How Do We Define the First Month? - Gemarah Rosh Hashanah 6b-7a

the yeshiva dotnet evolved amid base three lines from the bottom you'd bought your not what you liked what she liked this and that's what is talking about before is better food today food doesn't work schnitzel is not gonna work today it's a long hard to get martini the boil who they asked a Shia the been a high achiever the students of the Shiva asked the following question Kurt when you have a player meaning the first male born of your cattle your sheep the puss it tells us when it comes to a ploy for imperative Allah from a Hashem ellicott Olano Shona hey Shona we have an obligation when a player is born to give it to the client call you in slaughters it in the baser mikdash and then he eats it as his carbon with the people he chooses to eat it with in your yeah but the Titus says he should eat it in front of hashem shana by shana year by year for which we learned that cut off time for eating that the part is a year so here is a year but the question is when do you start counting the year you have a year to give it to the client and the client has to slaughter it within the year and eat it within the year now once it's slaughtered it's gonna be eaten that day or the next day because it's a carbon a carbon car can only be eaten as we say the snail member Lila so it could be slaughtered close to the end of the year but it has to be eaten within the year but the year since when since when does it start so you might say from when the day it's born if it's born on Huff Festivus so you start counting the year you have a full year till the next off customers to eat the pie yes of course today's day or so that's gonna be the question well that's gonna be that's gonna be the question may aim assign mine in law from whether you count shana yeah I'm saying today's day of course the coin can be mark over the base--emitter so they have to do is we have to wait till it develops a man if your part is born even in how many base I make this with a blemish or it develops a blemish it also calls to the call yet but the Cayenne then just treats it like a regular a regular right and the time of the base I make it does right so so what one eight say is that before it's born when the mother before the mother goes to give you sell it to a non Jew no but illegal sale to a non Jew so that when the code is born it belongs to the non Jew and by him he doesn't have the Mitzvah it's not one of the seven minces but I know yeah if if you don't do that in other words maker I didn't you have a prior you have a calf that's born in the farm which of course would happen if you're a farmer it's bound to happen that this is gonna be a male firstborn it's not every animal remember its Bakr and sorry silver there's no picture people for a part of a person is opinion and one other epithermal better tomorrow you could be poisoned you give the car in a sheep that's done you have that you have that some time to time somebody who wants donkeys and and the first don't give it L don't can you point it yeah before it's born it's not holy before it's born it's not holy once it's born though it's holy so if it is born you there's nothing to do it's a carbon it's it's hecka dish you can't work with it you can't share its wool you can't use it for your own benefit it's actually a challenge you have to basically let it you can't constrain it put the Oaks on it you have to basically let it be free until it develops someone wants to develop some more then then yeah you give it to the cayenne and the Cayenne could do what he wants with a treat it like a regular animal it's still the coils it's rusev the Quarian but he could treat it like a regular animal the question is when do I count this year this year that the Cayenne has to eat it within the year when do I count what's the question what's the problem the question is make me say my name is Shawn I buy armor abaya says massage an ointment from the time it's born the back of a Yaakov are mark massage the needle arts are not you have actually a longer time from the time that it becomes suitable to become a carbon hard saw comes from the word wreath silly Rutzen in other words from the time it becomes willing from the time that it's a little eruption on a carbon we say it's a little Ruxin laughs nasha it's something that generates a deep desire and pleasure Cavaliere by initial air level from the time that it's really hard song in other words when it's suitable to become a carbon and that is not the first day that is the eighth day after it's born the posture tells us in very Kirk of bays that when your animal was born so Shiva youngins seven days it's it's under its mother for her yeshiva Yamantaka see my oh my oh hush Minnie Valhalla yatza the carbon is Shasha from the eighth day anon it becomes suitable as a sacrifice - and that's why the Gemara uses in the word Hartsock because the plastics their uses the words yay Russell the carbonation Russia if this is the case a buyer about her says the first seven days its for a carbon so you don't count it why don't you count that time because it has to be a year from when you're capable of eating it a full year when you're capable of eating it the first seven days you naughty can't be mattress so you start counting from the eighth day which means you have someone of an extension sug the Gemara of a life leaky the two views are not arguing for say they're not arguing a buyer said from birth through Baca said from the eighth day herba time hubbub I'll move when Abbas has said you count from when you could bring it as a carbon he was talking about a top Tom means a wholesome animal that's unblemished and therefore you could bring it as a sacrifice in the base on meters and sins you have to bring it as a carbon before you eat it the client contracted in his backyard and eat it he has to bring it to the base assembly such as a carbon so the first seven days Shiva yummy joint mush minimal actually the first eight days its muscles asthma it's not yet available so you can't eat it so that's why you wait through the day that he could eat it so you should be able to have a full year when he could Eden's however hubbub on moon when a buyer says he count from the day of birth you're talking about a blemished animal as Rashi says should know that at first Rashi on Zion Amidala fish and oil of bill muumuu it's born with a blemish for a medley shafted by huts and therefore it stands to be slaughtered outside of the base of McNish me i'm shinola to Roy Acuff you can already slaughter it from the day it's born o mine my mission my luck that's for a carbon that's only for carbon emitted you could yeah there is one concern that we're going to see in a moment with a merit Nathan right so therefore there's no argument have all full and mundane animals like a car bomb wound you can't set it and therefore you can test it you can't just gonna miss emitters so you count straight from birth flag the Gemara it still doesn't make sense bowel movement motsi ocular can you eat about moom right away when it's born and therefore you say that the count begins right away that's not the case why until the 8th day we have a halacha that it's a Suffolk novel meaning we're in doubt that it may not survive and if it doesn't survive you're now allowed a Shack didn't eat it so you also have to wait to the 8th day because then you can assume that it is a bar Kaiama it's going to survive so just like by a regular poker that's going to the base of mikta Tom you have to wait for the 8 days by Obama mules have to wait for the 8 days so the logic here seems flawed you're telling me that by the time the year can't cast not right away because you have to give him a full year of eating eating time a full year when he can eat it Obama also needs a full year from the 8th day you can only eat it by the 8th day that's the question bowel movement motsi awful a rash explains the ocean not allowed on the day that it's born Dillman a full hava perhaps this baby calf is not gonna survive it's an eyeful meaning it's destined to dock the ain't shitome attire sorry actually you should smile a young him to show off or claim a comma and the locker is that you have to wait 8 days and this there will not make it suitable to eat even though your says to the baby you would not be allowed to eat it you have to wait 8 days when it's alive to make sure that it goes out of the status of a suffolk knife the tiny the gomorrah says in sharpest a bracelet aluminum the alignment culture char solution boredom in a novel of the very much minor young by a person you wait 30 days and buy a behavior 8 wait 8 days and if you don't it's a problem of low social call novela an eyeful which is destined to die is bacala novela just like an animal that you don't shaft an animal that just dies on its own is a novela and if you eat a novela casillas ya get Malchus because it wasn't shafted here even though you chest it if it's an eyeful it has the status of unavailable tential novela because on its own it would die and therefore you now that eat such an animal nice circle Cannavale oh that's what you mean yeah it's not yeah you're right you're right it's that's the question of snake rights back to that question back to that question yeah roy of animals of course i'm not my flim but there is a mirror that could be and therefore the opponent made you wait eight days so you didn't solve the problem and for the Gemara the cable a basically legged awesome you're right i buy your would agree after wait eight days so why does that buy you say buy a moon you could do it right away the answer is i buy was talking about a particular type of calf the Kimmel a Bay we know for sure it's established about this animal Bay means him about this baby male calf talking about a male of course that's where it says Bay not bought Chicago Hadassah that the months of pregnancy have been completed in other words it was a full-term and therefore you can assume even before eight days that it's not an eyeful that's not going to die and such a calf you can eat from the day that it's born calf scanty yes and therefore you could count from the day of birth what happens if like a Lulu Hadassah what what's what's full-term birth what's Fulton birth so that the famous sodium greatest of casts a Bahama Gaza would be nine months of a medaka would be approximately five months right experience no well here you push it's sort you count at the time of the months months a Bahama garson nine if you don't know them you don't know then you gotta wait eight days you rent then you know not tuck if eight mykola Hadassah since it can only be eaten after the eighth day you start the year counting the code only from that day you don't count earlier so trashy no that's it's a the king baby Chicago huh - okay believe it or not the Gemara finishes finished with bow tie how did the good mother get into this whole issue of mouth after in the beginning let's remember the opening of Miss Exodus Hashanah was our border Shoshanna name that forager Shawna's the first Richard Sherman was established as the first day of missing the first definition was a reshawna for malacca for kinks for this degree murder wanted to the whole history of the Persian Empire to establish that the way the Jews established the anniversary of their kings was that every recitation was considered a new anniversary for the Kings and the reason it was important was for legal documents then the Gemara said there's a second richest on indocin and that is Pesach begins there Shoshanna little golem Irish Hashanah for holidays in other words the beginning of our year when it comes to you Montoya miss Peyser who cares coal pays us the second holiday the third holiday for this we explained that the Mishnah follows the view of repression who holds that bow to after must follow the rhythm the pattern that the order of the ailment - it's not just shavoo asuka's Pesach its pace of shrew asuka's in that order which is white up Shimon held that sometimes you get to wait five young men toy him and you still not even a ball Tosca if I was mawkish my bahama on mug boy it