Hilchos Shabbos - Amira Leakum - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

Hotel and there's a door that opens a light he can't open the door can open a door to a closet to a to a bathroom could he have a guy open the door for him a person left clothing in the dryer very common Shila and the clothing is all dry ready-to-wear but you open the dryer door the light goes on a person what items for Shabbos left it in the car so to open the car door you put the light on so you probably realized I guess the crux of the issue today is a very simple but a very common question for me to open refrigerator door and put on the light is what's called up secretion I'm opening a frigerator door very innocent but you can't be you know in the dream world opening the fridge waited was putting on a light can I instruct a guy to innocently open the refrigerator but it will definitely put on the light in other words secretion by Y it has and I'll also as we know was also is there any hot tub secretion by your goal and I will see probably 20 other shyness about secretion regarding a gun and I guess part two is if there's no gullible same question refrigerator or a dryer is there any hat that they asked a very young child innocently open the dryer and pick out your clothing but he doesn't know but he'll find out sooner or later that he's putting on a light so one thing we all know secretion on Shabbos is a very serious issue this Gomorrah in eleven places you look on the inside of himself the Shabbos tube asuka all the eleven places sick raesha is also on Shabbos now to give one Marshall that we could relate to which is common we just had the UMP team of circus a person is eating his Shabbos or yom tov Sudha and he has to wash the tiller diary but Sam it's a theory bond and he's washing his hands from the chyme emits at their opponent for the Sudha but he's washing it over grass and the waters going there directly onto the grass so you might say he's doing the Mitzvah what should be a problem someone doesn't matter but that's what Sikh raesha comes in rebby aid you have to be realistic you're washing your hands is a wonderful Mitzvah but washing with water on grass is watering the grass so your action inevitably is watering grass and this is the Mahabad shin lime above sieve gimbal if you want you wash your hands outdoors even though you're now macabre to water the grass it's obscuration now this is a perfect example of situation because the person is doing something it's watering the grass but it is really arguing I don't wanna water the grass I want to just do them it's something else you're dying so we tell them very politely if you don't want to water the grass don't water the grass but you can't wash your hands over the grass water the grass but I'm not doing it there's no such thing you can't split an action in other words sick raesha is not creating a Nyssa it's just identifying it you're washing your hands on over grass that's the acept situation but what's really very informative Raschi and silk alignment gimel explains what's sick raesha you know we see secretions around she has the very interesting Muslim must tell you Rashi and the Rambam says this in the olden days children played with heads of chickens heads as in headless - hello chicken they cut off the head to play with the head and I'll tell you a child see the chicken he runs the other way they were interesting children they play with the head of a chicken so someone says I want to play with the head give me the head so he doesn't want to kill the chicken faster shop he wants us to play with the head but without the rest of the chicken so you can't do that dick even DFC shall I Thomas Kim a cabin caution may rush these are very important words if you want to cut off the head of a chicken to play with it but you don't want to kill it that's totally unrealistic so when you do decide to cut off the head of the chicken Kim a carbon flash of light in other words you have to be realistic you can't live in denial when you cut off the head of a chicken to play with it you have mohab enforce meet them I am NOT Robin this there's no such thing you can't cut up that without killing it now this is why the price can say obscuration the Nicolay isn't it's an erisa it's not just observer from chitin you're doing them the eastern is is cutting off time that's what you're doing oh boy since secretion the niccola isn't it so there i sir how could i ask you're going to do it we know whatever's aster for you to do you can have a guy do a ruff told me once people think that Emile Arkham is not only a Hatter but it's a way of life Sakura is not a heta it's not a way of life you can't do up sick I'm sorry Amira Arkham is not a hatter and out of I'm not a way of life I buzz Oh since we just proved up sick raesha by a lead is it there i sir so how could you instruct the guy to do obscuration but there seems to be not one but two McCoy is that maybe the situation by a guy is more mutter and once we figure that out we could apply that to the many showers in those days they had a different lifestyle they didn't have ovens like we have they had basically a fireplace and they kept calls that were hot and the cold kept a fool well some of them immerse the cook the pots into the coals to get it really hot and that's why you should know when you had a fire when you had a a food on the file you have a blood why do you have to have a black within the pack and the calls so we know the Camaro's show me your factor what does it mean show me a factor if someone stirs the coals that's the issue derisive Evora the marisa-san and then that fafa fight the burger column for Shabbos hypothesis sterling calls moving coals really reignite the flame and that's the SMI varam so the earth a ruin hopefully shot Erev Shabbos Simon has one thing burning machine has the following Schuyler Supt r0 if you have a path that's on the coals on top of the coals the hard there's no is to take the pan off because you're not stirring the coals the pots are the pot is on top of the coals but let's say the pact is embedded in the calls so when you take out the path innocently to have challenged the cover Chavez and it's intact but inevitably you are being McCarthy gullible zap tears Aurora that's secretion you have to be realistic taking out the part ISM as a Mesa Mitzvah of giving chalten cover Chavez but you're inevitably stirring the coals that's my path to become that's awesome sup the Earth's Aurora I don't know why people think it's mota to have a guy bring you the Cholan path just like a lead is now allowed a take out the pot because sick ratio of macarthur McCollum is a sir so whatever is impossible ye there's a stir by guys after hours everyone ah you're innocently asking him just bring me the pot of cholent you're not telling him to stir the calls that's what situation if it's it so here we see from the earth Aurora and I must mention I found that a half a dozen we've shown literally a mortify ravio she's by the elected and others all say this you say if it stock up stick race you going to stir the coals that's Hawara are yet can do it and the half of a guy can be asked to do it but there is also a different opinion - and Shabbos HOF oice cuff above i'm sayyig above ice cuff and I read the lawsuit I think it's very enlightening Oh Masha Honor I am Lenore 3 la jolla common minica column B Shabbos it seems that I guy's mind has held its motor to tell the guy to pick up the pot out of the coals and bring it to a year.this news Lawson ain't only Malloy loyal AHA boys from The Hobbit we don't tell him to make a fire bigger or smaller cuts to show them the ill he surah Carvin I didn't tell him tipster calls I told to bring me the pot the fact that he inevitably