Hilchos Shabbos - Challenging Bishul Questions - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

[Music] roof mi blemish a meeting shirt I like to welcome everyone to today's year from air vehicles that's miss Lita a topic of challenging visual questions I would like to have the great suspension here called ears and sherry tire seven one eight eight five one eight six five one you know that you're never bored there's always new questions new Silas recently someone asked he enjoys very much the instant hot soups that today are very popular is there any way to prepare an instant hot soup on Chavez in other words taking soup there was no instant and hot water use a clean slate it's a nice lishi there's any problem with that then we had a really interesting style of someone cooked eggs before Shabbos to make the egg salad on Shabbos and they cracked the first egg and they realized that the eggs were not hard well they were soft-boiled you can't make excel it from soft-boiled eggs it anyway on job is to make it from soft boil to hard-boiled and the third question which comes up quite often they the woman of the house prepared a super foods whatever it may be and forgot to put in spices now they're not going to serve to guess and tell them put your own salt I forgot to put it salt pepper they're very embarrassed it anyway to add salt or pepper or spices to a pot and then serve it after you added spices to a hot pot of soup or child or the like so for this we have to learn a Mishnah which will is really packed with information that's mogera to this and probably 20 plus modulus the Mishna says in Shaba staff members are alphas vaca Dara chef Viren Marat Safin you have a part that's on the fire you took it off the fire and now it's a Cleary showing a part of food that's off the fire the heat and the soy fun Kaplan you now that I add spices the assumption is uncooked spices to a hot pot of soup or hot pot of food this is mama shower question why is this so and our minds Vishal is when you have a fire you have a pot on the fire you have an oven but here the fire though the food is off the fire you took it off the fire so now she says precious words the Clery shine calls Mansour Isaiah neva so as long as the the pot is hot it has the ability to cook even if there's no fire and you have to realize when you cook a hot soup for example so none of the suit gets hot but the pot gets hot the pot is sitting on the on the fire for hours so the soup gets hot and the pot is hot so even though you took the part of the fire both the soup and the pot are still hot and that is the allocation you a test see if test a Cleary shine even if there's no fire it's fully capable of cooking meteor ice ax this could be Nagaya a person has there sometimes you have to shop this morning the mixer is very hot and the heat is already you want to throw in some cold water into a hot mikvah what's wrong there's no heating element now but a mikvah believe it or not is the clear Isha so here we have the following halakha Clery shine is always capable of cooking of course if it's still hot to give you a good example so we could relate to it a person had unexpected guests Friday night so my grandmother taught me if you have guests like tear Bissell Vasa put a little bit of water into the soup and you're okay to take cold water and add it to a pot of hot soup even if it's not on the fire is this Mishnah and pastas is it there I see - it's uncooked spices will soon see that today spices are basically uncooked to end uncooked spices to a hot pot of soup or cholent is mama SH our Mishnah that's the mission that you can add spices to a hot pot of soup but our case could be different for example you'll take the hot pot of soup and pour the hot soup into a serving bowl can I then add spices can I then add cold water to increase my volume of soup so this is the next words of the miss them I will nice to know the psychic aura now she says take the soup pour it into a serving bowl and then you're allowed to add spices or water into the serving bowl ah the soup is still very hot so Rashi says keywords the cliche me ænima vasa in other words the original part the Clery strain is capable of cooking once the food was transferred to a cliche knee a serving bowl or a soup bowl then you're allowed to add food because it does not get cooked now this we discuss the number of years ago steak 348 their heads but why a cliche knee can get cooked basically because the cliche knee walls are cold so the food cools off but basically we see from the Mishnah to bigger sizes Cleary shine always cooks even if it's off the fire and cliche knee is incapable of cooking this concept of cliche knee being in unable to cook is also a good Miranda Mohammed days the Chimera says regarding chemin you'll add an add oil to a cliche knee why sup the Gemara be Farish mommy now cliche knee ænima vassal that's the matsyas cliche knee cannot cook there's a third Meredith ma'am ma'am Bay's explaining a Mishnah that you louder add water cold water to a hot cliche knee to a serving bowl because again cliche me a navy vessel the fourth chimera will soon see regarding viscera the Torah axe meat it can never get cooked in a so here we have au side over and over which is kept askin and shelf Inara cliche me isn't capable of cooking know I've as I we have a great idea you could make instant soup if you forgot to make T cents before Shabbos you could put the tea bag into a cliche cliche in the enema vastrel what's the problem the problem is is another mission which is really the slum of this sugah the mission of cook mem hey discusses pouring hot water from a cliche knee not clear Eason hot water from a cliche knee so basically yo a cliche knee pour from a cliche knee cannot cook except Kurtzman Amelia hyoshin and a salty food the salty fish salty meat or the coleus or a spaniel now this is a type of a fish either it's a guy saw two touches either it's a Mac a Spanish mackerel or a cop but basically fish cooks much easier than meat I mean this is a maxius that we see meat you have to cook for a long time fish minimal cooking and today we see even though we took it to a new level today we take raw fish we gave it a hey Monsieur named sushi a masked eat how to eat raw fish because fished by nature is very tender very soft and it needs very little cooking so the Commission is saying that fish cooks much easier than other foods and even eerily cliche knee even pouring from a cliche knee is capable of cooking fish now to make a very long story short the sight of this sugar is Bissell is very subjective some foods like we said water oil spices are what called chyme ray huh Bissell it's hard to cook and therefore it cooks in a Cleary shine but in a cliche they cannot cook then there's a category called Bissell cow means easy it's easy to cook salty fish fish MacLeod since it is so sensitive to heat it could even cook in a cliche knee and the Mishna says because putting eerie cliche knee Zoey gumar melaka that's the finishing touches and the truth is you'll see you'll take a cliche knee a cup of hot water and pour it on to fish it will warm it it will boil it enough that you could eat it so here we have a new concept till now we learn cliche in the ænima vaso that's true but if you have a colleague abyssal that cooks easier that can even cook in a cliche knee there's another example I should mention that flama chest it's come out in the forest but the cousinís spells it out in noon bays you