tree intestine okay so I have kilrush Shoshanna it's almost a full year okay so I have Richard Shana one year is up there's a summit option iron-rich asana cops 911 summit offs nine base three years do i have to wait till to be shmatte would i have to wait till test of all freshmen if I plant a little small cache you're gonna tell me wait'll to be smart now you're making me wait more than three years till test for freshmen then I waited three years again if I planted my 3 tests love of I'm getting away with murder cuz Rosh Hashana Tufts anion Bay's basically only two years and one month past so you tell me wait another four wait another few months but what if I planted in a session I planted it in Kistler I planted in Davis I planted it you Daleks trap can I just wait till your Daleks rot or till the destroyed newspapers or 30 credits miss level huh so that's the question I have to wait till - Bhishma this is a question only is this a question wait why Swiss know why because like them you always have to wait till to be smart I couldn't care less that you planted an attachment why cuz the fruit still to be swapped are considered last year's fruits because they come from last year's rain but like you're actually you time is that it's an extension only to compensate for that month that you lost and therefore if you planted the tree within 30 days you don't have to wait till tomorrow no it's not the lotion it and actually it's and actually it's just applied enough no no cause from naturally see clearly along no yet but no but you see if it actually clearly says that if you planted your tree within 30 days before the Shoshanna right so by this by by the fourth Rosh Hashanah you're good to go you know after way right tell me that when he says it take book of the first Russian data masking tool it doesn't say that if you do this yep yeah yeah later there is shunned him explain it looking back she actually says a fisherman oscillates on income to pay the additional summer siliceous yeah a four-piece Armando also a Shoshanna what's also a sauna because it was more than 30 days before yeah like them it's not as more than 30 even within 30 days you have the same along axes even though you said also a summer don't think you're getting away with this you have to wait till to be smart and afterwards it's going to be revised and then look at the end of the Rashi la casa la la la made shell if Nader Shoshanna sham and Maya her tailor me to be smart buy a dresser Shana there's no mistaking that this isn't the case with Islam Adela snake what if there's no la middlin a stick to the regular dates stick Teresa son so this is going to be the question do we have to give this guy a duty to wait more than three years yes the wait till commercial service part or not according to toys fish yeah according to Rashi it's not clear so let me just tell you the kids are and they were showing them there's a big mouth like this about this itself like this no these are shining and it's three there's three apps that's three completely different this about this the number one is you gotta wait till hamish awesome a lot of the fourth year why because your first our year was not complete since your first our year was not complete you started an attachment and you waited till there's your summer that's not a complete year so you go Russia Shana for Shoshanna is your son and you already wait till to be smart once you're waiting you're waiting till to respond the other is no the Kufa of our law does not go into the fourth year but rather as a patisserie when you have the end of the third year you're good to go you're good to go you don't have to wait more than that year you don't have to wait and the third the most interesting in many ways is the of the Rambo the Rambo believes that whenever you plant the tree between Rosh Hashanah and Kamisha of a shot then your count is calendar years just three years day-to-day don't mix inner Shoshanna don't mix in to be smart you planted in the straightest cushman you waitress tried to scratch for three years later and you could that's the original there you go why huh then antenna back up then it becomes if you plant less than 30 days no crash says that no in our time there's no pages that I find it to be foot to be smart so basically says you never prolonged it nots the point is you never prolong this it's not a problem because by to be it's never prolonging because you're waiting you know you're waiting we we waited and it's not pretty sure and waiting because you're not gonna have fruits before so all the fruits are gonna be after to be shot so what's the promise everybody holds it's cooked in other words you wait Theresa Shawn at the third year right whatever that is and then you wait till to be shot you go over home and he said it's not a problem because you're not usually I'm gonna lose anything why you're not gonna lose anything cuz your fruits are gonna come out afterwards basically you can go the home run without any problem maybe the yeah yes things changing okay let's see a few lines here now some of the Gemara suckin do we still have to understand one question and that is why do they come up with 30 days come up with two months come up with a we do it like who decided 30 days like we did that yeah lapis is from the previous year it is for fruits it is for the fruits yeah it is for everything you're right yeah for every single inevitable yep something a martyred light with the light could have made this Bryson that tells me yes yes why not when it got you need the bats okay talking about a layman I could have made this Bryson that tells me cut off time is 30 days and less than 30 days it's not a year I'm sorry less than 30 days you have to wait till your next Rosh Hashanah perhaps it does not go like anime of us Epis neither mayor Haram area method bar shan okashi Hashanah the mayor holds that you haven't halakha a situation where one day during the year is considered a year so we believe that a corner have made of even if I plant a might recall SLO or huffed SLN one day past it's a year I don't need 30 days where is this it of May the time near we have a price very interesting brighter and this is a biggest site because whenever you read and homeless names of animals how do you know how old it is succulent made par Haram world but tourists stop whenever it says entitled it to bring up our a bull without specifying the age you should know a