stirred the coals that's his problem not my problem so this revoice is like our soil you tell him an innocent act the fact that inevitably the melaka happened is his problem so we have at least one reason that guy is my mini that's sick raesha by a guy is looked by years I'm Olaf of the riser by a guy isn't but there's another source again in those days they didn't have ovens electric arm they don't have steam they had basically a fireplace basic wire if it's called a very big fire that kept the house warm they had a smaller fire to keep child form so here was this I love someone it was shot this morning and the big fireplace already got a very a small flame and the house was very very cold you can't leave a house that's called you'll have to call the guy to start a fire to warm the house I called him a tow car as they state the show home at the end of race I involved and the hit also notice that the sharland that he made the covered Shabbos was now cold fully cooked but now was cold yes miss Alaska Bissell so the it'd knows you latter call a guy to light the fire to keep the house warm it's an esophagus you might get sick but there's no heta to warm the charlatan yes miss la cabeza so the trimmers had and Simmons Tomica valve has the following suggestions into Santa he says it's to pass this first tells the guy take the cold Charlotte and put it into the fireplace right now there's nothing wrong with that because the fireplace is basically almost extinguished no fires then innocently but Hector tells the girl you know it's freezing in here I'm gonna get sick you better like the the fireplace which he'll do and a warm the house beretta and all also warm the challenge sup the trimmer suggestion I it's a situation that is also warming the child on Shabbos and for that is know gente eh hillock famous Calvin Gama the lame is having the visa Croatia such a trooper suggestion just take this one step at a time you told the guy to put the challenge into the oven that's fine because it was no fire then you told them to light the oven be Hector also fine I inevitably the challenge becomes warm secure Asia by a guy's motor as I statement you miss others so we have two sources in Pais completion and the transition was an early Afrin situation by a glorious little cross the boy now don't forget we saw heifer doesn't be shining plus we saw the Jose Ruiz mask Amir how do we pass him so there are more enraged and gimble in the end of sea-fowl off' speaks about the first question that we mentioned about the case of these de cholent that's immersed it's embedded in the coals and he says that it's better to ask the guy to take the child out of the calls now if you're looking there are more it's not clear if he means if the child is actually embedded in the coals or on top maybe it's better if they ask you going to do it to hawaii Eilis but the makarov ramen says the mortify asses to have to go take it out of the calls but that guy is my mini is Mako so this we have a bargain of ramen that's Mako to ask a guy to do an outright situation the Mishnah brewer and see if cotton an olive also says my keys the Malcolm Sayer of Shabbos you could rely on the schita that's a grater by a guy azmuth and you look at the end of rationing gimel there are more quotes the true Messiah dashing that you loud to make this two-step process to warm the cholent tell the guy to put the the child into the cold oven light the oven bathtub secretion by a guy using water and the marking I from spells this out as if Cottenham Aleph SiC raesha by a guy is motor now just for the record I have them are gonna from in six in five other place in six other place I should say raesha involve Eurasia in Zion Zion seen you down at the end of sleeve carnation I'm an olive test should my medallion I'm sorry that's all together sixth place that that the marking of Rama is Mako secreta by you're going now I must mention once again I can't say all agree because we saw a showing them a maximum also the Vilna goin on our circle area has a problem when it's obscuration the loin meat fillet may be can make up by a guy but here you want the Charla to be warmed it's a situation Denis calling you mamas wanted shown to be one in other words in the first case when you're picking up the challenge the fact that the coals get stirred doesn't interest you because you finished with the challenge but in the case of the other case you want the child to get warmed among at the moody going said I don't know how you could be makeup because has another problem and the ties asks I don't get it you tell the guy put the chalant culture aunt into the fireplace then you tell the guy to light the fireplace the guy knows what's going on when he lights the fire to warm the house he's lighting the fire to warm de chollet so the tasks I can't accept this Rama my only point I'm trying to bring out is that it's not a head to bar we have some machining that I'm asking we have did only garden there's math me avatars that's mock me but at the end of the day if we have a mother from in six places that's Mako this value bravado yes ominous associate the mr. Burrowes also make them but before we apply this Lamesa I think we have in the freshmen to give what stockett upset if I end can't dupe secrets of situation of happen constantly secretion presumably is innocent ERISA so how could you instruct a guy to do obscuration whatever zoster by a disaster by a guy and since it's her eyes to what's there to buy you guys so the masters a shekel often art it says a very positive oh he says that really for you to do an is even there are born in is also but forget to instruct a guys to obscure Asia who's doing the Malacca at the end of the day the going so if I tell the gray to do an Easter managed that's awesome but if I tell her going which is not me to do up situation which is not that really a my sister just figuration that's like a doubly diluted ISM sick raesha amalaki is okay but when I thought was beautiful is the Rav struck American racial in gimble see field and the Rob says novel has but the situation do you ever wonder if I cared why can I directly tell a guy be Mikado Sabbath what's wrong guy is yourself us naive nice if I care so Rashi and if I desire learns that you know wipes equations also because yes Leah with very very low Qumran if a perv you tell a guy to do McAuliffe Shabbos to you so the former yes leaf is my October secret Varvara and it's like you Mahalo shadows Supt arrived that's the reason wife sick ray she's motor because my instruction to the guy was very clear bring me the child Mayans my sleepless was to do a hectare the fact that inevitably a Milazzo occurred that's not my sneakers my sweetness is fajita not for issah and therefore this always send me Lanka now beautiful but we could even add even more so because another reason and there is shine in my bright situation is by wipe sick ratio by a guy is by I'm sorry wear sleeveless why why me Larkin by a guy is also is really the prowl is not that the guy doesn't melaka but when i instruct a guy paint my house I mentioned melaka there's a mr. davanon for diabetic of i can tell a year I'm gonna paint my house tomorrow but that bird dog and I talk about a lot of activity so sup trashy trashy second reason if I tell the guy paint my house the problem is not that the guy painting my house the problem is my dealer oh now it's golden or a bazaar if I tell the guy bring me the chalant am I telling you melaka don't bring me the child every sick raesha there's no deeper of this so there's no sleep cause every cent there's no deeper this so we have two good reasons wide situation by a guy is not the only turkey in classes that there's a third reason for the mister of amira outcome the