may be phosphorus so then I have slowest I have suckers I have Pacers have slowest and absence which of course if Shiva wouldn't agree that a year gives you about the affair because according to the persimmon clearly says sometimes you have five minute item which is much more than a year right it's much more than a year but that's the view of it Shimon and that's why he holds a suspicious shun Allura golem you don't start when it comes to Baltar you start with pacer then the Commissioner goes off to a nutritious shot which we'll be discussing later which is beside the hello and then we come to the next Rosh Hashanah which we're familiar with very much which is bathroom addiction rate and we finally come to the last Richard Shana which is Rashied the shmatte or according to this hello - Bhishma Commission sufficient we did you get five oh you mean because paisaje right so the milkman the Mishna said the Arab innocent is both so the Gemara explained that the F of innocent means on the day when Nissen comes in so that day is Rosh Hashanah and that day there is Kurdish which includes the whole month includes also the second one but yes technically it's five so do the motor turning upon we are now quoting a bracer what's the Blazer the Brice's accidentally introduced another restriction the ex-husband is in Russia not only one more than one and it's not in our mission which is going to create a straw problem why our mission it deletes it Tonetta bomber the rabbi's taught in a Bryce the Arab initiation of the hardship the Hadassah the first day of Nissen is the beginning of the year when it comes to months in other words we start counting our months from the first day of innocent meaning the month of Nissen is considered the first month of the Jewish calendar the month of Nisan is not month - we don't start other we don't even start Tishrei Tishrei - when kiss leftovers swap others so Nissen would be the seventh month no i Rosh Hashana four months when does our year begin in certain context of what in context of counting months it begins Nissen so Nissen is always our first month that's what the price is right so we'll see next lay burden for leap years the Gemara will explain next with true mass column the Gemara will explain the time when we use the noose column to buy our new car bonus as the Gemara will explain Nissen is the first month the area and some say a fluster is bottom also for renting homes which the Gemara will explain the point is if I rent you a home and I make up with you that the rent is for a year for this year one is the anniversary when is the end of the year what is the end of the year so some say the end of the year is the last day of other when it comes the first day of nyssa the home goes back to me even if I rented it to you say middle of schrott and basically I say you have it for the rest of the year that means you have it for a month and a half not what not more because Nissen becomes the beginning of therefore scooters but now of course if you take the rest of this year if you say you have it for a year right then I rent it to be smart you have it till the next to be shot if you have it for a year but if I say if you have it this year till the end of the year so what does it mean of course if you specify in the contract it's not a problem then there's no wish so crashy McCutchin la minion Kochiyama to the count of the months of the year this is number one now you're going to say well my enough communi who cares what's the difference well what Sauceda mom lee Boren csoka died Tadashi says and at the moment we think what it means because ulka died which means it goes up on our mind Laish of bez Dhin for the court to sit will the iron to investigate to look into the night in my shana hibachi philosophic if the following year needs to be one of 13 months it needs to be so to speak a pregnant year which of course means adding an additional month an additional month is called a high dish eBrush nasa eber which means a pregnant year why just like a pregnant woman is carrying an additional life in her body this year carries an additional month it's a larger year-old Islamic scholar what's Thomas column a hawk revolution car bonus Halleck ocean mature Muskoka strzelczyk leshawna's ooo missin becomes the first month when we start offering sacrifices that we purchase from the donations in the boxes in the chests and the containers of the new donations that the Jewish people gave in this column of this year which will be going to elaborate on a flesh killer's bottom a massacre by law Havana you rent a house to a friend vomits on a zoo it's for this year not for a year for this year call session also become innocent the year ends on the first day of missin Buffalo Lloyd our boy Ella hi - not even if I rented it to him and he had it only for one month in other words I give it to him before a Scottish other so he has it for a month it's only a month on the other hand we see from Rashi that if I rent it in for example Bay's other and I say for this year then he has it for a full year why because we don't assume that a person will rent a house for less than a month so therefore by it we assumed that it means the full year that's what you see from Russia as the Gemara will explain late now the Camorra analyzes this price of a sudden and of not less than a month a month yeah not less than a month base other missin missin becomes the deadly dr. Kumar Lockhart you mean Allah Allah - you mean on how do you know that your straightest Nissen is delicious under four months maybe subscribe this year maybe search latest history alright Dixie's this is a buffet - of pasta in next week's partial partial boy before the Jewish people leave Egypt now here you have to remember something we're so used to missing near sieve and Thomas of a latisha we forget then a commission from Chautala there's never ever a mention of a name of a month all you have over there is a hi - Shari right beside your tradition as we're gonna have the bhai - Amy Beth Lakotas Messiah shochet me Bassam oh hi - we have the word of it we'll see in a moment we never have the name of a month so we are giving our interpretation so when it says on the seventh month and the first day your intuition below Schaefer we of course are we know it's this red how do you know how do you know what's number seven maybe you have to start counting number one the month that we call civil and number seven is another month that's all we're gonna be dealing with so we said Nissa Nissa Shoshanna look Hatchin how do you know so you're gonna tell me there's gonna be a pasta the positive is gonna say that the first month is gonna be missing but the boss it doesn't have the word in this assembly so this is what the camera is now gonna analyze the exhibit is a possible in parishes boy before the Jews leave Egypt Hashem speaks to my Shannara and what does he tell them these words afraid the shylaja Dasha we shine who'll ahem Luciana literally translated this month in other words when I'm talking to you now we have to figure out when he's talking to them posture doesn't give a date but this month when I'm talking to you has air this month it has to be this one is really - is the head of the months month months Risha you lock em it's the first one for you for the months of the year so we have two parts of the past sick apparently they're both saying the same thing this month is the first month and it's the first month of the months of the year what if more do you need so clearly you have a mitzvah minute Ida entire day in parishes but that listen is the first month for all the months of the year that's when you start counting the question now is why you're associated with Nissen how do you know what it is or the time of April maybe said maybe it's odd there maybe it's L what we call Ella she says you have to look at the whole context you Chris's passage base might you'd base versus Bush moisture base buses let's go to pass a given table Ella Cola husband a colored our sister Ellen speak to the entire community of the Jewish people say but osterlich our dishes on the tenth day of this very month this month that I'm telling you is the first month V column each cell of a service alibis every man should take a sheep for the entire family a sheep for one family for one home and of course this is the Mitzvah that of the 10th day of nyssa they have to separate a sheep or a goat for the Pesach for the Passover offering now you go to ok so what do we know how do you know this is missing so you just know in the same month on the tenth day you separated a sheep ok maybe it's a low next pasta glove volula Hamlisch Maris you should guard this sheep at our bar us are you a fighter shaza till you reach day 14 of this month and what do you do then the shuffle - I say we going where it says vishakha - I say Coyle Carla - Robin are by the entire community of Israel's had slaughtered his sheep Bane are by him in the afternoon when evening begins when dusk begins of this day 14 so in other words you purchased the Sheep on the 10th you guard it for 4 days and on the 14th of innocent in the afternoon you slaughter it ok so how do you know day 14 is the month of Nissen you're just building up we know it's all one month this month is the first month this month you buy the Sheep on the tenth day this month you slaughter the Sheep on the 14th day but we have one more pasta and for this we have to go away from parties boy and go to partials or a oak see if we have a pasta commercial a Devoran predictor zion chimers hi - Arvest you have to guard the month of what we call spring of if the beginning of spring when why we calling it spring really what others means is the time when the grain becomes ripe and edible the stalks of wheat of barley of spelt of oats of rye becomes ripe when you can harvest them and and eat them and enjoy them summer is reddish of guard this month of spring for a seesaw Pesa Larsa Malika it's in this month that you should make a pacer for our summer God and I'll continue the plastic ki bhai - arrivederci Oshkosh member lacasa mum it's Ryan lightly because in this month of other Hashem took you out of material at night clearly we learned from here two things number one the carbon pacer has to be offered in the month of others there's no arguing with that number two you'd see us retiring was in the month of others so now back the poshest boy you're telling me that you're offering we know that it's a carbon pace of comparisons buddy he says it's a carbon pacer and we know that it's in the same month that is the first month of the year and we know that's the 14th day of that month and we know that the next day they left Egypt and we know from partial survey that it's tried to shut off his if it's like the Charlotte now let's disturb loose which month is the month above it is a Tishrei is it Tavis is it L will is it simmer the azo hug the shares by others what's the side dish we have others what what do we mean by others viv comes word Ave which means a father it's the time when the grain reaches the first time full ripeness full ripeness that's what we mean by others that's why it's from the word of which is the father have the oil is endless this isn't this this you don't have to speculate this you have to go to your fields and your farms and see which month is the grain ready it's fully cooked so to speak it's fully ripe it's fully grown the car you ladyship and the Turner calls this month our dish of a fish which you can't argue with is the haria that the month that we came to associate with Nyssa which is the month when the grains in the fields are ripe and ready for harvest this which we which we call mister this is the month when you have to start counting the husband of your months it's a recession on the cartagia that's the Frenchman of the Gemara sorry the gancelot potential Rashi says how far - as all of them Umi know under Nissen exceed vehicle I'm celibate sir O'Keefe crafted in a shop a thermal inertia of is what spiders other say yes you boy oven what makes it wouldn't be in a month of of it so rash yzma diet it's the month in which you have of it