attest eggs Akali abyssal you could take water and a cliche even a cliche and put it in the egg and keep on changing the water you will be able to cook the egg because again egg is a very sensitive food and it cooks even in a cliche sheet are you wondering but we just said cliche knees that move on so that's this busting it's not my vassal a typical food but Kalia Bishop could cook even in a cliche sheet and I think we'll you see this most dramatically in that men basement Bay's the Chimera discusses soft salt as we know is not a typical food the salt is a mineral and the Chimera has two opinions regarding salt one sheet the halls salt is even better than tablet tablet is a Cali official salt is so much I'm sorry bohemianism salt is so much memory abyssal that even the Clery shine it cat doesn't get cooked salt only cooks on a fire but on a clear vision of the fire salt cannot get cooked it is so much a high my official that even the clear doesn't get cooked but there's another schita another Maria this is pudding for carrot salt is a regular Kalia Bissell that even gets cooked in a Christian you how do you understand the math Lycus of course it's a scientific explanation if salt could get cooked but the point that I think we have to understand is Hill tha's Vishal is very subjective something that cooks easy could get cooked in a cliche knee and even a cliche she I we had a few gamora's that cliche me any move on so that's why Maria Bissell and what does Crimea Bissell we know is water oil and spices now the last question and then we'll get to La Jolla miser is you know you gave us two categories high memory have this hope that doesn't get cook easy is water oil spices Polly official we had fish a salty food eggs what about everything else what does that mean what's the local for all other foods in between so here we could make the following assumption if you will tell me there's a cost of across the board cliche knee doesn't cook so then fine Kachina doesn't cook but since you told me that this colleague abyssal that gets cooked even a cliche knee so now if you have a food and you don't know what the status is and if it's a collie ambition then it's Clarence and this @erisa that's Clark we're gonna Rama says that mr. Brewer says it kaalia Bissell is regular Bissell their eyes so even in a cliche new even cliche she perhaps so if you're gonna tell me some food is softly collie official you should treat all foods like a Suffolk alia Bishop if you know for certain that it's it's Crimea Bishop for example water oil spices so you're safe but any food is a Suffolk and that indeed is the schita of the uranium I'm at the cook Lima dialed one of them literally restrain he's one of the Ballia tasteless he has this Schuyler and he says if you don't know the property of that particular food we have to treat it like a Suffolk Bissell and even cliche sleaze she say yachts to leathers my could cook and then he gives a very interesting example a common case to add a bag food to a hot soup for example you have a hot bowl of soup you want to add croutons matzo pala sup Tyrion the mice of pudding holla into a soup Karla's very soft and it's probably a collie abyssal how could you put a big food into soup ah what do you mean what he worried about the collar was baked already croutons were baked they're ready but maybe we'll be sliced this yes so after I feel cooking was one affect and I baking was one affect and now you're cooking it but I'm putting it into a soup bowl which is a cliche me and maybe even a cliche she maybe was from the original pot into a serving bowl into my bowl the cliche she but that's his finish since Lamesa it's suspect to be a collie official it could even cook in a cliche me and this is quoted by the monogram seed company first mr. Brewers if Cartman bezu Fache Oakland twice for Fay mmm Dalit and this is excepted halacha this hi Maria Bissell and let's consider over this foods that never get cooked in a cliche knee perfectly motomete dinner Mishnah water oil spices this Kalia Bishop that was certain is Kali official we saw a fish salty very salty meat or fish eggs is a Kalia Bishop and other foods will treat as a Suffolk ollie official and the uranium is maximum so now that we have the situs let's continue and discuss many many different shiners let's start with the question we began with someone has unexpected guests he needs extra soup you can cook on Shabbos what do you do very simple take the soup pot take pour the soup into a serving bowl and then add cold water consent a high the soup ends up tasting delicious that you can't even tell you you cook cold water on Shabbos that's true but water is definitely primary abyssal so if you put the water into the soup pot that's amalaki there Ison clear Eastern is my vassal even off the ice if you know that how long so you put it into a serving bowl and you have nothing to worry about me then hug Amara water is not Kalia Bishop someone asks me is actually his grandchildren enjoy putting ice cubes into very hot soup I asked them why they do that so the answer the one-word answer that explains many strange activities of our children is sticky like it's sticky to put ice cubes in the soup so Lamesa it's sticky and perfectly mutter why because ice cubes is no more than boredom and what is harmony abyssal so why can't you cook water in a cliche knee ah you'll say but l'm I see you're changing the texture from ice into water that's no ulid so the answer is my lid crushing is awesome no lid is only us up if it's you make a new Anthony here the ice cube dissolves into the soup and it's no longer noticeable so it's not even knowledge so again it's taka mutative put ice cubes into a hot soup next thing I'll give you an eighth to tie for my ID that will help avoid a lot of admin and fish very often we are given the job we have to Charles Grant job they want to prepare a baby bottle and you're gonna have to pull water from the urn into the baby bottle and there's a problem because the baby bottle was rinsed to clean it and now in the baby bottle there are there's water that was never cooked water from the sink so you're given the job drive the baby bottle well and then call me I'll make the bottle if you ever try it's very hard to draw a baby bottle you can't fit into the bottle you have to stop pushing in a towel and moving it around it's very difficult I'll give you an 8 so that will save a lot of time and Memphis all you have to do is don't drive the baby bottle keep with all the water get a regular cup any cup foam cup glass cup pour the water into it okay and then you could make the bottle by pouring that water into the wet baby bottle I give out this water that was never cooked but cliche nee ain't above this is already Eirik leash ain't even better but whenever you're given a job dried the serving bowl dry this drive that you could either be devoted and dry it or you could do just this kosher just as air low take the water put it in a cleat Shanee and then cliche nee ænima vassal someone prepared tea sense TS foods before Shabbos but typically they put it on to the bleph to keep it warm the problem is this shabu shabu they forgot to put it on to the bluff and now the tea essence is called problem this is a double life that cooled off yes Vishal official how do you make tea on Shabbos I'm this called tea sense the answers don't worry don't put the tea essence into the urn into the Chinese put the water into a cup and then you could add cold