Hilchos Krias HaTorah - Maxing out the number of Aliyos Shiur by Rabbi Nachum Scheiner

in the previous year we spoke about the M the sources from the clearly and then later from Ezra yet even later as well also is afterwards the whole the whole nest of kanaka was later we also heard Sunday going through clearly that was the for tonight I want to try to go through the between the different that we have say the number the amount of Alas and when you could make and when you can't make off we'll start off with the pastas every Monday Thursday shabas it's three alas thear says already why different reasons why three but you can't do less and you can't do more you can't do less that's par because if there's an amount and there's actually a reason for the amount you can't do less was three alas whether was or from but is three alas every Monday and Thursday can't do less and what's about the add what's about the add so the Mish says you can't add why can't you add you can't add to say you add more Al it takes time and people people are busy they have to get to work and immedately you can't add on so Monday Thursday's you can't add on oh so what's sh also me it doesn't mean that you you're making a by not adding on it's just that if you add on you V to being it's a you're taking away later is it a problem for let's say the guy before whatever it is he's skipping it but is it a problem to Lane after uh if they start before could you Lan after let's we'll leave the shil we'll leave the Shila we'll leave it that would be add to afterwards he's after what's I'm saying we leave we'll leave it on the side for now you can't you can't be you can't do less because he's a number but could you be mo you can't be mo the reason why you can't be mo is I want to ask says there's a reason for three if there's a reason for three if you're going to add on more to three you're not going to have Ked oh very good very good gal good so the Em by says Li one we lie however you could add more you could add more and it's not what's well said very well said from you could add on three or four I'm not going into Theo of how many to add on we spoke about this when we learned here even spoke M about this you could add on this but you could add on so what what's good what's if you have two on your dining room table so one is for Z one is for sh if you're going to have five six eight neigh so then it's more then it's not sh have two sets of three one three sets of three but you have two they take six right two sets of three eight can have two sets of three means six so you have six yeah but each one you have a one bundle for Z One bundle for sh but here by n if you have six eight n year at least when you have two bundles you have two bundles off of a sh what's the what's so the EM is that really handles this but he really says it's he goes and he says is that by by Hava if you use the misper of three or you can't stop adding there has to be an accurate how much what the gar says three you can't just stop add as many but what's Why by nous could means why because there's a mispers over here if there's a misper how come you can't add why could you add so he says cuz Friday night is AER the more nous there's moreas so you can't say because of the the misper of you can't tell me that you can add more because as much as possible the same thing is with the more the more people the more people learning is a but that can't be for more people to get you have to come on to the reason so shouldn't it be that we should just do shorter alos onas rather than than saying that we should have less alos during the week why why should we do shorter Shor on shabas we're going to get to shabas soon has a different amount and we're going to speak about shabas but now we talking about during the week during the week these three alas the the number of three is either ready from that's or it's actually a later from alas alas people have to get to work why three why three these are number three we're just saying have to come on that you can add on because people have to get to work typically if you're going to add on during the week and you're not going to do three you're going to have four you're going to have five so then you don't have k for that was saying that itself wouldn't say that you not let to add on Alias we'll get to shabas shortly for the N for for shabas is that we don't add but I'm sorry when said by I want to tell you like this says they made they said how much and that's what they said so you can't change around a you can't change around byas really from the the more nearest the better the more Nest shabas the more now the a you could do one also the a two over for but you can't is beautiful but you can't tell me because that I shouldn't do more than two moving along so we spoke about now the let's call it the Alias three Alias Monday Thursday by the next is are four so there also the Mish says not less not less is for you can't do less the why now even though like the the tour already brings but these however for men they could do Mal so there's also B we learn here however these many different also however why T is it for why is it four over three why do we add on we add on these four we add on one more than Monday and Thursday these more kadus but again a you can't take away because D is four but a because he's still are lot of work no so so no I a lot of work that's why so they're working even harder what do you have to come on it Rashi on the rift says it that the reason why is because even though it's reg it's a regular work day for menu I won't even say a little bit more they were able to be one because it's less work because it's less work so they're able to add one added one also the same so they could they were able to add one what's if they work it's a regular day what is where's it how does it affect them you could add one it's only a it's a but it's it's the same regular of three it's also three it's also three is regular it's a regular day it's three the same thing what say yeah even I'm going to get it's later what does to do with anything a a TI the morning is also but there's only three alas you don't add an alah these three alas is what ask him why do we have on uh I don't know so what do we have over here so far with a clite these four you can't be you can't be we also saw why we added on Al because he K it's very interesting it's very interesting that the gor when the gamor explains three k the gar says five but the gar doesn't say the doesn't say four we came out with if during the week it's three and it's more we add on one so what's doesn't say why that the G didn't even have to say a reason if you take a look in the it's like interesting but when it comes to it's I'm sorry it's why four why because there are four types ofon so it's four four alas ConEd additional types ofb that were good so that's uh three Alias four alas five Al that's it's it's more it's more so we add another the brings over there keder is morees than can cook so it's morees so we add on yam is five Y is six and then shabas is more is seven why is sh why is it more the ter is the m says that a person should be careful with every Mitzvah because you don't know one Mitzvah could seem very small but you don't know the you know we don't know however over there we do know we know the of based of what the Torah gives we know it's like shabas it's the same thing like shabas however the ofer isus the of shabas is soab is and we up and it's seven says that it's seven it's interesting Say by shabas they have other reasons the the sh says that seven because to make up for the people that during the week didn't they missed even though that's that's six days that they missed but and says seven connected the seven days at a week that's the different the number of seven but how how we get to Seven how we get to Seven because we add it on more and then shabas now let's go in a little bit spend a few minutes and over here adding alas up until now it's clear in the mishna there's nothing what to talk about you can't be mo you cannot be up until up until Y and chabas by Y