clown when I asked him Baba how this really master derivative made its minimum 24 months and a day which means two full years going into the third year part Ben Barker is a three year animal that already two years and one two full years and it's already in its third year one day one day is enough for a blessed rebel awesomer not the nest of our bhavish like some young 24 months and 30 days both holds that when toyota says apart it has to be within the third year it has to be three years old but what does it mean three years old three years old doesn't mean if the wait three full years from the day is born but rather it has to go into the third year that mayor says one day into the third years of Isis and a bilasa says 30 days into the third year will soon see why so higher that may or may that may used to say and this everybody agrees with this veto call malcomson mr eagle better to stop whatever it says in the toyota the word eagle without the word Ben buffer eagle means a calf been Buckra means the son of a cow of a full developed cattle full developed mammal whenever the trader says a go what is it then sauna bench sauna means it's within the first year it's within the first year remember it can be within the first eight days within the first eight days it's possible for a carbon whether it's in the first year and the reason is because in Paris Schmidty when it speaks about the eighth day of me Luo Yin it says over there the eighth day when they put up the Mishkan it says you should bring a gal of a Heavy's Binet Shona so this is opinion average so paradigm Eagle means till one year Cavis means till one year eagle the heifers come up come somewhere with a bench on when it says Eagle Ben Barker this is bench diam this is Eagle Ben Barker is the next level it's within two years no no no sharp IRAs gonna be three years third year that's the difference you have a girl you have a girl Ben Barker and you have part three different all of us hey girl it says clearly in screaming that it's within a year ago Ben Parker the traitor compares in that car in that in that in that parsha to one mile an isle is of course an older sheep if a sheep ends after one year so when does it begin to be a ram within two years so eagle bamberger's compared to the tile next pie whenever it says part whether it says power of pipe and buckler it's been showers it's within the third year it has to be three years or within the third year therefore the mayor says 24 months and a day is good rebel loser says 24 months and a month what do we see from the mayor one day of the year Liholiho can have the definition of a year accord to the velocity have to wait 30 days 30 days according to this it means like this within the first year it's called an eggo the moment the moment you go into the second year and one day it goes into the second year one day of course would have made it's called a goal Ben Barker and according to the bilasa you need 30 30 days okay so what do we see from here if this is the case why would it may it have a problem even with one day of ello it shouldn't be a problem even if there's one day it still hush up Sunnah so we have to assume that our price is following their bilasa and not trip mayor and therefore we have we need at least 30 days to give it a year that's the question so let's just see what the governor says no I feel attainment it mayor this can work with her main key kamar and may I method by shauna Hashanah desciption Ramaiya can count one day as a year if it's the end of the year for example you have a part he's two years old now you need to give him the end you need to give him a third year because of Pyrus three years old so therefore for the end of the three year count I could use a day of Albany less Sun ah but if you want that day should be counted in the beginning of your count of years for example you plant a tree before this your son oh one day and you want that they should be the first year law perhaps even if mayor would say you know you can end it off on a lenient note you can't start you have to start it off on a bang ah that would be the distinction the gum others may be making just to say that there's no we don't know but there's no hotter if there's no we're not forced to say that it may disagrees well maybe right maybe he does but you can't tell me conclusive evidence because they could be a smarter than the doomed in the beginning of the unit end of the year this is what the Gemara is suggested now which is going to be rejected immediately you look yeah a shark is not an indication of ADH you don't have the word sure you have the word pot pirates often it's not me gay are over there it's not nagae the shared cores at Gore's I don't care Walter this over here it's in the gay of the car but the question when Toyota says the word pie which is very very often four components what is it how long a separate question oh because you're looking for a wild ox that Gore's but then they didn't always straighten out loud oh you know I'm accustomed to plow you feel right so reality just reading up on this rodeo mm president jarba it's most ultimate horse tears but it could be a female so you could plow with a female what you could plow with a female to be also female 9 you'll still have to wait now if I plant my tree purim so there's a Sun as year 131 I understand it 30 days is a year for short 31 question is where I would if mayor not hold ya give me one day as long as you gave me a day you see by power you let that and you let me do that why you believe you go into the year you good that's what you believe in other words since listen if we wouldn't have a source and effort the tissue is richness not only from our Lord who wouldn't make em I would say three years three years wait three years once I learned Russian sauna Tishrei is considered a new year so how much time do I need from the previous year so the may is there would be how much time do I need I need one day I can't have one hour but I need one day I need something because if not it's a joke but I need one thing here we see you don't need one day you need 30 days so it's not like a geyser tomorrow wants to say no that maybe the mayor would agree that for the beginnings he won't allow a day to make you first year but to finish that off if it's around this class is brought to you by the achieve Annette please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot they ueshiba net / donate