Pease and schizont 8aa you see the water gets nice and hot but the tea essence is nothing more than water water is climbing abyssal waters not clinically shame I the tea part of it the tea part of it was already cooked imbecilic abyssal now this would be matsutake tea and this mr. Murray says difficult Lambert Ashton you test to add cold tea cents to a cup of hot water is perfectly month now many Eden our oysters for the Cumbre of Afghanistan ever have Uranus and Venus and Isis that is a problem Bissell of adding tea essence into water so therefore you put the essence in a second cup and you pour the hot water onto that that's a home run but me it could did then there is no Bissell whatsoever why because water can never get cooked in ecclesia any that gemara and that's macabre Johanna the next question is making a hot drink on Chavez for some reason there's a lot of confusion people seem to be convinced the color Meribah the more cups you use arrays amasova if there are cups and people are pouring back and forth let's simplify this once and for all it's really very simple you have to know the matheus you should know in all of our locker but specially in elseís Chavez especially because the food industry is constantly changing so before you know how local you have to know the master has a niche set a Miss Tyus in Macias is worse than a Tyson allahö so we have to know them at CES of coffee and tea and sugar and salt and milk etcetera etcetera but let's go one at a time instant coffee that we use on Chavez is basically coffee beans that was roasted then you take the beans and you're making it to coffee ground you grind it and then you cook the coffee grind the coffee beans after you finish cooking the coffee you have some somewhat of a coffee soup I don't wanna insult the coffee lovers so let's call it a liquid extract but that's a job you cooked coffee in water so you have like a soup of the extract of the coffee now there are two methods how to prepare that either the old method was spray dry it got out to water today tasteless choice uses a freeze-dried method but really there's no difference far as we're concerned coffee was fully cooked then the water was extracted I bizarre it should come out you'll ladder put the coffee into one cup and pour hot water from the urn or from the crock pot from from the from the samovar right into the coffee hi what do you mean but but you're cooking but coffee was cooked and this allaha bishop so meets a debacle all you need to make a cup of coffee is one single cup you put the coffee in pour the water on top and you even Yotes there ever be anything as far as the problem of sphere because you're not putting the dying agent into the water so why does the veldt use two cups this is for an interesting problem Dava your vase a dry food a Miculek abyssal but a double laughs a liquid we passed in at least Ashkenazim there are Marcy - yes miss Alaska Bissell how do you classify coffee or tea powder instant coffee or tea it looks to me like a salad but then again no one eats the powder plane it's put into water and being it that it's soluble it not only mixes but it turns into a liquid like the rest of the water the way the use coffee and instant coffee and tea is put it in water and it becomes a liquid again it's soluble that it loses identity oh boy says the master seconds you've caught my man our liver to keep egg in the end the racial and gimel says this and mr. Brewer BIOS and see if cotton alley and Aleph quotes them maybe we have to treat something power we like this like a dove a lot now he didn't have instant coffee he was talking about sugar or salt will soon see but any powdery substance is treat like a double life so now if you pour water onto the coffee powder or tea powder thy mighty Bissell I was already cooked but yes mr. box official bird of Allah so how do you avoid that problem very simple you put the coffee or tea into a second cup you take one cup fill it up with water and now you pour from cup number one into cup number two this is already a weekly shady and that you don't have to be cautious so basically the lover if you see someone making coffee and one cup don't don't give him Scylla he's it could be an elephant not a problem you want to be quite sure that's visited it of Allah all you need is two cups the same is true as far as adding sugar sugar today is always cooked they take the sugar cane they cook it and then it becomes like a slurry type of substance then they remove the water and you're left with sugar granules of sugar so the flavor ain't visual official but it's the same problem that sugar is soluble it's used when it's when it put into a hot drink and it becomes a liquid we treat it like a liquid and therefore the meaning is to use two cups and then you find artificial sweetener that's interesting saccharine which used to be more popular was made in a way that it wasn't ever cooked it was dried so there was a lot of turmoil about saccharin that's not cooked today's sweetener the Splenda sweet'n low is a different deposited a different system like explain it but it's it's probably fascinating how they do it chemically but it's not good but it is cooked the ingredients are cooked but it's not really much of an Africa Meena today we make hot drinks in two cups so even if it's never cooked like saccharine but the mice and a cliche she'd have to be worried about vishal call instant cocoa people say I heard it's it's worse it is worse in a certain sense because instant cocoa the cocoa of it was definitely cooked but there are other ingredients added that was never cooked just like coffee was fully cooked but flavored coffee another flavors made hazelnut flavored the flavoring was never cooked so that's why for another reason it's always safe to make a hot drink using two cups because even if it's not cooked you could be assumed that you have no problem of Bissel now why people use more than two cups is beyond me you know sometimes yeah grandmother si and it can make me a cup of tea bye Tommy finishes making a tea but this cup and that can pause it back and forth you could freeze from the cup of tea you know you take away the whole piece mark of a years are in exam is one cup is enough two cups divert Isum more than that the flyer up to my nose is no reason now once we're talking about cups I wanted to make a point you come to shul sometimes yeah we have to boksoon milk is very liquid that's a different problem the you come to show let's say after the shower morning coffee Russia alum you see dozens of cups lying around like in a battlefield you know cups that were the Viet that you throw out a place I'll tell you something I think there's a hundred percent Emmis without an exception you could have a thousand people drinking coffee and if they know it if they're using their cup with a K all you have to have at the end of a thousand people enjoying a cup of coffee is one extra cup not a thousand and explained very simple the first person takes a clean cup fills it up with water he can make coffee in that but he's from okay we like from the people fine he pours it into a second cup this coffee drinks and of course he's a man she throws it in the garbage now you have a cup that has water in it and let's assume in the worst scenario the water got freezing cold yeah special exhibition so you're not just leave it to be thrown into garbage but the next person comes along takes a clean cup okay and puts the coffee into this cup and it