How could Avraham cook Bosor Bechalav for the Malachim? Shiur by Rabbi Nachum Scheiner

Even though the shir tonight is based on nevertheless as we're learning of many come out from this discussion which is the Gomorrah says in Shabas the Gomorra Shabas for when up to get to the so said it was always up here the you want to take the down why should why should people get the they came to take the Torah and the garra says that the issue of why the are not have no to getting the Torah is because it says did you come out of resting on Shabas you work during the week that you have to rest on Shabas. So that was the and got the the medish. This is a medish on the medish goes on after the were broken and by went up for the second time the story happened again. The malim again said that why you giving it and the malim actually came with a t not you're giving the toal look they were it says and so how you giving them thera so the med says how you giving thera to just yesterday they were on the when this week's par says in the par this week's the what are you saying about that they were also got the just going to finish up the medish because it's going to be neg Ga throughout what we're going to discuss the measure says even a little child when he comes home from his and his mother wants to feed him of meat and cheese and the kid says but they told me in today and you have to in other words to eat. We'll see the next give them the what's in the is that the ate boss of we have to try to figure out how they got the boss of that the ate the boss of is not not we don't we're not we don't we're not worried about it the sh is how did the malim get the boss of how was the boss We learned we spoke about it last year. That's the basics in the to eat milk and meat together is only if it was cooked together. If it was not cooked together, there's no issu. So let's understand the malim got of. So if it was cooked already, we understand that they were either the iser eating b of but how did they get cooked bos of what are you going to tell me cooked it didn't cook it because it says in the garbu the whole so obviously didn't cook the boss of so if he didn't cook it so we was the is that they were on eating boss of they could have ate it together only if it was cooked together and if it wasn't cooked they weren't and who cooked it didn't cook it that's the shil and we'll see many we'll see but the shila is how did prepare this meal of how did he prepare it and cook it together one terret is brought in the stipel parrots. The stifler says that the malim actually cooked it. Also the dazum over here says how did the malim eat it? The malim ate it by burning it. They burnt it in their mouth. The goyan says over that these that people see are the same that eat from the which is also which means that they burning the food in their mouth. So the were also they did the and besides cooking it not only did they cook it they ate it. They did bishop of rebel asked before that it's not so clear that it should be bish because regular bishial is bish maybe it should go into the sh we discussed last time about but that's the first that the were the ones who actually accomplished that it should be bish of and therefore they ate it that's what the maj says that they over eating of in their mouths. They cooked it and they ate it. They bring inki son that they asked them the question. Why does the say that they were already bish of even if you don't eat it and these is to eat even if you don't cook. So why does the say that you will eating of they were also on cooking of >> it? They cooked it through eating. You mean really when it says eating it also says >> it says you're saying you ate of means and you also cooked it also. both >> he's the set at he brings says he learns it up and he says also it's a medish that the is we spoke about this last time also he says that the of is really to eat these are that you have has to be bish and even the is Bish is only because brings the bish also but the of what's the of the is eating not cooking the cooking itself is 100% the is but if they cook the and they eat they ate it if we're going to the med saying what they were they were on eating just to point out we said last time from The says the opposite. The says that the reason is because I mixing bad things come out says the I wise dear. So he says wanted to go so far to be from the mixing that even to eating because we're afraid if we're going to let you eat he might come to mix. But the is the mixing. He was saying the opposite the of is not the mixing. the eating. So that's the first terret to answer when the when the medish says that Abrainu served them and they ate bos of au didn't make any boss of but when they ate it they cooked it and ate bos of another terret another terret he says is that they weren't the he says that they weren't it's here in the simmon I'm sorry it's that you're supposed to wash your hands at least some cases to be between eating milk and fleshik you're supposed to wash your hands between meat you wash your hands and they didn't wash their hands the question is that if it's only is what was the big tina they What was the on that? It's But that's that was a But the truth is so then it's really not that you ate you really the answers he doesn't answer this on the sniper obviously but says here in he says that the the med says that the they were on eating bos they were by eating bos of that's what they were over on eating bos of these He's a Gomorrah. The Gomorrah says the garra says. So what's so which would seem of he asks the steer from the medish to what the garra says that got which means so asks why did they get the did they get thera because the why did we get the tray did we get the tray because on the bus of or because they were over So says in they're both true they were on but they were on bus of so like one saw in the stipul that the was the of that they weren't they didn't wash their hands in between the [snorts] himself actually says a different terret to answer this question what was the that they were also but he says the like we'll see also over there that you besides rinsing your mouth you're also supposed to eat something in between milk and meat if actually brings is pass and then the brings what you're supposed to rinse your mouth besides rinse in water is a da with pass or any other item as well. So the says He knew me when the ma they prepared pass but it says that was so they didn't bring any pass right that's the prepar but never brought out the pass so the so the second and third is that when the when the medish says that that they wen't of just to point out on these two roots that they were says that the office were not They were not. The same thing is also the godless says on this that it says that says what's the definition of and things that we will something that will But mitzvah raon is they weren't mim. So then the shil would be on this second and third that if they were mim if if the if the were mitzvah which is because it wasn't a gay only later when they saw you have to make of so they made earlier on there was no mock to bear so if they were the on you can't have the also So what do we have so far? So far we have one terret is that was of that they ate it was bish and they themselves cooked it. The second and third terret is that it was only boss of the bos of was either they didn't wash the hands or they weren't they didn't rinse their mouth eating bread in between the milk and the meat. The next terret, the fourth terret is mour and the mesh over here says that this benbak that a rau served was a ben pakua. What's a ben pakua? Ben pakua is uh when