what is of it ha ha - herb athira boy that food matures the two are so to speak fully the grain fully develops and matures Lee a specialist literally means cooked here it means of course fully ready fully right bakumaru Shula it reaches the crescendo the zenith of being right that's why it's called of --iv from the word I've I've is the father of the family the first one of the family in other words it's the first month when the tour is tour when it's great quite a shot flag the Gemara vein a year one second the month of the year the fact is you'll go to any farm you go to any meal some grain will be readiness and some grain will be ready yeah same thing so that's why the sharpest maybe that's why the show that's when our son spoke to Moshe and iron that's when you have to start counting the months that's when you have to bring the carbon pay so that's when they left Egypt so can you give Mara no the ena of is the lacquer remember the month is called ovis of it is from the words of I've represents the first one of the family the father figure of the family in other words it's the time that the Torah is first ready the first slew is ready the lekha here is not that month why because even though you have some food that gets fully ripe in the month of the year this is not the first for this is the later grain so it's not other which comes from the word I've an Tricia's reaction says Bettina other Valletta shekhar nikuman reminiscent you have grain that's already ready and listen vee cos ira failings Ibaka lawful the fact that you have seeds that produce and ripen up later that's not bother that's not the first bucket from the word car here right it's not the first it's the later ones so doesn't go into the category of oven when do you have of it when they have the first ones the a venus flag the Gemara way a buzzer I've a mother then it should be other because you will have some grain that will ripen in other so far care that's the father so I'm thinking Mara being a royal office the fact is most of the grain will ripen up in this ear you'll have the late comers other you'll have the early commerce but most of the grain becomes an Ave right most of the grain is ready innocent alekhya you don't have that another flag more than MIDI revolve ifs if it says in the tighter the toy - album is the height is what most of the grain is of if it's as high - olive maybe even if you have a few spokes of grain that are ready for kept those are the first those are the father figures that's the beginning so it would be other Shevat very in the stand up Tavis I understand that it's still winter it's not gonna happen but already or do you have it not the majority of the form the majority form is gonna be missin but you have it in other so you're back to square one maybe I shall spoke to Moses and Aaron in order and others to be the first month what would be the ramifications of this Durand vacations will be very simple when it says you have to celebrate Rosh Hashanah and the seventh month would mean a lot and when it says you have to celebrate Pesach in the first month it would mean other it would be all difference would be a whole different story everything would be different and when it says that on the seventh month on the 15th you have to celebrate circus and at the seventh month on the tenth day you have to fast it means you dare open up your Tishrei so it's very very important to know what is the first month avi asked before who cares what the first month is okay is what the first month is the whole time that speaks about months there's only one way I could know I have to know what's one what's towards me what's for so we have an easy way we say miss Cynthia seven but we can't take this for granted you see you learn from here and tarnish about that nothing is taken for granted we already live 3,000 years of Jewish life so we take everything for granted when it space to listen I don't know it's very nice this there's also two fingers in this Sinan Homer there's no sort of thing there's no other there's no listen this mission and Shanee so everything has to be analyzed everything has to be thy second it's just important to realize this everything has to be deconstructed it's called Deconstructor the company missile hell how do we know when they did it how do we know you have a video you have a very what was soda you're calling it listen the whole the whole word Nissen didn't exist in Jewish history you know that the months of the names of the months are not Jewish names they're Persian or Iraqi names Babylonia Babylonian names the gomorrah says Schmeisser Hadassah all the way mind me bother remember for the hundreds of years of Jewish history didn't exist four hundred years Jews came in Texas all before the first base of McNish another forty is the base of English almost for a millennium there were no names of months you know what are the names were just like Sunday Monday Tuesday didn't exist okay but I'm saying the beginning of Jewish history we same Churchill you like my own memory or shimmer Shabbos are you a near by shamans in fact there I'm bond says there are bond right since Amish it's as accuracy of my sharpest Licata you always have to remember the day of Shabbos he says the weakest now that I have its own names all the names have to be focused on Shabbos today is the first day leading up to Shabbos today is the second day from the seventh day it's all leading up the sharpest today's the sixth day are you a machine she Erev Shabbos it's always about sharpest it's not a Monday according to their mind Monday is not Monday Wednesday is not Wednesday Thursday is not Thursday it's two days before Shabbos very interesting number some people live like that they say in Yiddish I heat zoom tick tock montigue was resigned in stick mitzvah struck their asses doggish dictionary of shoppers but after star Burton some people have that policy understood a Jew it doesn't work in English shop is fighting it once sharpest composition Allah has the reference what was the reference of the month one two three months or oh yes right well you're not gonna complain listen to January listen became Jewish we may we turned it into like like Yiddish like the language of you dish sake this is prank but sargon it comes from some of the names the martial combos it says in the assess Co nauseam Mavic OSS Atomos the women wept for the Tama there was a deity called Thomas no Thomas I know the tumblers I lived it would you the big discussion in Spartan how the hazael remember they came up with bubble they came up from bubble the word small people who came from above are you dealing with Eze look we learnt before you have Ezra and the cameras above oh you mean a little and a little huh apart from the COTS care yeah you know in many circles LOL everybody becomes religious so the cuts could said i'll Tiffany well Holly limb don't turn Evelyn to a guard dog Tiffany well our little Davis Davis is around also in the month of Taylor's Tiffany Lily yeah it was a you do came to the COTS care there was a youth who came to the COTS can say how I found there was an interesting thing in 1991 the Bible used to give a brush head of him keep him after minister to the whole oil of the Claudia's cell so so before he started he turned to the copy they shot announced when might've is I was surprised you kept at night you don't call it my Navy a call if Clinton said announcer might have this so there was a year there he tells me that he'd once came to the coccyx ecause his son became a crosses and he was very disappointed she came to Erev Pesach to see how pay suckers he asked the cops period when is when is gonna be the Seder tonight she said supper is gonna be at seven o'clock he ran away because it just confirmed that this is not a normal place of Judaism he comes back out of him Kippur and he says when is gonna become their doing I said I might have a 630 so he lost his patience he runs into the cutting of Ebony says what type of disciples the ass I say then he called supper that should have dinner whatever he called it an and then politicals minor so the cuts could ever said it's proved Iceland and - didn't as yet the veteran is are sated and yet they might have is a commentary I teach my students that every supper is I say there and every might have is a comment so so you have Arabic seus of the names of the month that come only later in Jewish history when they come from Baba that means it's almost a thousand years without it so the Gemara now is just asking the question maybe hide the shove if there's other I know it's about trying to shove if I'm not gonna put you'd see as much crime in the month of Elul or Cashman or Kislev I'm gonna put it in the area of springtime but maybe it's the month of August that's the Schuyler by the way the Mitzvah and Iran say the reason this is so important is number one to know when the holidays are number two also to understand foolish and homeless you have a lot of dates on the second month on the twentieth day of the month the Jews left her scenic off year the cloud went up when is that for sure to have a Havana to have our one in homes sake tomorrow right Ella Arbor is de the Place des says you have a good point we refute the first source Mahakala we learned that the first month is innocence from another possible posture can purchase Emmer when it comes to suka sit says a spa hamesha hace la Haider sorry but us / chemist warrants on the 15th day of the 7th month when you gather the grain of the earth and deposit finishes to show you as hoggish am shiva sermon by yuri marushin Shabazz much money Shabazz on the 15th day of the 7th month when you gather the grain of the earth you have make a holiday of seven days this is of course the holiday we call circus the first days the seventh day the eighth day is shavasan which men call so many odd saris but your magician by your Marsh meaning they inter entered in intermediate days of Kalama nasal heard the shares verse if now I ask you which month do you gather the grain it's not the month that you harvest the grain it's not the month that you store you believe the grain outside to dry it's the month that you gather it into the garage to the silo into your house have an emissary why because remember an ancestor all the season of rain begins in the month of question you didn't want to leave the grain outside of the month of freshmen because it's gonna get ruined from the rain you wanted to leave it outside during the summer because you wanted it should dry so when did you take it in heaven is officially it took it in initially in order to man get wet before them before the winter you keep it as piles in the field in order to dry it out they cut corollary and you call it the seventh month I ask you a question so this month is the seventh month and this is the month we associate with Tishrei so when is gonna be the first month the first month is gonna be missing if tissue is number seven listen is gonna be number one flagging the Gemara let's see - she very my other the eCos I refer farmers bathroom a other you have early seeds that get ready another row evolve you need drive over so you drove to isthmus backness but most of the grain then the Romero says how do you know it's a species where sit for so much listen by Paris libido plant summon the colic is in a serious condition lavish all summer it spoils outside in the field or outside in the yard in order to dry up threatening a mother of a man my refreshment maybe her - Ashley is my freshmen okay oh my sri srila ear maybe it's the seventh month that begins the ear let's start the pista has this source - de stablish that Nissen is the first month maybe ear is the first month and tissue is the seventh month of ear I'm sorry it's catchment and it's a seventh month of the year how do you know in other words you should make ear the first day of the month and the seventh month will be fresh with other the Gemara being awesome the luck we said that yes you have to gather the grain in fresh when you don't gather the grain because you ready wanted inside because of the rain flag tomorrow paver a Morello maybe well no you're