pause from cup number one into this cup any child at all I it's Vishal I just water that's called but water and it's already clear Stacy this cup is ticklish Lisi water does not get cooked even a cliche and is a cliche I see now it's not use it's not infected it's not hooked sir it's not germs playing water so he uses cup and throws it out now you have this cup that's get invited to cold water okay let the next person take a clean cup put water in it and pour it into the cup with the cold water and have one cup so if you think about it you have one cup after the other all you have to have left over is one single solitary cup now of course we discussed in the previous share styrofoam cups since they retain the heat doesn't temperature doesn't drop drastically some amount it's not a cliche me but most place can feel that since Lamesa the we hold the Styrofoam cup is not packed like a pot hot pot it is treated like a cliche me but the point is you know to be Malcolm is one thing but stamp to be groping in darkness there's no reason we know what we're doing and we so what we have to do the next group of questions is adding spices whether it's pepper garlic onion salt to hot food so the Huayra this should be very simple because spices is a mission the mission that began with the mission mmm bass you let your now that a a traveling to a Cleary shine even off the fire but once you took it off the fire now look Clara you should those I'm sorry table n-- as you know is isn't it Cal is not its harmony official does not get cooked so the Huayra to add it to a cleaver hot path clear Eason is awesome that's the Mishnah but once you put into a cliche me it's perfectly motor re buzzer what's the problem now the truth is I want to mention the Macias ground pepper was never cooked pepper comes in peppercorns they grind it and they put it into a Visayas pepper it was never cooked onion and garlic and others instead of the powdered onion and garlic was also not cooked it was dehydrated which is probably not it's not at most it's it's a figure but it's not vishal but who cares the Mishna says that tafflin you allowed to add to a cliche they didn't cook their pepper in those days so what's the shylu so the hurry Mickey didn't meet dinner I'm Mishnah the housewife to forgot to put in pepper into a soup take the soup off the fire put the soup from the pot into a serving bowl and add kazan date explained to Salman and schmira Shabbos and well as all the new Prince and Oliver are a cook I undoubted he said that it's miss phaedra that our pepper today that ground into fine little pieces is already kali official since it's so small scalia bishop so therefore you can edit to a cliche now this of course the price game after prime is almond or wonder out loud what does that mean do me tell me that the times of the mission that they ate peppercorn they put it into the soup I mean the gomorian daily discusses grinding onion t'v and it talks about grinding pepper why should we assume they ate peppercorn so if the mission that permits putting table into our into a cliche knee it's talking about even ground pepper is very small but who said that that decides that has all new what's crime area business was Kylie ambition Serbs time is almost summaries of summer Psalm is a home run but I could say the poison that I consulted all were very surprised and the Mishnah that permitted table is even ground pepper so the luffing you could add ground pepper even to a cliche knee of course TV snapper to cliche knee because it's a crime a habitual now l'm icer a person wants to be master I'm also Malcolm stammers Albert Avila Bravo but in the case that I began with it involves a bin of Mahavira a quite Ishtar she the wife does not want to serve the soup but you have to put it there you know tell people put it into cliche she and then add the pepper that's better be Maha Marin Vinod Mahavira and rely on most cheapest that pepper today is no different than traveling of the Mishnah and you could not add it to their original soup odds we could add it to a soup a serving bowl and then serve it and then you solve the problem salt adding salt to a hot pot to a a serving bowl salt is a little different because salt is a Gemara pepper ism it is a Mishnah salt is a chimera and we saw the Gemara that some hold that salt is very much primary official even a Cleary shine show agama ashes mortem oh this safer carrot it's a county official how do we pass kit so the muhabba Inuit receive tests pass things like mostly shining that salt is an extreme chimera be so it does not get cooked even in a clear reason according to that schita you can add salt to the hot pot of soup and there's no problem there are more says yes I see a very mild endorsement the yeas are m2f salt even into a Shanee because it's my carrot Akali abyssal and then he called dices vimar tomato by Allah Bravo now obviously he's not past getting that it's awesome he's saying yes I stream and he quote spices together brother if you don't add salt to a cliche in Christian now so a miser our case want to add salt to a hot pot of soup the the right answer would be for smart emit smoke ilaha illa fast can a is emitted in its motor but there must as marketable Oh Braco I saw the moon cat rabbit in the MOOC Eric I am and I was sick and I was swimming he says his father used to say Allah mice you could add salt to a clear eternal cliche knee but I'm just remote izing a little bit imagine if there are more would come to town and it's giving brothels for the next hour in our base Majid here they'll probably be aligned till 36 Street getting a bra from Grandma so his father said for a little bit salt you give up a broth of the Rama I'll give you a breath but don't put salt in the top of our Bravo and we have to add it's not just a brush of the Ranma it's the brach of Tice's yeah probably a poisonous and Rabab so that's why people are refrained for putting salt into a cremation and perhaps even a cliche and even a cliche me why because we have a brother of the ROM Oh aunt Isis that the fight that salt is very much Kalia Bishop but the same mr. Brewer that quote that discusses this he says but could be our salts are better why now this is a big understand amid see it's because today things are changing very quickly there always was three ways of producing salt the easiest way is you assault that mind you find big deposits of salt and you crush it and that's rock salt which generally is not clean enough to be consumed that's use database that they sprinkle on ice but that salt that was not touched it's fair its groove its mind and its crust then there's sea salt salt that comes from the sea now there are two ways of producing salt from sea from the water in the sea there is one way you cook the water you get big amounts of water and you cook it so the water is evaporated and you're left with salt no that's Bissell but there's another way solar evaporation now it's interesting in the warmer countries to throw for example and California the Caribbean that are big producers of salt they don't have to cook it well you have to cook it they take a lot of water they put it in the Sun there's no rain there it's real for weeks you can assume that the salt will remain the water will get cooked not cooked the evaporated by the Sun so it's all about you know the bottom line is money why do you have to cook it if you could do without money because nothing so that's why it's been said and correctly so soil that