Hilchos Shabbos - Amira Leakum (2) - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

someday by 88 option nine Tests Bruce on my bone machine making sure stuff like the Welcome tackle I showed him to share by her alpha girl a Bianca this much lead on the topic of a mere Larkin and this time we would like to give a Mazel Tov be shamed initiate air in the tire cross over the country she heard him to one of the board members of English a trader approving wolf on his engagement I was door above Hashem David Asim Curbishley miss Abby Nadia al qiyamah sim Cavanaugh caused by them by Alec Indialantic 11 by Allah eating isn't a reverse smash Lita someone ask you this question he was he had to leave Matsuri Shabbos I think was from the bungalow colony and he had to be Alabama's right after this man the caller leadership car service that would take him my service arrived he wondered arranged before Shabbos today no I'm Jewish car service will be by his bungalow or hotel room whatever it may be pick him up and they could get on the roads right after this man but it meant that inevitably the guy will have to drive to get to his location to be them ladies man is that a new problem of a miracle then we had another son with Shiloh we're typically in the mountains they don't have mailboxes on every corner you have a private mailbox by your colony or by your camp so the question was to put the mail Friday afternoon into the mailbox but then that's not enough you have to lift up the red flag so the mail man that drives via a job this morning sees the red flag that's up that indicates he should stop and take the mail so you're doing is you're putting mail on Friday lifting the flag on Friday but that's almost an indication to stop and pick up the mail they'll be uninteresting Shila where someone's was moving cross-country to a different state and they were they hire a mover to take the stuff across country so basically the guy is driving on Shabbos do you have to tell the guy don't drive my luggage my stuff on Shabbos that is driving just for the year and the truth is as we'll see we have numerous other questions but the point really is in our society we have constantly new applications of amira akhom what are the basic guidelines someone just asked me was sitting in a house Shabbos say the ups rang the bell we have a package filled so I can take it can I sign it for you I know you don't sign can I sign it for you what are you supposed to tell them so there's no doubt about it Amira Akram is a very Hamid Acacia in fact it's lava Africa meal akhom the mr. Burris says specifically in race I involves he's cutting your olive if the guy on his own walks into your house and he sees it's dark and he says no no you know I I'm a experienced Shabbos you don't tell me let's do I know what to do I'm gonna put the light on don't worry rabbi you have to say don't if he refuses to listen look mister will chase him out of your house because Amira the outcome is lava Africa miracle the Miele Occam is really the guy doing Malacca for the year but we see a different aspect in Amira outcome that's unique amongst other suom and that is let's say the guy did do Malacca feel on Shabbos suck the Gomorrah and this is a gap a second and raesha involved it's also to have enough from the Malacca that the guy did for the eat but what's unusual is not only you can't ever know on Shabbos but even my saree shop is you have to wait the time that it takes to do that melaka for example you have a nice neighbor who walks into your house he says you know I just went apple picking this morning I thinking of you here I have a bushel a few apples enjoy so you know how to eat the apples on Shabbos or much sorry Shabbos until you wait the time that it takes to pick the apples now this is strange because if cos Michelle I'm a lead does melaka for another year on Shabbos we also know you know I have enough of my to Shabbos so the years now I have enough from what the other you did but there's no dinner of Kadesh easá you could have enough and what that you did for you or matauri Shabbos right after this man so the question is how could a guy do more lawful for you be more calmer then you do melaka for you the answer is because has i understood no ye'd will tell another year do melaka for me if it happens it won't happen again you don't have to make more of a protection than a Sun on Chavez but if a guy doesn't know lawful for you there is that chance that it becomes more calming rough one talk once told me that people think that amira outcome is not just a heta it's a way of life and I'm here like him is not ejeta and it's not a way of life and that's what cuz I were protecting when they said Amira ahkam is hasta Vaughn no on Shabbos even matsuri Shabbos the time that it takes to make that hon know now of course it's a lot to say but I think it suffice as the words of diminishes the true verse Menasha my name's Simon Dalit that was one of the Bali atossa been the Yankee me my gosh who s tireless Minister my him and he got responses and he asked a question about telling a guy to move a Nair in other words the guy is moving mobster for the ye'd which is a schwa specialist so the response was like CB biood the key Sokka is aku calling Ageha but Avraham can I get above us a night you're playing with Shabbos that's divided the pupil of their brunch thumbs I and especially I'm ear like my become of a kind must also have common physically the very me I used to Michel tire so Amelia outcome really needs a little more physical emphasis but I think we understand that you don't do Malacca I'm a guy kendama love the four-year period now let's try to apply this a little more specifically imagine the following case a person goes to a hospital and his muscle the door is an automatic door you can't get in you know if the door opens electronically but just then a guy walks by and also wants to go in so the guy stands by the door it opens can the Yid also go in together with the guy so la jolla this is having enough malacca sake but I'll tell you another sailor true story Ibaka asked me the Shia it was an off service and the ship was supposed to be closed he walked by Shabbos afternoon he knows the lights and mis medi sure on some riots the lights are on - quiet this man she wanted to learn he goes inside how the lights get on it seems the guy the greatest janitor put the lights on I guess he also had her off Shabbos he decided he didn't sleep on it variety came on Shabbos too sweet so the bar one throw could he learn a Majid the whole afternoon the guy put on the lights on Shabbos the answer is of course is allowed to important both case you allowed to use the lights and job isn't allowed to go into the hospital through automatic door I the didn't walk on Shabbos but you're missing one point the guy did melaka for himself he didn't want to put the lights on so he could learn he didn't know about that he put the lights on so he could sweep or the guy entered the hospital and therefore you open the door when is that Mila Akram or sir when a year when the guy does melaka for the ye'd if he does it what's my there's no listen this is one important Hector will refer to as my axe my he did it for himself now there's an issue if the guy might do the next time for the ehm ER because sure you like okay but basically the guy said personally nah the hospital's not doing it for you this would be a head to borough now let's go a step further let's say you eat once the mail letters Erev Shabbos here in Brooklyn and he has real her clay that she knows no years is going to process the mail there's no Eden working in the mail in the Indy Postal Service but he knows with certainty job this morning the guy comes to collect the mail from the mailbox is it motor to mail ladies Erev Shabbos again there's no issue of listener even question number two someone has the husana on Tuesday he needs his suit cleaned he brings it in Friday afternoon mamas a few minutes for this man this is I need it