right the today Evan says the mother could have said that we needed of is not to be ear but the Gomorrah is is giving a better answer from ear itself in other words it can be here because Cashman can't be called a sauce if you know the instead of just going back to Nissen an ear we're going we're going to this issue it's of you're right we could have also said that we already rejected here but we're also rejecting year because Cashman won't work so the Mercer's okay session won't work the a Morello we're almost repeating the same discussion but when it will talk coming to tissue and Cashman and vena ll make it L in ello you gather in some grain right well my sri srila the seventh month would be the seventh month of what we call other in other words are good is the first day and here you can't give me the answer that you want to give me that other is not obvious other is of if it's the beginning of our we it's not revolve it but at the beginning above it and for the Gemara the inner drive or civil occur it says the time of us if most of the grain you gather not an ll most of the fruits you gather initially for everything a more than midday very vociferous if it says it or even worse if it says must become you have to gather doesn't say how much maybe it's a minority so therefore if it's a minority could also be an L so L is the seventh month Rosh Hashanah is El Elyon Kipton is ll circuses L Oh and when did you see us miss Ryan have one was the carbon base a whole in order are you need of if you have of it and you know what the Gemara has no no answer for this from Hamish I don't have a source from homage I don't know there's no way it's interesting I don't know when it's his miss Ryan was I don't know whether carbon paste I don't know when trying to solve is I don't know when the seventh month is carga asif is it's around the area of missing but it could be other us become is around the area of Tishri could be able alam Aravena comes Raveena so we rejected the first view we rejected the pista the second view Raveena comes and says you're right I concede Davao said this thing which think that the first month is missin me Toyota's moisture banal oil Ahmad no very interesting expression we did not learn from the Toyota of my Shara Bey no there's no way we would know it formation of a nose text me DVA Kabbalah Ahmad no this is something that we derived from the words of the prophets there's a posse conspire you pay the Caliph the last guy is one of the prophets below him Eston enviable ash they are so foolish who hi - Shevat business talmud area vishal yet valid aeneas hiya Bambi ratio Bandido an avi lamer on the 24th day of the eleventh month which is the month of Shevat year - of the Persian king diary of a sh hashem speaks - sorry the prophet we learned from here that schrott is the 11th month if smartest 11th month it means that Nissen is the first month once already we establish look wash DBMS tavar ball the ash they also find it what does our sterasyl fetish mean I stay us is 11 who clay this rut he says clearly okay this right yep this limit could only come after the Jewish people already had the names of the month missin year seven Thomas etc which they brought back from bhava and they have this order of the months now you could bring her alia right now just without this just to tell me that Samantha's the 11th month doesn't help me right why how do you know listen is the first month how do you know listen is the first month maybe Shabbat comes before Tavis and other is the first month there's no way of knowing it how do you know Nissen is the first month maybe Shabbat is the eleventh month and the first month is other right and Shabbat comes before Tavis I don't know so you have to say that this is after they already had their months their names and they had to order shabbath comes after Tavis it comes before other and now it says Samantha's number eleven it means other is number 12 and misson is number one so now I go back and I say when the trailer says I've heard this as I lost ambition Elohim the house under which month is it from the V and we see that it's the month of Nisan Caracas number 11 ref grab a ruler Imam a haka this is Ravina rob of the son of allah has another source it says in McGillis estimated base button laka Festa della Mela by Allah sorry but they look at Estoril I'm a local fresh mannish I'll be small who say by Friday shall city latest Avis Esther was taken to the king of fish Raiders to his palace on the tenth month which month is it the month of tavis business travel among Xhosa clearly Tavis is the tenth month if Tavis is the tenth month and it's 10 after missin missin is the first month if Kahana Mameha if Connor goes to another post against higher-paid anxiety by e-business are Bilad al-sham ella hi Eduardo Najera barbala Felicia Chi big kislev on the fourth year of the of a sham speaks to Scalia on the fourth day of the ninth month which is Kislev if Kislev is the ninth month misson is the first month navaja by jakub mm a haka the battle Yaakov has another source also from Achilles Esther para chats by a car do say free MLF may say he by fighters Ashleigh she who riders even wish Lisa the s3 boy the scribes of the King Ahasuerus was summoned on the 3rd month the month of 7 on the 23rd day of the month they were summoned to do what to write down a New Eden and send it out to the entire Empire in which the Jews have a right for self-defense Basia mama Hoffa about she has another positive Magilla it says about her mom by faith this additional tradition established nasty nasty animal - straightish hip ill poor who are girdle atheneum on me i'm lee i'm omaha - Lahaina sh sh name uh sir who clay - odd door basically hummons casts a lapse from day to day and from month to month till the 12th month which is the month of other are there is not month one are there is month number 12 and what's month one the one after other which is missing because you don't have more than 12 months one second Vibha is same mao if you want to call in and out from the same post at the beginning of the PASOK bhai distribution who widest Nissen wish nastain Esther day the Malik ahave - he pill poor who are girdle of Mohammed on the first month which is the month of nyssa year 12 of a harsh Raiders hum on cast as luck remember hamid cast his lot in the month of Nissen and it falls out on the month of other on you'd gimble other that's what he's going to exterminate a little all the jews and the juror comes out you'd give them this and right before pacer who you and they have a full year to prepare for extermination of the jews from you given listen till you'd give my mother almost a full year 11 months of course during pace of everything changes because harmon gets hung but the evict is still not canceled that's why it's only enough gimel seven that the king is going to send out a new letter which doesn't cancel out the edict because he says I can't cancel my decree all he does is people don't realize he gives Jews the right to fight back it wasn't that Purim was just a dandy holiday that came easy there was a war and the Jews had to fight back all the King said was you have my right my permission to fight back in a year from now on you'd give a lot to so that was a very heavy year it's not like it was everything was I'm a high they were preparing for war on all fronts well you would have had the army and the police force against them now it was just private and two semitic citizens you didn't have the King behind it initially you had the whole empire no so he would tracted no he didn't retract his decree the decree was that every person should kill every single Jew in one day that wasn't retracted what was retracted was number one that the king will not assist it in other that wasn't retracted he just decided not to assist in a number two the jews could fight back which they did nobody warned they would have fought back but they wouldn't have had no think they could have been killed they had to go to war so save the Megillah it says how many of the enemies were killed it doesn't say about truth yeah because that we have 12 months yeah we are formed right we have 12 months flag the Gemara so did you see what happened here from moistures title we didn't learn it we learned it from the VN but then we went through a whole Raveena gave us Shabbat now look at this Raveena gave us wat rabba gave us Tavis if Kahana gave us kislev rabhasa gave us seven you see the pattern he starts with shots he goes Tavis it goes backwards Shabbat Tavis kiss live and then sieve and he doesn't have anything between 7:00 and kislev and then he gives us other all the way at the end and then he says and if you want he could give us this let me get more of a cool of my time allow me may hire you your whole point is to establish then this is the first month you have a clear plastic in McGillis Esther bhai - our nation whose right is missing why are you giving me all these other months and then you have to make a husband this way that listen is the first-ever puzzle Bakula my pen wimonrat for the Gemara Dillman my retiarius animals because in this posture you can tie tradition not the first month mission for the story written the most say means vision for this story for the event and it says behind the traditional Swedish missin bastarz mish-mashed emissary hip-hop or maybe the first month for example when hummin went up to power you could say it's the first month of the event something that happened in the context of that story that's when hummons story begin is the first month of hum and that's the month when I flex pay - appointed him as his prime minister and he immediately cast his lot and this would be part an important part of the story that he didn't waste time he became the Fuhrer of Persia and immediately the same month he plot an extermination but you can't prove that Nissen is the first month in terms of the count of the months of the year the other person can however you can prove it that's why Nissen was only brought as a last a last option so the Oracle on air says that the reason he doesn't start with any other month he wants to start with Nivea you haven't a V him and you have Kossuth him he wants to start with Nivea so he starts with Shevat okay once you start with Serrat now he goes upwards see he goes Tavis which is from Silva McGillis ester then he goes kissed love which is backed in a VM from Sarria then he goes to seven which is back Silva McGillis ester and then he goes back to McGill assessed and he goes to other he goes to other he doesn't want to start with are that even though he's starting from the bottom up because he doesn't want to start with the children wants to start with in the via when he finishes with that he goes to misson which is also from Silva so we established that Nissen is the first month I just want you to take a look at choiceless madere Kabbalah la mano it's an important Isis forces in terms of understanding how the month developed sucked Isis we don't learn it from Commission with the Kabbalah he says a very interesting comment now how do we know listen is the first month because it's brought in a VM in children that schmata is 11th month suck toy service if SH what is the 11th month listen is the first month one second but here I have a problem how do you know when missing us how do you know what you're telling me smartest 11th month okay maybe SWAT comes before Tavis yeah maybe Nissen comes before other maybe Nissen comes after year toys for says like Mott Sela Miller from economy now you clown there's no way you could learn out the truth from here employment if you're not gonna assume shall I say Kabbalah be Adam say - Maya Hadassah was a casa that when the Navi max of them were written they already had a tradition of the order of the names one after the other Raveena and the other a Miriam understood the new order of the names of the month so when it says Shabbat is eleven Nissen has to be the first the ha Fiamma bearish am Li hua Shan Meis is in recession Schmoyer Sokka darshan all will be Adam above the names of the month were not part of a rich Jewish history