was produced merits his role was never cooked it was left in the Sun that's not that's not levels of abyssal temperature but that's made in the American other countries that you can't rely on having Sun without rain for long times then the salt was cooked so therefore even if salt is Kaali abyssal but then against salt is cooked I hope you have to be fascia that maybe tag of a line but at least be aside salt was already cooked now here's the catch in recent times they studied analyzes system and again you I I did a lot of research it's interesting how the companies are focused on eliminating cost that's the that's the bottom line they figured out a system that you could basically get rid of the salt without using intense levels of heat I'm sorry the water without to get without using very strong Bissell they cook it at a low level the lower than Yahtzee lettuce and then they heat that mixture in an oven to around 10 minutes at a temperature of 200 degrees so all the ballet Alaka that know the Macias will tell you that it's not considered cooked because it was cooked and a level lower than yasuo now we come to a new phenomenon maybe so believe it or not is considered a fear but he put it into soap yes Mishawaka fear so Rebelle caesar handle bra had a very engine explorer and he said that really salt is no Bissell that stuff the macabre says even their muscles making it in it's just there I must obey all of raka so tavola Brock is salt that was never cook salt that was baked it's only a home run the age Alaska fear maybe then there are must Humber doesn't apply which is ok that that's what he wanted I saw another interesting store there's a real I found that really my mother self you could add salt our high salt because if the old salt is a type of a high memory abyssal that doesn't get cooked at all you could add it to a clear vision even today even those never cook what do you find she saw this Kali abyssal know if salt by property is Kali abyssal then the ten minutes in the oven was enough to cook it it gets cooked easy goods ten minutes and twenty degrees is it's pretty hot I will say yes Vishal Agra fear that shy when the Bissell is a different effect than they are fear you put mats into soup so mats baking is one effect and and soup is a different effect but salt doesn't change baking cooking so it's really you're talking to say that our salt especially if you're not sure what time it is you could even add it to a Cleary shine that's off the fight now that's really pushing it but definitely to add salt to a cliche knee there is it sad to be Mako either whether it's cooked or whether it's a fear or whether your lawyer I'm the macabre me I get it in okay if you want to get the grandmas Brava you want to beat Isis broke up lamai so to add salt to our soup bowl in front of us is almost always a clear solution because either you put the soup into a serving bowl or minimally you ladle it out with a ladle and some say a ladles already cliche knee it's very rare you pour from the part in to a soup bowl so as i'vei've we could say this clearly she to add salt you would even get the rama's Brava enjoy the salt and enjoy the broth a fascinating contemporary question that maybe ten years ago was not in the gaya and I have a picture in front of me I could sell tea afterwards there is the Mateus today you know people used to make shabbos today many people buy Shabbes you go to a take out and you buy ready-made food so it's very common diva buy for Shabbos they may buy raise ready-made chicken or or Luxan whatever it may be and they they but they know they're doing how a Bali I welcome you want to have hot chicken job this day is not such a problem you take the fully cooked chicken put it on top of a Chow and Pat and very often the chicken is piping at ah you are warming a cold chicken on Shabbos no problem because it's a missile artificial and it's not mastic Universal so that part is without concern you take a cold chicken that's fully cooked put it on top of a pot or you put it on the side of a bless that's now you know off the blessed but let's see next to the bath the kitchen you could warm fully cooked chicken from coal to piping hot without a shine but here's the catch takeout food I'm gonna take out food owner but the Macias is they add spices that were never cooked after the preparation of the food I have four pictures in front of me it's a color picture you could see it sometimes they add raw sesame seeds or parsley flakes or raw black pepper I'm two fully cooked food whether it's chicken or Luxan whatever it may be so here we have a new scenario pack them beside the chicken or the lobster that was fully cooked no problem but the spices that I just mentioned are getting cooked Italian is a Mishnah that Kalia Vishal I'm sorry that chimera Vishal that's if it was cliche me but are you putting on Gabby Hayes moms come on you're putting it on to the source of heat and that's why I saw the bottom of Lake there's nothing to a lake with per se but the political area that when you when you rewarm on Shabbos food that was fully cooked to make sure there are no components no spices that were never cooked before Shabbos again you could put pepper into a cliche knee that's the Mishnah but you can't cook pepper on Chavez and putting it on top of the cella pot if it gets piping hot you're cooking it that's almost like a agape Orange so that's the point to consider another case which is similar people today it became more of a minute be a minute quote-unquote but the people started putting Arbus into soup cooked our basanta so I see this and this is HD minute but the question is to put Arbus into a hot soup off the fire you took the soup off the fire you want to put artisan Macari there's no problem our bus is fully cooked imbecilic abyssal but you have our bus that were commercially made or even homemade you don't cook it with the spices you first cook the Ivar's then you add the spices so if you have black pepper for example that was never cooked so here you're putting spice that was never cooked into a clear reason for that even with Arabs lime is almost Homer this is putting in to clear each leg so that you have to be worried about so if you have an accretion II then we have the pastas that'll be multiple embers almonds you side with us it would be a problem talking so from schleimann see Scott Mohammed as he points this out as well let's eat our soy death is a problem with pepper even a cliche knee Donaire spices to a cliche now again if you wanna add your harvest to a cliche sheet to your cover your part of your bowl of soup that's easier but a cliche knee is an issue adding a slice of lemon into a hot tea mahira a slice of lemon was never cooked what stands out heta so some suggest maybe a lemon is considered a table so a table does not get cooked in a cliche knee so then when you put the water into your cup if your first cup but it's a cliche knee don't forget this is a cliche knee you could add a lemon however the case our show can cook off dial your dial it says that's not true because only the tablet has now discussed we are certain as a tablet they didn't have lemons we discussed a few months ago shy to speak about a lemon but they didn't have lemons McMorris who said it's a table rough moisture inhaler dalitai adult incontinence has some insomnia shabbos have a more fundamental problem a lemon is not a spice a lemon is a fruit many people you know use lemons other ways but it's not a start