back Tuesday so the guy says this is your lucky day because I have a slow business you'll have a tomorrow Saturday 12 o'clock p.m. you'll get 24 hours service for the same price you not to pay extra the guy tells you specifically he's doing it job this morning you'll have a 12 o'clock Saturday morning both cases think about it the Mayo and the suit is not blocks money he's not cleaning his suit he's cleaning the in suit he's male in the years male this is not the heta of lots white so maybe talk it's awesome but here we have a Gomorrah and we'll go straight to the South America they have a big agenda enraged name's Allie and see if I left the macabre postions based on a mission and Gomorrah you allow Tamayo lettuce on Erev Shabbos in those days it was the mail you allowed to dispatch the courier to carry the mail who bill vibe to show you a malaysia aleppo Shabbos don't tell to take it on Chavez you just be quite sets Dunham you pay him for the job you pay him for the delivery and that's it now this is a very big finish you're giving the guy email your mail he's carrying your mail and it's motor why is it motor so the answer as the muhabba calls to Gomorrah because he's crated slay dominant he did not tell to do it on Shabbos what's the shot and this is the you say that we need when you tell the guy to mail the letter and you pay him you're paying her for a job the job is not time related or time restricted the job is to mail the letter so it's not a Shabbos job he could do it on Shabbos he could do it on Sunday could do it on Monday so although he's mailing a letter for the ye'd but it's not a Shabbos malakal this is what's called and paste him I die to the knife shape it is not the head of lots my thoughts my is he is putting on the lights for himself or he's opening the door for himself here he's mailing the letter for the heat but the fundamental difference is that it's not sharp this job it's a paid job it's a cobbling it's being paid for a job so this is the Hat done because the fact that he chose to do it on Shabbos instead of Sunday or Monday is his decision it's his convenience a lighter than a shake in other words your job did not need a little Shabbos because all you have to do is do it on Sunday therefore you can understand the next question if you notice I've noticed the case even in our neighborhoods you see a truck driving around in the neighborhood in big bold letters and as the lens G period o period and the period I first saw it I thought this is mushy excitin it's Mufasa maliku spoiler but it's not nothing to advise them Geo d stands for guaranteed overnight delivery nothing doing anything about the venezuelan what is that you want males to be delivered overnight overnight it is called in business do you pay extra and they de a guarantee overnight delivery to give that service on Friday afternoon is awesome I mail this motor Mohnish down the mail for mail this is because here you are violating the second half cool if I tell you a Malaysia gala for Shabbos if you pay extra for guaranteed overnight delivery so then you're paying for the low Shabbos it can't be done on Sunday so what's the sorry push it regular mail is not a Shabbos sleepless overnight delivery is specifically for Shabbos this is both hilarious are found in natural Canora can raise them Zion Allah now consider the next case that we mentioned earlier you brought in the cleaners to the cleaners the suit and you told them I need it for Tuesday and he tells you straight out I'm doing it Saturday morning do you have to protest the answer is no why the fact that he did it on Shabbos morning Edyta denies shake and that's raised from valid Aleph and mr. Breuer adds keeping the cutter that I to the nav shape even if he tells you he's doing it on Shabbos its motor now consider the next question is gonna give us a tremendous insight to the Sylvia a person is home shop this morning and every shop this morning he rinses out a coffee cup because I'm with someone who's before him this Shalvis a little lazy has a live-in maid he tells the geyser could you rinse out my coffee cup by him rinsing coffee means put the cold water on rinse again invite but the woman decides to do it really perfect puts on the hot water and uses a sponge and so the kid said by time she finishes washing the cup to malakas the rice that were done using hot water and a sponge Skeeter now he's in a dilemma a key like what we can use this Kel coffee cup a guy did melaka for him on Shabbos now you think about it this is not lots more she washed the cup for him and this is not cannot wait till Sunday this is time-sensitive he wants to have a coffee shop us Sundays at work he doesn't need coffee and Al's so here it's not lots more of the guy and it's not something that could wait it's time-sensitive but doesn't seem that it's awesome why not so everybody say this what I think is another type of a tighter than a shape Yutaka want to go to mullah did you wash for you it can't wait till Sunday but you don't need milazzo to have a clean cup you can rinse it with cold or like you've been doing for years the fact that the guys decided to do an extra job and do Malacca that I died today nothing in other words you know the lambda says the trade enum and the big alarms is the adenine there's one hectare lots miter guide it for himself that's the fail passage then is a case where the guy could do it on Shabbos or Sunday and a guy's choice on Sun on Shabbos that's mutton but this third category is the question at hand does not need melaka it could be done melaka free the guy chose to wash with hot water because it's a little more convenient more comfortable and use a sponge to make it easier that's the guys convenience that's the guys choice but you don't need melaka and therefore smooth Ruthie's both varieties of a dye to the naphtha it could be done on Sunday or with our melaka our reform of lots my because the guy did Mellark of his own choice but this is something that is not a Gomorrah this type but it's Mustafa and I saw the CAF a high mansion Lamas Iron Chef Aleph quotes from the real cash and the other yaku has a very similar you soy if the guy is asked to wash the floor and the guy uses a map we'll soon see the details so the memory cache is says it's make is Maiko at least picasa talk because the guy could put water on the floor and use what's affectionately further as a sponger that doesn't need malacca so we have two forms of a tighter than option either it to be done on sunday or it doesn't need more luck at all now here you're gonna ask one second i don't get this you have all these fancy terms are tighter than i've shake but the my son we learned in the mr. brewer that if the guy does more welcome for the ye'd even if I don't ask him to do it I can't ever know until much I shall become a CR sir I didn't tell them do it it's still awesome so the fact that you caller ID I didn't I've state but I'm still having enough of all FS Shabbos the answer is very posh it if the guy put on the lights for me I'm having a normal life for Shabbos that's awesome if the guy did something that could be done on Sunday or didn't meet Malacca it's not a molester bus it's the guys Choice do Malacca I need a clean cup that's not maleficium and this is the macabre and raised from dollar dreams I enraged in Bay's that there's a hell of an archway and there's a head-to of I die to the nafs' you now let's go in in order not many many Silas hopefully you'll see how push it is once we have the aside question number one someone goes to a public plays hospital nursing home and basically because of security heightened security you can't come in you have to have a guard that sees you and feels you're not threatening and he buzzes you in I'm allowed to stand by the door and hopefully he will buzz me in think about it says a la casa readiness because the miser the guys doing it for me it's not what axe Lloyd and also I need it to be buzzed and today I want to go visit today not Sunday I can't