they came when the profits came back from Babylonia where is China in the beginning they had different names to Isis says what were the names this is gonna give an example what do we mean in the beginning not uncommon comas you only have numbers but for example in the viim before they came back from Bothell what did Schwimmer call Tishrei so ty service says we're shine in the beginning tsch they had a name Jericho a summon there's a posse Camelot him that they gathered by flood the yera face on them the months of the a-sun and why is it called a son and his son of means the powerful ones the mighty ones shibai no lieu of us Tishrei is the month when the others were born so it was called the month the month of the mighty ones the classroom was called Jarek pool the month of bull in Malakand para cows of Bashan Hashanah Arthas SCB era boo hi - hush Minnie the eighth month why shibai call her eylem helena evil that's the month that gets very close and Helen over all the leaves fall off no Velma share all the leaves fall off and also hurrah rates are soo you Beulah's Bullis also because of the rain and catchment the earth this becomes a clumps the earth becomes Goshen it becomes clumps also should boy boy luma Bahama the battalion people bring in the animals to the house because there's no pasture in the fields so Tishrei was called the air fa sonim question was called era bull the month of bull it's also the month when the marble began ear was called zip era Ziv again in Malakand para cada this is all the era of Schlemmer hemella it's before they're coming back from above oh it's after the time of UTSA with Ryan there are different names yeah as if wise are called zip the month of of of light of array she as believe I alumnus because the the juries come back to their full light and splendor McConville aileth once they came back from bubble they started to commute them with names of myths in here and that's why it says by he betrayed his innocence nos asked him but he betrayed his crystals mastered him but hey - I'll see you later Davis this is all later on in Jewish history when the names come back and they know also the order once they have the order now you can establish that if smart is number 11 listen is number 1 but from Toyota itself I can argue differently I can say other other is number 1 so therefore how do we know Nissen is Rosh Hashana love abortion it says how high - as Ella hemorrhage at Hadassah Mauritian who la cama hot-cha-cha know which month is that the month you brought the car basis but I still don't know that's the month of missing but from Tanakh I know what the month of Nisan once I know the time at it turns out retro actively that high - as elohim is missin and the turner tells me that dad has to become the first month of the month of the year and that's how I have to now learn homage and understand all the months and the number are based on listen being the first month the problem of course becomes why our mission ignores that importance Trish Hashanah that it's inertia sha-la-la-la-la Hadassah it's only in the Bryce it's not in our mission the fight it's a very important no siree when the tradition is comes we say now starts the count of the month this is the first month why don't we have that in our mission we ignored that we only averaged to shuttle them a lot of a lyrical okay Dobbs and Amidala and before the wide lines right before the wide line the wide line start with like a mighty will hold me the line before the mill set so in summation will left here with a question what's the question the de motor brought a Bryson the bracer says that the first day of Nissen is irrational of hadashah in other words it's the beginning of the year in terms of the count of the months of the year that the first month is clay dismissal that's always month number one so that's the rosh hashanah it's the first what do we mean rosh hashanah in the coming year there's going to be 12 months the beginning when this month one is missin and then the deprives have got another few details Borden true masculine and serious bottom which to tomorrow is going to discuss the other ones but first the focus was on item number one what is the meaning that it's her Shoshanna looks odd awesome and how do you know it so you brought a clear plastic from Parsons boy but this month is Rashad Asham it's the head of all the other month's recién who look em look Archer Shana nope you don't need more than this clear posting that this has to be the first month in other words it seems literally there are some is tally motion of a no on the month of Nissen this has to be called Risha ear will be number two and seven will be three and Tamas will be four now later we're gonna see this is gonna be an argument between the Bellas and a beer sure when the world was created the world was created at the end of Elam before Tishrei when the world was created the end of other before miss but this doesn't seem relevant to the discussion here the discussion here is the rich were points this out that no matter when the world was created the first month that you have to count we should overcome the hot summer has to be this even if Rosh Hashana what we coalition Shana Irish Hashanah is this rate why because the world was created Raffaello and other men cover were created the first day of Tishri if that's the case other men however their first month was not listen it was Tishri when they started to count their lives listen was month this it was a month seven not month one nonetheless and parshas by it says clearly recién who love hemlock Hashanah it has to be the first month for you yeah and there is showing them say why because we're supposed to count the months based on you'd see us mister him in other words let's talk about it differently you'd see us with try him is the time that the Jewish nation was born or as the Gemara puts it by Martin Toyota he'd see us with Ryan which culminate in a mountain tired of the Jewish people converted and Garrison this guy could cut in shinola dummy again is like a newborn child so the public birth humanity was born maybe in the first day of Tishri but there was a new humanity the Jew was born as part of the Jewish people when by in see estimates Ryan so missin is our first month missin is our collective and individual first month as Jews and part of remembering it see us mature I am every single day is that we begin our count when we become a nation which is during the exodus of Egypt DTS Messiah and it was says that's why it doesn't say Risha loo loo Hashanah it says recién who welcomed laka Josh Amma for the world may be rich in Makati Hashanah is tisha read original ahem for you who are being reborn as an independent people by Pesach by Nissen this is your first month this is like when you emerge emerge into the world and this would be similar to the days of the week we count your English Shabbos we have no separate name for the day of the week it all leads up to Shabbos so then the number of the months also we have a commandment that it should relate to the time that we left left it left Egypt but look I however you explain it it's a clear possum on this the Gomorrah challenged it we don't know that it's missing we know that it's a first month we know we know that it's we call it missin time of April time of pacer but doesn't say that how much he goes through the whole proof that it's a time yet to be in the carbon pace pace of course and hide the Shabbos tire shop Eve is the beginning of spring when the green becomes right listen I could be here he says here is only the late ones it's not the first ones he says it could be other this is honor it's not the majority this is mine now it isn't maybe it's not the majority maybe it's even the minority and therefore you reject and then the other proofs mister brings a proof from suckers that it says when you gather the grain you should celebrate sickness and it's the seventh month and that's when you gather the grain which is the month that you gather the grain before it rains it's gonna be tissue and you call it the seventh months of Tishri is the seventh month that Nissen is the first month and again he rejects it maybe it's freshmen he says it can't be casually because he gathered the grain Atisha maybe it's a low again most of the grain or fruits you don't gather a tition it but NLO but some you do so that was also rejected so finally Raveena said that this talk and no source of foolish lovers loin meat meat itis motion of anal oil Ahmad no there's no source in homage to commercially would it not the source comes from lithium and silver and he goes through a whole list of sukham international vmix of him from sorry I'm Achilles Esther will you see and he starts with schrott goes up to Tavis goes up to Kislev goes up to seven and then goes back to other from Achilles Esther Harmons locked and then even gives a parsec for missin Hipple poor that mark that that that the Kurdish additional tradition assume is not a massive long after April poor who are gardial as we read important in the Megillah clearly missive is called the first month so we proved it not kamesh we proved it from where from the vehemence oven that Nissen is the first month of Shabbat is the eleventh month and Tavis is the tenth and kislev is the nineteen seventies the third and Nissen is the first obviously listen is the first month so now when you go back to Commission it says this should be your first month you should overcome the Hashanah is it gonna be are there it's gonna be missed and that was the question can be Tavis nests for Chanel Aviv Davis's winter as you can feel outside at the moment but it is myths in which we see from tonight clearly is considered what the first month Naveen makhzoom and we can rely on us this one thing how come is the separation it's a good question but what's the relevance here because some of the things is being answered oh you're learning your sami Rosh Hashanah with some of these things that are connected to my English nice you're learning Mishnah is mine oh you saw me do my nervousness okay well over two different compositions one was an artist wrong and one was a hundred years later in Iraq in Babylonia there was a whole different different local travelers would bring their different information they got them bobbly they got comedy shove it that's why the how luck is like volley because they manage to see their show me it was two different compositions yeah it's like you'll have the show tomorrow over the base everything you'll have their utmost commentary right right and contemporaries so now the question the Gemara asks is all Xena's Oh so why doesn't our mission dimensions why doesn't our mission it was this mr. Shauna back up innocent we say there's a son of the Malacca there's a son a little golden why not there's a Shambhala cops that's the good models Island now after this discussion saga the Gemara Vuitton nerdy dawn what about our time our Tanner did on means our our town and our mission of base who did not say that one of the rarest saunas that begins on the first day of innocent is additional Hudson you have to answer but Shamim comedy but what's awesome about he's looking for something our bar rosh hashanah made our irish that defines the year the holy year when it comes to the king it's the full year at righteousness it begins an anniversary of a year the nexus credits listen will be year 2 year 3 year 4 year 5 and the same is true the other is shoshanna's whether it's research on allah my son Bahama rosh hashanah lee Lummis you're dealing with a full year Shoshana for Schmidt delicious on the frivolous here you dealing Irish Hashanah not a whole year we're dealing with a month the cut summer collection like Almighty not month that's that that could be an explanation that it doesn't make it into our Mishnah and actually says butternut did on the lake tana the must dissolution of the Hudson it's because bhushanam commodity but reduction Lloyd Kamini so toy service asks a very interesting question if you look entices Bashan income IV we're talking about years recognize was excuse me the first one I agree there's