of spice the whole concept is incorrect Sol mi Sol to put lemon into a cup of tea is a problem but if you used two cups so now your cup of tea is ready a cliche we could assume that that might be Mota because even though it is not a tablet but as well soon see there are things that we unless something is gamar be Shula clearly she would be ahead adding matzah croutons etc into a hot soup is mannish our uranium and therefore should not be done but dominica item is to add matzah and color and croutons i the area masses and older acronym quotas lavaca so the answer is our bowl of soup when you're adding your cooked item is already a cliche and therefore the ram agrees that's okay the Ramos Malcolm ear by earring matter to a cliche me and therefore if you have a bowl of soup that came from a serving bowl is very crucially see the mr. Bruin see if cotton mem hey says even if you took a ladle and from the pot into your bowl you could be sorry enough that the ladle is a cliche and even though it's not so positive regarding this child and then you could add matzo or croutons to your bowl of soup you could assume it's a cliche she now interesting these to be a very popular manic today it's lesson that's what people take a mozillian is K cookie and they dip it into the hot drink you have to realize that dipping a Messiaen is into a cliche knee into a hot cup of water for example which is a cliche knee according to the rain is the same problem there's notes nano exams the cost of matzah or Putin's cake and cookies is also the same yes Bissell AHA fear so if you wanted Africa dip mazzani's into your hot drink you'll have to use two cups so the second cup that's all confusing but the second cup is already in I love to akley sleazy and there's no problem what's surprising is someone prepared luxan before Shabbos and they want ability make it happen they want to add the Luxan into the hot pot of soup can you add fully cook locks it into a Cleary shine that was taken off the value and believe it or not the answer is it's perfectly motor because Luxan as opposed to matzo and croutons was cooked it's a w of H in Bismark abyssal so to add a cooked food to a Cleary turn off the fire is mutter it's not a question of Caracalla Hartley this is a mission a commission but very often when you cook Luxan F the collection you rinse the election and that'll option has cold water that was never cooked so that of course gets cooked in a cliche it's only in a clean it could get cooked if I'm sorry nucleation but in a cliche D that's fine now adding to a hot drink milk or lemon juice or honey is basically one sugar because the truth is that it always was that a person milked cows and they used it you squeeze lemon you have lemon juice today commercial milk lemon juice honey is pasteurized now pasteurization is supposed to be at a temperature of 160 degrees which is really enough to be considered Bissell the problem is in recent time they start they perfected a system to pasteurize something at a much lower temperature simply to save money save energy but let's assume that they pasteurized at 160 lacoya you lie to edit because any bish ilaha Bissell the problem is that milk lemon juice and honey is a double blast and yes Basilica bishop but here we come to America finish two out of the three prominent primary habitual that we know Medina Gomorrah our water and oil did you notice the common denominator that both liquids the rav shuffle knife seems to assume since your days that water and oil are examples of hi Maria Bissell but the route busting is my inves salmon who are then the SH I'm askin the rod makes a sweeping kritis and he says that any liquid is Jaime abyssal or a bizarre we're back to the Michelin you could add even uncooked milk and uncooked lemon juice hey mister lemon juice into a cliche nickname because it's a very official does not get cooked in a cliche me now the Sukumar's lost it and seafood gimel mood talita in the attentional mayhem or a charm ask him into a cliche it seems like the wrath however we don't find in any other place to him that mentioned other masks we find oil water and its life and its rush to jerusalem evolved he talks about milk and he says he's top of course but look that was not pasteurized but he says there are some things that get cooked even a cliche if it ain't a'no became the suffix killer who so he says the Farish adding milk to a cliche knee is a suffix Keela obviously he assumed only water and chapman the mr. Brewer discusses adding milk to a hot drink and he says it's multi because milk was already pasteurized imbecilic officials so the indication is the mister also holds that there's no cross the board had that regarding liquid then I saw a beautiful tumor that sums up the whole cig in the case of a for a path of up and Kayla get most mmm he says Dominica Asti says always was the gelada ad even uncooked milk because if it's cow it's harming abyssal then I found something that never LT nice and evil I see my earth I got frightened I found this night to be Hoda the flag on the drums just that adding uncooked milk is considered this new hires gala as I showed my son this and he says relax and my son showed me the Rav circular that liquid is not Kalia Kalia Bissell so here you see the difficulty of this Schuyler to add uncooked lemon juice milk honey according to the Rob who sea otter is mutton according to the sloth the McCoys of the mr. Brewer is a higher skillet so I'm not going through my fear but I know what I would do if I have a Suffolk like this we try to make it and at least we can clearly see then you could assume that a cliche she isn't capable of cooking honey is again commercial hunting is cooked if you have it Hamish you made honey is never cooked you have the same shiro someone's forgot to make in tea before chávez tea sense or a will talk about the instant soup so here we come to a delightful part of the soviet la jolla if you want to be from you'll put the tea in a cliche sea well the instant soup you're making a cliche you see and you can't go wrong because clearly she's not Mufasa but here we come back to our original Mishnah the Mishna says that there are certain things that that's the chimera melaka cool yeah so spanien that's so sensitive that cooks even in early cliche me that's the Mishnah and and the gomorrah says such foods that are so sensitive that this hiya practice if you cook it even an eerie cliche knee and the prima garden and as other pipes came up quick to point out it's eerie cliche nia salsa then cliche she is also awesome so what do we see certain foods that that's the Gemara mo lova and you need minimal heat to prepare it from non usable to usable even in a cliche she is a problem a good example is I mentioned earlier an egg because a nish and I mentioned earlier and the schmear Shabbos an owl of course aa test says an egg being it's so sensitive to heat it's shy official even in a cliche she you put in hot water please finish it then you change the water otherwise it won't cook but we keep on changing the water you could cook an egg in a cliche she and official because this is the command mole of an egg what to me was intriguing imagine snowing met with a child we began with someone cooked eggs and he didn't do a good job it's soft-boiled eggs can he put it in a coup increase Smee she wanted to make it hard boiled I saw a very thorough toover in the mcdonoughs le oh hey the gimbal I'm Italian beautiful - about eggs is it laughing your