wait till he's not take come back Sunday I want today but here we have the second type of a tighter than I've seen the guy get off his quote kiss Yakov white walk to the door and open it manually you don't have to have melaka to allow entrance to a hospital he wants to be lazy and sit sit by his station and buzz you in that's a guy to the knife shake my hand no is being allowed into the hospital all you have to do is turn the door now if he decides to be lazy okay he can maintain his laziness but that doesn't mean it's a molester Shabbos getting into the hospital does not need mawatha the guy's choice of Douma lockers as I didn't I've seen that should be perfectly would what's more than issue someone is just the other day they go visiting in a nursing home and there there's even more security eat to get on or off any floor you have to deactivate an alarm if depress the number of buttons otherwise the alarm rings of course to maintain security no one should leave there's no way of doing it manually you have to do Malaka so whenever your visits they have to have the guy press the buttons they activate the alarm that there is no health of a tighter than I've seen because there's no way that a guy could do without do Milazzo but the other Hector probably is that since you go on further our Mitzvah so it's a mere Allah Akram doing in this at the ramp on and deactivating an alarm that first this was the mark commit seppuku of of Vika column and that would justify that hadn't the doorbell rings it's the UPS he has a package to you that's left so love cuz he's singing a Seamus I was the bane of my balance and he's bring you a package well could you do tell him just put it down and I'm sorry I can't help you can you sign because I'm sorry I can't help you can I sign for you now what do you say if you say yes sign for me you're telling him to do melaka that's the shop america move actually I'm late see a left here Shabba step so what you do is you tell him this listen this is a free country do what you want everybody else does that you could do it do whatever you want now he's faced with the decision because if he doesn't sign for you is enough to put it back in his truck and come back on Monday if he signs for you he saved another trip so if he decides to sign for you on his own that is a contemporary but a perfect Edyta than I've seen it's Muslim he's signing for his coming if you have the package either today or Monday there's no difference to you that would be a guide to the Nazi someone was moving cross-country and hiring a trucker to bring all the stuff now if you stop Shabbos so you're losing that much time do you have to tell the truck that is not to drive on Shabbos so the answer is this is our Silk'n if the agreement was a Kaplan agreement you paid for the job you calculated the mileage whatever it is so the fact that the guys decide to drive on Shabbos is his decision you didn't give him a time you didn't give him a limitation if the guy decides to stop up all night and drink and sleep 14 hours you have nothing against him you can't have him against them so the fact that he drives on Shabbos is his decision when to take off and that looks like his motor we had this question in camp someone else to go you should work up bring me a box of a case of a soup bowls for the kid this finish all sugars whatever it is so the guy was a bit lazy and got on his golf cart and he goes to the stockroom to bring the box of goods so here you need the things on Chavez it's a it's a Shabbos related sleeveless but then again and this is the mid-season that case was that carrying a box of soup bowls is not that heavy you could do it by himself without think the golf cart the higher the fact that he used the car would be a question but died to the nafs' you know it's very posh should understand my hunger of balls can be done without moola about I could do it myself I asked the guy to do okay that's the job he chose to use the golf cart that's his issue but here there was a different problem which in many camps is the rule you don't use a golf cart the guy should the worker don't use a golf cart even though it's a tighter than option this is optional so driving around in a year this camp makes so much noise we'll soon see the source of that but something that attracts so much attention that this is a disparaging kedusha Shabbos is a zil's old Shabbos and will soon see more about that consider the next question you you come up from work Friday afternoon the car is crafting it needs a needs our food so you bring it in to the mechanic and you tell them I need it back Monday morning he says you don't have to have Monday morning I'm gonna do it first thing tomorrow morning come into tomorrow said 12 o'clock this is our Sookie since he could do it till Monday I'd I didn't I've seen the question let's say you tell them I want it Sunday morning so you didn't officially tell them do it on Shabbos but that's what happened because if you want to Sunday morning so this is actually the Farish which I said earlier you tell the guy I want it done on Shabbos is awesome and in Raceland bassy bays it says you vow to give clothing for the cleaners but don't tell them to do it on Chavez now generally this is this is really not so common I mean if you could wait till Monday why tell me do it on Shabbos so I dieted an option is what but don't tell do it on Chavez where this is they gay I saw a very interesting example the focus the item in our hi I'm Simmons Samak evolve was asked a question by someone they wanted to put in a advertisement in this Saturday newspaper and he wanted it in that paper the Macias is that they only print Friday night for this to the shop this morning paper dr. fell Casilla clave the person gave it in and Wednesday he wanted to be May cold because it's a tighter than I've shake butts up the kakizaki that's not no one prints the Saturday paper and Wednesday you do it on Shabbos so by telling him you won in the Saturday paper it's like you're saying I want you to print on Shabbos so that would be a good example of our show caller ID I did then after seeing what the unless you demand it to be done on Shabbos now the fact that you could that he could do it on Monday even if he tells you I'm doing it on Shabbos makes no feel like mr. Breuer and raised from Zion gimel says even if he tells you're doing it on Shabbos you could allow them to do it that's not a problem question you bring your car to the mechanic on Wednesday and you say I need it back on Monday plenty of time he says oh when it rains it pours I am so back like I have so much work I'm not touching this car until Saturday you wanted Saturday afternoon fine but not before Saturday I'm just too busy the Huayra now we have a problem because he cannot gonna do it till Shabbos and will soon see Sunday he's closed don't speak about that but the fact that he could do it from Wednesday till Shabbos in this case seems to be relevant cuz he's just to backlog he's not going to do it but you think about it that's the hair still lighted enough shake he could do yours first he could change the order the fact that he chose to go and oil is his decision and that is still the health of a dieted enough shape now I didn't find this actual case but the Deemer shag inhaling BAE's Coulomb and gimel as deshyla with someone high but he calls an agent I guess they're salesmen someone to buy things for him and the person during the week is usually busy he only has one or two days to be his agent chávez's Sunday now he didn't hire him specific day he hired to buy him items in a buy affair which is open every day but he knows that the person is only available Shabbos and Sunday and Sunday he has his own business so basically it's only Shabbos that this agent could work for him says the marsh AG but Lamesa he could do the work on any other day he decides to be busy all week that's his that is still a tighter than I've seen the massage ads but we find it so Connor Finch in Zion valid if