a sauna level of him as a year what about the second one the other ones are also years when do you start giving my Simba Hayden what's considered the year which behaviors that are born and this year that mice I understand FFL but what about there's your son alehrer Gollum what's her she suddenly regala Bokashi da comely regala vom male heir we just live in the previous Seguin your mother the whole city with Malta and evolve amid Bay's Kievan Ciavarella Shana Valerie : we're a gullible a summer the Gemara explained that bow tie affair your even if what if a whole year passes without the young M tourism and the Gemara to explain how that can work right those few situations or what was the second option if your mum toven passed without a year pacer jus asuka's pass without a year your even about basket new so what's in her she shot a little girl look - Liz Lemon we call Macumba seduction like come on taster says you're right there's a shuttle in a column does it necessarily include a whole year because pay sex rules circus is not a whole year is 3m toy but nonetheless it's not month by month it's something that spans throughout the year it's not an engine of one month by one month which is this situation witnessing is month one here is month - so when you say dress your son a la carte shipment means that this is the first month then is the second month it's not something that defines the whole year on the contrary it's a distinction of 12 units within the year no you're right you need 12 months to have a year but when you say but effort the mission is Rosh Hashanah it's not very summer it's not a day that includes the year it's the first day of the first month in the new 12 months right but how do you count in 12 months ah no you're right you should all a couple of carts a sauna so it's a count that today is number one which is gonna end in two 30 days or 29 days and then you're gonna count number two in other words it's one of 12 yeah yeah but you know what your starting is not something for the year for the year you're right you're gonna have 12 together and that's gonna be a whole year but that's is the hook then it's an oddball Rosh Hashanah mate or to put it differently it's not a date it's brought and smart and we brought it that you would we call it rosh hashanah macula session we call cool massage sauna so it's brought that rush means a head that a head is not just the beginning of the body yeah it's true that head is the beginning of the ladder ahead encompasses the whole body the brain has with him at every limb every organ every nuance of the body the central nervous system includes the whole body Suresh Sharma is not just a lisanna Rosh Hashana actually is like the neurological aspect of the year that's why there's your son is such a precious time because it's like in the brain a little you know a little scratch it's not obsess scratching the brain there's a little tiny mushy brain it affects literally the entire block yeah yeah I mean without sobbing the giver the cup is constantly gay so so so I think that that's connected here in other words when you say Risha Shaun is ahead of the Year in other words Ataka has within it and it could of the whole year right here what does it have in it there is a son of that combination is what of Nissen in other words that this is the rush of Nissen which is month one we should all become a co-chair son it doesn't define the whole summer it's it's a vert in the Yemen the melee here is gonna be month two Savannah's gonna be month three but that's gonna be a heart than the hardest man on the shona so toy super says that it's a cannot be duke that you don't pick about speak only about Charlotte also speak about other things but it's not like this by side dish the Oracle in air here makes a heart and he says that it's far it's very severe because if so why does the governor say the shun and come maybe because I'm like Hermione don't say but Shawn and Kamini that because awesome Locker mighty don't say bhushanam come ID arkla mayor says a very interesting cop he says let's remember what's at Rosh Hashana livery column what chakras your shop what makes it pay secretion a little column so the Gemara says that add a strip shimmer because the others this whole that pay stuff is not research on alert at all Lewis could also be the first jumped of circus good whatever you want call the first jump to this family gala halakha yabbies peso has the month of mrs. old the first don't but let my enough Goodman's whole circus the first jumped right here it's McGee that Nissen is the first month with Josephus when they go mow when when the bus it says you should blow so from the seventh month it means Titian it doesn't mean - well that doesn't mean ll it's important to know that the man of commitment that basically the first month first holiday so the Gemara says it's only in the gaining of Shipman because if Simeon halts that bout - after is kiss syndrome it has to be in the order of patience okay so basic is the first if sluice is the first it's not gonna work Baltar has to be pay some true so cuz I actually of Shipman said that sometimes you have to wait 5 mm tie them for about the after why they have to wait 507 because if you want Marcus the baby before schmooze Jeff Lewis so kiss basic suckers they said a bus a Egyptian man son of the golem is for sure here sometimes it's more than a year sometimes it's more than a year you weights Lewis you wait suckas you go till next Pesach yeah let's see you might do some a Milan boy him and so let me have a full year plus you have another school almost Lukas see scissors a shuttle little golem is the acquaintance of shipment that's what the Gemara said it's dose of shipment if so it's a year and it's more than a year Ms if it happens to be you a marketer's before pesos it's not gonna be it's gonna be only pay sexual circus but if you're Marcus after pacer or your mark - after slowest right before suckers so you have circus yeah you have circus you're gonna pay such rules you got a full year plus you wakeful suckers this is it's gonna be a Shana so the mayor doesn't work for some time that's what he's mayor and the tacticals only like the pre-shipment the gomorrah says it only works according to the shipment this is deception something about a white Vallejo Borden was proudly important sir Ashley said before the Budhan is that bez Dhin sits from rich tradition isn't to contemplate if the next year needs to be a leap year you have to add an audible something to get moderately booted me missin monena really you start counting when it comes to a leap year you start counting the first day of Nissen at the beginning of the year meaning then on the first day of missin best thing could say okay it's a new year let's decide if we need 12 months or 13 months other they can do this or this part of last year we don't discuss the next year now listen we're gonna start thinking about the leap here in other words it's erection Charlotte it's a new year it's a whole new year thread the Gemara before we analyze why our missional doesn't bring it first we have to analyze shock waha Tania there's a clear Isis that contradicts this in my Abilene ahsanul if Nader Shoshanna bez Dhin does not decide to make a leap year before issue Shana why not remember today it's hard to understand with our communication system what would be the difficulty but communication was extremely extremely difficult they were afraid that if they announced - NASA uber let's say in the month of year the month of sieve in the month of Thomas rumor goes out by the time the next year comes out the month of other people ignore it or forget it they forget that it's a Schnauzer a bore and therefore they celebrate Nissen right after other really nice it is supposed to be a month later and they're basically eating comments on pace of their eating comments on pace a pace of Shamy which is arif a successive of year they're eating comments because by them it's ear really it's missing because it was an extraordinary nice close to the month so therefore they didn't do it before Hashanah via me bruja and if they did it before there's an animal beerus it doesn't have her logic validity it's not considered on ebay on ebay our album with NASCAR but in a case where you have a stressful situation what's the stressful situation for example they're living in an environment with the Gentile government does not allow bez dn't to convene close to the month of other or another situation is the Nazi the leader of the Sun had knew had to be there during the vote he had to be summoned to the king for a long time and therefore they wouldn't be able to convene before other my a Brandeis after a Shoshanna me ad so then you still don't do it before in Sharma but you could do it immediately after a Shoshanna and notify the Euler the Nazi of the Sanhedrin did not see is the Nazi of the Sanhedrin the Chimera is referring it to a story this is a grammarian Sanhedrin that you cannot do eBrush shana without the agreement of the Nazi even though the nos is only one vote right it's only one vote in a vote of 71 but nonetheless you must have the Nazi on board and there's a story about Roma Gamliel remem Leo was the Nazi of the Sun headed for many years and he had to go to Syria where the local government was and he was delayed there and they had to do eBrush Anna and they did it with a condition that when he comes back he's going to agree and if not there's no eBrush on so generally you need to not see there and if you don't know what his opinion is is maybe a me could create a burn so therefore Bashar subtract if he has to leave he summoned and you don't know when he's coming back because he was responsible for the Jewish people and he didn't know what mishegoss or what win the governor the Emperor had so therefore you could do it earlier you can do it before that's ridiculous so here we're talking about the Nazi of the Sun in Israel because that's when you do eBrush shana yeah the Alpha PK nonetheless ain't my a Brunel or other even though you can sometimes do it after a Shoshanna the month that you add is always other you never add kislev Cashman Tavis you always add only the month of other you make to others and you do not add another month even though would be nice because if you're announcing it right by Tishrei so just do it right away so people don't forget no it's always the month of other what do we learn from here we learn from here one fact and that is on the first day of Nissen they were not sitting down to contemplate the leap year they were not usually they were supposed to do it later in the winter at most you do it right after it Hashanah which is six months before but you don't do it in this sauna let's see - so crash he put him in this Inman in and bit Tamiya that he - I invest and they should rely in but socially but it should have been listen we have a halakha aim I've been a mining bit circuit Cibolo ideal the gurgler she blew benzene as a shot you did not be my eye in and you're not don't notify the exile that best admittedly appearance package had over that other above we're afraid they're gonna forget album apnea Cox I'm a faculty shall digs it inoculation beds it dark times are coming and they're afraid that what the whole institution may be dissolved or you should turn I'm not see the Hudson arm Ella in a Brunel and Knutson us again I'm a person identified olive so then you can do it right after the Shoshana but alpha became a Manilla are there a my sniffing Freddie savasana Ella are there why why not kiss love so crash it exists summer a Swedish Shabbos you have to protect the month of spring which we know is the month of Nissen my dish has summer loveth a bear she Yahweh of abysmal so rash explains beautifully why they chose the month of other basically the primary reason to make a leap here why would anybody make a leap year why do we need an extra month in the Jewish calendar the answer for that is and we have to remember this you side throughout my secretary Shoshanna the answer briefly is as follows because we have a problem in our system the Roman calendar which is the