she the mother and the baby's inside and then it comes out. The ben pakua the is that the of the mother helps for the baby also. You don't have to make a on the baby. That's a dinner of Ben Pakua in Siml in the beginning of the D is no of Abraai. That's the dinner of Ben Pua. And says the by Pua is that the milk from a bent pua doesn't have a D of milk. He shows that based off the is by us over here by me. If you take out milk from a dead animal or for the same price [clears throat] out of sh the taz explains which is really the gor if you an animal and you take out the milk that milk doesn't have a to so why not why does why is there no on milk from because the says means that it has to be it has to to be a mother. And once it's once it's me, it's not says the since it has a din since it has a you know doesn't have a >> Oh, we'll get to that in a minute. Very good. Very good. We'll get to that. You're asking it's Roy. We'll discuss in a minute. Let's first see the terrors and we'll go into it. So that's a little bit we want to discuss also >> marion is a good for itself. Yeah. >> Yeah. Is is a good um good point what you're pointing out. Let's leave it on the side. We'll get to we'll get to the sh of in a minute. So let's first see the terrorists since the since the the milk doesn't have a dinner of milk. The meat seemingly does have a dinner of meatas. The milk doesn't have a d of milk of a benu cooked it. He prepared cooked it in that milk. But since that milk doesn't have a den of milk. So there's no bus of there's no bus of was not a problem. That's how Ara was able to prepare it. >> Oh, so that's really the Shila. It's a good sh You're asking very good. You're asking good. What was the What was the T on the Malim now? What was the T on the Malim that they ate of? They didn't eat of That's a very good question. >> That's one that you could say yo very good that they didn't know. One second. Let's before the one second. Let's talk about the issue of how there's no so that that's why says very good says clearly that the says clearly that they were of eating it's not so there's a few different either are notable wants to say that they didn't know so the gammorra says Rashi brings it over there. It's cool. It means but that's cool that it's I don't know if that's availing. Well, the is That was the is that he told him only thought another terret is that the din ben that has a din is only for someone who has a for and the malim didn't have a din yet so they didn't have the of benu That's also maybe a another question just a second a second another which is learned up when he speaks about this with he learns up like this but that the tina wasn't it's I don't know how it goes into the medish it says that they ate boss of the tina was that of you see when you let you were by a raino and he cooked the meat in the milk. How did he do it? The terror is because Benu is already a so like the is they already they already have the another but it's still the says that you boss of what would you say you have what's the eight boss of people >> wait what do you mean not therefore what >> using the heather of ban pakua No, that's that. No, that's fine. But they can't have a to keep the shay because they can't use the of >> No, they wanted thera up there. They don't have the din of Benua is not from the mitzvah. It's a den that has a shak that only has >> it's not a different toy. It's dim not the mitzvah. You're saying the mal also should have had it la to to get into this discussion a little bit about this milk. Let's just move into if it's right here. Does this milk have a den milk or not? So from the mesh that a milk of a banakua doesn't have milk it won't cause already pointed out that what was the what was it what we saw from the of and the of the of and the of um and and messa so over there the den is that it's potter I'm sorry not potter doesn't have it doesn't have a bas of the reason why it doesn't have a din of is because it has to be royal le. So those are not roy the benu is roy is misopic is and he lives by if does it have or not he's what's it that it should not have because since a pua has a so it has a shame in comes out that it doesn't have a he brings a from brings a from the doesn't have a what's his ask how do we know that is why is it not a problem of meaning to say is while the behem is alive it's a so just like is a problem why should how is the milk mut how are we allowed to drink milk from a behemoth tyrant It's a so the garra says maybe I have a bos we need a to say cooking them together is a seemingly each one separate is mut that's that's the gammor says wait a minute what's the from that obviously regular is I'll tell You regular I where do you need the to say you need it in a certain case of Ben that the milk over there it's because over there there's no in such a case you need the to say over there that is why didn't say that you see that from Benua doesn't have couldn't bring this as a as a as a on the to bring the argues holds that of of a benu is considered and if you cook milk from a ben together with meat is says it has so this fourth of the is not so clear the says that it didn't have was able to cook it it's not possible learns that this milk is is yes considered there would be there would be a problem of cooking it That was the mus of the just to sum up this back and forth in the says means so the the a lot of the bring and the safer is D if you take a lookam they say me the Gmorra says why why did they change the because the terret says it's nothing to do with the issa means that it's not royale which would mean it could be from today till tomorrow if it's from a rashi rashi says rashi says because It's not because it's not which really comes out. He's really being like his father-in-law brings some seems to learn that the is the problem is the but the doesn't really mean the is a way of saying which really means it's nothing to do with. So the really is we're learning now the says so when does it mean really is a way of saying that it has to be one final and the last ter is a ter that's brought in the he brings the malam he's and it's the malam right here and they say that ainu made the of the ben And you made it with you created it with the say in the says he made he created he made how did he make it? He made it with so he made he made it. It was a par. It wasn't milk. It's not they say and it was oh and when you make something they say it doesn't have dairy doesn't have a meat there's no b of if you're looking at me that says what do we what's the handle so there's a famous that speaks about what happens if you make a person with dominion and the mission bron brings it so we're going to speak this is the discussion of if you use to create it and it's Not here again is your question that it's not. So why would the he asks what does it mean of a person >> for them? It's a person. So that's the that's the fifth that there was no wasn't over anything by cooking it because it wasn't boss or it wasn't it was par there was no bishop. So just to to sum up over here wait the mash of the shil the crazy others ask that the gammorra speaks we spoke before that how do you know is so the sh is why don't we bring from the is so they ask the answer I'll be this because this is a different is no so just to be we have five roots how the bus of should have been for appear at the bishop boss of one we said is that he didn't cook it the malim cooked it while they ate it they burnt it the two second two and three were that they were the next we saw was the the was so and we saw and the final terret is that he made it with and that's he was able to prepare