you send the guy to the marketplace to the market to the fear to buy for you and the market the fair is only open on Shabbos it's awesome oh that I understand because he only could buy it on Chaves it's not open on Sunday but this agent could work any day of the week the fact that he chose to work to go on Shabbos because he's busy the rest of the week that's his priority that's his scheduling that's a dieted enough see a very important question I wanted to mention today many people have full-time workers whether it's a shul your custodian a yeshiva a camp a live-in maid sometimes you notice that the guy is putting on the lights say you know the boy what are you doing I'm doing my job just don't leave me alone you hide me this is my job my job is to put the lights on in the morning close them at night I'm doing my job here I go a shuttle I'm the Steinem he's doing his job that's not a tighter than a shake because his job is to work for you I thought that an obviously is when it doesn't involve pillows Shabbos or it doesn't involve Shabbos as opposed to something but the fact that his job is to nacala Shabbos for you is not a healthy so that's why you in any of these scenarios a custodian a building manager superintendent a live-in maid are all bound and restricted by regular hillcrist Amira the Aqua someone told me and that's why I felt like mentioning this in Dominica in a certain place of nurture all he says there was a official Shabbos great quote volunteer I said what do you mean the guys sat in a strategic position if someone needed help you know they're told they're not so many came around so if someone needed a Shabbos he would come right away to your house after Shabbos you would send him 50 shekel that was the agreement now that is not a hepta the fact that he's doing it to get paid is not a heterozygote that's the whole concept of a cobbler and versus hey i'm is getting paid so I think either he missed understood it or there was a lot of Cola shop is going on that city I imagine that there what the question was that someone needs a guy and his muster to call a guy so cake highly that I call the guys okay caught me later call a guy or any other case where God is mutter but in that particular city near its early one know guy I'm available so this guy decided to make a few dollars a few shekel actually any charge 50 shekels that's fine but there's no independent happy if I pay him he's doing it for his payment and therefore his motto that's not true if he's doing his payment to do work for you that is a regular sphere I'm that's working on Shabbos and it's also a very important question which leads us to many other questions as well someone is a no-tell for Shabbos and one's room service he wants this food brought this room can he asked by the desk please send me the meals up to my room now you are certain without a doubt that the goes that deliver the food to your room will not walk the steps they will use the elevator so the question is by asking for room service it's inevitable that they're going to use the elevator so if you are on the second or third floor like many of the hotels don't go too much above that no that's okay but let's say you're on the twelve story and you have a pretty big meal it's possible to do it but it's very improbable how do you define I dieted enough shape does it have to be reasonable that he could do it 12 stories heavy meal it's not reasonable or it's possible physically festival could he do it yes you need someone that's very determined and very you know not lazy but how do you determine how do you define how logically do words I dieted enough say does it have to be reasonably possible or possible you know the fact that it can be done physically a more common Shila you you need something Sunday morning and you bring it in Friday afternoon so Friday afternoon already is closing in a few minutes Shabbos cuz Shabbos and he's closed six o'clock oh but here's your alarmed ins he could work overtime and stay a few hours and do it Matteo Shabbes the fact that he's closed amatory Shabbos so let America overtime it's possible physically possible to work all the time but it's closed or how about you see you needed Monday okay but it's closed something is that a tighter than I've said he could work on Sunday but he never works on Sunday how do you define the word a diet is enough say you know in in bava kamma Bob mercy of amigo e of a katana here is Amiga he could have been open but he not open his mouth is not very possible so there's a very important lead to this circuit the Tarzan Raisman belt if cotton hey if you hire someone to finish so in the beggar door writing a book and your Mac bid when he finishes you knows you give it's time-sensitive and your Mac bid that it should make it that's not a tighter than a string why because he doesn't have enough time he's gonna have to work on Shabbos you give him a week to do a job that he has to work on job is that that's that's not a tighter than I've seen sucked the Prima Gotham and this I'll be the worst so important vas in me Anna's at Summa arcamax might be a shovel IVA Yahoo Yahoo League mother call maybe he could work every night over time and not work on Shabbos so compensate for Shabbos mekomo come I die today sir l of it this is what we refer to as Janna socks my it's physically possible to work every night over time and not work on Shabbos and finish by Sunday very good but that's Yanis at me has to work extra overtime and you look at the toddy the Pima Gardens Lawson kotaki soma do ik i dieted the Shroud of it he's not doing it for his convenience his convenience is to work 9:00 to 5:00 and work on Saturday and leave me alone to work every night over time even one night all the time that's to you not for me Barea I never work overtime you want me to work overtime and you cause I do not I'm doing it for you I'm scared of you that's not a lighter than I she I dieted thus relevance you're not giving him a choice the only Hector is the male the cleaner is the mechanic that he could do it any day and they chose to do it on Shabbos this is the aside of Yanis ax might but the Prima Gordon himself points out that value robber and she's cutting you at base seems to be maple that since physically he could work overtime he decides not to that's his decision now the PD job is not very very Myra but promotion paying down Gitmo I think he says beautiful Hesburgh and why this is what he's also makers at it since he could do it at night so he surround is persuade Messiah Sayaka melaka zoo the it doesn't care I want you to finish the job the fact that he does closed Shabbos is the guys choice I need a job that could be completed if you work a little overtime or a lot over time but doesn't it doesn't necessarily demand hello Shabbos if the guys decide to work normal hours and not to overtime that's the guy's decision how come let's say I'm actually math my sugar syrup lasts a small office at Harry's m'lila writes Alicia he wants to go to sleep so emotions understanding I died today the Edyta the Napster is it doesn't necessarily need melaka so we have a malaika's prima garden and a year album the mr. Breuer and Raymond boughs of cotton of Dalit postions like the Prima Gotham I saw the safest Shabbos mission about the emigration Aleph he quotes arriv'd that seems to say that if he could do it at night over time it's a tie to the nav say but it's a name my sir see them very Somalian my ass Akane because unless it's asana for the bar mitzvah Cal lady a day in la aquel and therefore don't be sorry Highness this had to unless it's really necessary in other words he is acknowledging that the fan you work all the time and he does the tighter than a shake but it's not worth being same upon the my sub it seems but I think the really the philic is you know the word overtime is not as bad as it seems many people work overtime I saw this enough : safe on health as Emile Arkham and very Mustafa that the Prima Gotham was talking about in