round mum seems like they shop is Caliban aha if a guy could do melaka for ye there goes the Shabbos he'll do everything three reasons why a mule alchemist awesome caliber NASA deeper and sleeveless if you wanna remember it in a very easy way Shabbos clay this kodesh is Russia favors calleb a NASA D bar and sleeveless now the problem is the reason of calleb a NASA the hi replies you're beating the system you tell me a guy to bring to the children so every time you'll do to obscuration maybe that's why the restrain him a mop smear or maybe you'll say the fact is that you have tons you have to go roundabout way it's not calleb a NASA but one thing I could say secretion by ago this fundamental question is a malaika's kid earlier a shining my ladies could only apply skin but tomorrow from in six places is comfortable to be make up the mr. brewer is seems to also be maker rationed gimel side the castration and on Tesco Fowler Frazier in Zion tested she llamas I annuities make up the promise in Raceland gimbal for olive and Rachel and Tessa charity and for Bob he's only make all the treasure of Shaba star may initially but we could say that if the mechanic rom is Mako we definitely have what the say makan the mom's sick and Achuthan Cookman customer East I've been a subscriber hmm BAE's the hell cuz ya'll given our time cook your tests are all maickel is that the mini kids to be Mako so we'll say that certainly if someone has a situation of need of assertive Shabbos we definitely have a heta Amir Allah outcome tells the guy to do a heads up even though the lava occurs to creation by your guy that sort of Shabbos is moot before you apply this Lamesa I just have one question I think you're probably wondering I don't get this I need hot cholent so I could be same upon the RAM on the mug and I've robbed I'll tell the guy to put the cold child into the oven then I'll tell the guy to light the oven to prevent illness and I'm okay but the question is how could you have Henault from the Holland besides the is a miracle there's a very all-encompassing is that if a guy did melaka for the ye'd even voluntarily doesn't is that they have i'm not my sous chefs a guy walks into your house and and put something on the fire that was raw there's no official outcome of course you now that have a not even though you didn't tell that's the issue of my sis job is to have enough molasses so how could we say that when the going war might Charlaine its motor and a phenom it is no secret there's no is of Melaka was a sick raesha but how could i have enough from the freshly warm to chalant it's a good costume someone else customer i'm sick and that trooper Kaufman says I'm a sick set of beautiful fish market terrace there's a fundamental silica if a guy walks into my house and cook something for me he's cooking for me that's my sous chefs a guys did malapa for me is asking me to have enough but in this case the guy did a miser Hector he put the shown to the coal chomp into the other the milazzo that occurred happened on its own that's not doing it for me my job I died to the knife shake to great the Malakal himself you could have aa that it even duma love to become fond that happen on its own if there happen on its own they didn't do it for the eat he was totally unaware of the outcome in other words sick raesha the outcome is not doing it for a eat and it's better than the case and the guy did it for the Eid so justr has over briefly we have to Croatia by eat is amalaki their ice if it's legally by your guy just to the other side like many PI scheme is mother and by Malcolm Sarah who could be same a hundred now let me show you how much we could use this Lamai so this simple concept let's start with an interesting question a person is either in the mountains or he lives in Muncie or lake with picots he's in the outdoors where you still see earth you know in Brooklyn we don't see too much of that but he has a dirt floor so the election llama science eBay's you know how to sweep an earthen floor on Shabbos because you know by moving the earth you are being matched to the comas that's the melaka flavors the question is a person just ate outdoors and it's very dirty can he have a guy sweep out the outdoors so you're wondering what's the style of you it can't do it happy to go do it but there are more in the same scene Lama Zion Bay's me you I there any who deimata a ye can't sweep the outdoors a guy can what's the issue what's the Casman Paris is beautiful there's no thee is some sweeping you're not doing them Allah could be a Diamandis you want to sweep the floor it's a secure a sure that you master the goomers zOC the Tilo the governance is caught in the game o secure a shy they are come ISM what commercial custom I mean I from separation and giemo so sweeping outdoors for years of separation but that's why for a guy is what now what's even more beautiful the bogota from and she lambert ah he quotes a Yamcha layman Bayer paraguay's cinema Matt gimel that is maximum he argued on the Cairo agenda under seminar how could a guy be motor what's the abscess famous reasoning he all that goes with shine him secretion by agar is also very possible but at least we have the Makarov ROM seems to be Mako there are more things to make oh and the mr. Berg Michael if you think about it we have around Morgan I've robbed mr.brother she tossed some that obscure Asia by your guy is motive obviously that would be considered a Tyrell is it seriously whatever the husband is but definitely we could say it's integration by a guy easement plus I want to mention when the guy sweeps it's also alone easily there he doesn't care he's not plowing his field and Tufts and I in test you know anytime too soon so the whole sweeping even though it is quite rich is obscuration Lane is late and it's very possible that even the guy in would be Mako cuz here it's Elaine easily they used to be some anything today it's a little obsolete but something calls a carpet sweeper you wanted to clean the carpet so they are a carpet sweeper one of the concerns with the carpet sweeper is that it's a secure age that you pull out fibers of a carpet so that's why on Shabbos we don't use a carpet sweeper but those it's still have it if a guy wants to use it or you want to s go to use it even if it's a sick raesha that you know pull out a strand and buy a guy that would be motive you just had the young tip of silkies and it was talked a lot of rain but a lot of the rain was pretty well timed and assuming a person was waiting Eurasian without fur to stop raining and burns him it stopped raining so we have slack this hook is dry but the problem is has to get to the silk the sucker has Ashlock that's now loaded with rain and if you lift up the slack innocently all the rains gonna splash onto the grass and since he owns the house he likes that the grass should grow it might even be a sick raesha then insulate so the problem which is very obvious is for you to innocently lift up the slack the tire of Mitsubishi bazooka is also up security should the knees go like that he's watering the grass and even if it's light neither light this still Anisa so the question is what do you do dancers you do what you always do you learn so hamara if you learn how long then you know the answer you call the guy and tell him please open my slack and you're fine this is the sick raesha by you guy and here it's a syrup shouts a mitzvah definitely and here although it's tickle maybe it's neither leg but what could you do you have to sit in the circle now of course there are some that say that maybe even a youth could do it because if it's such a heavy rain the earth is so saturated that's extra rain is not going to help but others question that you know you have to know