Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Great news. This evening, Thursday
evening, begins our annual
campaign.
Whatever you could do to be mishtif is
greatly appreciated. The best way to
help us out is to set up your team page.
You could go to our site, rabbidg.com.
You click the button to set up your team
page or if you would like to
participate, go to charity.commh26.
recording progress.
>> Okay, good morning friends. We're
continuing miss. We're learning
discusses someone who has a maka on his
hand and a bandage. So it's enough to
pour on the rest of the hand. not in the
makum har
which it's enough to pour on the rest of
the hand not on the bandage.
Then the says
literally that means you have to be
careful not to touch the bandage. Why?
Because
there'll probably be water on the
bandage and that water is and it will
not become
or
okay interesting.
That's how I read it yesterday.
Supporting that reading is the fact that
that's what the words mean.
That's one proof that we read it
correctly cuz that's what the how that's
the translation of the words. He says
you have to be careful. Not the word yea
means he doesn't touch the because it's
not it doesn't mean the water doesn't
touch the bandage cuz water is plural.
then it would say you go. Here's another
reason why it seems to be saying that
because the first step of the mab is
it's enough
to wash the rest of the hand.
Okay? Which seems to indicate it's
enough to wash the rest of the hand, but
not that he it doesn't say you're not
allowed to wash the bandage. The lion of
doy
seems to imply you don't have to wash
the bandage but you also are allowed to.
That's who we read yesterday but we had
the following question. The question is
that in sift test we mentioned that if
you found a rock on your hand after you
have to wash again with the so then in
this case why don't you have to how is
this a valid washing? water is going to
get on the bandage and then it's going
to recontaminate your hand like sift
test.
So there's an important gear change here
but I'm not so convinced
of this gear change. I don't know. Okay,
you you'll see.
Okay.
If you're not able to wash your hands at
all because of an illness,
wrap your hands in a cloth.
What should a person do if he could only
wash one hand? He has, let's say, a
Makkah on his hand and it's entirely
covered in a bandage. So the banishes
says
since he's only washing one hand it's a
suffic whether you make a bra
he's inclined to say you do make a bra
despite the fact that we say
nevertheless
it's not so push to say don't make a bra
cuz if you have a bra on a mitzvah the
Beneskai says we find the kazal we're
don't do the mitzvah without a bra
the cha brings it to
that it's better to enter a suffic
and to say
than to be bes not saying a brahitzah
You hear such a thing the the brings
from that you're better off saying a a
suffic
than to do a mitzvah
potentially without making a braha. It's
more severe prohibition to do a to do a
mitzvah without a than to say. Now
that's not a commonly held position.
That was a
>> Yeah,
that's a
okay. He adds as follows. He says
even if you wash only one hand you can
make and it's not
why because the issakana
seems to say similarly
says
If, let's say, you have a bandage on
your hand or a cast and you can't get
water on it and it's going to be very
hard not to get water on it, you wrap it
up, wash the other hand, and you make a
What about could you say
if you're only washing one hand?
He doesn't talk about that.
Okay, now let's see.
Literally, you should be careful not to
touch the bandage. No, change the ga. It
doesn't mean you should be careful not
to touch the bandage. What it means is
be careful the water doesn't touch the
bandage.
Now I have a little bit of a problem
with that reading because the first half
of the mab is it's die just to wash the
rest of the hand not
and then he's saying and by the way make
sure the water doesn't touch the
didn't sound like that in the first
statement when he says die that you only
have to wash the first part. It c it
certainly sounds like the other reading
that you only have to wash your hand but
since it's inevitable that the will get
wet don't touch it but that's not what
the primum says explains
if any gets a little bit on the bandage
and Then
the water that's on the bandage will get
on the hand.
So the the primagim I'm not 100% sure if
he's changing the ga or if he means this
is what it means to say
but nevertheless it doesn't mean you
should be careful not to touch the
bandage. You should be careful the
bandage doesn't get wet.
Now,
let's see.
Okay, it seems like uh a very
far-fetched possibility, though not to
get water on the bandage. How in the
world is that possible? Guys has a
band-aid in middle of his hand. He's
going to wash the rest of his hand. I
mean, he has to wash every part of his
hand that the band-aid is not there. How
in the world is he going to do that?
He's He's going to use a what is it
called? a water um
he's going to hose it down with like a
water pressure gun. He's gonna like, you
know, like cauter the hand. How is he
gonna do that?
I don't know. says
if you use
say it's better this of using is much
better than the second making sure the
water doesn't touch the bandage
basically it's the first is impossible
like we just pointed out it is not shak
You know efure means does not mean
statistically unlikely or highly
improbable. It means impossible.
They also write, "It's good to wrap the
bandage after the natila when you come
to eat with some kind of towel that's
clean to cover the grime of the
bandage."
Their says that he added these words.
Well, he added the words after the
those are not the words of the
say
they don't say after the says I added
that because
if you can do it before how you going to
get a towel precisely the size same size
as the bandage
otherwise you're
Because any part of the hand that
doesn't have the bandage on it, you're
now to eat ala
cuz you might come to touch the food.
They're only make the makum.
Okay,
right namely
the chuva in the name of the
I'm sorry
if the bandage falls off you got to wash
again
that in a situation where there's a map.
If it fell off, you have to wash your
whole hand again.
If the band-aid fell off,
then you're going to have to wash again.
Now, the says you have to wash the whole
hand. You can't just wash the place
where the bandage was because that's
says I'm not convinced.
Why? Because at the time of Natila
Shina, you didn't have any more of a
now let's go back to
the Mishak was bothered. If you have a
band-aid and you can't remove it, it's
enough. It's
since you cannot wash the other part,
it's like
so you wash the rest of the hand.
Well, now if the band-aid fell off, it's
like you grew another finger.
So then what? The says you have to wash
the whole hand. I would have I would
have said for sure you have to wash the
whole hand. How could you just wash that
finger? It's
the is not does not agree. The says I'm
not sure because at the time
you didn't have more of a
Huh?
So what? Yeah, but now you have more of
a So you don't have to wash the first
part.
Yeah, I I mean uh
I I would I would have thought like the
that you have to wash your whole hand.
What's the to only wash the part of the
hand that now no longer has the bandage.
It's
okay. This is the Rama. The Rama says
I'm assuming this is the Rama even
though he doesn't say hag.
This is not the Mia,
right? This is not the Mia,
but he doesn't say hag for whatever
reason.
So, you're allowed to wash into a sink
or on the ground.
You can't just wash anywhere.
Has restrictions.
You can't just wash it on the ground if
somebody's going to step on it.
Now this is Mashma does not have ruini
says you still shouldn't drink it
because it's
maybe R. Miller would say that if you're
so unhygienic that you're drinking
someone's
so people are going to say this is who
gives Tyra to. So you don't have that's
a Miller interpreted
like if somebody puts on two jackets at
the time so your inner sleeve is not
going to go in. You look like an you
look like a homeless guy and people
gonna say this guy is a say no don't
worry I'll take it away from him.
Okay, this concludes sim
recording stopped.