those days there was no electricity working at night was physically emotionally difficult you have to get a candle and work and it just wasn't done today people in the workplace don't know if it's day or night outside what's the difference working day or night and over time it is a very viable option very often so it's it's not physically difficult to work at night maybe tie a tie to the - say if something is difficult again you know - carries that food the 20 stories are under steps that's difficult so again it's hard to give a clear cut rule but I could say that the rivaled one of the Machine ready discuss this and was make abut felt that he should I should not be signing on it unless it's a shot clock but the point that I think is that if it's taka very improbable because it's difficult that DePrima God the mr. brewer masked man one should not be make up if it's just a question of his convenience the person works 9 to 4 so the fact he can work till six o'clock think most people know is that so difficult so if it's just a question of his easy of his early hours and he could work all the time that we are more business more night to be make up the other question is Friday afternoon he can't do it because you brought it in very late Sunday is closed you're gonna have to do it on Shabbos but who has to be closed so here the fire this is the same shilin he could do it on Sunday physically people could work people do work on Sunday but his clothes he's been closed with 20 years so the fire it's totally in the Prima garden versus their yerba that we mentioned earlier the Shabbos Bishop Ave points out and this is definitely right the Sam sofa in a few Chile's has this Schuyler and that even that even though he's they don't work on Sunday but that's his choice and that's considered a dieted enough shape and I'm sick in a future but is also makeup even though the clothes on Sunday so he points out that in the times of some siphoned RAM shake it was against the law to work on Sunday because sunday was La Habra favelas be the guy used to Shabbos it was a clogger and even though it was illegal to work on Sunday that some siphon mom super maker why because he could be not so religious Sylvia fryer gave us this left it's that's his choice so if that's even when it's all set to work on Sunday cause game today when it's just a question of choice you know a lot of people work on Sunday so again we have some siphoned Rams shake that our makeup Moises and in the next in our hi I'm up the seven dollar diamond dollz also make all the factories close on Shabbos close on Sunday so I think that's something that we can understand that really he could work on Sunday the fact that for twenty years he didn't work on Sunday that's I dieted an option for twenty years so they're all so we could save the mahkum syrup is definitely it's out to be maker if someone needs a car mom is Monday morning for a mitzvah and it's the person's clothes on Sunday we have all this to be silent on the room service that uses the elevator so again it's really a few floors is is conceivable it's probable in fact that he could walk beyond that you have a very difficult Shila that no one's going to slip twelve or twenty stories more of an issue when you have a wheelchair-bound person no one's gonna carry him even two or three stories so there if they do use the shot the elevator there might be a different head term that if the person considered a high Ella even hurl of shame by Sakana so college anybody said corner even a guy could do even a locket erisa so but then you have a different answer a the fact that it's a highly same basic corner especially if he's going for environment so to go to Davin so that's a different issue but just to carry things that have to be carried and it's improbable that the guy will carry it all those steps this is worse then this the fact that is closed on Sunday because here it's physically almost improbable that is going to do it possible everything is possible but probable it's very improbable unlikely and therefore you have a mr. Bruin the Prima cardamom a smear and the fact and again even if you may fill out that it over time and and Sunday that's because it's it's possible just his decision but here it's something very physically a lot of physical exertion you should be careful to make oh if it's talking not possible to do in a normal way now here is interesting a lot of hotels have a Shabbos elevator and a regular elevator so here the guy could use the Shabbos elevator the fact that he is both lazy and impatient to wait for the Shabbos elevator to go every floor that might be a tighter than a shake okay that I could understand question you have the guy washes dishes so that involves two possibly to retire using the hot water is Vishal using the sponge is Theta and after washing it for Papa for post Shabbos needs so I'm gonna I guess now to wash dishes on Shabbos cemetery Shabbos that's the mission and myself the Shabbos can to go do any or all of the above so the truth is the easiest Schuyler is if the guy is told you have to wash the dishes at your convenience but the guy wants to go home doesn't want to stay around for metoya Shabbos the great chose to do the dishes I died to the knife show that would be okay for a year it's a corner but for a guy it's also a fun but the choices you could do it on Shabbos and my job is the fact that God chose to do it on Shabbos in a tighter than asked if you tell the guy do it now that's the problem O'Connor Africa is also us but here free in this case I dieted enough see the problem that the guy uses hot water or sponges so here again this is not this is something that they're doing on Shabbos and the washing dishes for the next sue them they can't wait to massage Shabbos you need them to wash Friday night muscle for the dae-su them so they can't wait for my sorry shoppers to watch the suit this the dishes that you need so there's no head to of do it after Shabbos also it's not Lots money the guys washing your dishes but here we could use the other type of a diet is enough shake since the going could wash dishes like Ethan will have to wash dishes every Shabbos you use cold water and you don't use a sponge and it washes we even have been washing dishes for David iris and everything they survive and it's fine so they could wash bahattar the fact they want to you do it a little more convenient way using hot water and a sponge that could be a tighter than Asha you could do it like we do it cold water and sponge now this I saw the schmira Shabbos in mom and I'll lift test is Mako based on a diet and an option now if the guy is given the job to wash a greasy grimy shelling pathways that mom is so even with the sponge and and hot water it's a big avoider but the you cold water without a sponge is almost impossible that's taka not a head that I saw this mirror Shabbos in or Allah McBay says that if you can't do it then there's not a lighter than option but washing plates and silverware basically that would be the health of a tighter than option I should mention that the using hot water for a guy has a possible different header there arm on the end of racial and Gimbel says that sick raesha for a guy is motor using hot water is a secretion of Melaka their iced but no more than obscuration we spoke about this a few weeks ago so according to there are more using hot water freely is multi out situation the only problem is that the going in and the tires are not they're not agree to this ramble so late 2002 Gras there's no head turn of situation but we still have the header of the fact that it's a dieted enough shape many homes have what's called the tankless boiler which basically means that there is no boiler that boils the water in advance when you put the hot water on you activate a boiler that boils the water instantaneously that is not up secretion so then even the remorse Hector without apply let's say the guy is a listen to this he says listen I could do with cold one right so I