them it's serious is that true is it there's such a thing too much rain you know so we were going with a more safe heta you call the go to do it's a gradation by you're going ISM what I should mention if there's nobody available there would be a different answer if we get to do it and that is if it rolls or we should try to push it onto the pavement even though maybe later it rolls onto the grass that would be a groomer the first one to the pavement so you have possible star that we may collide a Israel but better I they outcome in a very simple application of up situation now let's talk about a pace of Schuyler someone remember to buy you know Mora romaine lettuce yum t'v but if you got to clean the lettuce and there might be bugs so for a year a head of romaine lettuce which presumably is infested is probably if he doesn't write that is is obscurations going to kill the bugs because whatever he does whatever uses to get rid of the bugs unless he does it very gently and slowly but if he uses a spray or uses a mix whatever it is but it washes or he rubs but this probably up security and he's my carpenter that he wants to get rid of the bugs so what do you do if you have lettuce that has to be cleaned so of course there is an ace up a practice of mitosis job this to have a go do it you tell the guy cleaned this well I don't like those bugs and he'll go with the vengeance to get rid of the bugs but he's washing it he's not doing a necessary to kill the bugs is to clean the bugs hopefully that would be considered uh gracious by your guy that's month but of course you have to have say call the guy that cleans the lettuce does that mean that it's you know Nucky from to volume so F he does his superb job makes you check it well to make sure you did it it didn't benefactor it superb job a fascinating question with the concept of a Miele aquam and a couple try you scrap is is the question of using hot water on Chavis a simple Schuyler it comes up a personal emotional needs hot water it's not at the cook now just need somehow water let's say for a child it could wait but he would like to have some hot water to wash a child let's talk about that case so of course the best thing is to use an urn but let's say there's no urn he wants to put on the hot water faucet and allow the hot water to run out and use it for a child so the emphasis without getting into the details using hot water per say putting on the hot water faucet it involves no is there's nothing wrong using hot water the problem is how the hot water gets there so to make a very long story short assume this is the boiler in our basement very interesting boiler a compact boiler but this that will be a boil okay the matthäus is when you take hot water and your kitchen sink you take a cup of hot water the way it gets them I can't explain because it's a little complicated but when he gets there is the cold water that's waiting coming all the way from the mountains from the reservoir is waiting pushing to get into the boil but the boil is full when you open the hot water for us if you allow a cup of hot water to come out it doesn't come out through magic it comes out because the cold water that's pushing is allowed entry because now you open up the faucet and a cup of cold water pushes out a cup of hot water basically using hot water the problem is not the water per se but whenever you take a hot water from your sink that amount is reply if you take a cup of hot water upstairs in your kitchen look over Chavez that's not a problem the problem is that a cup of cold water entered your hot water tank this hot water tank is a Cleary shine there's a fire underneath and even if there's no fire right now but it's a steaming hot I'm bhatia with very well insulated walls so if you put a cup of cold water into a hot water tank you definitely cook it right away even if the fire resort and cause him to fire is on which of course is a very serious sister but not not not good for a nice Jewish boy that's cooking a cup of cold water probably almost instantly a cup of cold water in a and a hot water tank is up to smear Shabbos mom and olive bays and I saw the orcish Shabbos and bay scientists says this as well by bizarre there might be a heta to tell the guy just give me a cup of hot water from the sink is mommy special but it's not a direct visual it's what we call a secretion a commission so forget to do it is us disrupt the guy to give me a cup of cold hot water even though what happens inevitably and it's the melaka their i sir but this is secretion by a guy or be in a mulatto rise up and but that's what we saw is not the base on the guys miami tea now you could really argue that this is a line needs relay for the year because he's not using the rest of the water he does need the rest in the water whatever gets cooked but at least we have a scenario of sick raesha on a very practical level the same is true and this brings it even to more practicality today many shoes and Yeshiva sand hotels and probably most commercial urns are no longer the old fashion urns that you fill it up and it goes today most the commercial urns are what's called autofill in other words when you take out a cup of water a cup of cold water goes in its place obviously any automatic automatically filling urn it cannot be used on Shabbos you're taking a cup of water you're putting a cup of cold water and it's cooking it so there's a guy buddy whatever it was my mother there before Shabbos he closes the autofill so it has X amount of potential but a mission sabes the question is if someone has a autofill earn it forgot to close it and now it's being automatically filled for you to do it is about aniseh their ice official the a tulip flavor is to have a girl yes I go to give me a cup of hot bring me a cup of hot water and that would be obscuration by a guy I have to have aa from the rest of the water go cook that water for that we'll use them around 60 aside this is secretion and but it's not a doing it basket lead and the efforts mode this mere Shabbos and her adalat points out that's if you ask a guy for a cup of hot water but if you have a line up in shul and 20 people need a cup of hot water and they ask to go get me one get me one get me one get me one after a while he catches on and he realizes what he's doing and therefore it probably be more of a my severe diam but this it's an e fillet for the guy so he says that would be considered more of a mice to be Italian but cause man that you're doing taking a cup of water here or there that's obscuration of IE that's also there i said by a guy would be motive I'll tell you another fascinating South is also quite Nigeria someone accidentally put on the hot water on Shabbos but ever reasonings my mistake you put the room for sit on a child that often does it now you how about water that's running the question is can you close hot water that's running now you're probably wondering what's the shower I mean you can't put on out what a particular you know that's you know to grace' what can I close hot water so I'll tell you very simply and again we'll use this as our hot water boiling when you have water running you'll notice after a very short while the water that comes out is nothing better than lukewarm you know you take a few showers so the water is lukewarm what's the explanation very push it if water sits in a hot water tank it gets cooked if the hot water is constantly running so the water is running through the hot water tank that what the tank punch doesn't have the ability to cook the water because the water is just running so it starts but it runs so water that's running the water in the tank is constantly exposed to a minimal amount of heat for short amount of time and it remains lukewarm now watch