vision but the end of day he says that a soft egg and a hard egg is two different worlds not like just improved not like you're getting him a gloom walk-up and he's concerned that cookie from softer hardly be Bishop this mere Shabbos and that tickle has a Suffolk but if summer forgot to cook the eggs fully or you forgot to cook it but well there might be an ASA put the eggs into a hot Sun that's grab the muhabba you can't go wrong soon your trusty demo you ladder cook eggs in the son Thomas mutton is the practical I don't know but at least it's Tim's now the next question to make a tea you forgot to make the tea essence can you put tea into a hot clichy of course if the waters cold there's no silent governor hot Clichy Solem ice the Macias is you see that tea gets cooked in a cliche she the truth is many people on a regular day make tea and a cliche me Chaves we don't make tea but even a regular day you put the water into the cup and then you add a teabag and this what probably why be efficient and see if your crest says that t w do I said be sullen cow a Nana Royce chambers Bastion Berkeley shady over cliche she in other words their construction is saying emphatically that a tea bag is a cut is not just Collier Bissell but that's become our Milan so that's the way you cook the cookie bag and he feels to put a tea bag into a cliche she is probably a melaka there I see the hill cassavas the Shabbos and professor or a 79 quotes are by Yaakov and their official and the schmear Shabbos and O'Laughlin Zion also says this that a teabag is a form of Collier Bissell the Gemara my lava that cooks even a cliche she moisture has his kiddush gaelic dollar endowed contest vote that he says nothing to get cooked in a Khaleesi I view our four silken says T because you see it gets cooked okay right it's not true because we take a tea bag and put it in cold water and also after a while it gets usable that's what a malicious citizen now I am at a kind of sore especially not about tea but people that know tea have told me that a tea that's made in cold water tastes differently than a tea those made in hot water so of course it's prepared then it has the same color so again if you ask what to do you know you see that the different sheet is but if they're Ashokan and many pay scheme try that it's Vishal their ice so you have to be careful the mr. Bruin chief cotton lama test discusses making tea he does not mention at all using a cliche sheet so certainly his feeling seems to be that it's a problem so probably the eight says you put the tea bag in cold water and then you could add that tea essence that you made on job is to hot water in a cliche nee that's easier because the water is vital water that doesn't get cooked in a cliche me the t-shirt boy whatever it is is not getting proud hopefully he's not getting more cooked instant soup and I'm going to thank represent the from their cupcakes giving me the clarification and this and others foods as well instant soup has three parts to it the vegetables that were never cook they were dehydrated the Luxan depending on each particular brand but some of the Luxan work was never cooked the Luxan is dried prepared in a way that when you pour water onto it you can make it edible some luck should is deep-fried that's true some was never cooked the spices are like spices some of it are soup that was dehydrated so it was originally soup so it was cooked some are spiced that will never cook pepper example so to make a instant soup even in a cliche she involves potentially amalaki the rice on the vegetables for sure if the vets if the lobster was never cooked its bitch'll on the Luxan also the instant soup used the hakama that's called Kalia Bishop and they made a system that you could prepare soup with men mohit so that's why to prepare an instant soup and a cliche she that might be the command Milazzo it's another example of our Mishnah that even a cliche she cooks it Roslin hey the crest time akimbo discusses cubes of instant soup which is easier because there's no luck sure there's no vegetable and even there is math we doesn't know exactly the Macias instant oatmeal to someone else we're making it on Shabbos so instant oatmeal the matheus is they slice it into thin slices and basically they toast it but it was never cooked you add the water you prepare it that's the Marvel game obvisouly that's just like instant soup the either gives the instant baby cereal was fully cooked and then they made it into a powder so that would be a question of a ambition a habitual if it reverts to a liquid which generally cereal doesn't so that's easier a scale of I'm gonna just mention this was really part of a different shape but we have to mention it for this sugar adding spices uncooked pepper or salt to a hot sharland hot cocoa someone asked that adding ketchup to a hot piece of meat a very interesting style today it thinks they're coming up new Silas people like to have hot pastrami Shabbos morning by a kid dish they keep an eye on how they keep it up your kid to keep it hot to take a piece to hot pastrami and put it on to a shower and the last Schuyler someone asked was he heard you now that I have coleslaw on the same plate with hot food what do I have against Coast Lee wanted to know I said I'm doing its coleslaw so let me explain this all in just in two minutes all of these cases Leclaire oh it's a cliche nee the pastrami is on a fire now you put it on to your auntie a piece of challah you want to add ketchup or garlic on too hot kugel you're not eating it on the farm and the in the back Ola you're putting it on your plate maybe it's a cliche knee maybe cliche she came from a serving bowl but if you know it is this is interesting till now we spoke about liquids as far as Bishop Hartzell hot water hot drinks cocoa now we have hot meat hot potatoes have cooled of a goose the other girls are going to many Gedaliah pie scam remains a clear yishun even if it was transferred the whole series of cliche nice we see is you pour soup into a cold bowl it cools off into another bowl it cools off but had fooled hot meat the hot solid food remains with the same eat and you see this because you have a soup that's lemony lukewarm but the carrot or the kinetic was much harder why first of all the cañedo love Sal was not affected by the walls and more so it retains the heat and the salad and in the center of it that's why the mr. Brewer says to pour pepper on cooked pepper on to a governor says mystery once you've gotten samba hey is a problem why we have to treat the hot love Google's meat or the Canadian as a clear eastern clear Eastern cooks pepper Todd was moulting a cliche not a clear reason taking meat hot meat and putting it onto a challah does it's out to be make up even though we should assume that it's yeah but then mice this is still the double cush maybe you could say and yes any bushel as I feel now we are slices for that but at least if you put the meat onto a serving bowl then onto your plate and then on th Allah at least you have what to be same upon that aim Basilica fear but basically to take our piece of meat onto a piece of challah is a problem the same problem like da now what's this coleslaw problem why what do we have against coleslaw so nothing with Kosovo but the coleslaw was never cooked in the coals for this vinegar or mayonnaise or both and both of them have parts vinegar commercial Vinick was never cooked vinegar has and and mayonnaise has positive that was never