secular calendar doesn't have this problem the Muslim calendar doesn't have this problem the Roman calendar the secular calendar today which we use also in America is what's called a solar calendar it follows the cycle of the Sun take the Muslim calendar is a lunar I'm just giving an example is a lunar calendar it follows the cycle of the moon as long as you're following one cycle you're consistent as long as you're consistent your system works the lunar and the solar orbits are very different why they different the solar orbit as we learned to previously in the Gemara finishes after 365 and a half days that's a scientific astronomical fact that is when the year ends the question is when to begin to hear when to end the year okay that you have to decide but the year always ends after 365 and a half days because that's when the orbit is completed what looks like the orbit of the Sun around the Earth or the earth around the Sun however you wanted to find it but that orbit finishes after 316 five and a half days so you make oh yeah because um - hey no problem now you want to divide it into 12 months divided into twelve months that's what I'm Eric that's what our calendar does you take those 365 and a half days you divided into twelve months the lunar calendar is very different the orbit of the moon finishes after 29 and a half days it's a much shorter orbit than the solar orbit now take 29 and a half days and multiply it by 12 and you'll have a year you'll make six months 29 days 6 months 30 days for this 29 and a half days and you'll end up with 354 days in other words you're 11 days short from the solar orbit Newton is careless so now you're counting a solar year I'm counting the lunar year my year ends 11 days before Yuri next year my year ends 22 days before you the next year 33 days the next year 44 days and the next year 55 days and so on no fine that's what the Muslims though their year finishes differently however the seasons summer winter spring fall that doesn't depend on the moon that depends on the Sun if we would follow that and we have to follow that because the puss success and boy are clay they're shallow camera shutters mission on the stomach obsession and what typhoid - I said the month is based on what the Sun doesn't give you a month the Sun gives you a year that Vanessa says a la cama ha - and cloud the Ain the lil Ivana Shama claw the moon got no year and the Sun got no month these are artificial institutions just for us to be able to order time better so we have to count the months of the moon it's a clear Mitzvah the tailor and as Ashley says a fetish as LFM reduction you should all assemble such a son is not repetitive it's saying two separate things how high this is referring to what the new moon hey ray you a sham showed moisture judicial Ivana and he said when you see this new moon it's a rush reduction we can't ignore the moon in Judaism although our months are based on the moon on the other hand it says summer sky this love it that's why it says summer what he after rocket bodyguards what is this a hello mom aye sir with they're looking for Kadesh Levon and there's no moon so they they keep a bodyguard there and he has a barrel of water and when he sees the moon being reflected in the water and covers the lid of water so he could protect the moon and then tomorrow you opens it up to do kiddush levana and he wonders who stole the moon what was some what were you what do you how do you guard hide the shovel what do you do what do you guard the chapter is you guard because when you're counting your years according to we counting your month according to the moon you're not gonna have pesos inside the shop why one year pay set the stock you're gonna come out and try to shove it but remember every year your pay stuff is falling behind and behind them behind the behind so at some point pace is gonna be in the winter it's not gonna be Fred each other so what do you do for this so once every 2 or 3 years the best did was responsible to give the moon an extra 30 days so it could catch up why three years because in three years the discrepancies 33 days so that's why every three years but on the other hand you can't only do it once in three years always because remember it's 33 days and a month is 29 or 30 days he's still gonna be falling behind that's why it's once in three years but sometimes it's once in two years and then the moon is actually gonna get ahead of the of them and gonna get ahead of the Sun because of once in two years it's only 22 days discrepancy and he gave it 30 days so it's now eight days ahead of this and that's how we equalize our calendar so that she says which month should you add you have to add the month of other why cuz summer is slowly the shot of it you have to protect this month of of it how do you protect it you technician is coming pay stuff is coming and it's not spring yet it's still winter it's the end of winter practically speaking the grain is not right Pesach is coming there's no right gray why it's the winter I it's pace us basic is the moon not the Sun so summer is slightly sure of it make sure that this whole dish is another how by adding another month so which one's the ad you had the month of other that's why you have to add that month that's what a she's saying it right this has some lovin oh babe that's how you protect the finish our office the frighteners that summer clothing I made sure y'all they are with bizminer in kiss live you don't do it yet you do it in the month of then your estoy dish is a farce then it's a fake you we have a physical responders based on the war 'but it has to be visible because i have to be visible you're right because the system that it was when they when we have a calendar the de system that was put in places that witnesses have to come and testify that they saw the moon yes so you see the moon it can't be mama SH in that position of the miler that has to be a little off so that people should be able to see right but it's still it's still based around the facts you're gonna start adding days it's not a month anymore thomas's it's our own user time we're looking for the real thing we're looking for the fight Assad Assad you gone absurd you gone right right now Raschi doesn't explain okay summer is try to solve of AD the month before why not three months before why can I be summer as hide yourself of three months before look are you that part of the shot is that is partial to the Indian image seus what do I mean in any intimate Sears let's say they would decide that kiss love should have two months or Tishrei initially let's say Cashman should have two months what can happen sometimes the the grain can surprise you sometimes it could it can get ripe a little faster and then they find out that you really didn't need an ABR they may make they may have made a mistake in a few days however when you do the Ebro right before Nissen so then it's much cash market because you really could see what's happening it's very very close to this and and you see you know it's half gas are there or how hay out there and five days is a rich tradition it's and it's not gonna be hard to solve it so therefore it's a much more logical system of when to add add your month oh so now we're gonna see in a moment you're right you're right but generally the month of other also toys vs. and resistance and Hedren says something else very interesting play some sex and Hayden says that if they would add another month you would have a problem because the Megillah says Magilla says to like we learned before that hum on through his lots McCoy - licorice name are so low finish add or in other other has to be the twelfth month if you're gonna make an ABR and the other month it means that other is not the 12th month other this is thirteenth month so therefore toys for Steiners that's why you have to make the Ebro yar in order so that way name Arthur is always further out of that year ah right right dress was right global warming's because that's the main other again the next year history what happened layaway so this is what happened to us okay that's what he's saying if we would make let's say a leap here in the month of Kislev right now there's the 13 since it says like this all the months have their name in Tanaka remains this is 3 this is 6 this is 9 this is 10 and other could still remain credits they must still say there's other there's one more void that says in Matilda and that is since it's a summer as hi - ah if you should watch try to shut up so what do we do we add another month in order to make sure that it's ready to show us so we're my Abra that Shana went myself a high dish sister Mathilda says it's similar to Ibrahim is just like where my Abra the high dish were all set over the years he says it follows the same system when do you add the extra day to the month to the beginning of the month in the middle of the month at the end of the month and that you have to do why you're not gonna add 26 make 2 days of 26 wine making two days of 26 instead of 29 you have 30 because you need 1/2 30 because the orbits finishes after 29 a half days so the yearly the leap year is compared to the - the Cardinal / - when you add a day in the third day just like the hydrogen to the last day so that month it's the last month you add another month that's another DUI - the mistletoe the - Ray Evan brings it here in the name of the Mustaine is the political but when and if you were added in the beginning and you come down to the month and you counted one one so sinusoid but lapel one is your first day destroyed each day 30 that's it not that's the last day of the month something am i right I'm gonna have masking by itself so we have a problem what do you mean which tradition is originally but it's not a Hashanah labeling what happens in our tradition is sir there's decide later just to add that's to say stamp just for information Ebru shana they used to make also other fish - for example sometimes it was a very rainy season right and the roads were unpaved there was no way Jews are gonna make material I am and this interface so would create a tremendous problem yeah sometimes these types of situations they would also add as a smock for ibrahim to add another month only to be able to as a smock as a support it could be didn't mess up whatever that was that was just another set another smash at what point but we're gonna discuss know exactly what's the date that you just saw pump it up Malcolm I you suck my abuddin it wouldn't meet something else very interestingly exact opposite the effort venison is not Richard certainly Borden that now is the beginning of the year let's decide if we're making a leap year because you wait for that my abuddin have soccer supportive it's a Russian sauna for an end not for a beginning what's not for a sucker said wouldn't judge then you cannot start anything that's negative or it's off suckers it wouldn't it stops the Hebrew yard meaning till when could you make them EBR till the end of her dish other till the end of her this other best and could say you know we want a second other the moment your childishness and comes in the Russian Hashanah lead bullet it's a new year you can decide ultra Scottish listen let's make this which I dish under Shaney oh it's baseness and let's make this base other shame having a judicial high dish right because basically missin came in so what do you want to make a leap year what sayst a leap year the year is over there's some believe burden the year is over what is it over for I've sucker supported now it's a new year for the next year ebook it's a new year that the last emperor is done finished new year is OB you want to leap here wait another year you'll make a leap here this is a new year sorry after Benison came it's a real thing it's Olympia this is the kaya you say listen after my fila show you'd be not there my feelings in not them I feel them with Italian right so Adam Adam Adam hey lemare there's so much et toi semantic noise similar Adam so Optima foolish a game after - was it in the courage of bested the moment they decide it's related even though it was a complete mistake