could use hot water right okay so let me even be more lazy and let me use the dishwasher a double a tighter than I've said I could do with cold water so hot water so what's the jump to dishwasher so he's he's right and the lumbus he's right in alarmed in taco Silvassa time' the the hinata you need of washing dishes you could do with cold water but here we have what i mentioned earlier which is not a mythical city it's erimar in Raceland bay CA be a choice embarrass i'am a mill that makes noise of a comic MCH Locker / tomas call dr. mr. brewer that the image there are most giving us a cloud even if something is Motamedi the din if it makes noise if attracts attention if it disturbs and is disparaging - kaduche a Shabbos that in itself is a sir some people refer to as either a small of samosa or Seleucid the Shabbos but basically whatever makes noise on Shabbos is come to dicks the Serenity the caduceus Shabbos and that's awesome there must as the mahkum say they could be Mako but hashish mas the the obstacles the Lucid the Shabbos which means it's a spirit to Shabbos it's noisy and attracting attention is also on Shabbos like drama caucus or the schmear Shabbos in lamb and Aleph you'd says that the guy could wash dishes talk with hot water if it's possible but not to use a dishwasher a dishwasher is a issue of optionals so that's something that's important to realize now for a guard to mop a floor in a Yiddish kitchen a camp hotel the like so I must mention mopping the floor is a listener abundant in chiffon auction i'm italian gimel ain't suckin a sock Erica what am i different I say I feel the home elusive why the issue of massugu Monsieur now that you might come to straighten out the earth and that's why better of Clow hidden and even Lahab should not be mopping floors on chavez de marzo leo and seminar a very thorough discussion about mapping floors and he really shows the problems involved in even a non-jew mopping a floor we're talking about a case with is it's over you have a big camp or big hotel and you must maintain you know safety it's a safety hazard if there's plenty there's lack of cleanliness some hot bugs the Bukit sir the floors must be mopped daily the given is that the floors must be mapped can you tell the guy to mop the floor so here again terminology is very crucial to tell the guy to mop the floor is telling them to be mahalo Shabbos mapping wringing out the map is Theta which is a very productive theta washing the floor with a wet mop is another skater that sort of may mayhem you want the floor to get moist but what you should have done you could have done or you could do is tell them to wash the floor washing the floor does not need maloca you could do it like a narrative roll you throw marble of water and somehow it ends up the floors clean you use a sponger which is plastic no sweeter so since it shines better but of course it's easier to mop the floor sup cacophony I'm that we mentioned the beginning quoting Murray cash there since it's shy - Hector you could have a mop flaw - Hector the fact that the guy chose the more convenient way of doing it a dieter than a shake but let me be clear washing floors shouldn't be done but there are cloud that's the South American channel amber Zion that's Dominica Searle but when it has to be done the guy could do it with the map but again precise terminology is important tell him to wash the floor but mapping was like telling him to do the Malakal next question we had someone asked this question they have today typically hotels and even many camps even some you Sheba's have a meat slicer you cut the cold cold cuts etc and the question is a guy wants to slice the meat on Shabbos with the electric meat slicer so the embassy is that of course you could slice meat with a knife but to make those perfectly thin-sliced let's leave it in a fancy hotel the the exact you know slim side that's supposed to be the chances of them doing 500 pieces of cold cuts is slim pun intended you know it's kamat improbable maybe almost impossible 500 exactly no precise eggs they all should be uniform so this is a real ya know a sad smile a very tremendous physical exertion and kula high blue light so that's something that really shouldn't be done because basically there is no way of doing it manually someone told me no but the machine has a a manual part of it you just move it back and forth so I found out that's incorrect you could move the meat back and forth but the cutter the blade is always going with electricity so basically you cut it before Shabbos and but not on Chavez if a guy wants to cut disposable tablecloths typically in the shul for shelters should this or any Shiva so cutting tablecloths for a year maha monoliths lon is either makatea cutting something to size or minimally it's Korea which is a barrier of ticklin it's a very constructive form of tearing that's you creating a tablecloth so how could you ask a guy to cut a tablecloth if for your disaster so we hear all sorts as far is that the truth is we can eat on the table as it is but the guy will have a hard time cleaning up yes take each cup and each plate and wipe the spill it's much more convenient if the guy cuts a paper cloth and wraps up the whole shall I show this and the whole kiddush and throws it out now the truth is that's really not so convincing because the it on a bare table is not appetizing even during the week it's not clean but the Shabbos which it's gonna eat on a bare table I mean that's analog control enough you have to have tablecloths so again it's something that he's doing it for himself but it's also done for yet I don't think the it would be comfortable eating because it is on a bare table so Lamesa you know I do Burstein in the maloca my my a pair of tests Simon hey says even if you will argue that it's lighter than our Shea but it says it's more double that a guy he is cutting paper claws for shall issue this or a kiddush it's again it's something that is very very very much a sphere to caduceus Chavez so it's really important to tell the guy in before Shabbos to do it cut table as before Shabbos so someone told me as a Ganser pockemon that he cuts enough petal quotes from a whole Shabbos and he puts them away so the guy could go there and take pre cut but the fact and then I'll have chemicals so the fact that the guy cuts pretty lazy to go to get the pre-cut a lighter than I've seen now it's like a meal it's the type of thing but again he's missing the boat 3/4 a guide to cut table words with me I'm ver a de for the either she use is at least a sizzle and Shabbos that definitely should not be done question the Yid ask the guy to wash dishes and this is the old days there's no hot water and not even a sponge but it's in a darkroom and the guy is going to have to light a candle to wash the dishes but at the end with cold water without a sponge is that I dieted enough shape because you can't wash in the darkroom but then again washing dishes doesn't need malacca so the ties in the end of race i involved is makeup you need wash washing dishes the guy could wash dishes the fact that it's dark in this particular situation you have not as wash dishes you can have the teletig i don't feel the great to light a candle wash dishes the guy knows that you have to put on light to wash the dishes that's a diet enough we would have thought differently but this is the halo guitars of suck now let me ask you three shyness and let's see how we could proceed a person was risky I'm at this is something reckless but he needed an hour to get from one place to the other Arab Shabbos and he had enough time to spare in people don't have time for Shabbos so he called the car service an hour and one minute before this man take me from place a to be and there's no traffic I don't know because he was reckless but he made it then he started thinking what am i doing I get out of my car service the guy is gonna have to drive back to his base he's driving because of me is any problem that the guys