and shabas the Mish lists out and says Y is five yipper is six shabas is seven you can't add you can't be take away but you could be is going on all three on yipper and shabas but all three of them you can make that's theas thean understands like that the pasas and Rashi it's Mish like that in the ram the Raam says clearly you can makeus yipper and shavas on these three you can't do less a on the three all these he says now he's for sure going on the three because then afterwards the ra goes toes and andberg also says from says you can make understands like that in the T you can make however thean argues and the says you can't make only even though the says which would seem that it's going on everything only not why not why not because if you're going to make a it's going to be like him Kipper and with adding ises and the same thing as you can't add another because you're going to add an Al it's going to be like shabas and shabas is more mes however shabas it is the most you can add alas that's why you can make so we have over [Applause] here like the not like all the other we the brings the two the both sheas and we Passa that you do not make however there's some exceptions exception number one is that we absolutely make by every Y and every Kipper the himself points this out every the a m these five Alas and besides the ma besides the five alas a m it's Al number six that's so make six with another another with a M that's oh so we'll get to that in a minute but sh this maybe it'll be a she for itself we but shabas is another and we l the same let's leave shabas on the side for right now but y it's a it's a separate sa it's a separate K but you know what the ter is here we talk don't go like and this is we spoke about this in the previous it's a later not later the said to to have to read the carbonis of yam cuz if you read the carbonis you have the kapar no actually I spoke about in the morning if we're not going to make this then we're not going to be lat you do not make we make it's interesting to know every y we actually make because want I think they read you can't do four and then the fifth one why not because thee of the five Al we didn't just pick what the care is it's said also go to p and read about carbas so you can't that from the five do like we also want but you should know that is what else is another that we make as many alas unlimited there also it's it's also considered call it everybody wants to be on the day that will the so we make but means that's also an exception even though if you don't make we make being that chabas we do make okay so we went a little we don't make however shab is clear we make it's aish that you make it's a mishna you clearly make on chabas what the meaning is by CLA is that we have seven Al shabas like you brought up before everybody makes even though you really don't have to CU if or not we that so really really you could have just laid seven Al really you could have just read seven Alas and done seven shabas you could have read seven Alas and done we do seven Kadesh and then I'm after the kades has to be that's not for right now but you could have just done seven and you're done why do we do another the because anyways so why not [Applause] be that's what we add in so everybody every does eight you do seven you finish the byes and then so make everybody answer because why not says why not to that holds even though we don't like that yes you you could you could you could give to I want to just you could I want to to get through another two three Nas over here even though shabas you could add alas clearly it's a brings about it the says you could you could the says you could but the sh is the says that it was later we made it that every has a before and after it used to be the first was got the the last got the not everyone made a br before and after only the first and the last people used to come late so they didn't know that they missed the first BR the people that left early could you imagine it's a ple people that leave early come late is but leaving early to add in we added in that's CL if you you're adding it's more another reason not to make even on is because it's before after the person comes let alone even there's another reason there's another reason which I didn't see inside but this is a clor reason that a lot of places are very very careful about it is of people speaking a lot of places shoes big shoes that technically give Al They limit it m they limit it because if so many Al that it get stretched out and and before and after makes it harder makes more of talking this is all said make office but this is a separate discussion these many people that have you could even says you could I remember I as a kid daving in in Lake with Yesa BMG in the par if I remember correctly every single was a separate Ali was it's right after I think there was like seven I was a kid then topping the but I'm just saying there was not to make however even though even though as we saw not this a different it's a very interesting cha there was a big big fight in a town about adding they wanted to add because it makes money sell so the first thing writes in the beginning that God you're missing the boat by fighting around this is this is not it gives mus over there it's s to see just part of the opening it's like this first of all there isn't time but hea says that it's not a Casher from the bras extra bras cuz I you could make the bras even before people that come late you could make a br you could be y from somebody else be allowed to make your own but he says like this he says just like we mentioned early in the year that you could if we add it this is called he selling it to make money to be ands I want to be part of such a thing that it's raising money just [Music] just to be in this idea of what was saying about making not making says these by a lot of places in that they always besides the ma they always make another what's it called another a lot ofs a lot of places have every single and the explains why he says because these seven Alas and we want to make sure that all you give somebody Al that doesn't know how to follow along in the we're going to learn learned already that if you you don't know how to read he can't follow along so we add in one more so at least from eight we have seven that are good but for that's only for shabas that's only for shabas wherever you can't make you can't add it's what say I'm asking I want to just one other but even when he's an this is important to know when you call up and you say brought the you say is the last Al if you end up doing five alas you say not on the eth AL but on the 10th the last say that if you're going to say by the E Al you can't add is the last Al one more one more small indion what he say no no no no just add and that's it you don't have to say not nothing the last after not only the last one is one more I I'm sorry it's overtime this year if and what do you do over there clearly we said like this we like yes when it's yes or no what no could you make very good thank you I wasn't clear read seven alas could you add 8 N9 10 11 could you add on those Alias could you add you could add no could you you could add you could addas because it's shabas from Shas The very good you be you could be however however have the same you have the same you should be able to a wholeo about this this past shaba I was by and spoke about you went through this whole also about it this not the time to go through I thought I go through a little bit about it says not to be why because if you take a look in the every alah ends every alah ends with Kap basic you take a look every a kapar if you're going to add more s you break it up you're not adding want to you could make just to be finish this year however the says it's like that we're not it's not to be he's speaking also it's that same CH they also wanted to add another the come up and he not another later he says we don't make but what he does say is that to say if you make a that's also natur true says the was to make you can make just because it's shabas it should be it should be