cooked and here says about Yashiro was an official or quote in the Mara Shabbos olive rage time of gimel that when a tuck meant when that coastal touches the hot cold or hot meet a challenge it's a dove a gosh that's cooking the non-cooked coleslaw however ups Lima Salman also via was quoted he said like Nikolay the gum gush and Iraq Suffolk below him is sobbing the gam cosmyk mikkel killed by cold Arif miss as the gametime blockers was that you're not like pepper onto a piece of Kobol you want to put the pepper on the cover here you want to eat the separate coasts floor and meat separate if I care if you're ruining it you don't like cook toast for subscribers Amin was making the other place FEMA mask Amir if someone is mask from a tougher love Brava if the kugel is already cooled off there's no problem but one thing we could say to put salt on to aid of a gush it was already cooked that's definitely motive because that we have the occurred in that ambitious aqua Bissell and that would be mother I couldn't talk to you [Music] require service miss today she and a few minutes of a Smith's will give a secret of today she five minutes [Music] what he fries which is deep fried deep fried yes yeah okay tomorrow you could kill it [Music] they're Malayan himalayan [Music] how is that possible clearly they know but I could have lunch is a straight thing how do you get into this shape it has the process before so it's a raw product but it's a raw product it's never ready the ready Supes talkative 86 shapes so there's it's cooked before it wasn't for a package that you already cooked so and what's your problem then what's and why's that is known about my job is this happening [Music] I seek him of today's Ivanova Smith let's take a few minutes just view we learnt about the Sam Cleary sign even off the fire is capable of cookie man attire it's a reg'lar Bissell there I saw something that was never cooked at edit or Clery shine even off the fire is the problem of Bissell that's the Mishnah cliche knee however the Mitch says is incapable of cooking the exception to that is as we explained the something called Kali official that cooks easily it's a more tender food and could in fact be cooked even a cliche knee the mister calls that the Kamara often but that's the way it's prepared that doesn't need that high level high grade temperature to cook even a cliche knees capable of cooking basically cold water is not at all Colley abyssal water oil and spices are definitely not Calais abyssal so to add cold water to a hot soup and a cliche knee into a certain in a serving bowl is fine to put ice cubes into a cliche knee certainly clearly she is okay if you want to avoid drawing a baby bottle of any Caylee put the water into a cup and then add it to the baby bottle that has water that was never cooked because there's no Bissell by water in a cliche knee you have cold Pease sense you could add it to a cliche knee to make coffee me it could have been if the coffee was fully cooked they would be ambitious official you could add hot water on to the coffee but there's a very good reason to be masculine to use two cups some states avea and the truth is some say today I just heard this he after this year that some coffee they add a little of Turkish coffee to the compound to the mixture so BAE - the in coffee you might have coffee that was never cooked which I was unaware before this year but that's something to think about so big it's a mini quiche Charles to use two cups so the second cup is already a cliche she but the extra cup you can have one cup as we explained for a thousand ok flying pH mister I'm could use one extra cup because basically the water in the cup even if it's fully it has cooled off entirely it is still ambition lock ability the points that water is climbing ambitions not get cooked in Accra Shanee coffee and tea or any powdery substance sugar salt etc even though even if it's fully cooked but there's a reason to say that's considered like a devil laughs because it's soluble and it becomes liquidy like the rest of the what it's put into and therefore there'll be a problem of a missile of the aged missile after Bishop eyes of Allah which is another reason to use a second cup when you're making a hot drink some coffees part of it will never cooked as we said flavored coffee or instant hot cocoa spices generally never cooked some spices were dehydrated pepper was never cooked but it's still the health of toplin that a cliche knee is motive so I'm a Salman said if it's ground it becomes a CLE a Cali official other place when I say shoes for that but definitely we could say that to put in a cliche she even uncooked spices would be multum adding salt has a Stickle of a reason to be more mock me even though Mia didn't salt is a very much higher abyssal but there are more Tyson says you get a Brock if you don't edit too cliche knee so people are marked with the editor McLeish leashing salt that was cooked there's another reason to be Mako and then Eric even to a cliche knee but again make sure that the salt that you have is cooked because now it's more and more that the salt is not cooked and maybe was dried but not cooked if you have a food at takeout food or any food that a person made and the other spices after it was cooked you can't warm that on Shabbos even there's no problem of kisara no prime official but there's a problem of cooking spices that was never cooked and that was not a cliche knee this is come out like a aah put Arbus into a hot soup if it's a cliche knee is mutter the problem is if there's pepper that was added then it's toppling the corner of Simon's Almanac Ashleigh she is needed but like most place game putting Arbus with uncooked pepper and a cliche knee is okay a slice of lemon should not be put into a hot cup of tea if it's a cliche she you could be Maiko that there's no Bissell by a cliche she even though we said by Gemara bishop even cliche she is us but lemon we are not certain is a chimera Bissell some do say it's a tough one so you could be signed by fleshly she is fine Knotts the croutons etc into a bowl of soup is generally mud to either it's a cliche knee or maybe even a cliche cheek because no one puts it into the actual soup bowl so we could assume that the ladle made it ready into a cliche sheet a cold lock shin into a clear Eason is fine if there's no water that was never cooked liquid that were pasteurized imbecilic official the problem is it cooled off so some say all liquid crust the board is karma official that does not get cooked in a cliche knee others arm a smear and the consider only oil and water to be firmer abyssal but the 80s cliche she is fine honey could be added to a cliche Sheila holidays instant soup or instant anything actually or teabag that's raw is a form of instant the fact that you put it into cliche knee or even cliche she could get cooked so if one should not make instant soup or a use a teabag perhaps even in a cliche she as we saw because that could eat that is the Gemara bitch'll of that particular item cooked eggs raw eggs to cooked eggs even softer hard many a masa that's also this extreme form of Cali official as we saw that ad of a gush is something that could cook so basically one should be careful not to add uncooked spices on to add of a gush but as we said if if the spices work okhla Marshall assaulted you know was cooked they will be attacked we make up the area to a diver gosh okay where's my Bianca how are you how's yourself