driving on job because of my job question number two the more tricky view a person has a making a Shabbos morning simcha he wants to have his favorite waiter or cleaning lady but they live in Queens they're not gonna walk from Queens for your kiddush can I hire them before Shabbos please be by my synagogue at ten o'clock you know they're gonna drive to your location on Chaves morning question number three we began with someone has to leave my sari Shabbos right with this mind can you call a guy Shekar service beam by my house at 6:12 and we're going now that means the guy is gonna drive to your location so to me the most posh it was the first case your job ended when the guy dropped you a Friday one minute before this man the fact that the great drives back that that's even more than a tighter than I've said that's nothing to me I hired him to drive me getting back that's your decision and the fire is moot question number two hiring a worker that must come from Queens and must drive shop this morning that you need a lucious now to say a diet that the knife they could stay in a hotel for Shabbos you know they were making $50 for the killers again spend $1,000 for a hotel I mean it's just more than yellow socks might but believe it or not this might be the task why are you Mallorca that I need is cleaning up how you get there that's your ASIC just like the ties this case you can't wash dishes without the candle so high that's also Morton the third question is interesting you need the car service at 612 by your hotel there's no way to get there unless he drives on Shabbos and again he's not gonna stay in your hotel over Shabbos Sultan minhas he it's country like Bob Simon cafe I thought about this all at started he was asked about didn't that need a car servicer in my wrong to get home and they called an Arab same deshyla and I don't see a hatter he says the fact that you tell them to be and you're by your place at 612 is like you're telling him drive on Shabbos and he quotes a different as that if you tell your agent buy stuff whenever you want but I'm leaving my sorry Shabbos and I need this stuff my sorry Shabbos so what do you mean how's it gonna get you the stuff if he buys it on Sunday so the minhas he it's clock is math mere as is the mishmash a persimmon curve of to me what the finish was that why isn't this even this third case our toss you need him to drive you 612 beyond the fact that he has to drive to get there that's not part of your driving but yes severe if you tell them I need your car I want to rent your car I'm going to drive and you could stay wherever you want that I can understand is the problem but here the fact that he's driving to get to your location your job is to drive 612 and beyond and I saw the RFS Shabbos on the tough I in Zion taco ass on Dominica's cook why isn't this the regular task now the emesis could be a stickler Philip is in the tosses case your you need clean dishes you have clean dishes you don't need an air here you need the car to take you the car could only be there if he drives at the six at five o'clock but the my sir the Memphis district was my premier but I juice to think and I saw the flame the mill is quoted and they're safe on business on Shabbos page 110 157 he's also make up and much me on the minister yitzhak I this is basically the task so the higher up we could say than all three cases that we had our mother based on the task someone SP was in a hospital he needed to visit a certain patient and you know what room they're in could he ask the receptionist which room is so and so now as soon as you real estate job to get onto the computer and they start punching in the information so if it's a written list that they could access and they cite the your computer that's a tie to the noshing but more often than not in hospitals certainly to such a turnover there is no written list this is not the corrected an option there is no way of doing it manually but since you're going to visit a hila this is a hostess the mocking mitzvah of the column that's what in contrast if you start going you facing a Shabbos convention you want to visit a friend and you want to know which room they're in and you go to the receptionist and there is no written list so if it's not to mark a mitzvah that would be a Amir Allah outcome because there's no other way of doing it bad hotel the wait is walking around whould you like for dinner Friday night mrs. and they write down your order so they're right in Malacca but that's who I lighted an option they could memorize it or run back to the kitchen and bring each other at a time but this is something I saw the Malacca Minaya also in Paraguay Bucharest said this is wrong this is a dill saloon Chaves they're writing down your Shabbos order I think about that they're writing down your shabu soda so you could eat look over Chavez this is a blatant bazillion of Shabbos if not Photoshop is the secretary that wants to finish up and do some work at home so this is mom Michelle was sugi of course I'm talking about a gracious secretary if you pay them per day or per hour it's a sphere join they're getting paid for working per hour and they work on Shabbos they're getting paid for Shabbos work and that's the sphere yeah that's awesome if they get paid per job finish up this job you're getting X amount dollars for the job they choose to do it on Shabbos they can do it on Sunday or Friday that is a typical Edyta than I've seen the question we began to put the mail in the mailbox Friday afternoon in the the mountain mailbox and lift the red flag sounds frightening but it's really not all I'm doing is I'm putting the mail that they could take it when they decide they don't have to take it on Shabbos they could take it on Monday you're 49 cents Stan doesn't get you too far just like you can't put it you got to put in the mailbox in the city why is the mountains different are you picking up the red flag that's like in a mirror to do it on Shabbos a red flag is not you talking that's not in a mirror and I saw the place give I make them interesting story someone arrived Friday and I'll tell I heard some Amish - ray recently and he was told to his great dismay his luggage was misplaced that's a nice way of saying it it was in Hong Kong it ended up somebody's in handgun but don't worry we'll get it to you as soon as possible so you went Shabbos in the hotel with no Shabbos clothing job this morning to get a courier service here is your or your luggage and of course a lot of mileage and don't sue us in oh the holes are mine yards question the guy drove the luggage I don't know from where but definitely to you just for you and they must get a t1 Chavez is there is a motive to have enough on the luggage so here it's not lights might and it's time-sensitive and basically there's no way of doing it per hectare but here we have a finish of the the Lu rabbity and the race I involved let's see the guy comes in some reason and puts out the light in your house then realize what he did and puts on the light says they all your ABBA then it's much that have unknown because that's called tikkun toys the guy made a mistake and now only rectifying his mistake you hadn't know without to go where Debbie Burton ticking ties is mahtim and it's probably a form of a dye to the nap say because you got to the trouble you have to get you out of it so it's very possible that our case is also a tick on toys because remember you had this stuff before Friday day they lost it and I saw taco one of the high ticket pipes that military says that this would be a case like of T of T current toy is that's what now contrast that to a different Schuyler which is I think I'm it's Olaf arson you told the worker the janitor custodian I won all the lights on and Friday morning this Saturday's casabas is coming put all the lights on don't forget before shabbiha to put up lights on and the guy forgot can he go and put on the lights Friday night the Huayra this is a real add I to the nosh