for example astronomically or the atheists maybe fooled them or whatever happened or even if they will miss admitting doesn't mean they were too shy and then it's not a best deny Russia's none of them it's not cultural of ESDA some missed it means they decided what make us right it's the wrong day because they decided it's the right thing because they avoid a crisis Hashem says the mission assassination our story is a fascinating story will see later duck off hey it's an unbelievable story the reassure had an argument with me I'm Leo when Yom Kippur is and if issue astronomically seemed correct and I'm Gamliel told him that on Yom Kippur his Yom Kippur which according wasn't him Kippur you should carry and it should bring his money and a stick huh and if the insurer was was horribly depressed he had to violate him Kippur and he met Rebecca van never came explained to him that since I'm gonna lose the Nazi of the Sun hadron so that Tucker becomes rue straightish to say that's Yom Kippur and Jim Kipp is not when you decided astronomically it's in Kippur that's in cubical to test three times are you some by the holidays elemér there's some particular ice up I'll take your ice son there's no no II couldn't see could say at them after my food will show you again after my film is ended at them I feel are no similar more timeless to Grace's it's always you you decide the holidays it's not just the astronomical facts you decided yes they tried to collect you know the calendar had to be made much later the calendar was made this mhmm Lille is a Nazi huh well you could study it this calendar was a work of genius hello it's not the older are you grab hello the calendar was created in the in the 5th century in the 400s the same time the Talmud Bavli was basically sealed the same time that the Sun had been dissolved and they realized that you can't be right right now that so many by talking about before the first amigos right sadly gone held for karat he held that the Eco were the calculations right the calendar was establishing what the Jews always knew and Beza used to calculate they just put that's the system why he saw there's not gonna be a Sanhedrin so basically we're not gonna have restored this anymore because ten head has to make a credit so we don't have even try them so Judaism will fall apart so what did he do he made a calendar for thousands of years and he was makka dish every year side dish for history he had a son hadron make every restraint ish till today holy ah six thousand years what yeah yeah oh you mean they went through everyone I don't know they Makati every single so that's why we have argument eyes my not a fake yum and toy them just just to be able to eat blintzes and keep up the culture I don't take them are how lucky come on time forward till till be a summer Shia when when did the system will go back to the way it was no calendar yeah you need the Sun headed annex assaulted oh yeah because he was the son had yeah well there's a fault become little can't decide on Locker and the realize yeah of course of course if the majority goes against him is I'm Lily losses yeah huh iris tradition so was a very nice voice from I think the the leader cognition the car since a market one of them said that the Gomorrah says it says are you some three times so awesome you could read at them yeah so after means you it's you under all circumstances no difference I feel the missus enough for the Shogun's read they said mother when it says I saw you read a term and then you see say act them under all circumstances when it says autumn Bonham at them wash them allocate them how come I foolish ugh again after my fila mazeed not to my fellow on no cinema it it's very hard to understand that mazeed means real decision because then it's not a best dinner the kymaro says in son had been cashier assure you made them in a million when he was a kid yeah yeah dr. Hamada have sucker see Buddha have sucker Cebu didn't look Rashi Chiquito Chiquito was a Scottish wish a missin post kershaw inertia of emily is mulberries Oh Shane Raksha endlessness another shake when is mr. Shawna had a sling anymore so new year you can't turn Nissen into other so what is it Richard Shawna trying to means cut off time the end not a beginning it's an end sometimes mr. under means a new year so there's I mean through the end of the last year I don't mean it's a new year for eboard it's not a million for a bore I knew you people you have to wait it's the end of last year saga did you murder the tanaan we learnt an omission in the sixth ad is about to be sure and if papayas Jemez II do they testified shall I burn a sonic all other that is best and so after put it you still have to make a leap here a whole other you could make a leap year show you a million people used to say that you can only do a leap here either put it till Porter but once the 14th of other arrives cut off time so to be sure enough papayas testified it's not true you could make an ABR till the end of other even Kafkaesque other Huff tests other you could say the next month is not missing the next month is other other Shanee now what does this mean this means till we're Tilton a day 29 or day 30 so generally it's interesting in Sanhedrin we learn that the day 30 they also shouldn't make into a leap here why because day 30 of other is really has the potential to be echoed venison and already the first definition you shouldn't do a neighbor however but the of it if you take lamb and other and you if you take lime and other you decide on lime and other than tomorrow is recite this other say me but the evidence fine okay did the evidence fine and if a does come and they say they saw the LaVon after they already made an uber yard not a problem Yuma cottage the side dish that day is not they thirty right that day becomes Alif and it becomes Alif other Shamy so imagine I'm day thirty order in the morning business that we need and we need a leap here okay so what is this this is thirty other so tomorrow we're gonna be rich Riteish other Shanee suddenly witnesses common all over the day right so actively they figure out this is restraint ish this is no problem this becomes theirs heard each other's Shanee so but the evidence going to work what happens if the aid has come before a br so mailer they made young slice in rich so just Nissen ready then they decide to make an AVR it's not gonna work I'm not gonna work Lyman are the record but the Evans destroyers Nissen Rosh Hashana Leawood an account could be a difference in one hour literally if the atheist came before they've escaped after ready to come out of my time and demand demand either put it what's the reason to make it to say to put him what's the vert what's the understand why you don't do it on one listen the reason you can do an ex-husband isn't actually said clearly you can't turn this them into other restrictors missing is really missing you can't do Nissen and other why can't you turn this in and other because the added month has to be other not listen once it's nice and it's listen got it but why can't you do it after put it what's trapped and for the Gemara are very interesting smaller Kievan dama meyerson's we have a Bryce soil umbilicus up a cicada map s exhalation yo the Jewish people have to start inquiring and learning and asking about how losses of Pesach 30 days before pay saw so that is of course put in because you doll admit an important is cynicism is air of pacer and that's when the opticals comets and beer comments aussolas zoomable comments what's happen is already poured in all the teachers all the Russia's Chivas all the darshan and mother upon them are explaining to everybody Hills as a pace so they're telling them they're telling all the women all the children all the men the 30 days start pacing now suddenly a week later Besant decide that we're adding a second order what's gonna happen our citizens ulla become ins they're gonna send out Slocum to all the communities and they're gonna say that boy sigh there's another month of other in other words pastéis is in two months not in one month they're gonna maybe they're gonna be Muslim comets versus isn't gonna be Muslim comets wasn't me they're gonna be missile and comets so the pastor's I would say it means they're gonna a lot of people think it's it's if Pesach is a flexible my son a moment ago I heard that in a month if I eat comets I'm gonna get chorus suddenly I learned now you have two months okay Newsom next year round they have three months I'm not in the mood I'm not in the mood I still have a comets party to God I still have too much Marsh in my cabinet they gotta finish it us loses all liberal comments that's one way Rashi tire now she however gives ups alumnist as she says us loses Oliver comets sacrament I put in veil of history whether shuttle dish without milk as a pacer who's cuckoo are showing them last the space endless a flaw with you being a verb as dynastar suddenly is sky blue devilish lucy best in the Scheinman let's assess a peso now she learns differently this is airless eden they save over one second my rabbi told me in a month is pay so you're telling me that my rabbi hacked and shine it I'm not gonna accept it huh they're not gonna accept it check why some women out there shaman they heard it ready from the door Charlotte today wouldn't be a shot nobody listens to any their son but then it's a big shot they're gonna listen they're gonna take it seriously now that that shaman meant well of course they weren't lying but they didn't know what's the but they don't of navarre but Benson is gonna do it's gonna create chaos so mailer they timed it after poor them you don't do it cuz after put him already people are getting ready for basis psychologically it's gonna be make a problem though I so why did it be assuring if papayas say you could do it after put it the answer is they hold that this is a very remote problem cuz made the idea the crowd knows the harsh - after my bar - beluche bond Italian Mills people are not as illiterate as you think they know that a leap here is not coming because somebody is in a mood to add another month a leap here is always tolerant Hegeman meaning because one Italian Melissa was trouble cause one Italian mosa summer and winter depends on the seasons of the Sun and when you have a situation that pay stuff is gonna be before spring arrives you have to go into your calculations and figure it out if you need a leap the sovereignty they say who's Shobana who the lace all accrual it up on another Eden when there's looking my best and come and say there's a leap year they're gonna say why didn't they tell us two months ago because till now the rabbi's didn't have a chance to make the fish bonus until now and therefore that it will not create chaos they'll understand that it's not an essential paradox and they won't have cognitive dissonance ready to go Mario Vuitton added on so why does our mission and not mention its reshawna baths have been this city or some of the Milano really Buddhist something a martyr box called the kamati buff sucker like almighty say Mahalo Irish Hashanah is the head of the year that includes the whole year what's gonna happen this year we're looking for beginnings we're not looking for ends this is an issue Shauna that's not starting nothing starts on s administer Fibonacci Sun you have to wait till after this asana we said better to wake late what is in addition under for cut off time the X of Benison I can't add anemia but I saw the commodity bicycle a commodity not looking at Rosh Hashana that the gadget of this your son is only Nagaya five soccer that it stops we're looking for their Shoshanna that something new begins then that left this begins as anniversary this is the first jump tooth this is the beginning of my summer as you're suddenly alone this was your son only Schmidt to Nishimura labels whatever their issues on this therefore those now she says Bob sucker Lake Almighty pedo Shoshanna now sucker Laurie car mighty this class is brought to you by the achieve Annette please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot they ueshiba net / donate