this if a Yid goes in his kitchen upstairs and closes the hot water he innocently closed the hot water but you know what he did he slammed the brakes on to this water tanker so now all the water that's there right that second is there two distinct now all this water is going to get cooked till now it was run through the system and remained lukewarm probably never get cooked but when you close the hot water that's running so the water that there is there to stay no water's coming in and the water is in the tank to be cooked eventually so by closing the hot water that's running says the smear Chaves Islamic base pay bathe and early in out of Memphis that would be the issue of cooking the water in the water tank not the water upstairs but the word and the word tank is now exposed to enough heat that we'll be able to cook it Shila so what should I do the waters can run a whole shabbos the answer is you could call the guy and tell him please close the the hot water and that's really a very perfect situation because the guy even though he became over the years became the shabbos Gabe again my stickler Thomas Holcomb so to speak he says you know I know you can't put on a light you can't put on fire but you can't invite on the hot water I know that also Rabbi but what's really closing hot water because he's not so you know smart this application so this is mom is an innocent act that has a secondary effect so this is a classic situation by a guy and therefore by a guy it's motive now am i sighs want to mention if the water is running and there's no glow available there are some that are Mako for the year to close it I the judgment of secreta so the answer is it is obscuration but sick raesha is always when it happens right away cut off the chicken's head situation every situation happens right away here it's not gonna cook instantly you secure a keeps the water in the tank and now it will get cooked eventually so the sick raesha big drama a combination sick raesha you slam the brakes so to speak you keeping the tank and then it's you keep it in a match against cooked secretion by your grandma many PI skip I mean certainly someplace kidnapping as the focus your eye makeup also I want to mention if someone just put the hot water on by mistake so if you close this right away it's probably motor also because the hot water and the tank is still hot nothing changed additionally if the water is just dripping very very slowly some are also making even for you to close it because the dropped a little bit of water that's dripping which means a little bit water going into the tank is cooked immediately so you're not achieving anything really a sort of sort of significance when you close that trip I'll give you another example of sick raesha let's say you're in the outdoors and a person notices when he pushes a stroller or a wheelchair he makes a carrots in the ground so making her eat in the ground we know that's the famous suger that's aggression that's good that it's the case of actually of a value of the grower or the meatus massage so shil nama saya now let's equation of making Harriet's so in that situation when a Yid will not do it out sag ratio of AIESEC are its it makes sense that guy could be asked to push the stroller or wheelchair that would be obscuration by a guy is important a Keith Urban a penny maven in seminary and olive has this HEPA I should mention more often than that when you when a person pushes a wheelchair or a stroller it doesn't make it her it's the point the place can refer to this with the Russian emission of Chi Vestas when you push a wheelchair especially when the earth is moist it doesn't make a like a furrow that you could plow on it it presses down it compacts the dirt that's under it covet says is not conducive for her Isha curvaceous means all the earth is there but it's pushed down that makes it harder to plant the issue of making the Ferraris when you remove the soil and now you have a whole when you push down the soil now you have to actually break the soil and then put the seed so whether to situate that is curvaceous compacting versus removing the soil then even a yet could push that stroller or wheelchair other like to have a guy map the floor using a map so forget the map a floor has the compounded problem first of all it's it's a secure a sure that you're making sweeter and also the cloud this is a very comedy cur is a word that burner we don't mop floors on Shabbos that's one of the he's swim involved in the issue of smoothing out the earth hidden we don't use maps on Shabbos for the procedure Asia of a theta for the issue of cleaning a floor it's possible that mix add the issue of theta you could tell the guy to mop the floor what inevitably happens that it ends up being a skater might be sick raised by you're going that's what I am its ideas sir of sweetened but I want to mention I saw the mass Lyon seminar in Allison I obeyed and other say there's also we have a great reluctance to washing floors mopping floors and shoppers even sweeping is awesome but mopping floors is definitely smoothing out the earth and if you learn the sugi even in a regular forces are auto auto buyers Shana Murat sip soba Dara cloud we avoid using a map even idea come but in a case where there is a need we should mention this that becoming too great to just to clean the floor and he certainly be decides to use the map so that would be his diet that than a say if you give him a moist map and say just clean the floor the fact that inevitably it's a situation by a guy there's some better makeup we just had at miss interesting Shila someone needed a warm compress which means you had to take a cloth and put hot water I guess from the urn onto the pit cloth no problem of Bissell so what's the Shila little harder for you to do it is a very serious Shila putting water on a cloth that the Morris says mohabbat brings attention base shreya site is elke busa so forget to put out water onto cloth it is mama ste is sarov keep us but look at this the safe I go there in air vents in Samak test he speaks about a situation were you making a meal before the meal and its many is in preparing for the Miele which is super involved so he says to forget to put hot poop to put water on to the sodden onto the cloth that's the issue of shreya Sasaki Busan so the eights is have the guy put the cloth in water now and this is quoted by the mother never um don't put the cloth in water had to go do it comes again the tasty Shabbos in Shin lime and olive see far fees that understand why is it going motor if it's a nest of their eyes they forget why is it going water doctor tiller dove it early and shin based asthma I know why it's a great situation by a guy is motor as I state until another day so now we can understand why the market I've run rings this safe I grew them because they ride it's another case of secretion by your guide this is one of the six places among Aramis maker to creation by ago now personally the CC Lahav n' is that obscuration or is that a my sister we're taking a cloth putting it into water that's not sick raesha incidental that's the yesterday is this don't put a cloth in water you know - uma your bigger hole is not a decoration is the issue right so why is this only pursue creation this demise to be a diet and I believe that's why the taster shabbos didn't think that it's obscuration you look in the Prima garden and on their mother mom he also wonders why is it mutter maybe bye-bye and it's at their eyes yes my team the beloved in Tyra he all seems to be say that something to do with the fact that your child needs it maybe for the Mila but there has to be a difference between a my superior Diamandis aggressive taking a course of putting in water is there