say you told them to do it on Friday he could have done enough in fact he told not to do it on Shabbos mokou shouldn't be moved to for the great to put lights on Friday night and the answer is I'll peel off it's a tighter than a shake but here we come to a very important around more we are more says that if a guy did melaka a date - a it's mutton but you can't have enough women on Shabbos although the muhabba is Mako because a tighter than a she's motor but there are more in Raceland Bey's sieve Dalit says even though i dieted an option you can't have enough from it on Chavez aye all the cases that we are Mako think about it all the cases the secretary did work on Shabbos but you're getting it on Sunday the mechanic the cleaners the mayo all the cases that guy did melaka a titan after you having it on sunday but what the have a not on Shabbos there are more says is improper and then verse ISM a car and we're gonna Roman tough cook test of all chief cotton gimel a mama shower case you told the guy do it on Friday the guy didn't and did it on Shabbos even though it's a tighter than I'll say but I know you're having unshod this is awesome and that's why Lamesa to have the guy put on the light is problematic I why was the luggage mother to have her not because there was a mock I'm sorry okay no shop no Shabbos clothing and there must make him welcome sorry but one thing I wanted to mention that this concept is important that having unknown is because the unknown is was done for you on Shabbos generally it's not the issue but if it does happen we have to be careful glacier not the maloca on Chavez Fran no I wouldn't talk say making shooter like your biggest require us mister today share Smith will give a secret of today share in about five minutes or and on your been Akashi military disposal as our case is you saw the figure given permission her mother knows officer Mont Segur yeah go to the other [Music] [Applause] [Music] you [Music] yeah [Music] let's clear the area for after the fall so the guy security got to quit here they seek him up today share please find your seats they're standing places I remain silent learnt a bath sm we your locker was a very serious I mean every SS eries every grab on in this series Ramiro Malcolm there's a special protection even I know I'm at sri Shabbos but they say Yassa is awesome so basically it's not a hat then it's not a way of life but today's so gear were the coolest in it so basically if the guy did melaka for himself he but i like for himself that yet could have enough from that that's why axe my it's Nana melaka Shabbos the finish of today's study was that a die to the nafs' a is a different form of that Hatter the guy could have done it before Shabbos but chose do it on Shabbos for his convenience or the guy could have done the same we saw had the same result without doing melaka could have washed dishes without hot water or a sponge that is not a malefic Shabbos so both forms are the ITER than after you could do it before Shabbos or ef-2 Shabbos or do it on Shabbos without amalaki is what's called a tighter than a shake and it's basically a form of lots might you don't need melaka to give me the ha know that I want on Chavez that's why you like to mail letters Erev Shabbos you'll either bring clothing into the cleaners or a car into the mechanic if it can be done before we after Shabbos and the guy tells you I'm doing it on Shabbos that's fine because it can be done before we after Shabbos to overnight a package or Mayo is also because you are specifically instruct me going to do it on Shabbos the guy tells you I'm doing it on Shabbos but you say I I need it first Monday it's fine basically if you have to get into a public place and the guy buzzes you in but it could do it manually okay that's a tighter than I've see because of his convenience the UPS delivers the package and can I sign you tell them do what you want don't instruction design but say do what you want that's a tighter than a shake if a glacial move is moving your your luggage you appear your possessions and they're not maklouf to stop on Shabbos as far as you're concerned tighter than a shake a worker that drives an item but he could walk with it and carry it that that I didn't I've say but again driving or going with the golf cart in a judicial campus or grounds is a problem of zil's old Shabbos the mechanic is can't do it before Shabbos because he's overbooked with other jobs but that's still his choice to do yours last and that would be a tighter than a shake the question of the fact that it's his job the muscle a maintenance manager a superintendent a bungalow county manager all these people are working it's his job to do melaka but his job is to work for you that is not a lighter than I've say that is a scary arm that's working on Shabbos for the yeet to put an advertisement in a Shabbos paper which is printed on Friday night is not a lighted and I've said it can't do it before Shabbos if the guy could conceivably do it but it's convenience he doesn't want to do work overtime we could could consider that a tighter than a shame if it's physically very challenging it's almost impossible it needs a major exertion that would not be tighter than after that's the end is absolutely the great to use the elevator for his convenience especially if there's a Shabbos elevator he has no patience for that that's a tighter than our say but there's a great to bring up food many many stories and to expect them to walk that is a very far fetched a tighter than I've seen a greater washes dishes with hot water and it's the soap and sponge would be a lighter than I've seen if it's possible to wash dishes that case if you have very greasy grimy parts that can't that would not be a dieter than I've seen don't tell the guy to mop the floor when you need the floor mop because of safety reasons for it to keep the sanitary conditions tell them better wash the floor and he choose to use a map that would not be a problem that'll be a tighter than I've seen a machine took twice lead very thinly which can't be done by hand is not a lighter than I've say a guy should cut have disposed papers before Shabbos a guy that does any melaka freed on Shabbos is an Esther bageno if the guide drops you up right before this man of course you up that's not a Schuyler he's going home on his own if he drives to work at your place shop this morning he can't walk the place got my makeup and even if he picks you up matauri Shabbos we saw Mike Lakers how poised him that might be worse because you need him to drive you to pick you up but even that there are those that are maker to ask information by a receptionist that has to go on the computer for vomits this motor unless there is a manual a written list then that's not to even not with arm it's about generally today there are it's all computerized and that would have to be motor because of a bar mitzva a secretary that works at homes a tighter than Ashley unless they paid per hour per day the red flag in the mountains is motor the enough from amalaka Don on Shabbos doramas math mere thicken toys if the guy put out the light he could put on the light and the letter I want to mention someone said it pretty good Samara if he told it I put light on Friday morning and he didn't do it and he wants to put it on Friday night so we said the problem is having enough from the light but it's possible that since the Meister right now there is no other time to do it so if I'm here on in it is no longer tighter than after saying we never had such a case he Friday it tells you I'm gonna do it Chavez that's fine because he could do it today but maybe that's the swirl why if the guy didn't didn't do it then it's taka doing it for the Eid now of course this is not a case of ticking toys because the guy the light was never on he forgot to put on the light that's not to entice but probably the issue is because right now on it is a is not a question like I did and actually the only time is do it on Shabbos