mice to be a dialogue like that's what I think now give you another example where this question comes to the fore someone is marketed not to open soda bottles on Chaves because when you open the soda bottle you're making the soul together okay there's something to make them but he is very mouthing he says that he opened the soda bottle you're making the cat the campus I was not usable it was not functional turning it off you're making the cap because I saw in the safer or for Shabbos page tough I incest he says so even if your Mac did not to open a Saudi cap throat about the eight is ask a guy to open the soda I inevitably the guy is making the soda cap sick racial buy your guy is motor another wonderful expression of secretion by you go so on the bottom equals I'm small I about the final developer ain't hat the busy border and I think I know why if you're telling him to open the soda cap you're telling to make the cap that's not a situation incidentally that's directly the mice but mom I said the truth is he says it's more about says if you tell the guy to open any throw away the soda cap then copy the Kevon is not at all for the cap it's just to open this in soda and that would be multiple Plus you have to remember some my maker but allowed to open it so high they acclaim but Malcolm Sayer if there's much of a morbid sad to be make up question someone and each has to go to feel a Friday night I forgot to comb the hair so we know this is the end of shin gimble based on a reverse combing here on Shabbos is is Malaca their eyes mr. Brewer says as the Pharisees rage Thomas if cut now live is based on a reverse combing hair on Shabbos of a loaf of the rice now you're probably wondering what's the melaka the riser it's very simple when you come here and you smooth out here there's no ista in that per se but when specially when women want to come to here they want to get out their nuts now the truth is you could comb the hair from hiatus morgan there's no magic that if you comb that here the knots somehow get unknotted to get open it doesn't work like that a comb doesn't open nuts how does it come straight now to hear any knotted hair is pulled out right so when you're combing here you ever having to pull out the hair that is knotted and that's why I mean mr. Brewer says it there's rush says it calming is not just a from is an issue their eyes I bazaar the Huayra doctor that the busan Aravind - Terrence beginning of shin ma'am he quotes the toughest tasks that the comb here on Shabbos even are they akhom even the toy of Fela is awesome because this is a Meera Akram in a melaka their eyes and you look in the ave mezda in the end of Coughlin hey he be tracks what he writes in a great owl and he says combing here I the oculus VR sadistic because it's an issue of pulling out to hear the question only is why isn't this a head of secretion by a guy you tell the guy just to come out to hear what happens inevitably the situation by you go and probably that's what the mouth disken meant to say in conscience a friend Simon hey Steve cut and coughlin he brings on the bush they throw that's math there but you could be medical I they are Kobe says probably he held combing hair sinister their eyes sir taka alta gracia but secretion by a guy using water now the question only is the duster couldn't think of that Nadine as you couldn't think of that but the terrorists the car is the same point calming is pulling out to here that's not it it's not I'm doing am i sir head to butt grab that happens to be I don't know I I I opened the schlock and all of a sudden the water came flying on the grass that's figuration but combing is pulling out there and who look in the mirror I'm sick and the tool that I mentioned he has this very Schuyler and Isha forgot to comb her hair could you have a go a Coleman so he says that oh sorry this at secretion by an ahkam but he said I'm not sure if that's really obscure Asia because you're McFadden to cut pull out the hair that's not it so at the end he writes something which is not usual the Mahmud Ghaznavi row he says Lamesa ain t massively eisah I'm not saying exactly he says my girlfriend Victoria they should go to Tila but he says I'm not sure this obscurations might be a my Sevilla value so the Mesa is whatever happens I want to mention this the best 8c is right away denisa realize this you didn't come to hear if it's Phil Boehner smushes like any Sita if it's still been as smash this call the guy because been as smart as the guy could be called for any Emile Arkham so even if it isn't there ISIL but the point that I think more than the halala mice of guy coming here for a year is this new CUDA Avada Mueller Arkham by a guy is motivated machina from but there's got to be a differentiation between our Miele alcone and mice of the Italian you can't tell them to do my sweet I was only up situation I'll give you a wonderful muscle the be a lock-up inch in Zion huh Fowler this is not even Chavez like this is a question there in the week he said you know there give a guy a miller hook up at been your he might and tell him cook meat in this path was not for you for himself you can't tell him give a guy take this meat and cook it in this path been your might why that's a sick ratio that this bus the bacala me allowed combustible caller now why don't we say it's not possible call of its situation when the guy cooks the the meat in the malefic apart the degree has come out and a whole terrible story it became possible color so wise to be a love for quoting prima causa massa there's this question when you cook that's what happens so it's not a situation that my ego is more tub it's a good more by a guy that's awesome the light in the fridge issue that we began with La Jolla for you to open the fridge a vadas also integration and even if he doesn't need the light he has enough light in his kitchen to creation by nucleus to love somebody but software moisture and failing base them and sama house the eight is called a guy and very innocently says please open the fridge and the fact that the light goes on is obscuration by your guy litter of Shabbos and his mother what to me was noteworthy the dish Mira Shabbos quotes from slim Salman who says that this case could be more to even might be going either going is maximum execration that's because it's an easily but here since you don't need the light of the refrigerator it's obscuration light maybe later go in his mood but somebody's album then ads and this is something to think about I'm not sure that the cloud this is integration now let me just explain what some Salman Square is coming from if you tell her guy please just lift up the light switch so see what what are you telling going to put a light now it's only obscuration telling a guy to put on the light switch is not of secretion that's the way you put on right that's a nice to be Italian says ups Leymah Salman again in issue a Shabbos lamb and olive she's cut an Aleph telling the guy to open the door of a light a refrigerator that there is no manual switch the only switch is to open the door is amazed to be Italian that's the switch to crazy should you do am i Sahara and I my sister curse but this is the way to put on the light and he is the case of the cholent tell the guy bring me the shawl and even though you must have the bigger column that's incidental I want Charlotte the fact that happens to be embedded in the calls that's a different issue but I'm bringing out so but opening the refrigerator door is putting on the light I say 10 up slam is down now what does he mean to say once we determined it's not obscuration but a nice to be a die-in there's no hair tie they aqua but the truth is it's not necessarily more time because open your door is a my Sahara grab that happens to have an accessory an taka in the ARCA Shabbos he quotes were small I you back up somewhere Samba Solomon's son that I talk to I with my father I was down the front of I don't understand why isn't this a regular situation LeMay Serb ramesha is make all the bear motion both test out CMM Olive gimel and I think that's the mini column if you have a real need you could call a guy to open the door even though life goes on so that looks like it is step one now of course if you could manage without opening the fridge if you have wine and you have the base necessity so don't call the guy but let's say you have the wine in the frigerator under give fill division and many Turkish Shabbos yes local the question is what he do now the guy opened the door the light is on what are gonna do is gonna close in tomorrow have to call them again so her Manisha says that you know this is or much and say but it's partially if you could put a towel on the so when you close the door the door will not close completely and the light will remain on so hopefully the fool won't spoil there's enough you know electricity that will keep the food cold but you won't close my then you can open and close it freely but let's say this is not feasible so moisture says and you lie to tell the guy to unscrew the bulb even though you tell him that rapidly to unscrew the bulb but this is a mark of key boy that's Moroccan since we hold a goof up so the Swiss - was there a button merlok on the map a mitzvah the same is true a person is stuck with an automatic light the S goes in her face in the bathroom in a in a hospital I'll tell a nursing home the opens or light goes on he has to use the facilities so the Aces have a guy please open the door can I ask you why you can open yourself that's a different problem but just open the door once a light that's obscuration by your guy and again the same heta hopefully we could rely on memory you see after that's obscuration atomize to be Italian the same is true you have clothing in the dryer and you want to take it out but to open the dryer door the lights gonna go on the simple eight says tells the guy open the dryer door the light goes on it's a gracious equation by a curious month the same is true if you were urged before Shabbos don't forget to buy this and this we need to recover Chavez and Bertram you remember to buy you the cover Chavez but the problem is you left it in the car this is in the mountains you have an area so forget to open the car door you're putting on the light so the eight says tell the guy innocently to open the car door the light goes on is to Croatia and then you could take out the Canadian food from the car today many hotels are coming more and more popular have what's called climate control when you open the door during the winter the heating goes on in some of the air conditioning goes on it's a major problem before you book a room you have to make sure this is not apply to your room but if a person had that situation by opening the door he's putting on heating or air conditioning a visor that's awesome the only eights is to get into the room you can have the guy perhaps open the door but beyond that you can have a problem but but any type of situation you ask the guy to open do something and the Malaka happens sort of speak automatically that will situation by a guy and that would be multiple we started with the question can I have a if there's no go available it's the middle of the night I need something can I have a cut on do execration let Marshall you need something from the refrigerator very importantly there's no guile can I ask my child lawyer Gilles enough very innocently please open the refrigerator so posh this what's the Schuyler if it's a guillotine if you can't tell the child to Malaga if it's lawyer Gilles chin up so this is not on the child is on the father it's the puss sick actor open the Kavita even though you give the pin if we can instruct the child in Malacca for the father and there's no doubt about it that's even while he gala dinner just like Lahab doula Bahama is why Yugi looking up but it's still awesome so the parrots is a child like you're gonna for the fathers in Malacca of the father so here we have an interesting thing some posts can suggest the following why is sick raesha by by year awesome that's so rad she says Kim I haven't possibly so what did that mean if I open a refrigerator door I know the lights going to go on so I'm not just my servant to open the refrigerator I'm a husband also to the secondary action of putting on the light so part of the situation is they do doer is my bobbin for the outcome as well so I saw tremendous care this but I want to mention because it fits analogously beautifully but Cheyenne burger in the juvenile miter okay I'm a doer BAE's a various good base he says if that's the reason why it's a gracious also because the person that doing it is aware of the secondary action it believes molasses mouth chef s so maybe buy a cotton that's law you give the pin up doesn't have the dice to know what's going on you can cause to muhammad possibly so it's lacking the molasses machetes that's what he says if there's no dice to make it macabre there's no is now the truth is this is very hard to accept I think most most importantly that the posts can be shiny Macarena buggin Aram all discussed a mirror akhom by a going had it been true that a cotton is emit that depth segraves acceleration by a guy whose mother hadn't been true that secretion by a cotton his mother it should have said it they don't have electricity in times of hazael but they had katana which is more practical called a girl you ever cut and do it had it been - it should have said it but the truth is beside that in the lumbus is yes yes the cowlick Tuva because if the opponent says could be part of the security the the the concept of to croatia is if you're my father to open the refrigerator that's the easter open the fridge Raider is opening on the right and the Charles were having to open the refrigerator that's like macabre to put on the light in fact I'd kadai cast it could be even for character revolver over the bay see it's hook in mm valid cast he wants to say a finished pumper character sins of cotton doesn't have gas so maybe even Maleficent see from the goof is awesome with their eyesight they cotton because he's not happy to do what he does doesn't make a difference the fact that he doesn't know that it's ain't see Hulagu fur a cotton does like I'm like a robot his mice is him once his mice is him it does make a difference the outcome so it could be for carrot once the cotton does it and he has that's the maloca you don't that that's for outcome so I think I could say that most place can say that this is not advisable to have a cut and do it what I could mention is if the child on his own is going to open the refrigerator to take out something from the refrigerator and he's lawyer gear look latina you kalau him to do it because he's a massage sick even though massage thing is not so posh that if atomizer but if a cotton is doing it you could allow him the truth be told summers Alma says is in the agama to failing dollar more on Shabbos if a child is going to open the refrigerator for his own syrup could be equal down even if Aquila thinner I happy to how could that be so the bear locking race in race mmmm demo quotes Aurasma if a cotton does a mulatto there are born on let saw your odds my you could allow them to do it even a Gilda thinner so the question how do you jump from opening am I to be a melaka their opponent so if it's just if it's not a contestant bulb let's say it's if it's an LED bulb which is not a real melaka there Durai sir perhaps you could be making in that situation the good of Charles doing - Latoya I've actually asked myself I must mention this following her aura someone is in the mood to play with the chicken's head okay don't you see why but this is a something that brings us to the side of the circle is it multi to tell a guy I need a chicken's head could you please arrange that so there's a chicken walking around with a head so far but you need a chicken's head so the Schuyler is can you ask the guy who's gonna understand and cut up the chicken's head so until today see what's going on it you telling you go to chef the chicken there's no head on shop okay it's not sweet - Custer's PETA but it's definitely the tail susharma but the truth is for today this might be month of the favor quite a lot of chicken said what's that called in la ciénaga mara secretion so if you go with the modern Aram in six places EPSA Croatia by a guy is mutter why can I tell the guy I need a chicken's head it doesn't sound right but why not so the terrace is very posh to the foyer the cast of Mishnah in health the shop is I'll evolve ask what's the difference in sick raesha and beloved wishes before the goofer - boom vein supplier is also why is it obscure Asia there it's a very posh it if you tell big digging is the my sister but opening Ashlock is out of my sister opening Ashlock when this water on it isn't my sister in other words the custom is saying to me so you've said till now many times there's a difference between sick raesha and my system I'll give you an example putting a cloth in water some call of sick ratio but we saw that it might be a nice to be a dying so now here's the finish which I'm give you for homework think about it if I tell a guy sick racer the figuration tell them to cut off the head of a chicken Oh tell I need a toy a toy called the head of a chicken that is see creation butts up the copies to Marmon Silko llama demo believe it or not grace it's the literal situation might be amazed to be a doll you see grace is a muscle that are happier than evident Lee but the actual sick raesha cutting off the head is maybe more than absurd gracious a nice to be a diam so until further notice don't play with the headless chicken I couldn't talk to you off shame here you sure talk tighter like a vegan staccato mr. today's ships a making sure tire let's go with a nozzle thought sort of eats extent on the gauge Minh of his daughter the collar to the sake to snap has to do so the yellow basalt elements life has pronounced miss will give a secret - year number five ten minutes so for non-genetic a shame arrest rockers both lose a consensus or treatable entire mixes and emma her husband city out to the other [Music] [Applause] the larvae on my own [Music] [Applause] [Music] why [Music] [Applause] [Music] besides I need to hear the cecum of today soon as I push the bonds gonna start automatically grace' wonderful just the reviewer learnt a passage m/sec raesha means that a person does one act and something else inevitably happens opening the refrigerator light goes on or the case of watering on to washing on the grass and since the Malacca and the action is inseparable it always happens it's Mama's one the Rashi says came a common question lay in other words you haven't toured to wash your hands you might happen to water the grass you might happen to open the refrigerator your Marvin to put the light on and that's why you're going to be showing them if it's obscuration than the Escalade it's a derisive because Yama havin to the outcome since it's an error that will occur there are sheeta's in machine m and the muharram seems to endorse that schita the opposite raesha is also for a yield me their eyes sir but you vow to instruct the guy to do something which is obscure age that melaka happens either upshot is it's a doubly removed is sir it's a mirror of outcomes you're not doing an obscure asia or like the Rav says there's no sleepless aware that there's no Tibor but the point is that there are many Maha Miriam but the monodrama mr. Brewer in most places is maickel so the mice some limit only when motor when it's like Nicolay and certainly it's only for the tariff Shabbos but definitely if it's a tariff Shabbos we could say Amelia ahkam even the do Malacca there i so that comes out with sick raesha we have enough to be sign off to be makeup and examples we gave is sweeping a dirt floor of a year disaster I'll smash my goomer's for a giri's muta of a guy using a carpet sweeper even if opposed out strands is a situation to learn earful a which would be muttering the schlock even though the rain will go onto the grass directly is obscure Asia by year disaster by Garuda motor cleaning vegetables that are infested per year is also for going to be more toxic raesha using hot water for a year for a guy would be Mota the urn that has an auto-fill that was not shut off should not be used by a year a guy could use it I must mention few people told me I was unaware of the Mattias that an auto-fill there's a better age say enough to have a guy do it just close off the autofill I didn't have time to research this but if your autofill this is only a totally mechanical act isn't of light there's no other millech tricity and yet could close it that's certainly better than having a guy do it so close the autofill so you could use it without a Shila too close running water either you throw we should refrain from it it might be secretion by Grandma that might be motor we said but definitely to have a guy close the running water or a drip a car that's obscured by your guide that's not them pushing a stroll on a wheelchair if it's curvaceous if it compacts to earth and yet could do it if it's Irish if it makes the Faro and yet cannot do it but a girl could be asked to do it that's a gracious by a guy that's motive mappings should be avoided even though you are calm but the shots of tractors I had to use a map with a guy that would be of secretion by your guy putting water onto a cloth is the problem of Shirazi Okubo site and the post game our maker were not sure exactly if the healthiest decoration maybe this is a my Sevilla diam but the Magna from seems to be Mako the mahkum a photographer a cotton for sure this would be certainly the Turkic cotton they'll be mad to even though Shiraz is Erica Busan opening some soda bottles are the outcome we found it's a two-vehicle that that's a situation by a guys personally throw it out combing here I should mention we saw it's a McClay kasam CID Alchemist also some I'm a Collider you saw someone pointed out correctly if the Isha combs her hair carefully and does not discover any knots so obviously the fever was done properly that's it sad to be making even are they in trouble because you're combing very carefully and there will be no pulling out here because you'll stop by any resistance but we're talking about when you get to or not knotted hair then we have that child if it's a hair tie the outcome or not opening a frigerator that puts the light on we have it's out to be maker they outcome if there's a serif Shabbos once it's open either put a towel don't close it correctly or have to go to unscrew the bulb same is true opening a card or a dryad or an automatic light in the door any case I'd easterlies and it said there I side the outcome the higher should be mud to a person should not use a cut in some secret it seems that's more of a my cerissa even lay Aguila fennec he shouldn't tell the child to do it there's a header if the cut opens the turquoise solicitor Bonham and most under most interestingly obscure Asia cutting off the chicken the chicken said asking a guy to give me a chicken's head might not be sick raesha that's mote idea might be amazed to be a diam and would not be motor idea